The Corona virus outbreak is causing a lot of fear, and misinformation. Here we are trying to separate the Fear from the Facts, with an interview with the Infectious Disease Consultant Dr Ravi Gowda
Hopefully, you have found the first video looking at the Corona Virus useful in understanding what is going on, and realising that whilst it is serious, the scare factor appears to be exacerbated by the way the story is being reported in the media.
Yes, the Wuhan Virus is causing deaths and is an international medical problem, but what is the SCIENCE? What about the facts behind the virus? Crucially if we look at the numbers compared to flu, should we actually be focusing our attention there?
Dr Gowda, has been terrific and clear in giving us unbiased, accurate and reasonable information about this virus outbreak and comparing it to other events in the recent past.
Some people will notice that a couple of themes from the first video resurfaces here. That is intentional if someone only watches one of these videos, I want to ensure the highest chances of the video helping them :)
One of the things we highlight here is the need to look after yourself, and part of that is being cognisant of risk. For most people, certainly outside of China and adjacent countries, the risk of Corona Virus is low. However the risk of flu is much higher, and we have that as a flu vaccine to minimise that risk of harm. So I get a mild scolding for not having had my seasonal flu vaccine, and end up on the sharp end of the needle, getting my vaccination!
Please drop your comments below, I’d hope to carry on this series but only if it is providing a benefit, and helping to provide good quality info to help you come to your own conclusions.
If it has been useful, what further videos would you like to see and how could we improve the format?
#Coronavirus #goodscience #health #vaccines
-------------------
Image copyright info
BruceBlaus - flu virus
Mosquito - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Muhammad_Mahdi_Karim
TB - cdc TB. Credit: Charles Farmer, 1963, courtesy of CDC
Malaria - http://journals.plos.org/plosbiology/article?id=10.1371/journal.pbio.0030192
MERS - Maureen Metcalfe/Cynthia Goldsmith/Azaibi Tamin - https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/mers/photos.html
Droplet spread - James Gathany - CDC Public Health Image library ID 11162
FACE MASK - Artur Bergman - CPMC Surgery
https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/
SARS - cdc https://www.cdc.gov/dotw/sars/index.html
You can now consult via video or in person with Dr Gill at Dr Finlay’s Private Practice - https://www.drfinlays.co.uk/services/video-consultation/
00:00 - Introduction
00:03 - Overview of Coronavirus: Incubation Period and Symptoms
01:50 - Safety of Air Travel During the Pandemic
06:12 - Treatment Options for Coronavirus
07:39 - Understanding the Fatality Rate of Coronavirus
09:22 - What Defines a Pandemic?
13:45 - Importance of Getting the Flu Vaccine
18:04 - Demonstrating Flu Vaccination
19:37 - Conclusion: Perspective on Coronavirus vs. Flu
[Music]
that's probably a nice segue to go back
into this coronavirus one of the
questions that we've got here from
Stuart Ardis you know how long against
the incubation for the virus and what
are the symptoms that people might be
getting the first thing to ask is what
do we mean by the incubation period so
the incubation period at the time when
you first get infected to the point you
develop the symptoms and for coronavirus
it's quite short it's usually only two
to five days an average about four or
five days from the from the case series
that we've happened from from China so
on the balance of probability if you've
not got symptoms within the first week
then you're unlikely to get it however
as a precaution because there's a
variability in the individual and the
virus we say that let's say you've come
back from China if we do not develop
symptoms in the first 14 days after
return you should be fine so 14 days is
the cutoff and how confident are we in
that fork and very confident because
we've got some got lots of data from
similar coronaviruses and if you look at
the molecular structure of this current
virus and compare it with with with SARS
it's actually very similar okay we think
it's even the same receptor the main
difference the main differences it's
much milder SARS was more serious and
there was a higher mortality with that
but the the new coronavirus curve in
nineteen is it's behaving in a very
similar way to the influenza virus I
think that a lot of people get worried
you know is it safe to fly can I go in a
metal tube you know and come out safe on
the other end it's a good question
listen it's a new virus so people have
not encountered the virus and therefore
people are going to become infected
until all of this until the virus
stabilizes in each of the countries in
in the communities just like the swine
flu
the important thing for people to bear
in mind is that it is a virus that
spread by droplets and therefore gonna
plane is not high risk at all you know
go on your holidays go to the countries
that you want to visit at the moment in
the UK the the Foreign and Commonwealth
Office recommending not to travel to
China unless it's it's essential so I'm
all right to go on holiday to Italy next
week yeah absolutely perfect I need my
pastor okay you said that we know it's
not that infectious let's bless you know
put it in context that people can
understand
I know if one of my patients comes in
with flu you know I'm gonna say rats I
wish I've got around to getting that flu
jab how effective or infectious is the
killer virus compared to flu okay so you
know viruses in the nitrous corona virus
are obligate intracellular parasites
medical school was a little while ago go
through that one again it was long for
me absolutely right yeah but I'm a GP
now I know a lot about a little know I
know a little about a lot yeah well you
can get a very experienced listen um if
you break that that phrasing to do into
each of those words obligate means it
has two intracellular means it has to
live within a cell a living cell a human
cell for example okay
parasite a parasite relationship because
we're a organism that's lives on and on
another organism to survive but if it's
taken out of that situation it can't
survive for example take the perfect
example exactly okay so viruses viruses
are organisms that they need other
another living cell to survive so when
they're outside and in that cell on a
phone most format means anything in
animate like it
able or a book or any other surface the
cancer survivor' very long and we know
in it from the evidence we have so far
for coronaviruses they survived about as
much as a flu virus in the external
external environment about an hour or so
okay
they can't survive very long and if you
wipe the surfaces down or you practice
good hygiene washing your hands then
then you even eliminate that risk as
well so we have mentioned about people
you know wearing masks and things but
correct me if I'm wrong but my opinion
is that a mask isn't going to do much to
protect a patient from getting you know
infection just walking down the street
but as you said just that good hand
hygiene making sure they're washing
their hands potentially using alcoa gel
that's how somebody protects themselves
from getting this isn't it yeah
absolutely
because this droplet spread it's off the
contact the services and then they mess
about with their eyes or the nose or the
mouth or people who might have influenza
marker advice will coffin sneeze over
people yeah face to face like me and you
are so first phase usually means about a
meter but arm's length all right and
that's when you get infected you know
you don't get infected when you're
walking down the street or walking
through an airport okay it's close
face-to-face contact when somebody
coughs or sneezes and when you touch so
when you wear a mask walking through an
airport you you're more likely to touch
surfaces that are infected and then
you're more like such your face your
nose your eyes or mouth and I personally
think masks are worse and increasing
risk of infection particularly not in
that context so we've got a good
question from Gordon Clayton what
treatment is being used on the people
that have contracted the virus I mean my
take is that if it's like influenza
we're just sort of tea sympathy in a bit
of chicken soup what influenza first of
all and it's supposed to repeat like you
said plenty of hydration to get look if
you want to if you're not vegetarian and
but if you're severely ill we can
give a drug called shot Olivia or the
common name is Tamiflu mm-hmm for the
cone of ice
most people again concert' him because
it's a mild disease for most people and
drink plenty fluid stick passage of all
and you'll get better however a small
group of your patients will be civilian
well and they'll be hospitalized and we
do have well tried and tested and drug
at the moment there is a drug called
remedy severe and that is being trialed
at the moment in China now it's been
used sparingly in other coronavirus in
the past but it's never been used for
curve in nineteen the new current virus
it's it's been used in humans so
therefore we know it doesn't have any
serious side effects okay so we have to
just go go go along and actually try
this and hopefully hopefully it might be
effective ultra wander has asked you
know why is the corona virus fatal which
i think is quite an interesting question
given me know what we've just talked
about that for most people it's kind of
like flu I'm glad you asked me that
cause it I think this is an important
question to ask to answer should I say
the bottom line is less than three
percent of people will die if they're
infected with the corona virus some
people have a very mild disease they
hardly know they've got it so let's take
things into context the flu the flu
virus okay it affects about five million
people at least confirmed case around
the world and it can kill about 600,000
people a year okay that's that's that's
that's more that's a lot more than than
the corona virus okay
the corona virus I said it's got a
fatality a case fatality ratio so a
number of deaths compared to the number
of cases of about to be precise two
point eight percent okay but but a bit
it's less than three percent okay so you
know it's it's not universally lethal
and so people need to understand the
people
fitting well I like it to have a mild
disease where it can be severe where it
can cause pneumonia and and people can
be really and well are people who might
have underlying health problems so
people who might have chronic lung
disease heart disease they may have
cancer or they may have a weakened
immune system or they're older over the
age of 50 65 and they're much more
vulnerable and they more likely get
severe disease so the fact that Netflix
is suggesting I watch pandemic class
tonight is probably just marketing and
that's not what we're looking at well
that's just I don't know that's what
help helpful okay the world pandemic
have got connotations of films and
people with masks and people and
isolation and people dying everywhere
now what does the word pandemic mean
pandemic means when you have a new
disease I can new virus that people the
human population have not encountered
and it begins to affect multiple regions
around the world for example multiple
continents so SARS that was a panda and
it was yeah and technically technically
by that definition you could argue the
current virus is a pandemic because it's
a new disease and it's affecting several
continents okay but it hasn't got
sustained spread within other continents
apart from sort of Southeast Asia so I
don't think we're quite there yet what
we want to sustain spread and you
haven't got that and from from from a
technical point of view people might
argue that and and so what you know
swine flu pandemic was there okay it's
now transferred from being a pandemic to
an endemic disease so now hopefully
circulating in it within the population
of Europe or through Asia or through
North America KP and that's not on the
news anymore no it still if
actually it's probably that there are
more cases of flu every year and there
are okay wait doesn't know the news it's
no more people are dying from flu but it
doesn't make the news so good just got
to be careful the word pandemic and not
be too alarmed by it so we seem to be
going back several times of this
coronavirus versus flu given the choice
I think that I'd probably prefer to
tangle with coronavirus than the you
know a straightforward influenza at the
moment that's the impression I'm getting
I think if you are fit and well okay you
have a very similar disease again often
the corona virus will be milder from
from from the evidence we have so far if
you if your fitter well but I think if
you have if your underlying disease a
pre-existing medical condition or of a
weakened immune system the both can be
severe okay and I would want either of
them to be honest okay
I think the slight advantage with
influences that there is a vaccine okay
at the moment with corona virus we don't
have a definite treatment or a vaccine
and and that's why it's important to
practice good personal hygiene so if you
are if you're symptomatic if you have
cough or sneeze okay if you're sneezing
make sure you use a tissue handkerchief
when you cough or sneeze if you haven't
got that easier arm we're elbow okay
stop the disease from spreading
pin it dispose of those tissues
properly into bin and then make sure you
kill it wash your hands or use our
culture afterwards with good personal
hygiene we can prevent the spread of
this virus and what's really important
is you need to make sure that if you've
got symptoms you don't go around public
transport or go on a flight don't go
into a hospital if you don't need to go
into a specific if the if as if this is
it if the symptoms are mild stay at home
okay so you know it's the things that
you don't expect people to be doing
anyway be polite be considerate about
other people if you're unwell we'll save
hope anyway yeah but people aren't
always polite are they this nice I've
got all over you and and you can't
control that okay and you can tell them
oh yes ooh it's really really really
vaccine get it it's cheap okay you can
get from local pharmacies in the UK
travel clinics do it and yeah and if
you've got a pre-existing disease like
heart disease or cancer your own family
doctor can do it free of charge
all right and it's still not too late to
have the flu vaccine you can you can get
it late in the flu season because you
know in the northern hemisphere the flu
season starts what sort of air is it
actually started earlier this year
instead of to the mid-october and you
just arts in November December but it
started earlier this year but it can
extend towards March April so I may have
been on holiday when the vaccinations
were done at my practice and then
subsequently forgotten um would you say
it's still worthwhile getting a flu
vaccine now I think so and what James we
can do for you well while you're here I
walked into that yeah absolutely no it's
now February there's still a high risk
for you because you're vulnerable you're
vulnerable because I'm going off you
rapidly because okay no jokes aside
you're gonna be encountering patients
who will have flu facts the flu virus
okay now you've wondered because I've
already told you that you can't have
serious complications with flu in fact
you know healthy sadly very sadly very
sadly healthy kids in the UK in a modern
advanced health care
system died of influenza the handful of
kids died and the previously benefiting
well so it's really important that get
the flu vaccine for your own safety but
also you're gonna be off work getting
enough work for a week as a week's loss
of income so it's it's it's really it's
really important for a number of reasons
that you get the flu vaccine and also if
I'm not work for a week it means no it's
going to treat my patients absolutely
yes it's it's a multiplier effect if you
like it right let's play devil's
advocate then people are always going to
say you know if I have the flu vaccine
you know isn't I'm going to get me flu
you can play the devil's advocate if you
want to but actually that's not true
the flu vaccine contains the killed flu
virus it doesn't contain a live virus
and for you to get the influence that
you need a live virus okay that's the
important you need to understand
absolutely and that's what has so
frequently I'll to say to patients
that's why we'll give it to people who
are on chemotherapy people who don't
have an immune system absolutely kill
them if we were giving them a live
vaccine absolutely so so people think
well you know if I've got pre-existing
medical problems or if I've got a
weakened immune system or if I've had
chemotherapy perhaps I shouldn't begin
these vaccine in fact the converse is
true you know as long as it's not a live
vaccine vaccines are even more important
in these vulnerable groups so these
groups should be vaccinated and flu
so what about somebody who's got a cough
the cold they're a bit under the weather
does that going to affect their ability
to get the vaccine so off they got a
cough or a cold and you know if they're
sniffily it's more likely that they've
got the common cold okay and that
shouldn't really prevent you from having
the flu vaccine it's only if you've got
a high fever of more than 30 degrees
centigrade or you really unwell that's
when you probably ought to delay or
defer having the vaccine otherwise just
go and get your vaccine okay well I tell
us
let's get that vaccine today since I'm
here absolutely appropriate yeah thank
you so much for the time today it's been
very interesting for me and hopefully it
helped a lot of people at home who have
been ain't worried about things so thank
you very much indeed probably James
time to the stop is happy all right
James you asked for it you said you had
not been vaccinated and you are a health
care worker yes I will hang my head in
shame
yep you should you should do well at
least you've solved yourself so we're
going to vaccinate this influenza
vaccine it's got four strains yes it
covers all the main strains you're not
allergic to anything are you no you sell
em theoretically I should be fine you
fit in well
yeah good are you working with needles
yep
no just anyway whimper alright just go
to anywhere myself because it's always
scary when people show the needle before
the vaccination goes in right ready
mm-hm left toss it back arm out so
looking a little bit cold right it's
going now sharp scratch
it'll be cold
all done not dead so you're sorted for
this flu season but you'll have to come
back for another one next season
I'm sure we can solve that good done
thank you you're safe right well I'll
leave you with your infectious disease
patients and then return from whence I
came
stay well all right I could come back
next year okay well I think that we've
all got a really good understanding of
the background to the corona virus now
and to be honest I think that we can see
that whilst it is worrying for many
people I think that we've got many other
things that are more important out there
yes I've been taken to task for not
having had my flu vaccine but I think if
we watching this video and learning that
little bit more about the corona virus
if it's been something that has had you
thinking and worrying and you know
watching all the news reports whenever
they come out if you've been in that
situation then dr. Guerra showed us
today how in fact a common or garden
influenza flu virus is actually probably
going to be a bigger worry for you in
which case we already have a vaccine
they're so taught along to your you know
pharmacy or talk to your health
professionals and get PacSun ated so
hopefully that's something else it'll
take a bit of worry off your mind if you
found this video useful I'd be really
grateful if you could siddur whether or
not it would worthwhile sharing this
with somebody else this is all my
education here and try to help people
understand the science behind some of
the slightly alarming news reports we
get thanks for much every time and I
hope you found a benefit here if you've
got anything you'd like to add please
stick it in the comments below and I'll
try and get back to you thank you have a
good evening
you
you