WINE SPECTATOR Top 10 of 2025: The Most Boring List of Exciting Wines?

Wine Chronicles
13 followers
Hi everybody! This is Agnesa from No Sediment and today we are going to taste some of Wine Spectator's
top 10 wines of 2025 and we're going to talk about this very exciting list. In all honesty,
I did not want to make this video because every year it is the same old, same old exciting wines
from Wine Spectator, just different vintages. My cameraman and I were following the reveal
and by the time they announced the top three, I was frustrated beyond measure and simply did
not want to talk about this list anymore. But my cameraman insisted, so here we are. Blame him!
California heavily dominates the top 10 list, just like the year before. One wine from Piemonte,
Nebbiolo of course, just like the year before. One Chateauneuf-du-Pape, again, just like the
before. And of course we have Bordeaux. Now, last year we didn't have it, but if we exclude that,
we have Bordeaux on almost every top 10 list, sometimes twice. No doubt Bordeaux makes some
really exciting wines, but it is always the same old labels, the 1855-class Bordeaux,
as if Cru Bourgeois does not exist, as if Castillon and Lalanne de Pomerol do not exist. And let me
tell you something, these wines can be just as exciting, if not more exciting, than those huge
brands. Bordeaux is so much more than second, third and fifth growths. At this point, it feels less
like an independent wine magazine, but rather a person or a small group of people who love
certain style of wine, have developed a certain taste and feel absolutely no need to peek outside
their comfort zone. I am not denying that I will enjoy these wines with great pleasure. I have been
enjoying Produttori del Barbaresco 2021 for a while now, a magnificent vintage and trustworthy
producer. I have talked on this channel about my love for Giscours, I have visited them, I really
enjoy their style. I have tasted Ridge Leiton Springs of several vintages and I think this
wine is top quality. But dude, you are wine magazine, one of the most influential in the world,
so for love of God, show that the wine world is so much more than that. Because where is Greece,
Spain, Portugal, South Africa, Austria, Germany, Hungary, and these are already well-established
winemaking countries. I am not even talking about up-and-coming regions and grape varieties.
So yes, while I am happy to taste the wines, the list for me is still very disappointing.
Especially because as we scroll past the top 10, we see it repeating itself. Wines 10 to 20,
another Bordeaux, another California, two more Chianti Classics. And only a Sauvignon Blanc from
Marlboro manages to creep into the 20th spot. Let's scroll further. Tuscany again, California again,
Bordeaux again, and one Provence Rosé. After 30 wines, only five countries appear. And even then,
New Zealand has one wine and Chile has two. So basically, out of 27 wines, only three countries
are worth exploring. Scrolling on, we reach wine number 39 and we are still only in five countries.
They are finally saved at the 40th place with Remi Uri from Rioja, Spain. Now that we have
crossed that line, things are starting to get interesting. We get Lazio, a Vermentino from Liguria,
and Manzoni Bianco. Yes, we are still in Italy, but at least these start to feel like roads less
traveled. Then we reach number 85 and I cannot believe my eyes. Now this is the wine they should
have put in the top three. In fact, they practically did it themselves because it has the highest score
of any top 10 wine, a White Bordeaux Smith-Olafitt 2022. It has 97 points. None of the wines in the
top 10 have more than 96. Yes, it is an ultra premium priced wine, but placing it at the top
would have shown that they actually understand how the market is shifting and what are the current
trends. And this is a really, really exciting wine. My eyes also sparkle at number 93,
Famille Libaud Muscarette Clisson. You might remember that last year, after the Wine Spectator top
10 video, I released my top 10 and this very wine was on that list. I am also very excited to see
White Rioja and Sauvigniers here. Can I just say that I am more excited about the bottom 50 than I
was by the top 50 wines? I guess I am a bottom feeder. So now that I have let my frustration out,
let's introduce ourselves with the top 10 wines by Wine Spectator of 2025. I have wine number 10
here with me and that is Chateauneuf-du-Cap from Famille Isabelle Ferrando 2022 vintage. They
recently changed the name of the estate and now it is Isabelle Ferrando and her daughter on the
front. Okay, so let's start with the smelling and tasting the wines. I will be honest with you,
I do enjoy Chateauneuf-du-Cap as well. It is one of the wine styles I like and I think they can
make some really beautiful wines. Sometimes I will maybe choose something else because naturally
Chateauneuf-du-Cap wines tend to have higher alcohol levels and I do pay attention a little
bit to it. But of course, when the wine is made beautifully and when it's all integrated and
balanced, you simply do not feel the alcohol on the palate or on the nose. And it does have that
red berry, that really ripe strawberry, raspberry, you know, bursting cherry flavor.
There's also some of that smokiness, some some cedar wood and some sweet toast on the nose.
And like dried garig maybe or dried mediterranean herbs. Just hints of them here and there.
Let's taste the wine. This is the very first wine for me today and it is relatively early morning
when we are tasting this wine. So thank god to the really soft and kind of mellow tasting
tannins. They are tickling your palate but they are not dominating it. We have beautiful lively
acidity. It is not also the dominant feature. It is really the fruit that shines here. What is
interesting and I do believe that this wine would appeal to many palates because there is this
really ripe, almost sweet tasting mid-palate, like ripe sweet fruit dominated mid-palate.
And I'm just wondering if this is a bit of residual sugar or is it all about the fruit
ripeness. But you know the finish is completely dry and almost earthy a little bit and so I would
want to say that this is mostly due to the ripeness of the fruit. I will give this wine 92 points.
Let's move to wine number nine which is Chianti Classico from Castello di Ama 2021 vintage, which
is really good vintage in Italy. And this is Gran Selezione San Lorenzo. So I do like my Chianti
Classico a lot. So it might seem that I am criticizing the very palate I have myself
because I do enjoy Chateauneuf-du-Pape. I do enjoy Chianti Classico or Barbaresco, Nebbiolo
altogether. You know that. I just thought that you know giving their platform maybe they should
have added something more, you know, to the list. But we've talked about that. Oh this is really
interesting and from the very first nose I would not directly go to the Chianti Classico. For me
Chianti Classicos are usually packed with these really bright red sour cherries, you know, red
berries. Ripe but there's this beautiful sourness, freshness, zestiness to it. This one is really
ripe. It almost seems opulent and there's a lot of smokiness to it. There's a lot of vanilla and that
really intense like sweet toast character to it. You almost have to dig through the
the winemaking to find the fruit. There's also some like blue plum plumy character to it. I think
this is a great wine. I think there's a lot of complexity to it and I absolutely think that this
wine will develop into something beautiful and age gracefully and add extra complexity
with its tertiary aromas. And I somehow feel the Sangiovese soul in there somewhere but it is
well hidden. I will tell you this because Sangiovese it has this nerviness. It has really
high bright acidity. It has like packed of tannin, you know, and the tannin is very textural. It's
always elevated. And here I almost feel like the wine has been made to taste a bit softer,
you know, maybe a bit polished. But I think somewhere the Sangiovese soul is trying to
shine through. Maybe it is slightly opening up. Now I do feel on the nose a bit of that,
you know, smoked cherry character. And with second and third sip the acidity feels maybe
more prominent. And this is where the Sangiovese is shining for me. I will give this wine 93 points.
Let's move to the eighth wine. No, we cannot move to the eighth wine because we do not have
eighth wine. Wine number eight was Wayfarer Pinot Noir. To be honest, it was almost impossible to
get any of the American wines, the wines from United States here in Europe. Some of those
wines are almost only on allocation and you can get them only when you sign up. And I don't live
in the United States. I live here in Europe. So it was impossible to get them. Yes, so unfortunately
I cannot taste all of the top 10. But we will move to the wine number seven, which I am quite
familiar with. We have visited the state actually together. Barbaresco Hangover is kind of easier
for you than a Barolo Hangover. You can try and you tell me. I had, I proved that. I have experience
in that aspect. So there is a podcast interview with Aldo Vacca from Produttori del Barbaresco.
2021 vintage is one of the top vintages you can get in Barolo and Barbaresco. And
I think it was Gaia Gaia who told me that if you see 2021 and you love Barolo and Barbaresco,
make sure to have those wines in your cellar because they are beautiful today and they will
be beautiful after 10 and 20 years. So of course it makes sense by Wine Spectator to add this wine.
This is great value by the way as well because it is a cooperative. And as a cooperative it is a
very unique one because they work only with Nebbiolo. And so they know, so they know their
Nebbiolo grape. That very small, you know, sniff during the conversation with you guys.
And it was just opening up. It had that perfume on the nose. It has these really ripe red cherries,
slightly smoked strawberries, but it also has some of the lilac and violets and roses and
peonies on the nose. It's just so floral and perfumed. It is a complete wine on the palate.
Like when I sipped it and you kind of expect from Nebbiolo this really high acidity and that really
intense, you know, large, almost like full power on tannin. But here this wine, it just, the first
sip you feel is all the flowers, all the berries, you know. It is so many flavors that are just
packed on this one first sip. And then the acidity comes and it just prickles and it teases. And then
the tannin comes. And the tannin, it just frames the wine and it adds a bit of structure to the
wine. And it adds a bit of grown-up-ness to the wine, if you understand my expression of it.
It just adds a bit of kick. And I do think this is beautiful wine.
And of course, knowing the people behind this wine, and of course, knowing how much they have
invested into making this wine, it makes me a bit guilty to criticize the list. Because I would say
this wine absolutely deserves the place. Maybe the argument is that we should always try to look,
you know, around the corner and look for something else. I do love my Barolos. I do
love my Barbrescos. I do love my Nebbiolo grape variety. But, you know, if you add it every year
on the list, it just means that you are not looking, you know, beyond these regions,
beyond these grape varieties. So yes, 2021 vintage. Absolutely amazing. Great value. 94 points.
Let's move to wine number six, which I was happy enough to find. And that is Clos Apalta,
Apalta. So we are now in Chile with the dominant grape variety of Carmenera. Carmenera is a very
unique grape variety. And I think it is sometimes or oftentimes misunderstood.
You just smell it and it screams I am Carmenera. This is beautiful. This is something that you
want from wine. You want from wine to express where it's from, what grape variety it is made
from. So there was a bit of confusion for me in the wine number nine, because I guess they add a
bit of Merlot to it. You know, it's not all Sangiovese or local grape varieties. So I guess
there's also a bit of new oak to it. And maybe I personally felt that it was a bit polished and
posh. And here, so you have that kick of jalapeno pepper on the nose. You have that tomato leaf,
that basil, dried basil character. And it is all mixed with these blackberries, blueberries,
cassis. And, you know, it's Carmenera. It just screams in the glass. I am what I am. You know,
you love me or you hate me. I don't care. I am unapologetically me. And of course, that color,
that really deep, intense, you know, ruby color. But it is not just fruit and those green elements.
There's also some notes of smokiness, you know, tobacco leaf, hint of cigar box, maybe.
This is really warm wine. It tells you that I'm coming from warm climate. There is this
fruit ripeness. There is this lusciousness, that debauchery of fruit almost. And it is packed on
the palate. We do have beautifully integrated acidity. It is not too high. It is not mouth
watering or zesty in any way. But it definitely adds great balance to the really luscious and
ripe fruit flavors. And we do have super polished, really ripe tannins. I do understand where the
appeal is with this wine. It is big wine. It is opulent wine. It is loud wine. But at the same
time, it does not lack elegance. It is still very smart wine. And I really wonder how this wine would
develop with age. Because all of that expressiveness of fruit might calm down a little bit and leave
room to more of the tertiary, you know, complexity. And that would be really exciting. I think that
sometimes these really ripe fruit driven wines are so appealing in their youth that we forget
that they can actually age beautifully as well. And maybe offer a bit of different dimension with
age. I will give this wine 96 points. Let's move to wine number five, which we do have. This one
comes from Saint-Emilion. So we are in Bordeaux. This is Chateau Beaux-Sageux Becau 2022 vintage. An
absolutely amazing vintage in Bordeaux. And of course we are with this wine in the right bank
of Bordeaux. So it is where Merlot and Cabernet Franc dominates, not Cabernet Sauvignon. I do like
the snooze. There is some quiet elegance to it. There is some calmness to it. At the same time, it is
quite seductive. These really small, tiny, blue colored plums. But they're with a lot of flavor.
They're really concentrated. And you know, they're fresh and zesty. So it does not seem cooked or
really overly ripe. At the same time, we do have some of that smokiness to it. You know,
hint of fireplace. Just, you know, some really aromatic wood burning in the fireplace. We Latvians
smoke and burn wood a lot. We know our wood. And this brings me some memories back from childhood.
Some cedarwood as well. Like you feel that there's some oak, but it seems really well integrated.
Because first of all, it is the fruit that shines. And some earthy hint like pencil shading or
graphite. Let's taste this wine. Yes, I mean this wine, it almost has a burgundy character to it.
If you're not paying attention to it, it's not screaming at you. It's not, you know, loud and
here I am. You really have to converse with this wine. So on the palate, it just felt so seamless,
so really elegant and precise. But at the same time, it was not punching you. So I think this
wine is this quiet kind of beauty that oftentimes in blind tastings, you just miss. Because when
you taste all of these really, you know, bigger, louder wines, these ones just stay there in the
corner, just shining bright. And you know, when there's a lot of noise, you just miss it. And I
think this wine has that elegance and has that presence. I do enjoy it greatly. And it has that
beautifully polished tannin texture. You almost don't feel it. And this wine is one, two, three,
four, five. It is the fifth place and it is the fifth wine I'm tasting. And somehow it seems softer
and riper on the palate than any of the wines before. But you know, tannin builds up on the
palate because it binds and sticks with protein. So it is really interesting that here with this
wine, I feel like it's so soft. It's caressing your palate. The acidity is there. It's just part
of the fruit. And I would always expect Saint-Emilion to have quite high alcohol because, you know, Merlot
develops elevated alcohol levels. But here this wine has 14 and I did not feel it. You know, on the
blind tasting, I would say it is 13.5 max. It is just so well integrated within the wine.
I will give this wine 96. By far at this moment, it is one of my favorite wines. Unfortunately,
we cannot move to wines four, three, and two. I have ordered wine Ridge, Leighton Springs,
but unfortunately it took way longer to deliver. So it is not here today. I have tasted that wine,
different vintages though. And I always marked it really highly. And I think they done amazing
things with Zinfandel, which is, you know, great variety. I find myself quite difficult
to work with. The fourth wine is William Salem Pinot Noir. That is one of the wines you can get
almost exclusively only on allocation. And despite it being almost like a cult wine,
I'm surprised that we do not have it here in Europe. So it is almost impossible to get it.
And then on the second place, we have a white wine, Auber Chardonnay from Sonoma Coast.
And that is something, by the way, a producer, at least I have seen several times on the top
10 list. So this is not their first rodeo here. And unfortunately it was also not available for
us. And I would have been really excited to taste white wine amongst these red wines here.
But because the wine number one was wine from Europe, from Bordeaux, Chateau Giscours from
Margaux 2022 vintage, we do have it. And I was really excited because that is a producer that
I love. When I first visited them, I was really excited about their wines. And I have had it
in wines from Giscours several times on this channel. So I have not tasted 2022 vintage.
So that will be a first one for me as well. Now this one is really out there. It is really
expressive. You do feel that it is a young wine, like in wine number five from Saint-Emilion.
It had that youthfulness to it, but it had maturity also, but like mind or smart, like,
you know, like, like just wise person. So there was this kind of mindful maturity to the wine.
This one, it just tells you, hi, I'm a youngster. You also see that in the color, like there is
these bluish, violet tones to it. Okay. Okay. Now you're coming down a little bit because before
it was all blueberries, you know, bursting wild blueberries in the glass. And now this wine,
as I'm aerating it in the glass starts to show a bit of that smokiness, a bit of that toastiness,
a bit of, you know, like toasted nutty character to it. Okay. Okay. You're coming down.
We do have way more energy in this wine. So it has that elevated acidity. It is part of the fruit.
It is not shining alone, but we definitely have a bit of energy, a bit of nerviness to it.
The tannin is firmer elevated. It is tightly grained and tightly knit. So there's almost
no way through it, but at the same time, it is really beautifully and elegantly done.
It is not aggressive in any way. And it is a young wine. I think the mid palette is just
packed with a lot of fruit, but that fruit is really fresh and bursting and lively. And I would
want to see a bit of calmness to it. And that wine will come down over the next 10, 20, 30 years.
I think this one will age gracefully, you know, Verdot always tastes younger than it is. And it
is surprising that for such a young wine, it develops and changes in the glass. As we speak,
there is a lot of pleasure to the wine, a lot of appeal to this wine. I will give this wine
94 points. I will happily enjoy it, you know, over next evenings. And I will happily
store some bottles in my wine fridge or wine cellar for the next 10 to 20 years.
Okay, you guys, my spirit has lifted a little bit. And there's definitely more smile in my face
because I've tasted these really amazing, beautiful wines. And there was no doubt about it that the
wines that Wine Spectator selects are great, are magnificent. And this tasting has proved it. I mean,
we have no lower than 92 points. So that is amazing. And you see the smile on my face right
now. But I still want to say this, there's so much more out there. And we keep walking the same old
roads, same old roads. And you know, when you walk the same old road, you end up to the same old place.
So why not, you know, take some roads less traveled, and see where the wine world would
deliver us, you know, what else there is beyond these amazing, beautiful, classic examples.
And of course, we are always allowed to come back, you know, those are our guilty pleasures.
We already know that these wines are great. We already know that these winemaking regions
produce amazing quality examples. And of course, Bordeaux needs a bit of spark now. It is really
in a complex place now. So I am happy to see two Bordeaux wines. I might have been more happy to
taste today white Bordeaux, to be honest with you. But that's in the past. I want to let you know that
as in previous years, I will also publish my top 10 wines of this year. There will be wines that I
have discovered or tasted again. And I just find they're really exciting and interesting. And I just
want to give them a shout out. So thank you very much for watching this video. I will be happy to
receive your comments, what you think about Wine Spectator's top 10, top 100. Was I a bit too harsh
today? Please just don't get offended by it. This was just my honest opinion. And if you're still
sticking around, make sure to watch this video next.
