Washing feels like the safest thing you can do with food. Water is clean, so food rinsed in water must be cleaner. That logic is right about half the time, and wrong in ways that matter the other half.

By the time food reaches your kitchen, many hands and machines have handled it, and some of it has been sprayed with pesticides or preservatives you cannot see. At the same time, foodborne bacteria such as Salmonella, Campylobacter, E. coli, and Listeria can live on the foods you like most. The question is not whether to wash, but what to wash, and how.

The rule that ties it together is simple: water removes dirt from the surface of food, but it does not kill bacteria. Only heat does that. So washing helps when the food will be eaten raw or lightly cooked, and it hurts when it spreads bacteria from raw meat onto surfaces that never get heated. Here are the ten foods where the distinction matters most.

1. Chicken: Never Wash

This is the most important rule in the list, and the one most people get wrong. About 70 percent of home cooks in the United States still rinse raw chicken before cooking, according to a study funded by the USDA, yet every major food safety authority in the country, the USDA, the CDC, and the FDA, says not to do it.

Rinsing does not remove bacteria from chicken. Some bacteria cling so tightly to the skin that no amount of tap water dislodges them, and the water that bounces off carries the rest onto the sink, the counter, your hands, and anything nearby. In a 2019 USDA study in real home kitchens, 60 percent of people who washed their raw poultry ended up with bacteria in the sink afterward, 14 percent still had bacteria in the sink after they tried to clean it, and 26 percent moved bacteria onto the salad they were making for the same meal. Droplets can travel up to 3 feet, about 90 cm, in every direction from the sink.

The bacteria at stake are serious. Raw chicken commonly carries Salmonella, found in about 1 in every 25 packages sold in American grocery stores, and Campylobacter, one of the most common causes of food poisoning in the country. Only a few Campylobacter cells are enough to cause illness, with stomach ache, diarrhea, and vomiting, and older adults are more likely than younger people to need hospital care.

What works instead is heat. Cook all poultry to 165 degrees F, about 74 degrees C, measured with a food thermometer in the thickest part, not by looking at the colour or the juices. Lemon juice, vinegar, and salt water do not kill bacteria on raw poultry, and they spray germs around the kitchen the same way plain water does. Store raw chicken covered on the bottom shelf of the fridge so its juices cannot drip onto other foods, wash your hands with soap for 20 seconds after handling it, and clean the cutting board and utensils with hot, soapy water.

2. Eggs: Never Wash

An egg comes with its own packaging. A hen coats each egg with a thin, nearly invisible layer called the cuticle, or bloom, which seals the thousands of tiny pores in the shell, keeps bacteria out, and slows moisture loss.

In the United States, commercial eggs are already washed and sanitized before they reach the store, and that process removes the bloom. That is why American eggs must be refrigerated at 40 degrees F or below, in their carton, on a cold shelf rather than in the fridge door, and used within three to five weeks. Washing them again at home adds nothing and can pull bacteria through the pores into the egg, especially with cold water.

Farm-fresh eggs are different. If the bloom is still intact, do not wash them until right before you use them. Once an egg is washed, the bloom is gone, so it must be refrigerated and used promptly, never put back on the counter. In both cases, the rule is the same: do not wash eggs before storing them.

3. Fish: Never Wash

Fish follows the same rule as chicken. Rinsing a raw fillet under the tap does not eliminate bacteria, it only spreads them to the sink, the cutting board, and your hands. A wet, dripping piece of fish also introduces bacteria into the cracks of a wooden board, where they are hard to clean out.

There is a second reason, too. A wet fillet will not sear properly. Pat fish dry with a paper towel before cooking, and it will brown better and hold its flavour. Cooking to the right temperature is what kills bacteria on fish, just as it does on chicken, so let the heat do the work and keep the tap off.

4. Pasta: Never Wash

Chefs are clear on this one, and the reason is flavour, not safety. Dry pasta is coated in starch, and that starch is what makes sauce cling to the noodles. Rinse the pasta before cooking and you wash the starch away, leaving noodles that sauce slides off.

The exception proves the rule. After cooking, a rinse is fine, and it is the right move for a cold pasta salad, where you want the noodles to stay separate. Before cooking, keep the pasta dry and let the starch do its job.

5. Mushrooms: Rinse Briefly, Never Soak

Mushrooms sit in a grey area, and the old advice about them needs updating. Generations of cooks were told never to let a mushroom touch water, because mushrooms are like sponges. Food scientists who actually weighed them found something different.

In one well-known test, food scientist Harold McGee soaked 252 grams of mushrooms in water for five minutes, blotted them, and weighed them again. They had picked up just 6 grams of water. Other tests found the same pattern: about 2 to 5 percent of their weight, most of it water caught in the gills rather than absorbed into the flesh. A mushroom is already about 90 percent water, so there is little dry structure inside waiting to soak more up.

The practical rule is therefore a middle one. A quick rinse under cool running water is fine, and it removes soil and microbes better than wiping alone. What you should not do is soak mushrooms, or wash them hours before cooking and then store them wet, because damp storage makes them spoil faster and turn slimy. Rinse them right before cooking, dry them thoroughly with a towel or a salad spinner, and cook them in a hot pan so the surface moisture evaporates in seconds.

6. Canned Beans and Vegetables: Always Rinse

Canned foods are already cooked and safe to eat from the can, but the liquid they sit in is worth rinsing away. Canned beans, corn, peas, and potatoes are packed in salty brine, and that brine adds a large amount of sodium you do not need, especially if you watch your blood pressure.

A USDA study published in 2011 found that draining canned beans alone cut their sodium by 36 percent, and draining plus rinsing cut it by 41 percent. For canned vegetables such as green beans, corn, and peas, draining and rinsing cut sodium by 9 to 23 percent. Rinsing also washes away some of the starchy liquid that can cause gas. The exception is foods packed in sauce, such as baked beans or soup, which are meant to be eaten as they are.

One more habit belongs here: wipe or rinse the top of the can before you open it. You do not know where that can has been, or who or what touched it, and the lid is the part that meets your food.

7. Fresh Fruits and Vegetables: Always Wash

This is the other side of the rule, and it applies to almost everything from the produce aisle. Fresh fruits and vegetables can carry soil, pesticide residue, and bacteria from the farm, the packing house, and many hands along the way. Washing will not remove every residue, but it removes a meaningful share of dirt and surface germs, and it lowers your risk of food poisoning.

The FDA gives seven simple tips. Wash your hands for 20 seconds with warm water and soap before and after preparing produce. Cut away damaged or bruised areas. Rinse produce before you peel it, so dirt and bacteria are not transferred from the knife onto the flesh inside. Gently rub produce while holding it under plain running water, with no need for soap or a commercial produce wash. Scrub firm produce, such as melons and cucumbers, with a clean vegetable brush. Dry produce with a clean cloth or paper towel, which further reduces bacteria. And remove the outermost leaves of a head of lettuce or cabbage.

Two details are easy to miss. First, wash produce even if you plan to peel it. A knife can drag surface dirt from the rind of a melon or an avocado straight into the flesh you are about to eat. Second, wash produce just before you eat or cook it, not right after shopping. Excess moisture in storage encourages spoilage and bacterial growth.

8. Lettuce: Always Wash, Leaf by Leaf

Lettuce deserves its own entry because it is eaten raw, it grows close to the soil, and its many folds hide dirt, insects, and bacteria. Farmers often spray it to control pests such as aphids, and the same leaves can harbour Listeria or E. coli.

Wash lettuce leaf by leaf under cool running water, rubbing gently, and dry it well. A salad spinner is the easiest way to remove moisture after washing, and dry leaves keep longer and hold dressing better. Pre-washed bagged lettuce is a different case: if the bag says it is ready to eat and has been kept refrigerated, it has already been washed, and re-washing it at home adds little. If you open a bag and the leaves look dirty or slimy, throw them out rather than trying to rescue them.

9. Nuts: Rinse, and Soak Only If You Like the Result

Nuts are the most debated item on this list, and the honest answer is that the evidence is mixed. Nuts contain phytic acid, a compound that can bind to minerals such as iron, zinc, calcium, and magnesium in the gut, reducing how much of them your body absorbs. Soaking is said to break phytic acid down and switch off enzyme inhibitors, making nuts easier to digest.

Some studies support that idea, reporting phytic acid reductions of 20 to 50 percent after soaking. But a 2020 study in Food Chemistry tested the usual soaking methods on almonds, hazelnuts, peanuts, and walnuts, and found that phytate changed by only minus 12 percent to plus 10 percent, essentially no meaningful difference, while minerals leached into the soaking water and were thrown away. A follow-up trial found that soaked almonds caused more flatulence, not less, and no better tolerance than unsoaked almonds.

The practical takeaway is modest. Rinsing nuts is a sensible habit, and soaking them for a few hours in water, then drying them thoroughly, is fine if you prefer the softer texture or find them easier to digest. It is not a reliable way to prevent mineral deficiency, which is unlikely from a handful of nuts in an otherwise varied diet. Do not soak nuts at room temperature for a day or more, because bacteria can grow in the soaking water, and remember that soaking in salt water adds a large amount of sodium.

10. Dried Fruit: Always Rinse

Dried fruit looks clean, but it is not. It is handled, dried, and packed, and it can carry dust and dirt from every step. It is also one of the largest sources of sulfites in the diet. Sulfur dioxide is added to many dried fruits to keep their colour bright and stop them from spoiling, and the FDA requires it to be listed on the label when a product contains more than 10 parts per million.

For most people, sulfites in normal amounts are considered safe. For a small minority, about 1 percent of the population, and for 3 to 10 percent of people with asthma, they can trigger flushing, hives, stomach cramps, wheezing, or an asthma attack, usually within half an hour of eating. A brief rinse under running water, followed by patting dry, removes surface dirt and some surface sulfites. It will not remove all of them, so if you are sensitive, choose unsulfured dried fruit, which is browner and less brightly coloured but far lower in sulfites. Do not soak dried fruit for hours unless a recipe calls for it, or it will turn to mush.

What the Research Can — and Cannot — Tell Us

Washing is a surface treatment, not a steriliser. It removes dirt and some bacteria and pesticide residue, but it does not kill the bacteria that remain, and no washing method removes pesticide residue completely, because some of it absorbs into the skin of the produce. The studies behind the chicken rule are observational kitchen studies, not laboratory proofs, and the numbers vary between kitchens. The mushroom tests were small, and the nut-soaking trials come from a small number of research groups.

What is consistent across all of it is the direction. Do not wash raw meat, poultry, or fish. Do wash produce, canned beans, and dried fruit. Cook meat to the temperature that kills bacteria, and keep raw meat away from food you will eat raw. Those four habits cover most of the risk in an ordinary kitchen.

Moderation Is Key

Food safety is about risk, not fear, and it matters more after 60. Older adults are more likely to be hospitalised by food poisoning, and their immune systems recover more slowly, so the same mistake that gives a younger person a bad day can give an older person a bad week. That is a reason to be careful, not a reason to be afraid of your kitchen.

A few habits cover the rest. Wash your hands with soap for 20 seconds before and after handling raw meat. Use separate cutting boards for raw meat and for produce. Refrigerate leftovers within two hours, or within one hour if it is above 90 degrees F outside. Keep your fridge at 40 degrees F or below. And if you are ever unsure whether something is safe to eat, throw it out. The cost of a meal is never worth the cost of a hospital visit.

The Bottom Line

The rule is not "always wash" or "never wash." It is "wash what you eat raw, and never wash what you are about to cook." Chicken, eggs, fish, and dry pasta stay out of the sink. Fruits, vegetables, lettuce, canned beans, and dried fruit go under running water first. Mushrooms and nuts sit in the middle: a quick rinse, dried well, and no long soak.

Learn the list once, and it becomes automatic. Your kitchen stays cleaner, your food tastes better, and the bacteria that cause food poisoning have far fewer chances to reach your plate.

Sources:

• Washing food: does it promote food safety? USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service. https://permanent.fdlp.gov/websites/fsisusdagov/www.fsis.usda.gov/wps/wcm/connect/2ceaa425-0488-4e86-a397-e2d9c470fc4a/Washing_Food.pdf-MOD=AJPERES.pdf

• 7 tips for cleaning fruits and vegetables, U.S. Food and Drug Administration. http://www.fda.gov/ForConsumers/ConsumerUpdates/ucm256215.htm

• Rinsing canned vegetables and beans to cut sodium, USDA Nutrient Data Laboratory study, 2011. https://www.thefreelibrary.com/Rinse+canned+vegetables+to+cut+sodium-a0329607058

• Does washing mushrooms really make them soggy? Weighing the sponge myth, including the McGee, Wolke, and Lopez-Alt tests. https://whatifkitchen.com/articles/does-washing-mushrooms-really-make-them-soggy-weighing-the-sponge-myth

• Soaking nuts and nutrient bioavailability, Food Chemistry, 2020. https://www.biochron.net/en/activated-nuts-benefits-post168

• Drying fruits, sulfites and asthma sensitivity, Colorado State University Extension. https://foodsafety.ces.ncsu.edu/documents/471278/Drying-Fruits-CSU-fact-sheet.pdf