Podcast: Supplements for Preventing Alzheimer’s

NutritionFacts.org
722 followers
3.6K Video Views·Nov 7, 2024
If you’re anything like me,
you have lots of ambitious plans for the future.
I’ve got a whole series of new books I want to write,
thousands more videos to script.
But guess what?
None of us may be able to do any of the things we want to do
if we don't have our health.
Welcome to the NutritionFacts Podcast.
I’m your host, Dr. Michael Greger.
Today we look at new research about the efficacy of supplements
in preventing Alzheimer's disease.
Oxidative stress from free radicals
is the one of the pathways
implicated in the development and deterioration
of Alzheimer's brains,
given the evidence of excess oxidative DNA damage on autopsy.
So, what about trying an antioxidant?
Vitamin E levels tend to be lower
in the bloodstreams of those with cognitive impairment
or dementia, but which came first?
Maybe Alzheimer's disease led to poor eating,
rather than poor eating
leading to Alzheimer's disease.
Greater vitamin E intake from foods
is clearly associated with a lower risk
of developing Alzheimer's,
but greater vitamin E intake from supplements is not.
But, that didn't stop researchers
from including a vitamin E arm
in the largest primary prevention study
of Alzheimer's disease to date.
The Prevention of Alzheimer's Disease
by Vitamin E and Selenium trial
randomized more than 7500 older men
to take vitamin E, selenium, both, or neither-just placebos-
for five years.
To quote from the conclusion:
"Neither supplement prevented dementia."
A separate long-term vitamin E supplementation trial
of older women similarly found no protection
against cognitive decline.
Neither did vitamin E appear to benefit those
with mild cognitive impairment,
but the trials on Alzheimer's patients themselves
started to get more interesting.
The first trial,
published in the New England Journal of Medicine,
randomized more than 150 Alzheimer's patients
to vitamin E or placebo to see if vitamin E could slow
the progression of the disease.
The primary outcome was the number of days
until of one of any of the following happened:
death, institutionalization,
loss of the ability to perform basic activities
of daily living,
or sliding into severe dementia,
where you suffer a complete loss
of sense of time or place.
On first analysis, vitamin E flopped:
no significant slowing of progression.
Digging deeper, the researchers realized
that despite the random allotment,
the placebo group just by chance
ended up with patients with milder disease.
After taking that into account,
the difference in outcomes
between the vitamin E and placebo groups
widened substantially.
Now, this kind of unplanned post-hoc analysis
is heavily frowned upon,
but the effect seemed so sizable
they went ahead and published it.
In the placebo group,
the adjusted time to death or loss of independence
was 440 days, but in the vitamin E group,
after the baseline cognition was normalized,
it was 670 days, more than seven months later.
However, given the unorthodox analysis,
the scientific world waited
for the study to be replicated.
And here we go: more than 600 patients
with mild to moderate Alzheimer's disease
were subsequently randomized to vitamin E supplements,
the drug memantine, both, or neither (just placebos)
for two years.
Although there was no slowing of cognitive decline
after adjusting for multiple comparisons,
there was a slowing of functional decline,
in terms of managing daily activities
like bathing or dressing.
The vitamin E group appeared to only suffer
about 1.5 years of functional deterioration
in the two years' time,
resulting in approximately two hours less caregiver time
required each day compared to the drug group.
If those were the only two clinical vitamin E trials,
I would give vitamin E serious consideration
for those with Alzheimer's disease.
But, there's a third, a six-month trial,
that suggested vitamin E may be detrimental
to cognition in some Alzheimer's patients.
Obviously, more research needs to be done.
I'll cover other antioxidants that have been put to the test,
including vitamin C, beta carotene,
Centrum multivitamin,
and the minerals zinc and calcium.
Alzheimer's patients have significantly lower blood levels
of 8 out of 10 antioxidants investigated,
though, of course, this could just be a consequence
of demented individuals eating diets
poor in fruits and vegetables.
When put to the test,
the PREADViSE study found no benefit
for vitamin E or selenium
in terms of preventing dementia.
What about other antioxidants?
In the Harvard Physician's Health Study,
nearly 6,000 older men
were randomized to beta carotene or placebo.
No difference was found after three years,
but after 11 years,
those unknowingly taking the equivalent
of 3/4 cup (150 g) of sweet potato
worth of beta carotene a day
had slightly yet significantly better
overall cognitive performance.
A similar study of older women
found no cognitive benefit over a period of nine years.
Maybe they just didn't wait long enough?
Vitamin E and C were also tested.
Vitamin E similarly flopped throughout and so did vitamin C,
up until the last cognitive assessment at around year 9
where the vitamin C group appeared to pull ahead.
However, two trials of a combination of vitamin C, E,
and beta carotene together versus placebo,
one randomizing 1,500 older patients
for seven years, and another truly massive one
randomizing more than 20,000 adults for five years,
both failed to show any cognitive benefit
for the antioxidant cocktail.
What about a multivitamin?
The Physician's Health Study also tested
taking the daily multivitamin/multimineral
supplement Centrum Silver for 12 years.
Compared to those instead randomized to a placebo,
the Centrum group experienced no cognitive benefit.
Souvenaid is a nutritional drink
containing a patented formulation of nutrients,
branded as Fortasyn Connect,
specifically designed to help in Alzheimer's disease.
Unfortunately, it doesn't work.
There have been three randomized controlled trials
enrolling more than a thousand people,
and those taking Souvenaid were no less likely
to develop dementia in the first place,
and probably it has little or no effect
on measures of memory or other thinking skills
in both those with mild cognitive impairment
or Alzheimer's disease.
In terms of specific minerals other than the failed selenium,
zinc has similarly flopped to improve overall cognition
over months or years of supplementation,
and it's possible calcium supplements
could make things worse.
Cross-sectionally, those taking calcium
have more "hyperintensity" brain lesions on MRI
(shown here in red, denoting evidence of mini-strokes)
and longitudinally over time,
women taking calcium supplements
appear to have twice the odds of developing dementia.
The Women's Health Initiative should have been able
to settle the question once and for all.
Thousands of older women were randomized
to calcium supplements (plus vitamin D)
or placebo for about eight years.
Thankfully, there was no difference in the risk
of developing cognitive impairment or dementia.
But that's what was originally found
for heart attack and stroke rates
before pre-existing supplement use
was taken into account.
See, more than half of the women
were already taking personal calcium supplements
before entering the study
and being randomized to calcium or placebo.
You can imagine how this could muddy the results.
If you just look at the women
who weren't on calcium beforehand,
starting calcium resulted in a significant increase
in the risk of cardiovascular events,
consistent with a meta-analysis of calcium trials
showing a 15 percent increase in heart attacks or strokes
among those randomized to calcium supplements
over placebo.
Unfortunately, such a reanalysis
has yet to be performed on the dementia data.
The bottom line is that vitamin and mineral supplements
probably aren't going to help prevent dementia or treat it,
but there are tons of other things we can do.
We would love it if you could share with us your stories
about reinventing your health through evidence-based nutrition.
Go to nutritionfacts.org/testimonials.
We may share it on our social media to help inspire others.
If you want to see any graphs, charts, graphics, images, or studies mentioned here,
please go to the Nutrition Facts Podcast landing page.
There you’ll find all the detailed information you need –
plus, links to all of the sources we cite for each of these topics.
My latest book, “How Not to Age” has been out for about half a year now.
Check it out from your local public library.
And of course, all the proceeds I receive of the sales
of all my books goes directly to charity.
NutritionFacts.org is a nonprofit, science-based public service,
where you can sign up for free daily updates
on the latest in nutrition research via bite-sized videos and articles.
Everything on the website is free.
There’s no ads,
no corporate sponsorships, no kickbacks.
It’s strictly non-commercial. I’m not selling anything.
I just put it up as a public service, as a labor of love,
as a tribute to my grandmother,
whose own life was saved with evidence-based nutrition.
