Concrete Crumbles to Sand in Hand, Pillars Break on Tapping, China’s Widespread Tofu-Dreg Projects

China Observer
822 followers
The video footage shows that while these resettlement homes appear as upscale villas from the outside, their true condition harbors alarming deficiencies. The walls, supposedly cemented, are less sturdy than the traditional adobe walls used by farmers which can be dismantled by hand; the concrete crumbles easily when grabbed; a layer of the cement wall surface can be scraped off with the outer casing of a lighter; and the reinforcing steel bars in the load-bearing columns are exposed. These houses are a stark example of shoddy construction. The villagers are too fearful to move in.
#tofudreg #chinaobserver
All rights reserved.
Can you believe this? They built it without any cement.
Look at this, it's like tofu. They call this construction?
I wonder what kind of construction it is.
What's the use of this? There's no cement at all.
They build walls without using cement.
The bricks are just laid haphazardly, almost like ash.
The farmers spend so much money, right?
To end up with a house like this, how hard it must be for them.
So, you received the house like this, didn't you?
They didn't pour this, right? They didn't pour it.
The rebar below wasn't poured either. You haven't touched it, right?
No, I haven't touched it. The load-bearing columns, the pillars are gone.
Recently, in Yanghuba Village, situated in Huzhou City, Zhejiang Province,
dozens of villagers who each spent 400,000 yuan on resettlement houses
were shocked to find that their homes were of substandard quality,
a revelation that has since drawn significant public attention after media exposure on October 22.
The video footage shows that while these resettlement homes appear as upscale villas from the outside,
their true condition harbors alarming deficiencies.
The walls, supposedly cemented, are less sturdy than the traditional adobe walls used by farmers,
which can be dismantled by hand.
The concrete crumbles easily when grabbed.
A layer of the cement wall surface can be scraped off with the outer casing of a lighter,
and the reinforcing steel bars in the load-bearing columns are exposed.
These houses are a stark example of shoddy construction.
The villagers are too fearful to move in.
During a site visit by media reporters, the deputy town chief arrived to address the situation.
He explained that the houses were built following a bidding process initiated by the village,
and any queries regarding the construction should be directed to the contractors.
Guo, the owner of the construction company, also appeared on site.
He claimed that the houses were built according to government-provided blueprints
and admitted some issues with the cement mortar, promising immediate rectification.
However, he was ambiguous about the specifics of these improvements,
offering only vague assurances to the villagers before attempting to leave.
His departure was halted by a villager, who shared that upon receiving their house,
they tried to replace a door only to have the entire wall collapse with a single hammer blow.
Fortunately, without causing any injuries,
the villager revealed that no concrete was used in building the walls, only ash.
Another villager reported that the decorative strips on either side of their windows were made of foam,
a highly flammable material, rather than the standard cement, posing a significant fire hazard.
With more villagers coming forward to report similar issues,
it raises concerns that the dozens of resettlement houses in the area might all be of similarly poor quality.
However, the deputy town chief downplayed the villagers' concerns,
claiming they were minor and posed no danger to residents.
His dismissive attitude infuriated the villagers,
who challenged him to live in the houses himself if he believed them to be safe.
Under pressure, Guo committed to addressing the villagers' concerns within a week.
Given the extent of the poor construction,
anything short of a complete rebuild seems unlikely to resolve the issues effectively.
Such instances of shoddy construction,
particularly in government-funded projects like resettlement houses for farmers,
relocated households and urban renewal housing, are not uncommon in China.
These projects, often funded by the government,
are particularly susceptible to corruption and rent-seeking behaviors.
It is common for construction contractors to be relatives of important local officials,
leading to cost-cutting and compromised construction standards,
resulting in substandard housing quality.
In terms of regulation, there is often an unspoken agreement to turn a blind eye to these issues.
In some cases, there may even be collusion between the regulatory,
construction, supervision and inspection phases.
The most affected are invariably the farmers and the urban poor who reside in these buildings,
as they are the most vulnerable and often overlooked by bureaucrats,
with little recourse for their grievances.
In a related development,
residents of another urban renewal housing project in Heilongjiang Province's Mingshui County
faced similar issues.
The Harmony Home Community, built in 2009 and completed in 2010,
began showing signs of structural issues in 2017,
causing residents to fear for their safety.
After reporting the problems to relevant authorities,
it was classified as dangerous,
and 331 residents were forced to leave and unable to move back for the past four years.
In July 2019, residents reported severe quality issues with the buildings.
In August 2019 and May 2020,
local departments commissioned building inspection agencies
to assess the structural safety of Buildings A and C in the Harmony Home Community.
Both buildings were classified as degrade-dangerous structures
and the reports identified significant safety hazards, recommending immediate action.
In September of the same year,
the local government decided to relocate all residents.
Now the building remains untouched,
and plans for new construction are uncertain.
The local government provides each household
an annual temporary resettlement allowance of 4,800 yuan.
However, residents report that the average annual rent in Mingshui County
ranges from 6,000 to 8,000 yuan.
Therefore, they were forced to pay additional out-of-pocket expenses for housing.
In an interview, a resident of the compound, Mr. Chen, stated,
The building became a degrade-dangerous building nine years after it was built.
Actually, after seven years, one unit had a floor collapse,
and later they found the upper floors had collapsed too.
The government later identified it as a degrade-dangerous building.
They then asked us to move out.
It's been almost five years since we moved out,
and they still haven't rebuilt it for us.
Look, the floor tiles are bulging,
and the ceiling's aluminum plastic board is too heavy.
It fell down on its own.
The floor has sunk four centimeters.
According to Mr. Chen,
this year's resettlement compensation remains unresolved,
and there is still no clear timetable
for the demolition and reconstruction of the building.
Additionally, business owners in the community report
that approximately 80 commercial tenants
have not received related compensation for over two years.
This incident has sparked social concern and resonated online.
One netizen commented,
A new building turning into a dangerous structure within nine years of handover
surely has a story behind it.
Another added,
Shoddy workmanship, inferior materials, contractors making a fortune,
and supervisors filling their pockets,
all at the expense of the common people.
A third remarked,
Without the Internet,
the public would have no place to voice their grievances.
Under the pressure of public opinion,
there has been some progress in the matter.
A resident of the community mentioned hearing
that the building is scheduled for demolition by the end of December,
finally bringing some hope.
On November 28,
the government gathered resident representatives
to review a new design plan,
and a temporary resettlement allowance of 4,800 yuan
was deposited into their bank accounts.
Everyone is now looking forward to the demolition of the building
and moving into a new home as soon as possible.
Let's turn to the issue of substandard construction in resettlement houses,
commissioned for poverty alleviation.
On August 28 this year,
according to reports by Chinese state media,
several villagers from Menggong Town in Laodi City of Hunan Province
reported that their poverty alleviation resettlement houses
were poorly constructed.
Since moving in in 2019,
they quickly discovered numerous quality issues with their homes,
including cracks in the exterior walls of the buildings,
doors made of paper,
various sized cracks in the interior ceilings and floors,
missing reinforcement in the beams,
and leaks in the toilets,
kitchens,
and even bedrooms.
One homeowner demonstrated the poor quality of his door.
From the outside it appeared normal,
but a single hammer blow revealed a hollow core.
The outer layer of cardboard could be easily torn away,
revealing that aside from a small wooden frame,
the door was filled with paper.
Ms. Wang, a resident,
stated that the floors in her bedroom and living room
had to be reinforced with additional beams.
Without them,
stepping on the floor would cause it to shake.
Her home also had multiple instances of cracked and falling walls.
Her door had even been blown down by the wind.
This door falls off with just a gust of wind.
When did you realize there were quality issues with your house?
We noticed as soon as we moved in.
First it was little things,
then it became more and more.
This wasn't here before,
now it's cracked.
This is even after reinforcement.
In the home of a Wu family resident in Unit 1 of Building 9,
severe water leakage in the bedroom is currently under repair,
with the ceiling showing signs of sagging.
As people walk through the rooms,
the floor can be felt shaking.
Reports indicate that this project,
known as the 2018 Poverty Alleviation Relocation Project in Xinhuang County,
Menggong Town's Fujiakun resettlement site
constructed 12 resettlement buildings.
These house 189 families and 808 villagers
from various villages in Menggong Town.
The project was completed in December 2018
and the villagers moved in by May 2019.
However, less than five years after completion,
the resettlement houses have frequently shown quality issues.
The construction was undertaken by Hunan Construction Engineering Group,
a state-owned sole proprietorship,
raising questions about how such low-quality housing
passed government inspection at the time.
A construction worker responsible for repairs and reinforcement
mentioned that all 12 buildings require reinforcement,
but so far only two sample units have been completed.
Numerous villagers have already moved out,
fearing a building collapse.
Such poverty alleviation projects,
instead of providing secure homes for villagers,
might be worsening their poverty.
This situation is not uncommon in China.
In November 2022,
villagers in Gaotun, Daizhuang and Zhongxiantai
in Hubei Baoding's national high-tech zone
celebrated the handover of their relocation houses,
marking their transition from villagers to city residents.
The local government held a grand ceremony for the occasion.
However, upon moving in,
the villagers discovered that the housing quality was substandard,
riddled with problems.
Look at the quality of this resettlement house.
The doorframe is about to collapse.
It's not even in use yet.
There are large cracks everywhere.
This was done by the state-owned enterprise MCC Group.
This doorframe is about to fall.
What are we going to do?
They really know how to fool the public.
In fact, a simple online search
reveals numerous videos highlighting issues with resettlement houses.
For example, in the resettlement houses
handed over in April this year
in Zhengzhou's Laoyacheng village, Henan province,
the cement crumbles easily when pinched by hand.
This is clearly indicating shoddy construction.
How can people live in such conditions?
In another case,
a large piece of the exterior wall of a resettlement building fell off,
fortunately not injuring anyone.
At a resettlement house in Shunyi, Beijing,
villagers discovered that what should have been a cement floor
was actually just dirt when scraped by hand.
In Guangxi, villagers waited six years for their resettlement houses,
which look impressive from the outside.
However, upon closer inspection,
the wall coating crumbles to the touch
and concrete pillars can be easily chipped away by hand.
And in the resettlement houses of Kunshan's Xinpo Peach Gardens,
the exterior wall coating was blown off by the wind.
Residents are concerned about the potential danger
if the falling debris were to hit someone.
This seemingly luxurious building is actually of substandard quality.
The insulation layer of the exterior walls periodically falls off,
causing great alarm among the residents.
In the Xinhai village area of Shuying District, Haiku City,
a shantytown renovation project was once listed
as a key project by the Hainan provincial government.
In 2021, the project was exposed as a substandard construction endeavor.
Local villagers revealed that nearly every household in the resettlement area
suffered from serious quality issues such as leaks
and cracked and crumbling concrete in the ceilings.
In addition to ceiling leaks,
the quality and workmanship of the doors, windows, and sanitary fittings
also left much to be desired.
The strength of the entrance doors was inadequate,
easily denting under pressure.
The plastic steel doors in the bathrooms could be punctured with little effort,
and the newly installed toilets' gaskets cracked after just a few uses.
Old media reports state that on October 20, 2015,
a housing requisition mobilization meeting was held
for the Xinhai Village Shantytown Renovation Project in Xishu Town, Haiku City.
The planned acquisition covered an area of 210 acres,
involving 58 million square meters of housing,
affecting 5,385 people and 2,200 households,
with an estimated investment of about 700 million yuan.
The farmers' lands were requisitioned,
and their original homes demolished,
only to be replaced with these poor-quality resettlement homes.
Moving in not only causes distress but also poses a potential risk to life,
while not moving in leaves them with nowhere to go.
This is a truly desperate situation.
In December 2019,
villagers also discovered that the resettlement houses in Xiaozhuang Village, Hunan Province,
had tiles felling off when they are touched,
and the concrete in beams and columns crumbled and fell.
In a video, villagers demonstrated that they could easily create holes in the walls with their hands.
On top of that, tiles detached upon touch,
cement floors produced dust when rubbed,
and the central beams and columns crumbled upon knocking,
revealing broken concrete inside.
The developers claimed that the building's beams and columns were not load-bearing
but were added for stability,
and that workers might have mixed in a lot of dirt or other materials during construction.
The company was in the process of rectifying these issues.
This shoddy construction project has sparked heated discussion online.
One villager questioned,
who would dare to move in?
If the pillars of the house are not solid, the quality can't be good.
Another said that simply touching the wall coating caused it to fall off,
indicating the contractors' cost-cutting measures.
Since Xi Jinping came to power in 2012,
eager to shape himself as a leader who could lift people out of poverty,
he set a goal in 2015 to eliminate poverty in China by 2020 using the current standards.
He claimed all counties will be removed from the poverty list,
addressing overall regional poverty.
In this political context,
poverty alleviation projects in various poor counties were launched.
However, due to the government-led nature of these projects,
they became hotbeds of corruption,
resulting in these numerous substandard poverty alleviation constructions.
For instance, in 2018,
a new village built for poverty alleviation in Dingxigansu Province
turned into a dangerous housing situation.
According to Chinese media reports,
in Tianping Village Anding District,
many houses had severely cracked walls,
with some completely collapsing.
Villagers resorted to propping up the walls with tree trunks
attached to grinding stones to prevent them from collapsing.
The corruption and arbitrariness in the operation of these poverty alleviation projects
are even more shocking than the typical substandard constructions
revealed by news reports.
From the initiation of relocation to the construction
and subsequent occupation of the new village,
the entire process was described as rotten from beginning to end.
According to local villagers,
the foundations of the houses were not solidly built,
filled with water, and excessively soft.
The drainage channels were hastily constructed
with only a couple of centimeters of cement,
and during construction,
only sand was used in the concrete without proper cement mixing.
Even more infuriating is that
as soon as the houses were built,
local officials urged villagers to move in quickly,
claiming that authorities from higher levels would inspect them.
When the villagers discovered the poor quality of the construction
and refused to move in,
the village authorities promised low-income support to those who relocated first.
However, after moving in,
the nightmare began for the villagers,
with some houses collapsing
and others severely sinking and cracking,
forcing the villagers to move out again.
Clearly, such construction of new poverty alleviation villages
not only fails to provide secure housing for villagers,
but may also endanger their lives.
According to the completion and final inspection
of the Dingxi Relocation Pilot Project,
the properties must be inspected by leaders from the city,
county, township, and village levels,
as well as poverty alleviation offices,
before villagers can move in.
The fact that such substandard projects
have either not undergone proper inspection
or have somehow passed inspection
raises serious questions.
How much of the poverty alleviation funds
intended for housing construction
was actually used for the building
and how much was embezzled by officials?
The low-income support, meant for the needy,
was instead used as a reward for relocation.
This highlights the misuse of power by government officials.
The poverty alleviation new village in Dingxi
ended up being a purely a substandard project.
Local officials forcing villagers to move into these unsafe buildings
is tantamount to playing with people's lives.
Sadly, such absurd incidents are a common occurrence in mainland China.
