Telling the Truth

Truth exists
11 followers
Hi everyone, this video is going to talk about telling the truth in writing.
So you've received an assignment to write a personal non-fiction narrative. It's our first
assignment this semester and we're going to get started by drawing on your own life
and your own experiences. So we're not doing creative journalism or anything like that,
you're really going to be reflecting on something that happened to you in the past.
As our textbook talks about, part of writing creative non-fiction is thinking about how
we tell the truth in the narratives. So this short presentation is going to go through some
different ideas about telling the truth in writing and especially in non-fiction. But I think it's
a topic that's important beyond non-fiction because even when we're writing poetry and even
when we're writing fiction, the goal really is to make our writing believable on a gut,
instinctual, emotional level. So the idea of telling something that's true. Hemingway said,
write one true sentence and then another. And what he meant by that was that even if it's
fictional, that there is something universal and cohesive and accurate about it emotionally.
So when we talk about accuracy, one of the things that we might want to talk about is what
counts as the truth? What is our obligation to the factual truth? And if our textbook says,
and as post-modernism says, truth is an illusion, we can't really understand what is
the black and white truth. How do we really write non-fiction? We always want to ask ourselves,
what if our memories are selective and full of holes? And if you have siblings or family members
or even friends that you reminisce about, you've probably had this experience.
I think one of the best examples of how truth can be this sliding scale is the show, This Is Us.
If you're not familiar, it is a multi-generational show that takes this family
past, present, and future. And in season two, episodes eight to 11, it does this really
brilliant thing where it shows the same event from the three different siblings' point of view.
So basically for three weeks, the show goes through and replays the exact same sequence
of events. But in each week, you're in a different sibling's perspective. And what's
interesting about this is how much we see that there is that difference, especially when we're
not talking about things and we're not sharing and we're not kind of reflecting in the moment.
Our experiences can be very, very different of the exact same event
from other people's. So then how do we really get to this idea of the truth?
I think it's more, I don't know, effective, really, or efficient to think about truth
as authenticity in your writing. So this quote here is from an epigraph to Tim O'Brien's
award-winning novel, The Things They Carried. And the epigraph says, and he's drawing this from
John Ransom's Andersonville diary. He says, this book is essentially different from any other that
has been published concerning the late war or any of its incidents. Those who have had any such
experience as the author will see its truthfulness at once. And to all other readers, it is
as a statement of actual things by one who experienced them to the fullest. Now, the really
interesting thing about the novel, The Things They Carried, is that it plays with this idea of the
truth. Starting really from the dedication, the dedication of the novel is to the characters.
This book is lovingly dedicated to the men of Alpha Company, in particular, Jimmy Cross,
Norman Bowker, Rob Kiley, Mitchell Sanders, Henry Dobbins, and Kiowa. The problem is,
those men are all completely fictional. Over and over, this fictional, novelized story
tells us this is true. So to have this epigraph saying that this book is a true story,
that this is actual events, it's not really accurate in the sense of the facts that actually
happened. But part of what Tim O'Brien is talking about in The Things They Carried is this idea of
story truth. And that's why thinking about telling the truth is so important, not only for nonfiction,
but as we get into other types of writing as well. And that is in part because in addition to the
facts, we really want to think about the kind of emotional resonance of the truth. One of the most
important things we can do, not only in nonfiction, but in any type of writing, is to tell the tough
truth. If you are writing your personal narrative, or a poem, or a story, and it doesn't make you
nervous at all, if there's nothing about it that scares you a little to write, you're probably not
telling a very good story. So really, one of the things that I'm going to ask you to do this semester
is to dig deep, to think about what are the issues, the themes, the incidents that you have been
avoiding? Or what don't you understand? What are the things that you're kind of circling on the
outside of, but if you look too closely at them, they're a little bit dangerous? The best stories,
the best journalism, the best poetry speaks to something deep within our human experiences.
And it usually does that by speaking to the things that we're a little bit afraid to look
too closely at. Which isn't to say that you should completely avoid the facts, right? It's really
important that you get the basics correct, to do a little bit of research, to ask people to make
sure that you have the times, and the places, the actors, and the characters right, the timeline
correct. Because you're not really going to be able to tell any sort of story, fiction or
non-fiction, without kind of laying out what it is that happened. But the really important thing
with this non-fiction narrative is to not get bogged down with the facts. You want to use them
as a guide, you don't want to manipulate them to the extent that you're now writing fiction,
but you want to kind of keep them in the forefront. And I want to share with you like another
really wonderful quote from Tim O'Brien's The Things They Carried. He's talking about telling
stories and thinking about his memories, or the character's memories. And he says,
remembering makes it now. And sometimes remembering will lead to a story which makes it forever.
That's what stories are for. Stories are for joining the past to the future. Stories are
for those late hours in the night when you can't remember how you got from where you were to where
you are. Stories are for eternity, when memory is erased, when there's nothing to remember except
the story. So if we think of stories, both non-fiction and fiction, as a way to encapsulate
the past, it is important then to get those basic details right. Otherwise you're writing
fiction, which is a perfectly appropriate thing to write, but you can't really label it as non-fiction.
The goal though is that you're not getting the facts so muddled and so overwhelming
that you miss the point of the story, right? The truth is in the telling of the story.
And if all you have is a list of black and white by the books facts, your story is going to come
off as flat and uninteresting. So really you want to judiciously select your facts to think about
what do you want your reader to get from them? What do you want your reader to take away?
What do you want your reader to feel? And really you want to think about what you've taken away
or come to understand in the process of writing. Non-fiction like fiction or poetry or really any
other sort of creative work should be an act of revelation and self-discovery. If you aren't
pushing yourself a little bit more to figure out what it is that makes you human, that makes your
experience in life distinct and interesting and important and different from everyone else,
you're probably not writing something that other people are really going to
want to pay attention to or read. So as you think about your non-fiction narrative,
your personal narrative, you want to really think about how you can dig into the truth of the
moment, the truth of the experience, both in terms of the accuracy of facts, events, and details,
but also in terms of emotion and the kind of truthfulness of the telling.
