This Time For Keeps (1947) is a warm and thoughtful romantic drama about love tested by ambition and circumstance. Starring Esther Williams and Jimmy Durante, the film follows a young couple whose relationship is challenged when career opportunities pull them in different directions.
Blending romance, gentle humor, and heartfelt emotion, this classic explores timeless questions about sacrifice, partnership, and what it truly means to choose love—not just once, but for life. A charming and often overlooked gem from Hollywood’s Golden Era, This Time For Keeps offers sincerity and grace that still resonate today. “Reel Thoughts with Tiffany and Rebekah” is a weekly film review show hosted by Tiffany and Rebekah. They dive into traditional and classic films, covering everything from mainstream blockbusters to indie gems. Each episode offers thoughtful analysis, diverse perspectives, and an engaging experience designed to connect with and entertain viewers. #moviestar#talkshow#classicalmusic#Americantraditions#Hollywood#theatermagic#cinematic#entertainment#celebrity#moviefacts#classicfilms#drama#artshow#performance#movieanalysis
He, qui tollis peccata mundi,
miserere, miserere,
Qui tollis peccatus annus Dei,
Qui tollis peccatus Dei,
What are you doing, Tiffany?
I'm reading about Mackinac Island.
What's that?
It's an island in Michigan where no cars are allowed.
Wow, that's really neat, but why the research project?
The movie we're going to discuss was filmed on Mackinac Island.
I think I've heard about that.
It was filmed at the Grand Hotel there.
That's right.
That was a big deal for the hotel,
but do you really want to talk about that movie?
Why not?
Well, it's a little late.
You'd consider 1947 late?
Are you kidding?
That movie was released in 1980.
Oh, now I understand.
You were thinking about somewhere in time.
The movie I have in mind was the first film made on Mackinac Island,
this time for keeps.
I'm Rebecca Brannan.
I'm Tiffany Brannan.
Welcome to Real Thoughts on Cinema.
Movies from the golden era of Hollywood often feature really great familial roles.
Right.
There are so many wonderful mother, father, and grandfather characters in classic films.
Interestingly, there aren't nearly as many grandmothers.
That's true.
Far more often, that older female family member is a maiden aunt, not a grandmother.
Right.
And in some of the few examples of grandmothers of which we could think,
they're rather stern.
Yeah.
But we finally thought of a movie which features a wonderful grandmother character,
this time for keeps, from 1947.
Of course, this movie has a lot of great qualities besides having a good grandmother.
It was made by MGM, produced by Joe Pasternak,
directed by Richard Thorpe, and it stars Esther Williams,
Johnny Johnston, Jimmy Durante, and Lawrence Melchior.
The story follows a young soldier who has just returned from World War II
and faces a dilemma when his father, a successful operatic tenor,
expects him to step right back into the life he has planned for him,
marrying the young woman of the father's choosing and singing at the opera.
But the young man, who goes by the name Dick Johnson to distance himself from his father,
has other plans.
When he first returned from the war, he met a beautiful young swimmer, Leonora Camberetti,
and when he sees she's performing nearby,
he can't help going to see her and meet her again.
Her manager and friend of the family, Ferdie,
is very jealous of any other men where Nora is concerned
because he has feelings for her himself, although he would never act on them.
So he takes an instant dislike to Dick.
However, after a rough start, Nora grows very fond of the young man
and takes him to Mackinac Island to meet her grandmother.
Although he passes grandma's approval, there are rough waters ahead for the young couple
when Dick's father decides to publicly announce his engagement to the newspapers.
This movie is a great example of what I'd call the Pasternak formula.
That's very true.
Because when you look back at the golden era of Hollywood,
you have to consider firstly the studio system.
Each studio had its own style, but even within the individual studios,
there were different production units, particularly at MGM.
Like the Arthur Freed unit was one of the biggest musical units.
But second most important was the Joe Pasternak unit.
And he had a very definite style.
He's my favorite producer because he loved music,
he loved old world charm because he was from Hungary,
and he loved family relationships.
And he has a particular affinity for classical music,
which is what I would say really sets him apart in the musical genre.
That's right.
So this film really ticks all the boxes.
Firstly, it's about an unusual kind of performer, a swimmer.
He made several of Esther Williams' movies.
She was this award-winning, competition-winning swimmer.
But very artistically, like these grand numbers that were more like aquacades than...
Or a water ballet.
Yes, rather than just swimming.
You know, it wasn't just an athletic event.
Very beautiful.
He also featured sort of novelty specialty performers like Jimmy Durante,
who was this old vaudevillian comedian.
But he would pair him with a more serious performer like
classical pianist Josie Aturbi, or in this case, Loritz Melchior.
Right.
Now he was a metropolitan opera singer, this great Helden tenor.
He made five major motion pictures, four of which were at MGM,
and all four at MGM were produced by Joe Pasternak.
That's crazy. I can't believe it was only five.
I feel like I've seen him in more movies than that.
He's such a huge personality that each movie seems like more than one.
But in this film, he really gets to showcase his acting as well as his singing,
as they always tried to do.
Very true.
And of course, all Joe Pasternak movies are also about family.
They'll often have a cute child in it.
There are a couple of cute children in this.
The niece of Nora, the great-grandmother character,
and then this little boy who's the son of one of the swimmers,
one of the backup swimmers.
So all these elements fit together, plus oftentimes an unusual locale
to make a great Joe Pasternak formula.
And you just can't beat it because it's a heartwarming blend of
there is some comedy, a very charming, wholesome romance.
There's a bit of conflict, but there's also sentiment.
So it's not just funny. It's not just romantic.
It's very heartwarming and sentimental,
as well as intriguing with an interesting location.
So I love the Joe Pasternak films.
Now, the leading man in this film is kind of unusual.
Johnny Johnson.
I believe this is the only real role he played in a film.
Yeah, that's right. He was a radio singer.
He did a specialty feature in Till the Clouds Roll By.
Is that right?
That's right.
Biopic of Jerome Kern.
But this was his only real acting performance.
And I think that's really a shame because he's very engaging in this film.
Very good actor and, of course, a beautiful voice.
There's a reason for that.
He ended up marrying Katherine Grayson, a big MGM singing star.
But she was the object of one of the executive's attentions.
And apparently, he was very jealous that Johnny Johnson beat him out.
So that's at least what I've heard about the situation.
I read the same thing.
But he's good in this movie.
He's kind of a Van Johnson type.
Right. Van Johnson, I believe, was originally slated for this role.
Which makes sense. He made a lot of movies with Esther Williams.
Right.
But Johnny Johnson does a good job.
He's a good singer.
He has a nice baritone voice, but not quite up to opera.
So you can see how his father really is kidding himself to think that he could be an opera singer.
I'm not saying he couldn't, but he clearly hasn't dedicated himself to that training.
Right. And he tries to tell him,
I'm not you, dad. I don't have your voice.
And, of course, his father's just like, who does?
Nobody has my voice.
Best in the world.
It's not just that he doesn't want to do it.
He really feels that he doesn't have the kind of potential for it that his father had.
So he's an interesting character in this.
Of course, Esther Williams.
This is a great feature for her.
This was the first time that she played a swimming star.
Oh, that's interesting.
She had swum in a lot of movies, of course.
But this is the first time she really was being, like herself, the star of an aquacade.
And one of the reasons why was the movie she made right before this was Fiesta,
which was very against type for her.
She barely swam at all on that.
And they were afraid that maybe audiences wouldn't like that.
So let's get her back in the water, really, as a swimming star.
Of course, other noteworthy actors we've mentioned in passing.
But the main reason we did want to talk about this was because of the great-grandmother character.
Right. Played by Dame Mae Whitty, who's kind of interesting
comparing her to Lawrence Melchior, who started his career so late.
She didn't make her first film until she was 72.
Oh my goodness.
And she'd done a lot of great stage acting.
She was a British actress.
But she started her film career very late, but was nominated twice for Best Supporting Actress.
First for her debut film, and then for the wartime drama Mrs. Miniver.
She was also in two Hitchcock movies.
And this film, being in 1947, was only a year before she died.
She must have been very old by this point.
Very, yes.
She was 72, and that was quite a few years earlier.
She's really charming and lovable in this role of the matriarch of this family,
the Camberettis, who are a circus family.
Nora is telling Dick all about how many members of her family have been bareback riders,
like her grandmother.
But she broke with the family tradition by becoming a swimmer.
But it's all right, because she's still a headliner.
And she brings that old world class and charm to this part,
as a woman who's very strong-minded.
And she won't let anyone...
She's not just a sweet, docile grandmother, but she is very sweet in her strength of character.
She just loves her granddaughter very much, her whole family so much.
And she wants to make sure that this young man is worthy.
And so she puts them through his paces.
She has very important questions to ask him, and she doesn't beat around the bush about it.
But then when she really sees that he has the right kind of spirit,
and so then she really loves him.
And there's a charming relationship between her and her great-granddaughter,
who's the niece, played by Sharon McManus.
Now, that little girl with very sad eyes is best known for doing
an adorable dance sequence with Gene Kelly in Anchors Away.
That's right.
She's a little Mexican girl.
Completely non-speaking role.
This time, she gets a chance to sing and to speak,
and you get to see more of her acting.
Crying.
Yes, she's quite dramatic.
And they, both the granddaughter and the great-granddaughter,
seem to be the only relatives who are in the area.
Right.
So you don't know what happened to the grandfather or her parents,
but either the parents of Nora or the parents of the great-granddaughter.
But the relationship between that grandmother character
and both her granddaughter and her great-granddaughter is really heartwarming,
because you see that a really great-grandmother
doesn't just affirm everything that her descendants want.
She's fighting for their happiness.
And she uses gentle love as well as tough love.
And then it's interesting how once Dick's father comes around
and realizes the two young people belong together,
he and her grandmother sort of conspire together,
try to bring them back together because they're angry at each other.
She found out about his having another fiancé,
and she doesn't want to forgive him for it.
So the two of them have to kind of band together,
and use some sort of tricks to try.
Because the grandmother tells him,
you can't just try to bulldoze her.
The Cameroonian women don't take to that well,
so they have to use subtle techniques.
She really is the only one who's able to get through to Dick's father,
because it's interesting.
Usually you think of the overbearing parent as being uncaring or even mean.
But Richard, who's the father, isn't unkind at all.
He really loves his son.
He clearly is a widower.
But he doesn't realize that he's smothering him with his love for him.
He's like, he's laid out his whole life for him.
This is the woman you're going to marry.
This is the career you're going to have.
Yeah, he just thinks you should be happy about this.
I'm looking out for your best interests.
And before the war, I think he was perhaps not as strong of a young man.
But now that he's had this experience,
he knows even more what he wants and doesn't want out of life.
But his father just thinks you're just getting back from the war.
You need some time to get back into society.
And nobody can really get through to him
that he's completely not listening to what his son really wants
until he finally is able to talk to the grandmother.
And he learns from Mrs. Cambretti
that he needs to not use these rough old world methods
of just ordering his son what to do.
He needs to really listen to what he wants
lest he lose him altogether
and he won't want to be part of his life anymore.
Of course, this is a musical.
So we have to talk about the music that's featured in it.
Right.
Kind of the love theme is the song, Easy to Love,
which was a very popular song around MGM, I would say.
It's featured in quite an old song.
Right.
Originally, Dick sings the song while Nora is swimming
in the scene when he first meets her.
And then the film ends with Lawrence Melchior
giving us his rendition of the song.
But beyond that, there's also Xavier Cugat,
another specialty performer, is featured in this.
That's another thing Pastor Nachoffen would do.
You almost forget he's in this film
because there's so much in it.
So many performers.
He often featured like a popular band leader of the day.
Right.
And so Dick actually gets a job singing with him,
but there's a beautiful female singer
from who sings the song, That's Why I Love to Dance.
Mina Romay.
As well as some opera excerpts are featured.
Yes, that's right.
There's an excerpt from Otello by Verdi,
which Lawrence Melchior sings.
And it's a very dramatic moment
because he's singing this great...
I love these movies because you get to see up close and personal.
This is long before the Metropolitan Opera
had their HD recordings.
Yet you get to see that kind of up close and personal performance
from Lawrence Melchior.
It's even more fun because you get to see the backstage drama
going on at the same time.
When he's singing Otello, it's kind of a funny moment
because his son is trying to get his attention
and he's like waving at him from off stage.
It's about the newspaper.
Yes, because he's so angry that this came out.
But his father just kind of looks off.
I'm trying to sing.
And then he just like walks over to the other side.
But he's trying to stay focused.
We've all had that moment.
Stop trying to interact with me.
I'm on stage.
Of course, the whole opera,
the whole movie actually opens with an opera scene.
But in standard MGM and not just MGM, Hollywood form,
it's a fictional opera called The Victorious Emperor.
And the piece of music which Lawrence Melchior is singing
with grand chorus accompaniment
is actually The Unused Day by Bizet,
who was a famous opera composer best known for writing Carmen.
But that work isn't from an opera.
It's just a sacred work
with the very standard Catholic prayer, Unused Day.
But because it was by an opera composer,
it has a real dramatic sound.
It works very nicely.
It's a beautiful opening sequence.
It's like this emperor,
could be Charlemagne maybe,
singing this prayer.
And of course, you see him singing.
You've got the chorus and the orchestra.
And then you also see Dick and his fiancée
and his future mother-in-law in the box conversing.
So you've got the contrast of the onstage.
And then, of course, at the end of the film,
he, Lawrence Melchior, gets up with Xavier Cugat's orchestra
to sing La Donna Immobile, the famous aria from Rigoletto,
which he does not finish
because then it transitions into Easy to Love.
But what we do get to hear of it is very good.
And at one opera rehearsal,
he's singing some excerpts from Marta.
Oh, yes, that's right.
And then he wants Dick to audition.
So he comes in and then he starts trying to sing the song Marta, Marta.
That's when we really hear that he doesn't have an operatic voice.
Then he realizes it, too,
because he starts turning it into a jazz tune,
which is interesting
because there was a popular jazz version of that song.
Yes, yes, there was.
Of course, the other musical performers who are featured,
like Jimmy Durante,
he has to do some of his standard banging on the keyboard
and singing a funny song.
He sings his very well-known Inka Dinka Do
and a little bit this, a little bit that during a swimming routine.
And he also sings The Lost Chord.
I would say probably his most notable number in the film.
That's the one that always stands out to me.
He's playing the piano,
talking about how he found this lost chord,
and then he loses it again.
So he starts tearing apart the piano,
which is another common shtick he had.
He starts ripping it apart.
And it's even funnier because Lawrence Melchior's character,
Richard Harreld, comes in to talk to him.
And he's just standing there watching,
what is going on here?
And then a song which was sort of original for this movie is
Snow Wonder They Fell in Love,
which is performed on Mackinac Island
when Nora and Dick and her little niece
are riding along in a horse-drawn carriage.
Right, and for the long shots of that,
the sleigh was actually driven by a local boy
who was about the same size as the little Sharon.
And a little song, When It's Lilac Time on Mackinac Island,
which you just hear sung very briefly
by a chorus of voices as they're showing
all the lilacs growing on Mackinac.
That's a nice little tribute to the location.
Speaking of which, we have to talk about that.
Yes.
It's the first movie filmed on Mackinac Island.
Yes, it was.
And Mackinac Island is so interesting.
I remember reading about it years ago,
because it's an example of a place
where they put something into effect,
some kind of a law or rule,
and it made a lot of sense.
It was very standard for the time,
yet they never got rid of it.
So then it became this oddity.
Because originally,
partly because it's such a small island,
only about three miles across,
the horses, which there were a lot of horse-drawn carriages,
were being scared by the new motor cars.
So they enacted a ban on cars.
Now, horses all over the world were scared by cars,
but particularly there, they made this rule.
And then before long, they're like,
hmm, that's kind of a good idea.
And to this day,
there are no motorized vehicles allowed on Mackinac Island.
Except, I understand, for some emergency vehicles.
Yes, there are a few emergency vehicles.
But not for just individual use.
Individual use, right.
There are so many bikes.
There are the most bike paths on that island.
And people use carriages, horse-drawn carriages,
and in the winter, sleighs.
Right.
There's quite a bit of use of bicycles seen in the film,
especially one scene when Jimmy Durante and Laura Smokier
were riding on a bicycle built for two.
Yes.
And it's so charming because that island
is really preserved in another time because of that.
Right.
And you can reach it by, I believe there's a bridge now,
or by boat like in the movie,
or there is a small airport you can fly over from a nearby area.
The main feature of the island is the Grand Hotel,
which has beautiful Victorian architecture.
And I think one of the, maybe even the longest front porch
of that veranda of that kind.
And it's very indicative of that style of architecture.
And that front porch was the location
of some kind of a demonstration by Thomas Edison.
So a lot of firsts have happened there.
And this was the first time a movie was filmed there.
Why they happened to film it there, I'm not sure.
I don't know how they happened to write into the story
that this was set in Mackinac Island.
Somebody in the production team must have been fascinated.
But it wasn't the first time that Joe Pasternak
had set a movie in an unusual or fascinating place.
Like he, a few years earlier, he'd made Seven Sweethearts,
which was set in this tulip festival in a town
that sort of seems like a bit of Old Holland.
So I think he liked those places that seemed like the old world
or places that were unique,
because maybe they reminded him of Europe.
And he thought that people should see
these interesting little locations.
So I think there's a good chance
that it was partly Pasternak's decision to film it there.
Probably.
And one of the most casual swimming sequences in the film
was when Esther is just swimming with her niece,
or Nora, I should say,
at the swimming pool at the Grand Hotel.
Beautiful, huge swimming pool,
which is now named the Esther Williams Swimming Pool.
Yes, yes, yes it was.
It remains that way as a tribute to her.
And only two movies have ever been filmed there.
This Time for Keeps, and years later, Somewhere in Time,
which was very, very popular.
And it's a time travel movie, I understand.
But every fall, there's a whole Somewhere in Time week
where people come from all over the place
to reenact scenes there, sort of a festival.
But I think there should also be a This Time for Keeps festival there
at lilac time.
Exactly.
And there are some beautiful sort of establishing shots showing the island,
but they did film with some actors on the island,
and there was a real house they used to be the Camberetti house.
And then, of course, the Grand Hotel.
You see little Sharon McManus running up the front steps
and giving her bicycle to the valet.
You can really see the beauty of Mackinac Island
and everything else in the film
because it's in lovely post-war 1940s Technicolor.
There's something very special about that, isn't there?
It's so vibrant.
I feel like it's the most vibrant kind of color that you can find in films,
right around sort of like the late 40s into the early 50s.
And everything is just sort of bright and fanciful almost,
and that color makes everything look more beautiful.
And that beautiful victorious mood, which was the spirit of the day,
having won the war.
And there is a strong element about a young soldier
who's getting back into society,
which is very timely for this film.
And with that beautiful color,
you get to see all the lovely costumes that the ladies wear.
My outfit is based on one of the costumes which Nora wears.
She wears it during her second visit to Mackinac Island.
It's a simple suit with a plain white top,
black shoes, and a little black scarf in her hair.
And she doesn't wear a lot of visible jewelry in this scene,
but in another scene where she's wearing a different suit,
she wears pearl earrings and a short pearl necklace.
My outfit is inspired by the costume worn by Dick's fiancée
the only time we see her in the first scene at the opera.
It is a fancy evening gown with one strap
and decorative details around the neck
with a matching embellished choker and large earrings and a fancy updo.
This movie is such a charming tribute to family, traditions, and music.
Yes.
I think it's a great introduction to the Joe Pasternak style.
And if you want to see some real location footage in a movie from this era,
which wasn't that common,
you'll definitely appreciate the shots of Mackinac Island.
Yeah. And if you're familiar at all with Esther Williams and her films,
I like this one.
I feel like it stands out among her films for being very multifaceted.
There's just a lot going on.
And as we've discussed, so many fascinating elements,
all the different specialty performers, the location in this.
Three or four types of music.
Several different interesting family relationships.
Yeah, that's right.
Both like the grandmother and then her niece
and then his somewhat contentious relationship with his father,
but which was all very nicely resolved at the end.
Yes.
This movie isn't available for digital streaming yet.
Hopefully it will be soon.
But you can buy it on DVD either as a standalone
or as part of an Esther Williams DVD pack,
which was released several years ago.
And you can purchase it on Amazon or through Barnes & Noble.
Maybe even on eBay or Walmart as well.
And if you do a little digging,
you can find almost anything on the internet.
You can't do that on the established channels.
There are multiple actors from the classic era
who are still famous today,
but there are far fewer directors from this era who are really remembered.
One of the few who is well known is Cecil B. DeMille,
best remembered for his biblical epics.
Join us next time as we talk about one of these spectacular films,
which features one of history's most famous and turbulent love stories.
Thank you for watching.
Goodbye.