[日劇人生選舉研究所] 立法院維持複數席次選舉方式,民進黨永遠不可能過半?

Linn County Republicans
18 followers
⏰ 每週一、六晚上固定更新 ⏰
成為這個頻道的會員並獲得福利:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCixY8imn25Ex2Z6vvWu4VJQ/join
朝小野大國會紛擾不斷,也令綠營支持者懷念過去八年完全執政的舒適,這集影片將帶大家來探討如果立法院維持大選區多席次的選舉方式,民進黨是否還有單獨過半的可能性?
====================================
😚 懇請訂閱 https://bit.ly/3Qzjax0
Ⓜ️ 會員頻道 https://bit.ly/3QyGpar
====================================
大家好,歡迎來到日劇人生選舉研究所!
從2023年6月開始從選區選民結構、小區塊基本盤、歷屆選舉歷史到主要候選人對比一一解析台灣73個立委選區選舉戰況,累積超過30萬點閱,非選戰期間也將持續不定期帶來新的政局觀察和解析,會員頻道持續更新對2026地方選舉各縣市之選情展望,當然也歡迎內地的小夥伴關心台灣政壇的發展,如果你喜歡我的影片,也別忘了幫我分享給可能感興趣的親友,戲如人生,人生如戲,就讓我們一起繼續看下去!
🍵 歡迎點讚、訂閱和分享!
====================================
#日劇人生選舉研究所 #選舉 #政論 #立委選舉 #單一選區兩票制 #民進黨 #國民黨 #台派 #日劇人生
Hello everyone, I'm YuanSheng.
Hello everyone, I'm RikyoRinShin.
This time, we're going back to the public channel to post a public video.
Before, I saw a comment in the video of the Ten Greatest Wars.
Someone asked me if I could talk about the election of the Legislative Council in 2001 and 2004.
However, the main topic of the Ten Greatest Wars is still the election of the single-term.
The election of the Legislative Council of multiple-term
In fact, what can be said is quite scattered.
So I thought about it and decided to change the way to discuss the election of the multiple-term era.
Let's discuss this topic today.
If the election of the Legislative Council is still the way to maintain the multiple-term election of the general election area.
Is it possible for the Democratic Party to be more than half?
Before we start the discussion, let's help ourselves first.
After watching this video, if you want to see my analysis of the election of the Mayor of 2026 and the election of the Taipei City Councilor,
You are also welcome to join my membership channel at any time.
The membership channel will update the membership video three times a month.
Now, the analysis of the first round of the Mayor of Taipei has been completed.
The part of the Taipei City Councilor has also reached the heart of Songshan.
The Taipei City Councilor will continue to go all the way to the Xinbei Islands.
If you haven't joined yet, please support me.
First, let's take a look at the results of the two elections of 2001 and 2004.
The election of the 225th session took place in three sessions in total.
1998, 2001 and 2004
Among them, 1998 was the era of Lee Teng-hui.
The political environment is actually quite different from the last two sessions.
In fact, the concept of blue and green was not yet formed at that time.
And that was the first election of the 225th session.
Without the previous experience,
The two parties' nomination strategies are actually more difficult to grasp.
The Democratic Progressive Party won the election in 1997.
It wanted to take advantage of the victory and fight in the Legislative Yuan to fight for the central government in 2000.
But because it was too aggressive, the result of the high nomination was not as expected.
The discrimination distribution in 1998 is actually quite different from the last two sessions.
We won't compare them together.
Just look at the two sessions of 2001 and 2004.
In fact, the overall discrimination of blue and green is almost the same.
The definition of blue and green is of course the KMT, the Pro-Democratic Party and the New Party.
In fact, the New Party was only left with Kim Il-sung's Wu Cheng-dien.
The blue and green is the Democratic Progressive Party and the LDP.
In 2001, there were 10 more than five major political parties.
Among them, Zhao Yongqin of Taipei County and Zhang Huaguan of Jiayi County were elected.
They joined the Democratic Progressive Party immediately.
So of course it's on the blue and green side.
Chen Wenqian of Taipei City South District, Yan Qingbiao of Taichung County,
Cai Hao of Pingtung, Lin Bingkun of Penghu,
Gao Jin and Su Mei, three local residents.
These five, of course, are on the blue side.
The remaining three, Zhang Hua, Chen Jingding, and Gao Mengding of Yunlin.
The three local residents, Wallace and Beilin,
are more difficult to define whether they are blue or green.
Because the trajectory of their re-election is actually blue and green.
In other words, they were all people who could fight for A'Bian.
Chen Jingding later joined the Democratic Progressive Party when Tsai Ing-wen was the chairman of the Democratic Progressive Party.
His daughter, Chen Xiubao, is now also a Democratic Progressive Party member.
But in the era of A'Bian, he was still a member of the Five-Party Alliance.
Gao Mengding used to be Zhang Rongwei's deputy mayor.
Of course, Zhang Rongwei supported him when he elected a legislator.
But his position has always been more towards the Democratic Progressive Party.
So he could be considered a bridge between the Democratic Progressive Party and Zhang Rongwei at the time.
Zhang Rongwei elected two mayors.
The Democratic Progressive Party, especially the one after that,
can be said to be a direct pushback.
He didn't want to fight with him at all.
That's also because of Gao Mengding.
Considering that the two of them are the electoral votes of the Legislative Council that A'Bian was more able to win at the time,
So I also put the two of them on the side of the legislature.
Wallace Bailin was actually more inclined towards Song Chu-yu at the time.
So I put him on the side of the legislature.
The overall legislature was 104 seats.
The legislature was 121 seats.
In 2004, there were 10 legislators who were not members of the Five-Party Alliance.
Li Yao from Nanqu in Taipei City.
Yan Qingbiao from Taichung County.
Zhang Lishan from Yunlin.
Li Heshun from Tainan County.
Cai Hao from Pingtung.
Lin Bingkun from Penghu.
Cao Erzhong from Mazu.
Gao Jinsumei from Sanli.
These eight people are not controversial.
They are all from the legislature.
The remaining two are Chen Qingting and Yang Zhongze from Changhua.
Chen Qingting said that I also put him on the side of the legislature.
Yang Zhongze is actually the most special one in this term.
He is also a political figure that can be blue and green.
He has a relationship with both the blue and green parties.
He has a deep friendship with the former Nationalist Party chief Liu Taiyin and the important economic leader Lin Xinyi in the A'Bian era.
In fact, he is a Nationalist Party in a more liberal era.
But for A'Bian, he is also a person who can fight for.
So I put him on the side of the legislature.
The total number of blue and green parties in this term is 103.
The number of blue and green parties in this term is 122.
So this table is for the blue and green parties.
Everyone can hear it.
My judgment is actually relaxed.
People who can fight for A'Bian can be blue and green.
I will regard him as a blue and green party.
But in fact, like Chen Qingting and Yang Zhongze,
they are not always on the side of the legislature.
In fact, the results of the two elections can be said to be very close.
It can even be said that there is almost no difference.
In 2004, the president was elected in March and the legislator was elected in December.
Because in 2004, the president A'Bian just won the victory.
Although the process can be said to be turbulent,
it was the first time that the Democratic Party cut off the Nationalist Party in a one-to-one national election.
Of course, it also makes the Democratic Party confident.
It is believed that there is a chance in a short time to copy the election results of Wu Wupo.
It is possible to push the flag of blue and green to be closer or even more than half.
Even the election atmosphere at that time,
many supporters of the Democratic Party also believe that the law has a chance to be more than half this time.
But the result is the same as the previous one.
Of course, the reviews of the Democratic Party afterwards include that
the communication with the allies in Taiwan is not very smooth in terms of nomination.
So the green side actually has a situation of over-nomination.
On the other hand, the blue side has the total control of the Nationalist Party.
So it is better to choose the blue side.
However, in terms of technical quality,
the Democratic Party of A'Bian Linjun is already a voting machine that can vote and vote.
It can be said that what can be done is done.
Later, we will open it up again in each county.
The proportion of votes will be clearer in comparison with the presidential election in 2004.
In short, because the election is in A'Bian's position,
of course, it is not as good as expected.
Also because of this result,
there is no way to break through and let A'Bian see that
this kind of election system with multiple seats in the general election area
If it continues to go on, the Democratic Party is impossible to be more than half.
So I want to make a bottom-up draw.
A single-seat election is actually a win-win situation.
Chen Shui-bian himself is a god of election.
His interpretation of the election is also insightful.
It can even be said to be beyond the times.
Chen Shui-bian later also liked to say that
This is also because in his time,
he changed it to a single-seat election.
The cause of this win-win situation
allows Tsai Ing-wen to enjoy this fruit.
Of course, you can also say that A'Bian is actually a result theory.
After all, the first election in this way
is actually a win-win situation for the Democratic Party.
But later on,
what he said is actually right.
Then we will continue to draw and cut to see.
Next, let's take a look at the two elections in each district.
What will be the result that is beneficial to the law?
In addition, it can be said that in these two years,
in fact, the seats in each county have also changed slightly.
Taipei and Taichung are all added together.
Pingdong and Yilan are all reduced together.
So the seats in each county
are compared to the one in 2004.
Even if these two years are both results that are beneficial to the law,
the total seats in the green camp will only come to 107 seats.
The main difference is still that
Taozhumiao East Outer Island and these pieces of aboriginal people.
Because these pieces are really much worse.
So how can the law choose
There will be a gap in the distance of more than half.
Let's take a closer look at the results of each county.
Let's look at the part of Taozhumiao Yihua in Beipei.
There are a total of 12 electoral districts in these 9 counties.
Among them, Jirong, Taipei City,
Hsinchu County, Miaoli, and Hualien.
The election results of these two years are exactly the same.
Yilan has fewer seats, so there is a change.
However, according to Yilan's basic plan,
there is no problem with the green two seats and the blue one.
This is the limit of these places.
It's the same if you choose again.
The three elections in Taipei County
In fact, the law in 2001 is better than 2004.
If they are all good results,
the first election district and the third election district
This is probably the limit.
I'm here to add the presidential election of 2004.
Let's compare the votes of both parties.
In these 12 electoral districts, I think only
Taipei County Second Election District and Taoyuan
There's a little bit more chance here.
The Taipei County Second Election District at the time
It includes the three Luzhou New Village.
These green camps are the main ticket offices in Taipei County.
The votes of Abian in 2004
It's all won in a row.
In this area, 2001 is a 5-5 draw.
But in 2004,
According to the percentage of votes in this presidential election,
In fact, the law should also have a chance to get six seats.
So the more ideal result should be like this.
Of course, this is also an ideal.
Because the Ming Dynasty election is still different from the presidential election.
The influence of people will be greater than the party.
Especially in Taipei City.
There are still a lot of influence factors of local factions.
Including the three Luzhou New Village in Taipei County.
Although the green camp in the presidential election is a stable advantage,
But the green camp in the Ming Dynasty is actually not cheap.
So I said this is an ideal number of the law.
It's still difficult to achieve in reality.
Next, let's look at the part of Zhongzhang, Touyun, Jianan and Gaoping.
There are a total of 13 electoral districts in these 12 counties.
Among them, Zhanghua, Yunning, Jiayi County, Tainan County, Kaohsiung City, and North District.
The results of the two elections are exactly the same.
Tainan City, Kaohsiung City, South District
The law is better than 2004 in 2001.
Kaohsiung County is better than 2001 in 2004.
We all get good results here.
Taichung City has an increase of one seat in 2004.
This seat was obtained by the law.
Pingtung City has a decrease of one seat in 2004.
This seat is less than the law.
The above electoral districts are the ones that benefit the green camp.
This should also be the limit of the law.
I will also compare the votes of both sides in the 2004 presidential election.
I think these areas are only in Taichung County.
There is still room for the law to go up.
Taichung County is also a place where the influence of the party is more important.
Although A'Bian 2004 was better than Lianzhan in Taichung County.
But the law is in Taichung County for two consecutive years.
Only four seats were obtained in the 11 seats.
This is a big difference from the presidential election.
Of course, the law of 2004 may see A'Bian in Taichung County for more than half of the seats.
So the law in Taichung County is to mention eight people.
The Democratic Progressive Party mentioned six people, and the Taichung County mentioned two people.
Excessive nomination is also the reason why only four seats were elected in the end.
If the nomination strategy works,
the law should be able to get one more seat in Taichung County.
Finally, it is the part of Dongpeng, Jinma, Yunzhuming District.
Taichung, Dongpeng, Yunzhuming, Jinma, Yunzhuming, and Matsu are the only places where the Democratic Progressive Party won.
Although the Democratic Progressive Party won more than one seat in Taichung and Dongpeng after the reform of the single-unit electorate.
But that's a later story.
At least in the time,
the Democratic Progressive Party was not strong enough to win the election in Taichung and Dongpeng.
So these four seats were the ironclads of the Democratic Progressive Party.
The third-place resident, the Democratic Progressive Party, also succeeded in the next election in 2020.
So it was also the ironclad of the Democratic Progressive Party in the past.
The third-place resident, the Democratic Progressive Party, also succeeded in the next election in 2004.
So the majority of the seats in Taichung and Dongpeng were taken by the third-place resident.
In fact, the blue and green districts are equal.
In 2004, the Democratic Progressive Party won more than one seat in Taichung and Dongpeng.
Let's look at the presidential election in 2004.
Although Penghu was also in the top five,
but Lin Bingkun was still very strong in the time.
The Democratic Progressive Party's Yang Yao was just a small member at that time.
The Democratic Progressive Party was not strong enough to compete with Lin Bingkun.
So in the end, how do you look at the percentage?
Or is it just that the percentage of the undivided area is a little higher?
If the percentage of the undivided area is one more seat,
plus the previous Taipei County, Secondary Election District, Taoyuan, and Taichung County can be one more seat,
the best case scenario for the percentage is 111 seats.
This is the result that can only be achieved if there is no mistake in the election.
That is to say, if you take the wrong step, you will not have this disadvantage.
So I said,
A'Bien should have seen through it after the 2004 election that
no matter what the law is, it is impossible to be more than half of the undivided area.
So it's a lucky draw.
We all know that A'Bien has a very strong gambler's personality.
He wants to say that he is going to buy it all at once.
This is also a very reasonable choice.
Finally, let's talk about the conclusion.
The Democratic Progressive Party cannot be more than half of the undivided area.
There are two main factors.
The first is the nature of the Legislative Council election or the election of the Ming Dynasty.
The factor of the voter is greater than the party.
The results of the presidential election cannot be replicated to the Legislative Council election.
The second is that the election of the pluralist system has a top and bottom line in each district.
We also saw that there is a difference of one seat more or one seat less in each district.
It is impossible for you to choose a good situation in each county.
It is impossible for you to swing to six every time.
Some counties in each district must be better chosen.
Some counties are not chosen well.
Your camp is the lion, the eagle, the cattle, the shark.
In fact, the ratio of the two parties in each district is almost the same.
Just like the situation in the two districts of 2001 and 2004.
After you change it to a single district, the two districts of 2016 and 2020, the Democratic Party can win by more than half.
The first one is to change the single majority to win all.
The upper and lower lines of the regional legislators are expanded.
If you talk about extremism all over Taiwan, you can get 51% of the votes in 73 districts.
The opponent is 49%.
Your majority is 73 to 0.
If the wind is strong, it is one-sided.
This is actually a result of 2016 and 2020.
The second is that the presidential legislature later changed to a merger election.
In this way, the voting rate will be higher than only the election of legislators.
If only the election of legislators, the limit of the voting rate is about 60%.
It's the same as the situation in 2008.
You vote because you think this election is related to you.
Many of them are votes that the local parties can influence.
The two elections of the presidential legislature will also have a certain connectivity.
It will weaken the tendency of voters to elect people.
Speaking of which, some people will say that even if the presidential legislature is elected together, there will still be split voting.
Indeed, the independence of voters is getting higher and higher.
The connectivity of the presidential legislature is also weakening.
In some areas, we can see that the presidential and legislative elections will also have a difference of 20,000 to 30,000 votes.
But this connectivity will still exist.
Split voting is a powerful political figure.
Of course, it is more powerful.
If there is no merger election, it will still be like the presidential election in January 2008 and the presidential election in March.
In 2016 and 2020, the Democratic People's Party may not be able to win alone.
The result is that changing to a single-party system is a short-term and long-term change for the Democratic People's Party.
Ah-bin said that he saw it from a distance.
In fact, it is also true.
Although this strong medicine made the Democratic People's Party lose and destroy the party,
it can be said that the medicine was too strong at first.
Then the patient may die soon.
In addition, in 2012, Ma Ying-jeou sacrificed the long-term interests of the KMT for his own re-election.
He let the president and legislators merge the election.
After that, it became a custom and it was not convenient to change.
Because of these two factors, the Democratic People's Party has the opportunity to enjoy an eight-year full governance.
If the legislative system has not been changed, even if Tsai Ing-wen wins in 2016 and 2020,
the limit of the Democratic People's Party is probably what I said earlier.
It is difficult to exceed the limit of 110 seats.
It is probably 105 to 110 seats.
This is already the limit.
The above is the extra part of this episode.
There will be a video of China-Russia-Japan-Taiwan-Gangxiong voting room analysis on Saturday.
The next video of the election will return to the member channel to analyze the part of the Taipei City Council election in Zhongshan Datong.
If you like the content of this episode, please help me to subscribe, share and like.
Finally, I would like to thank all the friends who joined the membership and supported me in the end.
Thank you for using action to give me the most practical support.
If you want to see the election of the mayor of 2026 and the analysis of the Taipei City Council election series,
you are also welcome to join my membership channel at any time.
I will read all the comments on the membership channel.
If you have any points you want to discuss, you can ask.
If there is a place where you can discuss and respond, I will try my best to respond.
If you want to see China-Russia-Japan-Taiwan-Gangxiong voting room analysis, we will see you on Saturday.
If you only want to see the election analysis, we will see you next Monday.
