British Museum Youth Collective presents Quizzing the British Museum s Director

British Museum Events
1 follower
4 Video Views·Nov 4, 2022
Join members of the British Museum's Youth Collective as they quiz the Director. Hartwig answers questions from members of the Youth Collective and the public, exploring how the British Museum can better connect with young people, encourage them to visit and engage with things important to them.Credit: British Museum Events
Welcome to our event where three members of the British Museums Youth Collective, Tessa,
Leila and Naomi, will be interviewing Hartwig Fisher, the Director of the British Museum.
We will be asking questions about the relationship between young people and the museum and answering
questions sent in by you.
This is part of a series we've created called Unlocking the Museum. You can check out our
other events on this channel and on our social media.
My name is Tessa and my pronouns are she, her.
My name is Leila and my pronouns are also she, her.
My name is Naomi and my pronouns are she, them.
I'm Hartwig and I suppose my pronouns are he and his.
So we're going to start with a couple of quickfire questions,
one from each of us before we go into the main questions. So Leila.
Hartwig, what were your experiences with museums as a young person?
Museums were very important places for me very early on
to understand what human beings are about and what I might aspire to grow into really, I think.
Kind of going off that, if you were 18 again,
which part of the collection at the British Museum do you think you would connect most with?
I would connect most with Africa, Oceania and the Americas on the one hand,
and with prints and drawings on the other at the age of 18, I think.
Similarly to that, if you could be director of any medium
in the whole wide world, which would it be and why?
I don't think I'd be director of a museum, I'd be rather an enabler of museums.
I think I would find it very intriguing to help people create their own museums
for their own purposes, with their own questions and their own very specific
collections, and I'd be intrigued to see what comes out of that.
Okay, so now we've got some questions that are from members of the collective.
So what do you think makes the British Museum relevant to young people?
Well, I think the British Museum is really a place of discovery.
If you want to know about yourself, it's helpful to know about other human beings in other
times and epochs and in other places of the world.
I think we all have our own background, even though through, especially through media,
we are now more linked up.
I think making the experience, the concrete experience of encountering what people over
the millennia, over two million years have created to shape their world
and to shape their communities is absolutely fascinating.
It's very easy to do that at the British Museum.
It's free of charge, you just walk in and it's yours.
That said, you have to decide to walk up the stairs, through the colonnade, into the grade
court and then explore the gallery.
So that's perhaps less evident than, say, walking into something with a less imposing
facade.
So what we try to improve is the ease and the self-evidence of this place being for
young people and making it easy to navigate, making it easy to find answers to your questions,
making it easy to understand that this is a unique place of discovery.
I was just wondering if there was any specific ways that you think the museum has tried to
connect with young people and make the museum less austere and to make that facade less
intimidating?
If you think of the Samsung Digital Learning Centre, for instance, that we have now offered
for quite a number of years, that enables children, young people to engage with the
collection through contemporary digital media.
And you can do that on site, you can do that with family, you can do that on your own.
And through these last 12 months of lockdown, we've used that also to communicate via digital
remotely.
Keep the connection, keep the engagement, keep the fascination, keep the pleasure and
the desire to explore.
So I think we've harnessed these media to better reach out, reach young people.
And I think we've also learned to interact much more, to listen, to understand, you know,
what is on young people's mind?
What is their concerns?
And of course, there are many, depending on where they are, where they come from, what
background, what their experience, what their aspirations are.
So I think it's a very dynamic process of opening up, of improving, of dialoguing and
developing.
Thanks.
And kind of on the subject of modern media, and I'm sure we'll address more in depth like
young people's concerns later on in this video, but talking about modern media and how people
like young people specifically relate to the museum, we're going to show you some TikToks
and memes that young people have made in response to the museum and about their feelings.
So are you aware of TikTok?
Have you come across it?
So just for anyone who's at home, TikTok is a sharing platform for short form videos.
TikToks usually come from meme culture, where you take a piece of media, usually a photo
or a video or a song from popular culture, and then change the context for comedic purposes.
So we would really love to show you, show these to you and get your response.
So this is a video made by a user called Arrow Witch, and it's to a soundbite called How
Bizarre.
Well, this obviously relates to parts of the collection that are that are hotly debated.
And the debate obviously is about the history, if you like, of collecting and of transferring
objects from one region to another.
So you can find this bizarre, obviously, if you think that everything should remain where
it was originally created.
Humans have always not only created objects, used objects, reused them.
And these objects then have triggered new developments, new understanding and understanding
also of how cultures relate to each other.
Thank you.
And on the topic of problematic acquisition and transfer of objects, this particular TikTok
is from Pariah Nation, and it's an educational video which is captioned How many stolen
artefacts are in Europe's museums?
So in this video, Pariah Nation is talking about some statistics and kind of objects
that he feels shouldn't be in the British Museum and other European museums.
These numbers refer to objects from Africa in European collections.
That's what he refers to.
And these objects have come to these collections in many different ways.
They were traded.
They were collected.
Sometimes they were plundered following military raids.
And I think it's very important when we talk about these things that on the one hand, we
are very clear that the British Museum makes great efforts to be very clear and very explicit
about this, how objects have actually come into the collection, the itinerary of objects.
And very often objects do not come directly from a place, say, in Africa to the British
Museum, but via several stations, if you like, or several successive ownerships, private
collectors, for instance.
So you have in these 69,000 objects from Africa in the British Museum's collection, a great
number of different ways of collecting.
And I think it is not doing justice to either side, if you say they're stolen.
And I think it's very important to be clear about that.
You know, the simple fact that objects, say, from Africa or from the Middle East or from
the Americas, are in other places than the places where they were created in itself does
not constitute or does not mean that they were stolen.
So again, I would take this video as a point of departure to discuss the many ways human
beings have been involved in creating, exchanging, transferring, taking objects through the
millennia.
And that in itself is an incredibly interesting, fascinating aspect of our shared complicated
history of human history.
And this is our last one, which is also a meme for a bit of fun.
So this one is addressing the Elgin marbles.
What does it make you think?
I think that, you know, it's poking a bit of fun at the museum.
Yeah.
And to make, you know, a quick contribution to it and trigger new thinking and introduce
new ideas.
And I also think like playfulness and like not taking yourself too seriously is a really
great way to connect with young people.
It just kind of the facade, as you talked about it being kind of austere and inaccessible
sometimes to young people, kind of poking fun and being playful is a great way to kind
of have that connection.
That's an absolutely wonderful thing you've just said.
You know, because obviously throughout the museum, you could hear the laughter of so
many human beings thinking about the objects that they have created and shared and cracked
jokes on and perhaps surprised and fooled each other.
So I think, you know, at once the visit of the uni of Ife, the spiritual head of the
Yoruba, and he came to the museum, which is a fantastic visit, fantastic conversations
we've had with him and the people who accompanied him from Ife.
And he called the museum a house of spirits and said that while he was there, he could
communicate with the spirits from all times and from all regions of the world.
And I like your idea of this, you know, the lightheartedness and poking fun at yourself
and at others.
And I'm sure that while he was talking to me, telling me that he was communicating with
all these spirits, that he must have heard a lot of laughter at the same time.
So those are the ones that we wanted to show you.
And though they're just also a bit of fun, they're really great at showing the perception
of the museum from young people.
And they're really kind of truthful dialogue about some of the kind of concerns that young
people have about the museum and about its collection.
And so kind of from that, I was wondering, how do you think perception and controversy
impact the relationship of the museum with young people?
I think it helps the museum to be very open and to be truthful and clear and to share
what we know about our history, the history of our collection, that, you know, the history
of so many people who put their passion into creating this and the many dialogues they
have had over the centuries with so many people.
So I think that unease is something that helps the museum to answer that question by coming
up with very clear and accessible information and engaging in that dialogue.
And that dialogue is a dialogue that we are having with young people from around the world.
And it's not something which is limited to London or to the UK.
It's a world dialogue about the future of cultural heritage and the way, you know,
we make use of it and we share it and we make it accessible.
And I think that's extremely important that we understand that this is not for the happy
few, but this is really for everybody.
And understanding these concerns and engaging with these concerns, I think, helps the museum
vitally to make it accessible, to make it easy to make use of it.
And I think it's that, you know, that is at least my experience from these conversations,
which will not end.
They are ongoing and they will keep being very much at the forefront.
But I think the trust that these institutions, despite the many questions many young people
have and enjoy, is also down to the fact that they do engage in dialogue.
And they take criticism very seriously and try to find answers through conversation,
through dialogue.
And speaking of trying to find answers, you said in response to the TikToks about how
certain objects in the museum have come to be.
And we were wondering, what would you say to a young person interested in better understanding
how the objects at the museum have been collected?
So when you go to the museum, you find information on panels and labour, so near the objects
or groups of objects.
And there's a lot of information about that.
There is, for instance, right now, a trail through various galleries of the museum where
you see that in relation to certain objects, we talk about the relation between empire
and collecting.
You go to the Benin Bronzes, for instance, and you find a lot of information about what
had happened in 1897, how the objects were taken, how they were transferred from Benin
City to the UK and then dispersed.
You go to the Parthenon sculptures, and there again, you find not only the objects, but
you find a lot of information about what the Parthenon was, how it evolved.
There was a temple, there was a church, then it became a mosque, then it became a monument.
How those sculptures, which are now in the British Museum, were brought first to the
UK and later to the British Museum.
You also learn about how people in Greece feel about it, what the Greek government would
like to see.
So in the room, we give ample space to different views and different voices.
So it's very clear that there are different takes on this, different opinions, different
attitudes, and a lot of passion all around.
And then finally, if you explore the website of the museum and Collection Online, for
instance, where we have four million objects accessible, two million with images, and a
lot of information on provenance.
And then we have the great curators of the museum who speak about our objects on social
media.
And there again, you learn a lot about how these objects came to the museum, how they
entered the museum, how they were interpreted over the centuries.
You understand that the interpretation of objects itself is a creative process that
never stops, and that involves the input of very many people.
With that, can I ask, so one of the aims of the Green Growth Youth Collective programme
that we're part of is to inspire greater change within the museum, to improve the
relationship between young people.
And is there anything that you're doing right now to improve the relationship between young
people and the museum?
The Youth Collective itself is a big step for us to improve these relations.
Working with you, learning from you, understanding what is important for you and what you would
like us to address is obviously key to move things forward.
But then let me give you another example.
We recently had an exhibition on manga, which few people would expect in the British Museum,
I think.
And this was a great exhibition.
It was hugely popular.
And it completely shifted the composition of our audiences.
Almost half of the visitors to this exhibition were younger people.
So there too, you see that as the British Museum addresses contemporary issues and
looks at contemporary media through which young people voice their interests, their
concerns, their passions.
I think that's another way for the museum to engage.
And then we have the friends of the museum, the young friends of the museum that make
specific offers, again, through dialogue, through exchange for younger people.
So I think if you look at what the museum offers, there is a lot, and I should say much
more needs to needs to be done to make the museum a place that is cherished as a place
where you make discoveries that matter for you.
And that is also a place where you like to come to hang out, to meet your friends, sit
around and debate, have a good time.
I think all that is part of the museum.
So in March, we did a call out and received lots of questions from young people outside
of the collective.
So we've got just a selection of the questions that we received to ask you.
And some of these questions have been edited for clarity.
So Sasha, age 21, says that a lot of people my age and younger feel like museums are austere
and far from their interests and values.
Do you plan on creating more exhibitions on themes like sustainability and decolonisation
of our vision of history to reduce that discrepancy of values?
That's a very good question, I think.
Yes, the answer is very clearly yes.
And I would invite Sasha to come and have a look at what we are doing.
You know, we've just finished the huge exhibition on the Arctic that looked at the
relation between culture and climate, showing in close collaboration with many communities
from the circumpolar regions, how the peoples in the north over millennia have managed to
live and survive in a very trying climate, and how they were creative in managing life
under these circumstances, and also in producing objects, beautiful objects, be it clothing,
big tools, be it objects of rituals and culture, or fun and communication and music.
And we had many debates in the programme on questions of climate change, the impact of
human beings, politics, the economy, what needs to be done to meet the Paris aims, Paris goals.
So I think that's a good example of the museum addressing absolutely crucial
and central issues of today that affect everybody.
And we had a lot of young people also participating in this and following it.
The other aspect of empire, colonialism, decolonisation, you will have seen that
the museum over these last five years has done quite a number of exhibitions,
bigger and smaller exhibitions to address exactly that question, to look at
the history of colonialism, to look at the history of collecting,
to look at how people in other areas viewed and view Europe. So I think there is quite a bit
in the programme of the British Museum that really responds to these expectations.
And I would agree, much more needs to be done and we are looking forward to doing much more.
And Samuel wants to know, how does external funding impact the running of the museum?
It's important to understand that the British Museum receives a substantial amount of money
from the government, the so-called grant in aid, that covers roughly 40% of our expenditures.
60% of the money we need to run the museum, to do the programmes, to work across the globe,
to do exhibitions, but also to work with colleagues in other areas of the world to
protect cultural heritage, we need to find this money through different funding streams.
One is commercial, by selling objects in the shops, by having cafes, restaurants,
by letting our space and through other activities. And then through philanthropy. The museum
fortunately has a great number of patrons, of friends, of patrons, of benefactors,
of supporters, of sponsors, that help us realise our programmes. So it's a mixed economy,
but it's very important to understand that the museum is intellectually independent.
This is another one from a member of the public, Maisie. So Maisie asks,
in your current acquisitions for artefacts, are they more contemporary and are they more
UK-based or still international? They are very contemporary. They are not exclusively
contemporary, I have to say. We keep collecting for all departments, but contemporary
objects play an important part. I'll give you two examples. When the pandemic started,
we got together with colleagues from around the world, colleagues who participated in our
international training programme, which brings colleagues, young colleagues from around the
British Museum every summer, to exchange, to discuss, to learn, to share skills,
share experience. So we have a network of roughly 300 colleagues now, and we contacted them and
asked them, can you help us to bring together a collection of objects that show how people in
various parts of the world have reacted to the pandemic? And a way to do that was to look at
masks. You know, the mask is probably the one object which was shared most widely during these
last 12 months. And it's absolutely amazing to see how people in different parts of the world
have shaped, decorated these masks. So it's super contemporary material
that will enable future generations to show, once they exhibit this, how we together
have lived through this experience, and what we share, and what differentiates us. So that's a
very good example, I think, of how the museum connects. As soon as we reopen the museum,
you will see that there is an exhibition which is called Reflections in the galleries of the
Prints and Drawings department. And that is a collection of modern and contemporary works
from the Middle East and North Africa. So again, and it was collected in the Middle East department.
So again, you have a department which has important collections of ancient material,
which is completely engaged with contemporary creation, and tries to bring that into the museum,
working with the artists, with gallerists, with collectors. So yes, contemporary is very important.
And as you can see, global is very important. This is not limited to the UK. It's reaching out
and working with people from around the globe that continues to inform the collection of the
British Museum. Thank you for that. For our final question, what are your hopes for the relationship
of the British Museum and young people in the future? My hope would be that young people
feel that the British Museum is a place they go to, to discover the world, to discover
their own history, and that they use to define their own place in the world, where they find
support for what they want to be, what they aspire to be, and where they come together
to debate, to discuss, and just enjoy. I think, you know, for me, the museum, from very early on,
when I was 13, when I started to go to museums, it's always been a place of fantastic pleasure,
of excitement, of discovery, of learning, of sharing. And, you know, that would be my hope,
that this museum continues to grow its, you know, the share of young people in its audience,
and that young people really use it, make use of it, and just activate it for themselves,
and do it in their own way. You know, there's so many ways to do this. Nobody can really tell
you how to do it. You define it yourself. Thank you, Hartwig, for joining us today,
and thank you to everyone who sent in questions, and thank you for watching. Make sure to check
out other events as part of Unlocking the Museum, and follow the Youth Collective on Instagram
at bmyoungpeople.
