Cooking Historically Accurate Christmas Food With Dan Snow!

History Of Food
342 followers
#History #food
Porpoises, beaver tails, boar's head and puffins are just some of the exquisite dishes on medieval tables during the festive season. In this episode, food historian Annie Gray joins Dan in his kitchen to cook up some delicious Christmas fare from ages past. They make wassail - an ancient alcoholic punch - and mince meat pies as they talk about the Pagan rituals, Medieval feasts and Victorian traditions that dictate what we put on our Christmas dinner tables.
By https://www.youtube.com/@DSHHPodcast
Welcome everybody, I'm with food historian legend Annie Gray, hello. We are making
real historic traditional Christmas mince pies and Christmas punch or wassail. Cheers.
Annie Gray, great to have you back on the show. Great to be back. Well, is Christmas one of those
things that feels eternal but like most other traditions just basically made up by the Victorians?
Yes and no. I would say most of the modern Christmas certainly was made up by the Victorians
with a kind of sprinkling of 1950s as well. The idea of Christmas goes back a lot further so
I mean, okay, we look out the window here today and it's absolutely beautiful, it's a glorious
sunshiny day. It's freezing though but the most normal thing in the British winter is pretty
manky, pretty rainy, pretty miserable. If you're back in the medieval period or before then and
you're a rural farmer, it's got the additional glory of mud, most of your cattle has been
slaughtered, you can't go out in the field, it's boring, you're poor, it's hideous. So of course
the best thing to do is to light a huge fire, get really drunk and eat what you can do and try and
forget about your woes. And that is something that you see universally throughout northern
climes. Hideous, foul winter, look it's really short days, let's get drunk and light a big fire
and forget about everything. And then when the Christian church comes along and starts to adopt
a lot of those early pagan, call it what you will festivals, they go great Christmas, okay,
fine, let's stick it there, it's fine, we want a big celebration. So all these things come together
and you end up with something, call it what you will, for a lot of cultures in the middle of
winter which is an excuse to get drunk and eat lots of food. So from a point of view of getting
drunk, eating lots of food and that idea of coziness and something to look forward to,
goes back a long way. From the point of view of turkey, Christmas trees, buying loads of presents
for people, decorating things and being really stressed out, that's mainly Victorian. And as I
learned on the podcast the other day, many of the things that we associate with Christmas foods,
all actually from the Americas. Things like turkey and potatoes, so it must have been post
Christopher Columbus anyway. Well yeah, I mean the idea of lots of food, that's the kind of pre
pre-Columbian Christmas if you like. But I mean even say things like turkey, potatoes,
not really associated really hard with Christmas until quite late on anyway. I mean turkey comes
in in 1520s, 1530s, we start to see breeding pairs come in, we start to see farms for turkeys
in France in the 1530s, they're mentioned in sumptuary laws later on. So turkey was there,
turkey was associated with Christmas, but it was associated with Christmas because it was big,
impressive and in season in the winter. It wasn't just Christmas, it was a festive, a winter
seasonal dish. It wasn't the thing you ate on Christmas day universally, really until the
1960s. So you know, if you went to a Christmas in the Victorian period, you'd have beef. Or you
might have goose if you were lower down the social scale. Turkey was there, but it wasn't the big
thing that it is today. So even after Columbus, not all these things were immediately part of
Christmas. There's a lot of goose in Charles Dickens. There is a lot of goose in Charles
Dickens. Charles Dickens is really dealing with the working classes and goose was a big working
class dish. But not just working class, if you look at upper class cuisine, goose is there as
well. It's tasty, it's a nice bird. And I think today as well, we tend to forget that birds like
that, poultry is seasonal. So goose, capon, even chicken and turkey as well. These are all, and
swan, which was another, not popular feast bird, but certainly a feast bird that was present.
Fowls like that were seasonal. And now we don't think of them as seasonal. We eat them all year
round. But at that point, you know, think about Micklemore's goose, you know, all these things
suddenly go, oh yeah, actually, you're right. It was better from September through to February,
wasn't it? I am not a big fan of swan. Have you tried swan? I had it in a pie once, but it was a
Queen's permission to do that. No, apparently swans crash land on roads, thinking they're
ribbers sometimes. And as long as you take them along to the RSPB or to vet and the RSPB is able
to check the tag on the leg, sometimes some people are then able to take them home. But
there's no point because if you actually look at swan farming in the past, it was always signet.
So you would get that year's brood and you would take your signet and you would feed them very nice
food throughout the whole of that autumn season. And then they'd be killed for Christmas. So your
average swan that's just crash landed is only ever going to be fishy and tough. What you need is you
need to hand raise your swan. So really you need to be friendly with the Queen or the King now,
I suppose. Actually, that was, yeah, forgetting. Or an Oxbridge College that's got the right to
swan upping. And swan upping, one upping. You can one up your neighbours with a bit of swan upping.
What are the 12 days of Christmas and are they important food wise? They were very important
for the medieval period and for those that were wealthy enough to afford to eat well throughout
the whole period. So your traditional 12 days running from the 25th or the evening of the 24th,
depending on who you speak to, through to the epiphany. So the 5th or the 6th, depending on who
you speak to. Generally in the UK it's the 6th. And that was the period of Christmas. So the idea
was that Advent was a period of fast. This is the point where we were obviously Catholic still,
pre-reformation. So as with all fasting, if you were poor, you'd be eating stockfish, which you
would repeatedly hit with a hammer for days and days and days and soak and then hate it. And it
would be maggoty and awful and you'd force yourself to eat it because you're not allowed
to eat anything that comes from an animal. And if you're wealthy, you're going to feast on porpoise
and seal and beaver's tails because they're seafood, apparently. Puffin, things like that.
And you're not really going to suffer any shortages. You're going to be absolutely fine.
And then once you get to Christmas itself, the fasting period is over. Wahey, meat feast. So
you've got 12 days of feasting. And that was the idea that you had your fast, now you feasted. And
once you got to the 6th, you went back to your normal rhythm where about half the year really
were fish days and the other half were meat days. So gargantuan amounts of feasting if you're
wealthy enough to afford it. Is it funny that we now sort of have our, we get loose in the build
up to Christmas, office parties, whatever else. And then we all get all abstemious and we worry
at first of January, the diet starts. Well, I think it's completely wrong. Yeah, that's wrong.
Yeah. I mean, now Christmas starts in like August. I mean, there are Christmas things
in the supermarkets before the children have gone back to school, which is surely really unfair.
And you're absolutely right. You get to about what, three o'clock on Christmas day. You're
sitting around having eaten 5,000 calories in your meal and you're still picking at bits of pig in
blanket and thinking, I hate myself. And then on boxing day, all the newspapers come out with,
we just told you to feast, but now you need to go on a diet, you filthy bastards. And in fact,
that's the other way around. So traditionally that Christmas day was the start. For us,
it's sort of almost. Now it finishes. And we do nothing for the epiphany anymore. So
back pre-Victorian, no Christmas cake, 12th cake, push it all out with a bang.
Doing it completely wrong. Make epiphany great again. That's what I say. Right.
What do you want me to do first boss? Well, I think we should start with a drink.
It's the drink. Yeah. Okay. So we're going to make some. What's that?
Well, it's a lot of things to a lot of different people, including the good folks of Walthamstow,
who I'm told go around today in a modern fashion with plastic bowls, asking for booze.
Yes. And to some people it is about fertility and orchards. And to other people it's about
mulling beer and whoever you ask or come up with a different definition, but they'll all agree.
It's very old. Okay. So some people, it's just get a big bowl and people just pour whatever they
got in it. Yeah. I mean, what else? One of those things that comes from the medieval era where it
was even before that, actually there was an Anglo-Saxon drink and drink response. So you
would shout drink ale and everyone would go was ale and lots and lots of reenactors today love
doing that with their big time kids. How do you want me to start? We're going to cook a 19th
century recipe because there aren't very many recipes for what sale. And this one is from the
1890s. We're starting with some apples. So I think we'll do half the recipe. So if you can just
core without breaking the skin. Do we have a special corer or am I just using a knife? You're
going to use a knife. Okay. I would have got you a piece of reindeer bone so that you could go
straight through, but I didn't have it on. And with a knife, I just got that, do I? Yeah. Okay.
Well, good luck. You might want to, yeah, put it down on the board like that and just start,
just pretend it's someone you don't like. Okay. There we go. Uh, a lot of wassail recipes in
heavily inverted commas involve brandy, port, beer, whatever it comes to hand. And a lot of
the modern ones anyway are hot. And this one is a hot wassail and they may have been hot in the
past. They may have involved beer. They may have involved cider. They may have involved anything.
It sounds quite loose to me. Yeah. It's really just a thing people drink in the autumn and in
winter. So it's sort of lots of different things. So the core, I didn't quite do that properly,
did I? No, but it's fine because you've got the bottom there now. Okay, here we go. Just cutting
a square out of the bottom of this apple, pushing it through. Actually, I'm going to push it that
way through. Come on. I should have brought my corer. Oh, I need this. This is what I need.
There we go. History in action. History in action. This is it. Okay. What do you want
to do? I've cored that. So we're going to put that on this nice foil sheet here. The main thing is
just that there's no pips and things that you don't want to eat in there. Okay. How many are
we doing? We're going to do three. There we go. I mean, obviously, wassails are a celebratory thing.
So ideally, we should probably do about 10 and make it to feed 30 people. The whole of team
history here. We'll just have it ourselves. Yeah, exactly. All right, here we go. This is the one.
This one's perfect. This one's absolute. This is perfect, listeners.
Yeah. So if you go to Somerset today, you'll find that wassail is big.
Just broken the wooden spoon. I was given that wooden spoon by my team at History for having the
worst performing social media post in the whole of the year. Well, I suppose now you've got the
worst performing wooden spoon ever. It wasn't here for purpose. There you go. Right. We're
going to put a little bit of butter into the middle of each of these. Why not? And also,
we will rub it all around as well. Effectively, at this point, we're just roasting apples.
Okay. This is one of those things where it became a bit of a fashionable... Look at that.
Butter. Nice and snug in there. Became very fashionable in the 18th century to do wassail
because that was all about nostalgia as Christmas always is. So people, men, would like to get around
a steaming bowl of something alcoholic, get really drunk, and talk about how great they were.
Just don't change, do we? Sadly. So you can make a non-alcoholic wassail. Right. So let's put those
in the oven and roast them all. Actually, let's add a bit of sugar first. I've got an oven that
is pre-215. Is that right? Baking tray. Yeah. Hang on. There's some sugar here.
Sugar. There's some sugar here. Or brown. Do you want brown or white? Brown is fine. Brown's
slightly better. Let's put a bit of sugar into it. God. Not messing about. We haven't even had
the alcohol yet. Jeepers creepers. Right. Stick those in the oven and we'll roast them until they
go all soft and squidgy and no... Okay. Or you could drop them. I'll just drop them in the oven.
Yeah, obviously. Your oven was really clean till I arrived. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
There we go. Right. That's a baking tray that I'll need to go in the dishwasher afterwards.
My role in life is cleaning baking trays. Not as much a prep chef as a post chef.
A plongeur, as it were. Oh, is that what it is? Plongeur. There you go. A washer-upper.
Right. What are we plunging into next? Next, we're going to make the alcoholic liquid that
we will eventually pour onto our apples. Okay. Which in this case, very, very late Victorian.
You know, the wine of choice for your late Victorian dude would be a nice German hop.
Really? Yeah. Always French wine. It's all new. It's good. I quite like it. But really,
what we want is a German hock. The kind of... Well, it's basically Blue Nun.
And you can use Blue Nun for this recipe. You can still get it. So we've got a bottle of hock here
and we're going to put that in our pan. So I've never heard of hock. It's a soft and fruity
Deutsche Landwein Rhein. So it's on the River Rhine. Yeah. It's not dissimilar to a Riesling
or a sort of Silvana. Those kind of things that we would go, oh, Alsatian wine. We like those.
Hock is just a little bit further along. Queen Victoria had a vineyard in the area named after
her. Really? It's really, really popular as a wine for the Victorians. And it still is slightly less
alcoholic than some wines as well because it's northern. So yeah, that one's 9%. So it's not
going to kill us. Where do you want this? I would like that in that pan, please. Along with 150
millilitres of water. I should say for those not watching this on the YouTube, but listening to it
on the podcast, we're both wearing very Christmassy jumpers. Mine is a National Museum of the Royal
Navy jumper. It's a Victorian. It has helicopters and ships. I'm sorry, am I putting this in here?
You are putting that in there. Listen to that, folks. That's a good sound. The whole thing?
Yeah. We then want cloves, ginger, mace, cinnamon and cardamom. So lots of spice. Let me just grab
some of these. Okay. Cloves, cinnamon. Yeah. About half. What's there? Some of that. Very
scientific. You're just throwing it all in. You know, the Victorians did measure things quite a
lot. But of course, if you knew what you were doing, you didn't need to. I guess the spirit
of Orsale is it's quite loose and it's quite relaxed. As I say, there really aren't any
written recipes before about the 18th century. And even when they are written down, they vary.
Yeah. And spices vary. Some people's spices are really, really strong. Some people's spices have
spent six months on a ship getting across from the Indias. I always think just use a bit more
if you're not sure that will do. Okay. That looks really disgusting. It's sort of light brown. Now
it's got various bits of spice floating in it. Lots of particles. There's a kind of scum
forming on top of it. It's good. It's Christmas. By the time you're drunk, you won't care anymore.
Great. We've created a muddy, scummy cocktail. Yeah. So chuck that on the heat. Ready? So tell
me what we're doing next. So what we're going to do now, once this gets to boiling point,
is we're effectively going to make a custard. A lot of sauces in the past were thickened with
egg yolks. That makes them very velvety and very lovely. And I mean, cornflour is easier,
but egg yolks are, I think, a nicer texture. It also shows how old the recipe is because using
egg yolks like that is quite an old fashioned thing. So I'm going to put one whole egg in there
and then egg yolk. It's not going to thicken it much. It'll be a sort of creme anglaise texture.
Oh yeah. Nothing but the best. Do you want me to heat that up? Not yet. No,
because otherwise we'll get scrambled eggs. So what we're going to do is fill that ladle full
while attempting to avoid all the whole spices. Pour it into here. So the kind of brownie liquid
is going a little bit thicker and a little more yellow when you add it to the egg yolk. Yeah.
So what we're going to end up with is a pale thorn liquid. I'm going to add a bit of heat
to this in a minute and just thicken it up slightly. And I'm just adding all of this.
Crazy boozy omelette. Yeah, really. So now, because I'm brave, I'm going to pour all the
spices in here, which we may live to regret if we're munching on them. We can sieve it
if you're particularly not fond of crunching on coriander seeds. So that's that bit.
So let's put this back into this one and then you can stir it gently. Very, very gently. Don't let
it boil. OK. Don't let it boil any more than that. And the idea is that we are making very,
very thin custard. Wow. Thin custard-y. Thin. Thin alcoholic custard. Just sounds amazing,
doesn't it? Yeah. And then once that is a nice thin custard, we're going to remove our apples
from the oven, put them in some of the big bowl, and then this gets poured on top. And the idea is
that everybody who's drinking your wassail gets an apple and some of your thin alcoholic custard,
which means that you're getting protein from the egg and you're getting spices,
which are obviously very good for you. Alcohol to kill off anything that's nasty and make you
feel fuzzy and delightful. And the apple, which is obviously one of your five a day.
So this is essentially Victorian health food. So it looks a lot better than it did. It looks
delicious. The sarcasm in your voice is a little unconvincing. So it's frothy on top.
It's a little bit thicker now. There's less floaters in it. Yeah. I mean, there's a little
bit of floater because the pan was a little bit hot when we poured that in. But yeah. So the
idea is you've got a bit of froth, which looks good. Yeah. Who doesn't want a bit of froth on
their food? Basically, you know, so modern. I mean, this is like an ale. It's like a hipster
ale. Yeah. And do you want to get, let me know when you want me to get the apples.
Well, let's see if they're cooked yet. Right. Let's have the apples.
Whoa. Hot in this here, I want to admit.
Oh, there we go. Perfect. Oh, I'm beginning to regret this Christmas jumper. That's hot. Yikes.
Right. Let's use this braoiselle. So these are nice and squidgy. Yeah. Look at that. Look at
that. Buttery juices. And then. Buttery and sugary and squidgy. The apples are just apps. They're
like, they're like, they've been turned into. Well, they're just the sponge like. It's great.
That's sort of like a tart tatin. Exactly. This is like a liquid tart tatin. Here we go.
I love tart tatin. There goes the good stuff. The liquid flowing down, submerging the apples.
And the colour of the liquid is more attractive now. As you say, it's almost like a kind of
Here we go. So apples are now floating. Think of the most wonderful Dickensian scene you can
imagine. Apples floating in a great dish with lovely warm liquid, giving off an aroma.
And there are loads of different versions of recipes like this with apples floating. You
get a thing called lambs wool because the apples disintegrate and look like lambs were on top.
And I mean, there's just infinite numbers of hot food recipes with apples in and some are
not. But the point is that they're all things that people might well want to drink at Christmas time.
Should we try it? I think we should. So I think we need some of this each.
It's a little bit of apple. Oh, you want to go for that squidgy apple? Yeah,
that's a good idea. You got your eye on that. Oh, thank you. So there's some squidgy apple
and some liquid spiced eggy hock. I think it's gone. The smell has gone from like
student mega mix anything into a big plastic bowl to like quite sophisticated Christmassy, I think.
Yeah, it's one of those things where people think of the spices that are in here as Christmas spices.
So cinnamon and nutmeg and coriander and those kind of things. And of course, they're not.
They are spices we use all the time, but also at this point in time, they would have been used
throughout the winter. But because now we associate those deep, dark flavors, things like Christmas
cake and mincemeat and spiced ales with Christmas, we've kind of lost this idea that these are just
warming spices. What do we shout when we drink this? Drink ale! Drink ale! Cheers! I spent far
too long with reenactors for that not to put a chill down my spine. That is absolutely delicious.
And I've already forgotten how much sugar. Yeah, I mean, your enamel is melting as you do it. But
and also, I do think the egg gives it that quite creamy, velvety texture without the need for
putting actual cream in it. Annie, when you were doing all that, I thought you were completely
bonkers. But turns out, you know what you're doing. Thank you. I mean, to be fair, it's
Castle's Dictionary of Cookery that needs to take the credit. But it's Christmas in a cup.
Feel ready to go. Right, what are we going to eat with our delicious wassail? Well, I think we've
got to go for mince pies, haven't we? The ultimate, the ultimate Christmassy snack. What are the actual
most venerable foods of Christmas? Oh, it is traditional. Yeah, I hate the word tradition.
Sorry, it is old. Old. Yes, it does go back a long way. So mincemeat, mince pies, Christmas pies,
as they were often known, although Christmas pies also meant something else, late medieval,
Tudor, etc. Was there meat in a mince pie? Yes. Oh, right. And we're starting with it. Oh,
we're actually going to do, okay. We are making Eliza Acton's mincemeat, which is from 1845.
And we are going to start with the most British of meats, which is, of course, roast beef. And
we want about half a pound, so 225 grams of new money, which is probably about half of that,
which you are going to mince up, please. Okay, stand by. So the original mincemeats were indeed
minced meat and other things. If you look at Tudor recipes, you've got about a third meat in there,
and then a third suet, and the other third is dried fruit. So I know, I obviously know this,
but the people listening or watching who don't know what suet is. Suet is the hard fat that sits
around the kidneys of a mammal. You have suet, I have suet, and cows have a lot of suet. So it's
usually cow suet. And what happens is you chop that fat up. And because it's a hard fat, it behaves
in really interesting ways. And one of the things it does is it gives a really lovely mouthfeel,
very velvety feel things when you eat them. Another thing is it makes very light pastry.
And another thing is that it melts very pleasingly. So it gives mincemeat that kind of
beautiful texture that you associate, I suppose, with mincemeat. Who discovered that? Okay. So,
because mincing is like, what, cutting it? Very, very fine dice. So we're going to chop that up
nice and small. A lot of the early mince pies used beef, some used mutton, there are versions with
fish and eggs for faster. So there's savoury, it was a savoury dish. It was a mixture. The
demarcation that we've got today between sweet and savoury wasn't one that was used so much in
the past because sugar was so expensive, certainly in the Tudor period, that it was used almost as a
spice. So, of course, in the 17th century, Britain started to colonise the West Indies,
brought in slave labour, that whole awful part of our history starts and sugar started to become
a bit cheaper. But at this point, so Tudor medieval mincemeats, very much sugar being
used as a spice. And what you see throughout the next two or three hundred years is the meat
quantity slowly dwindles. So by the time you get to the 19th century, which is the mincemeat we're
making, you've got very little meat left in them, just enough to give it a bit of a back note. And
by the 20th century, most mincemeats are meat free, but not vegetarian because they still have
serotonin. But this one, the original recipe makes about two and a half stone of mincemeat.
Two and a half stone? A toddler. And so it's a toddler of mincemeat, but probably only,
I don't know, a toddler's cup of liquid worth of meat. Two and a half stone of mincemeat,
a pound of beef. How are we doing here? Well, it depends on how coarse you want your meat,
really. I thought you were going to say that. Yeah. Let's go for chunky mincemeat. You know
what? I prefer it chunky anyway. Yeah. Chunky mincemeat is the way forward. The main thing
is that when we've mixed it all in, there's enough beef that you end up with a little bit of beef in
each and every single mincemeat. Oh, I see. Yeah. And the Tudors would have been all right because
they made quite large mince pies a lot of the time. So these were quite splendid things where
you would make a very ornate raised crust. And then to eat them, you'd take the lid off and just
often eat the inside. And then the crust would either be reused or distributed to the pork.
Then you get smaller mince pies coming in in the 17th century, although big ones didn't exist,
and so on and so forth. I mean, Fanny Craddock in the 60s was making big mince pies.
Was she? Yeah. She said that men preferred them. And while we're cooking this, I got no one,
no conversation about Christmas and the history of Christmas is complete without asking about
the reality of Oliver Cromwell. The Puritans during the Republic, did they ban Christmas?
No, they didn't ban Christmas. They did legislate against what they saw as its excesses. So there is
no legislation to ban mince pies, not least because mince pies were not actually associated
with Christmas as so much the whole festive season. What happened was that the Puritans
and especially the Scottish Presbyterians felt that Christmas was a really bad thing.
They did have a point. Christmas had become associated with rioting, with football,
with the working classes getting really drunk, having sex with loads of different people. I mean,
just Christmas had become... Sounds rubbish. Yeah, terrible. Very commercialised as well.
Too many orange sellers profiteering off the back of the demand for oranges.
And they felt that it was both pagan in that really it had just been adopted by the Christian
church and had never really changed, but at the same time papist. So all the bad things at once,
and let's not kind of examine that too much, but they felt it was generally bad.
So the trouble is it was liked a lot by the English, liked a lot as a celebration,
liked a lot as a thing to get through winter. And the Scottish didn't really celebrate it.
And the Presbyterians in Scotland, the Calvinists in Scotland in particular, really wanted to ban
it. The crooks point came in 1644 when Christmas fell on a day that was supposed to be not any
form of religious day. It was a normal day and all hell broke loose and there was loads of
legislation and everything was terrible. And people were told not to celebrate Christmas
and the shops were supposed to open. And it was a normal day. It was just a normal day.
And of course it wasn't. And there were riots and people being lynched. And it became a real
touch point and loads of pamphlets were published for and against Christmas. And it was a really,
really big cause for concern that it was almost as if all of the arguments over what was religion,
what was the Puritan state, what was the state of being, what was a moral person,
all of those kind of coalesced. So there's a lot of stuff written about Christmas and
Christmas became a focus beyond, in some ways, what it really was.
Culture wars.
Yeah, well, exactly. It was cancelled. So, no, there were incidences of some people being beaten
up by soldiers. There were diarists on Evening With One who tried to celebrate Christmas and
ended up in the cells. It was all very, yes, there was, yes, there wasn't. But either way,
we restored it in 1660 and then everyone forgot about it for 100 years. And all the bon-tons
went, oh, I don't think I like it after all. Contrary as ever.
Right.
In the bowl.
Is that all right? That meat has been diced with an inch of its life.
Good dicing. And now we want to put in some currants and some raisins.
OK, a handful.
The lot.
All of it?
Well, pow. That's probably not enough, might be over a pound. Marvellous. Save a few if you can
nibble on. And the same with those.
Whoa.
Yeah, good old raisins. Then we want some peel. This is very much a rich person's dish.
Oh, yeah. Is this the whole thing going in?
Yeah, all of it.
Yeah, you couldn't just, this is a lot of nice ingredients from all over the world.
Also slightly under half the recipe.
Half?
Well, you didn't have a smooth bathtub, so.
I didn't get in the bathtub.
Then we're going to mince up, I think probably about three apples.
OK, one, two, three. Like really mince, like smush them up.
Yeah. And the glory of mincemeat, of course, is you don't need to cook it.
So it really is just a question of chopping and throwing things in a bowl.
And then you've got this glorious, enormous amount of stuff that you can do all sorts of
things with. And today we only ever really make mincemeat tarts, but lots and lots of
different things you can do with it. Mincemeat pudding with loads of suet, mincemeat omelette,
which you can then set on fire, which I have to say is another excellent way to start Christmas
day. Mincemeat ice cream is quite good as well.
What kind of other mincemeats might go in the pie?
Well, anything really. On meaty days, you'd have beef, you'd have mutton.
You could do anything if you wanted to. Calf was very, very popular, so veal.
And then if you were rich, you might have something like sirloin.
But if you were poor, you might have something like a
carb's foot or tripe. There are tripe mincemeats.
They're not great, but mainly because there's not that much else in there.
So I'm going to just grate the zest of these two lemons as well to go in.
You also got mincemeats for fast days. So you also had egg-based mincemeats and
fish-based mincemeats. Don't be silly.
Mackerel mincemeat. Well, it's not.
I know it sounds kind of awful and I will be fair.
It's not amazing. But of course, there's so little fish in
there that really all you taste is the spice. So the fish is just for texture?
Texture and also wealth and prestige. Again, we have to remember, I suppose,
that people today talk about how they would struggle to be vegetarian in the past because
there wasn't any vegetarian food. And actually, that's not quite true because
so many people couldn't afford meat. So depending on who you read, estimates
are anything between 70% and 95% of the population largely eating a vegetarian diet most of the time
because meat was simply really, really expensive. So eating something like this with just a tiny
bit of meat in really is saying, well, hey, I could put loads in.
I don't have to. But look at how wealthy I am with this spice,
with this important dried fruit, with this beef and then later on as well with alcohol.
So this really is just an incredibly prestigious dish for its time.
I mean, this is just one among many dishes on the table that would have screamed wealth.
So you've got all that roast meat. You've got your turkey, your swan,
your peacock, whatever else is going on. You've got a whole tradition as well around
pork cookery, brawn, which in the early part of history was kind of half a pig,
like literally a vertical slice down the pig that had been rolled and boiled.
And then, of course, the boar's head, which we sing about in the Boar's Head Carol,
which was also difficult. A boar's head being a pig's head.
Well, boar's head was a boar's head until we ate all the boars.
And then once we'd driven the boars to extinction, if you're really wealthy or Queen Victoria,
who also was very wealthy, you could get a boar brought in from Germany.
But if you weren't wealthy enough to get hold of a boar, you would do it with a pig's head,
which you would make look like a boar and you would tart it up.
I mean, it's a sort of two week cook, this thing.
And there are recipes in Victorian cookery books for how you get your pig's head.
You have to get it cut back at the second vertebrae.
You then bone it. You brine it in red wine for two weeks,
turning the skin every day. You sew the skin shut.
You stuff it. I mean, it's amazing, these things.
You then swaddle it. You boil it for seven hours in more red wine.
You take it out. It looks, having made it, awful at that point.
And then you pipe it with lard or you put pastry across its forehead
or you put your family crest on it. You perk its ears up.
I mean, it looks incredible when you've finished it,
but it is so much work and it feeds a lot of people.
Normally, at least by the Edwardian period, you would get a caterer to do it.
There were rumours that people would cheat and use soot to colour it and things like that.
So it's one of those things where you had to have a reputable boar's head supplier, really.
Typical Queen Victoria importing a German boar and boning it.
I'm literally on fire at the moment.
I think the boar's head was a bit tastier than Albert, though, don't you?
It's the tiniest little topping knife I've ever used.
Ding, ding, ding, ding, ding, ding. There we go. Come on.
All that and off colour jokes about Prince Albert.
Yep, history gags.
Right, so some mincing skills are on fire.
Don't make me mince anything else.
OK, what's next? Lemon, including skin?
Everything. So these have been boiled.
One of the really, really lovely things in the past that we just don't do a lot now
is boiling entire lemons, mushing them up, making them into stuff.
So there's an amazing 18th century lemon pudding recipe from Rest Park, actually.
And it's basically lemon curd, but to make the lemon curd,
you mash up two lemons and it is the most lemony thing ever.
You know, you have a lot of lemon tarts and you just go, oh, this is so insipid.
There are recipes for pure lemon mincemeat,
which is just chopped up lemons and those other spices, and they are pretty amazing.
When you go for your recipes, do you go to like posh houses,
archives of posh houses or where are they all kept?
So not often in the archives of posh houses, because a lot of the houses,
when the families gave their documents to archives,
they took out all the stuff they thought wasn't interesting.
So they've kept in all the things about Lord so-and-so buying furniture
and all his hunt books and left out all the stuff about where they bought milk from.
So it's a mixture, really.
Lots of manuscript books.
There's a lot online.
The Wellcome Collection has got some really, really good stuff online.
Printed cookery books, although, of course, they give you a snapshot
and you're never quite certain anything was ever cooked.
Newspapers are quite good as well for the 20th century.
There's a lot of stuff hidden in the kind of reader's ask sections
of those kind of things.
That is mushy now, isn't it?
That is excellent. You can put that in now.
And then we're going to add in a little bit of salt
and some nutmeg and some ginger, all of which is in there.
So let's put in...
Nutmeg?
Yeah.
Straight from the spice islands.
Ginger.
Straight from somewhere.
I don't know.
China.
Some other places too.
Okay.
And we're going to put in probably about two...
Not the sugar again.
God, this is not good, is it?
Well, it's only once a year.
Well, it isn't for the Victorians.
Anyone else it would be.
Mince pies eaten throughout the winter season.
Okay, folks listening at home.
I've just put a huge amount of sugar in here.
I've got to be honest.
You can no longer see the ingredients.
There's so much sugar covering them all.
Yeah.
Okay.
And stop.
See how exact that was?
Very exact.
I'm going to put in some sherry.
Sherry.
Our sale's getting a bit chilly.
And then some brandy.
Yeah, get the brandy going in there.
Napoleon cognac.
Right.
You can use any booze for this actually.
You can use...
I've done it with port.
I've done it with ginger wine.
I've done it with all sorts of things.
So then if you give that a good old mix.
Mix with my broken spoon.
Oh my gosh.
See, when you mix it, you realise it's not that much sugar.
No, not at all.
Not at all.
That's right.
Doesn't that look so much nicer than a modern mincemeat?
There's no brown goo coming off it.
I agree.
This does look really delicious.
The extraordinary mixture of meat, currants, sultanas, raisins.
And apples.
Oh, is the suet coming in?
Yeah.
And this is the what?
The fat around the something lining?
The hard fat around the kidneys.
Although this is the modern version of suet,
which is the processed hard fat around kidneys.
So we haven't had to devein it.
Do you ever think when you're studying your amazing recipes,
like the things that humans have tried?
I mean, you know, who thought mix this with that
and rip that out of there and stick that in there?
I mean, it's extraordinary, isn't it?
But my squeamish factor is quite low, I think.
Partly because people often say,
oh, I would never eat that.
It's absolutely disgusting.
Or whatever it is.
And actually, I've tried some really awful modern things.
And you sort of think, don't laugh at our ancestors or think yuck,
because some of the things that we eat now are just.
Oh, it's a matter of respecting them that they worked it out.
Yeah, yeah.
One of the nastiest things I've ever eaten was a vegan mozzarella,
which was made of rice starch and didn't behave anything
like mozzarella should have done and tasted vaguely of rice.
Vegan cheese is rubbish.
Yeah.
But I'm afraid that is a fact.
Listeners, I love a vegan burger.
Yeah.
Vegan cheese.
Then we haven't got there yet.
It's OK.
No, and I think there's a really, really good vegan food around
that doesn't involve having to make something
that's essentially not vegan now to vegan ingredients.
That's right.
It's like paper straws.
We're just not there yet.
We're doing it because it's good for the environment,
but we have to be honest about it.
OK, what's next?
Next, we're going to put them into pastry cases.
Let's do it.
And I thought instead of doing big ones like the Tudors
or little raised pies, which would be a lot of work,
we would go full on Victorian and use puff pastry.
So in the miracle that is the modern world.
It comes pre-wrapped.
It does provide it.
What I would say is if you're buying it,
always, always buy the stuff that's all butter.
Otherwise, it tastes horrible.
But this is conveniently pre-flattened.
Very much in the spirit of the Victorians,
I think, to have cheats and short flats.
And what we're going to do,
would you like to cut out the pastry
or do you want to butter the tin?
I'll cut the pastry out.
Go for it.
We've got...
It's my grandma.
We made cookies every Christmas.
A mug which should be big enough to do the sides
and then the glass should be big enough to do the lids.
Get ready.
These are going to be quite large mince pies,
but then I think that's kind of good.
That's great.
Trying to get this thing out here is not easy.
There you go.
You know, it's the problem with using mugs,
but I think this is kind of quite a nice impromptu.
Speed buttering.
So what is it?
What's going on with the Victorians?
Why do we really...
Why is it we seem to think
so Christmas goes into overdrive in that they're about time?
There are lots of different factors really,
but what you see is around the 1840s,
there's a real feeling of the idea
that Christmas has kind of lost the plot.
It's been dwindling.
The Georgians weren't particularly into Christmas,
or at least the fashionable society
wasn't particularly into Christmas.
They thought it was a bit of a dreary thing
to kind of have to visit people
and it's winter and fine with the meals
and the feasting and all that stuff.
But the rest of it,
a bit sort of plebeian and excuse to get drunk.
And it started dwindling.
So you see the number of bank holidays in a year dwindle.
You see the 12 days dwindle down.
Obviously, it's the Industrial Revolution
or the first phase of it.
So there's not so many people
needing to sort of sit on their arse
all of the whole of December.
But now you've got the factories
and obviously also agrarian husbandry has moved on.
So you can now keep your cattle
a lot more throughout winter and things like that.
So there's this feeling in the 1840s
that Christmas has lost its way
and that we're going to lose it.
It's going to go the way of all things.
And lots and lots of people at that point
are saying this is not right.
Christmas should be about hospitality.
There's a real sense of nostalgia.
You know, today we're all about,
oh, the Victorians, that's what,
that's when Christmas was great.
The Victorians thought it was great in the Tudor period.
So they decided that actually it should be put back
to what they thought of as Christmas,
which was about hospitality and charity.
And you didn't want to bring poor people into your house
for like to steal something,
but you did want to give to charity
and that kind of thing.
And I suppose today we think of Charles Dickens
and Prince Albert as having
single-handedly invented Christmas
because those are the iconic figures
that are always talked about.
But it's not true.
Dickens was one of many writers who talked about it.
He was just one of the most popular.
And Albert gets all of the glory
for inventing the Christmas tree,
which was a German tradition.
It was present in this country already
in the shape of German bakeries.
Queen Charlotte, who had a yew tree in the 1780s at Kew.
Let's not give any more credit to Albert than he needs
and definitely give no more credit to Dickens
than he deserves,
which is less than he probably should get.
But I'm not a fond of Dickens.
Are you not?
No, he writes such terrible women.
Don't forget to leave,
oh, you've got a little bit left to put some lids on.
Well, I'm going to make a lid now.
I'm going to do lids.
Right, well, let's put some mincemeat in there in that case.
So you're loading the mince into the pies.
I am.
Shall I put a lid on?
Yeah, I've got a terrible habit
of overstuffing my mince pies, by the way.
So just place the lid like that?
Yeah, you get it.
There you go.
Now, so this is all classes,
because you mentioned there's different things
for different classes in terms of what's going in the mince pies.
This is quite a...
This is a kind of middle class recipe, really.
I mean, there's a lot of booze, a lot of spice,
a lot of meat in this, and it's quite nice meat.
And Eliza Acton's very much aiming at a middle class audience.
She was really, I suppose, in some ways,
the quote, unquote, real Mrs. Beaton.
As in, everybody always thinks Mrs. Beaton
was this iconic Victorian cook
who wrote about what to do for the middle class housewife.
But most of Beaton's recipes
were plagiarized from Eliza Acton.
And Eliza Acton's are really good recipes.
So this is solidly kind of middle class gentry level.
If you're working class,
you would probably buy your mince pies
because you wouldn't have an oven.
And you might well buy cheap ones with tri-pin.
You're probably going to have a goose
rather than turkey or beef or venison or game
or partridge or swan or bustard or heron on Christmas Day.
And if you're upper class,
you're going to have everything in the world on your table.
So meals at that point were really very, very large.
And you would expect to have your normal meal pattern,
really, at Christmas.
And it wasn't, again, it's not just about Christmas Day.
A lot of Victorian families would entertain
at the beginning of December
and they would have shooting parties
and they would entertain throughout that Christmas period.
And then Christmas Day may well have been just a family.
So it's really, that emphasis we put on one day
is very Victorian.
And it's quite late Victorian as well.
It's the Victorians that rename plum pudding,
Christmas pudding, for example.
And it's the Victorians that decide that 12th cake,
which used to be eaten on 12th night,
should be Christmas cake.
And they are responsible really
for giving us this obsession
with everything being about the 25th of December.
A big day.
They gave us the shopping sales as well.
So really, there's a lot not to thank them for.
So we're coming now to the end.
But the aristocratic tables,
I always think, have got a lot to love.
And obviously they have
because they're incredibly wealthy.
But you would get soup and fish
and loads of different meats
and loads of different vegetable dishes
and a huge amount of choice.
And one of the things that's really interesting
about Christmas's past is how varied the meals were.
Bearing in mind that now we are effectively told
that we should all be eating turkey
and Brussels sprouts and pigs in blankets,
which are really quite modern.
And there's not a lot of variety.
I mean, there is variety,
but it's not what we're shown in the media.
You look at recipes,
you look at menus,
even in the 1930s,
and they're suggesting beef and Yorkshire pudding
or a chicken or whatever else it is.
So, you know, I always think,
stop being told what to eat.
If we really liked turkey,
wouldn't we eat it on more than just the 25th of December?
I'm a weird guy.
I love turkey in all trimmings.
So you actually like to-
I would eat it in August.
If someone said,
let's do a big Christmas lunch in August,
I'd bring it on.
Why not do it in August then?
I should.
Because it's a huge pain in the ass, that's why.
Well, roast dinners are terrible.
One of the interesting things I think
is that we insist on making these roast dinners.
Let's pop those in the oven.
Right, let's go.
This is the big moment.
Here we go.
It's going in the oven.
Give it 10 minutes, 15 minutes.
10 minutes.
Yeah, drink some more wassail and relax.
Wassail!
Cold wassail.
Slightly loses its-
It's a little bit more like cold sick, isn't it?
Yeah, a little bit sicky.
Yeah.
We have got warm wassail, everyone.
Don't panic.
Okay, 15 minutes is up.
Smells ready to me.
You're going to look in there.
It's exciting, isn't it?
Nothing more Christmassy than getting-
Oh my goodness me!
Folks, these look like little mince pie volavoles.
That is amazing!
I thought they'd be a bit rubbish, tell the truth.
People make them with shortcrust and that's fine,
but there's nothing, I don't think there's anything to beat
crunching through all the puff layer
and then hitting that really dense, beautiful mincemeat within it.
I am salivating at that perfect-
I mean you just are.
Huge!
But then, yeah, you can't have a huge mince pie at Christmas.
When can you?
And you see how many people,
do you know how many people usually come to our History Hit recordings?
Zero people.
Do you know how many people are here today?
Lots of people on History Hit, do you know why?
Because you're cooking these pies.
Christmas mince pies!
Come on, it's one of the best things for that Christmas.
Oh my goodness.
Right, we're going to try a pie.
Watch out, they will be really hot.
I can't resist that, I can't stop myself.
And I'm just giving you the warning that when you burn your mouth,
I'm not responsible.
It's really hot.
It's really hot, let's just wait.
It's got a lot of sugar and dry fruit in there.
Yeah, it's molten.
Oh, that's the most delicious thing I've ever eaten in my life.
It's not the texture, it's great, isn't it?
Meaty mincemeat has got depth of flavour, texture, complexity.
That's just, it's a different ballgame.
You know, it's like instant coffee versus, you know, real coffee.
There's a space in most people's lives for instant coffee,
but when you have the real thing, yeah.
Wow, Annie, you have changed my Christmas from this day forward.
Like, you're like the ghosts of Christmas past, present and future.
I'm going to eat these mince pies, I'm going to drink or sail.
If you could change one thing about Christmas, what would it be?
I'd stop it starting in August and finishing on December 25th
and I would have it once more start very close to Christmas
and go through to the epiphany.
And then we would all celebrate the 6th with 12th cake and friends
and it would be really lovely.
And then we would go away,
but it wouldn't be this long drawn out torture that it is now.
Much more fun, proper midwinter.
Yeah, 12 days of brilliance that burns really hot and bright and stops.
You've introduced me to a sale of these proper mince pies.
What would you bring back from Christmas's past?
Food wise, I would bring back 12th cake instead of Christmas cake
because Christmas cake isn't something that a lot of people know when to eat.
They like it, but they're not sure what to do with it.
Whereas if you have it on 12th night,
it's a clearly defined moment to eat it.
You can look forward to it and it brings Christmas to a really lovely close.
So Christmas doesn't peter out with a whimper,
but goes out with a proper ban.
So you would have the 12 days of Christmas reinstated?
I would have the 12 days of Christmas reinstated and I'd forget all this.
I would ban Christmas going into their shops before about the 20th.
All these Christmas trees going up on December the 1st.
Malarkey.
What is this?
The need will drop by about the 13th,
especially in central heated houses.
I'd also bring back a range of flavours
and stop us being so obsessed with one set of dishes on Christmas day.
Eat mince pies throughout the whole season
and have 15 different types of mincemeat
and drink wassail and, you know,
have loads of different types of food on the table.
And I think Christmas should be what we want it to be
and not what we're told it should be.
Get rid of the shoulds.
Have only what we want.
Thank you for coming on the show.
What is your book called?
So everyone can live this out in their own kitchen.
It's called At Christmas We Feast.
And you're right, At Christmas We Feast.
And we will, thanks to you.
