Could we aim asteroid YR4 at the Moon on purpose? What would happen to babies born and raised on Mars? Should we use water as an insulation layer for our spacecraft? And in Q&A+, could we mine an asteroid that's stuck in a Lagrange point?
00:00 Start 00:28 [Goatlord] Could we direct an asteroid into the Moon to study the effects? 01:00 [MadmonkeyOz] Mars' ancient coast line 04:53 [Christian DesAlliers] Expanding advanced civilizations 07:52 [Web Fiji] Is there such thing as absolute stillness in the Universe 08:46 [TELE KOMIK] What will happen to babies born and raised on Mars? 10:52 [Len Kelter] Tackling the wait calculation 11:28 [Kasie Ream] Is it possible to do an X-Ray telescope? 12:06 [Jul Kar 'Cerum] Can we use water as an insulation layer for spacecraft?
⚖️ LICENSE Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)
You are free to use my work for any purpose you like, just mention me as the source and link back to this video.
Could we aim asteroid YR4 at the moon on
purpose? What would happen to babies
born and raised on Mars? Should we use
water as an insulation layer for our
spacecraft? And in Q&A Plus, could we
mine an asteroid that's stuck in a
lrangee point? All this and more in this
question show. It's time for the
question show. Your questions, my
answers, as always, wherever you are
across my channel. If a question pops in
your brain, just write it down. I'll
gather them up and I'll answer them
here. All right, let's get to the
questions. Coat Lord, could we use a
dartlike impactor to redirect 2024 wiref
to hit the moon? Seems like a good
opportunity to learn a lot about
asteroids and lunar impacts. Yes, we
probably could try to aim it more
towards the moon, but it's, you know,
it's pretty hard to predict exactly to
make it. You probably have to hit it a
couple of times to keep fine-tuning its
trajectory and you have to get it right.
But if you make a mistake, do you make
it hit the Earth? So, you got to be
really careful. But yeah, it would be
great. But you know, objects that size
do hit the moon on a regular basis. You
know, a 40 m asteroid is not that big.
Mad Monkey Oz data from China's Jurong
rover strengthens the case for an ocean
with a huge coastline on Mars. What do
you think of the hypothesis? I'm just a
journalist, so I have no opinion about
the hypothesis. However, what scientists
are reporting is that there is evidence
of the shoreline on Mars. And you know,
we know that there is water on Mars. You
look at the polar ice caps, there is
water ice still at the surface of Mars.
You can imagine a time when there was
water at farther latitudes, maybe
covered by ice. You have like a a thick
sheet of ice and then you get this layer
of water down at the bottom. That could
be easily explained even under
conditions right now. Like there could
be water under the ice caps on Mars. You
got all this pressure that's pushing
down. You got the internal heat coming
from Mars that could create this layer
of water and there could be life in
there which would be really interesting.
But the Chinese detected the presence of
a shoreline. And the way they did that
was, you know, this was part of the
plan. When they chose the location, the
landing location for the Jurong rover,
they knew that they were going to be at
this place that was thought to be the
boundary between what was once an
ancient ocean and then the shoreline of
that place. And then they had the rover
roll around in that area and use its
ground penetrating radar system. And
they tested this out on some of the
lunar spacecraft that they've sent.
They're able to peer down through the
regalith about 100 meters and and could
see the size of the regalith get bigger
and bigger and bigger on the moon. You
know, see at the very surface it's
powder and then below that it's kind of
pebbles and then it's larger rocks and
eventually it's boulders all the way
down 100 meters. as far as the as the
radar could go. And so they did the same
thing with the uh with the mission to
Mars. Jurong had a ground penetrating
radar system that allowed them to look
down under the surface. And so Mars
today is covered by sand dudes and
drifts and all of that material. But
Jurong went and just went back and forth
over the area where they thought the
shoreline was going to be and then
measured the depth of what was
underneath it. And they found this spot,
this this shoreline where the angle of
of hardened rock covered by sand was the
angle that you get when you're at the
side of an ocean. And that they were
able to then confirm they were able to
follow along where this shoreline is and
confirm that yeah, that that's that
perfectly matches that you had a liquid
ocean waves lapping against a shore that
were then creating this shoreline. and
to have evidence that you know there's
there's some other evidence as well that
was found. So people found um
ripples in sand that the kinds of things
if you go to a beach and you you know
when the tide goes out but the waves
have been have been going up and down
you get these ripples in the sand and
they found some places where you had
rippled rock that matched that but you
can kind of get that with wind. So, this
was like a really firm evidence that
Mars once had a liquid ocean, a fairly
large liquid ocean
and had waves and was crashing against
the shoreline. It's a pretty amaz, you
know, I think it's probably the greatest
discovery made by the Jurong rover and
just shows the benefit of sending a
ground penetrating radar to worlds like
this. When you think about the upcoming
Europa Clipper mission, the thing that
I'm most excited about that is that
they're going to have this a similar
system. They're going to be able to
penetrate the ice and map out where are
reservoirs of water. Are there cracks
and stuff under the surface of the ice?
How deep does the ice go before you hit
the the ocean underneath? Christian
Dalia, why does the Firmeny paradox
assume advanced civilizations would
expand at 10% the speed of light? Is
this realistic given the immense
challenge of establishing societies on
distant alien worlds? So, the
expectation is not that alien
civilizations would expand at 10% the
speed of light. The expectation is that
they would expand at 99.99%
the speed of light. That they would
attempt to gather as much territory as
possible within the laws of physics. And
so if you set out today at just shy of
the speed of light, you could create a
volume of empire with a radius of 16 12
billion lightyear. if you leave today.
So, you got to hurry. Um, that's pretty
big. Now, of course, that is just going
to be a tiny drop in the bucket of the
much larger universe that is outside of
your smaller little part. Um, but that's
if you leave today and you go at 99% of
the speed of light. If you go slower
than that, then you're not going to be
able to to reach that much of the
universe. 94% of the universe has fallen
over the cosmic horizon. So, six 6% of
the universe is reachable if you set off
at the speed of light. And so that is
going to be the limit that these
advanced civilizations are going to be
driving for is to get to this maximum
rate. And so when we look out into the
universe, the expectation is that we
should see these civilizations growing
at
the speed of light. But the thing is is
that if you can see or I guess you can't
see the civilization growing at the
speed of light because when you first
notice the civilization that wavefront
of expansion is passing you by and you
sudden you know it's like you learn the
bor are out there and now you're part of
the Borg. So um obviously if if there is
some but and so there's no physical
limit that says you can't go 99.99% the
speed of light. It's within the laws of
physics. And so that is probably going
to be the limit. Now, what do they do? I
mean, they're going to send
self-replicating robot probes. You just
need to send one. It makes its way to a
star system. It settles down in the
galaxy, finds an asteroid belt, starts
producing more copies of itself. Those
send themselves off to other galaxies
within the reachable distance. And then
the others start filling in the missing
pieces where they go from star to star,
gobbling up resources, creating more
probes, going to more star systems,
building more probes, setting up their
Dyson spheres, surrounding each of the
stars in the Dyson spheres, setting up
stellar engines that move the stars
around into a more attractive
configuration. That's the kinds of
things that a civilization without
limits would attempt. It's time to shout
out all the $5 patrons and above. Paul
Rodman TH Barker, David Alex I, Conrad
Cumley, Robert Thomas, Tony Ba, Robert
Tyler Dennis, and Roger Booth. Join the
club at patreon.com/universe today. Web
Fiji, is there anything such as absolute
stillness in the universe, like staying
in one place and watching planet, stars,
and entire galaxies zip past? Well, you
could just do that. Um you know you
could go wherever you want and move at
whatever velocity you want and then you
watch things go past you at the velocity
that you want. Um there is no single
place that is not moving in the universe
that that doesn't exist. It's not a like
everything is moving relative to other
things. you know, you are moving at
1,600 kilometers per hour if you're
sitting at the equator um relative to
the outside of the earth because the
earth is turning and you are moving, you
know, 1,000 mph in a circle.
Congratulations. You know, you're the
fastest human on earth, but that's
because relative to the surface of the
earth, you're not moving. So really you
always have to just say compared to what
telecomic do you think human gestation
and fetus development will be negatively
affected by the low gravity of Mars? We
just have no idea. Nobody knows. Nobody
has done the experiment. Nobody has put
a mammal into onethird Earth gravity and
then gestated it to completion and then
had the animal give birth and then saw
if there are any development issues with
the animal and that that experiment
seems important if people are planning
to go to Mars and live and raise their
families there. every person who is born
on Mars could be not viable. That could
that's a possibility. We don't know the
answer to this question. And so, uh, the
only way to answer that question is to
com is to have experiments that you
start with some kind of rotating space
station that has artificial gravity and
you can dial that gravity down to
different levels and then you have
various animals that you have them
procreate, gestate, uh, and then you see
if there's any issues. And you probably
want to go multiple generations. And so
if you you know if they if you have mice
and the mice give birth to babies and
then the babies you bring them back down
to earth and then you see if there's any
issues generations down the road and
then you scale up to monkeys and then
eventually you feel like you've done
enough experiments that you think you're
ready to try this with human beings or
to let human beings
take this risk knowing the the possible
consequences but also knowing that the
monkeys turned out okay and we We don't
know any of this. We just don't know it.
And so anyone who tells you that they
would like to build a city on Mars and
that send humans there permanently to
begin this great civilization um without
sterilizing them all is is asking you to
take a total risk, you know, like how
many um
babies with birth defects are you
willing to have? All of them. So, uh,
you know, whenever you consider these
plans, you there are all these basics
that need to be worked out and they
haven't been worked out yet. Len Kelter,
if we ever start exploring interstellar
distances with very long duration
missions, is there a solution to the
dilemma that future technology would
inevitably leapfrog the first mission?
That's called the weight calculation.
And the answer is no. You wait. You wait
until your technology won't leaprog the
miss the mission that you would already
send. Once you know how fast your
civilization is advancing, you know how
much energy you're producing, how much
energy it takes to go to another solar
system, you can calculate the day when
you don't need to wait anymore and you
can just send the spacecraft that will
not be overtaken. Casey re would it be
possible to have an X-ray or gamma
interferometer or could align to that
level? probably not, you know, and also
like X-rays and gamma rays, you don't
focus them in the same way that you do
with a with like a infrared telescope or
a radio telescope or even a visible
telescope that they require um it's
called like incidence. So essentially
you've got this this cone and the X-rays
are coming down the cone and you can't
you can't focus them. You can just nudge
them so that they're more likely to fall
on your detector. So um no it it feels
like it would be practically impossible
but theoretically possible. Juel car
serum how do you feel about using liquid
water insulation for the inside of a
spacecraft? Imagine exterior hall layer
of water internal centrifuge. Yeah
liquid water or ice water frozen water
is a great insulator against space
radiation. You just need one meter. If
you have 1 meter of water then you are
protected from space radiation. cosmic
rays, radiation coming from the sun,
you're set. And it doesn't have to be
water. It can be regul whatever. You
just need protons in between you and
space. And the advantage of having water
is you can also drink it. And you can
use it for fuel if you need to. So, so
water would be great. And you can
imagine some future spacecraft that is
surrounded, you know, a sphere of water.
Would it be a very weird spacecraft? And
then it there's a habitat inside. Did
you know that you can watch the same
video but with no ads and get a bonus
question over on Patreon completely for
free? We call that Q&A plus. And this
week's bonus question, could we mine
asteroids stuck in a lrangee point? I'll
put a link in the show notes. You can
just go watch that version. All right,
those are all the questions that we had
this episode. Thank you everybody who
asked your questions in the YouTube
comments. everybody who joined us for
the live show. We're still on our live
stream hiatus back in 3 weeks. But I'm
going to talk about the media that I am
consuming during this summer break. Uh
but first I'd like to thank our patrons.
Thanks to Abe Kings, Andrew Gross, Bay
Lake Roofing, Ryan Bod, Kedron, Chuck
Hawkins, Commander Ba, S Nelson, David
Gilton, and David Mats, Evan Pro, Greg
Phy, Hudson Morg, James Clark, Jeremy
Madden, Jim Burke, Jordan Young, Marcel
Smith, Michael Brouso, Monzo, Nick Borz,
Nick Solari, Paul Robach, Rank Kaidu,
Rob Shan, Sarge, Steven Fallon, Vlad
Chiplin, and Wolf Gang Claus who support
us at the master of the universe level
and all our patrons. All your support
means the universe to us.
So, just an update of all of the media
that I have been consuming this summer.
Uh, so first video games. I I picked up
Mechabellum uh a couple of months back
and played it a little bit and thought
it was interesting and then I've been
watching a couple of live streams. Uh,
was playing uh Mechabellum and I
thought, "Okay, all right. I'll give it
another shot." And I've been really into
it. It's a great game. It's sort of an
auto battler where you play against an
opponent and every round you get more
points and you send these mechs and
tanks and aircraft against each other
and there's a lot of fine-tuned, you
know, which units counter which units
and you can upgrade things in different
ways. And so you can sort of respond to
the battlefield as it changes round
after round, but things are kind of
locked in place. And so you're you're
it's kind of like a tower defense game
against another opponent where you're
sort of tower defensing each other.
Anyway, it's it's a really fun game and
I can see that it's going to take it's
one of those easy to start, lifetime to
master kind of games. The other game
I've been playing a lot of is Darkest
Dungeon 2. Now, I really like Darkest
Dungeon. I finished the game. Um,
Darkest Dungeon 2 is different and kind
of confusing to me. I'm still within the
first, say, 20 hours of playing the
game, but I'm starting to get the gist
of it. And the battles are very much the
same way as they were in Darkest Dungeon
1, where you sort of have this town and
you are attempting to defeat some great
evil with these adventurers, but the
adventurers get go crazy and uh they get
all kinds of of illnesses that you have
to sort of manage and take care of. And
it's sort of the same thing. What makes
Darkest the whole Darkest Dungeon series
great is the just the ambiance, the mood
where you've got this this incredible
narrator uh and just the quality of the
of the art all fits together and it's
just it's a wonderful experience to play
those games. So, if you've never played
Darkest Dungeon 1, definitely give it a
try. And if you you know, you cross that
hump into Darkest Dungeon 2, uh let me
know because I'm still kind of
struggling with it. Um, on the book
front, I'm now finishing up the sixth
book in the Dungeon Crawler Carl series.
Uh, and it's good. I think I think it's
my favorite so far. They do keep getting
better and better as less of the time is
spent considering the dungeon and more
of the time is spent considering the
universe that this is playing in. And I
think that was the right decision to
take, which is it's not about it being
this repetitive dungeon. It's about this
larger universe that is deeply flawed
and messed up. and Carl and the rest of
the dungeon crawlers are trying to
affect outside of their situation. On
the TV front, I'm watching Foundation,
which is is good. Uh it's again, it's
has nothing to do with the books apart
from a couple of names being the same.
And so, you have to sort of take it on
its own. And a lot of ideas are
terrific, like the idea of the of the
Cleons, this empire where they just keep
releasing clones of themselves so they
can maintain power forever. Uh, but
other ideas I think are are a little bit
diminished. So, but I think it's its own
thing and it's sci-fi and you know,
watch it. We also just finished watching
the second season of The Sandman, which
kind of wraps up the what was in the
graphic novels and I think that's the
end of the show and I think that's
perfectly fine, especially considering
sort of the controversy with uh with
Neil Gaiman. And so, yeah, like just
it's done. Let it go.
And then the last show that I'm
watching, which we've only seen a couple
of episodes, is Chief of War. And uh
this is based on sort of fighting
between the various islands of Hawaii.
And you know, Jason Momo is the is the
lead in this. And the part that was
surprising to me was they stuck to
everybody is speaking Hawaiian for the
entire show. For two episodes,
everybody's speaking Hawaiian. And I was
sure there was going to be this moment
where they were going to switch over and
go, "No, no, now you know just to show
you they're actually speaking Hawaiian,
but now everyone's going to speak
English." Nope. It's been Hawaiian the
entire time. And it's great to see uh
you know, it's just something you never
see. And so I'm really looking forward
to it. So far I've really enjoyed it and
I think it's a it's a really good show.
So Saman's on Netflix, Foundation is on
Apple TV, and Chief of Wars on Apple TV.
I got to say, Apple TV is becoming a
thing that is worth paying for month
after month after month. They we keep
going, "Oh, there's one more show and
then we're going to get rid of it." And
nope, we just keep watching. All right,
we'll see you next