Disaster! China even Totally Copied SpaceX’s Raptor 3 engine and Mixed the rockets! Elon Musk Laugh… === Intro 0:00 China’s engine and rocket copies 0:47 Copies’s problems 7:27 SpaceX’s systems dominance 10:45 Conclusion 11:16 === #greatspacex#elonmusk#spacex#nasa == Advertisers who want to place ads on our channel, please contact the email manager: [email protected] === SpaceX Starship SN Be the first to sponsor us Thank you. https://www.patreon.com/GreatspaceX?fan_landing=true Our video content is referenced by video sources at these sites: https://x.com/CNSAWatcher/status/1958733162223477198?t=J0SpXFs3eYR6NTz4Mf9B9Q&s=19 === 1) SOURCES OF THUMBNAIL: 2) SOURCES OF VIDEO AND IMAGES: TheSpaceEngineer : https://twitter.com/mcrs987https://www.youtube.com/@TheSpaceEngineer C-bass Productions: https://www.youtube.com/c/CbassProductions TijnM : https://twitter.com/m_tijn https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCDA8yz_nQY-0Uxd96-qxYjA Evan Karen: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCDN1X8Fz1oAXX-rBcOWjzmg WAI: https://www.youtube.com/@Whataboutit https://twitter.com/FelixSchlang Starship Gazer: https://twitter.com/StarshipGazer https://www.youtube.com/c/StarshipGazer === Disaster! China even Totally Copied SpaceX’s Raptor 3 engine and Mixed the rockets! Elon Musk Laugh… Let’s make a comparison! At first glance, these two engines may look identical—both resembling SpaceX’s Raptor 3. But that’s not the case. One is the real Raptor 3, while the other is a Chinese-made copy. After imitating SpaceX’s rockets and even their launch towers, China has now attempted to replicate SpaceX’s most powerful engine, aiming to use it in a hybrid rocket that combines features of their existing vehicles. So, how close did China get to copying Raptor? And can this effort truly rival SpaceX? Let’s find out in today’s episode of Great SpaceX. Disaster! China even Totally Copied SpaceX’s Raptor 3 engine and Mixed the rockets! Elon Musk Laugh… When it comes to China, we are no longer strangers to their ability to copy designs and technologies with astonishing precision. SpaceX, being the industry leader in modern rocketry, has become the most copied target. From rockets to launch towers, and now engines, China has repeatedly drawn inspiration from SpaceX’s breakthroughs. As the opening image of this discussion shows, SpaceX’s Raptor 3 engine has now been copied. The sleek black Raptor 3 represents SpaceX’s newest engine version, which is currently in production and will soon power the Starship V3 variant in just a few months. It was created to replace the Raptor 2, delivering stronger thrust while boasting an extremely simplified design. That simplicity not only improves efficiency in manufacturing but also streamlines operations, refurbishments, and reusability. In short, it is a highly refined engine meant to power humanity’s path to Mars. Disaster! China even Totally Copied SpaceX’s Raptor 3 engine and Mixed the rockets! Elon Musk Laugh… And yet, this same design has now surfaced on the other side of the world. The Chinese copy is called “Mammoth I,” produced by a company named Star Shuttle Technology. Interestingly, in some online updates and in the branding shown on the rocket, the company also appears to operate under the name ArkTech. This is most likely a newly established company, since it has not been widely known until now. The naming of the engine is also telling, because “Mammoth I” strongly suggests that future versions, or even entire families of engines, could follow. With SpaceX constantly innovating, it seems this company intends to mirror those advancements step by step. ---- We use images and content in accordance with the YouTube Fair Use copyright guidelines: https://www.youtube.com/intl/en/about/copyright/fair-use/ Any questions about copyright please send us via Gmail: [email protected] To be resolved, thank you.
Let's make a comparison. At first
glance, these two engines may look
identical, both resembling SpaceX's
Raptor 3, but that's not the case. One
is the real Raptor 3, while the other
is, you guessed it, a Chinese-made copy.
After imitating SpaceX's rockets and
even their launch towers, China has now
attempted to replicate SpaceX's most
powerful engine, aiming to use it in a
hybrid rocket that combines features of
their existing vehicles. So, how close
did China get to copying Raptor? And can
this effort truly rival SpaceX? Let's
find out in today's episode of Great
SpaceX. When it comes to China, we are
no longer strangers to their ability to
copy designs and technologies with
astonishing precision. SpaceX, being the
industry leader in modern rocketry, has
become the most copied target. From
rockets to launch towers and now
engines, China has repeatedly drawn
inspiration from SpaceX's breakthroughs.
As the opening image of this discussion
shows, SpaceX's Raptor 3 engine has now
been copied. The sleek black Raptor 3
represents SpaceX's newest engine
version, which is currently in
production and will soon power the
Starship V3 variant in just a few
months. It was created to replace the
Raptor 2, delivering stronger thrust
while boasting an extremely simplified
design. That simplicity not only
improves efficiency in manufacturing,
but also streamlines operations,
refurbishments, and reusability. In
short, it's a highly refined engine
meant to power humanity's path to Mars.
And yet, this same design has now
surfaced on the other side of the world.
The Chinese copy is called Mammoth 1,
produced by a company named Star Shuttle
Technology. Interestingly, in some
online updates and in the branding shown
on the rocket, the company also appears
to operate under the name Arct. This is
most likely a newly established company
since it has not been widely known until
now. The naming of the engine is also
telling because Mammoth 1 strongly
suggests that future versions or even
entire families of engines could follow.
With SpaceX constantly innovating, it
seems this company intends to mirror
those advancements step by step. The
most striking thing about Mammoth 1 is
its external design. At first glance, it
looks almost identical to SpaceX's
Raptor 3. from the nozzle to the
intricate piping systems above. Even
more surprising is that the company
copied not only the overall shape, but
also the very simplification that SpaceX
achieved in the Raptor 3. Like SpaceX,
the Chinese design appears compact with
only three or four large visible tubes,
while smaller details are tucked away.
If you look closely, however, there are
at least two clear differences. First,
the Mammoth 1 is silver, whereas the
Raptor 3 has the distinctive matte black
finish. Second, on the left side of the
Mammoth 1, there is an unusual
lever-like system that the Raptor does
not have. Aside from these small
distinctions, the similarities are hard
to ignore. Now, let us turn to the
performance details. According to
available information, the Mammoth 1
will produce 240 tons of thrust at sea
level, which is weaker than SpaceX's
Raptor 3 at 280 tons. Still, it
surpasses the Raptor 2 currently flying
on Starship. This alone shows how
ambitious this copy really is. Although
its vacuum thrust has not been
officially revealed, estimates place it
somewhere between 260 and 270 tons. In
terms of efficiency, the engine has an
impulse of 330 seconds. While this falls
short of both the Raptor 2 and 3, it's
nonetheless a very competitive figure
compared with most engines in service
today. Structurally and mechanically,
all evidence suggests the Mammoth 1 also
uses a full flowstaged combustion cycle
just like Raptor. Even the choice of
propellants matches SpaceX's design,
relying on liquid methane and liquid
oxygen. As for development progress,
Star Shuttle Technology announced that
Mammoth 1 passed a system plan review in
the first half of this year. The company
intends to proceed with component
testing and ignition trials before the
end of the year. If everything goes
according to plan, the engine could
enter service by 2026. But the copying
does not stop at the engine. Right next
to Mammoth 1 stands another replica, the
launch vehicle itself. This rocket is
named Glacier 1. And just like the
engine, its name suggests that future
versions may follow. And once again, the
design looks strikingly familiar. In
fact, Glacier 1 seems to be a mashup of
several rockets. Its first stage clearly
resembles SpaceX's Falcon booster from
its length to its grit fins and foldable
landing legs. These features strongly
imply that Star Shuttle Technology
intends to recover and reuse the first
stage, very likely through drone ship
landings at sea. Furthermore, the rocket
is said to be constructed from stainless
steel, echoing the same material choice
as Starship. Looking higher up, we can
see a hot staging mechanism positioned
between the stages almost identical to
the method SpaceX introduced for the
Starship V3. The concept of hot staging
where the upper stage engines ignite
before separation is not new. It dates
back to the Soviet N1 rocket. Yet,
SpaceX revived and perfected it. And now
Glacier 1 mirrors this exact approach.
The second stage is also a blend of
inspirations. Its long structure,
tapered tip, and oversized fairing are
reminiscent of New Glenn, Vulcan, and
Aryan 6. This design suggests that the
rocket is meant to carry elongated or
oversized payloads into orbit. In
overall scale, Glacier 1 measures about
5 m in diameter. That makes it larger
than Falcon 9, but smaller than
Starship. The company has not disclosed
the rocket's height, but based on images
and proportion estimates, the first
stage alone appears to be about 50 m
tall, while the second stage stretches
another 30 m. Factoring in the hot
staging cyst staging section, the total
height likely exceeds 80 m. Images
suggest Glacier 1's second stage will
use a single engine, while the first may
house 7 to 9, much like Falcon 9. The
rocket is claimed to lift 40 tons to
orbit, which with stainless steel
construction, advanced staging, and
reusability, promising launch costs of
just tens of thousands of yuan per
kilogram. On paper, this looks
competitive. But can copies rival
SpaceX? By skipping trial and error,
China's companies leapfrog hurdles. But
a copy is never the same as the
original. Without SpaceX's experience,
infrastructure, and years of testing,
it's unlikely they can match
performance, reliability, or innovation.
Meanwhile, SpaceX pushes forward. By the
time Mammoth 1 and Glacier 1 debut in
2026, Starship V3 with Raptor 3 engines
will likely already be flying. The gap
will only widen as SpaceX accelerates
progress. Still, China's efforts reflect
growing ambition and the influence
SpaceX wields globally. Even if Glacier
1 never reaches orbit, its existence
underscores how SpaceX has reshaped the
industry. So, what do you think? Can
these copies compete or will SpaceX stay
far ahead? Me personally, while I can
recognize the bold ambition behind these
copies, it's clear that they face
several serious problems. Let's start
with the Raptor 3 engine itself. As I
mentioned earlier, the Raptor 3 is
SpaceX's most refined and powerful
version to date. At first glance, its
design looks simple, but behind that
simplicity lies a wealth of advanced
technologies that only SpaceX fully
understands. Achieving this milestone
did not come overnight. SpaceX had to
endure a long and difficult process of
trial, error, and improvement. They
moved from the complex and less
efficient Raptor 1 to the cleaner and
more practical Raptor 2, and finally to
the highly advanced Raptor 3. Each step
required years of research, countless
tests, and constant refinement.
Simplifying, eliminating inefficiencies,
and integrating new solutions were all
part of this journey. China, however,
has attempted to bypass this entire
process by directly copying the Raptor
3. They did not invest the years of
development and testing that SpaceX went
through. This raises a critical
question. Do they truly understand the
technologies they have copied? The more
their engine resembles the Raptor 3, the
greater the doubts about whether they
comprehend its inner workings. Copying
is one thing, but mastering the
technology behind it is another. Without
that deep understanding, failures are
not only possible, but likely. And once
failures occur, private organizations in
China may find themselves unable to
recover, quickly disappearing from the
competitive market. The issues do not
stop with the engine. The rocket itself
shows significant weaknesses. One major
problem lies in the design philosophy.
Chinese developers often combine
features from many different rockets
into one with the idea that the best
rocket is simply one that includes the
best designs from everywhere. But this
is a flawed approach. The best rocket is
the one that balances all its components
to work in harmony, even if some of
those parts are simple. On the other
hand, mixing top tier designs that do
not complement each other can create
conflicts and failures. Looking back to
the Glacier 1 rocket as an example, its
design seems unbalanced with a second
stage that is far too long. To handle
such a stage effectively, the booster
should be between 60 to 70 m in height
to maintain control of the thrust.
Extending the second stage like this
suggests that the designers may have
been too focused on increasing payload
capacity without properly considering
stability and control. Another concern
is the placement of the grit bins.
They're located far too close to the hot
staging section. Hot staging releases
tremendous energy and with grit finins
so close, they are likely to be damaged
during flight. This raises serious
doubts about the rocket's ability to be
reused, a critical feature if it wants
to compete with SpaceX. From the
outside, these rockets and engines may
look like impressive copies of SpaceX
technology. However, the problems
quickly become apparent upon closer
inspection. In truth, perfection seems
to exist only in appearance. When
examined beyond the surface, these
copies cannot match the depth of
engineering, the years of refinement,
and the proven reliability of SpaceX's
systems. In the end, it's clear that
while the ambition is there, these
copies will not be able to surpass
SpaceX. The company moves forward in
confidence. Its Falcon rockets
dominating the global market through
unmatched reliability and reusability.
Falcon 9 and Heavy continue breaking
records in launches, landings, and rapid
reuses with performance and cadence
expected to climb even higher in the
coming years. Now begins a new chapter
with Starship powered by the simplified
Raptor 3 engine. Indeed, this V3 era
aims to achieve orbit, master complex
missions, and extend humanity's reach to
the moon, Mars, and beyond. Later this
year and into the next, SpaceX will have
the chance to showcase its innovation as
the space race heats up. The rivalry now
isn't just between nations or companies,
but between originals and copies. Yet,
SpaceX's proven systems backed by
experience and constant refinement give
it a decisive edge. Unless something
unexpected occurs, its lead will hold.
Though, the unfolding competition
ensures the race will be fascinating to
watch. This has been Kevin with Great
SpaceX. Don't forget to like the video
and subscribe if you haven't already to
stay uptod date with yours truly on the
latest milestones in SpaceX's journey.
Thank you so much for watching and
always remember, curiosity, imagination,
and inspiration will follow you so long
as you keep looking up.