Bonsai Die-Back | Myths and misunderstandings)

Eisei-en Bonsai
37 followers
Oh, stop, wait, don't cut that branch, you risk dieback.
But now imagine that this is a trunk of five centimeters or two inches thick
and you take a saw and you cut it off here.
Then all of a sudden in your tree you see this whole section dry off.
Now this could be described as dieback but it really isn't.
Now of course I'm not going to sit here and tell you that there's no such thing as dieback
but what I am going to say is that most people misunderstand dieback
because what is dieback really?
Dieback is the uncontrolled dying off of a trunk or branch after you cut it off.
This of course doesn't mean that every dying of a section of a branch is dieback.
In fact for most pruning problems that I see the dieback or the so-called dieback is actually
not dieback but it is a predictable behavior of the branch on the tree that you're pruning.
Particularly when you look at Japanese maple, if you look at videos, if you look on websites,
you often see, watch out, if you prune that branch there's a big risk of dieback.
So put cut paste, don't do it in the growing season, all these reasons are there
and people actually misunderstand the concept of dieback.
Now if you look at a Japanese maple and you look at the branch
you see that there between the leaves there is space.
And Japanese maple typically can only grow new branches
from the places where there's leaf connected.
Now if you cut right below a point where the leaves were
that means that all the way until the next leaves
there's no option for the branch to grow new side branches.
So that section will predictably die.
That's not dieback, that is just the drying in of a stump that is left after pruning.
Real dieback is when at that node where a branch could grow
the tree is unable to stop the dying off
and it then continues further down in the branch
and you see parts of the bark dying off.
You see one side might have a branch, the other side doesn't
and it slowly it can go in and in and in and in further down the branch.
Now what does this mean when you're growing out your own trees?
Now look at a branch like this one, right?
Here is a node.
There are old leaf stumps here.
And here's a node, here is a node.
So in this whole section not a single branch can form.
But if I cut right below at this point then this whole section will dry back.
Now at this stage you can clearly see I've cut it off here, it dries all the way to there.
But now imagine that this is a trunk of two inches thick
or five centimeters or two inches thick
and you take a saw and you cut it off here
then all of a sudden in your tree you see this whole section dry off
and then it could be tempting to say oh die back
but that is a risk with Japanese maple.
Now these are sacrifice branches that are never ever going to stay on the tree.
So it's not a problem because I'm going to cut it off all the way down below.
In fact this branch here down below is the one that I'm going to keep
and you see here are leaves, here are leaves
and it's a very short internode that's only two thirds of an inch, two three centimeters.
But down low here there's another fairly long sacrifice branch
so I might have to prune back all the way into that bud.
And there I have a half centimeter, a fifth of an inch extension growth.
This is ideal for the next trunk segment.
This is what we mean when we're talking die back.
It was cut off here, this berberis and then the trunk basically died all the way back
here, here and all the way into the base.
And if you follow this part down all the way here
it goes all the way until it reaches the ground.
So this whole part is dead.
And what happened is probably the top is gone
so there's no nutrients flowing down into the roots.
At the same time the roots have been cut short
and they are not providing any upflow either.
So here all the life has just disappeared.
It has slowly died back.
Now if you look at the side, you see on this side
a few of the branches have actually taken over
so this side of the trunk is all still alive.
Now this is a typical case of die back
and that is probably the result of a combination of both
the big prune and taking it from the ground.
Now if we look here at this Japanese maple
I cut the main trunk here at a slant
and this is healing over
but at the same time here a part of the bark has died off.
Now this could be described as die back
but it really isn't.
Here is a node.
This is where the branches grow from.
And if I look from the side and I...
The pot is now merged ground underneath
so I can't actually show you
but basically this is the first node from this point.
So there's a node here and there's a node here
and in between there is no nodes.
You can also see that here on this little branch
there's a node and there's a node.
So left alone to grow
these branches create fairly long internodes.
That's why when I cut it up to here
for the plant there was no reason to support
any living tissue here.
So slowly it dried in up to the next node
and there it has taken hold and here as well.
This is now going to close over fairly easily.
This is not really dieback.
This is natural predictable dying of the bark after pruning.
Now this pond granite illustrates very nicely
what dieback is like.
If you look at this stump here
this was a side trunk that I cut off.
And as this was dying off
there was nothing to stop the dieback
except for here this little side branch.
And you can see here in the bark
this spiral
this is where the tree was actually dying back.
Only here did the dieback stop on this side
and on the other side
it goes almost up to soil level.
This is dieback.
This is where the sap flow that kept this branch alive
was feeding the roots
and basically the bark had no more reason to stay alive.
It's really interesting to see how trees
respond to these big cuts.
So this is a very nice little cherry
that I air layered a few years ago.
And at the time I had a nice taper here
but it had reverse taper
so I created new roots on them
and all went really really well
until I separated it.
And at that point this side of the trunk died back.
There were no living buds here.
There were no roots on this side.
This trunk had been cut earlier
and as a result the whole trunk section
on this side died off.
In fact this bark is all dead
and I could probably peel it off now as well.
You see this just comes off with my nails
I can just pull it off.
This is all dead.
This is dieback.
This is what dieback looks like.
Now how do you prevent dieback?
In this case there were no roots.
It's not much you can do.
Basically because of this chop
this side had already very low sap flow.
Now when I started layering it
I interrupted whatever was left there
still at the roots.
There was no active current sap flow.
So one of the things that you can do
when you want to avoid dieback
is to make sure your tree is very healthy.
Make sure it is happy
it is growing and it's pushing.
Then if you make a big cut like this
it is often best to make sure
there's active branches growing already
at the area that we want to have.
And if there's no active growing branches
then you make the cut a little bit higher
than where you want it to have
because you don't know exactly
where the nodes might be on your branch.
If you leave a little stub
then that can dry in
and you get a branch growing.
Of course the combined action of this
having been cut the year before
and then me air layering this
doesn't help.
Make sure your tree is well established
in a pot before you do big cuts.
So for me the order is
big cut
then work the roots
but leave at least a year between
so that if you have made a big cut
this part of the tree can settle
subflow can reroute itself
to the roots
and once these have caught up
then you can do the rest of the work
on your roots.
Now what you can tell here
this branch died back
all the way up to the trunk.
And why is that?
Well this is a Prunus mumma
and Prunus mumma doesn't back bud
all that easily.
It's quite hard to get ramnification going
it's quite hard to get back budding
so it also means if you prune a big branch off
and the tree is not fully healthy
and they don't back bud all that easily
then yes the whole branch can die back
into the trunk
and maybe even continue down below the trunk.
You see this one is also dead
so once I start peeling the bark off here
would not be surprising
if in between these two branches
there's no living tissue left.
Now however
the one that people always say
is prone to die back
is right behind me here.
And what we see here
is that a big part of the branch
has been cut off.
In fact this was the leader of the trunk
growing really really tall
and I cut it off
and you see there's absolutely no die back.
In fact if I peel this off
this is healing over quite nicely.
So why is that?
Well that is because I looked at the bark
you see this tiny little line here
and that line defines the next node of the tree.
That is where new buds can form.
So I cut from one node
to just above the next node.
Of course I left this to grow vigorously
to make sure that the whole tree trunk stayed alive.
Initially I made a perpendicular cut
a year later I made it skew.
This also helps in avoiding the die back.
