Ranking Member Jamie Raskin delivers remarks

House Committee of the Judiciary
69 followers
1 Video View·Apr 3, 2025
Hearing: Artificial Intelligence: Examining Trends in Innovation and Competition
Subcommittee on Administrative State, Regulatory Reform, and Antitrust
Thank you kindly, Mr. Chairman, and thanks to our witnesses today.
It's hard to think of an antitrust matter more pressing than concentration in the AI
market.
The dominance of a handful of AI companies presents a long-term problem for our national
security, our democracy, our privacy, and basic fairness in the marketplace.
But President Trump has plunged our government into chaos and disabled the federal agencies
that we depend on to address such problems.
It will be difficult to effectively respond to dangerous market concentration in the assembly
of all human knowledge if we have governmental power that is dangerously concentrated itself
in the President to the exclusion of Congress as the lawmaking branch and the judiciary
as the protector of constitutional rights and values.
Over a century ago, Congress established the Federal Trade Commission.
It was created as an independent agency to enforce antitrust and consumer protection
laws outside of the controlling pressure and power agendas of any single president or party.
For more than a century, the FTC has protected Americans against scams, fraud, and other
unfair and deceptive practices.
It's also promoted and protected competition in the marketplace, which benefits consumers,
workers, and small businesses, driving innovation in business without monopoly.
Congress designed the FTC to be led by five commissioners across party lines who serve
seven-year terms, are subject to Senate confirmation, and can only be fired for a cause.
Congress structured this independence to ensure that the FTC would serve the nonpartisan interests
of the American people and be insulated from partisan political control.
Over 90 years ago, the independence of these commissioners was tested, and the Supreme
Court unanimously reaffirmed that the president cannot unilaterally fire an independent FTC
commissioner without cause.
Unitary executive power violated the careful federal design and infringed Congress's lawmaking
power to establish the FTC as an effective and balanced instrument for the public good.
Yet President Trump chose to violate federal law and defy the court's longstanding precedent
by attempting to fire, without cause, the two Democratic members of the FTC.
He did so to end the nonpartisan independence of the FTC and to make sure it responds to
his momentary political demands above the national public interest as contemplated by Congress.
Accordingly, the commissioners have brought suit to reverse their unlawful firing and
to, as Commissioner Slaughter stated, make sure that the work of the commission is done
without fear or favor, and more specifically, that we can take on the biggest companies
in America without fear of getting fired for failure to do a favor to the president's friends
or donors or corporate allies.
The strongest federal rules on AI were established by President Biden in a 2023 EO.
The Trump administration reversed that executive order, which laid down the guardrails for
the AI industry.
Not content with this rollback, the president has now hobbled and undermined the lead cop
on the AI beat, the FTC, which has for years been at the forefront of holding big tech,
including AI, to account.
It's hard to debate the proper scope of regulation in this political space when Donald Trump
has reportedly granted Elon Musk unlimited access to our most private and sensitive records,
data that's undoubtedly invaluable to ex-AI, his AI company.
Today, none of us here know whether Musk is using our data, classified information, and
other sensitive data from databases across government to train his company's AI models
and gain an unfair advantage over competitors and against citizens.
Musk has refused to answer our many requests on this topic, and now he's crippled the agency
charged with investigating these very tech abuses.
Even if we came together and found agreement on regulatory reforms and safeguards for AI
development, we still now lack an expert, independent agency to enforce our decisions.
The president and Trump, the president and Musk are ushering in a new regime in which
monarchical power, cronyism, corruption, and sycophancy rule.
He's using his office to enrich himself, his friends, and his donors, all at the expense
of the people.
The attempted firing of two FTC commissioners and his subsequent removal of any FTC resource
that might serve as a check on big tech illustrate how the president is dismantling the machinery
of government to serve his own ends.
Our constitutional order is under attack to concentrate all political power in the president.
It's the political equivalent of what we're trying to prevent in the economic sphere.
I hope that our witnesses can give us their best insight as to how to deal with this problem,
but we are facing a structural crisis now in our government.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
I yield back.
