(Ep. 179) The Income-Driven Repayment Waiver: What You Need to Know

Act Funding
1 follower
2 Video Views·Nov 15, 2024
Vastly underreported in the media, the IDR waiver is currently being portrayed as an option for tens of thousands who are eligible for PSLF or income-driven repayment. Join me as I discuss this once-in-a-lifetime opportunity, and how I see this as a way to help millions get forgiveness. Listen in as I break down all you need to know about the IDR waiver!
Hello and welcome to another episode
of the Student Loan Planner Podcast.
I'm your host, Travis Hornsby,
and today we are going to talk about
one of the most earth-shattering things
that I think I've ever seen when it comes to student loans.
We're gonna talk about the IDR waiver,
Income Driven Repayment Waiver.
This is one of the biggest deals I've ever, ever
had happen in six years of doing this.
The media is vastly under-reporting this.
People are not talking about this like they should be.
People are not raising borrower awareness
like they should be.
This is being sold as this thing
that's gonna help 40,000 people get PSLF
and a few thousand people get Income Driven Repayment
when we actually think that this could be something
that helps get millions of people forgiveness.
I'm gonna go into a great detail why in this podcast
as to why I think that, and I want to make you aware of this
and I also want to, frankly, make you aware
that there's probably gonna be
some major political fights about this.
I've debated about how transparent
to be about all of these things
because I don't want to imperil your potential
for getting this benefit,
but I also think the best medicine is transparency
and looking into the details of things
because what's really gonna happen
with all of these different programs
is that there's something to find,
somebody's gonna find it.
We need to be prepared to help you plan
for whatever will probably happen.
So I just wanted to go into what's going on
with the IDR waiver,
how you need to be paying attention to this,
who could benefit from this,
and what kind of just political and legal headlines
I think that we're gonna see with this IDR waiver
in the coming weeks.
First off, I want to set the stage for you.
So what is the IDR waiver?
Back in April 19th, I believe it was,
the administration announced that they are coming out
with this major IDR waiver to help rectify
all of the past periods of borrowers
not being given credit towards income-based repayment.
So if you look at the genesis of this,
it was an April 1st report from NPR
that found that 32 borrowers had received forgiveness
and 4.4 million people had been in repayment
for 20 years or more.
Now, there's a lot of power politics going on here, folks.
I just want to kind of make you aware
of everything that's happening.
There are probably people at either Department of Ed
or CFPB who basically are following a playbook here, right?
So PSLF waiver, what happened?
60 minutes, you feature people from the military
that have not gotten PSLF.
Shortly thereafter, boom, PSLF waiver.
This time, a bunch of stuff gets leaked to NPR,
intentionally, I think, to build a case
for the IDR waiver coming out
that they were going to do anyway, right?
And then you have this big NPR article that comes out
that looks like this bombshell report.
It is obviously pretty shocking that only 32 people got it.
And 4.4 million people have been in repayment,
according to that article, for 20 years or more.
Then boom, IDR waiver.
So that's one thing that I would be really hyper aware of
is whenever you see these bombshell reports,
there's probably a sort of strategy that's coming behind it.
So that would be one thing to be paying attention to
when we're thinking about cancellation
that might happen in the future.
Will we see some sort of bombshell report
from fill-in-the-blank, a major podcast,
New York Times, or WashPo, or something like that,
that gets dropped?
Then if you do, I think that what you're going to see
is a couple weeks after that,
you're going to see some sort of major announcement
by Department of Education.
Now, what's going on with these numbers?
How did they calculate these numbers?
So I've been digging into this like crazy,
trying to figure out how is the Department of Education
calculating how many people have been in repayment
for such a long period of time?
Now, it was an interesting letter to an acting secretary.
I think of the Treasury around February 2021
that was looking into how many people
have what kind of loans.
I think it was for like the PPP program purposes
because certain people I think were not included in that
because of their student loans.
So they were just trying to calculate
how many people have been in repayment
for certain lengths of time.
I believe they found in that letter
that over 2 million people had been in repayment
for at least 20 years, which is the first time
that anyone's ever published that information anywhere.
Now, after they published that letter,
there was some digging done
by the National Consumer Law Center
that looked at that data and kind of matched it
against this college scorecard data
to figure out of that group of people,
how many people have actually been in repayment
for 20 years or more on undergrad loans.
So the reason why that matters
is because think about the repay plan.
The repay plan is forgiveness after 20 years
for people with undergrad loans
and 25 years for people with graduate school loans.
So if you're looking at the number of people
that have been in repayment for at least 20 years,
those people probably wouldn't be eligible
for something like pay as you earn, right?
Because you have to be a new borrower after 2007.
So that means that when you're looking at this pool
of a couple million people
that have been in repayment for 20 years or more,
the people that have taken that out exclusively for undergrad
would be eligible for cancellation right away,
whereas people that have loans that are mixed in
from graduate school would be eligible after 25 years.
When you back out those people
that went to school for grad school loans
and they have grad school loans as a part of their total,
then the pool of people was sort of thought of
as maybe about 2 million people have been in repayment
on some kind of federal loan for at least 20 years.
And even that letter said that might not include
some of the loans from the Guaranteed Federal Loan Portfolio
and just some other FFEL random loans that exist.
Now, in April 2021,
there was a response to an inquiry from Senator Warren
who wanted to know in more detail
how many people have been in repayment
for what length of time.
So this is where that 4.4 million number comes from.
You can look it up on Google,
you can look it up on our blog posts.
April 2021, it's Department of Ed response letter
to Senator Warren.
And what it said was that 4.4 million people
had been in repayment for at least 20 years
on 211 billion of total loans.
Now, this is, I think, a little bit of a different definition
from what we saw from that earlier letter.
I think this definition is saying,
out of all the borrowers
in the Federal Student Loan Portfolio,
how many borrowers have a loan that entered repayment
for the first time at least 20 years ago or more?
I think that's the way they're doing it.
So in other words,
this is a little bit different definition, right?
Because maybe this includes forbearances,
deferments possibly,
it's probably people being defined
on when their first loan was taken out
instead of loans they might've taken out later.
But here's what I think's going on.
I think that that was very strategic
to try to get an idea of what kind of a population
could potentially be eligible
if they came up with the idea
of an income-driven repayment waiver.
So this is really an idea
that kind of came out of some of the work
of consumer advocate groups.
Like that's kind of who came up with this idea
as sort of your more progressive think tanks
is kind of who came up with this idea, right?
In February, early February, I think of 2021,
there was these big reports that came out
looking at what kind of actions
that the president might be able to take
to bring relief to people
given that you have a 50-50 Senate.
So why does this all matter?
I'm getting to that, I promise.
You know, when they published this letter,
they said 4.4 million people, $211 billion of loans.
Now think about the PSLF waiver.
There are a lot of different amounts of credit
on different loans.
Maybe you were a teacher
and then you went back for a graduate degree
and then you, you know, borrowed for that
and you came back and you went to medical school
or something, you know?
I mean, or you went to a different nonprofit
or something along those lines, right?
So there's a lot of times,
there's a lot of different credit
on different loans that people have.
So how do you solve that
when you're trying to sort of rush through a solution
via executive action?
You do it in the most generous way you possibly can,
which is to give people at least the max amount of credit
as the loan with the most credit
on the new consolidation loan.
So it used to be, they did say initially,
they said overlapping periods of repayment.
They realized that was too confusing for them to implement.
So then they did away with that
and they said at least the max amount of credit
for the loan that has the most.
You know, in other words,
what could have happened
is you would have gotten people that had loans
that didn't have overlapping repayment periods
for some reason,
and then that would have messed up the consolidation.
That's what they were trying to avoid, right?
So they just basically backed the truck up
and just said, all right,
we're just gonna say at least your new consolidation loan
for people going for PSLF
is gonna have at least the loan
that has the most credit on it.
That's where we've really seen
some pretty unbelievable stuff happen for borrowers
because, you know, if you have a loan from a long time ago
that's been in repayment consistently,
you know, one example is some of these
really small FFEL loans
that just never got into forbearance for some reason.
We've had people that have been able to consolidate
that one tiny $3,000 loan
with like 200,000 of loans from grad school
or even Parent PLUS loans,
and then the whole thing gets forgiven
because they take and apply to the new consolidation loan,
the loan with the most credit.
The issue with this data,
the 4.4 million people
that have been in repayment at least 20 years
with $211 billion of loans,
that number's also too low
because that data was published in December of 2020.
In December of 2020,
so by the time that the IDR waiver expires,
it's gonna be December 2021.
So in other words, we're looking at data
that's already two years old, basically,
which is just one of my big frustrations
with any department of education
under any administration,
it's just always like they're putting out data just so late,
and it's always like you're getting,
it's like you're looking at stars,
like you're seeing light
that people saw millions of years ago, right?
I mean, obviously it's not that bad, it's a few months,
but that's how it kind of feels,
is you're like looking backwards in time,
which is not telling you
if there's a supernova going on right now
or something like that, right?
So if you look at the pool of debt
that's 10 to 20 years old in this letter from April 2021,
they say that there's 10 million borrowers
that have been in repayment 10 to 20 years,
and those borrowers have about 450 billion.
If you think about loans that were 18 or 19 years old
in December 2020, by the end of 2022
are going to be at least 20 years old, right?
Because loans age.
So 450 billion, that's 45 billion for each year cohort.
I think that's pretty good to say
because it looks like these average loan sizes
as loans get older or larger,
because you're talking about,
in a lot of cases, a smaller loan,
people might eventually figure out a way to pay it off, right?
So the average loan size is higher
than the average overall of like 36,000.
I think the average is like 45,000 or something like that.
So you would say that loans 18 to 19 years old
is probably 45 billion,
and loans 19 to 20 years old is probably 45 billion,
and both of those sets of loans
would be at least 20 years old
once we get to the end of this IDR waiver.
So that takes your 211 billion and add 90 billion to that.
So now you're at 301 billion, so just say 300 billion.
That's about the pool of potentially eligible debt
for this cancellation for the IDR waiver,
unless they come out with something between,
whenever I say this or whenever you're listening to this,
and maybe if they put a limit on this
or some sort of cap or caveat.
$300 billion of potentially cancelable loans,
that's what canceling 10K for everyone would cost.
And this doesn't include the PSLF waiver benefit.
Even if potentially $300 billion of student loans
could be canceled from this,
why is it going to be a lot lower than that?
No matter what, even if they go crazy,
like saying, let's just go for this,
let's get as much relief to you as possible,
why is this 300 billion going to be,
what is the actual cancellation number
likely to be much lower?
And the big reason for this is a lot of people
are going to have to take a specific action
in order to get this.
So let's think about what this kind of means.
If you're talking about having to do something,
a lot of people that have to do something
are not going to do something.
Particularly, what do you know about consolidation
under normal times?
Consolidating, we always talk about this,
resets the clock for your time in loan repayment
and now you've got to pay for an extra 10 years
or if you're doing PSLF or 20 years
if you're doing not PSLF.
Usually that is the case.
But during the waiver, the PSLF waiver for example,
that is waived.
But people are terrified to consolidate
because of how long they've been told don't do it.
The same problem is true for this IDR waiver.
Once they say that you can consolidate
and get past repayment supplied
to the new consolidation loan,
a whole lot of people are still going to be afraid to do it
because of how many times you've been told not to do that.
It'd be kind of like somebody says,
don't put your finger in the electrical socket,
don't put your finger in the electrical socket
and you're afraid to do it
because you know you're going to get shocked
and then somebody literally tells you,
no, no, don't worry, it's okay,
we turned off the current, just go do it,
put your finger in the electrical socket
because there's a, I don't know, a bar of gold in there.
So that's kind of like what it's going on right now.
Yeah, so that's going to be one of the reasons
I think why the actual number,
even though that 300 billion
might be the pool of potentially eligible debt,
the actual people that would get that full consolidation
would be probably much smaller
because of some reasons I'm about to talk about.
One thing they might do to cap this
is maybe limiting credit from forbearance
that can be added to income-driven repayment.
The Wall Street Journal reported
that they were going to only give credit for forbearance
on IDR plans from July 2009 to March 2020.
That maybe kind of makes sense
because income-based repayment came out in 2009 in summer
and the COVID forbearance started in March 2020.
But I haven't seen that anywhere.
I'm not seeing that in Department of Ed's site.
Maybe they'll announce it between when I'm recording this
and when you listen to it, I don't know,
but I can't find that anywhere.
So we have to kind of operate on the assumption
until we see something public
that the forbearance credit isn't limited
and the income-driven repayment credit isn't limited.
Now, that's the other question,
is will they limit all kinds of different repayments
that can count for income-driven repayment?
They did limit it for the PSLF waiver.
They said we're only going to count repayments made
on October 2007 and after
because that's when PSLF kind of came out.
So what we have to do to figure out
kind of what the potential benefit
for this IDR waiver would be is to figure out,
well, how much debt
could potentially be canceled right away?
So if you look at the earliest data we have from 2007,
about 20% of the total student loan portfolio
was direct loans,
which is definitely owned by Department of Ed.
Now, of the remaining amount, the FFEL loans,
some of that's owned by Department of Ed, some of it's not.
So earlier than that, maybe 20 years ago in 2002,
maybe it was 10% direct loans,
and maybe, it's really hard to guess
because you're just purely guessing,
but maybe 10% of FFEL loans owned by Department of Ed.
So maybe like 20% of the total
might've been owned by Department of Ed 20 years ago.
It's really hard to know that
because no one's ever published this data.
Remember, though, that we expect that with this IDR waiver
that they'll probably allow you to consolidate
and get credit for the one loan
with the most credit on everything else.
Think about the debt snowball.
Let me just go off on a tangent for a second
and just rant about the debt snowball
being so bad for student loans right now.
If you do a debt snowball approach,
which is sort of a popular strategy
that some personal finance people recommend,
where you pay down the smallest loan first
to give yourself an emotional reward
for making progress on your debt,
and then you go down and try to pay down
the next loan after that,
that might make sense if it's a bunch of credit cards.
But when you're talking about student loans,
your smallest loans are typically also your oldest loans.
Those are typically loans from undergraduate
that also tend to have the most credit on forgiveness plans.
So when people pay down those small loans,
you take away loans with a maximum amount of credit,
and when you consolidate everything together
under waiver programs like this,
you eliminated your ability in some cases
to get your loans completely forgiven.
So I can't stress enough that student debt
is not like other kinds of debt.
If somebody purports to be a student loan expert
or have expert advice about student loans
and can't recognize that, run for the hills
or recognize that they're talking to you
about 20,000 of student loan debt
and their advice is just frankly completely irrelevant
for student loan debt that is larger
than a modest, modest amount.
Just be aware of advice about student loan debt
from your friends, from people on the podcast or the radio
that don't understand the nuances,
that aren't willing to be humble
about what they know and what they don't know.
I will tell you that I don't know that much about taxes.
I know enough to be dangerous, but I'm not a tax expert.
I know a lot about retirement plans and investing,
enough so that we feel comfortable doing an online course
about it to teach people how to do it.
But if I had something really complicated
that I needed to do, like set up a defined benefit plan
or profit sharing plan or some sort of IRS qualified plan
that and everything, I would look for somebody
that's an expert in that field.
I would not seek out advice from my uncle,
you know, who listens to personal finance shows
on the radio.
This stuff's really, really complicated.
And with these waiver programs,
stuff is about to get even more complicated.
Let's go back to the IDR waiver.
Sorry for the tangent, just thought I'd throw it out there
because it's something I'm seeing a lot of right now
and it's very frustrating
when somebody could have gotten their whole debt forgiven
and you have to tell them, hey, sorry,
you paid off your commercially held FFEL loan
that had 120 months of credit already for PSLF purposes
and you can't get the money back
because it's not owned by Department of Ed.
And oh, by the way, if you consolidate,
now you've got five years left to go
instead of being done immediately.
Right, I'm just, that's why I'm saying that
is because I'm frustrated
because I've seen a lot of that for borrowers
that could have gotten a lot more forgiven.
So hopefully you can kind of spread the word
that student loans are hard.
Okay, so let's go back to talking about
how many people could get this IDR waiver
just like immediate cancellation.
So let's say that of the 300 billion of loans
that might have been around for 20 years, let's say,
so based off of the National Consumer Law Center
kind of studying that college scorecard data, right,
maybe about 2.6 million borrowers
had 20 years of repayment,
maybe about 600,000 of those
had some graduate loans mixed in there.
So probably let's just say 75% of these loans
are for undergrad and 25% is for graduate school.
So if that's the case,
you can kind of take, say, of the 300 billion,
so let's say, I don't know,
20% of that is owned by Department of Ed,
that's maybe 40 billion-ish
that could be forgiven right away.
Now again, that might be lower than that amount too
because maybe this is debt that,
maybe that's like people have a lot of different loans
and maybe only one of those loans is eligible
because they borrowed for other degree programs later,
which we see pretty commonly.
So it could be a lot lower than 40 billion
because they might go and forgive all the stuff
that's older loans, but maybe they have newer stuff.
And so part of the question is gonna be
how fast are they gonna forgive these loans?
I mean, we've seen that with the PS Left Waiver.
It almost punished people who had their ECF form submitted
because in some cases they went in
and forgave loans that had been above 120 months of credit
that they could have used to consolidate
to get the whole rest of the amount forgiven.
So that's one question with this
is how fast are they gonna start processing this?
Because we need the formal guidance
so that we can know if people need to rush
to consolidate some of these older loans
before they get forgiven.
Maybe 40 billion-ish of the 300 billion
could be forgiven right away.
And of the total 300 billion that we've, you know, loans,
maybe let's say about 220 billion of that or so
is undergrad only, let's say, just hypothetical there.
And I didn't, you know, with my math from earlier, right?
So actually, so 300 billion, let's say,
is undergrad and grad.
225 billion, let's say, is for undergrad only.
And of that amount, let's say 20% of it
is owned by Department of Eds.
That's where I got the 40 billion number
that I think maybe could be forgiven right away.
So that means of the remaining 225 billion or so,
maybe like there's 180 billion that might not be
in the right setup to be forgiven
because it's commercially held
or it's not in the right
sort of Department of Ed-owned status.
180 billion there, you could maybe consolidate that
and have it be completely forgiven.
How many people will actually do that?
I don't know.
I mean, so let's talk about forbearances.
Maybe all the forbearances don't count.
So you might say, well, how much of that
remaining 180 billion has been in repayment the whole time?
If you look at FFEL loans,
they have very high repayment rates,
like 90% plus or something like that.
FFEL borrowers also tend to have higher credit scores.
So you don't have as much of the defaults
that you might see for the direct loan portfolio.
So I would wager maybe at least half of people
have been in repayment for 20 years or more
on these FFEL loans.
You know, maybe out of the 180 billion
that's not in the right status,
maybe you could say half of that,
like 90 billion could be consolidated
and wiped away immediately.
Sometimes people rationally keep their FFEL loans around
because they might have an interest rate of 1% to 3%
because they gave just outrageously good low rates
back in the mid-2000s and early 2000s
if you make consecutive payments.
This is really complicated.
Remember that to get the benefit from the IDR waiver,
you don't have to get your loans immediately canceled.
Newer graduates are going to see almost no benefit
from this IDR waiver because this is really helping people
that have been in repayment for a long time.
But let's say you've been in repayment for,
I don't know, 10 years.
And let's say you had some loans from undergraduate
that you started making payments on a standard plan.
And then you went back for vet school
and you borrowed a bunch of loans through vet school
and you started paying those back.
If you consolidated all those loans together
and you're in pay-as-you-earn or something,
then you're already set up to get the IDR waiver benefit.
You're going to have adjustments to your payment count
kind of done automatically
because all the loans from undergrad
have already been consolidated.
Now, for people who don't have their loans consolidated,
let's say that veterinarian had their loans from undergrad,
they borrowed for grad school,
and then they came out and they just like
did the usual six-month grace period.
That veterinarian, let's say that they worked
for like two, three years before school,
they might be able to get two or three years added
to their payment count if they consolidated
under this IDR waiver.
That's a freaking big deal.
That's a massive, massive deal.
And you don't have to get qualification
for cancellation to benefit from that.
Now, they said in the Department of Ed's press release
for this IDR waiver, 3.6 million borrowers
will get at least three years closer to forgiveness.
Again, I think that that's kind of like
extremely misleading because when you say
at least three years closer to forgiveness,
well, if the average amount of forgiveness
that people are going to get credited for,
let's say the average is 12 years,
and you say at least three,
technically that's a true statement,
but it's also super misleading
because actually most borrowers
are going to get a lot of benefit from this.
What is going on at Department of Education right now?
Honestly, I have no idea.
And I've debated about whether or not
after I found this to publish it
because I, again, realize that we're going to see
a lot of political fights about student loans in general.
And my job is to try to get you as much benefit as possible.
But ultimately, I decided that the right thing to do
is to be transparent about what's going on
because first of all, I want people to be aware
how big of a deal this is.
Because if it does happen,
which I think is the most likely scenario,
I think it's going to happen,
then everybody that follows our podcast and our site
and who subscribes to our email newsletter
needs to really pay attention
between now and the end of the year.
Because what's going to happen
is they're going to publish formal guidance,
they're going to publish FAQs,
we're going to be the fastest group in the country,
probably, to look at all of that
and implement that in terms of our advice
that we can give people.
And people that work with Student Loan Planner
and follow Student Loan Planner
are going to get vastly more benefits
than people who don't.
Just like people that have a person
who's really on the ball for taxes or something
saves more money than people
that don't pay attention to their taxes.
The planning opportunities from this IDR waiver
I think are going to be enormous.
But what I think is going to happen
is based off of my conversations with people
on both sides of the aisle on this,
everybody kind of thinks that this is going to be
like a $20 to $30 billion benefit.
The only way that's true
is if borrowers are completely clueless,
have no idea what's going on,
and nobody reacts in their best interest
to try to get as much cancellation as possible.
Because if nobody consolidates,
if nobody pays attention to loans
that have more credit than the other loans,
if Department of Ed totally neglected to mention
that they're not giving payment credit
for people before 2009,
I mean, you really have to say at this point,
Department of Education is either trying to forgive
a massive historic level of student loans
through cancellation through this order,
or they are about to announce some major limitations
in this IDR waiver that they were already thinking about
to keep this cost down to a lower level.
And what is going on in Department of Education?
This is either inconsistent,
because if you look at the press release,
it says 40,000 borrowers will get PSLF from this,
and at least a few thousand will get cancellation
under income-driven repayment.
And then if you look at studentaid.gov,
if you look at the IDR adjustment announcement,
they say on studentaid.gov,
borrowers who have paid their loans
for 20 years or 25 years
will receive automatic cancellation
regardless of them being signed up
for an income-driven repayment plan.
In the NPR reporting in April that started all this,
which again was probably leaked by somebody
at the Department of Education,
they say that 4.4 million borrowers
have been in repayment for 20 years.
So the press release says one thing,
and Department of Education's student loan website
or student aid website says something completely different.
Which one should we believe?
I have, I guess, a couple conclusions.
One would be Department of Education
didn't really think about this very carefully
and just wanted to try to rush as much relief through
for borrowers as fast as possible
before expecting that they're gonna have a lot of scrutiny
from a likely Republican House of Representatives,
at least in the midterms,
based off of current political experts' projections of things.
So that's one theory,
is that people didn't really look
at the cost estimates for this.
The other theory is that Department of Education
doesn't want this to get out,
or at least the people who wrote this order
don't want this to get out,
because if it does,
Republicans would potentially
mount a legal challenge against it.
If it does get out, I promise you one thing,
it's not gonna be because of us,
because, I mean, people aren't stupid.
We might be theorizing something before other outlets,
but outlets eventually figure this stuff out, right?
The investigative budgets
for New York Times, Wall Street Journal
is much greater than Student Loan Planner.
So, I mean, again, one of the people on Twitter,
that when I was kind of like,
kind of putting these projections out,
like they put a meme back at me.
They replied with a meme of a guy like,
going like, shh, be quiet, don't say this very loudly.
I don't think that that is how it works.
I think that, my theory is that people
at Department of Education
really didn't model the cost of this,
and they genuinely think this is gonna be a minor thing
that's gonna help a five-figure amount of borrowers,
small, limited group, get forgiveness,
and it's gonna move people
of a couple years extra closer to forgiveness.
And I think they maybe probably genuinely believe this.
That's probably the most likely thought.
I mean, the other thought is that
there's a sort of small group of people
that really know what they're doing,
that, again, are sort of really hoping
they can rush through a lot of these changes
that can't be undone once they actually get put in place.
And they know that this is gonna result
in maybe over $100 billion of cancellation,
but they really don't want that to get out,
and possibly are even not letting
the more moderate Democrats in the administration
even know this by issuing sort of more questionable
initial guidance in this press release
that kind of obfuscates the potential benefit
that borrowers could receive from this.
But I talked to some friends
that are more politically aware than I am,
and they were like, why would they do that?
Like, this is great.
Like, why wouldn't you, if you're the Democrats,
why wouldn't you be trumpeting this from the hills?
Like, we're gonna cancel all this debt.
Like, that's kind of great for their voters, right,
for the base of the Democratic Party.
And so that's why I think it's probably just education
like not realizing what they're doing here.
Like, I think that they understand
that a lot of people are gonna get benefits from this,
but I don't think that they have any idea
the scale of this, especially once groups like ours
get out there with like how-to guides
and how to consolidate and how to figure out
which ones to consolidate and which ones not to,
how to get extra credit towards forgiveness plans,
how to monitor if you are eligible for PSLF,
because also keep in mind,
they didn't give extra credit towards PSLF for forbearances
and not PSLF waiver, but the IDR waiver,
they are giving a lot of extra credit
for certain kinds of forbearances and deferments,
well, at least forbearances.
We're still even freaking waiting on them to tell us
if certain kinds of deferments are gonna count for PSLF.
I mean, to be honest, I'm really frustrated.
Department of Education is trying to rush things
through because they don't have the votes
to do anything in Congress,
and I understand that that's a restriction
that they have to live with,
and I understand that they wanna try to benefit borrowers
as much as possible,
but if you're gonna try to benefit borrowers,
spend some effort thinking through what you're doing.
Come out with a detailed FAQ
as soon as you have the announcement.
Department of Ed knew that they were coming out
with this major IDR waiver
the second that that NPR article came out,
so why not do the homework
and actually have all of the FAQ thought through
ahead of time so that when you make
this major press release announcement,
you can put out the detailed FAQ right there.
I mean, it's like 10 days after they announced the IDR waiver
and maybe they'll have that published
by the time this comes out,
but we're still waiting on details.
We have none of the details.
How am I supposed to give people good advice
if we're still waiting on the actual definitional basics
for this waiver program?
I mean, some of it's like Christmas
or Santa Claus gave you a gift and you just open it up
and you don't know what's gonna be in there.
I don't know.
I'd personally like to have the detailed gift guide
so that we can go through it
and actually explain stuff to people.
So we're gonna do the best we can.
I mean, we're gonna try to predict stuff
faster than other places.
We're gonna try to give you the best guidance
that we possibly can on what's gonna happen,
but there was another big piece of news
we need to talk about.
President Biden recently stated
to the Congressional Hispanic Caucus in a private meeting
that he's looking at canceling some debt
for student loan borrowers.
Initially, stories came out that said that
President Biden's thinking about
canceling all student loan debt.
That's not what he said.
He said that he's asked them to review his authority
to cancel all of it.
That doesn't mean that he wants to cancel all of it.
Probably you need to know if you have the authority
to cancel all of it first to be able to cancel some of it.
Does that kind of make sense?
Otherwise, it's sort of arbitrary.
Oh, you can cancel 10,000, but not everything.
You probably have to have the authority
to cancel as much as you want
to be able to cancel anything.
Does that make sense?
So again, sort of some of the articles
that came out about this are a lot of the stuff
you have to kind of put your politics hat on
and try to ask yourself what is going on here
and what does that mean as to whether or not
this stuff's actually gonna pass.
So a lot of the more progressive members of that caucus
kind of got out ahead of this and said,
hey, look, President Biden's gonna cancel debt.
In other words, they're trying to create a press narrative
to sort of corner in the president to do a certain thing
that they want to have happen
and that they think would obviously help a lot of borrowers.
Is that gonna happen?
I'll tell you this, usually with these prior announcements
like the PSLF waiver and stuff like that,
we'll see maybe the most partisan Republicans
on Twitter complain about it.
Like your Representative Jim Jordan,
your Senator Tom Cotton,
they tend to like to make a lot of waves
of comments about student loan cancellation
or forgiveness and things like that.
But you don't see a lot of noise from it from other people.
But this is a little different this time
because even someone like Senator Romney
was calling President Biden's comments about cancellation
to this private group of lawmakers,
he was attacking it, saying that it's a,
I'm using his words, of course,
basically that he said something like
it would be basically like a bribe to voters
and what should we do next?
Cancel auto loans, mortgages, what could go wrong?
He said something to that effect.
And obviously, Senator Romney
is one of the more moderate members
of the Republican caucus.
So if you're seeing comments like that from him about this,
what I think is gonna happen is I think that
Democrats are very smart looking at this polling data
and they know that the party in power
in a time with a lot of inflation
and an economy that's not where people would like it to be,
the party in power is gonna get the blame.
And almost every election,
the President's party loses seats
and they already have a razor-thin majority, right?
So they know that probably they're gonna deal
with a big loss of seats in the House at least.
And the goal is to keep that number down
to as low of a number as possible
because otherwise it's a harder hole
to dig out of in 2024, right?
So what do you need?
You need base turnout because right now,
the biggest change in the net approval rating
for President Biden is among young voters.
It's really swung, it was really positive,
now it's not nearly as positive.
So you really need to motivate
that core Democratic constituency to turn out and vote.
How do you do that?
All the other stuff that progressives have called for
is kind of blocked because it has to go through Congress
and you have to go through Senator Manchin
and Senator Sinema to do that.
So you can't get a lot of this stuff
that you wanna accomplish done through Congress.
So one of the reasons student debt cancellation
has sort of taken on this life of its own
is because it is one of those few final places
where progressives can exert political influence
and actually see something that they want accomplished.
That's kind of what's going on right now
is you've gotta turn out the base,
you've gotta turn out young voters.
And why would you make this cancellation announcement?
Why would you wait, right?
If you're gonna do this, why not just announce it?
Why not just get it over with?
Why has the White House been sitting on a memo
that likely says the president can cancel student debt
for over a year?
I think that the simple reason is because we're expecting
that President Biden's gonna announce
a huge student loan announcement,
probably cancellation for some group of borrowers
that's income tested, is what he initially said,
and a new IBR plan that's probably more generous
than current plans.
It remains to be seen whether or not
that'll be open to graduate school borrowers
and parent plus borrowers,
or if it's gonna be only for undergrads.
If that does happen,
we expect that that announcement would come
in like July or August in the heated midterms.
And if, take your clues from Twitter,
if you've got Senator Romney just ferociously attacking
the idea of student loan cancellation,
what's gonna happen?
They're gonna file a lawsuit.
And there's a lot of people that say
that nobody has standing to block student loan cancellation.
Well, that's great.
You've got to convince
a 6-3 conservative majority Supreme Court
that that's the case, right?
Because Republicans or some sort
of Republican affiliated group will challenge this.
Now, it could be a lot of people.
Maybe it's student loan servicers.
Maybe it's a taxpayer group.
Maybe it's certain members of Congress.
Maybe it's FFEL loan investors
that own a bunch of student loans that are old
that could be canceled under this IDR waiver
that stand to lose billions of dollars of interest income
if their loan portfolio gets canceled.
Any one of those groups of people
could potentially have an interest to sue.
Student loan refinancing companies
might have an interest to sue, right?
I mean, in full disclosure,
obviously those are some of our advertisers.
So I just like to kind of be transparent
and just think that there's a lot of different people
that might want to challenge this.
I don't know if a lot of them would want to do that
because I think a lot of them, so far,
I think a lot of them have chosen not to get involved legally
because they don't want the ire
of millions of borrowers, right?
I mean, a lot of these places
are probably just hoping this problem goes away
and they don't have to kind of do anything.
But if you're looking especially at the FFEL investors,
this is their whole,
I mean, this is a giant impairment of their investment.
Yeah, they get their principal back,
but they're losing the stream
of billions of dollars of interest income
far into the future.
You know, if you're trying to cancel all of that,
they might care.
Now, again, maybe they don't have standing.
I'm not a lawyer, I don't know that.
But I do know that somebody would challenge it.
And especially if it's done so close to the midterms,
that's done for a sort of a political calculation
versus if you do it earlier on, if you did it now,
and maybe it's more of like something you think
you can actually do from a policy perspective.
Think about why you would do this if you're Biden.
I think it's actually probably smart politics.
I mean, he's in a very difficult position
because of the inflation in the economy.
And you really do need your base to turn out.
So what do you do?
Try to come out with the splashiest,
most exciting student loan announcement you possibly can
as close to the midterms as possibly can
in a month with as low of an inflation print
as you possibly can.
Then you hope that Republicans challenge it.
And then if a Republican sort of,
you know, I shouldn't say I guess Republican,
but, you know, I mean,
a conservative majority 6-3 Supreme Court,
let's say they block it,
which is what we expect they would do.
If that's the case, then, you know,
you're looking at maybe you hope voters blame Republicans
for not delivering student loan cancellation.
And you look at, okay, well,
the only thing holding this back
is we've got to get, you know, 52 Senate seats
so we don't have to worry about Manchin-Sinema.
And so maybe that turns out the base.
So I think that that's kind of what's going on
in the student loan cancellation thing.
But the issue is,
I think they're already possibly setting up, you know,
as much debt to be canceled
as if they just straight up canceled 10K for everyone.
And the only reason people don't realize that yet
is because people haven't really paid attention
to the numbers and Department of Education
probably hasn't calculated it.
So what's going to happen
between now and the end of the year?
Chaos.
That's what I'm expecting is just pure chaos.
We decided, I mean,
I decided that we need to help as many borrowers as possible
because a lot of these opportunities when they're gone,
I mean, a lot of them are based off
of the pandemic emergency authority.
Eventually that will end.
Probably if you have one of the two houses of Congress
be taken over by Republicans,
they could just refuse to even fund the government
until they eliminate that emergency declaration.
And then all the student loan authority stops.
You have to just operate under the statute and that's it.
There's some regulatory stuff you can do,
but it's limited to, you know, making a new IBR plan
and maybe giving some credit for deferments
and forbearances on some things going forward
and things like that.
So what we decided to do at Student Loan Planner
is how can we help as many people as possible
between now and the end of the year?
So I decided, okay,
one of the things that we're going to get killed with
is just a lot of email
because we do take your emails very seriously.
And we do want to try to make sure
that we answer your questions
and point you to resources and help you,
you know, if you need a consult booking,
explain the best place to go do that and things like that.
So we just added four new admin folks
to help us out with that.
So that's big because we're just absolutely drowning
in requests right now from folks.
And I want to make sure that you get your email
or question answered really well.
And I want you to get the resources
and consult bookings that you feel like you need.
So I'm excited about those groups of folks
that we just added.
That's great.
So that's going to help us be a lot more responsive
than we've been in the past couple weeks
just because it's just been a deluge.
And then we've added one new consultant that's coming on
and we'll probably add another right after adding
to a couple months ago.
And that's just because we, I guess about a year ago,
the same time a year ago, we did 120 plans,
I think in April, 2021.
And this past April, we're doing about 350.
Triple, triple the number of plans
and it's going to get worse.
Why do I know it's going to get worse?
Think about human nature.
We procrastinate.
So if you've got the PSLF waiver expiring in October
and you've got the IDR waiver expiring in December,
we're going to see, I think, an exponential increase
in the number of people paying attention to this
as we get closer and closer to those waivers expiring.
Maybe there's a chance the PSLF waiver gets kicked out
to the end of the year too.
I think that would probably make a lot of sense.
So maybe they both expire in December,
but think about what that means.
You know, if you do have Democrats lose the midterms,
they probably do come out with some sort of announcement,
student loans are going to start again
end of December or end of January.
And if they do that,
then you're going to have everybody
that's paying attention to student loans
for the first time in almost three years,
along with everybody that's trying to get help
with the PSLF waiver and the IDR waiver.
And I'm scared because our job is to help you.
That's the point of Student Loan Planner existing
where we are a mission-driven company.
We do have to stay in business,
otherwise we can't help anybody.
But I like to think that we are a mission-driven company.
Our job is to help relieve student debt and anxiety
and frustrations and just take away that burden
on your life that's holding you back
from accomplishing your goals and dreams
that you deserve to have and pursue.
So, you know, in terms of what that means for our business,
you know, we're going to do our best
to try to onboard as many consultants as I can
to meet the demand that we've got
in a way that I think we can control the quality.
That's my number one concern.
I would rather have the people that we get advice from
get amazing advice than above-average advice, right?
That's why we have a four,
if you look at our studentloanplanner.com slash rev, R-E-V,
that just takes you to our reviews, which you can read.
And we've got over 1,400 reviews
and our average star rating is 4.96 out of five stars.
Why is that?
It's because we're obsessive
about putting borrowers first, putting you first.
I think that what's going to happen, like I said,
is as we get closer and closer to those dates,
people are going to just rush our calendar.
We're, at some point, probably maybe in like
middle of November,
we're not going to have any slots available, probably.
So I would say, if you want to get a plan,
just know that we've opened up our calendars
for three months ahead of time now.
So if it's early May or something,
you can book June, July, August.
You should be able to book all the way into August, I hope.
Get your plan on the books now,
and worst case scenario, you can always reschedule it
and we don't require payment up front
after the consult, too.
So there's not really any reason not to do that.
So we've got a lot of other things we're working on.
I guess I can share that I am now
a certified financial planner professional, woo!
So I've had the Chartered Financial Analyst designation
for many years and I thought,
well, why don't we just go ahead
and I'll start an insurance agency
and I'll get licensed in all 50 states for that.
So we did that and then I thought,
what would it be like if I got the CFP designation
just for fun?
Let's do that, too.
So I did that.
So I'm trying to stay busy, keep my mind active, right?
Continuing education, right?
That's what we should sort of support
since that's what a lot of our raters do, right?
So we're gonna have some cool resources and tips
and things available for you
based off of a lot of the work
that I've been doing in the background
while we've had a little bit of breathing room
pre-waiver announcement
with student loans being paused for so long.
So I'm looking forward to sharing some of those things
and some of those business initiatives with you
that are gonna make your life better
in the coming weeks ahead.
Just know that there's a lot of stuff
going on with this waiver.
Most people don't need to do anything today,
but you do need to probably do something
within a few weeks or a couple months.
So pay attention.
Thank you so much for listening to Student Loan Planner Podcast.
If you do need a plan, studentloanplanner.com slash book.
I'm Travis with Student Loan Planner
and always I love your comments and questions.
You can leave a question about the IDR waiver
at studentloanplanner.com slash voicemail
or just send us an email, helpwithstudentloanplanner.com
if you have any questions or comments
you'd like to share about the show.
Thank you for listening
and I hope we can save you as much money as we possibly can.
Have a great week.
