Blackstone’s Jon Gray on real estate, rates, and building a winning company culture

Investor Insights
1 follower
1 Video View·Oct 30, 2024
Blackstone is the world’s largest alternative asset manager, with more than $1.1 trillion in assets under management. Blackstone President & COO Jonathan Gray says recognizing patterns and having a contrarian view are key to excess returns, and the reason why Blackstone has been able to grow so rapidly. In this Goldman Sachs Talks, Gray sat down with John Waldron, President & COO of Goldman Sachs, to discuss positive signs in the real estate market, why company culture is important, and lessons from his over 30 years at Blackstone.
To generate excess returns, sometimes you need a contrarian view and say, hey, I can see what's
happening. The fundamentals are decent. Cost of capital is coming down. Transaction activity is
going to pick up. The wheat market started to recover. Let's try to get ahead of this.
All right. Full house. Welcome, John Gray.
I love it. We love Goldman Sachs. We've had an amazing partnership for a long time,
so it is an honor to be here. Great. Okay, so we're going to start. We have a lot to talk about,
and I know there'll be questions, so I want to make sure we leave people time to ask some
questions. Okay, so I don't think John needs a lot of introduction, but just quickly, Blackstone,
world's largest alternative asset manager, over a trillion dollars in assets under management.
John is a member of the Blackstone Board of Directors. He's President and Chief Operating
Officer of the firm and sits on, I think, most of, if not all, of the investment committees
across the firm, so deeply involved running the firm, deeply involved investing, and we'll talk
a little bit about how he's kind of a player coach still, which I think is part of the success
for John and also for the firm. John grew up in the real estate business,
was global head of real estate at Blackstone, still, I think, involved in that business,
but obviously, he's emerged well beyond that, but that was kind of his path through.
Sits on the boards of Hilton, Corbridge Financial, and Harlem Village Academies.
Super involved with his wife, Mindy, in philanthropy, and towards the end of this
conversation, I'm going to ask him about that. They've established the Bassler Center for
Research, Treatment, and Prevention of BRCA-related cancers at the University of Pennsylvania.
I'll give him a chance to talk about that, but it's an extraordinary thing that he and Mindy
are doing. They've also established the New York City Kids Rise Program to increase college
savings for low-income children in New York City. So, we're going to talk to John about the economy,
about markets, about Blackstone, and leadership. So, let's give John a proper welcome at Goldman
Sachs. Welcome. So, let's start with your personal story. You grew up, I think, in Chicago.
I grew up in Ohio, so I've always liked that about you as a Midwest kid.
We're a long way from home.
We are. Just talk about how you got to Blackstone in the first place.
Yeah. I grew up suburban Chicago. I'd never been to the East Coast until I went to college.
Never been to New York. My senior year in college, in a three-week period of time,
I met a young woman in romantic poetry class, true story, and I got a job working for a very small
financial firm in New York. And now, almost 33 years later, I'm with the same woman,
I'm working at the same firm. So, I have the most boring biography of anybody you would have met.
And when I got to the firm, it was a tiny place. It was 75 people. We managed $750 million,
one private equity fund. I worked in M&A. We had an advisory business at the time.
I worked in the private equity business, mostly my job, running numbers, doing pitch books,
and making sure the associates had dinner by 7 p.m. That was the key thing.
And about a year into it, the real estate world had collapsed.
And our visionary founders, Pete Peterson, Steve Schwarzman, said,
hey, we should go into this. They found a great guy in Chicago named John Schreiber.
And they said, we need some junior people. Do you want to help?
It's going to be a short-term gig. And I said, sure. And I spent the next 25 years helping to
build what became the largest real estate business in the world. And about seven years ago, I got
this job to be president and COO. And so, all I know is Blackstone, and it has been an amazing run.
It's an incredible story. Let's talk about Blackstone, also an incredible story. So,
Blackstone today, trillion-plus dollar alternative asset manager. But go back to
your remembrances of the beginnings, because you were there pretty early.
And talk about the evolution and talk about some of the key elements of how Blackstone
has become the Blackstone we know today. It was a very small place, obviously,
when we started. And alternative assets really were a very niche business,
because large pools of capital only invested in liquid assets. And interestingly, that didn't
really change until 10 or 15 years ago, in some sense. Private equity developed,
which was our first business, then real estate private equity. We moved into credit when we
bought GSO. But that was really opportunistic, distressed credit. We had a hedge fund business.
But mostly, you gave us and our competitors money to do a small number of things,
very high-return strategies. And we had a small number of customers. We had several hundred
customers, pension funds, sovereign wealth funds, some endowments. And I'd say the tipping point for
us really was after the financial crisis. Rates came down significantly. And investors became
open to trading away some liquidity for higher returns in other asset classes, safer, more
yield-oriented, core plus real estate, infrastructure, performing credit,
both investment-grade, non-investment-grade. And the number of investors began to expand
pretty dramatically. So we moved to more institutions, to individual investors,
to insurance companies. And I would say it's been a pretty amazing change the last 10 years or so.
And even though we've grown to be much larger today, my optimism about the potential of the
business is much higher. And what I would say is the most important thing that took us on this
journey. I'd say two really key things. One is we always focused on delivering returns. You know,
it's a bit like you're in a pizza shop, right? The taste of your pizza is what really matters.
In our business, it's the returns we generate for the customers. It's a very competitive business.
And the second thing is we've always had this very entrepreneurial spirit to sort of push
and do things. And Steve Schwarzman deserves the credit. He put that in the DNA of the firm.
How can we serve the customers in different ways? How can we do this in Europe and in Asia?
How can we do it up and down the risk-return spectrum? And the larger we've gotten,
there've been a lot of advantages, like Goldman Sachs has, in terms of scale and insights and
relationships. So, you know, it in some ways feels very different, but the basic business,
raising capital, delivering good returns, running a high-integrity firm,
trying to have a great culture, the basic building blocks have stayed absolutely the same.
Yeah. So I want to talk about a transaction. I wouldn't ordinarily ask you about a transaction,
but you and I both know a company called Hilton Hotels reasonably well. You better than I do.
It was a transaction Goldman Sachs was involved in, Blackstone-led,
right at the precipice of the financial crisis. To me, it just speaks about that time in the market
and a lot about how you guys have grown beyond that, as you just pointed out. Probably the best
single private equity deal of all time from a nominal profit standpoint didn't start out that
way in the early days of the financial crisis. Maybe just tell the story of Hilton just as a way
to, you know, kind of bridge from that point to where we are today.
It was a terribly time transaction. And we bought Hilton Hotels, we committed in July of 2007,
just about the time of our IPO. Just about the peak of the market.
Just about the absolute, you can put a pin on it when we committed to this. We closed in October
and we bought the company for $26 billion. We put $20 billion of leverage. It was a different era
on it. We put $6 billion. Goldman Sachs was a minority partner, but we put a ton of capital
from our real estate funds and our private equity fund. And we went all in, in absolutely the wrong
moment. And, you know, fairly soon thereafter, the financial markets, as we all know, got into
big trouble. The real economy got into big trouble. And we found ourselves highly levered with EBITDA
cashflow down 40%. So let's just say it was not a good setup. And we wrote the investment down
by almost three quarters on an unrealized basis. So you can imagine the investor meetings I was
having at that point. Fortunately, we had an amazing management team. Our mutual friend,
Chris Nassetta, did a great job through the crisis. And since then, we had some great assets
in the company and a really powerful business. The Hilton brand, Hilton Garden, Embassy Suites,
Hampton, and all these amazing brands. A global world that wanted these brands.
And we had a strong instinct that this was cyclical. It wasn't secular in nature, that
people ultimately would travel again. And we'd seen that in a smaller way after 9-11. So despite
all the negativity out there, we stuck with it as a firm. We ended up putting in $800 million.
We worked with Goldman and the other banks, really in a consensual way to get to a good
outcome for the company to help delay. How controversial was it inside Blackstone
at that point to write that $800 million check? I mean, there were obviously doubters,
there were concerns. But the good news is we set parameters that we had to get enough time on the
debt. We had to make sure we had cashflow coverage. And I think some of those concerns
made us ultimately make a better deal. But I think generally, there was a consensus that
this was a really good business. And fortunately, just after that, we committed at the end of 2009
to do that, put the money in in early 2010. Things started turning around. And the cyclical
recovery happened. The business kept growing. The management team did a phenomenal job.
And we ended up taking the business public. I think you guys were the lead on the IPO.
We broke it into three companies, and it's been phenomenally successful. My big mistake was,
should have just held those shares. But I will tell you, what are the key takeaways?
To me, there were two. One, pretty obvious, which is maintain your equanimity in very difficult
periods of time, because you could have gotten quite discouraged and not kept working it,
and you would have had a very different outcome. The second one, which I think has really been
fundamental to shape me as an investor and some of the things we do at the firm,
is you look back in this and say, how could we have paid a huge price at the absolute worst time
and ended up making $14 billion for our investors? Well, we obviously had a really great management
team that helped, but we invested in a great neighborhood, global travel, and a great business
model, this sort of franchise management capital-like business. And so it made me think,
how can I find other things like that? Single-family housing after the financial crisis,
global logistics with the movement of e-commerce. Today, things like data centers and power,
certain areas geographically around the world, India, all these things. And you start to say,
the model matters and the 60-page memo matters, but maybe that first paragraph,
what is the sector I'm deploying capital in and the underlying business? And maybe I should focus
a lot more on that. Now, it doesn't mean you can pay any price. We saw that in 2021 for a good
business, but there is no question that investing in better neighborhoods, your chance of success
goes way up. And so when you see Blackstone and you see these sort of high conviction thematic
areas, I think a lot of it comes back to that somewhat searing experience that happened in
Hilton. Yep. That's a good message. I'm going to come back to some of that thematic point that
you just made, but let's just go to the macro for a second because you think a lot about the
macro environment. As you think about how to steer the firm forward, and you've got a unique
vantage point. You see companies' assets all over the world, similar to us. That's one of the great
privileges of being at these two firms. You have an enormous purview to watch a lot of micro data
points. What is your current take today on the macro, whether it's your bottoms-up analysis or
your top-down view? Well, I would say what I've learned the most is looking at the data, to your
point, John, is the most helpful thing. Because reading the paper and other things, for us, the
230 companies, the 13,000 pieces of real estate, all the infrastructure, everything gives you a
lot of real-time data. And what it's been saying the last couple years and even now is the U.S.
economy and the global economy have been more resilient than we would have expected, despite
very tight central bank policy. And we see that in revenue growth in our companies. We see that
in the low level defaults to our non-investment-grade borrowers. What we are seeing, though, is some
slowing. Sequential revenue has been coming down in terms of growth. Hiring is definitely more muted.
And in the consumer segment, where you look at our theme parks or some of our consumer goods
businesses, we see some of that slowing. The good news is that much of the slowdown obviously has
been caused by the central banks and it's only slowed so much. And the Fed has been quite
successful and other central banks in killing off inflation. And when we look at our portfolio
companies, our manufacturing companies have very little increase in input costs. Rental housing
costs are running well behind the government's lag data. And in the labor market, we survey our
portfolio companies every quarter and we ask them, you know, what do you think wages will be a year
from now? They're saying a year from now they think it'll be low threes. And so I think the Fed
has real air covered. There's a lot of debate and saying the economy hasn't slowed enough. Why is
the Fed cutting rate? Their mandate is price stability and full employment. And they've had
real success now with price stability. And so they're looking at employment. Their mandate
isn't to slow the U.S. or global economy. So our take here is I still think there is some downward
pressure slowing things down, but there's definitely, and we've seen it in recent numbers,
not just in the U.S., around the globe, slowing inflation. And central banks here and around the
world will be accommodative now. And for all of us who are engaged in asset values and transaction
activities, this is a very good thing. It may not be a good thing for your personal life next year
in terms of how busy you're going to all be working next year, but rates coming down is very positive.
We agree. So let's shift to transactional activity. As a big customer of capital markets
activity, funding, lending, wanting to take companies public, sell businesses, what's your
read currently on activity, capital markets availability to your prior point? How do you
think about the next 12, 24 months? The healing has definitely begun. One of the reasons,
starting a year ago, we started allocating more capital is we're beginning to see these
early signs. Obviously, we've been watching the inflation come down,
but rates really peaked in October of last year, early October. We began to see spreads come down.
And to sort of understand real world why this matters to transactions, we did a deal with
Emerson. When we tried to do that, we could borrow at 13% was basically the cost of debt capital,
and we could only borrow in the markets 20 or 25% of the total enterprise. Think about the cost
of capital when you weighed in equity as well at high teens. That makes doing deals very hard.
So as the Fed lowers rates, as the 10-year treasury comes down, by the way, people become
more interested in fixed income, spreads start to tighten there, and the weighted average cost
of capital comes way down. And that starts to get that flywheel going. Now, the other piece of this,
which has not yet begun, and you would have more insights, but the IPO market, that should restart.
As equities continue to rally, that will be like a magnet sucking in private companies. Yes,
the early ones will come out at bigger discounts, but I think we'll see more of that. And so you'll
begin to see more transaction activity. If you went back to the early 90s or after the financial
crisis, M&A volume fell 50, 60%, and then it started to rebuild. Same thing happened 22 and
23. Now with more accommodated policy, we're going to start to see things get better. So I would
expect much more robust transaction activity. Now, geopolitical things could happen. You could get a
bad inflation print, but I think the path of travel is definitely to more transaction activity.
All right, let's go back to the themes, because I've always looked at you and thought one of your
superpowers is you create this thematic perspective. Just clip through the things
that right now are top of mind for you guys thematically. So I would say data centers are
definitely top of the list. And the way we think about it is what are big things that are happening
and are there ways that are slightly derivative, where you can play the picks and shovels without
necessarily having to pick the winner in something like AI. So if you think consumption of
data is going up, cloud migration is going to continue, our lives are going to keep moving
online, and then AI is going to fundamentally change how we live our lives, how businesses
operate. What is the physical manifestation of that? Where do they put all those GPUs together
in these large language models? Where does that happen? It happens in data centers. We've been
buying all sorts of businesses, different parts of the supply chain. And it's exactly like you said,
John, which is if you see something and you have a neighborhood, how can I express it in private
equity? How can I express it in real estate, in credit, in infrastructure, in growth, in liquid
markets? What can we do? How can you flood the zone? And it feels to us like this still has a
ways to go, certainly when you listen to the biggest technology companies. Directly related to
that is power and energy. People think of power and energy as not that exciting. For those of you
in the utilities group, like, oh, people aren't saying that's the most exciting business sector
to go in. Today it actually is because two megatrends are happening at the same time.
One, many companies and countries are trying to move from hydrocarbons, particularly coal,
to renewables. So that's impacting where the supply of power is coming in a very big way.
And then on the demand side, after 20 years of flat power demand in most developed markets,
because of electrification of cars, because of some reshoring, and particularly because of data
centers, we're seeing this huge surge of demand. So what does that mean? Well, build lots of
renewables. We have a big renewables business in Venergy. Invest in transmission to the extent you
can. We're building a hydropower transmission line from Quebec to Queens. It also means
traditional hydrocarbons. That's an important part of this. And then there are all sorts of
services that utilities need, software consultancy, grid hardening, as this electrification
wave continues. And you play it in credit and in private equity and our energy transition funds.
Again, another really good neighborhood. I'd say life sciences would be another one of these.
Again, the power of technology now going with the power of science, what we're seeing in genomics,
putting these things together. I think all of our lives are going to be very different as a
result of precision medicine that rather than a doctor saying, well, maybe you should take this
versus this, your genome gets sequenced. This is the therapy or mix of therapies.
That just means a lot of things. Invest in companies that run trials. We bought three
of those businesses in Australia, Japan, and the US. Invest in the real estate. We have been
a major investor in some of the big drug therapies out there in partnership with
pharma companies, life science companies, in oncology and around the heart and neurology
and the whole thing. And again, it's a very big area where there are going to be more demands.
And we could go on and on. Obviously, alternatives is a space we know a lot about. Secondaries,
stakes and other managers, leverage loan, direct lending. Try to find things. Geographically,
India, we've been probably the biggest foreign investor in the world there on both private
equity and real estate. Super exciting things, a government that is pro-growth,
lots of new infrastructure, physical infrastructure, but legal infrastructure,
dispute resolutions improved, enforcement rights and credit, the capital markets.
We were talking beforehand how India is the strongest IPO market in the world. By the way,
after the US, it's been the best performing stock market over the last 10, 20 years in dollar terms.
And there, we're really trying to be builders of businesses. Find a financial services or
travel company or healthcare company that's serving the rising middle class or shopping
center or logistics, real estate business, and bring our management expertise and capital,
really help them grow, do some acquisitions. That's an area where we think there's a lot of
runway. And some of these things can last a long time. There's a global shortage of
housing as we talked about. So finding these things and then executing against it, to me,
this is the way we can really differentiate ourselves. And it's really something we try
to do at the firm level. And it's now beginning to happen organically across the firm. And then
you try to share those ideas and insights across the firm. And we're not perfect, but we're trying
to get better every day. So let me pick up on that last thread because as a chief operating
officer myself, the execution part of that is always the hardest thing to get right. So when
you decide on one of these themes, any of them, how are you actually getting Blackstone to prosecute
it as a firm as opposed to off of one platform? Yeah. Well, it's definitely a team sport and
people can identify these. I'm one of many voices who are seeing these things. But when we identify
something, you try to point it out. We have our Monday Blackstone TV, which is an internal Zoom
call, but we call it Blackstone TV. We're going to get to that. Yeah. And we try to talk about
good neighborhoods thematic. We talk about it in the various investment committees, in the
operating committees, at the partner meetings. When we see a really great neighborhood, we may
have one or two people across different business units come and make a presentation so the other
partners can see across the firm, we're seeing something really unique. And then it makes
everybody, somebody in credit say, gosh, I should be thinking about lending to those type of
businesses. There's an element of concussion bombing to this, right? You find something and you try to
signal it in everything you're doing. And you're encouraging people and rewarding people also
financially for finding opportunities in a good space. One of the challenges with the thematic
investing is a couple challenges. One is you end up paying too high a price just because you get
so enthused or it's a bad business in a good neighborhood. The other thing is sometimes
the neighborhood may change, right? There have been trends that have been really good,
but then the technology changes something. So you've got to constantly be checking. I mean,
one of the questions on data centers these days is, do you have a bubble? Is there too much capital
going to it? There, fortunately, we think the power is a real constraint and you tend not to
speculatively build a $2 billion data center. So the tenant demand creates a constraint as well.
But you have to, as an investment organization, as much as you're leaning forward, constantly
be questioning. And so the investment committee process can be one way where we say, yeah, that's
a great neighborhood, but use streaming as an example, right? That was a really good area.
A lot of people, production of content. I still think it's a long-term growth business,
but there was too much capital and we've seen a retrenchment now. So there's a balance to this.
And so we're definitely encouraging it, but then we want to be cautious and skeptical at the same
time. Okay. Very good message. I want to ask you about commercial real estate because you've got
so much expertise, history, you know, footings. Everybody asks, you know, is it bottomed? Is it
not bottomed? What are the risks? Just give us your view on commercial real estate broadly.
So we said in January publicly on earnings that we thought commercial real estate was bottoming.
And we've continued to believe that. I'll explain why in a sec. And we've been very
busy this year deploying capital. We've been a huge buyer of logistics in Europe,
got a bunch in our Asian real estate pipeline. If you look at commercial real estate, I would
break it into two parts. The office sector, which has faced fundamental challenges because unlike
Goldman Sachs and Blackstone, at most places, they're in the office two or three days a week.
You guys probably have noticed that. No ties in here, but people are here.
We're the only ones with ties. So, you know, the office sector's 25% vacant in the U.S.
There's weakness in Canada and Australia, you know, the city in London, La Defense in Paris.
And that's going to take a while to dig out of. And that's really hurt the values significantly.
In the rest of commercial real estate, in the two big areas we focus in, logistics and rental
housing, the vacancy is 5%, 6% in the U.S. The fundamentals have slowed totally fine.
What happened was, back to our cost of capital, you know, the interest rates went up. The borrowing
costs went up. The cap rates or unleveraged yields went up. The multiples came down. They
went from 3.5% to 5%. That's happened. But the business is fine. And so when we began to get
those signals at the end of last year, saying, look, the markets are recognizing inflation coming
down, the Fed's starting to tilt towards a different area, as cost of capital comes down
in these sectors, we should go out there and get ahead of it. And the problem for investors is
they're often looking in the rearview mirror. So they're saying to themselves, real estate,
oh, I got all this troubled real estate. I don't want to go back into that.
And they're reading the headlines of the deals that were made in 2021, which are coming due,
the debt comes due, or the bad office deal, or whatever. And they're like, oh, there's still
a mess here. But if you went back to 2009, the best investments in that cycle were then.
You didn't get the all clear sign from everybody else till 2012. And so to generate excess returns,
sometimes you need a contrarian view and say, hey, I can see what's happening. The fundamentals
are decent. Cost of capital is coming down. Transaction activity is going to pick up.
The REIT market started to recover. Let's try to get ahead of this. But it's hard for investors
because they tend to look backwards. And they tend to see the pain that has occurred. And yet,
in reality, in real estate, it's a cyclical business. And if you were an investor after
the downturn in the early 90s, you would've made a lot of money. If you were an investor in real
estate after the financial crisis, you would've made a lot of money. And my guess is if you're
an investor today, the same thing will happen. All right. Let's shift to your leadership style.
Now we're going to get into Blackstone TV and morning runs and-
The really important stuff.
Yeah. Holiday videos. So-
I love the laugh on that.
You're a very approachable guy for a person in your position. It strikes me. I'm sure people
in Blackstone would say the same thing. Describe your style. What is your actual leadership style?
Look, I guess I feel incredibly lucky to do what I do. I have genuine affection
for the people I work with. I love the intellectual challenge of investing capital.
I love the entrepreneurial spirit of thinking about how we can build a new business.
And I feel incredibly fortunate, blessed. I know you feel the same way in my role.
So I try to bring some enthusiasm to what I do and some humility too, because the investing
business definitely can make you humble. And I think if you come at it with a lot of energy,
then that sort of flows to other people. And the social media, the holiday videos,
sometimes they call Christine Anderson, who you know, who runs our corporate affairs area,
and they're like, what's your strategy for all this? And really, this stuff sort of happened
naturally. You know, when I got the job, we had to cancel the holiday party because we'd gotten
too big to get everybody somewhere. And I was like, oh my gosh, I'm going to be Scrooge here,
right? I'm going to cancel the holiday party. And instead, I said, we've got to do something.
And we came up with this idea of this spoof office holiday video, which kept getting bigger each
year until last year, we sort of jumped the shark. And now the pressure is on to do something
equally. You must be already planning now. Trust me, we're on it. Equally insane, cringeworthy,
the whole deal. We got to do all of that. But it shows a humanity to your organization and to your
investors around the world. Blackstone TV, our Monday Zoom call came out of COVID. It was a way
to start communicating on a regular basis when we were all at home in our boxer shorts, like,
hey, here's what's going on at the firm. And it's become a powerful tool for me, Steve Schwarzman,
Vic Sani, to talk to everybody about what we're seeing in the world. We have photo contests of
people having babies and getting married and climbing mountains or with their pets, whatever
it is. And then we talk about what's happening at the firm. And then the running videos, we were
talking about it beforehand. I used to do these things for my kids because I'm traveling the world
and I didn't want them to forget I exist. So I'd be like, hey, I'm in Australia or I'm in Europe or
wherever I am in the world. And I decided when I was doing a run in Sydney to just do some of that.
And I put in a little bit of business content as well. And it went totally viral. So the team was
like, you should do this again. So Tokyo, East Lansing, Michigan, whatever it is. And I think
people genuinely like to see folks like us in human situations, sweating, panting. What do
they do on a trip? There's something authentic about it. And it makes you more approachable
and makes people realize you're human beings. You're like everybody else. You're trying to
regulate your body and you're in a different spot. And so it's become sort of fun. At some
point, it may be too much. My kids, I'm sure, will tell me that. But for right now, I'm having fun.
Yeah, I think it's great. Making yourself more human is a great leadership style.
All right. In the time we have left, I want to give you a chance to talk about philanthropy.
So I mentioned at the outset, just talk about how you and Mindy have approached your philanthropy,
how you think about it, why it's important, what your forward vision is.
I think like a lot of people, we never expected to find ourselves in this kind of position.
From where I grew up in Chicago, Mindy grew up in a pre-Civil War row house in Philadelphia.
And I think we both felt a sense of responsibility, that you got to do something
with it that has an impact. I would say we started doing it poorly, dabbling here, doing this.
And a little bit like high conviction investing, we said, you know what? We need a good management
team. We brought our friend Dana Zucker on board to help give us some structure and guidance.
And we said, let's pick a couple things we really believe in. And for us, it was this BRCA gene
mutation because we'd lost my wife's sister, Faith Bassar. And we wanted to try to accelerate
the research, early detection. We set up the center of Penn, but it supported a bunch of
other medical institutions around the world in this area. And the other area of focus was low
income kids in New York City because our kids got every advantage in the world, private schools and
tutors and this and that. And here are all these deserving kids who don't have the same kind of
opportunities. So what could we do around education, health care opportunities? We set
up the Children's Savings Program in partnership with the city. We partner with all these different
organizations, swim lessons, sports program, cultural programs. Give these kids a shot
to find opportunity, to get to college, to get some of those same opportunities my own children
get. And what I'd say about it is the rewards of doing this are enormous. And I'd recommend it. I
know many of you do philanthropic things. Goldman does a ton of stuff. I know you personally do.
It has all these ancillary benefits. And for many and I, it's been a great way in our lives
to spend a bunch of time together and to feel like we're making a difference. And I feel great
about it. You know, sometimes we don't get it perfectly right, but we run it a bit like a
portfolio company, regular reports, regular meetings, disciplined sort of ROIs on what we're
doing. And like anything I've learned, if we focus on it, structure it right, have the right people,
partner with the right organizations, good things can happen. Well, I commend you both. You guys
have had a huge impact and I think you will continue to have a huge impact. We're going to
say thank you, John, for taking the time to do this. First of all, it's enormously valuable for
our people. I think it strengthens the relationship. There's more education, understanding
what you're trying to achieve with Blackstone and how we can be helpful at Goldman Sachs. And just
thank you for what you're doing and really appreciate you being here. Have a good weekend.
Thank you. It's been wonderful. Thanks, everybody.
