What’s NEXT for Chicago Cubs on the pitching market?

Chicago Cubs Fans
23 followers
Cubs made their first free agent signing Monday morning, and it's not that exciting.
You are locked on Cubs, your daily Chicago Cubs podcast,
part of the Locked On Podcast Network, your team every day.
Thank you, Freden.
Oh my gosh, I am too far down my outline.
Excuse me.
I'm so excited for this episode.
And quite frankly, I don't even need the outline for this part of the show anymore.
In fact, the other day, Sam, I felt like I was on a roll before I even opened my doc,
but you are locked on Cubs, part of Locked On Podcast Network, your team every day.
Alongside Sam Ulver, I am Matt Cozy.
Sam and I are lifelong fans, taking our passion into discussion with you on all things Matthew
Boyd.
Thank you for being part of the show and making us your first listener today.
And the best way you can help us grow the show is to listen every day, like the video,
and comment anything below.
Today's episode is presented by GameTime.
Download the GameTime app.
Create an account.
Use code LOCKEDONMLB for $20 off your first purchase.
And the wee hours of Monday morning, the Cubs did sign lefty starting pitcher Matthew Boyd
to a two-year, $29 million deal.
We're going to expand on Boyd himself and what he is capable of, where he fits in the
rotation, where he fits in on the team, things like that.
We're actually going to do that later.
Right now, I want to move the ball down the field after Sam did a nice reaction episode
earlier in the day.
I think there's two options after this move.
This is just pitching I'm talking about.
They either, because I don't know what their goals are.
Sorry.
Okay.
There's no need to apologize.
Add a top of the rotation starter that pencils in between Steele and Imanaga because that's
what I thought they were going to try to do.
So either they're going to do that, which they didn't do yet, or they're going to go
back to front and they're going to, Jed Hoyer's going to take a major departure from what
he's done in his run out of the bullpen.
And he's going to not only add two or three relievers, but one of them is going to be
a clear closer that costs a good amount of cash.
That's the only thing I can think of right now with this Boyd move.
And you're probably asking, Sam and everybody else, well, why can't they do both?
Why can't they get a closer and a top of the rotation starter?
Well, after they chose to sign Matthew Boyd, money becomes more of a factor.
Well, because they let it.
They're $39 million to the first luxury tax threshold.
Folks, the Cubs are not going to pay the repeater tax.
They went $800,000, $900,000 over last year.
We can get into all of that and why that was a mistake.
Why didn't they go more over the tax?
But they're not going to pay the repeater penalty.
And I think they might even want to start the year.
You know, I keep citing to that first line.
It's really probably 10, 10 Ms under that line to leave space for in season move.
So if that's the case, then they only have 29 Ms to that line.
I just I don't know what their plan is in terms of targeting pitching.
Because then you have the offensive side of it as well.
Do they just target a reliever?
Do they keep Matt Tice as the backup catcher?
Do they just go all internal offensively?
I'm left with a lot more questions than I realize.
And it's not even the winter meeting.
Yeah, I'm going to I'm going to stay away from Boyd specifically till later on.
In terms of this, so I want to read what you sent me first,
because I think it sums it up perfectly.
You do a really nice job over these messages,
just summarizing things quickly with words.
Quote Matt Cozy.
Hard to say when we don't know what the goals are.
Seems like a good signing if they were trying to improve the back end of the rotation,
but lots of money for a four or five starter or four or five starter.
That's pretty much sums it up.
And I would say instead I would substitute instead of goals.
But hey, what part of the offseason is this?
Is this the the major free agent starter?
And that's it.
Now we're trading a guy.
Are we going to trade for a better start or whatever?
But here's the real point before we break down Boyd specifically.
Here's the real thing.
What this acquisition told us, right?
A couple of things, Matt.
Number one, when you're a fan and you react,
your reactions are based off of expectations.
And one of the reasons why I think I was probably initially,
I think in a very rare situation,
more positive about this deal is I have no expectations for this offseason.
The second they tapped out on Juan Soto before the sweepstakes even had begun,
that let me know that this is going to be one of those type of things.
And so I looked at it differently.
But then here's the other part of it.
And this is the key.
Matt, if the Milwaukee Brewers signed Matthew Boyd this morning,
what would we be talking about on the show?
Watch out for Matthew Boyd.
Diamond in the rough.
If the Brewers like him, he's really good.
Who knows?
He could just skyrocket.
Because they have a track record getting these things right.
We don't.
The Cubs don't, right?
And so with Jed, you can't give them the benefit of the doubt
until you see it on the field.
Because this is the same guy that signed Drew Smiley.
This is the same guy that signed Trey Mancini.
So when you make these moves, everyone,
there's kind of like this pessimistic feel,
because Jed's earned that with a lot of it.
But he's also signed Shota Imanaga,
which now looks like, oh, that was a can't miss thing.
But there are a lot of questions surrounding him.
So we'll just, we'll have to let it play out.
But I think you said it best.
This move is hard to evaluate and make a concrete evaluation
until we see what else they do.
If this is a feature move, if this is their,
hey, this was our free agent starter,
we're just going to trade for some starter depth,
then it's not enough.
Because this is a lot of money, as we'll talk about,
for a guy that has a lot of implied risk.
But like you said, we're still a week
before the winter meetings.
There is some things there.
What are the goals?
What are the pitching plans?
Hopefully the trade that we feel like they're inevitably
going to make is for more of a top end guy,
or they spend money on rotations.
But this move did not surprise me.
As we're going to talk about even later in the show,
they have all, and I guess you're right about expectations,
because they have all these caveats,
all these conditions that put them
in the so-called middle tier
before the off season really even kicked off.
That's what I was reflecting on Monday during the day.
So, okay, they're out on Burns, Freed, and Snell, out.
Yep.
Well, then you get to the next tier,
there's all these caveats.
Oh, well, they can't have a qualifying offer
attached to them.
Okay.
Severino, out.
Minaya, out.
Pavetta, out.
So then you get to Jack Flaherty.
Well, he's probably going to get nine figures, out.
Then you get to Nathan Evaldi.
Well, 10 teams like him, out.
So then you get to Walker Buehler.
He was horrible last year.
You get to Shane Bieber.
He's not going to be ready till June.
The next name is Matthew Boyd.
But the problem is we were all under the impression
that they were getting someone to pencil in
in the two or three lane.
And Matthew Boyd is not that.
He is a number four or a number five.
That's what he is.
And if they were trying to improve that spot,
they do that and then some with this signing.
Now, it's not great that it cost as much as it did,
which we'll add on to later.
But if that's what they were trying to improve,
then that's a so-called good signing, right?
Because I think Hendricks got paid more than this last year.
Hendricks paid $16 million last year.
I believe with the way it's structured,
I believe that Boyd's actually only getting seven next year
and then like 16 the year after.
I believe that's what-
Right, right.
But I think the luxury tax hit is still 14 and a half.
Let me double check.
But yes, I saw that as well.
Because I thought maybe they gave him a signing bonus
so it doesn't hit on the tax.
But I don't know how that-
But what are the Cubs-
Are they trying to pencil someone in
between Steele and Imanaga?
What are your thoughts on Jack Flaherty?
I kind of mentally eliminated him today.
You did?
Yeah, because of this.
I've always felt that they were going to go get one free agent
and then trade for another.
I think I'm just now of the mindset
that the trade now has to be the guy
that they pencil in between those two guys.
But I will say, and we'll talk about it in a second,
I'm a little higher on Boyd's ceiling than you are.
Yeah, okay.
But I think he's a four or five floor with some ceiling.
But as you said, it's a lot of money
for a guy that could be good.
That's why I was sitting this morning, just real quick,
and I didn't find out about this
because I was doing some work stuff.
I didn't find out about this until nine.
And I was sitting there and I'm like,
I try and encompass everything.
I wait to make sure.
Once I saw Rosenthal tweeted it, I'm like, okay.
And I'm like, do I want to do this?
Do I want to go do an instant reaction or not?
Yeah, I want to talk about that later.
Or we can do it now.
And my deal breaker was the money.
They gave him 29 million over two years.
Matt, Matt, that's almost a third
of the free agency money that they had this year.
So I was like, hey, I have to do this
because this could be the biggest free agent move they make.
This could be it.
You know, I just saw a tweet.
I think it was from Marosi or somebody
that Higashioka and the Rangers are close.
Yeah, yeah, that did just break, yeah.
You know, so I'm thinking to myself,
if I don't do this now,
you know, we might not have a lot of opportunities in free.
Well, let's go over that because,
okay, let's do that this early.
So let's do it right now.
So I don't like that my first reaction
was a shrug at seven in the morning.
No, but you're right.
And my gut instinct was,
well, we don't even need to do an instant reaction episode.
I think, I think you're, I had the exact.
And now I'm fearful that these are the moves
the Cubs are lining up.
I had the exact same reaction.
And then it wasn't until I got the money confirmed
where I just said, if they're going to give,
and this was before I knew the whole structure of the deal.
I said, if they're giving this guy 14 and a half million,
that could, I gotta go.
We're doing an emergency episode for Matt Boyd.
What is happening?
I don't like to say.
This is supposed to be a crown jewel franchise.
I don't like to say.
What do we do next week?
Not emergency.
When the Cubs signed Gary Sanchez,
are you going to do an instant reaction?
I don't think so.
No.
Okay.
I don't know what my threshold was.
I just, it was, I just felt financially
that type of money.
I needed to come out and say something.
The other option to upgrade in the party notation
is via trade.
I'm getting the vibe that you don't want me to do that.
And, but here's the thing about the trade, Sam,
people keep mentioning Seattle.
Is there another caveat here?
Do they want to trade their four young guys?
No, they want to trade Luis Castillo.
No, we can't take on that type of money.
That's not an option.
The other dude that's available is Garrett Crochet.
That's not happening, right?
I would think that the Cubs wouldn't want to take
that large of a risk on his arm, but who knows?
How about Rokey?
Well, right.
But, but I think all of this is independent of him
just because of his amount cost.
Right, right.
Cause you could just fit him in anywhere.
None of this should be impacted.
No, no.
You can get him anywhere.
The Cubs could sign four.
None of it.
The guys could start.
Should have zero impact.
Zero.
The Cubs could sign four more starters
and still slot him right in for his cost.
Exactly.
All right.
You're fired up.
Here's the other option.
You're right.
It's ridiculous that we had to do that.
It's ridiculous.
But I had to.
Right.
And that's, and that's Jed Hoyer's problem.
And Tom.
Here's the other option.
And what does Brain Kenny do?
Do they go all in on the bullpen?
John Marossi reported.
What does that mean?
Go all in.
He's hearing the Cubs are one of the most active teams
in the industry on bullpen arms.
Well, all in to me means.
Let me bring up the best names available.
Tanner Scott, Jeff Hoffman, and Clay Holmes,
who might actually not even be relievers next year.
And Carlos Estevez next year.
Tryin and Yates and Jansen.
Do they load up on the bullpen?
It would be a major departure for Hoyer.
But Tanner Scott, Sam.
Isn't he projected to get like 15 million a year?
15 a year.
But he's left-handed.
They haven't had a good lefty in 10, 20, 30 years.
Well, besides Chapman.
He would be the clear closer.
And then everyone else goes back a rung on the depth chart.
Maybe they should use the 15 M's on the next, you know.
So they spend the next half of their money.
Figure they end up 10 M's short of the line.
Maybe they get Tanner Scott.
They call it an off season.
No catcher, no bench.
Well, then I'm glad.
I'm glad we did a show then.
Well, Tanner Scott is worthy of an emergency show.
No, look.
Everybody goes back a rung that if you sign someone like him.
I've never seen Jed spend big, big, big dollars like that for a reliever.
So I'll believe it when I see it.
I think that they're more focused on depth pieces for the bullpen.
That's surprising they don't like Jack Flaherty as much.
No, I do.
I don't dislike him.
It's not that I don't like him.
I'm saying what I think the Cubs are thinking.
Bring me anybody.
This team needs a lot of help.
So what do you mean by depth pieces?
Is that like Matt Moore and Andrew Kittredge?
Those are all free agents.
Yeah, I just don't see it.
So they already traded for Eli Morgan.
Yes, they did.
He's a middle reliever.
Yeah, I think they'll add like two relief pieces.
And I think I would be really pleasantly surprised
if one of them was one of the first two or three names that you mentioned.
Because, you know, we've talked about this.
Jed just doesn't.
I'm thinking they should do that.
All right.
I don't know if it's smart, though.
Well, I don't know if any of this is smart.
I'm about to tell you why I like Matthew Boyd in this next segment.
Because Tanner Scott's in the ninth.
Okay, everyone goes back a rung.
Porter Hodge, set-up man.
Yeah, I just have concerns.
I just have concerns with relievers and their volatility.
I wouldn't be surprised if Tanner Scott forgot how to throw a strike in April.
Camilo Doval got DFA.
David Bednar was one of the worst relievers.
We wanted him last year at this time.
I just get concerned with those guys.
But at some point, there's cons to everything.
You got to go out and take a risk.
I just don't think this organization really works that way.
So let's talk about Boyd.
But maybe they make a trade with one of the teams that's having TV trouble.
You know, do they get Duran or Jax from the Twins?
Can we make a trade with ourselves?
Because there's got to be some sort of TV trouble on our end.
Well, I'd have to look into that.
I know we're not getting as much money from Marquis.
Well, we didn't go after a generational free agent who might end up with the Red Sox,
who were in a worse position than we were in going into the year.
Let's find out more about Matthew Boyd next.
Hey, today's episode is brought to you by Game Time.
Whether it's a Cubs game, a comedy show, or a concert,
I love going to live events.
And now Game Time has a new feature called Game Time Picks
that makes getting tickets for your favorite live events even easier.
Game Time Picks filters out the bluff
to show you all the incredible deals on great seats.
You don't have to waste time searching through thousands of tickets.
Clear last minute deals, all-in prices,
use your receipt and their lowest price guarantee.
Game Time takes the guesswork out of buying MLB tickets.
The experience of searching for and buying tickets on Game Time
is simple.
Plus, Game Time is the only ticketing app
that gives you complete peace of mind with your purchase.
See the view from your seat before you buy
so you know exactly what to expect when you arrive.
Download the Game Time app, create an account,
and use code LOCKDOWNMLB for $20 off your first purchase.
Terms do apply.
Again, create an account, redeem code LOCKDOWNMLB for $20 off.
Download the Game Time app today.
What time is it?
It's Game Time.
On Monday, the Cubs signed Matthew Boyd.
Two years, $29 million, first reported by John Heyman
in the wee hours of the morning.
Boyd made eight starts for the Guardians last year.
2.72 ERA with 46 strikeouts and 13 walks and 40 innings.
That's after returning from an injury.
He also had a 0.75 ERA and 12 innings in the playoffs.
Fastball slider change, Sam.
Fastball in the low 90s.
As you said earlier, durability, big question mark.
What I would call attendance issues.
A career-high 32 starts way back in 2019.
Go ahead.
Pros.
The Cubs are...
Folks, the pitching landscape has changed.
If you look at the full body of work for Matthew Boyd,
you're going to say to yourself,
what are the Cubs doing?
But things change yearly.
Guys add more to their...
In Boyd's case, throw a change up more.
Slider less.
Reinvent yourself.
Different arm angles.
Sean Mania last year.
And clearly, whatever he did to reinvent himself
in the 2024 season, the Cubs feel is a sustainable product
and something that they think is real
and that he could be a guy.
He started postseason games last year.
He was really, really good.
The 46 strikeouts and 39 innings are really, really good.
The problem is that since 2020,
the most innings he's thrown in a season is 78.
That's not going to cut it.
And there isn't a very big sample size here.
So you just gave $29 million to a guy that...
You basically gave him $29 million
because you like what you saw over a 39
and two thirds inning sample in the regular season.
And I think 11 and a third in the postseason.
But this is what it's like now.
They got all these guys.
The Zombro hire, the pitching gurus,
these smart guys probably said,
hey, that's a guy to target.
See what he's doing there?
It's sustainable and he's going to be really good.
In a vacuum, as I used in the reaction video this morning,
I'm cautiously intrigued in a vacuum.
But when you consider everything
and all the messaging that we're getting from the Cubs,
of course, it's a shoulder shrug.
Of course, it's an eye roller.
But I do think if healthy,
Matthew Boyd can really help the Chicago Cubs.
He's better than 2024 Kyle Hendricks
and he's better than Javier Assad.
That's the starting point.
And hopefully he adds to their ceiling
and it's a high risk, high reward situation for this team.
Yeah, I think the looming question even right now,
but definitely if he doesn't pitch well,
definitely if he's just not around,
is why didn't they acquire more of a sure thing?
So again, I know I'm just answering my own critiques,
but I think he is a sure thing
for the spot and the rotation he should be in.
But is he going to be in that spot?
Is it going to be Steele, fill in the blank,
Imanaga, Tyone Boyd?
I don't have a crystal ball.
So this is the move that we're analyzing right now.
Again, I don't think this impacts Zazaki's market at all.
I would love him on the Cubs.
If it does, then we got real.
It shouldn't.
He's not going to make any money.
Why should it?
But why does he cost so much?
Yeah, so it's a great question.
I know there's dominoes falling.
Go ahead.
Well, there's pitching dominoes already falling.
Snell, Montas, who else?
I think Montas.
Missing a couple guys.
Yeah, they're all, Kikuchi.
Yes.
Two years, 34 million.
When I saw that before I went to sleep Sunday for Montas,
if I didn't see that, the boy price would shock me.
But because of that, look, Jed has a track record of this.
He overpays a lot sometimes on guys that he really thinks has a distinct quality.
Sometimes he hits, sometimes he misses.
But I know it's a lazy thing to say, but we'll judge it when we get to spring training.
And most importantly, we'll judge it when the games start to matter.
This guy needs to produce.
I was seeing some stuff on Twitter today.
Oh, well, he'll be a good swing man.
There's no $14 million swing man.
This guy's going to be starting every fifth day, whether we like it or not.
He's not even going to be in the bullpen.
No, he needs to pitch, and he needs to pitch well.
Now, maybe in Japan, the first two games of the year, it comes out of the pen because
everyone's going to need work, and guys will be shorter.
But for over 162, he's going to be getting the ball.
He needs to produce, and he needs to pitch well.
And I do believe, if healthy, some of the things that he fixed, I know it sounds crazy,
33-year-old reinventing himself, but welcome to the new pitching world.
It's just a lot for a guy who projects as a 1.9 war player for 2025, according to Fangraphs.
It's a lot.
I suppose this is the market, but wow.
And the projection that MLB trade rumors had was two for 25.
This isn't that egregious from that, but yeah.
The pitching market, clearly, I thought Cucucci was two for 32.
We got three for 63.
These guys, clearly, it's elevated.
That's why I really do believe this is probably it for the Cubs, in terms of free agent
acquisitions with the starter.
Yeah, because Evaldi will get definitely a three-year deal now, maybe four.
Yeah.
No, I'll tell you, guys like Freed are just thrilled with these deals.
Burns is going to be 35 a year, easy.
Look, I don't dislike it as much as others do, but this is what the Cubs have created.
Until we see it play out on the field, when you come out publicly and disqualify yourself
from Soto and Freed and Burns, and then your first two moves of the offseason, I'm not
counting dice.
Our Eli Morgan and Matthew Boyd, people are going to do exactly what you did at 7 a.m.,
and that is shoulder shrug and say, all right, whatever, and they're totally in the right
by doing that.
If we're in June and Matthew Boyd is 5-1 or 5-2 with a 2-7-7, and we'll go back and go,
all right, Jed was on to something there, but we're not going to give them the benefit
of the doubt because they haven't earned it until we see it.
And your first measuring stick, you've even mentioned this within the last couple of
weeks, is Memorial Day.
Talk to me about all this stuff on Memorial Day.
And I wonder, let me count tonight how many games that is.
Last year that was about 62 or something, so I'll have to double check on that.
Wow, yeah, this was the first, oh, the other thing I wanted to say, Sam, that was, I was
forgetting, the other thing I thought this morning while getting ready was, why does
Carter Hawkins have so much influence on this team?
But then I remembered Boyd was actually with the Tigers, and Hawkins was with the Guardians,
so I don't need to go down my conspiracies there.
Yeah, and I actually, after watching the Bears press conference today, I have respect for
the Cubs' organizational hierarchy because at least it makes sense.
Carter's the GM, he reports to Jed.
Jed's the president of Baseball Ops, who actually knows baseball, and then he goes
to Tom.
But I just, look, guys, every single Friday for the last five Fridays, I've tried to warn
you that this type of stuff's coming.
And so we'll see.
Maybe they make a big splash for the trade, but.
No, I was actually sketching out my predictions for next week, last night, late.
And I had all basically one-year deals for the Cubs, one- or two-year deals.
So they just signed Boyd in free agency.
We expect them to make a trade for a pitcher.
That's number two.
We expect them to get.
I don't expect that.
Okay, I do.
Yeah.
I don't want Javier Assad.
I'm, you know, whatever.
Three, a catcher, another catcher.
Four, bullpen acquisitions, maybe two of them.
And then five, maybe like a utility bat.
A bench player, yeah.
So basically, this was like 20% of the off-seasons.
No, I had the Cubs signing five players next week.
Well, here's one.
Coming up next, I just, I want to review just or emphasize our, what I would call a gut
feeling on this.
Stay tuned.
This episode is brought to you by FanDuel.
Get ready to tackle the NFL action with FanDuel, America's number one sports book.
Because right now, new customers can bet $5, get $150, and bonus bets if you win.
The FanDuel Sportsbook app gives you everything you need to take to place live bets on the
NFL all in one place.
So when you get a hunch in the middle of the game, you can check out the latest stats,
do live play-by-play, and so much more on the same page where you place your bets.
The Bears open at five and a half point underdogs over, I believe, Santa Clara is where the
49ers play those games now.
And yeah, I don't really know about this game.
McCaffrey's hurt.
It feels like kind of a, if the Bears win, everyone's going to want to hire Thomas Brown.
Based on one win?
Well, you just know how it goes.
Don't tell me if they don't go out there and beat San Francisco, that won't be the
story of the talk shows on Monday or Tuesday.
I just lost all trust in that organization.
Correct.
That sounded like counsel.
But five and a half, you can get the Bears.
Just visit FanDuel.com to join today.
You'll get started with $150 in bonus bets if you win your first $5 bet.
That's FanDuel.com.
Never waste a hunch and make every moment more with FanDuel, an official sportsbook
partner of the NFL.
So we're 30 minutes in.
I just want to bring up, are our initial thoughts and feelings correct?
Because you know what?
They basically happened the last two years since we've done this show.
Again, the Cubs can mitigate this by getting someone to pencil in between Steele and Imanaga.
But if they don't do that, our initial thoughts and feelings aren't correct.
Are they not?
Well, assuming our initial thoughts.
Do you think it could be a number three?
I think he has three upside.
I think if it were to go really well.
How about we just get more certainty?
Okay, no more upside.
No more projections.
Get someone that we could put in pen, not even pencil.
But Matt.
Number two or number three spot.
Get someone that we could put in pen in the eighth or ninth inning.
But Matt, this is what you're going to have to fight with the next two or three months.
We're going to say this about every acquisition.
They said no to Juan Soto.
Soto goes.
Hey, Scott, anything from the Cubs?
No, they're out on you.
What?
When they did that, they told you that this is the gut feeling.
This is the expectation.
So I didn't realize it had that heavy a ramification.
I was disappointed in that, but I thought they could still make a buzz.
I thought they could still create a buzz.
After that passing came out and said they don't want anything to do with the high major starters
and freed.
So what more?
This is it.
This is what we're working with.
So do we make lemons?
How does that?
Lemonade out of lemons, whatever that saying is.
Do we do that?
Or we could be absolutely in the right and just come on every day and talk about why
aren't they spending more?
Why aren't they doing that?
But we still have to try and win games here.
And do they actually run back the offense?
Well, it's starting to trend that way.
But maybe there's a Horner deal or a Bellinger deal.
Yeah, I think the Braves might be a Bellinger sooner.
I'm higher on the vacuum situation of Matthew Boy.
If you take away everything that we've heard from the Cubs and just look at this signing,
I think they got better today.
I think they got better.
But if this is their only free agent acquisition in terms of starters, this was the one.
Did they get enough better?
The rest of the offseason will determine that.
Thank you so much for checking out this edition of Locked On Cubs.
I didn't even speak English.
Enough better.
20 to 30 minutes.
We'll give you all things Cubs.
After 30 minutes, it's all out.
A laugh or two along the way.
Be sure to hit subscribe on YouTube.
Smash the like button for the algorithm and leave a five-star review on Apple, Spotify,
and everywhere.
Yeah, I did think we were going to go a little bit longer.
He's Sam Olber.
I'm Matt Cozy.
This is Locked On Cubs.
See ya.
