00:45 What ancient DNA has revealed about Rapa Nui’s past Ancient DNA analysis has further demonstrated that the people of Rapa Nui did not cause their own population collapse, further refuting a controversial but popular claim. Rapa Nui, also known as Easter island, is famous for its giant Moai statues and the contested idea that the people mismanaged their natural resources leading to ‘ecological suicide’. Genomes sequenced from the remains of 15 ancient islanders showed no evidence of a sudden population crash, substantiating other research challenging the collapse idea.
19:29 A macabre parasite of adult fruit flies Despite being a hugely-studied model organism, it seems that there’s still more to find out about the fruit fly Drosophila melanogaster, as researchers have discovered a new species of parasitoid wasp that infects the species. Unlike other parasitic wasps, this one lays its eggs in adult flies, with the developing larva devouring its host from the inside. The miniscule wasp was discovered by chance in an infected fruit fly collected in a Mississippi backyard and analysis suggests that despite having never been previously identified, it is widespread across parts of North America.
32:04 Briefing Chat How a dye that helps to give Doritos their orange hue can turn mouse tissues transparent, and an effective way to engage with climate-science sceptics.
Subscribe to Nature Briefing, an unmissable daily round-up of science news, opinion and analysis free in your inbox every weekday. https://www.nature.com/briefing/signup
Welcome back to the Nature Podcast. This week, what ancient DNA has revealed about Rapa Nui's
past and a tiny parasitoid wasp that's been found in an unexpected place. I'm Benjamin
Thompson and I'm Nick Bertracheau. First up on the show this week, ancient DNA is helping
to answer some contested questions about a tiny island in the Pacific known as Rapa Nui.
If you've heard of this island, you may be more familiar with it under the name Easter
Island, and you'll likely have heard of it either due to its great Moai statues that
dot the landscape, or because of a popular idea that its population was decimated by
its own mismanagement of its natural resources. Now that idea has been challenged by scientists
for a long time, as there's a lot of evidence that conflicts with it, and this week in Nature,
a study on ancient DNA from Rapa Nui people may finally put that idea to rest. That DNA
also may help researchers understand a less controversial but still hotly debated question
about Rapa Nui, when the people there had contact with the Americas. Modern DNA evidence has shown
that local people have Native American DNA, but it's unclear whether mixing between peoples
occurred before or after Europeans arrived. To investigate these questions, Geoff Marsh
is here with the story. Around eight or nine hundred years ago, a group of Polynesian sailors
continued their eastward expansion across the Pacific into the far reaches of what we
now know as the Polynesian Triangle, a vast area of the Pacific with over a thousand islands,
including New Zealand and Hawaii. They haven't set foot on land since the last island they
inhabited, nearly two thousand kilometres back to the west. So it must have been cause
for celebration when looming out of the Pacific waves, a tree-covered paradise, untouched
by humans, broke the horizon. So Rapa Nui was one of the last islands to be settled
in the remote Oceania, together with New Zealand, and around nine hundred, eight hundred years
ago. My name is Katrin Negele, and I work on the reconstruction of the past through
archaeogenomic methods. And my personal focus is very much on tropical regions, both in
the Americas and in the Pacific, and I have a special interest in islands. It's very clear
from the genetic evidence and also from ancient DNA evidence that people who settled the remote
islands in the Pacific came from the West. It very likely started with something called
the Austronesian Expansion. So somewhere in island Southeast Asia, people started travelling
along the islands into remote Oceania, and then eventually also the extreme corners of
the Polynesian Triangle. Rapa Nui is this super small island, it's just some tens of
kilometres around. You can actually use your bike to go around in a single day, and you
still have the rest of the day to do other things. This is Victor Moreno, from the Globe
Institute at the University of Copenhagen. I am an evolutionary geneticist. I am originally
from Mexico, but I have been working here in Copenhagen for a while now. Victor is first
author on a Nature paper published this week, about the legacy of this tiny speck of land
that had such an outsized influence on the study of human history. In Rapa Nui it's actually
one of the most isolated places in the world that is inhabited by humans. So it's this
very isolated island, where you have Polynesian peoples living for the last 800-1000 years.
And the thing is that once they get there, they get this very rich culture that fascinates
us all. They have these huge stone statues called Moai, that they put on also these stone
platforms, they are called Ahu. So they make it there and then they develop this amazing
culture. Then it's in 1722 that the Europeans arrive in the island, the Dutch, and then
that starts the usual colonial history that we know in many other places, right? But between
the 1200s and 1722 we have these classical Polynesian people thriving there.
You're more likely to have heard about Rapa Nui by a different name, Easter Island, given
to it by its first European visitor, Dutch explorer Jacob Roggeven, who happened to arrive
on an Easter Sunday in 1722. And you might have heard about Easter Island in the context
of a widely held theory put forward about the self-inflicted collapse of the islanders.
As Katrin Nagel, who wasn't directly involved in this paper, but who wrote an accompanying
News and Views article, explains.
Yeah, the most popularized narrative about Easter Island is one where the Easter Islanders
over-consumed their resources and this led to wars between people and even to cannibalism,
according to some people. And this is basically used as a cautionary tale to tell us what
happens when we do not manage very well the resources that we have.
And actually, in a way, it works, right? This story has been used for saying, hey humans,
look at what happens in these different places with these cultures that were so magnificent
and they ended up destroying their environment and finishing their resources and they end
up eating each other.
Jared Diamond is the one who popularized this story in his book Collapse, and he said that
15,000 people once inhabited this island. But because they did not manage their resources
as well and because they cut down trees, all of the trees, the land eroded and they
couldn't produce enough food. And so when the European colonizers arrived, only a few
thousand were left and supposedly the Europeans also encountered not only very few, but also
very miserable Rapa Nui islanders.
But Jared Diamond wasn't the first person to propose these theories about the societal
collapse of the Rapa Nui people. Others had previously made similar claims, although without
much backing from the scientific community.
Another contested question about the history of the Rapa Nui islanders was when they had
contact with people from the Americas, because analysis of modern Rapa Nui genomes does show
evidence of mixing between their Polynesian ancestors and Native Americans. But it's hard
to say for certain when that happened, given that more than a thousand Rapa Nui people
were taken to the Americas during the Peruvian slave raids of the 1860s before eventually
being repatriated.
In a peculiar twist of fate, another result of the Rapa Nui's colonization may now answer
some of these questions.
Fifteen ancient individuals, labelled as Rapa Nui, found their way into the Natural History
Museum of Paris during the late 19th and early 20th century. After careful talks with the
contemporary Rapa Nui community to get properly informed consent, Victor and his team set
to work.
Even though this collection was labelled as individuals from Rapa Nui, we wanted to actually
confirm if this was the case. Because if they are actually individuals from Rapa Nui, that
is indisputable evidence that the Rapa Nui community can use to repatriate these remains
back into the island.
Second, we wanted to look for evidence of this alleged collapse. If there was a collapse,
we would expect to see very little genetic diversity at the time of the collapse, which
is the 1600s.
And the third thing we were looking for is, we wanted to use their DNA to ask whether
the ancestors of the Rapa Nui, whether the Polynesian ancestors of the Rapa Nui were
actually in contact with Native Americans. And if so, we wanted to date when that happened.
Was it something that happened before European contact? Was it something that happened before
or after the peopling of the island?
So we got access to these individuals and what we did is to extract DNA from bone powder.
What we're doing is we're sequencing the whole genomes of these individuals. So this gives
us access to a very wide variety of possible analysis that we can do with the data.
So the first thing that we wanted to ask is, are they Rapa Nui or are they not? So we took
their genomes and we compared to different populations around the world, which one is
the most closely related to them? And the answer is they are most closely related to
present day Rapa Nui. So as we said, that's indisputable evidence that they are Rapa Nui
and then they can, well, hopefully that starts the process of bringing them back to the island.
In addition to getting their genomes, we're also radiocarbon dating them. And the radiocarbon
dates show us that they are from after the 1600s, which is when the collapse is supposed
to be happening.
Today we have population genetic methods that if you have genomes from a population, you
can ask, how did the genetic diversity look like 10 generations ago, 20 generations ago,
50 generations ago? And because these individuals were post-dating the collapse, we thought,
well, if we use these methods, then if we detect a sudden drop of the genetic diversity
of this population around the 1600s, then that's the evidence of the collapse. Well,
it turns out that we don't see that. It turns out that what we see is that around the 1600s,
we get that the population diversity is increasing steadily.
And the third thing that we wanted to look at is where we could find any genetic evidence
of contact between the Polynesian ancestors of these individuals and Native Americans.
So what we find is that across the genome of these individuals, the large majority of
it is Polynesian in origin, but 10% it's Native American in origin. Then we want to ask, what
are these Native American bits coming into the Rapa Nui genomes? And in order to do that,
the idea is that depending on when the Polynesians were in contact with Native Americans, the
chunks of Native American DNA, their lengths would change. So every time we have offspring,
these genetic chunks get broken apart, and then they are inherited shorter and shorter
through time. So we have statistical methods where you feed in the length distribution
of these chunks and ask, when is this admixture event happening? What we get is that this
admixture event is happening more or less in the 1300s.
And dating this Polynesian-Native American mixing event to the 1300s is important for
a few reasons.
First, it post-dates the peopling of the island, right? It's something that happens after the
island is peopled. But it predates two important dates, right? The first one is it predates
European contact with the Rapa Nui. Europeans made it to the island in 1722, but it also
predates the arrival of Europeans in the Americas, which is in the 1500s, in the 14-1500s.
So we have very strong evidence that this admixture event is happening without being
mediated by Europeans.
But what the results can't tell us is who made the journey for the mixing to take place.
Was it a continuation of the Polynesians' eastward expansion before coming back again?
Or did Native Americans travel west to find Rapa Nui themselves?
We know a lot about Polynesians, and we know they managed to get to every single Polynesian
island in a matter of very few thousand years. So they were exploring the Pacific. They knew
what they were doing. They were very good sailors, right? Probably the best we have had.
So if you make it to Rapa Nui, the Americas would be a very hard target to miss, right?
It's very unlikely that they stop at Rapa Nui and they never go to the Americas. And
if they can go to the Americas, of course they can go back. If we consider all the evidence,
we favour this idea of Polynesians going to the Americas and back. However, that's still
an open question.
There was a well-documented collapse of the people of Rapa Nui in the 19th century, when
Peruvian slave raiders decimated the population to around 100 people. So how is it that it
was the Rapa Nui's careless ecological suicide narrative that took hold so firmly and for
so long?
Many of these narratives, in many cases, like the narrative of the collapse or the narrative
that Polynesians couldn't have made that amazing status because it had to be made by Native
Americans and so on, they are usually put together as some kind of colonial narrative,
right? With different purposes in mind, from getting access to the land to other even more
obscure and darker things. And here we have an example of how science can help debunk
those narratives and put them to rest and hopefully re-vindicate other cultures.
Everyone also happily accepted this narrative and perpetuated it. And so I think it also
tells us something about, you know, maybe sometimes we have to check, especially when
there is so much evidence speaking against it. And this paper, while I hope that it's the
last nail in the coffin, it was not the first one, right? There are so many other lines of
evidence that for the last decades have shown that this narrative is wrong, but still this
update has not made it through to the general public and also into common knowledge. And I
hope that with the attention that ancient DNA research is getting, that this can finally
happen.
This narrative around the ecological collapse in Rapa Nui, while false according to many
lines of evidence, has been a powerful cautionary tale at a time when we're destroying our
own environments at a rapid rate. So what lessons, if any, can we still learn from this
remote island and its past?
Well, I think that rather than being a cautionary tale about the ecocide, it can still be a
cautionary tale, but with a much more positive outcome, right? I mean, we're facing climate
crisis right now, and sometimes one feels like losing hope because it seems we cannot
do anything about it. And I'm sure that maybe at some point Rapa Nui islanders felt like
this, but they were very resilient and invented new strategies and new agricultural methods
to overcome these problems and persisted through them. And I hope that this type of cultural
change is also something that we can do on a global scale, right? That it's not just
possible on a small island, but that globally we can work to change our culture from a culture
of overconsumption to a culture of sustainability.
That podcast piece was produced by Jeff Marsh. In it, you heard from Katrin Nagler from the
Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology in Germany and Victor Moreno from the University
of Copenhagen. For more on that story, check out the show notes for some links.
Coming up, the chance discovery that revealed a new species of wasp with a gruesome life
cycle. Now though, it's time for the research highlights with Dan Fox.
Around 48 million years ago in a lake in what is now Germany, a few bat-eating fish bit
off more than they could chew. Fossilised remains of two species of extinct lake fish,
gar and bowfins, were discovered with the remains of a small extinct bat in their jaws.
The bat's wings probably got stuck in the jaws of the fish and the researchers behind
this paper conclude that these mammoth morsels might have impeded the movement of the predators,
leading them to die of starvation and exhaustion. The large number of other bat fossils found
in the area suggests that gar and bowfins had lots of opportunities to scavenge on or
attack drowning bats, and these tiny mammals may have represented a substantial food source
for the fish. If you want to chew over that research a little
more, you can find the paper in Biology Letters.
Lake Amana in the Brazilian Amazon is known as the home of the manatee, but new research
suggests a better name could be the manatee's garden, based on how the gentle aquatic mammal's
dung shapes the local ecosystem. Researchers took advantage of an extreme drought
last October, which dropped water levels to reveal grassy, muddy balls of dung from
Amazonian manatees around the lake's edge. The team collected 96 dung balls and picked
out over 2,000 seeds from 9 plant species. The vast majority of the viable seeds were
from an aquatic grass previously observed sprouting from manatee dung balls. The grass
is even able to use moisture and nutrients from the poo to grow on a scorching hot sandy
beach. Seeds take 5 to 9 days to pass through a manatee, which means that this threatened
animal can act as a gardener, moving seeds of its favourite foods long distances in the
Amazon region. Read that research in full in the Journal of Nature Conservation.
Drosophila fruit flies are very well studied insects. For over a century, these tiny animals
have been at the centre of many of the biggest molecular and genetic breakthroughs in science.
But despite being under the microscope all this time, it looks like researchers have
missed something. And that something is a miniscule wasp that preys on some species
of Drosophila. Now, this isn't the sort of wasp – you might call it a yellow jacket
– that interrupts your picnic. Oh no, this is a parasitoid wasp, belonging to a group
of animals with a very unusual and often quite macabre life cycle. Females of these wasps
lay their eggs on, or in some cases, in, other living insects. In the latter case, these
eggs develop into larvae which grow and feast inside the host before bursting out to continue
their life cycle. A paper describing this wasp is being published in Nature this week.
It's tiny, just a couple of millimetres long, and the team that discovered it did
so quite by chance. Unlike many other parasitoid wasps, it lays its eggs in adult insects,
rather than the juvenile stages, the larvae or pupae. To get all the gory details, I phoned
Matt Ballinger from Mississippi State University in the US, one of the authors of the paper.
He told me the story of where the team first found this wasp, which began very close to
home.
It did begin in our backyard. We study in my lab microbial symbiotes, you know, bacteria
that live inside insects and protect them against parasitoid wasps and other types of
internal parasites. And so we regularly will go out and we'll collect wild parasites.
I had requested that my student and I collect some mushroom feeding flies because we're
interested in nematodes. And we just happened to have collected, with those mushroom baits,
also a fly called Drosophila affinis. And when I was dissecting the mushroom feeding
flies, looking for nematodes, I just noticed that this particular fly looked a little strange.
Its abdomen, the testes, these spiral structures on its abdomen are bright red in this particular
species. They seem to be sort of protruding from its abdomen, like there was something
inside. So I took that fly and dissected it, and inside was a parasitoid wasp larva. But
this should not have been there in an adult fly. There are no cases, whether we're talking
about fruit flies or any other flies, that are parasitized by wasps during their adult
stage.
So you were looking for nematodes, but instead you found the larvae of a wasp inside a fruit
fly. Did you think it was a mistake or anything like that?
I did. Initially, I felt like this could be a confused wasp that oviposited in the wrong
host. Or, since we know that many pupil parasitoids exist, that somehow a wasp larva had persisted
in the body of a Drosophila affinis fly. But of course, we wanted to test that, so we kept
collecting until we saw very clearly, after hundreds and thousands of collections, that
this was a consistent infection of adult flies. And eventually, we're able to expose adult
flies to adult wasps that we raised from those in the lab to observe those oviposition
behaviours into adult wasps.
But it wasn't just physical evidence you collected. You looked in the genomes of wild caught fruit
flies, and it appears that one very famous fly that many of our listeners will be familiar
with, evidence suggested that it had been infected.
Yeah, there's this fantastic data set, and it consists of genomic data collected from
hundreds and hundreds of pools of wild Drosophila, so that that data can then be used by researchers
to study population scale evolution of the fruit fly Drosophila melanogaster. And so
we used that data set, reasoning that if this particular parasite is infecting Drosophila
melanogaster in nature, we might see some of this parasitic wasp DNA among those sequence
reads from that global data set. And that's exactly what we found. I frankly didn't think
that we would, because I thought, this is Drosophila melanogaster, right? Like, people
understand what parasites it has at this point. But my graduate student, Logan, first author
on the paper, contacted me and said, you're not going to believe this, but I've got the
preliminary results from that. And we've got multiple states in the US where the parasite
is present in this sequencing data.
I mean, let's just back up for a second. Drosophila melanogaster is one of the most studied organisms
on the planet, right? It's been studied for, what, a hundred odd years. It's a model organism.
We know a lot about its molecular pathways and what makes it tick and what have you.
As you say, there are multiple wasps that attack it in its larval stage, but you're
saying that no wasp had been found that attacks the adult stage in all this time?
Yeah, that's right. Drosophila melanogaster, it can be attacked by wasps during the larval
and the pupal stages, but no examples of wasps that attack it during the adult stage have
ever been described.
I mean, that must have been quite something when you saw that, because this is one of
the most famous organisms on the planet.
Yeah, that's right. That's why we were so shocked to have found it and thrilled, quite
honestly.
And so let's talk about this wasp then, Matt. What's its name? What does it look like? How
big is it?
Yeah, it's a very tiny wasp. This is a wasp that belongs to a subfamily called Euphorinae
and in the genus Centritus. And this is a group of wasps that is known to specialize
on attacking hymenopteran hosts. So that's bees and wasps in general, and quite a surprise
then to see it in a fly. But as you could imagine, with such a small host, this particular
wasp is a little bit smaller than some of the other wasps in the genus.
This particular wasp, we named Centritus perlmani, named it after a colleague and a former mentor
of mine, Steve Perlin, and he's done a lot of work on Drosophila parasite interactions.
And let's talk about its life cycle, because there's some videos associated with your paper
that I have been watching, and they are quite something, I have to say. When a female wasp
comes across a fruit fly, what happens?
Yeah, she sort of adopts a new stance. You can see her posture change. She becomes very
focused, and you can almost see when she locks in first and says, oh, this is a potential
host. And then as she decides she's going to try to lay an egg inside this host, of
course, her ovipositor is behind her body and the host is in front of her. So she will
bend her abdomen underneath her body and extend her ovipositor outward in front of her face
to sort of charge in to the host while stretching that ovipositor out.
And so this kind of egg-depositing lance then, what, pierces the abdomen of the fly?
Yeah, she goes for the abdomen. In the case of the fly, after oviposition, the egg takes
several days, three to four days, it will develop into a much larger embryo before a
larva hatches out. And that larva will be free-floating in its body. At the same time,
really interesting cells emerge from the membranes of the embryos as well. These are called teratocytes.
They disperse into the blood of the fly and they grow as the larva grows. They accumulate
lipids, proteins, everything a growing wasp needs. And so there's some evidence that teratocytes
in this group of wasps are sometimes used as nutritional sources, but also that they
play important roles in modulating the host's defenses, protecting that larva.
And I've seen in one of your supplementary videos then, this larva kind of writhing inside
the fruit fly and it obviously brings to mind the movie Alien. What sort of size is the
larva when compared to the actual size of the fruit fly?
It's shocking to see its size. In fact, those last few moments before the larva is actually
emerging, it looks like it must be maybe the size of the fly's abdomen or so. Of course,
it's squished in there. As you see it emerge, you realize this larva is almost the full
body length of its host. So it is really, by the end, it is squishing, it's pressing
to get out of there. It's ready to move on to the next stage.
And so it bursts out and I guess then ultimately the wasp develops and off we go again. Are
the fruit flies okay after bursting, Matt? Tell me they're okay.
Shockingly, we have seen them get up and survive up to 24 hours after that. But they are a
Usually, we find them dead within a couple of hours, but you would not expect it seeing
the ordeal that they go through. But they'll pop up and they'll stay active for at least
a few hours.
I was not expecting you to say that. But the flies aren't completely defenseless though,
right? In one instance, you can see a fly kind of facing down a wasp. It's kind of pouring
away if that's the right word with its legs.
That's one of the very exciting parts of this. Now we have an opportunity to look at interactions
between a parasite and an adult host, right? As opposed to a parasite and a larval host.
There's a whole different arsenal of potential behavioral defenses. We've seen in some cases
that the flies seem to recognize there's some sort of threat here, whether it's specific
to the parasitoid wasp or this is an aggressive behavior from a fly that we just haven't seen
before. In the case of the video you're describing, that flies seem to recognize the wasp and
approach it while kicking its legs out. And that interaction goes on for a good 30 seconds
to a minute. They're both quite persistent about it until eventually the fly sort of
scampers off.
I think we've talked a bit about how well studied Drosophila is. I mean, will this lend
itself to working out what happens once the egg has been injected? Because I think as
you sort of alluded to, there is almost an arms race of the flies' internal defenses
versus the larval offenses, that kind of thing.
There is lots of fantastic work on what happens after certain parasitoids lay their eggs inside
Drosophila hosts, all in a larval system, some in a pupal system. There's from species
to species of parasitoids, different strategies for how they avoid that defense. In some cases,
the wasp eggs are coated in sort of a sticky protein, and that protein allows them to stick
to host tissues inside the body and protects them from some of the host defenses. One of
those host defenses is reduction of immune cells, sort of like blood cells. What many
of them do is they will wrap around the egg in like a death burrito, and they kill the
egg inside those cells.
So now we have an opportunity to look at how those interactions proceed in the adult immune
system. The occurrence of this wasp in Drosophila melanogaster opens a lot of doors for research
into some of the more precise mechanisms of how this type of parasitism works.
Do you think that you're going to get a lot of correspondence from other fruit fly researchers
going, oh, that's what that is? Because I guess these wasps are very, very small and
difficult to see, but it seems like they're all up and down, certainly the eastern seaboard
of the United States. Somebody must have come across this without realizing in the past.
Yeah, in some ways, maybe. The folks that I have talked to that I would expect they
might encounter this organism had not had the opportunity to see it before. Part of
that, as you said, it's quite tiny. So really, unless you happen to catch it just at the
moment where it's encountering a fly in the wild and preparing to oviposit, it doesn't
stand out. It's a dark colored, two millimeter long, one and a half millimeter long insect.
Maybe that's one of the most exciting things about this as well, is it just shines a light
on what sort of cool biology is still out there, right? Things that we definitely should
have found by now if we had just been looking in a slightly different way.
That was Matt Ballinger from Mississippi State University. Head over to the show notes for
a link to the paper where you'll find some of the videos we talked about.
Finally on the show, it's time for the briefing chat, where we discuss a couple of articles
that have been highlighted in the Nature briefing. Ben, what have you been reading this week?
Well, I've got a story this week that I read about in Nature, and it's based on a science
paper. And it's all about a new way to observe the organs inside live mice. And it's kind
of unexpected, because it involves a dye that helps give Doritos their orange hue.
I mean, that does sound rather unconventional as a way to do this, but maybe let's back
up a little bit. Why would you want to see inside the mice? Why would you want to see
its organs in the first place?
Yeah, I mean, a lot of biomedical research necessitates seeing what's going on inside
a living animal. And this can be quite difficult to do, and involves implanting endoscopes
or cameras or things like that, obviously, which are quite invasive. And this method
might be a way to avoid that and be a less invasive way to monitor live animals. And
it's kind of fascinating. One of the videos in this story shows where this dye has been
applied to the skin of a mouse's scalp. And you can see the blood vessels in its brain
appear really quite quickly.
Oh, wow. That sounds very cool. But I guess I'm wondering how exactly this works. You
said this has come from Dorito dye?
Well, it's come from a dye that's used in a lot of food, which is called tartrazine.
Now, this dye changes how body tissues that are normally opaque interact with light. And
what happens here is the fluids and fats and muscles that make up tissues, they all bend
light to different degrees. And so that causes the light to be scattered, making something
opaque. And this got the team behind this work thinking. They wanted to know if they
could use a dye to make this bending of light more similar between tissues. And they've
done a bunch of research here. And this is where the tartrazine comes in. And when it's
dissolved in water, it makes water bend light more like fats do. So a tissue containing
fats and lipids becomes transparent when the dye is added. So they bend light in a more
similar way.
That's super neat. And I'm guessing as well, because this is something that is used in
food, it's pretty safe to use on the mice.
That's definitely a pro to this approach. And what happens is it's massaged in. OK,
so the researchers demonstrated the ability to make things transparent by testing it first
on thin slivers of chicken breast. And then they've used mice, as I say, and they've massaged
it into various areas of live mouse skin. Now, I mentioned the brain there, but they
also they can see the intestines contracting during digestion. They can see muscle fibres
in the leg. It's quite something to see.
I'm certainly going to look at it myself. But I'm wondering what the reaction is from
scientists, because as you said, this could be quite useful for various kinds of research.
Has there been any reactions to this in the article?
Yeah, one of the scientists quoted says that it's a major breakthrough, but of course,
it's not ready for prime time just yet. They can only make the skin transparent to a relatively
shallow depth, which could make it of limited practical use for thicker tissues or, you
or I. But as you say there, one of the big pluses is it's something that is a known quantity
and also that it can be used in live animals. But also it's reversible. If you wash the
dye off, the skin goes opaque again. So it could be a much more non-invasive way, as I say,
to look at what's going on inside and potentially has a myriad of uses. There's a couple that I
mentioned in the article. It could be used to understand a bit more about the nervous
system and how it functions in mice and potentially even more about neurodegenerative diseases.
Well, I'm certainly going to be giving my skin a closer inspection next time I eat some Doritos,
but thanks for that story, Ben. That's fascinating. For my story this week,
it's about climate change and this is a story I was reading about in Nature. And it's a question
that probably you and I and many of our listeners have asked ourselves. How do we change people's
mind about climate change?
Right, because of course, there are sections of society who are sceptical of climate science and
And this story is part of a growing understanding of how best to engage people who are maybe a bit
sceptical about climate change, because as scientists have talked more and more about
climate change over the years, they've got better understanding what works and what doesn't. And
I think it's well understood now that just showing people like melting ice with sad polar
bears doesn't really work. Instead, you need to really engage with them. And so this study
was testing a specific way of engaging with people, which is to tell them certain facts
about climate change, particularly that 97% of climate scientists agree that it's real.
Now, this has been done before, but mostly it's been done in the US to
understand how people's views change when you present them with these facts.
This study looked at 27 different countries and saw how people's opinions changed before
and after you present them with those facts. And it seems that telling people these facts
does actually make them likely to change their perspective. And interestingly,
it was people who were maybe more sceptical or less familiar with these facts who were
more likely to change their perspective.
Right. And does the research explain why this might be the case?
Yeah. So as I say, this is the latest in a range of studies that have looked at this.
And what they have found is that informing people about the scientific consensus really
can change people's attitude. And it speaks a bit to the authority that science has.
I think often people who are in science can sometimes despair thinking that some people
may not really be taking certain things like climate change seriously. But actually,
giving these facts, like 97% of climate scientists agree that human-caused climate change is real,
can actually shift their perspective.
Now, what we don't know with this is how long this effect lasts, whether these changes in
perspectives are enduring. Because other studies have shown that maybe this can change people's
mind for a little bit, but it may not last that long. And to get that real lasting change,
what many researchers are now saying is that you need to engage people with personal conversations.
So try and find the things that matter to them that you can engage with those people on.
So maybe they care about jobs, or energy, or things like that, and try and find the
climate perspective there. And that, many researchers believe, can lead to more long-lasting
change.
So engagement and dialogue, as is so often the way, is key. I mean, this seems like it
could be very useful in, say, policy spheres. Is there anything on that?
Yeah, so there's actually a part of the article that talks about a campaign that persuaded people
in a rural town in Canada to support a renewable energy policy. And the people who were involved
in that campaign said the top strategy they had was to get out of talking point fact land,
and instead exchange personal stories.
So rather than saying, like, oh, X amount of forest will be set on fire by 2030, or something
like that, instead they said things like, you know, there's now six weeks of the year where
I can't let my kids outside because there are fires around, and there's smoke, and things
like that. And so that sort of way of engaging with people may be better.
And there was also a study that was done recently, not about climate change, but about reducing
prejudice towards transgender people. And so what happened here is people went door
to door and asked people to share their views on this topic. Then, once they'd shared their
views, they asked the people to talk about a time that they'd faced judgment for being
different from others. And they found that this actually increased support for a non-discrimination
law, and the social acceptance that they saw persisted for at least three months when they
were resurveyed later.
And so it seems then that this approach has shown efficacy, and could when talking about
climate as well.
Obviously it'll have to be tested, and that is something that's being done. It's been
systematically tested, this approach for climate change. But the thing is, as the world
warms, as the world changes because of that warming, there is a climate change angle to
everything. So there are, for better or worse, increasing ways to engage people with conversations
about climate change, because it's something that is really affecting them now. And, you
know, they can really see it and feel the effects.
So there are ways to engage with people and try and meet them with the concerns that they
have about their lives. And hopefully with that, more people will be engaged with this
issue and move forward to try and prevent, as much as we can, the worst effects of climate
change.
Well, it's a topic that's not going to go away any time soon, and it does seem that
conversation is key. But let's leave it there for this week's briefing chat. And listeners,
for more on these stories, and where you can sign up to The Nature Briefing to get more
like them delivered directly to your inbox, check out the show notes for some links.
That's all for this week. As always, you can keep in touch with us on X, we're at
Nature Podcast. Or you can send an email to podcast at nature.com. I'm Nick Petruccio
and I'm Benjamin Thompson. Thanks for listening.