This Chinese makeup is sparking an online debate
because of her latest tribute to the great Kobe Bryant.
Yeah, we got to talk about it.
This is going viral in some circles right now.
Long story short, Izzy Balbo
is a famous social media makeup artist in China.
She does a lot of imitations of a lot of celebrities.
She did one for the late, great Kobe Bryant,
passed away tragically three years ago.
And this sparked a huge online debate,
and there was such a spectrum of opinions.
On one side, people were like, what are you doing?
This is blackface.
Some people were a little bit against it.
Some people were a little bit supportive,
and other people were just like, dude,
why is everybody so serious, sensitive in 2023?
Like, she was trying to show love to Kobe.
Yeah, and it also brought the conversation
even to like an international level
about how people internationally,
in different countries and different cultures,
they don't necessarily understand the same dynamics
that are going on in America.
And should they be subject to those American dynamics?
I don't know, but whether you agree
or disagree with her doing this, I will tell you this.
It is clear that Chinese people love the NBA,
and they love Kobe Bryant
because her caption translated into English
was literally, Kobe is forever, love him.
And she did issue a statement being like,
yeah, I am not trying to imitate.
I'm just showing my love and respect for Kobe.
She is a makeup artist. That is how she does it.
And again, she has imitated other people.
But regardless, this is a different topic,
so we're going to talk about this.
We're going to go through the comments section.
Please hit the like button.
Check out other episodes of the Hot Pop Boys.
Literally, I read maybe 1,000, 2,000 comments for this, Andrew.
There is no way that people think
that this is one of the most serious issues
going on in the world right now.
However, you know what I noticed, Andrew?
Like we always say, people like discussing silly things
more than they like discussing,
like, I guess, right off the rip, serious things.
They'd rather make serious things out of silly things.
Yeah, yeah, yeah, you want to draw serious conversations
from silly things, people like to do that.
I think that's human nature.
Somebody said this was a beautiful tribute
and art that was his intention.
That's how I'm personally taking it.
I saw this comment from a lot of different races of people.
No, and I will admit it and say, wow,
she did kind of look like Kobe Bryant in a weird way,
and it was kind of weird to see it all happen.
Yeah, yeah. There's some strangeness to it.
There is. There is some strangeness to it
because I guess you didn't think a Chinese woman
could even look like Kobe in any type of way.
Now, I don't know if the end photo
was kind of Photoshopped or anything,
but regardless, it is impressive,
and I will tell you this, when it comes to the makeup artist game,
she clearly got the mama mentality.
Yeah, somebody said there are a lot of rules
around cultural appropriation,
and they shift culture to culture.
It's very difficult to know what is acceptable
or what is not acceptable because even people within a group
have a variance of opinion.
Exactly. Like, judging from the comments,
obviously a lot of black people spoke out.
Not even all of them, and I wouldn't even say
most black people were offended by this.
You know, a lot of people were defending her
or just saying, like, yeah, it's not that big of a deal.
Maybe it's a little bit strange. I would say, yeah.
I mean, but I do think that it's not wrong for people
to be offended if they are a little offended.
That's how they feel, for sure, because I can understand.
There was another comment that addressed this, Andrew.
It said, whether people view it as hypersensitive or not,
don't you think that after all the racist laws
and the histories that African Americans have been through,
they deserve to be on the defensive mode?
I think that people can leave whatever comment they want.
Other people can leave whatever comment they want.
However, I think as far as, like,
canceling this makeup artist or, like, taking her down,
obviously I think that's too extreme.
She probably doesn't deserve that
because it wasn't out of that intention.
It was literally out of her love for Kobe.
But I will say it can come off as strange,
especially when you're getting content
that is imported from Asia,
a place with completely different dynamics,
and you're seeing it on an American platform out of context.
Yeah, sometimes there's misunderstandings.
I do think it's a worthwhile conversation,
and I'm never going to tell anybody to be offended,
to not be offended. I'm never going to tell somebody,
like, oh, you can only be offended to a four out of 10 level
and not a seven out of 10 level.
Everybody got their own life experiences
and their own lens on life.
Somebody said, this is a white guy saying,
there is no white or black culture.
It's all homogenized in 2023.
If you can't zoom out and see that,
then you're just not seeing big enough picture.
I think it's so tough because I think on certain levels,
it's clear that culture is all borrowed
and appropriated in a healthy way
and re-imitated and all this thing all across the world.
Other cultures, Asian cultures in America,
obviously a lot of American culture,
even black American culture
specifically exported to the rest of the world.
What is Taco Bell? What is Panda Express?
These are like representations of foreign cultures
to American soil, but they've almost become American culture.
But then also on the internet,
as much as culture is being shared
in an authentic and positive way,
there is still racism. There's still absolutely racism.
Dude, it's so complicated, man.
I get what he's saying in the sense of like,
if you're talking about Western culture,
somebody coming in, Andrew, as a Buddhist,
is still way different to the West
than people who are different types of Protestant.
You know what I'm saying?
If somebody's Baptist or somebody's Episcopalian,
a Buddhist is looking at it,
it's all just Protestant to them.
So it does depend on what lens you're viewing similarity
and difference, what largeness of context, right?
Exactly.
Somebody said, but did you guys know
that Kobe was named after Kobe beef,
which comes from the city of Kobe, Japan?
Yeah, I mean, I think he was.
Is that the real story though?
Yeah, that's the real story.
Yeah, he is named after Kobe, Japan.
So I don't know.
Well, he has a Japanese name, actually.
Somebody said the Wayne's Bros
did a complete movie in whiteface.
Was that okay?
I don't know.
I mean, yeah, of course,
you can have a long conversation about comedy
and the lines of comedy, or if there are no lines.
And is it very different when you're punching up
or punching down in the power structure?
Absolutely, I think those are valid.
But again, if you're from Asia,
are you punching up or down or just sideways?
Or I don't know.
Like, it's so hard to tell, right?
Yeah, I mean, the easiest way to say it
is you are just an alien.
And aliens, I don't know,
are aliens subject to the dynamics of the West
or are they just on their own alien planet?
So I wanna be clear.
I think most comments were either neutral
or positive for the makeup artist
and more understanding of her intentions.
There were some people who were firmly against it.
They weren't all black people.
They weren't all white people.
It was a mixture of people.
But what did they say?
I mean, they were basically saying this is blackface.
Given how culturally sensitive the historical context is,
you should have the common sense to not even get this close.
Somebody was saying, if you are gonna show enough love
to an American icon like Kobe,
you have to do more research on American racial dynamics.
That is an interesting comment.
Okay, now, I think that it's tough
because how do you also tell someone how to show homage?
Obviously, she's not doing it in a disrespectful way.
She did an amazing job with the makeup.
Like, she didn't make herself look all goofy
and almost like a Picasso photo.
Like, she literally tried to do as accurate of a job
as possible.
It's almost like a one-to-one or she tried her best, yeah.
Yeah, almost as good as I've ever seen ever, right?
But that is fair that if you love American icons,
do you have some responsibility
to try to understand some American dynamics?
Right, but then people were saying,
who is even agreeing on the American dynamics?
Because there's so much disagreement
about where the line is or where the threshold of,
some people say the threshold is here,
some people say the threshold is there.
But that's why it's a debate, people.
Somebody said, what if a black person
changed themselves to look like Asian
and had slanted eyes, would that be okay?
And somebody said, I don't know,
if you could make yourself look like Bruce Lee,
I think that that would be pretty impressive.
All right, so I do think there's a level of accuracy
that if anybody could make themselves
look legitimately like Bruce Lee or like Lucy Liu,
like an Asian icon, and make it look that accurate,
I guess I'm curious to see it.
Yeah, I would think it was tight for me personally,
but I could see, like, listen,
I'm not saying the historical context of being Asian
is the same because there's not the black face
in the 20s and 30s with the Broadway and the Hollywood.
It's not gonna be doing the eyes.
This is not how you're gonna make yourself
look like Lucy Liu.
Other people said they were moderately against this.
This guy said, listen, I know that this girl,
this guy was black.
He was saying, I get it, she's from China.
She doesn't know.
She did do a great job, but it is blackface,
and I would use it as an opportunity to educate her.
So this is the campander, like we said,
like there was a whole distribution on the spectrum
where they're like, they're not trying to crucify her,
but they're against this existing war.
Yes, yes, yes.
I don't think everybody should try to do it,
but I do think that if you wanna leave a comment,
and obviously she is now informed of the situation,
I think that's totally fine.
Now, does she go on and do Denzel Washington
and do all these other black icons?
Probably not.
She's probably not gonna do Martin Luther King.
Don't worry.
But I think that it's totally fair
in informing her about the dynamics.
Yeah, this person was a Asian person.
I guess they was moderately against this.
They said, listen, I'm just going to listen to black people.
If even a portion of black Americans are offended,
then I'm offended with them.
So this is interesting.
I mean, like, hey guys, like I said,
some people triangulate their opinions
with the opinions of other people
that they feel like are closer to the blast zone
of that issue.
It's not wrong.
Somebody said, this is a section of black Americans, Andrew,
that were unbothered.
They thought it was cool, or they thought it was neutral.
This guy said, I'm black, and I'll allow this one.
Chinese people worship Kobe Bryant,
and just all around Asia, they love Kobe.
If white people did this, I would feel different about it,
and maybe it would be in a more mocking, insulting way
if they did do it.
Oh, does it matter, David, that Asians, especially in Asia,
and let's just put the spotlight on China,
the China market has bought so many Jordans and Kobe shoes,
and they love Kobe.
Well, they actually make up like 40%
of the NBA's profits, right?
Yeah, does it matter that, honestly,
they have supported Kobe his entire career, essentially,
his entire famous career, and that they love him so much
so it's almost like when other people see that,
they're like, man, I just know those people.
They probably don't mean it like that,
but they probably just look at it through one lens,
but they really are famous.
I think it means a lot if you really understand,
like on a real level, for sure it means a lot,
because the reason why a lot of people
don't really dress up as Asians, in my opinion,
is because they don't really care about Asians
that much on a pop cultural level.
You have to care enough about somebody
on a pop cultural level to worship them.
Now, I'm not saying, by the way,
that sometimes worshiping somebody or idolizing somebody,
it doesn't come out weird,
but you still have to worship them initially
to even, as a basis, right?
That's true.
We're not getting a lot of makeup artists
doing yellow face for us.
Yeah, because people don't worship Asians
in a pop cultural sense at all.
Yeah, literally people do not want to be Asian,
so they, yeah.
Somebody said, I do think it counts as blackface,
honestly, but she's just showcasing her talent.
This turned into a whole discussion
about what is blackface.
Some people are going off the 1920s, 30s definition.
Some people are saying, no, anybody
who is of lighter skin tone,
who paints their skin with a darker skin tone
is doing blackface, so there's semantic arguments
over the dictionary word.
Yeah, but I guess there's also brownface, right?
Because if you're depicting anybody
who has a darker skin tone than you,
let's say if we, I'm not saying we whatever,
dress up as a South Indian who has darker skin,
or even a Filipino, you know what I mean?
I guess that there's such an American dynamic
and history to the word blackface
that sometimes it is so hard to apply it
to the entire world.
It's hard.
Some people said, I thought it was dope.
I know she replicates a lot of different ethnicities
around the world, so that's what makes it more okay to me.
Somebody said, would it be offensive for sure
if she was white and she did an amazing job?
I do think it's possible that it is offensive, right?
Because white people have a history of doing it.
I mean, because the whole concept of blackface
was white people doing it in the 1910s and 20s.
Yeah, but also I think if she's a white American,
she's already aware of these dynamics.
What I could see is maybe a white person
from like Sweden, or Belgium,
or it's just somewhere far off in Europe.
Maybe Russia or something?
Yeah, that's doing their depiction of Kobe Bryant
and what if it's very good,
but it's like technically blackface?
I don't know.
This is why there's an online debate.
Yeah, like I said, guys,
these are comments that I pulled off the internet.
A lot of Blasians, Andrew,
that were actually half Asian, half black,
I'm assuming mostly with a black father and an Asian mother,
they supported it.
Oh, yeah.
I guess, David, overall,
what are your overall takeaways from all this?
What can we learn from this debate that's online?
First of all, again,
I don't think people are trying to tear down her account.
I don't think people are accusing her of being racist,
but they are saying that this falls
under the umbrella term of blackface, which is offensive.
Yeah, I mean, guys, just to sum it up
in terms of my analysis,
I probably read about 1,500 to 2,000 comments.
I would say maybe 10% were like outwardly against Balbo,
and then you had a whole spectrum in between,
and maybe I would say like 25% were fervently in favor,
and almost everybody else,
like 60% was in the middle somewhere.
I feel like my takeaway is that I saw a lot of people
leaving the comment,
and this was a comment left by all different types of people,
not just Asians, but people saying,
hey, guys, the world is bigger than America.
These American dynamics and history
does not have to apply to everybody in the world possible.
Right, right, and I agree,
and like I said, for me, it's like tough to say, right?
Because you're saying, all right,
if you're paying homage to American icons,
do you have to be subject to all these nuances
and things like that that not even all Americans
are aware of, to be honest.
So it's like, I don't know.
I mean, I don't think that she was doing her makeup
for the American market.
She was doing her makeup for the Chinese and Asian market.
Right.
So I don't think that she was coming onto American TV
trying to do this.
She was just doing it on the Chinese platform, so.
I guess my takeaway is I totally understand
if people are offended or they find it strange.
I wouldn't encourage makeup artists anywhere in the globe
to do more of this, to be honest,
but in the terms of her case, I mean,
I thought she did, obviously on a purely talent level,
she did an amazing job,
and that's her way of showing respect.
However, if a sizable enough portion
of people feel greatly offended by it,
then I think that people should take that into consideration
although, let's be honest,
even within the black American experience,
they have a variance of opinion all along the spectrum.
Right.
All right, everybody.
You know what?
We're gonna leave it right there.
You guys let us know what you think
in the comments down below.
Keep it civil.
Keep the arguing to a minimum.
Like we said, guys, I think the majority of people,
even when I read this post being posted on The Shade Room
and other more, I guess,
predominantly African-American audience-based Instagrams,
it was like overwhelmingly at least neutral.
Yeah, yeah, I would say so for sure.
I mean, I will just say it is definitely odd
almost how well she is able to pull
some of these makeup transformations.
Hey, Balbo, honestly,
she might be one of the best in the entire world.
Like if I just pop up some of the other ones she did,
like her Neymar one is good.
It honestly looked like she had an AI filter
for a lot of these celebrities.
I'm not just saying the Kobe one, all of them.
But anyways, guys, you let me know
in the comments down below.
Keep it civil.
Hit that like button.
Check out other episodes of the Hop Out, boys.
Thank you so much.
Until next time, we out.
Peace!