The Mystery That Led to 3 Nobel Prizes in Physics (Including Einstein's)

Scientists won the Nobel Prize
12 followers
In 1887, German physicist Heinrich Hertz was conducting experiments to prove James Clerk
Maxwell's equations of electromagnetism when he noticed something peculiar.
Hertz had placed two electrodes at a distance from each other to generate electric sparks
between them so he could detect an electromagnetic field.
To get a better look at the spark, he placed the receiver in a dark case, but an unintended
effect happened as a result of this.
The maximum spark length in the receiver was smaller than it was outside of the dark box,
and after taking apart the case piece by piece, he found that the side of the box that separated
the transmitter from the receiver was the determining factor in the phenomenon.
Upon noticing this, Hertz tried different materials to test the effects on the receiver.
He found that using a glass box shielded the spark, but using a box made of quartz allowed
the spark to transmit.
He used this information to then use a quartz prism to break up the light coming from the
transmitter, and from this he found that the wavelength of light responsible for more powerful
sparks came from the ultraviolet.
Hertz didn't do more research on this strange phenomenon after he discovered it, however,
so more advancements came from other minds in the coming years, such as Wilhelm Hallwax,
Philip Leonard, and J.J.
Thompson.
This phenomenon came to later be known as the photoelectric effect, and would be described
as light at or above a certain frequency hitting electrons and causing them to fly off the
material they previously existed on and send them through the air.
Philip Leonard was arguably the biggest pioneer in experimentally demonstrating this effect,
using cathode rays to show that it was purely determined by the light's frequency and not
by its intensity.
But the reason this effect was so intriguing is because it contradicted the classical laws
of physics established by Newton, Hooke, and Huygens centuries earlier.
Previous experiments, such as the famous double-slit experiment in 1801, had led scientists to
believe that the light was purely a wave and therefore should always act as such through
classical wave theory.
However, the photoelectric effect was a direct experimental contradiction to this theory
in two key ways.
The first was that, according to classical wave theory, the energy from a light wave
is uniformly distributed and dependent solely on its intensity, meaning that the kinetic
energy of the so-called photoelectrons should increase as the intensity of light also increases.
However, Leonard showed that the kinetic energy varies based on the frequency of light and
not on its intensity, and thus we have our first contradiction.
The second was that, according to classical wave theory, any frequency of light should
be capable of ejecting photoelectrons.
Hertz and Leonard showed, however, that there was a certain frequency of light that caused
these ejections and that it existed in the ultraviolet, and anything below the ultraviolet
would not cause this effect, and thus we have our second contradiction.
Leonard won the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1905 for his work with cathode rays that led
to these advancements in the photoelectric effect.
That same year, a new up-and-coming scientist, Albert Einstein, published a paper in which
he proposed a new revolutionary idea that would fundamentally rewrite the nature of
light and explain the confounding photoelectric effect.
Einstein's explanation for this phenomenon was that light does not just exist as a wave,
but also as a particle, or a discrete energy packet, with its energy depending solely on
its frequency.
Einstein used an equation derived by Max Planck in 1900 to describe this.
He made a bold move by endorsing Planck's turbulent new theories to describe blackbody
radiation, but it was a move that would surely pay off in the coming years.
To explain the photoelectric effect with light as a particle, Einstein postulated that so-called
photons collide with photoelectrons and transfer energy to them in two forms.
The first form of energy is that which is required to eject the electron from the atoms
they exist in, which he called the work function.
The rest of the energy transferred is in the form of the kinetic energy of the photoelectron
as it travels freely through the air.
Using this relationship for energy along with Planck's previously established relationship
for energy, Einstein was able to do two key things.
The first was establish a theoretical value for the threshold frequency, denoted experimentally
previously by Lennard, and define it as equivalent to the work function of the atom.
The second key factor in Einstein's explanation was determining the maximum kinetic energy
a photoelectron can achieve during a mission.
Using his previously established relationship for the work function, he reached a relationship
between the maximum kinetic energy of a photoelectron and the photon's frequency, incorporating
Planck's constant and thus explaining the effect with quantum physics.
These equations formulated by Einstein in 1905 turned out to be a great way to experimentally
calculate the value of Planck's constant, and such was done with extreme precision later
in 1916 by Robert Millikan.
Millikan, ironically, was motivated by proving Einstein wrong in his particle theory of light
and believed that the only reason the photoelectric effect was happening was due to the apparently
flawed experimental setups previously done by Lennard and others.
Millikan in his quest unexpectedly proved Einstein and others further correct through
his ingenious setup which involved a rotating plane of three different metals in a near
perfect vacuum chamber.
A blade would constantly clean the metals as they rotated and the metals would take
turns being exposed to UV light.
Upon seeing that the photoelectric effect still occurred in his setup, he used a previously
established relationship by Lennard, Einstein's equations, and his previously calculated charge
of the electron to solve for Planck's constant.
His calculations were so precise, in fact, that his calculated value for the constant
is still within 0.7% of today's currently accepted value.
Even after all this experimental evidence, however, Millikan stood firm in his beliefs,
swearing that Einstein was still incorrect, but through means that they did not yet understand.
Millikan's thoughts can be summarized through one of his quotes.
Einstein's photoelectric equation cannot in any judgment be looked upon at present as
resting upon any sort of satisfactory theoretical foundation, even though it actually represents
very accurately the behavior of the photoelectric effect.
Three Nobel Prizes were handed out throughout the course of the photoelectric effect saga.
Lennard in 1905 for his experimental contributions, Einstein in 1921 for his theoretical explanation,
and Millikan in 1923 for his experimental validation of Einstein's theories.
Alongside blackbody radiation, the photoelectric effect was thought to be one of the final
mysteries of physics during the turn of the 20th century, but upon the discoveries made
by these brilliant scientists in both topics, an entirely new world was opened up, and the
quest for truth continued into the depths of the quantum realm.
If you enjoyed this video, please consider liking and subscribing.
Click here if you want to see more scientific progress made during this time period.
Thank you for watching, and I will see you in the next video.
