Hidden Giants - Supermassive Black Holes in Galaxies

Hubble Space Telescope
12 followers
Sep 5, 2023
Due to technical issues, our live broadcast was split into two separate videos. We have combined them into one to better help our viewers watch after the fact.
Part 1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mtv9L...
Part 2. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ayaaf...
Supermassive black holes are enormous black holes with sizes hundreds of thousands to billions of solar masses. They reside in the centers of galaxies - some are more active than others, and many are gigantic masses more hidden.
"Gravitational Waves"
February 12 at 3:00 pm EST (20:00 UTC/GMT)
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YYBLlxMrzN8
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/events/1695651323984064/
G+: https://plus.google.com/b/116092146128069853604/events/c9dgah8g254a2si8mbhgtuhiuv4
Hello everybody and welcome to this week's Hubble Hangout.
My name is Tony Darnell and we have a really great hangout planned for you today, especially
if you are fans of gravity, because it is gravity week here at Astronomy Land, I guess
not just Hubble Hangout but everywhere.
If you have been, unless you've been living under an astronomical rock, which I'm sure
you haven't been, you've heard the news today about the long-awaited observation of the
prediction from Albert Einstein's General Theory of Relativity, that of gravitational
waves.
Astronomers and scientists using the LIGO observatories in Hanford, Washington and Livingston,
Louisiana have observed gravitational waves and they have been predicted for a hundred
years and now have finally been observed.
And today we're going to talk very briefly about that, but we are here today to talk
about another prediction that Albert Einstein's General Theory of Relativity gave us, which
was one of his most extreme predictions, that of black holes.
Now as you may have learned today, gravitational waves are these small ripples in space-time,
but black holes are Albert Einstein's extreme prediction.
That is where it bends light so much, or bends space-time so much, that not even light can
escape.
And we're going to talk about these objects today, not just black holes, but supermassive
black holes in the centers of galaxies.
Yeah, our black holes are bigger than theirs.
That's right.
And so we're going to be discussing that and a great many other things, as well as what
the supermassive black holes, what roles they play within galaxies and things like that.
But before I get going, I have to introduce my co-host, my guest, my co-host.
You must.
You're contractually obligated.
Well, I try not to, but if I don't, then Scott gets really mad.
But anyway.
I cry a lot.
He does.
It's really kind of scary.
But anyway, with me this week, as she is with all of them, is Dr. Carol Christian.
She's the Hubble Space Telescope Outreach Scientist.
Hi Carol.
Hi Tony.
How are you?
I'm doing great.
It's good to see you again.
Also with me is Scott Lewis.
He is the guy who handles all of our social media and drives the internet and all kinds
of other issues.
Hi Scott.
Welcome back.
It's warm.
It's really, really hot in L.A. for February.
Excuse me.
I don't care about that.
It's 29 Celsius out.
You don't care about...
Oh, nice.
It's 29 degrees Fahrenheit.
Yeah.
As he does his weekly rubbing it in of the great weather that he's having.
I'm from Michigan.
This is lovely.
All right.
Well, we want...
Before we get...
Before I introduce today's guests and we start talking about today's topic, I want to make
sure that we have a little bit of time for questions.
We're going to have a little bit of time for questions.
All right.
Well, we want...
Before we get...
Before I introduce today's guests and we start talking about today's topic, I would like
you guys to...
I'd like you guys to leave us questions and comments throughout the Hangout, and we hope
you'll do that in a variety of ways, which Scott will outline for you now.
Scott, please tell our kind viewers how they may interact with us.
I will outline that for you now.
So since we are streaming live on YouTube and I'm seeing bunches of you already going
at it, we have the live chat going on.
I'm going to go ahead and start it.
There are so many different comments going on.
So what we'll be doing is, as we're going on, if you have any questions or comments
regarding Supermassive Black Holes or anything for our panel here, please let us know in
the chat, and we will try to answer them live while we're going on.
Also, we're going to be over on Twitter as well, live tweeting the event and pictures
going on with it using the hashtag Hubble Hangout, and I'll be tweeting from our Hubble
Space Telescope account, so it's at Hubble Telescope.
So if you haven't followed us on Twitter, go ahead and do that, and you're watching
us here on YouTube.
If you haven't subscribed, make sure to do that as well.
Yeah, what's up with that?
If you haven't subscribed.
Yeah.
Subscribe.
Yeah.
I see this all the time.
Also, real quick, just tell them how they can find out about future Hangouts as well.
You're putting these out on Facebook, aren't you?
Yeah.
So we have Facebook events up.
So if you go to Facebook or if you have a Facebook account, you search for Hubble Space Telescope.
We are the verified one, so the one with the blue check mark.
And on there, you can click on events and allow you to subscribe to events.
So every Monday or Tuesday, I create the events over on Facebook with the YouTube URL and
have it all ready.
So we already have a bunch of people, a little over 125 people that are interested or going
just on Facebook alone that link back to this.
So you can actually subscribe to these.
So whenever I create events for the live shows, you can be notified via Facebook as
well.
Or if you're not on Facebook, you can do that through YouTube.
Whenever we do that, you'll be notified whenever we're live on YouTube.
Yes.
So that's a good way to keep track of when the next ones are coming up and what they
will be about.
Okay.
So let's get to the Hangout today.
Let's just jump right in.
First, let me introduce our guests.
With me today is Assistant Professor Kai-Han Gueltecken.
He's from the University of Michigan.
Welcome, Kai-Han.
Thank you for having me.
Good.
I like your models in the background.
I'm going to have you explain them to me in just a minute.
Also joining me is Dr. Todd Lauer from the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical Observatory,
right?
We are the National Optical Astronomy Observatory, and we're run out of Tucson, Arizona.
That's right.
See, I got it right.
When I know an acronym, I just got to blurt it out.
I just can't help myself.
Okay.
Well, as I mentioned at the top of the show, we're going to be talking a little bit about
the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
We're going to be talking a little bit about the NOAO National Optical and Astronomical
Observatory.
Turns out there will be a hangout tomorrow by Harley Thompson of NASA on gravitational
waves.
So they will really delve into the subject quite deeply and after the hangout, Scott
can put a link to that on the website.
So it's something to look forward to.
More about gravity and black holes, but as I said before, the supermassive black holes
are much bigger than 30 solar masses.
Exactly.
So we're going to be talking about really, really black holes, really big black holes.
Supermassive black holes.
Blacker than black holes.
Supermassive-er than massive-er.
Blacker than black.
Oh, Scott.
Okay.
So let's go.
So there was one, I want to make one segue, one way I thought about making the segue from
that announcement to what we're going to be talking about today was I heard in the social
media sphere today, as this announcement was going on about gravitational waves, that
this is actually proof, this observation of gravitational waves, is now proof that black
holes exist.
And Kai-Han and Todd, I'd like you guys to comment on this.
That surprised me.
I thought we had a pretty good idea before this that black holes existed, right?
I mean, we had maybe not direct observations because you know there's no light that comes
up.
There's no direct observations, right, that sort of, I don't know, wasn't that proof enough
what we had before, Kai-Han?
Sure.
As you said, what we had before was indirect proof, but it was still indirect.
What we learned about the gravitational waves is actually that there was a presence of an
event horizon around these objects.
Up until now, all our evidence of what we think are black holes, and we're pretty certain
that the other things we've been calling black holes are small, compact, dark masses.
And in order to explain them as anything other than a black hole requires invoking sort of
non-mainstream or really implausible physical ideas so that black holes were the most likely
explanation of all these.
But they did not contain any direct evidence of an event horizon or a singularity, which
are the definitions of a black hole.
So that's what these gravitational wave observations actually prove or are consistent with.
Okay, well, that's a good segue into this then, because what we're going to be talking
about today, as I mentioned before, are not just black holes or stellar size, and by stellar
size we mean something on order of tens or so times the mass of our Sun, but there are
black holes believed to be at the center of all galaxies, right?
And these things are on order of thousands to hundreds of thousands to even billions
of times the mass of our Sun.
Earlier this week, in fact, it came out just today, oh, what am I saying?
It came out today on spacetelescope.org, these images of NGC 4889, which was an elliptical
galaxy that is 300 million light years away, and they're saying it is home to a record-breaking
supermassive black hole, 21 billion times the mass of the Sun.
And so this was released just today, and is that a pretty common, I mean, well, first
of all, let's talk about elliptical galaxies and the whole galaxy structure and this idea
that there are supermassive black holes at the centers of these.
Is it safe to say that every galaxy has one, a supermassive black hole?
You're making a face.
Kai-Han's making a face.
Todd, why don't you take this one, I'm sorry.
Right, so a little history with detection of black holes and the work with space telescope
is done.
The idea that there are massive black holes in galaxies goes back to the 60s when they
discovered quasars, they needed something to power it, and a black hole was a good candidate.
So a great idea, but at the time, people thought these are sort of theoretical objects.
So there was this long quest that started actually, I realize at about the same time
that people started going after gravitational wave detection, to look for black holes in
galaxies.
This picked up at the end of the 70s, there were a few cases in the 80s where we said,
we think there's a black hole in the center of a galaxy, like we felt there was one in
the Milky Way, there's one in Andromeda, but they're very hard to do, the kind of supporting
observations from the ground.
So this is going to be with the Hubble Space Telescope that we'd really make great progress
with this, and I and a few other people put together a team of astronomers, we applied
for time with Hubble Space Telescope over several years, and we began a census.
And we discovered that basically any time we looked at the center of a galaxy, we would
see a massive black hole in the center.
And so we realized that black holes are a normal part of galaxies, they're rather than
being exotic or strange, you expect to see them.
They anchor the galaxy, they participate in its formation.
After we studied a group of these, we called this the demographics of black holes, we saw
patterns.
We saw that big galaxies had big black holes, and the question was, how far does this go?
If we looked in the most massive galaxies in the universe, would we see incredible black
holes?
And this galaxy, which is known by the catalog number NGC 4889, it doesn't roll off the tongue
easily, is actually the brightest galaxy in the coma cluster of galaxies, which is very
close by.
It's really one of the most massive galaxies in the nearby universe, and so we said, let's
try that and see if it has a black hole, and if it's unusual, and it turned out to
be a record breaker.
So that's a case where we said, we think this galaxy, if we think that black holes are related
to galaxies, and part of them will have the most massive black hole, we should check it
out, and we were rewarded with a definitive, yes, verily, there is a high-mass black hole
in this galaxy, which beats anything that we had known before.
So it's very, very satisfying to see that we are really understanding that black holes
have a place in normal galaxies.
Well I want to get to the idea of how they got that big, and this galaxy as well, in
a moment, but I want to go back to your comment on the, not the classification, but the census
that you took.
And Scott, if you wouldn't put up that tuning fork for me, there is a, was that census that
you were talking about with the Hubble Space Telescope, and Scott's got it up here now,
where we've kind of come up with this, what's called the tuning fork, Hubble tuning fork
of classification of galaxies.
Did that come out of that census, or was this different work entirely?
Oh, well, the short of it is that we've known the Hubble tuning fork goes back to Edwin
Hubble himself, besides discovering the expansion of the universe, he gave us really...
So it's not the Hubble Space Telescope's classification, it's Hubble's classification.
My apologies, yes, this was...
No, no, that was me, that was on me.
Hubble did many things, and actually discovering that there were other galaxies, that they
were equal to our own Milky Way or beyond, was also a crucial part of his research career.
And he sorted them into different types, and he called it the tuning fork, and it's sort
of a tool to sort out types of galaxies, spirals, ellipticals, there's an intermediate kind
called S0s, and poorly organized kind.
What I would say is that, you know, when we've looked in all kinds of galaxies, at least,
you know, high mass galaxies, you know, we've been able to find the black hole regardless
of its...
Well, welcome back everybody, sorry about that, we had a bit of technical difficulties
with the Hangout connection, but we hope that we will get you back, because we had to start
a new Hangout on air with a different link, and Scott is currently sharing that on all
the social media stuff, so we're hoping you will come back to us.
Where we had left off was we were talking about the relationship between, of the different
kinds of galaxies that Edwin Hubble had come up with early in his career, and it was sort
of a tuning fork arrangement where we had spiral galaxies and barred spiral galaxies
sort of going into these much larger galaxies, and today, we are talking about a galaxy observation
that was done by the Hubble Space Telescope of an elliptical galaxy, NGC 4889, and elliptical
galaxies are among the largest in the universe, and Todd was just telling us that there is
a relationship, and I was about to ask him what kind of relationship there is between
the size of these galaxies and the size of the supermassive black holes at their center,
so Todd, let me go back to that, and you were talking about, you looked at larger galaxies,
you were hoping to find larger supermassive black holes, and lo and behold, you did.
Is there an easy relationship, or is it a complicated relationship, or is there a relationship
at all between the size of a galaxy and the size of the supermassive black hole at its
center?
Well, the best...
The linear thing, or...
Right, so the thing which is fun about that is there is more than one relationship, and
they conflict when you get up to bright galaxies, the biggest galaxies.
The first relationship that we discovered was one between the typical velocities within
a galaxy far away from the black hole, and that predicts one kind of black hole mass.
The other is just the amount of stars, and they agree very well for run-of-the-mill galaxies,
but when you get to the brightest galaxies in the universe, they are in conflict, and
one of the things we want to do is say, which one is right, because you use these relationships
as yardsticks to gauge the black hole content of the whole universe.
Help me understand the conflict, then.
As you reach a point where, with the very brightest galaxies, they don't have the largest
black holes, or I don't understand what you mean.
No, the question is one of prediction.
So you look at a galaxy, and you say the galaxy has a set of properties, how much mass
is there, or how quickly it's moving.
There's other properties.
You can write them all down in a table, and you try to make a prediction from these properties.
What do you expect to see for a black hole?
Nearby, for galaxies that are not as massive, all these things agree, but when you extrapolate,
they made different predictions.
One or both of them had to be wrong.
This is what we did.
You look at different kinds of galaxies to extend your yardsticks, or these relationships,
to new things you hadn't studied before.
That's why we went after this bright galaxy, because it was a way to sort of feel out this
conflict between what kinds of black holes galaxies were expected to have.
OK.
And so this, and the conflict was that they, well, I guess I still don't get the conflict.
OK.
You extrapolated, but what's the actual conflict?
The conflict is, you know, if I look at you, and I've never met you, you're just a figure
on a webcast.
Right.
Pardon me.
But let's just admit.
But I look at you, and I might guess your age, you know, I might guess your weight.
I might guess things about you based on various ideas.
You have height.
You have weight.
There are properties that I can see now.
And some of those things might be better than others.
If somebody said, you know, how much money do you make, or how old are you, you know,
I would use different things to judge that.
And so one measure with a galaxy is just simply how much stuff is there.
The mass of stars.
Including the matter in the stars, right.
Or just the amount of stars.
You look and say, the galaxy is this bright, it has this much stuff, so the black hole
should be this big.
But if I take a spectrograph, and I say how fast are the stars moving around, which is
a form of temperature, okay, that gives a different prediction.
And for a lot of the galaxies, those predictions are one in the same.
But when you get up to big galaxies, and what happens, another way to say this is that the
bright galaxies, the brightest ones have a tremendous amount of stars in them, but the
typical temperature or speed of the stars that move around is actually not that high.
It's kind of modest.
It sort of tops out.
It doesn't really, you know, they don't swirl around, as it were, more than, you know, less
massive galaxies.
So you'd say, oh, based on that, the black hole should be nothing special.
But you say, well, but look, they have all these stars in them.
You know, that says there's a lot of stuff, the black hole should be really massive.
So what's the right answer?
It's where you pick up a telescope, and you go look.
I see.
Well, I thank you for clarifying that.
I think I've got the, so you can't use one set or even a couple, a few sets of properties,
because at some point, they start to get in each other's way.
So what you're trying to do is figure out this relationship between these galaxies and
their black holes.
But I want to go a little bit here from, and let me ask you this, Kai-Han, there's a question
here from Shadow Assassin that kind of alludes to where I want to go next with this.
On YouTube, he's asking, yeah, but which developed first, stars that eventually collapsed into
black holes, or were they just areas of gravitational pull that made the development of stars possible?
So where would these supermassive black holes have originated?
Would they have come from individual smaller-sized ones, or were they somehow formed out in another
mechanism?
That's a fantastic question, and I wish we knew the answer to that.
But that is one of the most important questions about supermassive black holes, is how they
formed.
There are three main ideas, which Shadow Assassin has gotten two of them, basically.
One is that the first generation of stars, because of properties in the early universe,
you know, in the early universe, everything was just hydrogen and helium, and that allowed
the first generation of stars to be much more massive than the current generation of stars.
And so the thought is, well, you take a star that is much bigger, it evolves just like
stars do now, only it's bigger, and it turns into a bigger black hole than ordinary.
It still would only be a couple hundred to a thousand solar masses this way, a couple
hundred to a thousand times the mass of the Sun, and it would still have to eat matter
and grow along the way up to the millions and billions of solar masses in the supermassive
black holes that we see now.
But you want that head start.
The second way, which Shadow Assassin referred to, is you have early parts of the universe,
you have places that are more dense and places that are less dense.
And in the denser places, the matter, due to gravity, will collect there, and it will
get even denser.
And you can have this sort of, a little bit of a runaway, if things can smoosh in together
early on, together, and it happens fast enough, it's called a direct collapse mechanism,
and things all flow down, and you start off with something that is, say, 10,000 or 100,000
or maybe even a million or 10 million solar masses, and from there it grows on the rest
of the way.
A direct collapse, I had never heard of that before.
So there's a bit, that looks like a hard thing to construct, isn't it?
Something that...
It's actually, well, I mean, it's the, right now it's the favored idea.
But that doesn't mean it's not hard to construct.
There are lots of details.
As stuff, you know, falls in, you know, it tends to heat up, and then that makes a lot
of light, and light actually has...
Well, yeah, you're going to want to have some stars falling in there, aren't you?
Yeah.
Well, we're ignoring stars.
This is just big balls of gas sitting in the potential, sitting in the...
And somehow don't form stars, but...
...dark matter.
Yeah.
There's annoying stars.
It somehow doesn't form stars, but directly collapses into a black hole.
Wow.
You have to avoid the stars, because the stars will...
Right.
...kind of heat things up, and halt everything going into the center and becoming a black
hole.
Wow.
That's amazing.
I'd never heard that before.
That's...
You haven't, yeah.
That's probably unlikely, but you're saying that's a best, that's a favorite mechanism
for getting these things started, these really large black holes.
Yeah.
The third idea is you start with more ordinary-sized black holes through normal stellar evolution,
and they can live in clusters or something, and they end up merging with each other relatively
rapidly early on in the universe.
And this is actually related to the LIGO discovery, because this would...
They can detect that.
That's right.
They can detect that now.
Yeah.
As long as it's close.
And this happened too far away, too long ago for LIGO to directly detect it, but it's
the same idea as what they have detected.
And you just...
You have to do it a lot of times.
The problem is that every time you merge these two black holes, you tend to kick one out
through dynamical interaction, so it tends...
They're very messy eaters in this way when you get these black holes in a cluster.
Yeah.
Well, that one makes a lot of sense to me.
I like that one the best.
And, of course, what I think goes...
Carol will tell you.
It's all about me being confident.
And I like that one the best.
That one makes...
Well, let's go in...
While we're on the subject of forming black holes, I want to just...
Let's just bring in dark matter, because not for sale, Bernie2016, not a political handle
at all, is talking about dark matter.
And as I read the comments, I'll just read one of them, because, well, it's believed
that dark matter makes up like 90% of all the matter, right?
No, it's more like 25% or 26% of all matter in the universe, not 90%.
But let's...
So my question is about dark matter.
Surely, this stuff has a role to play in black hole formation, right?
Well, probably the answer to that is what created the galaxies in the first place.
And I really don't separate black holes from the stars in them.
It was all of a piece.
Dark matter, as it were, formed the framework that brought the ordinary matter together.
It made sort of a little shape or ripple, and the matter fell into it and was able to
collapse.
Like, you know, the direct collapse that Kaihan was talking about probably happened
early in the universe, and it was dark matter that got that going.
So that's the role that dark matter plays.
It's really what gives the shape to the galaxies and starts them off.
The ordinary matter, right, is just a small part of what's there, it's sort of frosting
on the cake.
Although, for us, very important frosting.
All right.
Okay.
Well, that was a good comment.
Thank you, Bernt.
Not for sale, Bernie, 2016.
Okay, so let's get to the fact that we were looking at this elliptical galaxy, which are
among the largest, they are the largest galaxies in the universe, and they got this way, my
understanding is, is they got this big through galaxy interactions, mergers, galaxy collisions,
and things like that, right?
Yeah, that's pretty much how we think it happened.
Again, this galaxy we're talking about is right at the center of a very, very rich cluster
of galaxies.
And so it's sort of King Rat, you know, it's there at the top of the hill, and, you know,
we look at other clusters of galaxies, we can see merging of galaxies going on, even
now with evidence that happened in the past.
So yeah, the biggest galaxies are, as it were, the biggest fish in the ocean that got that
way by merging, you know, smaller galaxies together.
So absolutely.
And in addition to being large, they typically are of a specific, you look at a spiral galaxy,
it's well defined, it's got this beautiful structure to it, it's often blue in color,
lots of star birth going on, very vibrant, very pretty objects up in the sky.
Ellipticals just are these gigantic blobs, they're featureless, they are generally sort
of yellow, and so, well, can one of you comment a little bit about what the nature of elliptical
galaxies, what are some of their properties?
And I'll, maybe Kai-Han, can you tell us?
I can, but Todd is the world's expert on elliptical galaxies.
I knew I'd get that, I had a 50-50 chance of getting that one.
Okay Todd, would you do it, would you let us know, just tell us a little bit about ellipticals.
Well I don't know if I'd go with featureless blobs, some of my best friends are elliptical
galaxies, so.
I mean they are, I admit that they are less photogenic than spiral galaxies, but what's
happened is spiral galaxies, you see the way they are because of the gas, they have ongoing
star formation, that's what makes the pretty spiral arms, the clouds of dust, and everything
around them.
If you merge two spiral galaxies together, two things happen.
One is it's chaotic, and a lot of the gas gets funneled into a burst of star formation.
In that interaction, you will disorganize it and use up a lot of the gas, and this is
actually where a black hole comes in, is some of it will be funneled into the black hole,
and there will be an energetic back reaction as you try to stuff all this gas into the
black hole, and it will heat up and blow out the gas, and it may actually clear out
the galaxy, leaving it clean as a whistle.
So it is the process of making ellipticals out of spirals that gets rid of all the things
that we associate with spirals, you leave just behind the stars.
But they're interesting systems, I mean the stars at the center elliptical galaxies are
extremely concentrated.
I calculated once, there's a little galaxy right next to the great Andromeda galaxy called
M32, it's a little tiny elliptical galaxy, and the image you're looking at would be probably
even dimmer than one of those little red dots away from the main galaxy there, which is
M87.
But if you were at the center there, the stars are so packed together, you could read
newspaper at night by starlight.
It's basically, we have one star in our galaxy, and M32 you'd have 10 million.
So it's certainly photogenic if you happen to be at the center of one.
Fair enough.
You did a good job sticking up for him, I was not being fair.
I can see that now.
My apologies to all ellipticals out there, I did not mean to get personal there.
So, Kai-Han, can you tell us a little bit about our galaxy, the Milky Way.
We presumably have one of these things in the center of our galaxy, correct?
We sure do.
In fact, the supermassive black hole at the center of the galaxy, of our galaxy, the Milky
Way, is one of two supermassive black holes that were quite positive, is in fact a supermassive
black hole.
Of course, because it's closer to us than anything else in any other supermassive black
hole, we can get really precise measurements of the motions of stars going around the black
hole at the center.
I've seen some of those animations, not animations, but series of observations are really, really
cool.
Yeah.
And because of that, we can see how close these stars get, and we can say that these
things are, that whatever it is that's doing the gravity, that's moving the stars around,
is quite small and quite compact, and it is almost inconceivable that it could be anything
other than a black hole.
It's dark, and it is massive, and it is small.
We don't know that it has a horizon, although there is an experiment called the Event Horizon
Telescope that is working on getting radio observations of the plasma around Sag A Star,
that's the name of the black hole at the center of our galaxy.
Good thing to say.
Yeah, it's working on getting radio images using telescopes all over the globe so that
you get the high resolution images from having a telescope that's about the size of the
Earth at relatively high frequency radio, and so therefore being able to see the shadow
of the horizon of this black hole, and therefore proving that it actually has a horizon, or
a definitive proof.
Maybe you need to tell me what you mean by horizon, because I thought a black hole couldn't
be a black hole without an event horizon.
Are you saying something else?
No, what I'm saying is exactly that, is that in order for one of these objects that is
dark and massive, in order for us to be able to say conclusively that it's a black hole
and not something else, we want direct evidence that there is an event horizon there.
And so, until we have direct evidence that there is an event horizon, we are just mostly
sure and pretty confident that what we're seeing is a black hole.
Oh, thank you.
Okay, good.
I understood.
I understand what you're getting at.
Well, Scott is now showing those observations of the stars.
These are actual movies of actual stars, aren't they?
This was taken with ground-based observations.
This is Andrea Goetz and Reinhard Genzel, who have done this work, and this is the closest
we've been able to look at a black hole at the center of any galaxy, and that's because
it's in our own galaxy.
But to amplify on what Cayenne said a little bit, and to bring it back to what happened
today, you know, we know from these observations that there is an immense amount of mass in
a small space, and by our theories, that can only be a black hole, but that's the best
we can do for galaxies until we get this event horizon telescope.
The thing that happened today was, for the very first time ever, we actually saw the
horizon of two black holes, and that said, yes, black holes really do exist.
So, it's circumstantial, as it were.
There's nothing else that can explain what we see in the galaxies besides a black hole,
but they're still away from seeing the unique signature, and that's what happened today.
That's why it's so exciting, that said, yes, in this case, they are black holes.
There's no other way, no other thing they could be.
And because of those gravitational wave signals, we were able to actually see the event horizon
itself.
Absolutely.
We saw the size of the event horizon, we saw what happened to it, and if you look at the
thing that came out, the thing that's absolutely fascinating is you see what's called a chirp,
the waves at higher and higher frequency, but they don't get infinitely high, they stop
at a certain frequency, they said like middle C, and that frequency right there, it tells
you the size of the horizon.
They get up, they get, you know, high enough, but then they hit a limit, and the merging
takes place.
And that is a direct measure of how big the horizon is.
Okay.
Well, that's, thank you for that.
That was really, that was really, helped me understand what they meant by not only just
the horizon aspect, but also the importance of today's announcement.
So really good.
Okay, well, the, I was trying, while you were talking, I thought maybe I could bring that
chirp up, but I'm not going to be able to do it right now, it's just too many things
going on.
But, so I have a question though, okay, we have lots of evidence for different sized
black holes, and as you said, okay, it's consistent.
When you look at velocities, or you look at the x-ray signature, you get an amount of
mass which is in a space which is too small to allow light to get out, and so we infer
there's an event horizon.
But it would be kind of weird that we would have gravitational waves and then have all
this other evidence from all these other telescopes that would be something different, right?
Oh, it all hangs together, you know, but if you, you know, look at what people say, maybe,
let's put it this way, maybe, you know, Einstein's theory isn't exactly right when you get close
to making a black hole, maybe when you get right to where you think a horizon should
form, something else happens, you know, there are exotic ideas for putting a large amount
of mass in a small area, and just because you run out of ideas, you know, doesn't rule
out there might be something you didn't even think about or you haven't, you know, haven't
worked out yet.
So it's an extra step.
It looks pretty good, but you want proof positive to see it exactly like Einstein ordered them
up.
That's what we got today.
That's the thing which is so exciting about the LIGO stuff today.
It is exactly, straight on, what you expected from relativity.
Can you guys see what I'm sharing now?
Because I've got it up.
Right.
You're showing the chirp, and if you freeze it, if you can freeze it for a second, so
what you see, it's a little bit noisy, but ah, right there, that's good.
You see a noisy trace, and as you move to the right, it becomes more regular, but you
also see the peaks getting closer together.
That's called a chirp.
It is, they're orbiting, and as the black holes merge, the period of the orbit goes
up, but then it stops, and that's the merger.
And the best part of this is you're looking at the two separate stations of LIGO, one
in Hanford, Washington, and one in Livingston, Louisiana, and they saw it at the same time.
So this is exactly what a merger of a black hole looks like, and when they worked it out,
there's lots of parameters required to get this right.
General relativity tells you what those are, and the analysis says this is dead on exactly
what you expected for a merging of two black holes.
So when we were talking about the formation of supermassive black holes in these kind
of three scenarios, one would think, one would think that if you have supermassive black
holes that are formed for, I mean, the supermassive black holes have so much mass that if you
merge two halves of that, or three or four all together to make a supermassive black
hole, that would have a very large signature, and do I understand that the problem with
that is that those events would have occurred very long ago, the formation of the universe,
or this thing that the black hole just goes whoop and forms, that also formed so long
ago that right now the technology would not allow us to see those events, although they
would have been producers of massive amounts of gravity waves.
Well, it's not quite that. It's a different thing. It's like, you know, you can only hear
with your ear certain pitches. You know, it goes up and you can't hear high pitches beyond
some thing, and it gets worse as you get older, but then low pitches, you can't hear, you
know, you can't hear things very easily. Your ears just don't hear, you know, very, you
know, low-pitched sounds. With LIGO and its four-kilometer arms, the objects have to be
fairly compact. With these massive black holes, they orbit at each other in a fraction of
a second. For the supermassive black holes that we have at the centers of galaxies, they
would take several hours to go around, or longer, and that's just beyond what LIGO
can do. We had a proposal for an instrument called LISA, which would be in space and would
have arms, you know, a tenth of the size of your exorbitant antenna. That could see it,
okay? That could see massive black holes of the types that are in the centers of galaxies.
LISA will not be able to detect the kind of massive black holes that we have studied with
Hubble Space Telescope and galaxies.
Okay. I've got a question here from Twitter. We're running out of time, so I want to get
a couple of comments in from Twitter. KranteeElement8, what are black holes made of? Would there
be any normal matter or just very deeply curved space-time? Is there anything in there, or
is it just curved space-time, and that's all we need to know about a black hole?
That's the best answer, is they are curved space-time. They are warped in space. What's
at the center, one could go on for quite some time. That's the singularity, which
might, you know, but I won't get into that. But the best way to think of a black hole
is it is a distortion in space. That's the best bet.
All right.
I think one of the best descriptions I heard of, it was at a Carnegie talk a little while
ago, and it was that there's all this mass that has no surface. And to think about it
that way, you have all this mass, much, much mass there, but it actually has no surface.
Like, we're used to living in a world where everything has a surface on it. You know,
there's something tangible there. But when we're talking about black holes, it actually
does not have a surface. You just have that event horizon. You're not actually able
to touch anything on it.
Conversely, when you get far enough away from the black hole, it acts like it's just
a bunch of mass.
Right.
That's right. That's absolutely right.
Because if our star turned into a black hole, our orbit would stay the same. We would just
not have the energy from the sun anymore.
The horizon, by the way, is a perfect thing. That's why it's called the horizon. If
you went down to the ocean and saw a ship disappear over the horizon, you couldn't
see it. But if you tried to go after the ship, you know, you would sail over the horizon
and nothing special would happen to you. You'd say, oh, it looks like a regular ocean
until you went over the horizon and just couldn't see where you came from anymore.
A black hole is like that. That's why it's called a horizon. It's just, you know,
if you try to go in it, you know.
That's where my head starts to hurt when we start talking about that. Kai Han, did
you want to add something to this? You looked like you were about to say something.
Yeah, but I forgot what it was.
Oh, it's just a joke.
It must have been a lie. Yeah.
All right.
Or it was a profound truth.
Okay, so here we have one more from Juz Turmans from YouTube. How long do the gravitational
waves last? Is it just good timing that we saw something happen billions of light years
away? Who wants to take that one?
The one that was announced today and was seen in the middle of September lasted less than
a second, just, I forget exactly how long, just a few milliseconds, I think.
And so it was good timing, but these kind of things happen, are thought to happen a
lot in the region of the universe in which LIGO is sensitive to these things.
So in some sense, it was good timing that more or less as soon as they turned on the
instrument they saw something, but it would have happened eventually after listening for
a while.
Yeah, and I think the two observatories, I think, noticed it about 20 milliseconds apart,
but it was on order of seconds, but I don't remember either. So good, okay.
Well, Scott, we are almost out of time. Do we got anything else I missed?
I only have two hands. I believe so.
Um, everything on Twitter has actually been answered while we're on air. So thank you
everyone for going on Twitter. You guys are having a really great conversation there in
the YouTube chat. And let's see here. Hans Milling, I did post a link to the black hole
time lapse. It's up there from Chandra. So if you just search for Sagittarius A star,
I'll bring you to Chandra's, Chandra X-ray Observatory's website and you can see the
animation there.
But other than that, no, I think we're doing really well.
All right. So, um, well, all right, I guess we'll stop there. So, um, I want to thank
our guests, Kai-Han Gjultgen and, um, Todd Lauer. Thank you both for, for showing up
and talking to us about black holes on a day when gravity is paramount.
For being the weakest force in the universe, it's doing pretty good today.
I know, it's doing pretty good today. Gravity week.
Gravity week. All right, guys. Thank you very much.
Yeah. Thank you for taking the time out to talk to us about these awesome things,
supermassive black holes, elliptical galaxies, and the, uh,
Tuning Fork Diagram by Edwin.
By Edwin Hubble.
Yeah. I always called it the Hubble Tuning Fork Diagram. And I don't know why in my
head I had that associated with the space telescope, but I did. There you go.
There you go. Maybe someone needs to take a little hammer to you until it resonates.
Hammer to my head. Yes. Or a tuning fork to my head. One of the two. I deserve it.
Anyway. All right. Well, at least I learned a new thing, too, today. So we're all never
too old to learn. And believe me, I'm about as old as it gets. No comment, Scott and Carol.
All right, folks. Carol.
I was just going to say you had low metallicity.
God, that's a good joke, actually.
That's a really good joke, Scott.
All right. Well, Carol, do we have anything next week, or is it a surprise?
It's always a surprise. I think there might be.
Carol likes to keep us guessing.
Yeah. I keep on guessing. It'll probably be something more planetary-like.
Hey, guys. All right, folks. Well, that's it for this week in Hubble Hangout Land. I want
to thank you all for watching. And as always, keep looking up.
