An Italian Tries the Best Lasagnas in America-- Only One Made the Cut

Symphony for Two
6 followers
66 Video Views·Aug 1, 2025
Which Italian restaurant makes the best lasagna in the United States? We decided to find out by visiting all of the most popular places: Olive Garden, Carrabbas, Buca di Beppo, Maggianos and North Italia. Does anyone make an authentic Italian lasagna? Will any pass the Italian husband taste test?? Come along with us to find out and don't forget to tell us who makes your favorite lasagna.
Hey guys, Alessio has been craving a giant cheesy delicious piece of lasagna. Yes. And obviously
we're not in Italy, so what are we going to do? We're going to go around to some of the most
popular Italian restaurants and see who makes the best lasagna and if any are approved by him.
Alessio is going to be judging by three different things, visuals, taste and authenticity. Are you
ready to see if any of the lasagnas are good Amore? Let's go see who is the first.
All right, so we have lasagna. You're gonna need that. Oh, they gave us something.
A loaf of bread. Oh, that's so cute. Okay, so.
A nice presentation here. Here we go. Here we go. The first lasagna. Oh my gosh. The bread
smells really good. Okay, I think I need your help to open it so I don't spill it. Or maybe I got
it. Okay. Okay, so last examination the lasagna. One thing that jumps out to me is I see sofrito.
Like I can see the onions, the celery, the carrots and it's big enough pieces where you can tell that
they made their sauce with a sofrito. You're right. Which is a good thing. You're right. Then we've got
the pasta obviously. Looks like typical lasagna noodles. And the cheese, what do you think about it?
Well, so every single place has a different recipe and so Marjano's recipe, they have a bolognese
sauce made with beef, an Italian sausage, herb, ricotta and marinara sauce. Okay. I think they
should add that they use sofrito on their description. Maybe most people don't know what
sofrito is. I can see the small onions right there. And then this is the serrano carotte. Yeah. It's what you do
when you make a start for a sauce. With the meat. It's a very good thing to do. And now I will say
their marinara does not look super red either. No, no, no. I'm not sure if that's a good thing or a bad
thing. I noticed that. Well, it depends on the style of the lasagna. It's multiple styles of the lasagna.
So then let's try it. To be honest, you're the professional, so your opinion matters more. Yeah.
You just squirted me with the sauce. I do see, also I see fennel. Oh, yeah. Definitely,
the sausage is going to be American Italian sausage.
We basically, we don't calculate this like Italian when you see who makes the best lasagna.
So not who is, this is close to the Italian thing. But we did, I'm gonna, we have a category for
authenticity. Oh, wait a second. It's zero for everybody, I think. Let's say first visuals. Three being the best,
two being average, and one being poor. What score are you going to give for visual? Visual, I give
three. Me too. I actually think it looks really good. Yeah. And it doesn't look super fake when
you look at it. I agree. Then the second category? Taste. Again, three being best, two being average,
one being poor. Two. Two, me too. Okay. Authenticity? Zero. Well, you can't give a zero.
You have to give a one. I give one is, I need to say, it is there, but the ricotta, I know it's a
Sicilian thing, but it's not a real lasagna. And American with ricotta. And the fennel, you remove
the fennel, and we're going better. I agree. I do think that this lasagna is not in your face,
it's more mild in flavor, which I appreciate. Yes. But I agree with you, it's not super authentic.
We're going to have to give it a one. So overall, they get six points. Six points. In my opinion,
it's a good score. Shockingly good, actually. Then, if somebody's going to tie it, we need to decide
which one is the best from the tie bit. So this, for now, starts strong. Ragazzi? Impressive.
Impressive. Let's see the next. The next one is? Bucca di Beppo. Okay, so. Already, I have to admit,
it smells not good. Not lasagna, but let me go close to you. Okay. Okay, ragazzi. So we got a
corner piece, you can see here. Yes. But I'm going to flip it around so you can see the layers. Okay.
To me, it looks like a burger. It kind of does have a burger vibe. To be honest, guys, it does
not smell very good. It smells kind of like dirty water that they clean the tables with. Bucca di Beppo
was pretty famous a long time ago, you know, in the years. It used to be one of my favorite Italian
restaurants when I was little. I used to love it, the decor, the atmosphere. I never ate their lasagna.
This time, you start. Give a bite. So I just want to say first, on their website, they say it has
meat sauce, ricotta, mozzarella, provolone, and parmesan. So they've got a lot of different
cheeses going on here. Okay, cut and tell us, everybody. It's also very hot in my hand. I'm
having a hard time. I need to cut it in my lap and then I'll. Yeah. Okay. Oh no. Okay, go.
Your score, you cannot say the score until I eat it. So just take all the flavors with you. All
the water, dirty water for me. Let's eat. Can I tell you already the presentation?
It has to get some sauce. Let the flavors develop. Soak it in. You have it? Of course I have.
The first category. Appearance. So the visuals. To me, see something like that, it is a zero. Oh,
I know. I told you we had to give a one because a one is like four. Okay, one. So one out of three.
Okay. I agree. The visuals are not good. The taste. I wish I could give a zero for the taste.
It's a zero. It's a one because we have to give a one. Authenticity. One because it's a zero. I
can't. It's a zero. This should be a straight zero all through, guys, but because of the way I
organized it, it gets three points. Bad organization. We should give a zero.
You think I should change it now? Let's put. If it's just really bad. Let's put zero, zero,
zero points. Okay. The other ones, yeah. To be completely honest, it's very much lacking in any
kind of flavor. You don't taste any tomato. You don't really taste any flavor at all other than
that dirty water taste. Yeah. I taste unsalted, like unsalted water. Yeah. It's not salted.
The ricotta, even though we don't like ricotta and lasagna, there's no flavor in here at all.
I just keep tasting that plain yucky water taste. I don't know how better to describe it to you
than when you go in restaurants using those dirty dishrags to wash the table and you can like
inhale that and you kind of taste what I'm talking about. That is what this tastes like.
I use my microphone. You see the microphone? Pocadipepo is terrible. Change everything about
this lasagna. Can you hear me? Change everything. Everything. Change everything, ragazzi. Well,
I'm surprised it was this bad because in the past I know it was that bad.
This is like a hamburger maker. Unfortunately, I think they've fallen into one of those things
where over the years the quality just keeps dropping and dropping and dropping. They need
a lifeline. They need a life-saving something. I agree. So yeah. And ragazzi, we're talking about
about the usually the lasagna go with bechamel. Everybody doing with ricotta, bechamel. It is the
way to go. But yeah, the ricotta, stuff like that. But we understand it's hard to gonna find
the bechamel. We'll see if we find somebody. In the U.S. they always make it with ricotta.
It's a catch al tesoro. Pretty much. Okay. So this, yeah, has made us change our rules.
May change the rules. The zeros need to come. Next. The next one is Olive Garden. It's hard
even to say it. There we go. Your favorite place. We've been here a few times for other past videos,
but. Can we find? I forgot. My mind is forgetting what is tasting lasagna. So let me refresh and
see if they get one. Maybe if they get one, they beat Bucca di Beppo. They're gonna be happy.
I know. There's not much that they need to do in order to beat Bucca di Beppo. Just a little flavor
in there. A little flavor and you're bidding. Guys, you are there for the competition.
They're from the best lasagna. Here we go. Of course, they provide you with breadsticks.
Oh, wow. World famous. Then I think, okay, here's our lasagna. Okay. And then we got a big salad too.
Oh. It automatically comes with it. Why are you looking at me like? No. Classic weird situation.
No, they always give this kind of stuff. You've got your croutons, your dressing,
salad. Okay. It comes with the package. Okay. Okay. Okay. But we're focused on lasagna. Lasagna,
guys. On their website, Olive Garden describes this as a meat sauce with beef, Italian sausage,
parmesan, mozzarella, and pecorino romano. Oh, wow. That is a very cheesy looking one.
It's really, really cheesy. Come on, you can do it. I believe in you. You can do it. Put some
sauce. You don't have to waste time or procrastinate. Gross. Oh, a double bite.
Wow. Oh, okay. Okay. Don't let it slip. Don't let your mask slip. I'll tell you why later. Okay.
It's because you love it. Yeah. Okay. Well, right off the bat, it smells better than what we had
at Bucca di Bello, so I'm happy already about that. I'm going to take my little bite. Okay.
While we think about Olive Garden lasagna, so what is the first category?
Visuals. It's better than the other one, so you get at least one point. Yes, I'm giving you one
point because visually it does not look like an authentic lasagna. No. It's super saucy and
cheesy, but it's better than the other, so you get one point. Taste. I'm also giving it a one.
I give it one point. Because it has some flavor. It's better than the other one. It's actually
not as overpoweringly garlicky as I remember in the past. Yes, yes. Maybe our videos are
changing things. No, this is not the one of the 10. If you have one, two, or three,
one is not good. We need to say, but we are like happy to say one. Yeah, you arrived on the top.
No, it's not the case. Because my expectations are so much lower because in the past, I remember
the garlic burning the inside of my mouth, but not today. It gets a one. Authenticity, a zero.
I agree. So it gets two points. Get two points. Get two points. You're Olive Garden. I see you.
Okay. Giving two points. No, giving two points, it is a lot.
That's the system. It is the authentic way. We agreed. We said a zero out of 10, but it's okay.
No, zero out of 10 gives you too many variations. They have two points. Two points.
I thought it was a label, but there's nothing. However, Carabas was one of our best full reviews
in the past, right? Yeah. Carabas. Carabas describes their lasagna on their website as
a pomodoro sauce, a meat sauce, ricotta, Romano, and mozzarella. Okay. I smell the Romano. Yeah.
You have that sharper smell than a Parmigiano. Exactly. It's more sharp. Yeah. Okay.
So for now, what we understand, every lasagna has different cheeses, like who put Parmesan,
who put- Someone did Provolone. Provolone. Interesting.
Everybody's using the authentic recipe. Everybody, they make their own recipe.
And that's what they like. Oh, goodness. Okay. Carabas. Starting with the visuals,
what is your score for visual Carabas? One. One. Yeah. It didn't look very good. No. Yeah.
It wasn't horrible. No, it was horrible, but it's a one. A one. Okay. Taste. You know,
I give, should be 1.5. I was thinking so too, but we, I mean, it's definitely better than
Olive Garden. It's better than Olive Garden, but it's not impactful, the delivery. Yeah,
but it definitely wasn't a two. It's not a two. Which is what we gave Maggiano. Maggiano is better
right now. One and a half. One and a half. Okay. And then authenticity. Of course, this is a one
because it's not- It's not authentic. It's not authentic. It's not an authentic lasagna. But
because we put the zero too, I would like to give a zero. Really? Yeah. I want to put a zero for
that. Why? Why? Because the flavor was there. The authenticity is not there. I think it is just a
little bit better than Olive Garden. I know, but I think sometimes you're saying it's got to be
all or nothing. Like the point of the range of scores is like, okay, if it's, you can say it's
not authentic, but give it a one because- Because one, it is no good. No, it's technically is the
poor score. It's poor score. You want to give a zero though? So it's a two and a half. Yeah. So
only 0.5 better than Olive Garden. Yeah. I think it was much better than Olive Garden,
personally. In my opinion, I think that this for Americanized standard of lasagna is decent.
Like if you're going to compare with Italy, it's not authentic. You wouldn't compare, yeah. I know,
but it's not authentic. However, it's a lot worse than Maggiano's because it's kind of a different
style of lasagna. However, if you're going to judge it based off of these chain restaurant
lasagnas that have tomato sauce, cheese, I think it's so much better than Bucca di Beppo and Olive
Garden. I think it deserves three. Yeah, but the Pecorino Romano is pull me off. Like for the
authenticity, the Pecorino Romano pull me off and say, I don't want this taste. That's why I don't
want to give a one point and give to zero because if it was that strong, and this is just for
authenticity, some people love more Pecorino Romano, respect Parmigiano Reggiano, and I don't
understand these people. So in my opinion, Parmigiano Reggiano, it is the cheese where to
put it because it's the balanced flavor, but some people like strong flavors. So for me, the
authenticity goes zero for that. Two and a half is the score then. Two and a half. Listen to my words,
leave alone the score, it is a little bit, it is better than Olive Garden, but it's not that much
better. I tried to give our videos a scoring way because so many people are like, but you
don't have a scoring method and then this is why. The method goes out the window every time.
I tried, I tried. Cosa abbiamo qui? We're in North Italia and their lasagna is a little bit
different than what we've seen so far. Okay, yes it is different. I was thinking when I was
holding the box, it felt like there was nothing in there. It felt so light and now we know why
because it's the tiniest lasagna I've ever seen. So you'll probably notice that this lasagna
is a white lasagna. Oh yeah, it's a white lasagna. So on the menu they say lasagna bianca
and it's not your traditional like red sauce ragu lasagna. What they described it as is braised
short rib, bechamel, grana padano, provolone, mozzarella, and herbed bread crumbs. Provolone
is a strange choice for lasagna. I agree, but we were excited and felt like we had to try it anyway
because they have bechamel, which is what we've been missing in all the other lasagnas because
they do ricotta instead of bechamel. But this is their only lasagna on the menu right now. They
don't have a traditional one so this is what they put out. So we're gonna judge them based off what
they put out. Oh my goodness. So you can see the meat is rib instead of beef or sausage. Ready?
That's the provolone. Let me try this. What is this tuna? I told you it's braised short rib.
Oh the rib. It's like a rib that they cut up. I told you braised short rib.
What do you think about the visuals? Visuals get a one in my opinion. I get one. It was like a flat
one layer lasagna. Just looked like a big blob. I want to say appealing. I would say the lasagna
don't need to be really really perfect straight. True. It could be super flat because sometimes
when you make homemade it's coming super flat. It's not like you see in the commercial. I don't
give that the thing. I give one just because they deserve one. Well I think the problem with this is
like the usually the layers, like you said, they're not like a perfect stack like is advertised to you.
Real authentic lasagna in Italy falls down pretty low but here they have the meat on top of the
lasagna instead of in the layers. So the layers were just noodles and sauce and then the meat
was on top. If they had wanted to stack it up a little bit they could have mixed the meat into
the sauce. Yes. So I'm giving it a one. Flavors, taste, support. Support. Guys I give a zero.
Really? I don't like the ribs. I liked it. I was gonna give it a two. Give a two. Because I enjoyed
but we have to come up with the agreement. Okay. Oh agreement. We've agreed on everything else.
Well I agree for you.
No I give a zero. Why did you give it a zero? That's pretty brutal. I know I was biased.
I know it's Olive Garden. You gave Olive Garden a one for taste. I know. And you gave Carrabba's
a 1.5 and you're giving this a zero? I don't like the ribs like this. I'm sorry. I don't like it.
What about the bechamel? Because why I was smiling was that you actually had the flavor
of the bechamel. I could taste bechamel inside. Provolone is other things. Can we not do like a one
in between me and you? So what are we gonna do? Go with your zero? I don't want to agree with...
Okay fine fine. How about authenticity? I can give that a zero because it's not an authentic
lasagna. Zero with revision. I'm gonna try to revision your the other lasagna. So for me guys
we will try to find something but you are disqualified for this thing. They're not
even scored? They're disqualified? I want to disqualify. Wow okay. Yeah. Well that gives us
our winner. It's Majano's by far. By far was the best lasagna. Majano's got a six in our original score
and we even thought about it later and we wanted to up their authenticity score because we were
disappointed they didn't have bechamel or mozzarella but we said we should think about
the ingredients actually used and we were going to give them actually a two. Yeah. But now I'm
going to say six and a half. Yeah. So actually they scored way way higher than anybody else.
We enjoyed that lasagna. We enjoyed the lasagna. But I want to say this Majano's if you want to
take it to the absolute next level no ricotta, add the bechamel and mozzarella in your lasagna
and we might be talking about something. Wait and remove the sausage and put just ground beef. Yes
and if you do this. If you do this call it the Pazzini's. Yes the Pazzini's lasagna. You can keep
your classic one on the menu but add this one and we'll be there every week. And it's going to be
always sold out. Yeah. Trust me. So Majano's congratulations to the winners. So let's see
who's going to be the next adventure. Maybe we're going to eat who is the best pasta. Just tell us
what do you want to see. That's tiramisu. Actually it's good.
