A federal judge in California ruled that Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins’ Christmas and Easter emails to approximately 100,000 USDA employees likely violated the First Amendment, ordering her to stop using her official position to pressure workers over religious beliefs while preserving her right to personal religious expression.

By yourNEWS Media Newsroom

A federal judge appointed by former President Joe Biden issued a preliminary injunction Thursday, Nov. 19, restricting Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins from sending religious messages to Department of Agriculture employees after determining that two Christian-themed holiday emails crossed constitutional boundaries separating government authority from religious expression.

U.S. District Judge Trina Thompson of the Northern District of California found that messages Rollins distributed to approximately 100,000 USDA employees in December 2025 and April 2026 created coercive pressure by suggesting that Christianity was the shared faith of the department’s workforce.

The 21-page federal court ruling granted a preliminary injunction in favor of six USDA employees and the National Federation of Federal Employees, who filed suit in May alleging that Rollins’ department-wide communications violated the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment.

Thompson concluded that the challenged emails went beyond routine religious holiday greetings because they came from the agency’s highest-ranking official, used government communication systems and contained language implying that employees shared the secretary’s Christian beliefs.

The ruling does not prohibit Rollins from practicing Christianity, discussing her faith with interested colleagues or expressing religious views in appropriate workplace conversations. Instead, it restricts her use of official authority to promote religious beliefs to employees who may feel compelled to receive and read her communications.

The controversy centered on two messages Rollins sent to USDA personnel celebrating Christmas and Easter.

On Dec. 23, 2025, Rollins distributed a Christmas email containing a video in which she described the religious significance of the holiday and the birth of Jesus Christ.

“The spirit of generosity flows from the very first Christmas when God gave us the greatest gift possible, the gift of his Son and our Savior Jesus Christ, who came to free us from our sins and open the door to eternal life,” Rollins said in the video, according to the court’s findings.

The message also described Christ’s birth as the foundation of the Christmas celebration.

A second email, sent April 5, 2026, was addressed to all USDA employees and opened with the words, “Happy Easter – He is Risen indeed!”

Rollins described Easter as “the greatest story ever told, the foundation of our faith, and the abiding hope of all mankind.”

The email discussed the crucifixion and resurrection of Jesus Christ, the destruction of sin and the Christian belief in eternal life.

She also encouraged employees to draw inspiration from the resurrection, comparing their responsibilities to the mission of Christ’s earliest followers.

“And so, like the very first disciples to encounter our risen Lord in the Upper Room almost two thousand years ago, this Easter let us too be alive with hope, full of Paschal joy, and confident in the mission each of us has been called for,” Rollins wrote.

The Easter message concluded with appreciation for USDA employees’ work and a blessing for their families and the country. An illustration depicting the empty tomb of Jesus accompanied the email.

According to Courthouse News Service’s examination of the decision, Thompson found that the Christmas and Easter communications presented a constitutional concern because Rollins was speaking as the leader of a federal agency rather than solely as a private individual.

The judge identified three central considerations: Rollins’ supervisory authority over employees, her use of an official government email account and language that appeared to assume recipients shared her religious beliefs.

The lawsuit was filed May 13 by federal employees Lanette Dietrich, Thomas MaGee, Ashley Miller, Anne Poopatanapong, Ethan Roberts and Jennifer Wolfe, together with the National Federation of Federal Employees.

The union represents approximately 110,000 federal employees nationwide, including more than 19,000 USDA workers.

The plaintiffs, who hold different religious and nonreligious beliefs, argued that receiving messages promoting Christianity from the head of their agency made them feel excluded and pressured to conform.

Their complaint also alleged that employees could not reasonably ignore emails from Rollins because her official communications regularly include important workplace information involving agency operations, personnel policies, reorganizations and government shutdown planning.

One employee alleged that a request to be removed from the distribution list was rejected and that continued objections could create professional difficulties.

Other plaintiffs described concerns about openly discussing their own beliefs. According to the court record, one employee who practices Buddhism became reluctant to discuss a religious holiday, while an atheist employee reported feeling silenced and a Pagan employee expressed concern about professional advancement.

The plaintiffs argued that the emails constituted government-sponsored religious pressure rather than ordinary expressions of personal faith.

Thompson agreed that the plaintiffs had demonstrated a likelihood of succeeding on their constitutional claim.

The judge also examined the USDA’s own November 2025 guidance on religious expression in federal workplaces, which protects employees’ ability to discuss religion while prohibiting the use of supervisory authority to pressure subordinates.

The guidance allows employees to discuss their religious beliefs, explain the importance of their faith, invite interested colleagues to religious activities and express religious viewpoints during appropriate conversations.

However, the same policy prohibits persistent unwanted religious advances and requires employees to stop religious discussions when colleagues object.

Thompson concluded that Rollins must follow those standards when communicating with employees.

The judge questioned why the secretary should be exempt from restrictions that apply to other USDA personnel, particularly given her position at the top of the agency’s leadership structure.

The court also considered Rollins’ use of inclusive language such as “we,” “us” and “our” when discussing Christianity, along with the absence of comparable department-wide messages acknowledging holidays associated with other religions.

Thompson determined that those circumstances could create the impression that adherence to Christianity was an expected part of belonging to the USDA workforce.

The decision emphasized that employees’ ability to receive important official communications should not require them to encounter religious messages that could pressure them to conceal or change their beliefs.

In its report on the ruling, The Associated Press noted that Thompson distinguished between constitutionally protected personal religious expression and communications that use government authority to promote a particular faith.

The judge’s order also rejected the plaintiffs’ separate claims under the Administrative Procedure Act, determining that the emails did not constitute final agency actions subject to challenge under that statute.

The constitutional claim, however, remains active, and the preliminary injunction will govern the challenged conduct while litigation continues.

The ruling specifically preserves Rollins’ freedom to express her religious beliefs in her personal capacity, making clear that the court was not attempting to regulate her private religious practices.

The lawsuit drew support from Americans United for Separation of Church and State, which represented the employees alongside other legal advocates.

Rachel Laser, the organization’s president, welcomed the decision and argued that government officials should not use taxpayer-funded communication systems to promote religious beliefs among public employees.

“Today’s decision should send a message to the Trump administration that it cannot misuse taxpayer resources to preach, hold government-sponsored prayer services during work time, and broadcast Christian nationalism over official communication channels. Not on our watch,” Laser said.

Rollins has publicly defended her Christian faith and previously addressed criticism of her Easter message through social media.

Following the lawsuit, she wrote, “It’s just another opportunity to remind everyone: He is Risen.”

The dispute comes amid continuing legal disagreements over religious expression in government workplaces, including the distinction between an employee’s constitutional right to exercise religion and restrictions on government endorsement or coercion.

The First Amendment protects religious exercise while also prohibiting government establishment of religion. Courts evaluating disputes involving public employees must consider both protections, particularly when religious messages come from supervisors who exercise authority over employment conditions.

The Supreme Court has recognized protections for individual religious expression by government employees, including in its 2022 decision in Kennedy v. Bremerton School District, which involved a public school football coach’s postgame prayers.

Thompson distinguished that precedent from the USDA dispute, finding that employees receiving official communications from a Cabinet secretary occupy a different position than individuals observing a private religious expression.

The judge noted that the USDA’s communications system does not provide employees with a practical opportunity to avoid the secretary’s messages without potentially missing important information related to their jobs.

The court scheduled a further case management conference for Dec. 17, with the parties required to submit a joint statement by Dec. 10.

The preliminary injunction does not represent a final judgment resolving every allegation in the lawsuit. It establishes restrictions on the challenged conduct while the constitutional dispute proceeds.

Under the order, Rollins may continue discussing her Christian faith voluntarily with interested colleagues, but she cannot use her official position to pressure employees into religious participation or create a coercive workplace environment through unsolicited religious messaging.

The ruling leaves the USDA secretary’s personal religious freedoms intact while requiring her official communications with federal employees to comply with constitutional restrictions governing the relationship between religion and government authority.

Original article