「一邊一國」不是口號，而是現實！當大陸人問：做中國人是恥辱嗎？我只能沉默…台灣不是中國？我來告訴你為甚麼這是事實，不是挑釁！

Hello everyone I am James Taiwan and China are two separate countries Not subordinate to each other I think this question is very clear. Very simple Very straightforward I do not understand Why do many Chinese people not understand this problem? Later I slowly felt that It turns out that many mainland Chinese He has never been to Taiwan. He really has never experienced this in Taiwan. The sincerity of Taiwanese people simple So they always think that others are the same as them. In fact, they are the most special people. Today I saw a few videos online I want to make a topic about these videos First, let me show you one A very interesting handsome guy. A handsome boy living in Japan He encountered many troubles in his life and work. Let's listen to what he said. ah Hello everyone I am an unknown netizen studying in Tokyo today Something really happened that left me speechless. And met extremely speechless people I didn't talk about this in the previous video today. I met Taiwanese people before I serve him He said he is Taiwanese Don't you admit that you are from mainland China? Today I met a group Taiwanese I asked politely in Japanese at first. Are they Chinese? Then he replied in Japanese I replied with a seven-ga-five no I asked again in Chinese, "Are you Chinese?" He said he was Taiwanese Not Chinese He told me directly that he was not Chinese He knew I had finished speaking Chinese. He has been communicating with me in English I do not understand Really, I really don't understand Yes, you admit that you are Chinese Is there something shameful about this? Hey, this question hits the point. Ha ha I do not understand Don't you know Are there many shameful things in China? This little kid Here are some of his views. I find it very strange You work in one place You serve no matter where you serve You have to keep asking people where they come from. What are you doing? I really don't understand this thing. Maybe you just went abroad. I want to find someone like you who is from mainland China What do you think? Make friends How so But you have to meet someone who looks like you Someone who looks a bit like a Chinese Just ask him Where are you from? Where are you from? He said he was working in Japan. Many Japanese people look like Chinese people. Why don't you go out and ask people on the street? You do your job Just do your job well I think if I were the boss in the future Then I want to tell my employees Don't see any guests. Whether foreigners or Chinese No Don't ask people where they are from when you see them. If there is communication between you With chat There's a conversation Then suddenly ask where you are from Then you are OK But you are working Didn't you say you were traveling? You are traveling You see foreigners You ask where you are from Maybe we are from the same place. That's understandable. Then you are working You ask where they are from. What are you doing? And really as a Chinese There are really many places I'll show you slowly. Okay, this kid really doesn't understand. What is his reason? Let's finish watching his video first. I don't think there's anything shameful. A colleague of mine He is a Vietnamese He asked me Aren't you all Are you Chinese? Why Why not use Chinese? I told him I said it was because of different political positions. So he doesn't admit that he is Chinese He asked me why He also said he also uses Mandarin To be honest, brothers This question really confused me. Did you know I am there I was stunned for a long time I was confused for a long time. I thought about it for a long time I can't answer this question. I'm also wondering why Why do they speak Chinese? They don't admit they are Chinese. I am who I am Next time I meet someone like this, I will Look, if you see someone like this next time He is about to reveal that he is Chinese The true face of mainland Chinese people. Well, he asked this question at last. It's a very soul-searching question. His Vietnamese colleague asked him You are all Chinese Why not speak Chinese? Of course I don't know what language they use. If they speak Cantonese In this Japanese word I don't know this in Japanese. What do the Chinese say? But this I think it is consistent with what I have been saying before. It's very, very overlapping. I think for foreigners They really can't tell the Chinese apart Singaporeans and Taiwanese, right? They will also feel You all speak Chinese Why not Chinese Right? Then he said I can't figure it out either First and foremost For foreigners I think we overseas Chinese need to popularize this. Just like you are Korean You have to make it clear I am Korean Not North Korean This is definitely different. Do you think Koreans and North Koreans are the same? Do you really think that Koreans and North Koreans Their quality is also good Their cognition is also good Their text The culture might be a little bit close. Everyone eats kimchi Just their Are they really the same people? Then he said he couldn't answer the Vietnamese man. This question I think it's a good answer. How come your cognition is so poor? You are so great China Is this how I educated you? Lose it or not? Do you have to be Chinese to speak Chinese? So many people around the world speak English Are they all British? Shouldn't the British say You Canadians are us British You Australians are us British You New Zealanders are us British As long as you speak English all over the world All are British Is there anyone who speaks like this? Lose it or not? And what is the Chinese name? Is it called Chinese? Are they all Han Chinese? So you say this You are Miao How do you speak Chinese? Why don't you speak Miao? Is that right? You have something very simple. Language cannot represent You are from the same place. Next we'll take a look Why doesn't he understand He thinks Taiwanese people, why don't you understand? I'm going to show you guys. Thanks to this This is really a coincidence. My good friend and big brother in Taipei Today he sent me this out of the blue I told him I said, hey, I just wanted to make a video Just wanna talk about this Many people in mainland China don’t understand Why are Taiwanese reluctant to say they are Chinese? Because the people in these two places are different. Look, this is the election study center. This is the election center. this Their election center in the university Survey conducted Every year This is the survey on July 7, 2025 Let me show you this survey. The result is from 1992 to June 2025 Taiwanese people consider themselves Taiwanese. Still Chinese This distribution This trend Everyone take a look It's from 1992 to June 2025. If it is green I think I am Taiwanese. Considering oneself both Taiwanese and Chinese That's the red one Everyone, take a look. The blue ones really think they are Chinese And gray and black I just don't have any reaction I don't feel like I'm from anywhere Maybe no answer or something. Look at this line Since 1992 There were still many Taiwanese people at that time It's true that they don't consider themselves Taiwanese. But look at this line. From 929394 all the way up Until now 2025 More than 60% of people consider themselves Taiwanese All right People who think they are both Taiwanese and Chinese From the original is redundant I only consider myself Taiwanese. 46% has dropped to 30% today. I think both are true. It is said that 30% of Taiwanese people think that they I am Taiwanese But you can also say that I am Chinese But the premise is We don't know What exactly does this China refer to? The People's Republic of China Still Chinese from the Republic of China Is that right? So we need to clarify this issue We will know after we figure this out. So in this data We don't know about the 30% of people in the red line. Do you consider yourself a Chinese of the Republic of China? Still Chinese of the People's Republic of China It's the same as Taiwanese people. So what's the most interesting thing? I think I'm really Chinese. Residents living in Taiwan I won't tell you where they are from. Taiwanese residents in Taiwan Do you really think you are Chinese? From 25.5% in 1992 That is to say, in 1992, only 20% That is 4 Only 1/4 of Taiwanese people consider themselves Chinese of This data is not known to people in mainland China. Mainland Chinese I just think Taiwanese people should be Chinese But you didn't consider There is a word in the world called human rights You don't consider the human rights of others. This figure has increased from 25% in 1992. It has fallen to now. Among these items, it has dropped to 2.3%. Taiwan has a population of over 20 million Only 2.3% of people still consider themselves Chinese I used to think This group of people is probably the old ones. They are the refugees from the Kuomintang. After these old people pass away I think Taiwanese people identify with Taiwanese people. Will get higher and higher This is what I have always thought. The funniest thing is These Taiwanese residents who consider themselves Chinese There are actually not as many people as those who did not respond. 4.3% of people did not respond Only 2.3% consider themselves Chinese. This is already too little. I don't know how much less it can get. Just like you ask Canadians Do you consider yourselves European? Maybe there are some people We consider ourselves Europeans But most Canadians They think we are Canadians Just like you asked me James where are you from I will confidently tell you that I am Canadian Right, even if my child is born Even if both parents are from mainland China Children born in Canada He will tell you later I am a Canadian I am a Canadian, is it lost? He can't possibly say that when he grows up he will suddenly say I am Chinese The Chinese he refers to is his ethnic group. Maybe that's what he meant. But he would never say that he identifies himself as Chinese. If you say it in Chinese so This is something that many Chinese people don’t understand. Then I'll say it. He just said Is it so shameful to be a Chinese? Hey, I'll show you. Look, isn't it embarrassing? There are many exaggerated actions and words in China. Everyone, take a look at this video I used this video in my video. Mainland Chinese Ability to obtain public paper in public places How to hold toilet paper Really The people who filmed the video said This is not for getting paper. I'm here to purchase goods. So you say you feel ashamed to be Chinese? Oh, to be honest See this video I feel so ashamed My IKEA in Taiwan IKEA in Singapore This time I went to IKEA on a special trip. Why did I go to IKEA specifically? Because there was a video before IKEA in mainland China You can go and have a look yourself. If you are a mainland pink, Go and see for yourself the IKEA beds in mainland China. Seats are especially good in hot summer weather How many people are using the bed there? Free air conditioning As a result, some security guards Must hold a small speaker Shouting there, please don't sit there Please don't use the bed etc. etc. Isn't this shameful? I feel shameful So I really don't want to say that I am Chinese It's not just me Don't think I'm extreme. Cui Yongyuan, a famous Chinese host Mr. Cui Yongyuan himself said He has a video I used his video. He said I don't even want to say I'm Chinese This is too embarrassing The face is too shameful I can understand this idea very well. It's true So it's scary What is it There are also some older Chinese No words at all I can say there is no humanity. Come on, let's listen to it. Warning to Taiwan Taiwan's return does not require your opinion When Zheng Chenggong recovered Taiwan Have you been asked for your opinion? When Kangxi recovered Taiwan Have you been asked for your opinion? So now China has taken back Taiwan No need to ask for your opinion Look at this old man. Speak with confidence I feel like he really does make sense. You hear it at first It really makes sense. Is that right? That is to say, right If I had someone to recapture you back then, you wouldn't have to What era is this? Was there a concept of human rights at that time? That's the imperial system. Slavery Why did Mr. Sun Yat-sen To overthrow China's slavery Right? I want to democratize. His idea This statement sounds reasonable at first glance. So if we follow his teachings, So why do Chinese support Russians? To retake Ukraine Because before the collapse of the Soviet Union Ukraine was part of the Soviet Union Now we take you back Do I need your opinion? This is you don't respect others I'll take a step back. If you have to do this, The Mongolians Should China be taken back? You Chinese mainland It was part of Genghis Khan's Mongolia. Do I need your opinion? I will recruit you directly. Take you back Can't I? Lose it or not? According to his logic I didn't make it up, did I? I followed this old man The old man said this in his original words If Mongolia wants to take you one day Or the Qing Dynasty Manchus, I want to take you Han people in. Can I speak in Manchu from now on? Is the Qing Dynasty lost? Let's continue listening. Taiwan is an inalienable part of China's territory I'm talking about the land of Taiwan. Not from Taiwan Everyone, please listen carefully. This is the real core Many Chinese people really think so Because many Chinese Don't treat people he looks down upon as human beings Please pay attention to the following words. Taiwan's return also means that the land of Taiwan must return Not all Taiwanese people have to return The people of Taiwan must recognize this. We want this land. It doesn't mean that we accept all Taiwanese people. It's up to you to leave or stay. Identify with the Chinese Patriotic welcome to stay Let's build the motherland and Taiwan together Those who do not have a sense of identity can choose to leave Taiwan, China See? Many mainland Chinese really think so. They think that's the sentence. Leaving the island but not the people You Taiwanese people They think Taiwanese people Are you dead or alive? Life or death has nothing to do with me I just want this land Well, your life or death has nothing to do with me. We don't talk about human rights or humanity at all. What civilization no Just like Russia invaded Ukraine All I want is land Didn’t Trump also ask Russia and Ukraine to cede land? To solve this matter? But are the Ukrainian people willing? We won't let an inch of land be lost. Taiwanese people, you should know Many people There were about 2% of people there just now. Consider oneself Chinese But these people really want to come back. People who want to return may think It's indeed mainland China. The economy is good. The world's second largest economy etc. etc. But you have to know There are many things that are not you As simple as I thought First, let’s take a look If you return What will your child be like in the future? Take a look Since the implementation of after-school extension I complete my homework with my classmates at school Encountering a question you don't know how to answer You can ask the teacher for advice You can also ask your classmates I think the school should provide extended after-school services Many benefits First, I do my homework at school If you have any questions, you can ask the teacher at any time. Very convenient Secondly, I finish my homework much faster at school After-school extension I gained a lot Homework for the day Problem of the day We can solve it all on the same day After-school extended service My evaluation is very satisfactory Because I'm doing homework at school I can finish writing it neatly. And it was written very quickly. Doing homework at home I'll just procrastinate. There are still some things I don’t want to write And do homework with classmates There is a kind of unwillingness to fall behind Positive and hardworking spirit What do you think after watching this? Friends from Taiwan If you hope that one day your child Talk like this Does it look like the Korean model of unification? Unified tone We all like The great Chairman Mao gave us red scarves. If you hope that your children will one day Become this If you are in a state like a robot OK, welcome to the mainland. I believe the mainland will welcome you with open arms. The so-called return Is the whole family safe? Have food and clothes And study You can also be interviewed It's also catchy. Go and say what you want to say. democracy and freedom The more the better Is that right? So you have to understand Maybe after returning This is your future There are still many people who think that The mainland's economy is so good Then let’s look at another Just let me I just looked it up online today. This is not my intention to smear This happened in Hunan Just recently This October What happened last month in September In an open-air market in Hunan These farmers are trying to grab a good place Staying there all night to reserve a seat This is China I can't say everyone. If you are in the city Urban household registration Since childhood Born with a silver spoon in his mouth OK, no problem You, your life is pretty good. But China also has Premier Li Keqiang who said There are 600 million people who earn 1,000 yuan a month. That was just back then Didn't I say it? I said double it. There are still 600 million people who earn 2,000 a month. 600 million people get 3,000 OK A little more There are still 600 million people in China who earn 4,000 RMB a month. Is that right? How much is 4,000 RMB? How does it compare to Taiwan's minimum wage? Lose it or not? There are many more people That's just the average number. There are many people who really live like this I would like to ask Why do Taiwanese people consider themselves Chinese? What are the benefits of being Chinese? Reply to the handsome guy in the first video He works in Japan Meet Taiwanese guests People don't want to say they are Chinese Have questions? It is both emotional and rational I just came back from a trip to Taiwan Finally, let me share my own feelings First, according to what the old man just said It doesn't require your consent This is typical CCP rhetoric. It's complete bandit logic. Occupy the mountain and become king Landlord After going up the mountain After becoming the king You can also go down the mountain to grab a wife I won't ask for your consent at all. This is the CCP's thinking Is the CCP's consistent gangster logic correct? So after I went to Taiwan twice, As I got to know Taiwan more and more I found that it is indeed two sides of the strait, one country. Not subordinate to each other If we must trace back history Taiwan's founding date He is the grandfather of the People's Republic of China. The People's Republic of China is also called the Republic of China Call grandpa After all, they founded their country in 1910s. You were only built in the 1940s. That's over 30 years. It's really the era of two generations. What did I really experience during my time in Taiwan? I happened to be in Hualien area. The photovoltaic line was damaged The reason why I specifically decided to take the Taiwan Railway This time I want to feel it I thought the Taiwan Railways were green trains. Because I heard others say Taiwan Railways is equivalent to the green trains in mainland China As a result, I found my old Taiwan Railway is also quite luxurious Very comfortable It's really cool The price is cheap What is the key I witnessed it in the car. Change into rubber shoes before arriving at the station I also do live broadcasts You can watch my live broadcast at that time. Change into rubber shoes and take shovel to go down to rescue Why am I mentioning this? It's not that the Chinese don't do disaster relief. Of course there are disasters in China There will be many volunteers to rescue. We can't deny this. But I rarely see it online. Because I am making this video about Taiwan I often follow the news from Taiwan and Taiwan's self-media I rarely see Taiwanese people posting photos. Post it! Oh, I'm going This what what what what Be a volunteer Go be a superman How, how, how, how Few mainland Chinese people would go to rescue many people. I can't say he's just trying to get traffic. But at least his purpose of going there Not like the Taiwanese Rescue is so simple Well, I'm just saying it's not that simple. but He might really want to help people. Just grab some traffic. Take some more photos by the way These young people in Taiwan are really great. Once you go, you go. Go there to work Work hard Work hard It's true So the simplicity of Taiwanese people This is simplicity There's not so much scheming in my heart. I do this thing I'm not doing this for any consequences What results are obtained? Get a favor Get praise Get praise I really mean it from the heart That's where my awareness is. Where is the awakening of mainland China? I really can't see So to answer what the kid just said Do you admit that you are Chinese? Is it embarrassing? Is it shameful? Sometimes it really is Really There are still people making money from disaster relief. To embezzle disaster relief supplies Even the COVID-19 pandemic There will always be people during the Wuhan virus By withholding the government's food and wages. Go, go, go make money This is a shameful scene for the Chinese And the attitude of Taiwanese people I met in Taiwan Really everyone helped me Everyone greets me Everyone recognizes me on the street Give me a smiling audience This kind of simplicity is really not found in China I lived in China for 28 years. I have lived in mainland China for more than 20 years. But I haven't felt it in more than 20 years. Maybe now there is But unfortunately The last time I went to China was last year Nanjing Beijing Three major cities in Shanghai I won't say it, right? I had four fights in three weeks. Being cut in line countless times The restaurant clearly states that it does not give Smoking and someone is smoking next to you I'm having dinner with my kids This is the real environment of the mainland So I still say that If you want to travel to the mainland Try not to follow a tour group Don't follow those people like Ma Yunjiu What what What what what this exchange group This kind of team You can't see the real China at all You don't have to watch the curator's live broadcast Because he went to China to make money. That's the planned route. You are a Taiwanese traveling to Shanghai Why hire a Minibus with Anhui license plate bus These are all the Taiwan Affairs Offices of the CCP. The Taiwan Affairs Office has already arranged everything. What he showed you This is not what real China can see. He can show you Can he see that I just drew the paper? Lose it or not? He can see inside the vegetable market. Are there people who queue up at three or four in the morning? Can he see it? You really have to go into China yourself The most down-to-earth life of the people Only then can we see the true face of China Don't be fooled by the high-rise buildings in Beijing, Shanghai, Guangzhou and Shenzhen Blinded by the eyes I've been thinking about it these past two days I really hope that one day I can take my international students here International students from mainland China It doesn't take long for them to Maybe three or four at a time. Four or five or even two or three I took them to Taiwan to have a look. Because I took them to him If they go with me That really shows the real Taiwan. Join me in Hualien Playing the flute and watching the moon at the seaside Eating night market food We just sit on the ground This is grounding Truly experience the way of life of local people I'm in Hualien I am in Qingtan Take advantage of the moonlight to make sure everyone can watch my live broadcast Everything is online All of them, not just me. There are really many local Taiwanese people coming here one after another. Watch the moon there This is the most simple life of the locals by the sea I believe people living in Hualien Maybe many people have had this experience. In many places in Taiwan As long as people near the sea Maybe everyone has had this experience. But if you are a tourist I think it might be difficult to get you to 11:12 pm Walk from your five-star hotel to the beach Watching the moon on the beach I think It seems that the tour group should not have such an itinerary Okay, I think Ma Ying-jeou brought this student from mainland China Visit Taiwan There may not be such a trip Wow, right? Okay, so today I want to share with you Why do many Chinese children They don't understand Taiwanese people. Unwilling to say that they are Chinese First and foremost They aren't themselves. I've already said one country on each side. One country on each side is not subordinate to the other If you must recognize your ancestors Please call the People's Republic of China the Republic of China A grandpa Then the other point is A very normal thing is Because Taiwanese Their folk qualities It has absolutely nothing to do with mainland China. Okay, this is what I want to reply to these kids today. Their questions They don't know how to explain it. Don't think that just because you speak Chinese you are Chinese. There are many white skin Black foreigners can also learn Chinese Are they Chinese too? That's not right. Okay. If you have anything you want to talk about, please continue to comment. Let's continue chatting Keep saying thank you so much for watching Any good news leads? You are welcome to email me to provide news clues I was very happy to go to Taiwan this time. I also hope to have more friends when I go to Taiwan next time. I was welcomed by real locals. Let me have a meal at your house. This is watching TV Watch Taiwanese shows with you See what news you read Is that right? Miss me Really want to experience it The real life of Taiwanese locals Okay, that's all for today. thank you very much Nine Years