We broke 8 carabiners in a bracketed system. They all broke above MBS or Minimum Breaking Strength that is printed on the spine of the carabiner. It's fun to watch things break! This video focuses on HMS carabiners or the pear shaped ones and most of that type if not all, are locking carabiners. These carabiners have different gates and we show them to you before breaking them. It's a hybrid between a buying guide and teaching what HMS lockers are and just pure edutainment. I think it helps trust carabiners you trust your life to, when you see HOW they break, not just a number printed on the side.
00:00 - Introduction 00:36 - Ronda vs Nautilus 03:58 - Wild country vs gravel 05:42 - Madrock vs Edelrid 07:28 - Climbing technology vs black diamond 08:24 - Nautilus vs Gravel 10:15 - Climbing technology vs MadRock 10:41 - THE FINALE 11:35 - The olympics of Carabiners 13:34 - Outro
Today in our Slack Snap Lab we are going to go with eight walking carabiners into a head-to-head
showdown. Hi I'm Ryan Jinks and welcome to our Slack Snap Lab where we are going to break test
eight carabiners and we're going to start with these two. Let's go over them. I stand next to
you really shows the height difference. So all the carabiners we're testing today are pear-shaped or
HMS carabiners where it's wider on one side than it is on this side allowing you to do things like
a munter or clipping a bunch of stuff in here. However if you clip part of your anchor or put
the load on the gate side it could reduce the strength 50%. The spine is where you get all the
strength. This carabiner has an anti-crossloading feature in it and there are other Ronda locking
carabiners that do not and the lock is what's actually most interesting about this. The latch
is actually less than flush with the outside of this. You can't accidentally open this as opposed
to this Edelrid locking carabiner where this latch is exposed. Now we did a bunch of videos where we
were like opening carabiners all quick like and everyone was like do the Ronda and we didn't have
any. Now this is not going to be as easy to open because the latch is not exposed but come here let
me show you something. The thing about opening carabiners with ropes is there are no rules.
Theory I could put it up against if this was a hanger and open the carabiner but we'll stick
with ropes for a minute. Instead of clipping both strands which is not what we do as climbers we
usually clip in between two so it doesn't fall off the end. What happens is you could in theory
get it to do this and then in order to get it to come out you'd have to be very careful
not likely to happen. This Metolius is the cheapest locker you could get so I've seen a
lot of them out there and I think they're they're good quality. This is one of the smaller HMS you'll
see out there. Very simple design but good carabiner. It is still rated for 24 kilonewtons
and it's going to just be a lighter locking carabiner but this has a screw gate instead of
the well that's not a that's a fancy gate as opposed to most things we've been testing as an
auto locking. The other feature of this in addition to being the cheapest one on the
market for a long time it may still be also has the most screwing required of any screw
lock that I've ever seen. Oh the chokes, oh the chokes.
No! The one we really wanted to feature in this video broke first. It definitely does not function
it just twists. So it rocketed across the room and hit stuff along the way. Do you think that's
from hitting something? Maybe stretching? Yeah the stretching. I haven't seen a carabiner do this
it knocked my can over. Yeah. I found that on I found that on the lost aerospire that's why it's
on my wall. Oh. It's probably John Salatay's himself. Probably. Probably. Nobody else ever
climbed it. Where was it? Yeah lost a notch. So that's where like a powder coat instead of
anodizing. I don't understand how that happened. That's crazy. When a carabiner meets a hydraulic
and they fall in love that's how that happens. Somebody's gonna get hurt. Somebody's gonna get
hurt. Our next one is Wild Country and Gravel. That is a hard carabiner to clip onto a rope.
That's my thought. When you sometimes fall you'll have gate flutter and this gate will flutter and
while it's open if the peak force hits this carabiner is going to be rated for only nine
kilonewtons and could potentially break. That's why there's this extra gate because if it comes
off of this gate it's going to fall out of the other gate. So I don't consider this locking.
I consider it really hard to get in. You hear that? That's flutter. But while it's open this
is still holding the strength because you gotta have these gates closed. Now because there's two
gates the Gravel is actually rated for 30 and I'm banking on this one winning this entire round
because it is rated so high because it has the two gates. Now it also fixes gate flutter
locking your carabiner. This is a Wild Country Ascent Light. Is it light? It is pretty light
and it has good ridges here for the locking so you could do this with gloves I'm sure.
And what's that one rated to? Does it stand a chance against my 30? Uh 26. Nope.
Is it still a double gate if one no longer locks? What I am surprised about is the fact that this
thing rated for 26k in broke above 30. Oh if you lock it then you have 50% of the strength left
because half of it's still connected. You won't believe this but this is a carabiner that opens
with the same goes all the others do and Mad Rock decided to put on this one a twist lock at 26k in.
About the only thing that's the same is this also opens. It has a three stage. So one is up,
two is twist, and three is open. So every carabiner is one stage at least. Sure. Anti-crossloading
and Edelrid I believe calls this the bulletproof and it has a steel insert here
because steel is harder than aluminum. It's also heavier so they only have a little part here and
the part that will wear the most. So if you use your carabiner a lot for top roping that won't
get a groove in it is that correct? It will take longer and I really would like to see this
delaminate from the carabiner when we pull it. All right we're gonna go head to head with these.
The MBS of my fingers is less than oh my god okay. I was really hoping to see this result
uh it no I mean actually that's cool it's just like um a filling.
Oh my gosh there is no nose left on that. Oh no there's none of them open anymore.
Oh got it. It's not the same shape I think that's the problem. There we go. It's like a
two-stage locking carabiner. Climbing technology and black diamond. This this is uh pre-Bobby
joining the channel. Ryan started making climbing content and we broke a lot of black diamonds.
One of your first climbing content videos. Is that what made you watch the channel?
Uh no. What was it? I still don't want the channel.
So I have black diamond here. I have a climbing technology made in Italy. And you have the
anti-crossload feature. Me too. It's called these two fingers. Both screw gates. Screw gates. And
both the same notches and they're both the same size approximately. Yep. Yep. And they're both
I got 23. I got 23.
It's super stuck. It's changed its shape just enough. The banana's pulled through. Yeah because
the crack spread it out. So next is Metolius who's been up to 25 and Gravel who's been up to 30.
It's the only way those open now. I need to thank John Ferroni from ExtremeGear.org who chased all
these carabiners down for us. Kind of a pain to get. Well he got a total of 30 carabiners for us.
All different brands and types. And you can actually get almost all of these on ExtremeGear.org
and when you buy climbing gear from there, 10% supports his channel and the rest supports the
Cave Exploration Society which does cave exploration around the world. So your money
goes to some great places. You can get all sorts of great carabiners and you know what you're buying,
what you're getting. Go check out our video on counterfeit products that we just recently made.
I personally do not think the Gravel is going to perform that well because one of the gates that
provides that 30 kilonewton rating is not engaged and this one's locked shut. I actually don't know
what's going to happen. So what I saw happen was the Metolius shot over here and hit this boom boom
and landed here. That thing looks stressed. Oh wow that nose. No that's not the nose.
That's the rear. The pin blew out. Yeah. Where'd the... you see like that's the nose.
The nose is still locked. We still have a locking carabiner. Um it's still compromised the same way.
It's no different. Yeah. Wow that thing got... but you know what? I'm impressed. This actually
got 31.52 and yeah it's only rated for 24. So this this rocked it. So what's next is
Climbing Technologies at 24.76. Madrock's been taken up to 28 already. So Madrock has a chance
to be the winner here. So neither one of these open at this point. Oh you got it? Yeah.
Well there's the nose just wobbling in there like a bobblehead.
Why doesn't it open anymore? Slow-mo of it shifting.
Wow it still functions. You know I thought that wasn't fair because this is such a strong
carabiner with the two gates but then technically we haven't had this gate in the game for a while.
Do you have thoughts Bobby? Uh I would still use this carabiner before I do that one.
Oh Bobby that's not how to get sponsored. You're never gonna get sponsored.
Oh look a nose. Um yeah we took it above its MBS a couple times. Yeah yeah yeah. Before it broke.
This is where you click off the video thinking I'm gonna talk for five more minutes and there's
not gonna be anything else to share. But wait there's more. Time for the Olympics.
So in this video you can see what happened and who won but in our last video we had this one
and now we can do the Olympics of carabiners. And they both broke at 31.57 and 31.61 so we're
gonna find out which one is going to win. And what's funny is this one also sort of works.
Let's find out who wins. I'm going for Austria Alpine at 35. All right let's go for the Gravel
at uh 33. Okay what are you guessing? Uh I'll go Gravel at 31. Uh Austria Alpine 32. Austria Alpine
35. Oh that was the same thing I said. All right yeah so you guys got to pick. Yeah yeah yeah you
got a full circle. Yeah full circle. Austria Alpine 35. No no you can't have the same like
pick like 35 point something. Rock paper scissors for that. Yeah yeah. No no no we're not gonna
We're on the same team. Oh my god. Okay okay okay. I think the Gravel is going to win and
then we're gonna pull it to its final death at 40. Should we break it? The mop needs to know.
Well there's a lot of parts to this. That makes sense because they gave you extra parts to begin
with for redundancy. Oh that's a pretty good number. We've done a couple carabiner showdown
videos now at this point and I want to know if you guys like this flavor or if we just should put
them all in line. I think this is a clever way to share all the different brands, types, styles,
and it's kind of like a fancy gear review. A little entertaining and it is kind of fun to
see which ones break higher. Now if we repeated this whole test again we might get different
results because there's variables. I appreciate you guys supporting this channel by buying gear
from extremegear.org and make sure you subscribe so you might be able to see future videos. Cheers.