Aug 8, 2022 Skip the waitlist and invest in blue-chip art for the very first time by signing up for Masterworks: https://masterworks.art/baumgartner Purchase shares in great masterpieces from artists like Pablo Picasso, Banksy, Andy Warhol, and more. See important Masterworks disclosures: https://www.masterworks.io/about/disc...
-- The arrival of a large, complicated and possibly important painting to the studio was a perfect opportunity to introduce a young conservation apprentice to the highs and lows of working with problematic paintings. -- Support me on Patreon / baumgartnerrestoration
Follow me on Instagram - / baumgartnerrestoration Facebook - / baumgartnerfineartrestoration
This video is brought to you by Masterworks,
the startup democratizing the $1.7 trillion art market.
And empathize, I certainly don't wish
the shoe on the other foot.
Yeah, no, it's clear, I understand.
And we will go ahead with that course of action
and yeah, we will just figure it out.
Yeah, good talking to you.
Yep, yep, bye-bye.
All right, Kit, give me a hand here.
We gotta move this big old painting.
Okay.
I'm gonna lift it up and then maybe rotate it down to you
to get through the door.
So what are we doing with it?
That's a pretty good question.
Well, suffice to say the client was surprised
by what we found.
I don't think that they expected that.
I don't really think that they were very happy.
I think maybe more disappointed
that it's not a Murillo.
I mean, there's pretty much no way that you can cut this
to make it anything other than it is.
It's a copy of a Murillo by a Kansas artist.
And while I think that they like the painting,
that's probably part of the reason why they acquired it.
I think if what they told me was true,
I think that they bought it
because they thought that it would be
a really good investment.
The original is in Sevilla,
so they knew that this was not the original.
We're thinking it's not a school of either?
I think they thought it was maybe a student work
or a studio work or a contemporary of Murillo
copied his work.
In which case, it certainly wouldn't be as valuable
as the original,
but it would definitely be an important painting.
And aside from its aesthetic value,
there would be, you know, there'd be monetary value.
So that's all out the window now.
You know, the aesthetics of the painting haven't changed,
but I mean, I'll be blunt.
I don't think that there's any value in the painting.
Even though, I mean, we identified the artist
and everything, we maybe could establish provenance
or something like that,
but it's just the client doesn't really care.
That's a good question.
We know who the artist is.
Charles Stitcher was not a really well-known artist.
I mean, he was locally,
but you know, he's not in any private collections,
not in any museums.
There's not a big body of work.
So I don't think that anybody would be particularly
interested in this as a Charles Stitcher
and as a Murillo, well, it's not.
So, you know, if nobody's interested in it as a Murillo,
cause it can't be, or a Stitcher,
cause who's this guy, what is it worth?
And where do we go from here?
Yeah, well, that's the big question.
Does this happen pretty often
where someone comes in with a painting
that they think is something special
and then kind of figure it out
because you're very casual about this
and this kind of sucks for me.
I was excited about this.
Yeah, well, I mean, it's not the first time I've seen it.
It's not the 10th time.
It's probably not the 100th time I've seen it.
You know, I think everybody buys art for maybe two reasons.
One, it speaks to them on a visceral level.
It kind of touches their soul
or they want to make some money.
And I think both of those are valid reasons
for wanting to have art.
I think they're also both really problematic reasons
for wanting to have art.
I think pure love can cloud your rational approach
and you can end up buying something that speaks to you
that, you know, maybe is a money pit.
I think also buying things purely for investment vehicles.
You really have to know what you're doing.
And also if you're just buying it as investment
and not because you like it or love it,
I don't know, that kind of defeats the whole point of art,
at least my perspective.
But, you know, I don't buy or sell art,
so I don't even really collect art.
I'm lucky, we're lucky that we get to kind of spend
every day surrounded by art, a rotating cast of characters.
So, I mean, I don't know about you,
but I kind of get my fill of it.
Yeah, I mean, this definitely feels like
a very dangerous environment to be in.
We get to just kind of-
There's all the scalpels and stuff?
Yeah, well, not our environment.
Our environment's fine, I'm cool with the scalpels.
Buying something because you love it
or because it's an investment, whatever,
it feels like it's very much like a teeter-totter
of just trying to find that balance.
You're right, I mean, that's a great way to put it.
It is a teeter-totter.
I think if you swing too hard on either end,
you can really upset that balance.
And in the best case scenario,
you find this perfect harmony
where you really care about something
and you know that there's a good, smart, sound investment
so that when you do want to sell it,
you can reap some profits.
This feels really surprising
that someone would invest so much money
into something like this
and not be 100% sure of what it is.
Is it private collectors
that this thing happens to most often?
Does it happen, do museums get fleeced like this?
Yeah, well, I don't think anybody got fleeced.
Okay.
This was not a case where somebody sold them a bill of goods.
It happens to private collectors all the time,
I mean, regularly,
but it happens to dealers and good dealers, galleries,
and every single museum on the planet
has found themselves in this situation
where they acquired something
and then through research or conservation or whatever,
they discover that it's not what it purported to be.
There have been dozens of Caravaggios
that have been downgraded to school of Caravaggio
and then follower of Caravaggio
and then after Caravaggio
and then in the realm of kind of near Caravaggio
and then they get back up because there's more evidence
that said, nope, these are school of,
and then it's like the scholarly stuff
behind attribution of artwork
is just kind of all over the place.
And if you're not an expert,
I mean, to think that you could get into that space
as a beginner and survive it is a lot of confidence.
Yeah, it sounds incredibly risky and nerve wracking.
I don't know if I would enjoy that very much.
I feel like-
No, that makes me wanna quit and go for a walk,
the idea of having to do that kind of stuff.
But I mean, you worked in a gallery
and so you kind of get the duality
of the economics of art and the passion of art.
I don't think anybody who gets involved
in the world of art doesn't love art,
but galleries love the artists they represent,
but they're trying to make money
and collectors love the art that they buy,
but they're also trying not to lose money.
And it's this ugly, complicated, tangled web,
art and money since the Medici's, it's been,
and it will be for history.
And this is kind of a prime example
of how that can get tangled up
and really complicated.
It's like trying to untangle a ball of yarn, right?
It happens so quickly and undoing it is so complicated
and there's no easy solution.
And sometimes like in this case,
you're just left with a lot of questions
and not a lot of answers.
I hope sometime in my future,
I'll be able to maybe afford a painting that's beautiful,
but I mean, the situation just made me feel
like you really are going it alone most of the time
and it's just your best guess and your own research.
And it just, it really, it's really discouraging for me.
Yeah, no, I mean, I hear you, Kit.
I think what I've been doing this for 23 years or so,
and I've only bought two pieces of artwork.
It's not because I don't like art or want to have art,
but it feels really scary.
And I consider myself somewhat of an expert
in the field of art, at least, you know,
within my little corner.
And even for me, it feels perilous
and it feels like I'm just kind of out there alone
with no backup.
You know, that feeling of going it alone,
it's just not what art's about for me.
I think art is about affecting within us
an emotion that we can't otherwise trigger.
It's about feeling something
and feeling heartbreak and disappointment and being alone.
Well, it's just not what it's about.
Julian, you're not alone.
Great, this guy again.
Well, I was going to say that there's a better way
than buying two paintings in 22 years.
You've heard of Masterworks, right?
Yeah, I've heard of Masterworks,
and I know that they're doing some pretty cool things
in art, but I never really looked
into precisely what they were doing.
Masterworks is a platform for investing in blue chip art.
Warhol, Picasso, Basquiat, you know,
the kind of paintings that are locked away
in storage vaults and out of reach
for all but the wealthiest of people.
But Masterworks is turning that on its head.
They're making it possible for anyone to own a part
of the most amazing and valuable artworks ever created.
Masterworks makes it so that you can have access
to this art for a fraction of what billionaires pay
at auction.
And get this, it's not all for the feels.
The super rich have been buying art for years
to diversify their investments and keep their wealth safe.
And now you can too.
Because the art Masterworks offers
has near zero correlation to the stock market.
Don't take my word for it.
Listen to the New York Times.
When stock markets take a nosedive,
people look to invest in art.
It's more tangible.
And not only does art have low correlation,
it's got performance too.
Because the contemporary art market has outpaced the S&P 500
by nearly double for the past 25 years.
And in tough times like today,
when inflation and uncertainty are causing blue chip stocks
like Apple to dip 15% and Amazon 28,
investors are taking notice of art's performance
as an inflation hedge.
Because the last time inflation was this high,
art appreciated a whopping 33%, beating even gold,
which was long thought of as the premier inflation hedge.
Well, I'm no Warren Buffett,
but those numbers are pretty clear.
Art can enrich your life, but also your wallet too.
Now, Masterworks has seen a surge of interest
with inflation rising,
but don't worry about being put at the end of their list.
If you use my code below,
you can jump right to the front of the line.
My little treat.
All right, so what are we doing with this painting?
Isolation layer.
That's what we have to do to it now.
No, like what are we doing with it?
First, we're gonna put an isolation layer on it,
and then we will figure out what happens to this painting.
So one step at a time, young grasshopper.
Yeah, just make sure we get all of the little fuzzies
and little hairs and stuff off.
We don't want to trap any of that stuff in.
All right, here, why don't you take.
We're just gonna pour it all on, right?
That's right.
Like an epoxy resin table.
So just start on your end and try to get an even coat
of the isolation layer across the entire painting.
It's thicker and stiffer than the normal varnish we use,
so it's gonna feel different.
You can't go too fast because it drags.
You'll start to get the hang of it as you're doing it.
Obviously, if you have any questions,
just ask me and I'll give you the info.
Oh yeah, it is much thicker.
Yeah, and unlike when we apply the varnish,
we aren't so concerned with the final sheen
and brushing it out,
because this is just the isolation layer.
This is gonna get covered by a varnish.
So you can see I'm applying it kind of haphazardly.
Really, I just want to get it on
and get the whole thing covered at this point.
The final sheen and making it look pretty
comes with the final varnish.
This is just the isolation layer, so an intermediary step.
So isolation layer means that we're doing retouching?
Right now, we're just focused
on getting this isolation layer on
and doing as good of a job of that.
I know it sounds like I'm being coy,
but I really just want you and me, us,
to focus on the task at hand
and not to think about other things,
because then we can start to get distracted
and we need to be focused on this.
I don't think I like the smell
as much as I like the other one.
You notice the smells.
Yeah, I don't like the smell of any of this stuff,
but you get used to it,
or maybe you just go smell blind.
And Kit, you can see just how different the painting looks
with the isolation layer on it.
Yeah, I really like when you were brushing over it,
the heart with the arrow in it just started popping.
So why don't you put an isolation layer
on every painting that you retouch?
Not every painting needs it.
I guess one of the big takeaways in this studio
is that everything that I do, everything that we do,
is relative to what the painting needs
and wants and can tolerate.
So we may do a treatment on painting A
that we don't do on painting B,
because painting B can't accept those materials,
or painting C just doesn't need that treatment,
so it's superfluous, and we don't do superfluous work.
So everything kind of goes through the spectrum of,
is this what the painting needs, wants,
and can it accept it?
How do you, what do you think, look good?
Yeah, it looks pretty good for now,
but it smells really bad, and I want to get out of here.
Sounds good.
So what are we doing next?
Time for retouching?
Kind of, but not really.
So talked to the client,
and suffice to say they were not happy,
not pleased with the results of what we found.
Not angry at us, but just disappointed,
I think, more or less.
They had really high hopes
that this was gonna be a really valuable painting
and that they'd ride off into the sunset.
I mean, I see it all the time,
and this kind of deflated those hopes.
So I think they were torn with what to do,
and I laid out three different avenues.
One, they could just call it a day, and that's that.
Two, they could continue on with the project
as we outlined in the proposal.
Or three, I proposed kind of a middle ground.
Before you do the final retouching,
you kind of have to lay down some color
and some form and some shape,
kind of how a painter would build up a portrait.
You block the form,
you start putting in your lows and your highlights,
and then you start to refine.
You start with a big brush and you get smaller.
Well, we do the same thing,
particularly when there are big areas of loss.
Start with a big brush
and just start putting some color blocking.
So I proposed that maybe we could do something like that,
where we do some amount of retouching.
We kind of just get it so that from 10, 15 feet,
the damage isn't really visible.
Kind of an approach that conservators often take
in churches where they just color block the damage
so that it blends in a little bit.
From a distance, it just kind of,
your eye makes up the difference.
Right. Okay.
Relatively crude, relatively loose,
but something better than nothing.
And they were begrudgingly accepting of that.
I mean, I don't think they were enthusiastic,
but I think that having a middle ground
is always the right answer when you're faced with extremes.
And so I think that they were appreciative
that there was a path forward,
even if it's not good, it's not bad.
And so that's what we settled on.
And now we get to do our best
to not fully retouch a painting.
Yeah. I don't really know if I know that balance quite yet.
I've never, at least in retouching, done color blocking.
So I'm nervous, excited.
Yeah. I've never had,
you've always just done full integrated retouching.
Right. Which is the thing.
Well, I mean, maybe that's the silver lining, you know,
that instead of not seeing the project completed
and the loss of that validation
or closure, you get to walk away
with experiencing a pretty lousy situation
and learning something new.
So half full.
Half full.
Nice.
While Kit has the day off,
I've taken the opportunity with a little peace and quiet
in the studio to start on the retouching.
And I want to do this because I need to get a feel
for exactly how much time it's going to take
and how far I want to go before I have Kit jump in.
It would be unfair to throw her into this cauldron
and then be critical of her spending too much time
or not enough time when I haven't actually
gauged that measure just yet.
And I'm going to start with a bigger brush
than I normally use,
not the typical very, very small one,
because I need to cover more surface quicker.
Again, because the budget has been capped,
I just don't have the time to allocate.
And if I use a very, very small brush,
I'm going to exceed the allotted time.
So using a bigger brush allows me to work faster
and get more of this done,
because I'd like to be able to give the client back
something that at least approximates
a comprehensive retouching,
even if that's not really in the books.
So I'm mixing my paint.
And this is a conservation color by the Gamblin Company,
specifically designed for retouching.
It has no oil in it.
It uses a synthetic resin,
which is stable and fully reversible.
And that's important because I don't know
what's going to happen to this painting.
It may never get retouched again,
but it may go to another conservator
or it may come back to me.
And though we have an isolation layer on it
to protect the painting,
having a reversible paint is still pretty critical.
If you remember back,
all of the paint we had to remove, that overpaint,
that was all oil and it took a lot of time
and it was really hard work.
If this ever needs to come off, it's relatively simple.
And it's pretty clear that the type of retouching
I'm doing here is much rougher or loose
than what I normally would.
I'm just basically trying to take this whole area
that had paint loss and blend it in,
just kind of give it the approximation
of a fully retouched image.
It's hard intellectually and also technically
to shift gears into this modality,
but this is the reality of this project.
And even though it's not perfect, it's good.
And I have to be content with that and call it.
All right, so the basic premise
about this type of retouching,
as opposed to like what we normally do,
is you're just going to not do-
What we normally do.
What we normally do, right.
Yeah, I mean, you kind of have to turn your mind off
and kind of not do the job that you want to do,
which is going to be really different
and really weird feeling.
And so what you have is a bigger brush
so you can get through this a little bit quicker,
and you're just trying to kind of camouflage this area away.
So you're not worried about kind of capturing
the subtle changes of the paint.
Think of it like a 10 foot retouching, right?
So at 10 feet, it's fine, but obviously as you get closer
and you really start to study it, you'll be able to see it.
Whereas normally we're trying to go for a three foot
or two foot retouching.
Even here where it's like obviously a different,
it's starting to progress in,
it's more just kind of a general blanket color.
Yeah, just kind of a,
well, it doesn't have to be all uniform
because you're still going to mix the color.
You know, you can certainly make it lighter here
and darker here, but you just have to have more restraint,
which is kind of odd because you're having more restraint
to do a lesser quality job.
It's not, no, it's no longer restraint in like stippling,
it's restraint in like the amount of time it takes me.
You know, the amount of time it takes you.
And I mean, the amount of like intellectual capital,
you know, you're going to spend.
You just have to modulate what you're doing
and the client understands that, you know,
it's not an ideal situation,
but we still can affect a positive change.
So anytime you're ready.
Yay.
What we're doing here is really just to get the painting
in a state where the client can hang it up
and figure out what they want to do with it,
if they want to do anything with it.
So like, this is good enough.
This is okay.
This is fine.
Yeah, it's weird, right?
I mean, is it good?
No.
Is it good enough?
Well, I mean, yeah, it's fine,
but fine is what we're going for.
And yeah, it's a really weird intellectual space to be in
when fine isn't ever good enough.
Yeah, it's very uncomfortable for me.
Just like, oh yeah, it's whatever.
Like that's not who we are.
Right, and it's not what conservation is about until it is.
And I think one of the important things
about any work you do is you kind of have to understand
the field on which you're playing, right?
Not everything based on the client, based on the project,
based on a whole bunch of external factors.
Sometimes the client will say no to something
and you can advocate for it,
but ultimately when you're in private practice,
you don't get to have that final say.
If you work in a museum or for a private collection,
then maybe as a conservator,
you get to have that last word.
But in private practice, you have to deal with clients.
And if the client says,
I don't want to spend a penny more on this piece,
but you need to make it presentable,
rock, hard place, and you.
So with the, you know, deciding what to retouch,
what not to retouch.
I mean, obviously I understand like the little scuffs,
it's 10 feet, but it's something like this,
where it is that overpaint.
Like, is that something that we would go?
I mean, you and I obviously, we see that pretty quickly,
but is that something that a client would be like,
hey, that needs to be worked on?
I mean, where do we stop?
It's a good question.
I mean, the client very well may say,
well, I can see that little damage, you know,
why isn't it fixed?
And my response will be because you made that,
you stopped work.
You eliminated the budget,
which meant that the time changed,
which meant that we had to allocate our resources
to the most consequential areas.
And our professional opinion was that
this was just not as important as this.
And yeah, just using our best judgment in,
within that's no fun.
You know, I mean, to some degree,
that's why people hire professionals, right?
Because they have experience to deal with things like this,
when things aren't perfect.
And, you know, I think that the client trusts me and you
to make those hard decisions about
where the very small budget that they have created
for this project is gonna be spent.
And, you know, I definitely wanna retouch
this little tear here, but you know,
the frame rabbit will probably cover this.
And so I have to say,
that's not gonna be a good use of time or their money,
because we still have this to deal with.
I wanna be really exacting in this,
and it just, it's not fun.
Well, I mean, you know, the old saying,
and it's hackneyed,
but don't let perfect be the enemy of the good.
This is kind of a prime example of that, right?
You know, this is a massive painting
and it's gonna be displayed kind of high up
above a big mantle and hearth.
And so nobody's ever gonna be close enough
to see this perspective.
And so the perfect at this stage, at this range,
that's gonna mean that we won't be able to do good
on another section of the painting.
And so, you know, we kind of have to modulate
and figure out where that new sweet spot is.
I mean, I'll go back through it and...
No, because we don't have that.
We don't have that time.
I know, right?
That's the problem with this.
And that's why it's so frustrating.
You know, we could easily spend an extra hour,
another hour, you know, another hour,
but, you know, this is a business.
And ultimately, as much as I want every painting
to be conserved fully and completely,
because that's kind of like in my core.
Exactly.
You know, it's not charity work.
It's not pro bono, not for this project.
Maybe for another project it is,
but that's not where this one falls.
So we can't, you know?
All right, I'm gonna...
Or how do you wanna?
No, you can work here.
I'm just gonna start working on this.
And then maybe when you're done with that,
we can work on that.
Yeah.
I'm gonna get a solvent for me.
You can use that one.
You know, just instead of sitting here and watching you,
maybe I can be a productive member of this business.
Yeah.
Novel thought.
Typical.
It's tricky, right?
You have a general contractor come into your house
and their job is to, I don't know,
redo your kitchen or something.
And they give you a really specific breakdown
of what they're gonna do and the cost.
And at no point in the history of general contracting
do I think a contractor will ever say,
yeah, no, don't worry about it.
We'll just do the bathroom too while we're here
at no extra charge.
That would be amazing.
It would be amazing, right?
It would be kind of like the greatest, kindest contractor
who goes out of business very quickly.
Very quickly.
We're obviously not gonna give the client back a painting
that we're not okay with.
You know, we may not be delighted with it.
We still need to be proud of it to an extent.
Yeah, no, I mean, we need to be satisfied
with making lemonade, right?
We didn't expect this to happen.
We didn't want this to happen, but it happened.
And so now we have to pivot
and just make the best of the situation.
Is this good though?
Is this okay?
Yeah, I mean, this is exactly what we're looking for, right?
Like up here, no, it's not okay.
But over there, it's fine.
Look at that giant seam.
Right, and we spent like the amount of time we spent on it
is in accord with what the client has allowed us to do.
You know, our hands are tied,
so we have to work within that constraint.
So now I'll give Kit a shot
and see if the instruction I've provided her
has been accurate enough
that she can understand what I'm looking for.
And this will be an assessment,
not only of her skills as a conservator
to pivot and adapt to a new situation,
but an assessment of my skills as a teacher
to get her to that place.
I mean...
That's it?
That's...
That's it.
Yeah. Yeah.
Okay.
I don't feel great about it, but...
But at least it's not what it was.
It's true, right.
I mean, if we can walk away from this feeling good
about how we've maybe salvaged it,
I think in this situation,
that's where we have to land.
And, you know, go to the gym tonight
and work out our frustrations elsewhere.
Are we going to wrap this up?
Or are we gonna, you know, give it a day, let it breathe,
see if there's anything else we wanna do with it?
I think we're gonna varnish it.
Client said they didn't wanna varnish it.
Well, the client said they didn't wanna pay for the varnish.
But I just don't feel right about not doing that.
Not only to protect the painting,
but also to make it look a little bit better.
Yes, I know that that's not in their budget.
And honestly, frankly,
I think the amount of retouching we've done,
we're probably underwater on this project.
We've probably lost any profit.
But it's maybe bad business, but it's like good people.
Yeah.
And it, you know,
if they can walk away from this feeling a bit whole
and we can help facilitate that,
I will feel satisfied with this project.
So, on to varnish.
Let's do it.
So why aren't we spray varnishing this?
Well, the compressor is broken.
So that's the acute reason.
And I don't know when it's gonna get fixed.
So we're gonna brush it.
Which is not all that unusual
because before I had a compressor,
I would just brush things.
But we are gonna do something a little bit different
to the varnish because it's a big space
and we're both gonna be varnishing it.
At least getting the varnish on, the first step, yeah.
The varnish dries pretty quickly.
And over a painting that's this big,
you know, you wanna put the varnish on
and then kind of even it out.
You don't want it to start drying in one spot
and be still wet in another spot
and then get streaks and get uneven spots.
So we're gonna give the varnish a little bit more open time
and we're gonna slow down the evaporation rate,
which will keep it wet so we can kind of even it out
and then let it dry slowly.
As we wrap up the work on this painting,
putting the final varnish on
and then bringing it over to the front half of the studio
to take a look, I have definite mixed feelings
and I know Kit does too.
We spent months working on this painting.
We did just about every procedure we could.
When it came in, it was really, really a disaster.
And we had high hopes,
not only for what the conservation would bring,
but what the project would reveal.
Unfortunately, along the way,
we learned that this painting wasn't by Muriel.
It wasn't a studio work.
It wasn't a student work.
It wasn't even a contemporary copy.
It was effectively a modern copy
and that rendered it a very different painting
than when we began.
Certainly the artistic merit didn't change.
Its beauty didn't change.
But the calculus of the client did.
And as unfortunate as it was, we had to adapt to that.
We had to pivot and find a solution
that would allow them to feel whole,
the painting to look better and us to feel satisfied.
And though we couldn't hit the bullseye,
I think with the adjustments we made
and the extra work we did, we definitely hit the target.
Well, not bad.
I think we salvaged it, but we're not done.
There is one more thing.
Just hang on one sec.
I think you earned it.
Oh, yay!
Thank you.
You're very welcome.
Wear it in good health.
I don't really like this color.
Give it.
I'm going to put little patches on it and stuff
and like buttons.
I'll put a Bob Roth button on it.
It'll be perfect.
Now I have half of my Halloween costume.
That's our video.
Well, that was certainly a project, but it's not over.
In fact, there is a lot more that both Kit and I
have to say about this work, about this project,
about the clients and about the experience.
So go ahead and join us over on Patreon
where we'll answer your questions in an epilogue video.
And you'll get to see some extra footage
and hear Kit and I talk about, well, everything.