#pie#recipe#delicious Welcome back to Sunday morning and The Old Cookbook Show! Today, we’re diving deep into Canadian food history with a rare and unusual dessert: Bales Pie, from the 1910 Canadian Farm Cookbook. This vintage raisin pie recipe features a creamy filling made with light brown sugar, milk, egg yolk, lemon juice, and chopped cooked raisins, all tucked inside an all-butter crust and topped with a rustic single-egg meringue.
Never heard of Bales Pie? Neither had we — and we’re still trying to figure out why it’s called that! Join us as we explore this forgotten piece of Canadian baking, with roots in Myrtle Station, Ontario, right in the heart of buttertart country. Could it be an early butter tart cousin? Or something else entirely?
We also talk food history, why raisins used to be boiled, and how classic cookbooks captured regional farm recipes from across Canada. If you love vintage baking, old-timey desserts, Canadian comfort food, or uncovering culinary mysteries, you’re in for a treat!
🔗 If you have any information about the origin of Bales Pie or the Canadian Farm Cookbook, please share it in the comments below!
BALES PIE.—1 cup chopped cooked raisins, 1 cup sweet milk, 1 egg yolk, 1 cup light brown sugar, juice of 1 small lemon, 1 teaspoon cornstarch; mix smoothly, add raisins, and bake in 1 crust. Make frosting of egg white.—Mrs. A. HARRISON, Myrtle Station, Ont.
Welcome friends. Welcome back to the kitchen. Welcome back to Sunday morning in the old cookbook show today
We're going to do another recipe out of the Canadian farm cookbook published in 1910. This is a community cookbook
recipes that were sent into Canadian farm a publication that I'm
not
able to find much
Reputable information about if you have some information about them, please let me know down below so I can look into it a little bit
further the recipes are
Essentially from farming communities across Canada, but heavily weighted to the southern Ontario region
Windsor to Ottawa the recipe we're gonna do today is from Myrtle station Myrtle station is very close to where I live right now
Used to be a railway that ran through there between Toronto and Montreal
There was a station became known as Myrtle station
It is now a place where I report to Oshawa Tower on one of the approaches to the Oshawa Airport
And we're gonna do something called Bale's pie
It is essentially a raisin pie. I have never had this version of a raisin pie
with lemon as a flavoring and
I've never heard it referred to as Bale's pie and I'm hoping that someone out there
Knows why it's called Bale's pie and can let me know down in the comment section
So light brown sugar and
Next in is cornstarch
Cornstarch is just so powdery and sticky and I'm gonna mix that together with the brown sugar
Makes it so much easier to dissolve the cornstarch later if it's mixed in with the brown sugar now
Okay, so that's mixed in there. Well, we need some milk calls for sweet milk. And as we know sweet milk is
just milk Oh
And a monster puts the milk away
empty
Who does that?
Okay, I
Guess it's my job
to change the bag
there we go cup of milk and
Since the copper hole is rattling around. We're also gonna need this so I'm gonna get it down
Milk toss that in I
Need an egg yolk in here and it says to make a frosting of egg white
and
I'm assuming that it means just to use the single egg white from from here
That's gonna be tough
That's gonna be tough because you know
There's not much of a frosting that can be made from a single egg white
Okay egg yolk in
Give that a whisk
Okay
juice this lemon and
lemon juice
into the mixture
So I've got here an all-butter pie crust
In a pie tin. So this is an aluminum tin put it on a tray so I don't spill got the oven preheated to
350 with a pizza stone and I'm gonna put this directly on top of the pizza stone
I
Get a nice bottom crust that way without having to blind bake and most of the recipes from this time period
Don't mention anything about blind baking blind baking is something that comes along later
Now I'm supposed to put in a cup of chopped cooked raisins
The cooking part of the cooked raisins is what a lot of people would do today and soaking them
Back in the day, you'd be buying raisins in bulk and they would be dry. They would be so dry
They would be so hard today. We're we're spoiled. We're buying raisins in plastic packaging
And it's in airtight plastic packaging almost the whole way. They're much softer
There's not as much moisture loss
This time period lots of moisture loss hard as rocks
Soaking or boiling them a little bit beforehand
Was needed because you just you just couldn't cook with them
You couldn't put them in muffin
You couldn't put them in a cake or a pie like this without them just soaking up all of that extra moisture
Not as important today
But if you wanted to go right ahead, I'm not gonna so here we go
For the filling in carefully, so I don't disturb the
raisins too much
Into the oven
No clue on the time
I had debated setting the oven to 425 or 450 to start and then turning it back to
350 to allow the cook just to give it that heat at the beginning
I
Don't know how long there's no mention of how long
Every pie is a little bit different. I'll just have to keep my eyes on it
It'll be okay
Okay, I'm gonna start whipping these eggs
It's a fake egg
We'll see what we can whip up
And the pie I think the pies ready. I should probably pull it out now
And I'll crank up the broiler
So we can broil
The meringue when we get it on top
Okay, we'll just put this back in to brown a little bit
I'm gonna keep the door open and keep an eye on it
Hi
Looks like it raisin it, but it's not raisin
Milk egg yolk light brown sugar and a lemon. So it's like a cream lemon juice. See me kind of version of a butter
Well, you know how you find out
I'm in I'm expecting the lemon juice to really kind of cut this over sweetness of it
It's like a lemon pie. Oh, they're not a lemon pie
It's like a lemony raisin pie and you're right. It's not as coyingly sweet as the raisin pie. Yeah
The lemon cuts the sugar. So it's I mean, it's make no mistake. Oh, there's it's sugar. It's sugary
It's really sweet, but the lemon kind of cuts that and makes it so that you could eat the whole pie
It also changes the texture that not the lemon but the
The milk sugar combo the thing that's kind of like a buttery tart. Yep
Changes the texture from being that seedy
Seedy raisin
That's really good. And you know one eggs worth of meringue worked out. Okay
It's that waste not want not
You put the yolk in the filling. What are you gonna do with the white?
You throw it on top because that's what you're gonna do. This is really good
I have no clue why it's called Bale's pie. I
Want to lick my fingers. This is what I'm trying not to do
We'll do it anyway, no clue why it's Bale's pie
Must be named after somebody maybe perhaps there's a more traditional
Definition of Bale if you know
Why it's called Bale's pie if you've ever had a Bale's pie if you know, mrs. Harrison from Myrtle Station, Ontario, I mean
You might not know her this is was 1910 but
You might know something about it because I don't know anything about it. There you go. I've had raisin pies
Yes, I live in the neighborhood
Of butter tart land of of where this is from and I've never had this pie. I don't know anything about it
That's you know
And but that's the thing about regions, right?
Regional and family and all those things it there be signs who you are from a yes from a food standpoint
There could be someone down the street who makes it makes this every Sunday. Yes, and we've never had it. So let us know
But this is a great pie. Absolutely. Fantastic. I think
Oh would have eaten the entire thing. I see. I just want to pick this
Thanks. Stop. Yes. See you again soon