(Ep. 235) Demystifying Life Insurance Myths with Rob Bertman and Lauryn Williams

Channeldo Credit
5 followers
1 Video View·Nov 10, 2024
The topic of life insurance has so many nuances that even people who already own policies find it confusing. Lauryn Williams, CFP®, CSLP®, and Rob Bertman, CFA, CFP®, discuss the complexities of life insurance and how it can be misused to exploit people. You’ll hear anecdotes of people who have invested in whole life insurance policies with high fees and low returns, sometimes being sold on the idea of building wealth by unscrupulous salespeople. The dynamic duo also shares how reputable financial advisors and investment options are more accessible and affordable than ever before. Finally, you’ll learn the importance of life insurance as a necessary product for catastrophic loss and ongoing support to safeguard your dependents.
I was one of the OG consultants at Student Loan Planner.
I was, in fact, the second hire.
But guess who I have on the podcast today?
The first hire, not the owner,
but the first hire after the owner.
It is the real deal Holyfield OG, Rob Burtman.
Hey, how are you doing today?
Hey, everybody, I'm good.
Yeah, Lauren, I remember it's been a long road together
and the company has grown incredibly fast.
It's kind of amazing to even think about how much it's grown.
Yeah, I think we're now 11 consultants deep.
Stay tuned for a new episode with our newest consultant
coming up soon as a matter of fact.
All right, so today we will be talking about
something that has been a thorn in our side
over the course of our professional year.
So Rob is both a CFP and a CFA.
I am a CFP and a CSLP.
The whole point in us telling you
about all these fancy certifications
that we know a lot about a lot
as it pertains to finances.
And one of the things that neither Rob nor I
am a big fan of is whole life insurance.
People get taken advantage of so frequently.
It really, really just makes us upset.
And so today we wanted to walk through
why whole life insurance sucks.
Rob, do you think that's a good topic,
a good title for today's episode?
I do.
I mean, to be more, I guess, more even keel,
it's a widely misused, right?
It's widely oversold.
Too many people have it that shouldn't.
And we're gonna talk about why that's the case.
But yeah, I mean, I've been an investment,
I've been an investment professional since 2001.
I've been in the investment industry for 22 years.
So I am the real OG of the SLP crew
because I think I'm the oldest person at 43 years old.
So I've seen a little bit of this
and I've seen how whole life or permanent insurance
is used for good and mostly how it's used for bad.
And I'm excited to dive in and talk with you, Lauren,
because I know you've seen a lot of great,
not a lot of great and horrible stuff with this.
And so we wanna make sure that you all out there know
if it should be a piece of your financial plan.
And for most of you, it won't be.
But we're gonna talk about why.
Something like that.
99% chance, no, it is not for you.
So before we jump in, a bit of a disclaimer,
Student Loan Planner does have an insurance arm
where they sell disability and term,
but neither Rob nor I sell disability or term.
That's a separate Student Loan Planner arm.
And guess what?
They do not sell whole life insurance.
So that should be in and of itself,
something that tells you like,
this is not something that SLP believes in
as an overall value standpoint for this company.
And I also wanted to say, Rob, at 43,
you are the one that is just outside
of the official title of millennial.
I am.
Millennials are now this year, 26 to 42.
So you really are an old bird, you Gen X-er.
I'm a cusper.
I was born in 79.
You do okay, though.
I've seen your reels on Instagram.
You seem pretty millennial to me.
If you haven't checked it out,
family budget expert, everybody.
Thanks.
Yeah, I'm trying to get a little bit silly
and I try to stay young.
And part of that's having kids.
And so it's like, before I might be like,
who's this weird guy?
But now it's like, oh, he's just a good dad.
He's like entertaining for his kids.
Absolutely.
So without further ado, let's jump in
and talk about this whole life insurance.
And I think I'd like to start really with a story
on what's even prompting us to talk about this topic.
It's still coming up.
We've done episodes in the past about this.
We talk about it frequently in blogs and other places,
but you still get people that don't know, haven't heard.
And so if you're newer to this podcast,
this is, like I said, a newer topic for you.
And just this morning, I had a gentleman come my way
who was putting 3% into his 401k.
So very, very small amount.
When we all know from a student loan perspective,
or maybe we don't know, I'm gonna tell you
that a easy, easy thing for you to do
is put money into your 401k.
That's going to save you money on taxes,
get you ready for retirement,
and also lower your student loan plan.
He was putting 3%, which was probably less than $600 a month
into his 401k, and then also putting $600 a month
into a whole life insurance policy.
And it was just like big red flag going off for me.
No, no, no.
And so as I got to talking to the gentleman,
he said he didn't really know why he had it.
He felt like it was kind of a scam.
The guy was very salesy,
but he didn't really feel like he could get out of it either.
And there was a whole bunch of myths
that he thought, or that the gentleman told him
as it relates to why this was a good product for him
that were all untrue,
and that's what we're gonna be talking to.
So it is happening all the time.
Yuck.
Right, I mean, I think a lot of it is,
well, we'll get into why.
We'll get into the why.
But first, the need for life insurance is a real need, right?
And so the way I like to think about life insurance
is when you're young,
you have all the future expenses ahead of you.
You're gonna buy a house.
You're gonna have kids maybe,
maybe send them to college.
You're gonna have cars.
You're gonna have vacations.
And so the idea behind insurance is,
when you're young in your career,
you haven't had time yet to build up your wealth.
So if something happened to me
and I haven't had time to build up my wealth
and I have a family,
I'm leaving them with nothing if I don't have insurance.
But over time, if we do things right
and get great financial advice,
work with awesome financial planners,
then our wealth will build over time,
plus the future expenses go down.
So kids graduate from college, house is paid off.
The need for, and you've had time to build your wealth,
the need for insurance isn't really there anymore.
And so the idea behind whole life or permanent insurance
is that you have it for your whole life, right?
You have it your entire life until you die,
you're paying premiums.
And what they say is that your premium
is gonna be the same, it will never go up
or it should stay pretty much the same your entire life.
Well, when you're in your 20s, that's like your prime,
in 30s and 40s, that's like your prime wealth building part.
And if you're putting it into this product,
rather than putting it into a Roth IRA or your 401k
or paying down credit card debt
or building your emergency fund,
you're really setting yourself up
to be way behind in the future.
Because at the end of the day,
whole life insurance is just, simply put,
it is a super high fee, high commission product
that has very, very, very low investment returns.
So you're paying a lot for like very little.
And we're gonna dive into-
I always call it like a really crappy savings account
because that's what it ends up being as far as returns.
There's been a lot of, like you said, studies and things
and like the high end is like 2%,
which in this current market,
we're getting 3.5 on savings accounts.
So it's a really, really crappy product.
It is.
And let's talk about how it works, right?
So the idea behind insurance is you pay a premium.
And if I were to die and I'm paying life insurance,
then my beneficiaries, could be my family,
could be a trust, could be whatever,
will get the proceeds, the death benefit when I die.
And with whole life insurance or permanent insurance,
the premium is a lot higher than term.
It sometimes is five, 10 times the premium.
And so part of it goes toward that death benefit coverage.
And then the other part goes
into this cash value accumulation account,
which is just a fancy way to say,
it's an investment account that's invested in stocks,
bonds, cash, real estate.
But the problem with, that all sounds good, right?
But the problem with that is, again,
super high fees, super high commission product.
So that's kind of how the insurance works.
And we'll talk about the fees and commissions,
but anything to add there, Lauren?
I think you got it covered right there.
I think the one thing that kind of stands out to me
as I think about it is this idea that,
like you said, the really high fees
is the part that they don't ever talk about,
but they do talk about the investment aspects of it.
So you think of it sitting
on that consumer side of the table,
the things that you're hearing is like, oh, real estate.
Like, oh, I want to invest in real estate.
I want to be in that.
You can get a REIT and be in real estate.
You can get an ETF that has real estate in it
and be doing much better on return.
So I think just thinking through
like what the little pieces of the puzzle are
that the person is telling you
as they're trying to tell you
about this wonderful, awesome thing is,
hey, wait, does this really make sense?
Like you also mentioned like a death benefit.
So that's the point of any insurance.
Health insurance, if you get ill,
you want your insurance to kick in
because a catastrophe has happened.
Auto insurance, you want your insurance to kick in
because a catastrophe has happened.
Life insurance, a catastrophe of some sort has happened.
You no longer exist.
You want the benefit to go to the people,
to your point, Rob,
that might need that cash from your life
because they no longer have your earnings
to be able to support themselves.
So be thinking about it as that.
This is something that's going to cover me
in the event of a catastrophic loss.
It is not, in fact, an investment vehicle.
Totally, totally.
And I can tell you, I'll go into an anecdote
and then I'll tell a couple of stories
or what I've seen and then talk about the cause of that.
So I've analyzed a bunch of whole life policies
and permanent investment,
permanent insurance policies over the years
just by nature of being in the business.
And I have not yet found a case where up to 10 years
and maybe a little bit beyond
where the amount of money of premiums
have been paid into the policy.
Remember, this is supposed to be an investment product.
So you would think the goal is,
if you invest $1,000 a month, let's say,
for 10 years and you earn a 7% return
and you're putting $1,000 a month,
that $120,000 invested at 7% annual returns
will grow to be $200,000.
You've only put in 120
and the returns have given you an extra 80,000.
Your money is working for you, right?
That's how it's supposed to work.
But when it comes to these whole life policies,
not only has the cash value in the one,
I'm talking every single one I've analyzed
that has been the 10 years or less,
not only has it not grown,
it is less than the value of the premium is put in.
So for example, if someone has put in $1,000 a month
into a whole life policy,
thinking they're getting an investment return,
the actual value of the cash value
is less than what they put in.
In other words, they would have been better off
putting money in the bank or putting it under their mattress
than putting it into these policies.
And I'll tell you why in a sec,
but first of all, I want to see if you have.
See anything like that too.
Yeah, I just think of the things
that I've experienced as well.
So like you said, in communities
where people don't have a lot of money,
in communities where a lot of minorities
don't have a lot of financial literacy,
my particular background,
what it's been sold as or that cash value component
is like you said, this investment piece of the puzzle.
And the reason that sometimes people
are really excited about it and like,
this is awesome, you should also get it,
is because they're not able to save on a monthly basis.
So they're stretching themselves so thin
to be able to put money into this life insurance.
And they're like, I also have this cash value.
Then something happens,
and they don't have an emergency fund.
And so guess what happens?
The three or 4,000 that they got into that cash life,
saves the day for them.
But they don't ever think about the fact that,
like you said, if they've been doing $500 a month
for the last three years,
that was 6,000 times three or 18,000.
You have $18,000 you could have had as your emergency fund
and instead this life insurance is saving you,
quote unquote, in this moment with two or three grand
and whatever type of emergency you're having.
So that's an area where I see people
not being able to do the math or see it
or really see the full picture of how this works
and realize that they're being gypped
and also would go and tell a friend
that this is a good thing, quote unquote.
Or worse yet, they don't have enough money
in cash value to take out.
And so they end up going into credit card debt
at 20 to 30%.
And so you're being charged 20 to 30% interest
and you're not earning anywhere close to that
in these whole life policies.
In fact, it's a negative return for the first 10 years.
So why is it a negative return, right?
Because like we talked about,
the cash is being invested in investments, right?
Here's the real problem.
It's all about the commissions.
And I can tell you that this is not easy to find anywhere.
You cannot find this in the disclosures
when they give you their policies.
I've looked and looked and looked.
The only reason I know this is because the person,
my insurance person, who I'm no longer using,
tried to sell it to me.
And this was maybe 10 years ago when I had my second kid.
And I was like, well, I don't,
honestly, I think I know about it, but I don't.
So can you tell me a little bit about how the fees work?
He couldn't explain it to me.
So I said, well, do you have someone that will?
He brought his manager.
His manager couldn't explain it to me.
So they went up the rung one more step
and I finally got it explained to me.
And I honestly don't think,
I think that people who sell whole life insurance
are not bad people, a lot of them, right?
They think they're doing the right thing.
This is their training, their background.
And so they feel like they're helping people.
And so their heart's in the right place.
But the method is, in my mind, is completely wrong.
So here's how the commissions work.
And this is gonna blow your mind.
Okay, and this is any insurance, really.
This is term insurance.
And these numbers are not exact per company,
but they'll be pretty close.
So the first year premium,
any guess how much of that first year premium
is commissioned?
So let's say, for example,
if you work with an investment advisor,
they'll charge one to one and a half percent
of your investments, right?
So if you put $1,000 in,
they're charging you $10 on that first $1,000 or $15, right?
Over the course of a year, if you invest 12,000,
you're probably gonna pay about $12 in fees, $18 in fees.
Or if you have a robo-advisor,
it's gonna be a fraction of that,
less than a dollar, probably.
So with that in mind,
any idea on what the commissions are
for the first year of life insurance?
Since you're telling me that they're astronomical,
we can hear it in your voice, Rob.
I'm gonna go with maybe six month worth
of whatever you put in,
because that would be pretty, like I said,
in this $500 example we've been kinda using,
six times five was $3,000 of I put my money in.
Do they get all of that?
They get more, more than that.
So the first year commission,
and now the person who is selling the whole life
doesn't necessarily get all of this.
This goes to the company and then there's a split, right?
Just like any commission business.
100% of the first year premium is commission.
So you put in that $500 a month,
none of that actually hits your cash value.
It's all commission and fees.
So 6,000 in, 6,000 out, okay?
It goes down over time, but guess what it is in year two?
90%?
Well, it's 50%, five, zero, right?
So it's half.
And then it goes down to 25%
and then eventually it goes down to a trailing three to 5%.
Now, even that trailing is much higher
than any other investment product out there, right?
Any other investment product
might charge you one to one and a half percent tops.
They're charging three to 5% of the premium that you put in.
Now-
Forever and ever.
And not only that, but okay, so think about it.
So if you pay 100% commission in year one
and 50% commission in year two,
you've paid for two years, 24 months.
18 of those months of payments is commission.
You're only left with a quarter of what you put in
that would even enter that cash value.
So I'll give you an example of this.
So I had a client who had paid
into a whole life policy for three years
and they put in, I think it was like,
let's just call it $1,000 a month, $36,000.
Their cash value in their account was $20,000
after three years, so $16,000 less.
But the surrender value,
which is like if you cancel the policy,
what you get out of it was $6,000.
So they had put in 36,
but if they canceled it, they would only get six out.
This is where I like really get angry
because to your point,
I have also analyzed quite a few of these.
And a lot of times people are coming to me,
and I'm looking at your full financial picture
and we get to these insurance policies.
They're like, yeah, I got insurance.
Look at me, like one of the things I did
because a lot of it, you know, when I ask you questions,
like, oh, don't have an accountant.
Oh, don't really understand my 401k.
You know, there's these things
that they recognize are wrong,
but they think like, I got insurance, Laura,
you're gonna be so proud.
And then I'm looking at the policy
and I'm like, oh my God.
And then it's like, we have to decide,
do I hold on to this for a couple more years
to even get out of this area
where the surrender fee is crappy
and I can't really get anything?
Or, you know, do we just like throw it all in right now
and just say, we'll go get some different insurance.
But it's ridiculous to see these numbers.
You just said what, 36,000 went into this policy?
Here's your six, you can have it back.
Right, and it's hard to convince people
once they're in it to get out of it,
because, you know, again, if you have one of these policies,
if you're out there listening like, oh my gosh,
I made a mistake, there's nothing wrong with you.
It's what you were told.
But the difficult conversation comes in,
why is the surrender value only $6,000?
It's because that's all that's in the account in real life.
The cash value is not there, it's already gone.
And so you have to have the conversation,
we put in 36, this thing is worth six,
and we're still paying $1,000 a month,
is it just worth it to keep it?
And the answer, in my opinion, is no.
Because you're still paying 25% in year three,
you put in 1,000, 250 of that is coming,
still going to commission, right?
And then after that, it's still gonna be
the most expensive fee product,
investment product that you have.
And plus, this client also had $25,000 of credit card debt.
Which, as we know, if we put $1,000 toward that,
that would have been gone.
So, and they had credit card debt
when this policy was sold to them.
So it's all about the fees that are really
what makes this really, really bad.
If I had a client come to me and said,
I'm invested in a blended diversified portfolio
of stocks, bonds, cash, real estate,
I'd be like, great.
If they said, well, but it's in cash value,
I would say, ooh, you're paying a ton of fees.
And you're not gonna earn that
five to 7% they're projecting, right?
They have their projection
and they have the guaranteed rate of return.
And those are different.
So it's, you know, they would have been better off
putting money under their mattress.
And literally under their mattress, exactly.
And they would have been in a better position.
So, have you ever seen anything like that?
I have seen quite a few situations.
Luckily, I think the word about term insurance
is getting out and people are less and less
getting involved in those whole life policies.
But I wanted to circle back to your point
about the person selling it is not a bad person.
Because I think that that's a really thing
that we should, like someone who is listening to this,
like you said, the number of life insurance salesmen
that are out there, someone is listening
and they're offended.
They're like, oh my goodness.
But what I've experienced is like you said,
these are sometimes very religious,
very high moral, very high value.
One of the things you touched on though
is that the person can't explain the insurance policy to you.
If you ask the right questions, they can't explain it.
They've been trained to sell.
They've been trained to tell you exactly how awesome it is.
And all they've been told is how awesome it is.
You went up to the next rung and they also said,
oh, I have no idea how this actually works.
And once someone actually does learn that,
a lot of people that we see
are leaving the insurance industry.
They're like, this doesn't feel good to me.
Or they're staying in insurance,
but now they're switching over
and they are pushing like a term product
or something that is a lot more appropriate
based on a person's personal situation.
But it's all about knowledge.
And the lack of knowledge, the ignorance is the one thing
that can be so damaging and so destructive.
And like I said, I've seen it over and over again
in my community.
And I also was a victim of that.
Very beginning of my career as a professional athlete,
I was single, 20 years old.
I had a million dollars of whole life insurance.
I was paying roughly six grand a year.
And this is back in like 2004 ish.
So God knows what it costs now
for this million dollars of whole life insurance.
When I'm 20, I'm in the best shape of my life.
For 20 bucks a month,
I probably could have got two or $3 million of insurance.
And been set up for the point
at which I wanted to get a family or kids
or things like that,
which is another point that a lot of times people talk about
like, when do you need insurance?
If you're single and you don't have any kids
and things like that,
maybe it's not even the right time to get it.
You've got to decide what's appropriate for you
based on what your future looks like.
But the person who sold me the insurance,
I still wouldn't classify as a bad person to this day,
but I absolutely did not need that insurance.
Definitely.
And all the people I know that sell insurance
or most of them are good people.
They've got, they're very kind people.
They're trying to do the best they can.
They're trying to do what they can.
But the way that the insurance companies are set up,
and there are a couple in particular
that have really this down to a science,
they hire young people
who have networks of young professionals.
And they say, go out and close X amount,
have X amount of meetings a week
and try to close this amount.
And if you do, you're gonna make this much money.
And here's why it's good for them, right?
We all see the commercials,
we all see the marketing materials,
and they think, great, I can help people and make money.
This is great.
So why are the insurance companies incentivizing
young people to sell to their friends?
Well, typically young people don't have investable assets.
So they can't go about
the traditional financial planning route.
Although there's now flat fee advising, right?
Where you can now just, it's very explicit fees,
$3,000 for financial plan or whatever.
And that's it.
Where the AUM model, the assets under management model,
where you're being charged a percentage,
it's hard to find 20 somethings
that have enough to make it worthwhile.
So if someone, if a young friend of yours has $100,000
and they charge one and a half percent,
the commission on that's gonna be 1500 a year, right?
Or the-
Living as a financial planner on that.
Totally.
But if you sell them a whole life policy
and you get them to pay $500 a month,
that's $6,000 a year commission for the company.
And then the next year it's 3,000.
So they make $9,000 in commission over two years
instead of maybe three or $4,000 over,
if they even have that investable money to start with.
So that is my opinion on why the industry is set up for that
because it's a way to collect fees and commissions
for people that haven't yet gotten,
because haven't yet gotten built up their wealth.
Because if you think about, Lauren,
who are the kind of people that get the most calls
and you see most often in these policies?
What professions do you know?
For me, it's dentistry and physicians in residency.
They hit them up while they're still early, young.
You know they're gonna make a lot of money.
You're telling them how important it is
to make sure that they secure their family's future now.
I've seen that quite a bit.
Is there a different profession that you've seen?
No, those are the keys.
Any, it's like they have a list of residents
and newly minted attending physicians
or dentists who just graduated dental school.
They're making, they just had their income jump way up
from residency salary to full on attending salary.
Sometimes, you know, five, six X the income
in a short amount of time
and they're looking for things to do.
And so they can easily sell a $1,000 a month
insurance policy or 2,000 a month insurance policy.
I also see this a lot in the real estate industry,
real estate, commercial real estate professionals
because their income is pretty inconsistent
but can be very high over time.
And so usually it's the high income professions
which there's a lot of our audience here
at Student Loan Planner, graduate level professionals
who are doing that kind of work.
So the thing that stands out to me about what you said
is the way that the system is set up.
And I think that is why people listen to podcasts
in the first place.
They're trying to get better handle
on their personal finances
and we don't understand the system.
So it's like, I don't understand my personal finances
but then as I learned more about my personal finances,
I realized there's like 10 rabbit holes.
So it's like, oh, I learned this about budgeting
and now here's the 10 rabbit holes.
Here's the 10 different ways to budget.
You know, now we're talking about insurance.
Oh, there's term insurance and whole, I should avoid it.
But also like, if you really wanna know,
like here's all the different things you need to know.
And it gets overwhelming for people
but understanding the way the system works,
the more you know, the more you can fight back against it.
And to your point, you said financial planners
traditionally have not wanted to deal with people
who don't have a lot of assets
but now you have networks like X, Y, P, N
where they're focusing on young professionals.
You have, I think it's Garrett Planning Network
where they work only hourly.
So you're not gonna be measured
or you're not gonna be able to only get access
to financial planning help or a certified financial planner
which is the person who's kind of like a general practitioner
in the financial planning industry.
You're not only gonna be able to get access to them
if you have a million dollars.
Cause you're like, once I've gotten a million dollars
in the bank, what do I need a financial planner for?
You do, you do still need a financial planner
but we all need financial planners as well
no matter what your earning levels are.
So don't be afraid to find someone
that is appropriate for you
and don't be afraid to look and say like,
hey, this is how the system always works.
This is what I know about it
but is there any other alternative?
That's what we're talking about.
It's like insurance people hold themselves out
as financial advisors all the time.
So that's another piece of the puzzle.
He was like, oh, my financial advisor, blah, blah, blah
fill in the blank.
And then I hear they only have a million dollars
of whole life insurance.
They don't have any investment accounts.
They don't have any other aspects
of their financial life in place.
And it's like, that's not a financial advisor.
That's someone who sold you whole life insurance.
Whereas you actually need someone
that can look at your full financial picture.
So all I'm saying in this messaging is don't be afraid
to kind of look beyond what is right in front of you
and see how you can best be helped
because there are professionals out there
that are willing and ready to help you.
And don't be afraid to overcome that fear.
Like, oh my God, I bought this thing.
If you're listening to us and you're like,
I'm feeling shame, I'm feeling guilt,
I feel a little bit embarrassed
about what I didn't know about this.
Like you guys have pulled the cloak off,
but also I have no idea where to start.
Start by saying, hey, this is not okay
and I'm gonna look into this more.
This podcast is just the introduction.
There's a lot of places that you can go.
And I think actually, Rob, you and I,
maybe we should do a podcast about getting help
and the idea that people don't even know
what they need sometimes and how they can overcome
that idea of like, ah, I'm scared to get help
about this thing that is really scary for me.
I think that's great.
I would love to do that.
I think it's super important.
And I mean, you're right.
It's never been easier to get financial advice,
good financial advice, I should say.
There are any number of different advisors out there
that are really reputable.
You can see the reviews.
You can see what people are talking about.
I mean, access to investing.
I mean, I remember when I was starting out,
I mean, you used to charge 5 cents a share to trade,
or like $20 per trade.
Now trading is free.
You used to only be able to get into A share
or C share mutual funds paying 6% or 5% on the front end
or trailing 1% a year or 2% a year.
And now you can trade for a fraction of a 10th of a percent,
not even a 10th of a percent, but less than that.
And there's all sorts of,
there's so many young people out there
that care about helping people.
Kind of like your story
of how you got into financial planning,
that people are trying to come up
with better economic models to serve those
who haven't been served in the past
and help provide access to high quality financial planning,
high quality financial literacy at a low cost
and get exactly what they need.
So I would say life insurance,
the industry in general is kind of antiquated
because it came out in a time
where marginal tax rates were like 80%, right?
So people used to sell this as, oh, it's tax deferred.
You'll never pay taxes on the investments in here.
And that's worth, that was worth something back then.
And it's worth a little bit today,
but only if you've exhausted every single other aspect
of financial planning.
I mean, full life insurance does have a path
for super wealthy people
who they've exhausted every other option there.
They've maxed out,
they've got millions of dollars in retirement,
they've got their backdoor Roths going,
they've got their brokerage accounts,
they've got, I mean, they've got everything in place.
Right, Lauren?
Literally, they've got money coming out of their ears.
And that is yet another one of those sales pitches.
This is what rich people are doing.
You'll hear a life insurance agent tell you that
all the time.
And you're like, oh my goodness,
if this is what the rich people are doing,
let me get on board and start doing
what the rich people are doing.
It literally only makes sense for somebody who,
like you said, they already maxed out their 401k,
already maxed out their Roth IRA.
Like they've got money coming out the wazoo,
and they're trying to find yet another place
to put their money.
It's an additional vehicle for them.
For 99% of America to your point,
360 million people,
we know that more than half of them
don't even have enough to cover a $500 emergency.
So we can't cover an emergency,
we're probably not putting enough into our 401k,
we don't need this full life insurance.
And so that's an easy way to be thinking about
why this is not appropriate.
Another thing you brought up though,
you mentioned the education piece of the puzzle.
They sell it also as a great place
to be able to hide funds,
to get ready for your kid's education
so that from a FastBus standpoint,
your income is lower or whatever the case may be.
Do you wanna talk a little bit about that?
I know that was one of the things
that the gentleman mentioned
that I was talking to recently as well.
Yeah, I mean, it is a way to do that.
It's a super high expensive way.
I'm a big believer that you don't do things
to totally disrupt your financial life
in order to save a little bit of money here or there.
I mean, there are other things,
other better things you can do
if you're like on the cusp of qualifying.
But I feel like there's kind of this mindset sometimes
of I'm gonna hide all my assets
or I'm gonna put them all over here
or I'm gonna, so I can declare bankruptcy
or get out of my student debt.
I just feel like that mindset doesn't serve.
It's kind of like,
some people have an anti-wealth mindset
where they're against it or they feel like,
and that's okay.
But sometimes what happens is that mindset
stops people from accumulating wealth themselves
because they feel like there's a conflict.
Like I can't be rich because I don't,
I think there's a disparity,
which is, again, whatever you believe is fine,
but just know that these are mindsets
that can hold us back.
I would think a bigger issue with this whole life
and how it's sold is just,
if you need money, just take money out.
You can take it out as a loan.
And so they say you can rely on this money if you need it.
Kind of like what you were talking about before
where you've got this forced savings,
which then you can take the money out.
The fallacy there is that you are actually charged
6% to 8% interest on that money
that you take out of your whole life policy.
And then they say, when you put it back,
if you put it back, don't worry,
we're gonna act as if you invested the whole time.
We're gonna give you those investment returns
you would have earned.
But the problem is,
most people don't put money back
into their insurance policy once they take it out.
In fact, they rely on it and rely on it
and rely on it until it eventually goes away for good.
Like the policy has to be canceled
because there's not enough to pay the premium.
So it's, I think that's a big fallacy too.
There's this whole concept called infinite banking
where you kind of become your own bank
in your insurance policy.
But what we talked about before
is you actually have less to borrow from yourself
because of all the high fees and commission.
So, and then you have to pay interest
on the policy that you take out anyway,
when you would be better off putting money in a bank
and then taking a loan out against the bank.
And you would have a lot more money saved up,
a lot greater net worth if you kind of invested instead.
And you can get a much better loan
from any financial institution.
It doesn't have to be a traditional bank.
It could be anywhere.
That's gonna be much better
than taking it out in the whole life policy.
I think what you just explained is,
people who have lower income,
they are preying on people with very little income
and actually putting you in a worse financial situation,
which is one of the problems
with creating generational wealth,
closing the racial wealth divide.
All of those different things
that we're constantly talking about,
they're preying on the idea of what you don't know.
So people wanna make good decisions for their kids.
They're like, I wanna be able to pay for my kid's education.
Let me do this thing because that's what they said.
But you might've forgot to do something very simple.
It's like, am I even gonna be in the realm
of people who need to hire?
Do I have enough income to even need
to be thinking about this strategy
so that I don't have the income
so I can qualify for FAFSA or whatever?
Like you might not even be in the income level
where that's relevant, period.
But they painted it as a picture
of like something else that can help you.
Then there's that piece of the puzzle of like,
this is not absolutely something
that's going to help me over time.
Rob just gave you 97 examples
of like why this is not a good idea.
And I think that the key piece of the puzzle
is like tuning into like, hey,
am I being sold something that's actually gonna prevent me
from building wealth?
Or am I being sold something
that's gonna help me gain wealth?
Am I having a hard time saving?
And is this something that like,
oh, I could see myself getting this money in here
thinking that this was a good investment.
But then, oh, I didn't realize that I'm actually,
I could just put this money in a savings account
and I don't have to worry about all these stipulations
related to getting my money out later on down the road.
These are all the things that happen
that get people preyed upon, yeah.
Yeah, and it's really bad because what ends up happening
is they have less money to draw on
because a lot of it's gone to fees and commissions
and they put themselves in a bad situation
when they take it out.
So it's really bad for anyone who is not super duper wealthy
who has exhausted every single other avenue of investments.
So yes, it is what rich people do,
but it's because rich people have exhausted every other means
if they've done it right.
So let's-
This is depressing.
I like to think of this as like reverse Robin Hood.
That's what I'm gonna start calling it.
They're robbing from the poor and giving to the rich.
Like taking people who already don't have a lot,
taking the little bit that they have
and then making themselves filthy rich.
Yeah, it's...
I mean, maybe we can turn this around, Lauren,
and let's talk through some things
that people should do instead.
Okay, yeah, let's do this.
Finish on a high note, people.
Yeah, so Lauren, what else can people do
if they're thinking about taking out whole life insurance?
What could they do instead
that would be much more positive for their future wealth
instead of getting in a whole life policy?
Well, at the very top of the show,
we talked about this term insurance,
and we didn't go a whole lot into it today,
but it is the alternative.
And so the example I always like to give
is like million dollar policy,
you could probably get for 50 bucks a month
if you're pretty young.
Whole life insurance for that same million dollars
is probably like 500.
And so to your point, like 10 times as much,
you know, spend the 50 bucks a month,
get your million dollars of insurance,
make sure that your family is covered
in the event of your loss,
in the event of the loss of your life,
that that income that you're providing
and that support you're providing can be replaced
while you go ahead and build wealth.
Take that other $450 and invest it.
So instead, get yourself some terms
and invest the difference is what I'm saying,
based on what that person is telling you,
you can afford to pay for your whole life insurance,
which is probably gonna be much less coverage
than you would get for term insurance anyway.
Absolutely.
Yeah, I like to tell,
I think it's really important
that people set the financial foundation.
And what I consider the financial foundation
is credit card debt-free,
doesn't matter if it's 0% interest or whatever,
get rid of all of it.
An emergency fund of whatever you feel is necessary
if your income is unpredictable.
Unpredictable, you need more
than if someone has a super steady income.
You know, most people say three months,
but you can go plus or minus on either side.
And then three is getting the max match
from your employer retirement account.
If they offer a match,
make sure you're taking full advantage of that.
If you're not doing any of that,
that is gonna give you the biggest bang for your buck.
It's gonna set you up for financial success right there.
And you'll have your basis covered.
I mean, imagine having no credit card debt,
having a cash cushion in place
and making sure that you're investing for the longterm
in the most efficient way possible.
Like, how much better off would you feel
under that circumstance?
So.
There is somebody who's listening to this podcast,
has been listening to us for a year.
They love our podcast.
And they still not done any of those three things.
What do you think it is that's holding them back
from doing this?
My thought process is that it's not sexy.
They're listening because they're like,
you guys give some good advice,
but I really wanna know when you're gonna,
one episode tell us how to make a million,
take my $1 and turn it into a million.
Like, can't you give them something more sexy to do
than those three things?
You know, I mean, the number one predictor
of future financial success
isn't what you do with the money.
It's how much you have left over in the first place.
So a lot of times we feel like we have to budget
or we have to give up what we love
and cut out the bad stuff.
But just think about a better way to think about it, right?
A more empowering, positive mindset is
how can I take every single dollar that I have
and deploy it in a way that helps me live my best life
and everything else, let's put it towards building my wealth
in the best way possible.
And if you think about, I wanna live my best life
and build my wealth over time
so I can have that financial independence,
think about it that way,
rather than, oh, I have to do all this stuff
and this is boring or I don't understand.
If we start thinking of approaching it that way,
you start thinking about your money differently
and better, right?
Amen, hallelujah.
Today is action day.
There's somebody who is listening to this podcast
who has been listening to this podcast
and you still are working on that credit card data
slowly but surely.
Let's turn it up a notch.
You know that you can put one or two more percent
into your 401k.
Come on, you can do it.
Hang up the podcast and go do that thing now.
Start putting the money into the emergency fund.
Set up the auto transfer as soon as you're done listening.
The basics will get you where you need to go
and you know we've been saying the same thing
over and over and over again.
So why not give it a try?
And we have to add, of course,
if you have six-figure student loan debt,
you need to have a clear path on how to pay that back.
So make sure you get a student loan consult also
because you can actually save a ton of money
if you go about paying your student loans
in the more efficient way.
And student loan rules, as we all know,
as you all know out there,
super complicated, super different
than any other kind of debt out there.
So let's get that cleared up.
And Lauren, exactly what you said,
let's get this stuff moving.
All right, this has been another episode of Student Loan.
If you have student loan debt, like Rob said,
and you don't know where to find us,
you found this podcast,
but we are at studentloanplanner.com.
Very easy, very simple.
You can set up a 60-minute consultation
and we will create a plan for you.
We will also point you in the right direction
as it relates to some of this stuff
because everybody on our team is a CSOP, CFP, CFA.
We've got all kinds of financial titles.
So we can help you a little bit above and beyond
just getting your student loan plan.
Don't be afraid to take action.
Let's get going.
I'll see you the next time.
