Gwen Stefani just said she's Japanese now a lot of people are coming out against her calling it
classic cultural appropriation a lot of people are coming out to defend her saying that she
should be able to identify however she wants and this just turned into a hot political debate.
I would have never guessed that Gwen Stefani in 2023 would be able to get 7 million internet
comments some supporting her some going against her some in the middle let's break it down we've
got five major takeaways representing the five major viewpoints of course we're going to give
number one let's just get into the right wing response because the right wing they had a field
day with this one they said hey classic overwokeness a white person in America can't even
show appreciation anymore without being called racist she liked the Harajuku culture and then
people trying to call her racist for it this whole country's stupid. I mean if a man can identify as
a woman why can't a white woman identify as Japanese she's an artist anyways clearly she
appreciates the culture. Yeah I mean I do think there is something to be said for people being
overly sensitive but I do think obviously they're not taking into consideration any sort of history
from Gwen Stefani any sort of other comments that she would have made and obviously she's probably
also a Republican now now that she's married to Blake Sheldon so they're more defending their
own tribe. You know what I would like this conversation to go is what are we fluid about
when it comes to identity are we fluid about gender that's fine cool are we also fluid about
culture and ethnicity not as cool right now so I guess I want to have more conversations about that.
Yeah because I would say the gender and ethnicity are different. Yeah they're different I get it
they're totally different that's why we need to have these conversations because are you applying
that logic to this or not but we need to have we need to specify. I'm not going to give the right
wing zero out of ten points on this but definitely I don't fully agree I think they have unbalanced
perspective of course number two Andrew speaking of unbalanced perspectives probably also the left
right the left said basically you white people are the dominant baseline culture ever since
Anglos conquered the world 200 to 400 years ago and they just feel like they can go around saying
that they're Asian that they're Chicana that they're Indian which is all things that Gwen Stefani's
been accused of even though she's Italian American not Anglo but like basically white women can just
take all the parts they want fetishize it and then throw away all the realities because where was
Gwen Stefani when all the Asian women were getting attacked over the past couple years
she said nothing clearly if she identifies is so Asian she actually only likes two streets
in Harajuku. This is fair this is fair listen if someone's going to say they're Japanese do
they have to feel the pains of being an Asian person right whatever pains there might be I'll
tell you this if she said if Gwen Stefani said I'm black that would have been taken a lot differently
I don't know if Candace Owens would be defending her in the same way you know what I mean so I do
think that although being black and being Japanese are viewed completely differently
in American society it's it's obviously like where do we draw the line and by the way I think that
the left also made some valid points however not fully also it was also an unbalanced perspective
to be fair typically when you're this end of the spectrum and you're that end of the spectrum
you just go on for all the points that support your tribe and your side and not the whole thing
moving on to number three Andrew we got to talk about the pop cultural mavens this actually
represents a larger section of the internet than you would think these are people who aren't
hyper political I'd say they probably lean more left but they're really more about just pop culture
details and the art behind it right and they were basically going into Gwen Stefani's past like she
did the Chicana thing she did the Indian thing where she was rocking a bindi she likes to play
with culture because she points to her upbringing in Orange County being like oh I grew up with so
many cultures around me and some people were like I don't know we have to look at this within the
context of Gwen Stefani's career of kind of being a culture vulture okay you know what I'll say this
and I'm not gonna go ahead and call her a culture vulture because I did she did quote and say that
she was appreciating all those different cultures that she grew up with she had a band member who
was Indian so she wanted to wear the bindi whether that's the right way to show it she's an artist
right um but I would say Gwen if you say you're Japanese do you speak any Japanese have you ever
dated a Japanese person what if she was kind of pulling the Ariana Grande where they kind of meant
I want to be Japanese but only if I'm pretty much the top Japanese person in the world if I'm the
last samurai then that's how I'm getting also if she means that she more cares about Harajuku
style just say Harajuku instead of Japanese because Harajuku is its own style it's its
own glam rock like less than one percent of Japanese people fit into the Harajuku archetype
anyways what's the next perspective David it comes from otakus like these are people who are
actually into Japanese culture especially pop culture yeah they basically said in Japan that
people would not really care that Gwen had the Harajuku girls because they don't even really like
listen to Gwen's music that much maybe the international school kids did and if anything
at that time in 04 they probably were appreciative they probably were like
hmm the way she's doing it is a little weird but in Japan we like weird and some people were saying
pointing out though that the Harajuku girls that sometimes had to bow to Gwen like Gwen was the
emperor or like some sort of like ceo so some people were like you know it just kind of fits
into the senpai kohai dynamic and I guess if we isolate it she was the queen pop star in 04
and they were underneath her like tutelage so I guess they could see why she was the senpai
all right guys I do think that it leads to our next perspective which is more the moderate
perspective which is someone who's like I get the outrage but I can't feel the same because
basically it's saying hey listen I wish that Gwen Stefani would just come out and say she's an artist
she loves cultures she's eccentric of a person and she's kind of a weirdo so she's gonna play
around with culture all those Harajuku girls they were in character they got paid they lived a fun
life so what's really wrong with it it was probably her word choice yeah I think that the moderate
answer once you take all arguments into like their totality is basically like in 04 Gwen was definitely
a good pop artist or a great pop artist because she pushed boundaries sort of like Madonna right
she was trying to be the new school Madonna right so she was pushing the boundary in 04
the goalposts in society change whether you like that or not especially right-wing pundits I'm sure
left-wing pundits like it more because the goalposts have shifted in their favor the goalposts
have changed you cannot do what Gwen did in 04 with Chicano Indian and Harajuku culture in 2023
now how you feel about that is up to you but to pretend like it's the old days like 1990 standards
it's wrong like basically what she did back then was acceptable it's kind of weird to cancel people
post retroactively right right right it is but obviously if somebody debuted nowadays a pop
artist using all those influences it would be way more called into question well even the past 10
years we've had a lot of conversations about Katy Perry Kim Kardashian with the kimono uh all this
I mean this is a thing that comes up again and again but Gwen because she has this long history
of being into Japanese culture and appreciating it in her own way she's doubling down on it in 2023
which people just thought was a little bit and they don't like it because she's married to Blake
Sheldon nowadays so it's actually a micro mid macro situation my overall takeaway is this
I liked it when she did the Harajuku girls in 04 we thought it was kind of interesting
yes I thought it was cool because at that time I was always into Japanese sneaker culture I was in
Harajuku Shinjuku stuff I was following Nigo and all this stuff way back in the day but a lot of
people really weren't right so I was like man she's like bringing it to the forefront now when
she brings it to the forefront it is can be a hit or miss I think she had elements that were dope
but them bowing to her I could see why that was definitely cringy like I can overall like the
movement for 04 standards but acknowledge that there was swings and there was misses and there
were swings and there was hits yeah I mean I'll say this listen she is an artist she pushes
boundaries and I think in art you do have a little bit more flexibility however she definitely did
not update her firmware for 2023 by doubling down and saying she's in the job she could have been
more nuanced and just said hey I'm really into Harajuku because I don't know about her matcha
brand does she have like a traditional matcha brand is she out there doing the teeth like
the Shinto yeah was she into Shinto Buddhism would it like she's not really like Japanese
she's not Japanese that's just a fact right so she's she's into the sides and small aspects of
Japan that are very popular globally that she likes listen that's like me saying I grew up
listening to rap I dated a black girl so hey I'm black or something like it's literally people
would be like nah that's not exactly how it works but you know I guess what I'm saying is just like
basically she could update her firmware for this interview and it might have saved her some trouble
if you want me to really get into my last final macro takeaway Andrew how much is sort of like
this Anglo view on the eastern world gonna be the default American view because that's what
Megyn Kelly and all the right-wing pundits are trying to maintain they're like listen guys as
long as the Anglos are like whoever's Anglo adjacent we just show like love who cares if
like the love was a little misplaced or was a little bit misaligned or it wasn't fully 100 out
of 100 on the mark at least we said something positive about you we used to want to kill you
guys you know what I mean obviously referencing World War II and stuff I'm being dead serious
that's how they think they're like compared to where we came from even a misplaced or cringy
love for you guys it's still just just take it just accept it right and obviously us being like
actual minorities or people like you know for example the writer of the article I know I didn't
want to make it sound like I was overly criticizing the allure Filipino writer like I don't fully
support her or go against her at all I think she just made a solid point that I don't fully agree
with but it's like I guess isn't it fair that other minorities we don't accept that same fondue
point listen it's fair to question Gwen Stefani even in 2023 you can ask her those questions and
be like hey what do you think about these accusations I thought it was weird what do
you think and if she doubles down then she has to live with how people are going to perceive it
because she's not keeping her ears to the ground she doesn't really understand how people would
react to that and even if in her heart she feels Japanese she should also know I guess how that
might be taken but it is also true that Japanese is not a group despite the whole bombing of Japan
and then also the internment of Japan and then the whole war against Japan they're not really
considered like a oppressed group in America that's not how we see it people do not take
that's not how we Japanese seriously or I would say Asians in general but the particular the
cartoony anime Hatsune Miku aspects of Vocaloid aspects of Japan very seriously because I will
end on this Ariana Grande used to love speaking Japanese to her crowd but then she got a tattoo
that was wrong like the hirakana was wrong on it and she wrote like hibachi grill on her arm
everybody made fun of her and immediately after that she stopped learning Japanese forever
so clearly I'm not saying that she was fully wrong for ever learning in the first place but clearly
the respect for the culture seemed to be on thin ice I do think that if you want to use a culture
and you think it's interesting I think that's fine but you still have to do your research like
if you are going to get more popular by using elements of a culture I think that's totally
cool in America like it's generally fine because I think that if you have a true appreciation why
not America's a mixed society of course but do your research that's all I'm saying and yeah I
mean have some more conversations about it all right you guys let us know what you think in the
comment section below I see a lot of you know discussions arguing about the micro but at the
end of the day hopefully we brought it to a macro level let us know what you think in the comment
section below until next time we're the hot pop boys we out peace