81st Presidential Advisory Council on HIV/AIDS (PACHA) Full Council Meeting | June 6, 2024 | Part 4

USDOHAHS
156 followers
Jun 19, 2024
81st Presidential Advisory Council on HIV/AIDS (PACHA) Full Council Meeting | June 6, 2024 | Part 4
• Subcommittee Updates and discussion
--
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) | http://www.hhs.gov | HHS Privacy Policy | http://www.hhs.gov/Privacy.html
>> Marlene McNeese: Good afternoon again, and welcome back. We are on our final leg of the
PACHA meeting for Day 2. And I am so grateful on the agenda that we carved out some deliberation
time and that as members of PACHA, we were really able to reflect on what we've heard over the past
day and a half and really want to take this next step on the agenda, moving us forward
with really reporting out as a body to each other and to the public about what resonated
most and how what we heard will become -- concretated into the final work forward
over the next short-term, long-term plans for each of our subcommittees.
Most of what you will hear reported back today will likely take course over the next three to
six months, which I'm excited about the urgency and the movement in action. So,
looking forward to the report outs, and I've had a request for the first
subcommittee who wants to report out -- and let me just publicly give a round of
applause to Stigma and Disparities as a subcommittee. It is their model --
>> Male Speaker: Raniyah, Raniyah.
>> Marlene McNeese: -- that we are following her -- Raniyah Copeland and Leo Moore, who really,
really work very hard and tirelessly to stay organized on the path ahead
and the work that needs to get done. So, I appreciate their leadership. So,
Raniyah, I will turn the floor over to you.
>> Raniyah Copeland: Thank you so much. We're really excited to be advancing the work when
it comes to stigma and disparities, and we're excited to report a bit out what
we've been doing as an entire subcommittee. I think you all will remember that earlier this
year, the Stigma and Disparity subcommittee came together for a planning retreat in Los
Angeles. And from that, what we really wanted to do, especially when it comes to something
as big as stigma and something as big as disparities, really when we do HIV work,
I think that we're talking about disparities for the most part, and specifically populations
that have been left behind, especially as we talk about ending the HIV epidemic.
And so, we decided to think about what are three priorities that we can really lead in our time
together. And we came up with three workgroups. We came up with a Stigma Disruption workgroup
that is led by Dafina Ward. We came up with PrEP and PEP workgroup that is led by Natalie Sanchez.
And then we came up with Criminalization and Discrimination that's led by Marvell Terry.
And so, I'm excited to let them share a bit about what the priorities are that they currently have,
what are some timelines and goals that we're working to achieve, and where, particularly
from this meeting over the past two, three days, we've made any updates and revisions to what we
think are priorities and looking forward to, especially over the next few months, hearing
back from community as we really hope to align, refine, and have some impact around our goals. So,
I am going to pass it over to our fantastic workgroup leads to lead the rest of the updates.
>> Dafina Ward: I'm sure you all can read that very well [laughs]. As Raniyah mentioned,
I have the pleasure of leading our work around stigma disruption. So, I'm going to share very
briefly about our formative work that we've been doing over the past couple of months. So,
we determined in the Stigma Disruption group that our focus really needed to be around
acknowledging that stigma is fluid as a term and addressing it in its many different contexts,
especially in thinking about it as discrimination and bias. And these words we sometimes use
interchangeably. We have to affirm that stigma in its many forms, it's perpetuating
HIV disparities and inequities that we've talked about so robustly over the past couple of days.
And so, our priorities are, one, defining stigma disruption through a lens that we recognize has
to agitate systems and policies that perpetuate these acts and doing that and focusing on those
perpetrating the acts rather than doing on the backs of those subjected to said actions,
which is so often how we conduct research and talk about stigma. And so, people are not the problem,
and recognizing that we need a working definition, a collective definition
that we all are using when we're talking about stigma and what it means to disrupt said stigma.
We want to identify how federal agencies have already implemented recommendations
from PACHA. Specifically in 2017, a number of recommendations were made related to stigma,
and we want to identify additional opportunities for meaningful disruption of stigma among
agencies. And lastly, as far as the priority, I guess this would be the big deal kind of priority
is the passing of a resolution or some type of action by PACHA that seeks an additional pillar
that's focused on addressing stigma, which we know is a critical component to reaching the
goals of the EHE and looking at local examples and practices that can help us to inform what we're
doing at the federal level, namely the quality of life pillar that we've seen established in Texas.
So, as far as our timeline, our short-term timeline, initially,
we want to establish some research parameters in our own capabilities to assess the application
of previously entered recommendations from PACHA as it relates to addressing stigma. We
want to participate in PACHA listening sessions during the upcoming USCHA,
namely with the focus on the South this year. And we've heard about the disparities in the
South across the meeting the past few days. And we think that'll help us to identify our framings
necessary to talk about what disruption truly means in the context of this work.
And then also, a resolution introduced or a letter -- we're working on that -- an action
introduced at the next PACHA meeting, seeking adoption later this year,
where we really want to elevate and define disruption, look at key indicators,
and addressing stigma, and with some midterm goals around actionable research, assessing
the application of these recommendations from earlier years. And lastly, by the close of 2025,
at our meeting next December, we hope that there are some indicators that we can look
to where we can talk about how we've established definitions, indicators,
and measures around disruption, and how we measure success in doing such in our work. Thank you.
>> Raniyah Copeland: Any quick questions or comments -- maybe we'll limit them to
one or two -- for our Stigma Disruption workgroup?
All right. We'll move on to PrEP and PEP led by Natalie Sanchez.
>> Natalie Sanchez: Hi, everyone. So, our focus is on equitable access and utilization of PrEP
and PEP. I think over the past two days, we've heard a lot of information on data and looking
at the disparities. And so, from that, it's really guiding our work, and we're going to incorporate
that into, you know, how we focus on PrEP access and utilization in the very different communities.
So, something that we did incorporate -- so, we've previously talked about PrEP for women.
Now we're looking at, you know, also focusing on PrEP for undocumented people -- that's what we
also heard -- and then also hearing from today's panel about how anti-LGBT legislation could also
dissuade access to healthcare services, which then can impact their access to PrEP as well.
So, going back to our priorities, we want to create real solutions to address disparities
in PrEP access. And one of our priorities is to launch a PrEP Awareness Day, so to do that right
before World AIDS Day. Because what we feel is that there's not enough awareness on PrEP in,
especially communities of color. And so, we want to increase that ongoing awareness of
PrEP, informing them where they can access it and the benefits of PrEP.
So, our short term is securing buy-in from community partners such as NMAC,
Southern AIDS Coalition, PrEP4 All, AIDS United, Latino Commission on AIDS, as well
as other organizations across the United States, and to get their support that we're not just doing
this as another awareness day, that this is really adopted as a community mobilization,
what can happen on the ground in these different communities to help raise awareness on PrEP.
And so, again, our goal is to develop and increase PrEP awareness through a PrEP Awareness Day and,
again, focusing on the communities that are impacted, as the data is showing,
where the increases in new HIV infections, because that's an indicator of where PrEP needs to be.
>> Raniyah Copeland: We've done -- the PrEP and PEP workgroup did meet with HIV.gov as well,
to hear a little bit more about their approach to HIV or to awareness days. So,
we have a huge amount of insight [laughs] about some of the challenges and opportunities
of awareness days that we're hopefully going to be bringing forward. And one of
the kind of priorities they talked about, recommendations, was really having strong
community partners who can anchor the day, so action happens on the ground.
Any questions for Natalie, our PrEP and PEP workgroup lead? All right. Well,
we are going to have Marvell Terry II close us out with HIV Criminalization and Discrimination.
>> Marvell Terry: Thank you, Madam Co-chair. For the HIV Criminalization and Discrimination
workgroup, I feel our priorities are in the title [laughs] of our workgroup. What we have
learned through community conversations and assessments over the last couple of months is
that criminalization includes more than just intercourse or sex, that it also can include
chest feeding. It includes sex workers. And there's a long list of other things.
And we've learned that information by meeting with Center for HIV Law and Policy. And so,
also for discrimination, looking at things such as how housing and employment as well.
Some of our priorities have been hearing community feedback on molecular surveillance
data and monitoring legislation related to HIV criminalization and data protection. Before today,
I thought I had it all figured out, but there was a presentation this morning from Whitman
Walker Institute that gave insight, that there has been some update on data protection. And so,
we're going to take the information that we received this morning,
reassess what we want to do, and then come back together as a workgroup and then a subcommittee.
But before this morning's presentation, one of the short-term goals was to present a resolution
or a letter or a document -- we're still trying to figure out all of those things -- around data
protection at our next PACHA meeting. Again, I want to reassess the information that we received
this morning to see if that is something that is still needed. We also -- one of our
short-term goals is to review the most recent CDC NOFO that mentions molecular surveillance.
After recommendations from this body,
we have found out that the CDC is still doing what the CDC is still going to do. And so,
we're trying to assess in our workgroup as well as in our subcommittee our best path forward. And so,
what we're doing at our next workgroup meeting on June 18th is review as a workgroup. Because
we understand we have new members as well as seasoned members. And so, we want to
catch everybody up on what has been done in this group and what can we do in the future.
A long-term goal would be for the CDC to release a letter to district attorneys around
HIV criminalization. And our overarching goal is to continue to hear from community and people
living with HIV networks, about surveillance. I do want to provide an update on the networks
that we have met with and the community groups that we have met with. On March 13th,
we met with the U.S. People Living with HIV Caucus. We met with the CDC. And PACHA Dr.
Leo and myself met with them as listening individuals around molecular surveillance.
On March 19th, we had a presentation provided to our workgroup from the Center for HIV Law
and Policy. And on April 16th, we met with Drew Gibson from AIDS United to hear about the work
that the Public Policy committee has been doing around criminalization as well. And so, we're
taking all of that information, compiling it, and determining the best path forward as a work group.
>> Raniyah Copeland: Thank you so much. You all see, these workgroup leads are working very,
very, very hard. And I think the thing that I would ask, particularly from community,
from folks who are leaders in the HIV workforce, when you think about the
Stigma and Disparities priorities, particularly when it comes to stigma disruption, PrEP and PEP,
and then surveillance and disparities -- no, criminalization, criminalization,
discrimination -- that if there are things that you think we're missing, to let us know, to reach
out to us, to reach out to HHS. Because we'd love to include additional priorities or galvanize on
things that are already happening in community to have some type of impact. So, thank you, guys.
>> Marlene McNeese: Outstanding and exactly what we were hoping for,
from having space and opportunity to have this conversation, both in subcommittee,
but also with the ability for other PACHA members and our other federal
colleagues to understand and hear some of the priorities coming up and being lifted up from
the workgroup is also equally important. So, thank you for getting us started,
Stigma and Disparities. We will now move on to Aging with HIV, Long-term and Lifetime Survivors.
>> Jesse Milan: Thank you. Our committee met over lunch, and we reviewed the priorities that
the co-chairs created at the co-chairs meeting after the Houston PACHA Council meeting. And so,
we reviewed those, and we've identified what are the best priorities for us to look at for the
short term. And for us, the short term means between now and the August meeting of PACHA.
So, we've identified three things that we are going to work on. Two of them are slightly
longer. One of them is more immediate for consideration for today. The two that are
slightly longer are we will be developing a resolution for PACHA to authorize -- to
recommend to the Secretary that he do an audit of all the state aging plans to identify
how people living with HIV have been incorporated into the state aging plans.
And that would be a very important document for our community because it would be able
to look at how different states have actually done something with regard to people with HIV
and whether there are some best practices that other states need to be aware of. So,
that audit of all the states is a recommendation we will be bringing to you in August.
The second is that we have had so much excitement in our committee from what we've
learned from the Agency on Community Living, the ACL, with regard to their SHIP program,
which provides one-on-one counseling to people who are either current Medicare beneficiaries
or future Medicare beneficiaries. So, we're going to be looking over the next several months about a
resolution urging that the Secretary consider the -- using or adapting the SHIP program to
include a special offering for people living with HIV to use that as a mechanism for giving them
guidance and support for their transition from private insurance or no insurance to Medicare.
So, we will be crafting that resolution for your consideration in August. And the
resolution is likely to consider whether the SHIP program itself or another program should
be created. That could be the Technical Assistance Center for people living with
HIV. Those are the two that we are looking at in the short term between now and August.
For today, we have -- we should all be aware that the current Older Americans Act is up for
reauthorization at the end of this fiscal year, which is September 30th. Currently, this current
administration issued a rule through ACL that made it -- that identified people living with HIV as a
population of greatest social need. That rule is under the current legislation, but the current
legislation expires on September 30th. And so, the community of people living with HIV who are
aging have been advocating for including in the reauthorization that people who are older adults
living with HIV be included in the new legislation as a population of greatest social need.
So, we are going to recommend today that the co-chairs be authorized to send a letter to
the Secretary urging him to make, as an immediate legislative priority for HHS,
adding older adults living with HIV as a population of greatest social
need in the reauthorization of the Older Americans Act and that the subcommittee on
HIV and Aging and Long-Term and Lifetime Survivors be tasked to write that letter
for the co-chairs for its dispatch to the Secretary by the August meeting of PACHA.
>> Marlene McNeese: The only friendly amendment I would add is that the draft language be allowed to
have a level of review by full PACHA members and then if so agreed, be taken upon us as
co-chairs to follow through with that submission action, so just adding in a PACHA member review.
>> Jesse Milan: Accepted [laughs].
>> Marlene McNeese: I see a question. Go ahead, Raniyah.
>> Raniyah Copeland: Maybe a question and a comment. Do you think it would be useful to
specify all people who are older and aging with HIV, or can we add specifically, like,
certain races and ethnicities and genders that you want to call out?
>> Jesse Milan: The aging community has generally been thinking of all people who are within the
age range of the Older Americans Act, with no specificity with regard to race or age.
>> Raniyah Copeland: Do you see differences, though, when it comes to race and ethnicity?
>> Jesse Milan: Well, it's my understanding,
there most certainly are, but I don't know whether we can add that in this language,
that people of certain race or ages or racial backgrounds be a subgroup of additional people
with special needs. It's a possibility. We could. Would you like us to look at that?
>> Raniyah Copeland: I would. I think being able to be very specific about what communities need
allow for specific support so that you aren't advancing disparities, right? I think -- because
I think that's what we do unintentionally when we aren't being very specific.
>> Jesse Milan: I think we can add to that in the letter to the Secretary because of
the disparities, particularly by race and -- yes.
>> Vincent Guilamo-Ramos: So, Jesse, just one comment, and it's not in any way to
discourage the group. Because I think this is work that is fantastic and amazing. And
I appreciate the specificity as well as the specific actionable next step. But I
think what just happened is a good example of why, when we move these ideas forward,
that we need to have some process within PACHA from subcommittee and then some socialization
to the larger body. Because while many of us may agree, there may be nuance
that has to be built in. And probably that's work that should happen before we move it to
the meeting. And so, I think Marlene kind of offered a friendly amendment. I think,
Raniyah, you gave us a terrific example. So, thanks to both of you for that.
>> Marlene McNeese: I think it was Carole. And then we'll
turn the floor over to our colleague from ACL.
>> Carole Treston: Just a point of clarification, and I may not be fully informed here. I'm not
fully informed here [laughs]. But isn't the Older Americans Act of Congress?
>> Jesse Milan: Yes.
>> Carole Treston: And so, asking the Secretary to do
something that -- I guess I don't understand what you're -- what --
>> Jesse Milan: We're asking the Secretary to make it a legislative priority for HHS.
Because his legislative office does provide input to Congress on behalf of the agency.
>> Marlene McNeese: Go ahead. The floor is yours.
>> Andrea Callow: Yes. Hi. Thank you. So, these are, you know -- first, we appreciate
your attention to our programs. They are a foundation of aging services in the United States,
and they are there for people aging with HIV and all older adults. I will take your
suggestions or your draft recommendations back to the assistant secretary for Aging who heads
the Administration for Aging. I'll also talk to the administrator of ACL, Alison Barkoff.
Between now and August, we really would encourage you to come to us and avail
yourself of the technical knowledge we have about our programs and how you can really
make these recommendations work in a real-life, sort of tangible way. So,
for example, the regulations just came out. We have our grantees coming into compliance with
the regulations. They're all revising their state plans. It's happening on different timing cycles
for certain states, depending on their need. So, doing an analysis of all the state plans
right now might not make sense because they're all, basically, for lack of a better word,
being thrown up in the air and being changed. So, that's something we might want to think about.
It doesn't mean we can't do anything around the state plans, but an analysis of state plans just
might not make sense from a timing perspective. So, that's just one example. Like I said,
I think there are a lot of conversations we could have between now and August to come up with some
really trenchant, effective recommendations for Older Americans Act programs and ACL programs.
>> Jesse Milan: That's terrific. Thank you.
>> Andrea Callow: Thank you.
>> Marlene McNeese: Yes. And I would add, it may be excellent if we can align the timing to have a
very specific aging subcommittee conversation with ACL about exactly what you're just describing,
what makes the most sense, what should we be aware of? And then it really best informs the
way PACHA may want to move forward or proceed in a process. So, thank you for that offering.
It's exactly what Vincent and I were hoping to achieve with the subcommittee report outs,
but also guidance and direction about how do we move forward with some of these
strategic priorities over the next couple of months? So, thank you. And I see, Guillermo.
>> Guillermo Chacon: First of all, congratulations to that recommendation,
to that subcommittee. I only want to add that the urgency for timing as U.S. state,
number one and number two, that I think would be -- my recommendation to you to move a resolution,
I mean, a vote of support of this initiative, just because PACHA is only -- can support when we are
all together. The next meeting is in October. And then I will strongly recommend for you to
consider to ask for a vote of support of we as -- together on that initiative. Thank you.
>> Jesse Milan: Yes.
>> Marlene McNeese: Thank you. And just a point of clarification, Guillermo pushed us all the
way to October. We're actually scheduled to tentatively meet for August, as well as December,
so soon, actually. So, urgency. I get your point about that. And so, Jesse and Alicia,
I don't want to move forward if you have any other priorities or closing comments.
>> Jesse Milan: Those are our three short-term priorities. But inviting
ACL to our next meeting, which is to be scheduled in June or early July,
we're all about that. I think it would be fantastic. Fantastic. But
the Older Americans Act is expiring on September 30th, whether we meet or not.
And so, your amendment that this letter be reviewed by the co-chairs and PACHA so that
it can go out as quickly as possible prior to reauthorization deadline, I think makes sense.
>> Marlene McNeese: All right. Thank you. And we will move on to Ending
the HIV Epidemic subcommittee, Guillermo and Tori.
>> Guillermo Chacon: Yes. On behalf of Tori Cooper and yours truly and the subcommittees
that are here attending this meeting, Ending the HIV Epidemic wants to quickly update that
we established a month or less than a month, I think, ago, a month and a half,
a workgroup that will focus on workforce. They will be co-led by Dr. Tookes and Duvia Lozano,
and both will begin to craft and focus. And we will report at the
August meeting their breakdown following this new outline that was shared to date.
In terms of the focus of the Ending the HIV Epidemic, will be to monitor closely
the implementation of Ending the HIV Epidemic from the length of addressing
inequities in the Southern region. In terms of priorities -- and this is a work in progress,
by the way. Because we ran out of time, to be very honest with you. In terms of priorities,
an action item will focus on addressing some recommendations on the type of action to
address inequities. And we appreciate yesterday's presentation by HRSA that highlight that. That
was the only presentation that highlighted that. And we appreciate very much that.
The second priority is to invite a couple of key presentations at the upcoming August meeting
of a national report that will be released shortly, sometimes in the next -- very soon,
to learn about the update of the National Hispanic Latinx Health Leadership Summit
and to request CDC to present some data on the home testing as the three areas
that we believe we will be recommending to the co-chairs to consider for the August meeting.
The third priority is to support the working recommendations that the workgroup,
Focus on Workforce, will put forward and that touch across the board. Because obviously, we
have been debating as PACHA, how concerned we are on the stage -- the current state, I'm sorry, of
the public health workforce. In terms of goals and dates, we will be putting attention in the next --
between now and -- between August and the December meeting, to present a resolution or a letter -- we
will debate in our next meeting -- on strategies to address inequities on ending the HIV epidemic.
We will be also presenting some initiative or recommendations on stigma reduction,
focus on addressing the challenges that we see not only on language, but also specific on homophobia
and transphobia, in a potential letter to the Secretary on actions items to be implemented
between 2025 and 2030. Let me pause and ask any member of the subcommittee if I missed something
in my report. Any questions from other PACHA members? Great. Thank you. Work in progress.
>> Marlene McNeese: Thank you, Guillermo and Tori. And now, we will close out with our last
subcommittee, but certainly not least, Global Updates from Jen Kates and Patrick Sullivan.
>> Patrick Sullivan: Thank you. I'll share our discussions on behalf of Jen and our
subcommittee members. So, our focus is really kind of twofold. One is to try to connect the
global and the U.S. epidemics and to try and shape how we think about the U.S. as part of the global
epidemic and what the implications of that are for our own response. And the second is to be
a source of information for PACHA members about, particularly PEPFAR and the U.S. global response.
I think in our role as PACHA members, we -- even if we work largely domestically,
we get asked about everything [laughs]. And so, I know for myself, I would usually text Jen,
but so that we all have a shared base of information and can sort of speak to that.
I do think that although our focus is clearly on the domestic response,
we are part of the global epidemic, and I think we need to be able to provide information.
So, in terms of our priorities, our two priorities are to raise awareness on PACHA
about the global response and its components; and by the relationships that that we have,
that our subcommittee members have, and that all of you have, identify and share
innovative models and interventions so that we're, you know, learning humbly from what is
going on in other places and asking how, you know, that might benefit our own response.
In terms of goals and dates, our short-term goals. By the end of the year, Jen is going to facilitate
a PEPFAR 101 at the August meeting -- it's part of the August meeting -- that will just sort of
help provide a base level of knowledge for all of us. Although Jen's base level of knowledge will be
a lot of things I didn't know about. But so that we all have a common starting point about PEPFAR.
And then at the IAS meeting, we want to do a couple of things. One is just to
take advantage of the HHS.gov colleagues that are there. And as we see things,
try and have a low threshold for, you know, getting in touch with that team. Doing a quick,
you know, summary of something that we heard. I think we'll talk some more about and figure
out who's going to IAS, but we're happy to coordinate that. But I think the things that
you see and hear for those that go are important and just thinking about what we want to share.
We're still a little -- I think we've taken a step back from being so definitive about poster walks,
but I still like the idea of at least flagging presentations that we think
are important or might inform our U.S. response. And we could share those in
some way through social media. Or if the logistics aren't too complicated,
we could do something kind of informally to get people to walk around to those.
In the long term, sort of identifying and sharing innovations from global partners and providing
examples to PACHA members, either at meetings or even in between. And I think -- my thought is that
we don't want to have such a high threshold that we need to save up for six months and then have a
45-minute PowerPoint presentation. But are there ways that we can sort of share more in real time,
things that are innovative globally that we want people to be aware of and think
about how we might learn from that? And so, I think those are our main priorities. And
we've got a bunch of other little notes, but I think that's most of it. Anything to add?
>> Jennifer Kates: No, thanks. That's great. One thing I would add is since
we're trying to prepare some kind of educational session for all of you
in August, which is not that long, far away, if anyone has any particular -- like,
we're trying to decide the scope. And right now, what we've thought of is focusing on the
U.S. government's global response to HIV, which is primarily PEPFAR, but not only. So, we wanted
to capture all of that. If there are specific questions or issues that people are really
interested in and you think have a moment to email us, that would just be helpful. Thank you.
>> Marlene McNeese: Any questions for
Patrick or Jen? Just want to say you get a thumbs up from Jesse. So, that's saying something.
[laughter]
And I just want to say thank you for being so responsive. I know that there have been several
members asking to understand more about the federal work in the global space. And so, I do
think that is responsive in the idea of providing around the clock sort of updates year-round of
important advancements and interventions that are showing some success in other places,
would absolutely help us not only understand that, but be able to dissect and potentially
disseminate what might be helpful in our own local domestic responses. So, thank you for those ideas.
All right. We are at the place in our meeting where we sort of have
room built for any opportunity for member and/or federal partner conversation or
close-out reflection of the meeting. This also is open to anyone around the table who
is so inclined to have anything else to add before we close out. Anyone? Go ahead, Vince.
>> Vincent Guilamo-Ramos: So, just a few brief comments. I think, as I was pondering over the
last few days, what really came forward in my mind was that we have many terrific plans. And
I think the reality is that the work remains around the implementation of those plans. One
of the profound experiences of this past meeting, and I also felt this way in Houston and at many
of the PACHA meetings, was that we continue to demonstrate that there are inequities and that
those inequities continue to impact populations, that depending upon who's on PACHA, depending upon
the voices that are around this table, some of those get lifted up, and others don't, but that we
need to continuously ask for data that reflects the inequities as a way of guiding the work.
And so, I also want to say publicly to Dr. Cheever that your presentation was so powerful. Because
it was the only one that I recall at this meeting that really highlighted progress,
but also showed where there had been inequity and then also the strategic efforts to address
those inequities. And I think those kinds of data are particularly useful for PACHA.
I want to say that at times during the meeting, I felt a kind of sadness. And so, I'm opening
up here a little bit about some of what was shared. And I'm not going to focus on
the Latino community. I think you guys heard me yesterday, elevate the Latino community. But I
want to focus on Indian health service. And I'm looking at Rick because, Rick, for four years,
since I've been on PACHA, I've experienced you as coming into all the meetings. Generally,
you're always here and really reporting on the progress, really reporting on the sort of
monumental efforts, also being optimistic and hopeful. But I've heard a lingering message,
and this is my interpretation. I don't know if this is how you feel. But the
interpretation that I've had is the structural under-resourcing of the Indian health service.
And so, I'm intentionally bringing this forward not because I want to add to the list, again,
another population that we should focus on, but just as a way of saying that, collectively,
our work must be around looking critically at the inequities. And I hope that that is
something that this group will carry forward because I think it really matters. And, Rick,
in your case, you know, I've sort of thought privately, which I'm now sharing publicly,
have we done enough to elevate the work that needs to happen in Indian
country and just want to flag that for the -- you know, for PACHA as a whole.
I was also struck by this disconnect between our policies and science. And I think that came up a
couple of times. Director Ruiz brought that up in his comments. But how important that
is. We had recently an outbreak, a reported outbreak in Shelby County. And I think a lot
of what I see as being unique about that context is the extent to which policies
and laws are really negatively impacting the jurisdiction and have a real impact. We got
that from Dr. Breyer today. I mean, there's sort of compelling evidence that that is happening.
I'm going to wrap up in a second, but I want to just hit two or three more quick things. One,
Patrick, thank you for the indicators. Because I think that kind of thinking
about novel approaches to how we can really hold ourselves accountable and really measure
our progress in terms of what we're doing as a nation, we need that. And I think that we
are looking for more guidance on how we can do that and incorporate that information.
I really love what I see happening on PACHA in terms of the energy,
the ideas, the interests in advancing specific actions. And I was really proud of, Marlene,
what Caroline and you and I and others developed, which is really that set of very specific actions
and ways in which the work can move forward. And I'm looking forward to having more opportunities
over the next couple of months to work with some of the subcommittees. Marlene has tasked me,
as sort of my departing assignment, to work with some of the subcommittees around getting
very clear about ways to move things forward so that we can be effective,
and we can actually have our work have meaning for what we all are here to do.
The last thing I'll say is I just want to say thank you. I've been in PACHA for four years.
This is my last public meeting. I will be staying on through August. And I've gotten my assignment,
which Marlene has given me. So, I'm definitely going to do that. But I have grown professionally
and personally, and I've enjoyed very much working with folks in
the federal government. I have a deep respect for what you guys do
and for the ways that you are leveraging your unique positions to try to end HIV.
I have also a profound respect for the people that have been on PACHA and that currently are
on Pacha. Because you guys are my inspiration, and I feel honored to know you all and to be
part of this group. And so, with that, I'm going to say thank you very much and special shout-out
to Marlene who has mentored me and been a great role model. So, thank you very much.
>> Marlene McNeese: And, of course, I'd be remiss if I didn't thank Vincent for
his leadership. In the time that we've been able to share co-chairship together,
I have really been impressed by your passion for bringing the science of the work that we
do in line with implementation. So, I do appreciate your commitment to
making sure that our efforts are evidence based, that they're informed by the data,
as I keep saying all day, both quantitatively and qualitatively.
But your focus and expertise has not gone unnoticed. And I think that influence,
I will do my best to carry that forward as the leadership of PACHA. Because that
is important for the work that we do. So, thank you to Vincent,
and if we could all -- if you would join me in giving him a round of applause for his service.
And I do want to give opportunity, before we officially close -- I don't see anyone
clamoring for the microphone. That means you are all done done. But I wanted to offer
our Executive Director, Miss Caroline Talev, if she has any closing remarks.
>> Caroline Talev: Thank you, Marlene, and everyone. This is my first meeting as
executive director, and it is a privilege beyond words that I have right now. So,
I want to say thank you to our co-chairs, Vincent and Marlene, and particularly Vincent, for -- I
know this is your last public meeting. And so, we still have a few more months to process. So, I'll
do that [laughs] with some time. But just want to thank you and thank you both for your leadership.
I want to thank our federal partners who continue to grow with PACHA, who participate
not just in the full council meetings, but the subcommittees and ongoing. And so,
we believe that our federal partnership is very strong, and we're really grateful
for your involvement. And to thank our PACHA OIDP team that continues to grow.
We have our new alternative DFO, Tim Harrison. Chloe Loving, who is a part of
our team. We'd be lost without her. And Emily Downes, [unintelligible], Stephanie Tiller,
and Damon and Dana who does our notes. And so, just all of the work that's done, we couldn't do
it without everyone. Oh, and Miguel Gomez from HIV.gov and his team. And so, just wanted to
thank everyone that can make it happen. And to our PACHA members, the work continues. And so,
with that, safe travels home and then lots of emails coming your way [laughs]. Thank you.
