Triumph Thruxton R vs BMW R nine T

You’ve got my wheels spinning!
31 followers
15 Video Views·Nov 7, 2022
When a bike manufacturer sends us out one of their fancy pants, exotic bike
launchers, we've got a fairly obvious task in hand, which is to find out as
much about the bike as possible, given the short time frame that we've got with
it. Now, it really, really didn't take long to figure out that the Thruxton R
was just a gorgeous creation from Triumph, but whilst a bike launch is
always specific about that bike model, the journalists, the video bloggers, the
guys and the girls that go out there to ride the bike are also thinking in the
back of their head, what is this thing going to be pitched up against when it
finally goes on sale in the UK? Well, to me, there was only ever really one bike
that this thing was going to go up against, and it's just as fast, it's got a
very similar combination of old-school styling and modern touches, and it's also
got that lovely quality of finish like the Thruxton R, and of course it's BMW's
R19. Now, with two such stunning machines, it felt only right to come to an
equally pretty locations film, so we're here in the Lake District with our
friends Aaron and Geoff from Knox, who are not only going to help us ride the
bikes, but they're also going to film us filming the review, so it gives you an
insight into how one of these videos is actually shot. I can see Aaron is kind of
dribbling over the Thruxton behind the camera. I've not ridden ZBMW before, so
we're going to go out now and find some nice roads to ride. So, if you want a
Thruxton in your life, this is not the cheapest way to go about it, because they
also do a base model which comes in at £1,300 cheaper, but by the time you've
considered the fact that this comes with better suspension, it comes with
better brakes, better tyres, and generally just cooler trinkets, you'd be sort of
mad not to go for the R, and not mad just because those are nice things to look at
and nice things to have, but also because they complement that nice little engine,
which is an absolute peach in the Thruxton. Now, I say little, but actually it's a
brand new 1,200cc water-cooled parallel twin unit, makes just under 100
horsepower at just under 7,000 rpm, and it's got this really, really nice mixture
of torque down low and then power up top, and to be honest, the whole bike feels
quite contradictory in many senses, because it's got that classic look to it,
it feels quite retro to ride in some ways, and yet superficially, it's a very
modern bike. You know, you take the Ohlin suspension, you take the really
high-spec Brembo brakes, the very new Pirelli tyres, and then those Showa big
piston forks. Those forks aren't particularly revolutionary, but they were
a few years ago. They're on the current Gixxer now, they're on the old ZX10, so
it's a proper performance machine, and it's fantastic to ride when we rode it
in Lisbon for the launch, and then also today, it's just been a nice reminder of
what a cool bike this really is. It sort of does it all, it's very fast through the
corners, it's fantastic to look at, it sounds great, and then even though when
you look at it, it looks like a proper racing machine, it's got the clip-ons,
everything feels quite solid, it's actually not too uncomfortable. The seat
is very hard, but because the seat's quite low, actually the riding position
isn't too uncomfortable. Now, because we've gone for the high-spec Thruxton,
it's only right that we do the same with the R9T, so that is the R9T Sport,
and like the Thruxton, it also comes with some high-spec stuff, but it's not the
same as the Thruxton in the sense that most of the upgrades that you do get are
kind of less performance-focused. So on the Sport, you get heated grips, you get
that cafe racer style seat cowl, you get the brushed aluminium tank, but then the
performance-focused aspect of it is that you get a high-rise Akrapovic exhaust,
which just makes the bike sound so good and complements, again, the engine,
which is also a 1,200cc unit. It's a boxer twin, obviously, and it makes just a bit
more power than the Thruxton. That's about 110 horsepower, and to be honest,
even though they both look very retro, both those machines are properly quick.
So when we first jumped on the bikes today, I had a feeling that it was going
to be really difficult to differentiate the bikes in terms of which one I prefer
more and how they feel, but actually, despite the fact that they both look
fairly classically styled and they both fit into that retro class,
these two bikes are so different. They really are chalk and cheese.
Aaron's been riding the Thruxton a lot today, and he prefers that bike.
I actually prefer the R9T. Now, the reason for that is, personally,
I think the Thruxton, when you're riding it, it feels totally different to the BMW
in the sense that it feels quite heavy through the corners. It feels like it
wants to go straight a lot of the time. It's got that cafe racer vibe to it.
It's got the clip-ons. It's got very short bars, and it's also got a very short tank,
so you naturally want to kind of tuck your elbows in, duck down, and sort of pin it
through a straight line, and it doesn't really want to track around corners and
flick from side to side. It certainly feels top-heavy when you're doing that.
Now, the BMW is kind of the opposite. It doesn't feel quite as stable as the
Thruxton. It doesn't feel like it's got that weight behind it to keep it on track,
but it feels a lot, lot more nimble through the corners. It's much easier to flick
from left to right. It's got wider bars. It's got a more upright riding position,
and you've also got a bit more ground clearance on the pegs as well, so it's
just, through the corners, it feels like a more nimble machine, and it also feels
like the type of bike where, if you're in a town, it'd probably be easier to sort of
flick it through traffic and navigate and filter, basically. So, despite the
differences between these two bikes and the way that they handle, they've also
got some real big similarities, and I think, most noticeably, it comes down to
the quality of finish that they both have. So, if you park them up side by side,
they're quite similar in some senses, like, for example, you've got the brushed
metal exhaust, the brushed metal casings on the Triumph. You've got the brushed
aluminium tank on the R9T. Then you get really high-quality suspension on both
bikes, very sticky tyres on both bikes, spoke wheels on both, very high-powered
brakes on both. Notably, on the Thruxton, you've got really powerful Brembo
brakes on there. I think the biggest difference, really, with these two bikes,
in terms of how they feel, handling aside, comes down to, actually, the differences
in drive. So, you get a normal chain drive from the Thruxton, whereas on the
BMW, it's got shaft drive. And it's not that the shaft drive feels snappy, it's
just that, because with the shaft, you've either got drive or you don't, it just
feels very immediate in its power delivery. It doesn't have the give that a
chain does. On an electronics front, they're also quite different, because on
the Thruxton, you get riding modes, and then you get a traction control
incorporated into that riding mode as well, whereas on the BMW, you don't get
anything. There's no quick shifter, there's no riding modes, there's no
different fuel maps, there's no traction control, there's no anything. It's just
how it should be to me. It feels a bit more manly, it feels more turnkey and go,
and for a bike like this, which is retro-themed, it just kind of fits a bit
better to not have any of that electronic stuff, which I would probably
just turn off anyway. I'm not going to get into the topic of styling too much,
because I know that just comes down to personal taste, but a few things I will
mention is I know that a lot of people don't like that rear fender on the
Thruxton. That's just one of those annoying things that comes down to
Eurocrats, you know, you need the number plate extending over the back of the
rear wheel, so they kind of had to put it there. Something I hate on the Thruxton
is the press finish on the tank. It just doesn't look up to scratch for what this
bike costs, and another thing, a bit more personal, is the indicators. I'm sure some
people like them, I just don't like those big, bulby, orange ones. Now, on the R9T,
if you compare tanks, press finish on that one, whereas you get a gorgeous
aluminium weld on the R9T, and it just really lives up to the finish
that you'd expect from a bike like this. Another thing that's a bit fiddly on the
BMW in it, I know why they've done it, because it comes down to trying to give
it that analogue, old-school styling, is the dash is basically really hard to
read at speed. It sort of shakes around a bit, but the actual numbers on the dash
are absolutely tiny, so if you're wearing a dark visor, if you've not got
perfect vision, or something along those lines, it's really hard to just take a
quick glance down at it and see what speed you're doing. So, as I've discussed,
these bikes are very, very similar, but they're also very different, and that's
why it makes it quite hard to pick a winner, because they're just suited for
different things. So, I think the best way to choose which one I'd rather have is
to talk about which one I'd rather have, depending on the scenario. So, I think if
this was the second bike, and I wanted it for the weekend, and I wanted it to look
cool, I'd probably go for the Thruxton. It ticks all the boxes, it goes quickly, it
sounds nice, but I think living with it every single day, I'd start to get a bit,
not bored with it, but, you know, the seat is extremely hard. It's a real pain to do
U-turns, as Aaron found today, when we were looping around to take different
shots for the camera. It's just very heavy and difficult to turn. The R9T, on
the other hand, if I wanted a bike that was my primary bike, I also wanted it to
look good, and I was going to use it every single day to commute, to do long
distance, that is the bike I'd have, because it's got the heated grips, the
standard, it's a bit more comfortable, it's certainly got a more comfortable
riding position, it's got a very, very tractable engine, and then on top of that
I really can't see any downsides to it in terms of the quality of finish
anywhere. The R9T surprised me today, I thought I was going to be lusting over
the Thruxton at the end of the day, but it just really, really has grabbed me that
bike. The Akrapovic on it, it's a bit unfair because that one's just got a
stock hand, but the Akra sounds absolutely awesome. Every time you start
that bike up, it shakes itself into life in a really good way, it just feels
characterful, you can't help but blip it when you're going through towns, it's very
comfortable, it's extremely fast, it's got 110 horsepower, it really will keep up
with the best, and it's just a lovely, lovely bike to own. So if I was going to
buy one as my primary bike, and also something to just dribble out over the
weekends, I'm really sorry because I'm British and I want to save the Thruxton,
but I'd be choosing the BMW.
