99 Video Views·Oct 15, 2024
🔵 Sign up for the American Thought Leaders ALERTS newsletter to stay up-to-date on new episodes, releases, and special events 👉 https://ept.ms/ATLnewsletter
This is the TV version of Jan Jekielek’s interview with James Burling. The longer-form version was released on Epoch TV on October 1, 2024.
James Burling is vice president of legal affairs at the Pacific Legal Foundation and author of “Nowhere to Live: The Hidden Story of America’s Housing Crisis.”
“It used to be, if you could build on your property, you could farm on your property. You could cut trees on your property, as long as you didn’t hurt your neighbors. And now the federal government, the state government, local governments, are your partners in anything you do to your property. You can’t do anything. You can’t say ‘boo’ without getting permits from somebody. And with that kind of impediment, a lot of people who would otherwise build homes said, ‘I’m going to do something else with my money,” says Burling.
What are the root causes of the apparent shortage of housing in America today? And why does Burling believe many housing-related proposals, from subsidies, to certain zoning rules, to rent controls, are actually counterproductive?
“The idea of having national rent control, as has been proposed by some people, is going to make a problem that is confined to the cities with rent control into a national problem. And it’s been a disaster wherever it’s been tried,” says Burling. “We start taking away property rights, and then it becomes easier for the government to control us. If the government owns the printing presses, are you going to have a free press? If the government owns the churches, do you have freedom of religion? If the government owns interests in housing everywhere, and you have to get government permission to have a home or to build a home, are you going to be as willing to criticize the government that has the power over you of where you’re going to live?”
CHAPTER HEADERS
[0:00:01 - 0:00:56] The Housing Crisis and Permit Requirements
[0:01:04 - 0:03:51] Impact of Housing Subsidies
[0:04:08 - 0:11:04] Historical Context of Zoning Laws
[0:11:27 - 0:19:54] James Burling's Background and Significant Cases
[0:20:10 - 0:22:46] Balancing Environmental Regulations and Housing Affordability
💛 Support us 👉https://donorbox.org/american-thought-leaders
-------------------------------------------------
© All Rights Reserved.
it used to be if you could build on your
property you could Farm on your property
you could cut trees on your property as
long as you didn't hurt your neighbors
you can't do anything without getting
permits from somebody and with that kind
of impediment a lot of people who'
otherwise build homes said I'm going do
something else with my money James
Burling is Vice President of legal
Affairs at the Pacific Legal Foundation
an author of nowhere to live the hidden
story of America's housing crisis what
are the root causes of the apparent
shortage of housing in America today and
why does Berling believe many housing
related proposals from subsidies to
certain zoning roles to rent controls
are actually counterproductive the idea
of having National rent control as has
been proposed by some people is going to
make a problem that is confined to the
city into a national problem and it's
been a disaster wherever it's been tried
this is American thought leaders and I'm
y Kell
James Burling such a pleasure to have
you on American thought leaders it's
great to be here so as we're filming uh
the first uh presidential debate just
happened and vice president Harris
mentioned uh
$25,000 subsidy for housing for new home
buyers so and this is I guess tells us
that there is some kind of issue in
society as you've been saying there's a
crisis and I've been wondering is there
really a crisis but apparently there is
something going on so tell me what is
happening it's a huge issue people can
no longer afford the way they used to to
rent or to buy a new home it used to be
the rule of thumb whether you spend a
third of your income on housing many
many people today are spending over half
of their income on housing which leaves
little left for medical costs for
transportation food and the other
Essentials of life and we've gotten
ourselves into this problem gradually
slowly but clearly we're in a
uh that's a century in building a bad
government policy after bad government
policy just making things worse and
worse and now we've hit the boiling
point well I I I want to dig into that
like just kind of the whole picture that
you that you develop in your book before
we go there let's talk about some of
these policies that are being put on the
table recently like for example this uh
this subsidy to get for new home uh
buyers a subsidy is generally a terrible
idea in the short term and especially in
the long term it's a terrible idea in
the short term because all it does is
shovel more money into a sector of the
economy without necessarily increasing
Supply and so when you shovel more money
into a sector of the economy that
doesn't increase Supply you have
increasing costs costs are inevitably
inevitably going to be going up if
people are given $25,000 for their first
know down payment if that happens people
will start raising prices to take that
into a consideration that hey there's an
extra
$25,000 we can raise the cost of homes
to by a commensurate amount in addition
a longer term problem is once you start
a subsidy like this it's virtually
impossible to get rid of these subsidies
later on even if you find out that you
can't afford it I mean this
$25,000 per person for a new home is
estimated to cost in the next 10 years
at least hundred billion that's $ 1010
billion a year that's a lot of money
where's the money going to come from
it's going to come from you and I the
taxpayers and as a result all other
costs are going to go up as well there's
no such thing as free money and so I'm
very concerned that proposals like this
is also just going to bankrupt part of
the economy and cause prices to go up
you know these are typically uh
described as kind of stop Gap measures
at a time when people are having
difficulty to support them right like
you can imagine from the perspective of
the buyer hey if I have a little bit of
money right a little bit more money to
buy a home maybe I can actually do that
yeah I have all kinds of Sympathy for
the home buyer trying to buy their first
home I mean it is very very difficult
but stop Gap measures are never stop Gap
as I alluded to a moment ago they last
forever and second of all it's not
solving the problem of Supply it's just
having more money chase the same number
of homes that there was before four and
supply and demand is an inexorable law
and you can't overturn it I mean people
have tried North Korea's tried to
overturn it Venezuela's tried to
overturn it and even the California
legislator has tried to overturn the law
of supply and demand it just doesn't
happen you know it strikes me that there
is a model uh of this kind of happening
I guess when it comes to you know the
cost of education is that would you
would you say that's it's a very good
it's a very good analogy because higher
education what we saw is the Government
Federal Government shoveling all kinds
of money into higher education and as a
result universities and colleges started
on spending spree where there used to be
dormitories or now these castles these
luxury residences that people can't
afford before they go to college and
can't afford afterwards but when they're
in college they're in the lap of luxury
and after a while the government funding
starts to dry up a little bit so you
have all kind of student loans but the
price of tuition has gone up and up and
up in universities and colleges far
faster than the rate of inflation and
this is because you have so much money
washing around from the federal
government in the process as soon as the
you know there's any kind of fiscal
issue the students have to pay back the
student loans which is increasingly
difficult so then the taxpayers are
supposed to come in and subsidize this
process even more directly than they
were before this does doesn't solve the
problem of the quality of Education it
doesn't solve the problem of
availability of Education all this money
just increases the cost of the education
we have and if nothing else it makes it
worse because now on our University
campuses we not only have professors and
a few administrators we have an army of
bureaucrats overseeing the
federalization of higher education the
same thing is going to be in housing if
you start putting all kinds of money in
it whether it's $225,000 or new home
buyers or the other proposal to have $40
billion for subsidies for home builders
all this money washing around is going
to create great distortions to the
market and it's going to be increasingly
difficult for the ordinary Joe to go out
and find a home that here or Josephine
can afford well so let's uh shift gears
a tiny bit and just talk about some
other policies that are in discussion
right now one of them is uh you know
challenges to the single family zoning
policies so H what do you think about
that I think that we need to rethink our
zoning laws this is one of the things I
talk about in great length in my book
nowhere to live because zoning started
out in America on a
very dark side of first zoning law in
America came in 1910 in Baltimore when
George McAn a y educated attorney and
his school teacher wife decided to buy a
home commensurate with their success in
life as an attorney and a school teacher
George mcmechen bought a home in
Baltimore in a very nice neighborhood
called Utah place within several days of
buying that home local youth came to his
property and essentially rioted taking
rocks and throwing them and destroying
and cutting down every window in the
house and the Skylight why they were
insense that George mcmean had bought
this house because George mcmechen was
all black and the neighborhood was all
white Baltimore more soon followed up
with the nation's first zoning law that
made it a crime for a black person to
move into a white neighborhood or uh
subject him to a fine of $3,000 in
America current dollars or a year in
jail uh this was the first zoning law we
had in America now the Supreme Court
struck down a very similar law that came
out of Louisville Kentucky in
1917 that case was U brought by a white
real estate dealer and the head of the
local NAACP and they argued this is a
violation of our property rights this is
a violation of our economic rights and
the court agreed so I think property
rights are very important now zoning
continued after that though in a
different form it was not racial zoning
but economic zoning which had pretty
much the same effect and by economic
zoning I mean you have areas of the city
that are laid out for residential and
others for businesses and N the twain
should meet but but also the residential
areas often excluded multif family
housing it excluded Apartments it
excluded triplexes duplexes and even
boarding homes and that made it
impossible for working class people to
live in the nice Suburban areas outside
of cities uket Ohio had a very had a
ordinance it was modeled on one out of
New York City the New York city
ordinance was designed to keep Jews from
having garment factories on Fifth Avenue
um it sounds awful but that's what it
was for and the one in uid Ohio was
designed to keep the immigrants out by
banning all apartments this went also to
the Supreme Court and here the Supreme
Court had a change of heart and the
Supreme Court said look uh apartment
buildings in a residential neighborhood
are nuisances they're kind of like a pig
in the Parlor instead of the Barnyard
now I don't know if the court was
thinking that the term Pig also meant a
Polish American at the time but clearly
the court was concerned about immigrants
and workingclass people moving into nice
Suburban neighborhoods like the members
of the Court lived in and it upheld that
ordinance ever since zoning single
family zoning has taken over in America
and it has made it virtually impossible
today especially that working class and
new families starting out can afford a
home in many many neighborhoods in this
country so when we talk about single
family zoning you have to think about
the history you have to think about what
it does today even if we no longer think
about zoning in terms of keeping out
workingclass people or keeping out
minorities that is the effect that it
has so people are talking about the need
to reform single family housing in in
various ways and it could be allowing
duplexes where there's single family
homes or triplexes or small apartments
there are lots of things that could be
done to make housing more accessible for
better zoning or elimination of bad
zoning in many cases uh we're going to
take a quick break right now James okay
and we'll be right
back and we're back with James Burling
author of nowhere to live the hidden
story of America's housing crisis well
you you seem to know an astonishing
amount about this and of course you know
there's a very much in your book but
tell me a little bit about your
background before we jump to some other
policies because uh you know this has
kind of been your life it has been my
life but I had a life before this if you
will I used to be before I was a lawyer
a productive member of society I like to
say I was an exploration geologist and I
climbed up and down Hills all over the
West looking for deposits of gold silver
miminum and copper and I thoroughly
enjoyed that but in that experience I
ran into a lot of bureaucrats Federal
bureaucrats in particular and I was
appalled by the power that they
exercised which was extra legal that is
they didn't have legal authority to tell
me what I should do it could and
couldn't do and I thought this is
ridiculous we should sue these people
well my boss in the mining company
didn't want to sue anybody and I said
well I'm going to go to law school so I
can fight bureaucrats and so I went to
law school uh and I have been fighting
bureaucrats for the last 40 years and
it's not only in mining or environmental
laws but all kinds of things dealing
with people trying to build homes and
being styed by all levels of Regulation
at the state and local and federal
levels what would be the most
significant case would you say for you
personally that you participated in
maybe let let's talk about one that you
that that you won and maybe one that you
didn't win so I'll talk about one that I
won first because then I hope we can
forget about the one that I lost are
ones that I've lost I've lost a number
of cases of course in 4 years it happens
but the most significant case that I had
was representing Anthony palazolo who
was a owner of a small wrecking yard and
tow truck operator and he had a little
bit of money that he set aside and he
bought about 20 acres of property in
Rhode Island along the coast uh not
right on the beach but on a big pond in
the area and his Hope was to develop
that property and he bought it as part
of his corporate ownership and he had a
little Corporation he's the only owner
under the corporation the so Corporation
and he tried to develop it year after
year after year eventually he said I'm
not going to try houses I'll do a beach
club just a parking lot some sh shade
structures and some bathrooms that
people can use and then the families
when the water is too rough in the ocean
they can come to the pond and enjoy
themselves Rhode Island turned down the
permit because in its words this was
going to advance a private interest
rather than a public interest now
Anthony palazolo was loaded for bear
because when he started having problems
with the state of Rhode Island he wrote
to the legal publishing company called
West and said send me everything you
have on property rights and they did and
he read it his son later would tell the
story you know when I was growing up my
f my friends parents they would talk to
their kids and their fathers about
football and baseball my father talked
to me about the Magna Carta and about
the Constitution and so when
sued saying that his property had been
taken for a public use without being
paid he thought he could win his case
and he had his own private attorney in
Rhode Island and he lost case after case
uh and eventually the RH Island Supreme
Court said look you've had this property
so long you you knew that there were
regulations in place and he knew the
regulations are getting H harsher and
harsher uh you you bought this property
or you you know knowing that this
regulatory scheme was in place out you
know next case please and we got to and
Anthony got together with us and uh I
took on the case and went to the US
Supreme Court with it and I Rhode Island
was arguing and it was a attorney
general Sheldon White House at the time
that argued the case of Rhode Island and
I argued that Anthony palazolo had the
same rights to sue for a regulatory
taking of his property as anybody
regardless of when he bought the
property in terms of when the
regulations went into place the rights
and property don't disappear with a
passage of time and the Supreme Court in
a five to4 decision agreed with us and
an opinion by Anthony Kennedy wrote that
you know future Generations too have the
same rights and property as the present
ones and they can sue so I think this is
critically important for the idea that
property rights really do not diminish
in time simply because you have more and
more
regulations so I I think these are the
sort of precedents that when I was when
I with Pacific Legal Foundation that
just really help a lot of people now you
asked about cases I lost you still want
to answer that ask that
question well know absolutely well it's
also interesting because I think in your
book this the erosion of property rights
is kind of the central theme I mean you
argue that that is the unifying
principle behind all the problems with
housing right AB absolutely because Time
After Time people have had the right to
use property taken away for various
reasons and another case that I have
it's kind of a heartbreaking case in
some way was representing OC Mills and
his son Carrie they had a small plot of
land outside of Pensacola Florida and
they wanted to build a little cabin
fishing cabin for his son and to do that
on this little you know quarter acre or
less lot he started putting sand on the
property EPA came out and said stop
you're filling wetlands and he thought
that was absurd because these lands were
dry what do you mean wet land well he
got another letter from the EPA saying
stop right now he stopped he went to the
state and said because he thought well
EPA there you know they're sharing the
same office building you know if I talk
to people in the state that I know
they'll come out and help me and they
did they came out and they actually drew
a line in the sand and said on this side
Wetland no touch this side you can
develop it so he began to bring in some
more sand and clearing the land the next
thing that he knew he was being arrested
and he thought this was so absurd he
could just go to court and tell his
story he didn't have an attorney when he
started out and he ended up losing his
case and he spent 18 months in federal
prison with his son because he filled a
wetland But the irony of this case is
after he got out of federal prison for
filling this Wetland he had to clear it
so he took the sand off and then the EPA
said you haven't taken enough off it's
not wet enough and he went back to court
this time he got a different he had an
attorney and a different judge this
judge went out to look at the property
and said yeah you've taken enough sand
off but really this is an Allison
Wonderland scenario this I don't think
this is wet L to begin with and you're
basically going to prison for putting
dry sand
on know clean dry sand on a Sandy
area and the judge thought that was
absurd so that's what I came into the
case trying to get his conviction
reversed because having the conviction
he had limits on his ability to hunt
with guns he had limits on his ability
to vote and all the other things that
felons uh Federal felons have you their
rights are forever limited and we tried
to get his conviction overturned on the
basis of what the second judge had found
and unfor fortunately the 11 circuit
court of appeal said it was too late he
should have brought these arguments
better uh in a better way when he was in
trial court the first time and it's too
late to overturn his conviction so that
was a disappointment but the key to
housing in this case is that you have
such power of the federal government
over individuals federal government can
say don't touch your own property don't
put anything on it not even clean sand
or you may go to prison that's a
terrible impediment for people to build
homes and it's a terrible incursion on
their private property rights it used to
be if you could build on your property
you could Farm on your property you
could cut trees on your property as long
as you didn't hurt your neighbors and
now the federal government the state
government local governments are your
partners in anything you do to your
property you can't do anything you can't
you know say boo without that getting
permits from somebody I guess the big
question is you know what was the
rationale in the development of all
these regulations I mean presumably it's
with you know population size increasing
and needing to you know protect uh you
know vulnerable habitat or things well
certainly we we developed an
environmental ethic in the 1970s and you
know it makes sense we have to start
paying attention to the environment we
live in and we have to protect it but
there has to be a balance in what we do
and this is something I argue in my book
that when we simply blindly take vast
areas of land off the table for
development whether it's for wetland
endangered species habitat vad corridors
agricultural uh preservation zones all
these things take very large amounts of
land off the table without considering
what is the impact on housing what is
the impact on affordability what is the
impact on future Generations who may
need this land for some purpose or other
if it's taken off the table under threat
of going to federal or state prison and
this is a balance that's been lost this
is the debate that we should be having
about well how much Environmental
Protection is enough and what are the
costs of environmental regulation people
used to think I think that it was free
you just regulate something and you
don't develop property and there's no
cost to society well you know there
should be payments to the people whose
land can't be used and that's one thing
we've argued for years at Pacific Legal
Foundation but there's also the social
cost of increase in price of housing
that has been a result of this and and
many other regulatory programs and so
you know what I argue in nowhere to live
the hidden story of America's housing
crisis is that we really need to
reconsider the regulatory oversight that
we have on home building to make it
easier for people to if they have land
and it's time that the Family Farm isn't
working out anymore because the
commodity prices have changed or the
city's growing up next to me that I
ought to have the ability of building
some homes on that property but that
right is diminished so much now that
people are not doing that and it's uh
causing a huge Distortion in the market
and increase in
prices um any final thoughts as we
finish James the crisis we're in and I
do think it's a crisis uh is something
that is not inevitably permanent we can
get out of it in the past we've had you
know waves of immigrants in the 19
Century we built our way out of the
housing crisis then we can do it again
but we have to focus on how the
regulations that are important but at
the same time recognize that too much
regulation just makes it impossible for
people to build the homes where people
want to live well James Burling it's
such a pleasure to have had you on the
show it's been my pleasure to be here
thank you all for joining James Burling
and me on this episode of American
thought leaders I'm your host y Kell
[Music]