St. Louis Gooey Butter Cake - Week 45 of the 2024 Baking Challenge!

Blackberry Hill House
143 followers
5 Video Views·Nov 9, 2024
hello and welcome to week whatever of
the 2024 baking
challenge has been a very long stressful
depressing week and I feel like that
absolutely calls for sugar so we are
making St Louis gooey buttercake grab
your
ingredients try to find a smile and
let's bake
[Music]
St Louis gooey buttercake is something
incredibly special don't you dare call
it ooey gooey buttercake that is not
what it is this is St Louis gooey
buttercake it's a funny story because it
was actually created on accident a baker
made a mistake and boom all of a sudden
the Midwest has the most amazing
delicious
fantastic dream dessert to start off
with we are going to have a small bowl
you have got three
tablespoons yes three tablespoons of
room temperature milk gross I know 2
tablespoon of lukewarm water that's all
in
here so gross um that's okay and two
tpoon of active dry
yeast all
right you're going to give that a little
mix
gently use my spatula and then you're
going to set that aside so what this is
going to do is this is going to start
activating the yeast I should pause and
explain exactly what a gooey buttercake
is you have a cake base and then you
have the
filling um so it's essentially a layer
cake except the center of the cake is
is
well sugar and
butter and a few other things but mostly
sugar and butter and it turns out
fantastic and it is one of my favorite
treats I've never made it before so this
is very exciting all right grab your
mixer and the rest of the ingredients
for your cake and I'll see you
back okay into the bowl of your mixing
you are going to have 6 tablespoons of
butter room temperature so at least
65° you're going to have 34s of a
tablespoon of salt and 3 tablespoon of
sugar
tablespoons yes
tablespoons I am going to apologize in
advance because the child is playing
games with his friends and it's very
loud also this was a half uh tablespoon
by the way so there you
go I'm making all kinds of
interesting decisions tonight with this
all right you're going to mix up your
butter sugar and your
salt all right while that's mixing I'm
going to crack my room temperature Egg
everything's got to be room temperature
for some reason at least for the cake
[Music]
part so let me get that egg cracked
oh there's a
shell there we go got it out
okay so you're going to get your egg
cracked you're going to get your butter
and your sugar mixture
going you are going to want to scrape
down the sides of your Bowl before you
add your egg
um I am making this on a Thursday night
this is like almost a 4our
bake and I have not been getting up and
doing this in the mornings because I
have to work so not enough time all
right got my S scraped going to go ahead
and get this kicked off
again and and in goes the
egg
okay all
right you want to get that pretty good
and mixed before you add in the
flour um so my bowl is not balanced this
is the new machine and I think I'm going
to have to get on the Mr mixer site and
get one of those
Springs um if you have a KitchenAid and
your paddle is not getting down into the
bowl go look up M
mixer um it is this fantastic company
and they work on kitchen AIDS they have
a ton of aftermarket parts and
things and one of those things things is
a ring that you can put on there to make
sure that that paddle goes to the bottom
of your bowl that way you're not leaving
ingredients in there all right to this
we are going to add our flour which is
one and 34s of a cup of flour so let me
grab that because I did not measure
anything out oh my flowers is on the
counter um I did not measure anything
out ahead of time because got off work I
had a quick dinner and here we
are so what did I say one and 34 cup
okay yeah I'm not well prepared for
today and that's all
right all right 3 +
4 is
uh
seven so I need seven seven of these
1/4
cups I'm going to go ahead and turn this
on low while I do
this so that's
one
two
three plus my cup which is
[Music]
one two
three
and
four while I'm sitting here thinking
about this I also believe that I did not
add enough of the water because I was
using
a half a tablespoon instead of a full so
let me add a little bit more to
that there we go
it's
fine all right it's a very crumbly
mixture in
here oh you're supposed to add the flour
and yeast mixture alternating in between
oops see this is why you shouldn't bake
when you're tired friends just don't do
it you're going to make
mistakes so my bad
it's
[Music]
fine yep that is a cake
mixture and you're supposed to end with
the flour scrape your bowl as
needed and then mix
again mine
is kind of a stiff consistency probably
because I got the directions out of
order and I do
apologize um I have actually been trying
to get this bake done all
week and here we are at the 11th Hour
getting it
done
so I have loved this challenge so
much
um but it is
definitely definitely a challenge as far
as time constraints especially now that
I am back in the corporate world so all
right let's give that another
[Music]
go mine's a little dry I am going to add
just a little bit more water to
mine
um
because I am not comfortable with how
dry it is so just going to add like
another half a tablespoon of water see
how that that
goes it's definitely getting better
there
okay all
right it's not going to be a cake batter
I know it says cake it's not going to be
a cake batter you're looking for more
like a dough it's a very firm almost
bread-like but very dense that's what
we're going for okay and mine has hit
that Mark I probably added a little too
much water at this point I don't
care so you're going to make sure you
get all of your
[Music]
dough
out and then we're going to backtrack to
the very first step of this which was to
grease a
13x9 baking pan I am so sorry use your
Pam it's fine it's it's not going to
hurt
anything all right I probably over
greased mine and my dough is a little
too wet but again it's been a week so
here we
go it's probably going to be easier for
you if you use your
hands
okay this is going to rise remember
remember this is a yeast dough so it is
going to rise you just want to make sure
you're covering the bottom it doesn't
have to be up the sides it just has to
cover the bottom okay
so just has to cover the
bottom I just don't want any of my
filling to get underneath there or the
top layer it's not really filling cuz
nothing is going to go on top of it it's
just a top layer of cake using that term
very Loosely okay what you're going to
do with this is you are going to cover
it and let it rise about 2 and 1 half
hours okay during that rise time just
don't worry about anything at the end of
the rising time you're going to preheat
your oven to 350° and then we're going
to make the topping so I'll see you back
in about 2 hours
so in true form for this week my cake
did not rise I was worried about that it
is really cold in here tonight I didn't
want to turn on the furnace or turn the
furnace up cuz I'm being stubborn
midwesterners know what it's like it's
going to be warm again in like 2 days so
we will just layer up and not make
anything that requires yeast to rise so
I went ahead and skipped an hour my
crust my the bottom part of my cake is
just going to be really dense and not
all that great and I'm okay with that
because that's just how the week is
we're going to make the filling I have
my oven preheating to
350 in a mixing bowl you're going to uh
mix up 12 tablespoons of room
temperature butter
unsalted and 1 and 1/2 cups of
granulated sugar plus a half a teaspoon
of salt hopefully this teeny tiny bowl
that came with this mixer is going to
get the job
done um I thought it was so cute and
that I would probably never ever use it
but here I
am so once that is Thoroughly mixed
you're going to oh I forgot see cuz I'm
forgetting things cuz I'm exhausted in a
separate Bowl you're going to to mix
together A4 of a cup of light corn syrup
2 tbspoon of water two and a half
teaspoons of vanilla extract oh two and
1 half teaspoons see I didn't add that
much and I thought it seemed off so
we're just going to do what I do best
with vanilla and wing it cuz nothing
else is measured correctly in here so
why
not you're going to mix that up because
we are going to be
alternating in a couple minutes we still
have to add the egg to
this um scrape the sides of the bowl and
add the egg I'm not going to I'm not
going to bother scraping the sides of
any Bowl I don't care that much I've
already made so many mistakes with this
recipe that I'm not I don't think it
matters that's that's where I'm at I
don't think it
matters all right we're going to add the
egg that's looking pretty good I will
scrape the sides of the
bowl this time
though I'll do it this time oh good the
oven is
ready let me turn this down to half
speed there okay turn it
off this little bowl is not too shabby I
like
this okay
okay I know I say that a lot so we're
going to add 1 and 1/4 cups of flour
alternating with our corn syrup mix
ending with the flour oky dookie here we
go so I'm going to go ahead and add the
fourth of a cup first or the half I'll
do the
half why not
all right there's the
flour and here is
like half of my syrup
mixture then we're going to do the other
half of the flour mixture of the flour
mixture it's not a mixture it's just
straight flour
and then we will do the
rest of the corn syrup
mix and then we're going to do our four
a cup of flour
now sometimes when you buy gooey
buttercake in the store it has a very
yellow look to it they're really playing
up the butter factor and I can almost
guarantee that that's a food color
additive you're not going to get that
bright yellow color with
homemade it's probably going to get a
little golden looking when we bake it
but don't expect that insane pop of
color at least I don't think so all
right I'm gonna scrape the sides of my
Bowl
here and give it
another another good
[Music]
mix so here 30 seconds more we're going
to mix
[Music]
this that's probably more than 30
seconds I don't
care down goes the
bowl see if I can get it off of here
now here we go so what you're going to
do is you're going to spoon this topping
over the cake the Risen and mine did
rise a little bit I'm being slightly
impatient because it's late and I'm
tired and just done with the world right
now but that's okay so you're just going
to spoon this
over like
so it's very light and
fluffy um this is not you guys this
can't even claim to be a healthy recipe
all right there is so much sugar in this
recipe um that it's yeah I mean this is
like don't eat more than one little
piece of this or you're going to make
yourself sick that's how much sugar is
in here between the crust and the
topping it's so sugary but so good using
an offset spatula and if you do not know
what an offset spatula is this is an
offset
spatula I have several of these in
different sizes and shapes I get mine
from Wilton I'll put a link below
they're the best I've had these for I
don't know like a decade longer so
you're going to use that spatula to kind
of even this out we're going to go all
the way are we going all the way to the
edges yeah yeah you're going to go all
the way to the
edges and try to make it nice smooth
even
layer
okay
okay this is the part where I get a
little
obsessive whenever something is supposed
to be smooth across and even on the top
I'm I'm going to work at it until it's
correct I can't help
myself it's like when I eat M&M's and I
color C them first yes I do and I'm okay
with
that just one of my little personality
quirks all right there we go get this
out of the
way this is going to go into the oven if
you're using a metal pan for about 30
minutes if you're using a glass pan or a
ceramic about
45 the cake is going to rise and fall in
like waves and have a golden brown top
but the center is still going to be
liquid when it's done okay this is one
of those
incredibly
deceptive kind of cakes this is going to
be
liquid you're going to take the cake out
and cool it completely in the pan then
you're going to dust it with
confectioner sugar now if you have never
dusted anything with confectioner
sugar what have you been doing with your
life and I'm going to show you the
easiest way to do that and make it look
like totally professional you're going
to want to get one of these mesh
strainers I love these I have a set of
three in different sizes I will post the
link below you put your sugar in top and
then you just tap tap tap tap tap all
over the top
okay then we're going to cut it we're
going to eat it and we're going to see
what it tastes
like real fast because I will absolutely
forget later this is not a dessert that
is stored outside of the refrigerator
okay the eggs the sugar the gooiness
you're going to want to store leftovers
in the refrigerator well wrapped okay I
just did not want to forget that there
you
go I overbaked my
cake um I had the issue with the cake
base not
Rising that doesn't seem to be a mistake
now it it Rose in the oven have a very
large cake to topping ratio not thrilled
about that um and I I did overbake
it I don't know if you can hear
this um my cake wasn't getting that
golden color and if you've been here
from from the beginning and you remember
the debacle with the butter bacon
molasses Tarts all the eggs mine didn't
bake correctly I ate it anyways I got
violently
ill there's egg in this I was a little
paranoid that's okay we're going to see
how it
tastes it smells like gooey butter cake
um again this should be opposite you
should have this much crust and this
much
filling but here we are and uh it is
what it
is
okay
okay the Cake part is honestly more like
a sweet bread it has the
consistency and texture of bread but it
is very sweet The Filling is a delight I
wish that there were two times the
amount of um topping on
this I like the crunch on the top I
think it's nice it's not like hard it's
not break your teeth it's not like um
burned so it's got a nice crunch to the
top where normal gooey buttercake does
not it's very soft on the top you're
going to have some
some denseness around the edges but
that's pretty much it I like this even
though I messed up the recipe completely
from start to finish I'm going to have
this for breakfast so successful bake
especially if you actually follow the
directions don't be like me don't let
your depression Cloud your baking mind
and your exhaustion just if you're too
tired to bake put it off a day and then
follow the directions
well that is it for week number 45 I
hope that you were able to bake a
successful St Louis gooey buttercake not
ooey gooey buttercake St Louis gooey
buttercake it came from here it's it's a
tradition all right don't don't mess
with Traditions be respectful please
um if you haven't already feel free to
hit the Subscribe button below I put out
one of these every single week um on
Saturday mornings at least until the end
of the year I don't know what direction
this channel is going to go in when this
challenge is over with um I've enjoyed
every second of it so we'll see also you
can head over to the Facebook page every
Wednesday morning I'm going to post the
name of what we will be baking and the
ingredient list that way you can decide
if you want to bake along and you can
get your shopping done in time I will
see you next week
[Music]
