Bobby and John broke some cave anchors. They tested the Climbing Technology's Soft Anchors and also the homemade ones by Andrzej Rudkowski.
CT dyneema broke at 14kn and rethreaded with Max sk99 4mm broke at 16kn and in tension broke at 11kn.
Soft Shackle homemade anchor broke the metal round stock at 18kn, then the soft shackle at 23kn and then the bolt itself at 25kn but when pulled in tension, the soft shackle destroys the circle at 17kn.
Clown hangers broke the ropes first. Super good enough. I'm quite impressed how strong they are and would totally rappel on them.
00:00 Not Ryan 00:30 About John and the anchors 2:33 Climb Tech hangers 5:30 Soft Shackle hangers 08:11 D12 Max 99 Test 10:08 Pulling in Tension 11:02 Clown Hangers
Hi, I'm Ryan Jenks.
And I'm Bobby Hutton.
And today we're going to test some string bolts.
So this is actually not Ryan.
He's actually hanging out with his girlfriend.
So I decided to sneak into the lab.
This is our friend, John Fioroni.
John, introduce yourself
and tell us a little bit about your experience.
Yeah, so I'm not Ryan.
I'm a caver and I've been caving for about 29 years now.
During normal times, I get to spend about five weeks
underground doing exploration and research.
I'm one of the co-founders of the Cave Exploration Society.
And we have expeditions going on in Cuba,
Iran, Turkey, and Kurdistan right now.
Perfect.
John, you want to tell us a little bit
about what we're testing today?
Sure, these are soft anchors or AS anchors,
if you want the French acronym.
They are used primarily for deep caves
and expedition caves in Europe.
They come with a five millimeter Dyneema string.
They're bored for an eight millimeter bolt,
so traditionally used with a spit anchor.
To make these worthwhile, it's best to throw out
the one meter of cord that comes with them
and replace them with about one and a half meters
of five millimeter Dyneema.
So why would you use that as opposed to like
a normal hanger with a quick link?
These are a bit lighter and they allow you
to place an anchor above a sharp edge
where the Dyneema can wrap around the edge and not break.
And these allow you to bypass a quick link or a carabiner
where you can tie the cord directly to a figure eight
and save a bit of weight.
Is this something you use a lot?
I use these in some of our expeditions in Turkey.
They have a little bit of popularity
kind of in the Northwest of the US,
but they're not used too often over here.
So in the climbing world,
if we wanted to do something similar, we would use this.
Why don't you just use something like this?
It's more about weight savings
and saving volume in your cave pack
because we're limited on how much we can carry into a cave.
So this actually condenses into a much smaller package
than a hanger and a quick link.
And it's probably a third the weight.
It is, yeah, it's much lighter.
Traditionally, they're attached to a spit bolt
with a eight millimeter bolt,
but because we're not testing the spit itself,
we've used a more traditional threaded bolt
onto a block of steel.
Just so we can be authentic,
what would you normally attach to this soft anchor?
So traditionally in caving,
we use an oval locking beaner, which we have here,
but we also have the option of tying the Dyneema
directly to a loop on a figure eight if we wanted to.
We might try that.
Soft anchor.
I originally thought that was some scarring on the aluminum,
but what do you think it is, John?
I think it's just a little bit of Dyneema
melted to the aluminum hanger.
Oh, totally.
All right, John, show us how it's done.
So this technique bypasses a carabiner or a quick link,
where we tied the Dyneema directly
to the figure eight on a bite.
And you can use this in the middle of the rope.
You don't have to have the end of the rope.
Correct.
So this will technically work,
but for safety, you would loop it over the top like this.
And then bolt it to the wall.
And then attach it to the wall, exactly.
Would it be easier if this cord was longer?
Yeah, so this is a good reason
why you don't want to use a meter of cord,
but 1 1⁄4 to 1 1⁄2 meters of cord is better.
It gives you a little bit more slack here.
The knot doesn't get sucked up right next to the hanger,
and it makes it a little bit easier to tie,
and it gives you more options for different variations.
I keep these just for using them as redirects,
but then I normally tie them
with about a meter and a half of cord.
Okay, and what kind of cord is this?
This is five millimeter Dyneema cord.
It's a Dyneema core in a Dyneema sheath.
It's important to use a five millimeter cord
that is 100% Dyneema and not a nylon sheath on it
for maximum strength.
Soft anchor test three,
this time with an eight millimeter rope
tied directly into the Dyneema string.
I'm a little surprised that the eight millimeter
broke first, but not surprised that it broke in the knot
like every other test that they've done.
So those were the climbing technology,
caving anchorages, soft anchors.
A viewer sent us an alternative.
Those of you who have been watching a long time
will recognize this as one of Ryan's favorite things.
And it looks like it is a round,
a just like aluminum round stock
that has been bored out and threaded.
So let's see what these break at.
So we have it screwed into a bolt.
It is threaded and that's a spacer
because this wouldn't thread all the way down
and there's nothing really to grip.
If I was designing it,
I'd probably remove the threads from this
and then just screw a nut down on top of it
like a traditional hanger.
We've got an oval locking carabiner here
because my expert says that was the best.
John, predictions?
I think it's going to break up in the radius here.
I'm guessing it's going to break around 25 kilonewtons.
What was that?
Kilonewtons.
Oh, okay.
Is that the right way to say it?
I have no idea.
I learned from Ryan.
What do you think?
I was not expecting that.
It actually blew out the sides of the soft hanger.
And our soft shackle is a little damaged,
but still intact.
So that is stronger than the ones from Climbing Technology.
So since our setup before bent the bolt so much
and that was hard to get off,
I used a smaller bolt.
That's a 716th bolt and it's bypassing the threads
and just nut is tightened down on it,
which is how I would install these.
So yes, definitely better to have it flush
where you're not having the bolt bending over itself.
That could, kind of what we had,
could almost simulate this being pulled in tension
versus in shearing.
So third test, third type of result.
So our bolt there sheared off
and I'm sure is somewhere in the lab.
That is why we stand behind cover.
And this is still intact.
You can see there that it's deforming the Dyneema Amsteel,
but it does not seem to be cutting it yet.
That was our strongest result so far.
Okay, John, what do we have here?
All right, so to try to get the actual
aluminum hanger to break,
we've threaded some four millimeter SK99 Max Dyneema
cord, this is supposed to be stronger than the five mil.
And so hopefully that will break the hanger
and not the Dyneema.
Larry came to visit and he's gonna give us a prediction
on what this breaks at.
1350, 1350 pounds, you convert it.
Okay.
Yeah, I think that sounds about right.
It still breaks around the radius of the hanger itself,
which seems like it makes sense for being the weakest point.
Over 50% stronger than it's rated for.
Yeah, yeah, it's substantially stronger.
There's a pretty good safety margin.
So John, thanks so much for coming down
and breaking stuff with us.
What did you think of these guys?
Are you still gonna use them?
I'm still gonna use them for deep caving.
They have no place in kind of the recreational caving area.
They're a specialized hanger
and they work well for their intended uses.
We learned that they tend to always break around the radius,
which makes sense because it pinches the Dyneema.
This one was sent in by a viewer.
It's a homemade soft hanger.
It worked very well.
There's a few areas to maybe refine.
There's some sharp edges on the inside
and then the radius maybe could be expanded
just a little bit.
But the idea of having it on a soft shackle
really makes a lot of sense.
I think we need to test some cyclical loading on it
to make sure it doesn't come undone.
But I do think these have a place
in expedition caving for sure.
I believe Ryan is working with you
to do some gear sales as well.
What's the name of that website?
That's extremegear.org.
All of the net proceeds from both websites
go to support our expeditions and research.
Rad.
John, thank you so much for coming
and sharing your expertise
and we hope we'll have you on again.
Thanks for having me.
Take care.
Bonus test.
I was bummed that I missed John,
but it was cool that Bobby and him
got to break those cave samples since John's a caver.
But I wanted to know what they did in tension
and I had one of each left when I went back to the lab.
Well, that's intense.
There's another piece.
This did not break.
I mean, it's not in great shape, but it did not break.
Wow, that is an interesting chart.
So this happened.
I want to see what this does in tension.
This thing held.
I'm impressed.
That's some pretty sharp edges
against this Dyneema stuff though.
And since we're testing some obscure cave anchors,
I thought we would grind off the bolt
that's on a clown hanger
and install it onto our rectangle jib.
And then I started with an eight millimeter rope,
which broke the rope first
because the rope goes around the bolt.
And then I stuck half inch rope on there,
which is the biggest rope I had
to see if it deformed the hanger at all.
And it did not.
And the rope broke first.
So then out of sheer curiosity,
I clipped a carabiner to the damn thing
and it broke pretty low,
lower than any other hanger I've ever tested.
Granted, you're not supposed to clip a carabiner to that.
Now, for some reason,
I cannot find the footage that has the numbers on there,
but I remember it being like nine or 11 kilonewtons
to break the hanger.
And then the ropes broke more or less full strength,
but it's irrelevant because you're just ascending
or descending on those ropes,
which is about one or two kilonewtons.
So the clown hanger is pretty creative though.
I appreciate my patrons for supporting
this nerdy niche content
because it's probably not gonna get a ton of views,
but I think it helps know what these things break at
if you see them in a cave.
Head over to hownottoswag.com
and don't forget to wipe and subscribe.