Four Antique Smallswords

Rune Slicer
2 followers
2 Video Views·Jan 26, 2026
A comparison between four different types of antique smallswords
G'day viewers. So we're back with another antique sword video. In this case we're going to be looking
at four different kinds of essentially small swords. The reason for doing this is basically
I've been asked for a sort of a flat bladed small sword as recommended by Sir William Hope in New
Method for ages and ages and I happened to come across one in an antique store just the other week
and so I snapped it up and I thought this would be a good opportunity to compare four different
kinds of essentially small swords and I'm going to be joined by my friend Dan. Two of the
swords are his, two of them are mine and he knows a lot more about them than I do from the arms
collecting point of view and so we're going to be talking about the interesting aspects of each
sword design. So we're going to look at some antique small swords. The first three of them
are all around about the same age that is sort of 1640 to 1650. So let's start with this one
because this is very much a very typical small sword that you get pretty well all the way up
into this 18th century. So tell us about it Dan. So this is English, it's from the 1640s
and the hilt and the wire, I'm just trying to let you have a good look at that, is all silver and
it's all done in this sort of cut and chased kind of fashion so that when it was new and was sort of
highly polished you could wear it to a ball or just even wear it out and all of those little
facets cut into the silver there would catch the light and it would shine as if diamonds were put
into it. It's exceptionally light because it's, I don't know if you can see there, the hilt is
pierced all the way through there, the pommel's pierced all the way through there, it weighs...
It weighs 350 grams. Yeah nothing, absolutely nothing. It's got a sort of a very classic kind
of epee blade on it, it's very very stiff, there is absolutely no flex in it at all.
Yeah just a generally very nice example. Yes very nice. Now this one from about the same era but as
you can see has a much much wider blade so could we call this a Kalishimard? Close to, I would say
if not it's very very close. Yeah. It's wide enough that you could probably stop something
that had a bit more cut to it, something like a spadroon or maybe a transitional rapier. Yeah
and it weighs 450 grams or 100 grams heavier than that which in terms of percentage of the weight
is quite a lot. Yeah. The fittings are again pierced, you can see that ricasso bit there
that's hollow, the pommel also hollow. The guard's pierced all the way through. The guard's pierced
all the way through there as well and it sits in the hand absolutely beautifully with that sort of
bulbous bit there. If I turn around this way my thumb just sits there in exactly the the place
I want to hold it. It's really really nice and we think this one might be German
but yeah I'm not too sure, it could be German, it could be anywhere on the continent really
with those kind of fittings. Yeah again also incredibly stiff, no flex at all
and if I hold them both even though this is lighter honestly you don't feel it.
No. The difference really comes in when you have to wear it all day
and that's really what a lot of these were going for. They want to be light because you're
going to put it on your hip and walk around all day. And not do all that much dueling I presume.
No probably not especially with this you're probably not wearing this because you intend to
use it. If you have to you can but it's about looking good. Yeah whereas this one I think
it's a much plainer set of fittings so and with that really broad practical blade I think this
was probably intended for fighting. It's interesting as well when you look at the
part of arms there they're quite large you can very comfortably pass a finger through.
When you look at these ones here I physically can't, not even close. Not that you should be
putting your finger through, McBain says don't do that. No but absolutely if I'm holding that
they are just there to space that shell. Yeah so your thumb does not bang into the shell.
The other thing about this one is the the blade's shorter than that that's nearly 31. This one's
28 from there but I get about another inch from that large part of arms there which makes the
the difference in length trivial. So those are the first two and they really are classic
small swords. Yeah you'd see them all about Europe at that point. Now Sir William Hope in his
later more experienced period actually says he doesn't like Kalishimard blades.
In fact he's not particularly fussed about triangular small swords at all. He says what
you want is you want a rapier with a good edge so he wants a blade that you can still cut with
and he also says that you want what he calls a poor man's blade that is something that is flat
and flexible so it's less likely to snap. I've been after one of these for a long time and I
found one in an antique shop not all that long ago and I snapped it up and this is it here. So
it's about 33 inches in the blade so it's quite long and as you can see the blade is
a fairly thick hexagonal diamond section thing all the way up to there and it does
have a reasonable amount of flex so it's not going to snap should I hit
the bible in somebody's breast pocket while I'm fighting with it. The fittings are solid
okay there's some piercing on the shell but the rest of the fittings this is just solid silver
and it weighs 550 grams which is more than either of the other two but it feels even
heavier than that it feels a little bit droopy. Now obviously you're not going to take anybody's
limbs off with that but it does have enough of an edge that I could slice somebody across the face
and effectively cut them open which is really or hit them on the hand and make them drop their
sword which is really all that Hope is fussed about so this is very much the sort of thing
that Hope would approve of. Do you have anything to add to that Dan? If you were to get some
calipers out we'd find that this shell here is actually substantially thick it's the first
thing I noted on when I picked it up. Yes that is quite a heavy shell and it's interesting so
we'll just talk a little bit about the cosmetics here. You'll notice that it's entirely plain this
side but if you turn it inside you can see again that sort of all of those cut silver
sort of sections all those little dots that's again the exact same one style as we saw before
where that the polish will make it shine beautifully the reason for this is when you
wear it it's pointing up so you don't care what's underneath the shell it speaks to the fact that
this is a probably a cheaper one you don't bother decorating the bit no one's ever going to see you
only decorate the bit people will see. Yes and speaking of wearing it one of the coolest things
about this sword is that it came with at least a partial scabbard so I'm going to put it back in
the scabbard so we can show that off. So that's the scabbard it's wood possibly bamboo I think so
yeah covered in what appears to be paper or vellum maybe I think it's vellum it's very very thin
it's designed to be as light as possible yeah it's not structural at all because it's only ever
going to sit over a sword yeah and it has sadly lost a few inches off the end pop through but
nonetheless we have a scabbard and the coolest thing about that is that it's got this thing
what's what is does that thing have a name it might have a specific name I just call it a clip
and these were very very common so you you do see I think in some of um Angelo senior's
illustration they're wearing them on a baldrick but if you look at a lot of art that depicts
gentlemen of the period they're wearing a very simple clip like this and a chain which is longer
at one end than it is at the other so that it'll sit at that sits at that angle so if it's sitting
on your hip as Dan was saying all you can see is the fancy bit there you can't see there yeah and
this clip thing clips on your belt just really really easily it's such a fantastic invention I'm
amazed it wasn't more widely used and we'll we'll insert a little bit of video of me doing that in
a minute yeah there you go so here's the belt clip thing um which is curved and has this big thing
there and you just slot it over your belt or into your pants and this bit sits over the belt and
locks the whole thing in so it's not going anywhere it's not going to come loose or fall off
um and it's fantastic it's such a cool way of carrying your sword um and should you need to
take it off and leave it at the door because it's that sort of establishment very very easy to do
that to take that off and hand it over or hang it up in your hallway when you get home um so
excellent very cool um you don't have the original these these are the original as well
those little um hooks original really there you are original look at that so you can still buy
those in the hardware store today yeah a little bit of tiny little bit of spring steel in there
which you may or may not be able to see so you can you can just flip it in and off push it in
and off that's it there you are well I am going to be more happy and confident about using those
scabbards in the future now that I know their period yeah um and there's an extra little ring
there I wonder what that was for I think the ring between this one and that one is broken
right and they've just they've just shortened it it's not normally that short on that right yeah
I say yes it probably has because you can see little ring big ring little ring big yeah but
you could probably replace that I probably could this is not really video content um so this is
the sort of hope approved small sword um when I compare it to the other two you really do feel
that it now has weight um and so I would be more confident in parrying something more sword like
with this than I would with even the Kalishimard because it's just got a lot more presence
and it's got it's got enough extra weight that it is now just a little bit slower so if you start
parrying too widely you would lose control of this very quickly it's not like the other two
that weight essentially nothing you can flick them around with your fingers um willy-nilly
and not worry about that sort of thing um so a rapier with a good edge the last one we've got
is also an edged weapon so what the hell is this thing um so this one's a bit weird uh I
essentially I bought it and it was described as a master at arms sword uh which is a sort of a naval
rank um basically I don't believe they had a patent sword so you could kind of have whatever
you want um the the blade you might be able to make it out there it says I'll try and get it to
focus for my country and king we'll get a nicer photograph of that um so we know this was these
exact kind of blades are marked to runkle in many cases so we know it's beginning in the polionic
wars um this is ebony with uh there's little steel bars in there which have just tarnished
down to match the ebony uh and a sort of a steel hilt there would have originally had a chain that
went from this little ring that little gap there with text as a knuckleball presumably sort of
they're not they're not really going to stop anything um but that's the kind of the fashion
at the time b did sort of chains um but really it's a it's a nice kind of spadroon-esque sort of
cut and thrust it's got a little bit more cut than maybe that uh small sword that you just saw
it's not going to take off arms but it is very comfortable to fence with in a forward weight
like we expect to sort of see small swords used yeah at the end of that yeah and it really in
the hand it doesn't feel that much different to that one uh the distribution of the weight is
further back which makes it actually feel a little bit more balanced than the uh
yeah the earlier small sword um and it is yeah a much more effective cutting blade you would do
more damage with that it's also much thicker at the ricasso um and so down at the forte there this
is much thicker it's a diamond section all the way up and the handle is a lot more substantial
the thing i find about this is the handle is really large even for a sword of its kind of
yes size but it would give me a lot of confidence parrying sabers even trying to move a pike out of
the way which is what you're looking at in the georgian navy a cutlass or something like that
yeah i would be confident taking it up against it um it does have a fair bit of flex i'm not going
to flex it because of how sort of corroded this section of the blade is unfortunately wasn't
but yeah it's a sort of the end of that kind of cutting small sword yes
very nice i'm sure hope would approve yeah it's basically what you see yeah
yes it's very very shearing sword you just want a bigger hilt yeah more bars more bars yeah
is there anything else you want to add i don't know are we going to do the which one would you
pick if you had to kill somebody all right after that um sorry which one would you pick if you had
kill somebody i if i look it depends what they're taking um if i'm on a ship this every time this
uh because my as beautiful as the um the silver hilted small sword is it's not stopping stopping
a cutlass or a saber um but if i have to go to a nice ball and i want to impress all of the
the young ladies that's not it i'm going to have the nice silver looking thing and look very
impressive fair enough yeah no i think i agree with you and and hope in that you know a nice
shearing sword is pretty well on the par with the small sword as far as thrusting goes but you've
also got cuts which are going to be extremely useful in a practical sense so yeah no i agree
i would have one of those two and i would have this one over the other two for precisely the
same reason being able to smack somebody on their hands and make them cut their fingers off that
would be useful yeah it's a pretty simple question if you want to live right here's the thing that
i hope you found that interesting um i've learned a lot so now i know a lot more about
my small sword than i did before we did the video um so thanks for joining
