A senior French police union official says officers are struggling under repeated deployments and increasingly violent attacks during nationwide demonstrations, warning that existing laws do not adequately protect law enforcement personnel.
By yourNEWS Media Newsroom
PARIS — The head of a major French police union warned Monday, Nov. 2, that officers are approaching exhaustion after three consecutive weekends of nationwide unrest, accusing violent far-left activists of undermining public order and calling for stronger legal protections for law enforcement personnel.
Frédéric Lauze, secretary-general of the National Police Commissioners Union, known as the Syndicat des commissaires de la police nationale, said French authorities cannot sustain the current pace of mass demonstrations, arrests, property destruction and attacks on police.
In an interview published Monday by Le Figaro, Lauze compared the unrest to the Yellow Vest protests that began in 2018, warning that prolonged disorder could place an unsustainable burden on the country’s security forces.
“We cannot continue like this; we cannot repeat the ‘yellow vests’ of 2018… Seventy thousand police officers have been mobilised again this time. To maintain order, they are sacrificing all their weekends, their family life, their children. It is an immense exhaustion. Every Saturday, they are confronted with violence, looting, raids, and far-left delinquents who burn police officers and vandalise businesses,” Lauze said.
The union chief also accused radical left-wing groups of engaging in what he described as a form of street-level fascism.
“Our police officers are no longer protected by the laws of the Republic,” Lauze said in remarks translated from French. “France is sick with its far-left fascism. There is a red, street-level fascism that is ruining our country and leading us toward bankruptcy.”
His comments followed another weekend of demonstrations across France, where hundreds of thousands protested rising living costs, deteriorating public services and government policies.
Although most demonstrations were peaceful, violence erupted in several cities as groups clashed with security forces, damaged businesses and set fires.
According to the French Interior Ministry’s official report released Nov. 1, approximately 320,000 people participated in 291 demonstrations nationwide Saturday, Oct. 31.
About 70,000 protesters gathered in Paris, while additional demonstrations occurred in Lyon, Marseille, Bordeaux, Grenoble and other cities.
Organizers estimated national participation at nearly 500,000, substantially higher than the government’s count.
The demonstrations marked the third consecutive weekend of major protests, following larger gatherings on Oct. 17 and Oct. 24.
Interior Ministry figures show participation declining from 550,000 on Oct. 17 to 410,000 on Oct. 24 and 320,000 on Oct. 31.
Despite that decline, the government maintained an exceptional security deployment involving approximately 70,000 police officers and gendarmes.
The repeated mobilizations have required officers to work extended shifts and sacrifice scheduled time off, according to police union representatives.
Lauze said the continued strain has created growing frustration among officers tasked with protecting demonstrations while confronting individuals engaged in criminal violence.
He argued that the attacks extend beyond legitimate political protest and reflect recurring acts of disorder directed at police and businesses.
The union leader also criticized the country’s legal framework, contending that police lack adequate protections when responding to violent groups.
His statements reflect the union’s assessment of the unrest rather than a judicial determination that the protest movement as a whole is extremist or unlawful.
France’s Interior Ministry has similarly distinguished between peaceful demonstrators and smaller groups accused of organizing violent confrontations.
In its official assessment of the Oct. 31 protests, the ministry said some participants associated with the radical left and far-left extremist movements attempted to enter city centers and attack security personnel after authorized marches concluded.
Officials said police intervened to prevent those groups from reaching commercial districts.
The ministry reported 565 arrests during Saturday’s demonstrations, followed by another 214 during Halloween-related disturbances, bringing the combined total to 779.
Authorities recorded 116 injuries among police and other security personnel during the protest operations and another 43 during the evening disturbances.
The report also documented 515 fires, damage to 36 businesses and looting at three commercial establishments.
Those figures represented a decline from the previous weekend, when authorities reported 1,435 arrests during demonstrations and 267 injured security personnel.
The Oct. 17 protests had been considerably more violent, with 2,628 arrests and 1,144 injuries among security forces, according to the ministry’s comparative figures.
The government said police operations had prevented more extensive violence during the latest demonstrations.
Interior Minister Laurent Nuñez condemned attacks against police officers, gendarmes and firefighters, describing the perpetrators as individuals pursuing violence rather than participating in legitimate demonstrations.
The Interior Ministry said it remained committed to allowing authorized protests while preventing attacks on public safety personnel and property.
One of the most serious incidents occurred in Paris, where a Molotov cocktail was thrown toward gendarmes during Saturday’s demonstrations.
According to Le Monde’s reporting on the incident, prosecutors opened an investigation into attempted murder of public officials.
The incident occurred amid clashes near Porte de Charenton as officers moved to disperse groups following a larger demonstration.
Authorities also reported confrontations in Grenoble, while police in Marseille used tear gas and crowd-control equipment after an otherwise largely peaceful march.
In Lyon, security forces conducted extensive identity checks and restricted access to parts of the city center.
Police arrested several young men suspected of possessing materials that could be used to manufacture improvised explosive devices.
Those incidents have contributed to concerns among police representatives about the possibility of further violence during planned demonstrations.
However, reporting from multiple cities indicated that most participants engaged in peaceful marches focused on economic and social grievances.
The nationwide movement began in mid-October with protests organized by high school students dissatisfied with educational conditions.
Students raised concerns about deteriorating school facilities, teacher shortages, university admissions and uncertainty about employment opportunities.
The demonstrations subsequently expanded to include labor unions, university students, public-sector employees and other groups protesting rising living expenses and pressure on public services.
According to Associated Press coverage of the Oct. 31 demonstrations, many participants marched peacefully, with some wearing Halloween costumes, while violence was concentrated among smaller groups near the conclusion of demonstrations.
The movement has become a significant challenge for President Emmanuel Macron’s government ahead of France’s 2027 presidential election.
Protesters have criticized the administration’s economic policies, public spending priorities and restrictions imposed on demonstrations.
The government has maintained that additional security measures are necessary to prevent a recurrence of the extensive destruction recorded during the first weekend of protests.
Authorities have redirected some marches away from major commercial districts, imposed localized restrictions on gatherings and increased the use of identity checks.
Security personnel have also received support from surveillance equipment and additional deployments around sensitive buildings.
Those measures have generated criticism from student organizations and civil liberties advocates.
Some protest organizers argue that police restrictions interfere with lawful demonstrations and unfairly associate peaceful participants with people committing violence.
The National Union of Students of France, known as UNEF, has accused the government of failing to address the movement’s underlying demands.
Student and labor organizations have called for additional demonstrations and strikes, arguing that restrictions on public gatherings will not resolve concerns about education, employment and living costs.
A nationwide day of industrial action and demonstrations is scheduled for Thursday, Nov. 5.
Some student groups have also called for school blockades earlier in the week.
The prospect of further mobilization has intensified concerns among police unions about staffing levels and the ability to sustain prolonged operations.
In remarks reported by RT en français, Lauze warned that officers could not indefinitely maintain the current deployment schedule.
He also drew parallels with recurring violence associated with New Year’s Eve and Bastille Day celebrations, arguing that some participants were engaging in destructive behavior unrelated to political grievances.
Lauze called for a stronger legal response to people who attack police officers, loot businesses or participate in organized violence.
His criticism comes amid broader disagreements in France over policing, judicial sentencing and public security.
Police unions have repeatedly argued that officers face increasing risks from violent offenders and that the legal system does not always impose sufficiently strong consequences for attacks on law enforcement personnel.
Civil liberties organizations, meanwhile, have raised concerns about excessive use of force, preventive arrests and restrictions on lawful assembly.
The competing positions have become more prominent as the latest demonstrations continue.
France has a history of mass protest movements capable of disrupting transportation, commerce and government operations.
The Yellow Vest movement began in November 2018 in opposition to fuel taxes before developing into a broader campaign against economic inequality and Macron’s policies.
Demonstrations continued for months, producing confrontations between protesters and police, damage to commercial areas and extensive deployments of security personnel.
Lauze’s comparison reflects concerns that the current unrest could develop into another prolonged confrontation requiring sustained police mobilization.
The latest demonstrations differ in their origins, beginning largely with younger protesters concerned about education and living standards.
Nevertheless, their expansion into broader economic grievances has created similarities with earlier protest movements.
According to Agence France-Presse’s reporting on police deployments, the government mobilized approximately 70,000 security personnel following serious violence during the Oct. 17 demonstrations.
Authorities also warned that calls for looting and attacks had circulated on social media ahead of subsequent protests.
The government has sought to prevent those incidents while allowing authorized demonstrations to proceed.
The latest official figures suggest that security measures have coincided with a reduction in arrests, injuries and property damage compared with the first weekend of unrest.
However, police unions argue that even reduced levels of violence impose substantial physical and psychological demands when tens of thousands of officers must be deployed repeatedly.
Lauze’s warning adds to pressure on the French government to address both public security and the underlying causes of the demonstrations.
The government faces demands from police organizations for stronger protections, from protesters for economic and educational reforms, and from businesses for measures preventing further damage.
Those competing priorities will remain prominent as additional demonstrations approach.
For now, France’s Interior Ministry maintains that security forces are preserving the right to peaceful protest while responding to violent groups.
Lauze contends that existing laws provide insufficient protection and that repeated attacks risk further exhausting the country’s police personnel.
With another nationwide mobilization scheduled for Nov. 5, French authorities are preparing for continued demonstrations as the government attempts to contain unrest without further escalating tensions between protesters and law enforcement.
Original article
Comments