It might seem odd to ask why New Zealand is an independent nation but in the late nineteenth century, its inclusion in Australia was seen as a certainty. Yet, as you'll know, it never joined the Commonwealth of Australia. But why? To find out watch this short and simple animated documentary.
A special thanks to all of these Patrons below, without whom the show wouldn't be possible:
Kevin Sanders Ian Jensen Mickey Landen Kevin Phoenix Richard Wolfe אורי פרקש Robert Brockway Can’t Think Of A Name Mr Sandman SirAlpaka Connor Glaze D. Mahlik Björnosaurus Porkmeister David archaeologist jdk anon sharpie660 Dragan Mcfeld Andreas Mosand Qi Xiao Ainar Garipov John Bisges Southside Mitch Wolf Rod D. Martin Dexter_McAaron Jeremy Ryan Haber Chris Fatta Adam Stalter Mantodea Andrew Niedbala Riley davidson John Garcia Andrew Patane Nathan Perlman Paul McGee Bernardo Santos Heytun SkyEye Yick Chung Tristan Kreller Mik Scheper Jane Sumpter Chris Dolan Christopher Godfrey Warren Rudkin Nicu Merge Prin Soare Robert Woodward Erik Martin Chris Hall Perry Gagne Joooooshhhhhh Danny Anstess Shaun Pullin Darnell Barbour Alen Magdalena Reinberg-Leibel bas mensink Henry Rabung Joshua A Bishop Caelen Hadwin Tsar Roman II Clay Carroll I'm Not In The Description Vilelmus_veliki William Wold Noremac_Cameron Gregory Priebe Joker 54 FF Nelly Chach Cap Mark Ploegstra Liam Gilleece Blake Dryad Craig Cunningham Sytze de Witte Ciege Engine JAY ALAN EDELMAN Luke Robinson Haydn Noble Jeffrey Schneider Kinfe85 Alteredcorgi Matthew O'Connor Chrisaztec TooMuchWaterYouDie Thomas Wang Spencer Smith Josh Cornelius Harley Raptopoulos Piotr Wojnowski The Roger Luna Colm Boyle HelloAgainThere Phillip Gathright Björn Wittmann Dakota Brunell Arthur Hosey Jr. Alex Adorno Colin Steele Serius_Loyola SmythProductions Konstantin Bredyuk Dennis the Cat Richard Manklow Franco La Bruna Donald Weaver Matthew Hogan mohd Liam Mahon Alan Romero Steve Bonds João Santos Christian S. Trenk Pierre Le Mouel Christine Purvis Seth Reeves
Sources:
A Concise History of Australia by Stuart Macintyre.
A Concise History of New Zealand by Philippa Mein Smith.
Breed, culture, and economy: The New Zealand frozen meat trade, 1880-1914 by Rebecca J. H. Woods
New Zealand, alongside being the current reigning champion of places that people forget to put on
maps, it's also an independent country. This independence did not occur through one single
event like that of the United States, but through a century-long process of reform.
And across this century, many were fairly sure that New Zealand would become a part of the
new Commonwealth of Australia, in the same way that Quebec was obviously going to be a part of
Canada, or how Bombay was obviously going to be a part of India. Yet, as you'll know, this never
happened. But why? Why isn't New Zealand a part of Australia? To begin, we have to go back to
those ancient days of pre-Australia, sometimes called the mid-19th century. At this point,
Australia wasn't one colony, but instead six, and they were, as far as the British were concerned,
a part of an eight-colony collective, the other two being Fiji, and of course New Zealand.
All of these colonies had different economies, different foreign interests,
and different cultures, which is why at first many were opposed to federalisation.
Things changed when Germany started eyeing up the region, which made those in the eight colonies
pretty nervous. And when the colony of New South Wales changed its mind about federalisation,
the other colonies now feared being left out, and thus, it was time to build an Australia.
For New Zealand, this being cut off was less of a problem. Whilst New South Wales, Tasmania,
Victoria, Queensland, South Australia, and the other one may have traded primarily with each
other, New Zealand traded mostly with Britain. There were other reasons for New Zealand rejecting
federation too. The first was the massive distance between itself and Australia,
which for reference is the same distance between Britain and Morocco. Another was that the drafting
of the documents for Australian federation were done by those who lived in Australia,
which might sound incredibly obvious, but New Zealand and Fiji weren't given an opportunity
to contribute much to the discussions, and thus they were largely seen as places that would be
added to Australia as opposed to a foundational part of it, which upset many New Zealanders who
wanted to be seen as equals. And this lack of consideration for New Zealand's distinction is
what mostly scuppered any chance of it being a part of Australia. You see, New Zealand had a
long and storied history between the island's indigenous people, the Maori, and the European
settlers, the Pakeha, and there were concerns that integration into Australia, a place not
highly rated on the kindness to the people already living there-o-meter, would mean that the Maori
would again be reduced to second class citizens and importantly violate the Treaty of Waitangi,
which as a result would lead to another war. There were fair reasons to believe this,
since the draft constitution explicitly stated that the indigenous people were to be ruled over
by the whites there, and New Zealand thus demanded that this not apply to them and that
they would refuse to join unless Australia amended its constitution, which it agreed to.
So why wasn't this enough? Well, it was mostly a concern by New Zealanders about the number of
Chinese and Asian workers in Australia, and particularly the potential that those workers
would head to New Zealand, which the leaders there really didn't want. And when Australia
federated in 1901, it was these combined reasons that saw New Zealand sit it out. Although there
is still a clause in the Australian constitution that allows New Zealand to join whenever it wants,
so the door is still open.
I hope you enjoyed this episode and thank you for watching, with a special thanks to my patrons
James Bizonette, Kelly Moneymaker, Anthony Beckett, The Pastry Section, Danny Maloney,
Rob Waterhouse, Moe, Aaron the White, James Castaneda, Jordan Longley, Jerry Lambdin,
Marcus Arsner, Gustav Swann, John Bailey, Cooling Castleman, Rashid Ali, Spinning Three Plates,
Filda Oink Oink, Izzy, David Silverman, Maggie Pakskowski, Winston Cawood, Spencer Lightfoot,
Robert Wetzel, Fortunate Calf, Lexi Schwinn, Skye Chappell and Marvin Casal.