This fragrant, seven‑ingredient mixed spice recipe is the heart of so many classic Irish and British holiday bakes—from Christmas cakes and mince pies to puddings and tea breads.
To make: mix all spices in a clean jar, seal tightly, and store away from light and heat.
📌 ABOUT GEMMA & BIGGER BOLDER BAKING 📌 I’m Gemma Stafford, a professional chef from Ireland, two‑time cookbook author, and host of Bigger Bolder Baking. My mission is to help you bake with confidence anytime, anywhere—with trusted recipes, baking tips, and Bold Baking Basics like this one. Join millions of Bold Bakers for new videos every Thursday at 12:00pm Pacific!
Bold Bakers during the holiday season one
question I get asked a
lot is how do you make
mixed pie spice because a lot of my
traditional Irish recipes have an
ingredient called mixed
pie spice. So what is mixed spice? Well
it's a spice that's used
during the holiday season
in Britain, Ireland and other
commonwealth countries. It's
a mixture of nutmeg, cinnamon,
ginger, allspice, a few lovely
ingredients that we know and love all
mixed into its own blend.
It's very similar to pumpkin pie spice
but used very
differently. So here's the recipe.
Our first one up is ground allspice, one
tablespoon. That's one of the bigger
spices in this recipe.
It's warm, sweet, peppery and definitely
has a more savory vibe to
it. You will often see it whole
and they look like this. Next up my fav
ground cinnamon. Cinnamon
is a staple in holiday baking
no matter where you are in the world. But
this mixed spice blend
incorporates so many other
flavors and notes more than you would
just get in cinnamon. Ground
is perfect. Another big player
in mixed spice. Next up is nutmeg,
something that you normally use
sparingly. It adds a lot of heat.
It's very strong, you definitely know
when it's in something.
These are some whole nutmegs.
Next up is mace. Now mace is not a very
common ingredient. Do you
recognize this? So what is
mace? Well normally when you find a
nutmeg there is a kind of a lighter brown
thin shell around it
just like that. That is mace and this
ground down by itself separate to the
nutmeg is its own spice.
Next up are some cloves. Small amount of
cloves because they are
very strong, very distinctive.
Can be used both in sweet and savory
cooking. Go really well. Studded in
holiday hams. You can
also have them in festive holiday drinks.
A little goes a long way. You might be
more familiar seeing
them like this in their whole form. Next
up is coriander. Another
one that can be used in sweet
and savory. Fantastic in curries but also
lovely in tea cakes,
Christmas puddings. You might
recognize the little round seeds that
look like this. Then lastly a
little bit of ground ginger.
Something that adds brightness, spice,
warmth and is a welcomed
addition in our holiday baking.
This is the fresh root version of it. So
where does mixed spice come
from? Well as you probably can
guess it came from England in the 18th
century. It began there and evolved as
part of their baking
tradition and just like today in England
and Ireland and
commonwealth countries we use it
a lot in our holiday baking but also in
things like steamed
puddings, tea cakes, fruit cakes
very traditional dishes that maybe we
didn't love as children but I definitely
love now as an adult.
So this blend was made possible actually
by the spice trade.
Around the 17th to 18th century
spices came from Asia, Caribbean, the
Middle East and they
were transported to Europe
where this spice was born. During the
Victorian era around the
19th century home baking became
huge in Britain. Used to make fruit
cakes, hot cross buns,
gingerbread, even their Christmas
puddings. Because of British colonization
their traditions, their
foods and their spices
traveled all around the world to
Australia, New Zealand,
South Africa, India and of course
Ireland. So there's a little bit of
baking knowledge for you.
When you have all your spices
together put them into a jar seal them up
nice and tight keep them
in a store that is dry and
out of light and you can use them
throughout the whole year. If you go to
biggerbolderbaking.com
you can find so many holiday recipes
where you can use your new
homemade mixed spice. You can use
it for my anti-rosine's Christmas cake
which is an absolute favorite on my
website. You can use it
to make my traditional mince pies and of
course any of my Christmas pudding
recipes which I have
many. And don't forget outside of the
holidays you can still use it in my
barnbrack for Halloween
and my hot cross buns for Easter. I
really hope you enjoyed this
bowl baking basic it's a really
great one to have in your pantry. Thanks
so much for watching and
I'll see you back here again
really soon.