Zhang Youxia's Alive or Dead? 5 Versions of Rumors! Xi Faces Three Crises

China Insider
192 followers
310 Video Views·Feb 26, 2026
Is Xi Jinping backing down, or preparing to strike a decisive blow?
The apparent downgrading of the charges against Zhang Yuxia has sparked a wave of speculation.
At the same time, a flood of conflicting rumors about Zhang's fate, ranging from a life-threatening
hunger strike, to a secret execution, to claims that he remains safe in Beijing, has only
deepened the sense of turmoil within the power circles of Zhongnanhai.
If Zhang is still alive, Xi may have time to consolidate and legitimize his position.
But if he is already dead, a political earthquake could be imminent.
Where is this life-and-death struggle at the top of the Chinese Communist Party headed?
And who truly holds the initiative?
Let's break it down in today's program.
Is Xi Jinping backing down?
A source said to be close to the military has revealed that Xi Jinping's handling
of Zhang Yuxia appears to have softened.
On February 24th, the Epoch Times cited insider information claiming that Xi intends to address
a political problem through criminal proceedings, seeking to prosecute Zhang on charges of buying
and selling official positions, rather than the previous accusation of seriously trampling
on and undermining the responsibility system of the chairman of the Central Military Commission.
By doing so, Xi would effectively separate political retribution from judicial procedure,
allowing the case to move forward more quickly on a technical level.
I have no way of independently verifying this information, but if it is true, it would mean
that the political characterization of Zhang Yuxia's case has been significantly downgraded.
According to commentator Li Muyan, within the Chinese communist system, the buying and
selling of official posts is widespread and hardly considered an extraordinary crime.
Across sectors and at every level in China, the practice is nearly ubiquitous, nothing
new or shocking.
However, the charge of seriously trampling on and undermining the responsibility system
of the chairman of the Central Military Commission is of an entirely different nature.
It is an extremely grave political accusation.
Among all political charges within the Chinese Communist Party, this classification ranks
at the very top, tantamount to internal betrayal of the regime.
It could be described as a political death sentence.
Therefore, if Zhang Yuxia is prosecuted on charges related to selling positions, it would
suggest that Xi Jinping is raising the stick high, but bringing it down lightly, reducing
what was fundamentally a challenge to his personal authority into an ordinary anti-corruption
case.
Xi may be using bribery and the sale of offices as the primary legal avenue simply for procedural
convenience.
Yet, given that no one within the party, government, or military has publicly expressed support
for Zhang's arrest, it cannot be ruled out that Xi has been forced to take a step back.
Whichever scenario proves accurate, it points to the same conclusion.
Xi Jinping appears to be in a difficult position, and the internal power struggle within the
Chinese Communist Party has escalated to a life-or-death confrontation.
Is Zhang Yuxia alive or dead?
Five mysterious versions of his fate.
Over the past two days, information concerning Zhang Yuxia has continued to leak through
various channels, and the momentum is building again.
The central question remains the same.
Is he alive or dead?
Let's first review the different revelations and narratives, then examine what meaningful
conclusions, if any, can be drawn.
The first disclosure surfaced on February 22nd.
Hu Liren, a Shanghai-born businessman now living in the United States, stated on his
personal media program that Zhang Yuxia had directly resisted the investigation against
him.
Zhang reportedly insisted that the accusations brought by Xi Jinping were fabricated, refusing
to confess and launching a hunger strike in protest.
According to Hu's Beijing sources, Zhang has been forcibly tube-fed and is being kept
alive through intravenous infusions.
His condition, they claim, is critical.
That same day, several other overseas independent media outlets also reported on Zhang's fate.
Tan Jingyuan cites military insiders.
One version claims that Zhang Yuxia and Liu Zhenli were arrested on January 20th at the
Central Party School and secretly executed within a single day.
According to this account, they were attending an opening ceremony at the party school when
agents from the Ministry of Public Security detained them and escorted them to a secret
interrogation site in Beijing.
The arrest allegedly bypassed all internal party and judicial procedures.
That very night, both men were reportedly executed in what was described as a black
box operation.
No documentation, no public notice, not even formal records of the transfer of their bodies.
Their families have allegedly received no official confirmation and have not been permitted
to view the remains.
The report claims the news has caused shockwaves within the military, with some theater command
leaders privately expressing dissatisfaction, leading to shaken morale.
There are also reports that Zhang Yuxia's son, Zhang Shen, issued an urgent appeal stating
that his father died during interrogation at a Ministry of Public Security facility
and demanding that Xi Jinping authorize an investigation and allow the family to reclaim
the body.
The purported letter asserts that prior to his detention, Zhang was in good health and
stable spirits, carrying out his duties as usual.
The sudden news of his death in custody, without official notice, medical records, or family
presence, prompted a call for a high-level investigative team composed of the Central
Commission for Discipline Inspection, the National Supervisory Commission, and the Military
Discipline Inspection Commission to review the entire process from arrest to death.
The letter also questions the legality of the arrest, arguing that, as a military officer
and vice chairman of the Central Military Commission, Zhang should have been handled
by military authorities, rather than detained by civilian public security organs.
A third version comes from overseas democracy activist Sheng Shui.
She said she received an urgent call from a senior insider who told her that no one
would see Zhang Yuxia again because he was no longer here.
When asked whether the death resulted from torture, suicide, or other causes, the source
replied that the details were unclear.
He only knew that an internal notice had circulated stating Zhang was gone and that more information
might emerge in a few days.
The source also hinted cryptically that one injection would settle it, implying the possibility
of lethal injection, though he admitted this was speculation.
Overall, while the details differ, these versions share a common thread.
Each suggests that Zhang Yuxia is facing grave danger, either critically ill or already secretly
executed.
However, as is often the case, an opposing narrative has also emerged.
On February 23, commentator Kai Shengkun said that according to his sources, Zhang Yuxia
has not left Beijing.
After his arrest, he was allegedly detained at a secret location in the capital under
dual supervision by the Beijing Garrison Command and the Central Guard Bureau.
He is said to be completely secure, in normal health, and with his family unaffected.
What makes this noteworthy is that the Wall Street Journal had previously reported that
Zhang's son had been detained, a claim that contradicts the family unaffected version.
All sources agree on one point.
The incident occurred on January 20 at the Central Party School.
The discrepancies lie in the details regarding Zhang's life or death and the status of
his family.
Commentator Tang Zhengyuan argues that if Zhang Yuxia is still alive, that would work
in Xi's favor.
It would give him time to get on the train first and buy the ticket later.
To complete the formal procedures, extract a confession, and weaken the anti-Xi faction.
But if Zhang is already dead, Xi would face at least three major problems.
The first problem, no confession.
Without one, it would be difficult to legitimize the case.
Merely leaking information twice to the Wall Street Journal and then having it circulate
back into China would not be persuasive within party ranks.
Moreover, if a senior official is arrested and then suddenly dies within days, before
any formal investigation or intervention by the Central Commission for Discipline Inspection,
it would be extremely difficult to retroactively fix the paperwork.
Without procedural legitimacy, Xi would struggle to regain control of the military and reassert
his dominance within the party.
The second problem, Zhang Yuxia is not just a princeling, but effectively the leading
figure among military princelings, a representative of the red aristocracy that controls the regime's
guns.
His political weight is entirely different from figures such as He Weidong.
Although both hold the title of Vice Chairman of the Central Military Commission, their
influence is not comparable.
If Xi were to eliminate Zhang, it would amount to breaking an unwritten rule dating back
to Deng Xiaoping.
Internal power struggles must not cross the line into killing members of the red elite.
Such a move would be tantamount to declaring war on the entire princeling class, dozens
of powerful and wealthy political families.
That would be extremely disadvantageous for Xi.
The third problem, if a Politburo member and Vice Chairman of the Central Military Commission,
in effect treated at the level of a standing committee member, can be arrested and executed
at will, without procedure or clearly defined charges, it would inevitably trigger panic
throughout the official system.
If Zhang can be killed today on accusations of treason, who is to say that Zhao Leiji,
Wang Xiaohong, or Ding Shuixian would not be next tomorrow?
No one could feel secure.
The likely result would be a shared mindset.
Only by joining forces to remove Xi Jinping could officials gain even a minimal sense
of safety.
If Zhang is indeed dead, this could prove to be the gravest mistake of Xi's political
career.
The dead cannot return to life, but military power would not automatically fall into Xi's
hands.
At that point, Xi would be left with only one path, total confrontation, either he eliminates
his opponents or they eliminate him.
For these reasons, I believe the likelihood that Zhang is still alive is higher.
If he had already died, the party elders and anti-Xi factions would hardly remain so outwardly
calm without any major visible reaction.
Moreover, Zhang Yuxia's photos and titles as Politburo member and vice chairman of the
Central Military Commission still remain on the official websites of the Central Commission
for Discipline Inspection, the Party Central Committee, the Central Military Commission,
the Central Propaganda Department, and various provincial portals.
There are now just four days until the Politburo's end-of-month meeting and a little over a week
until the two sessions.
These events could mark the first major turning point since January 20th.
Have four veteran military factions formed an official alliance?
According to reports circulated by Sound of Hope, rumors within the military suggest that
a significant counterbalancing force has taken shape.
Four factions of retired senior generals are said to have formally aligned with the stated
aim of preserving the overall situation.
In other words, safeguarding the Chinese communist system in what they see as a moment of crisis.
The four forces reportedly include former Central Military Commission Chairman Hu Jintao,
regarded internally as a symbol of institutional legitimacy and someone with moral authority
in times of upheaval.
Former CMC Vice Chairman Fan Changlong, who was personally promoted by Admiral Liu Huaqing.
General Liu Yuan, son of former State President Liu Shaoqi.
Liu Yuan has recently appeared in public with newly dyed black hair, interpreted by some
as a symbolic sign of a political comeback within the military.
He is said to be aligned with Deng Pufang, representing the core Prince Ling faction
within the armed forces.
Finally, the family network of Liu Huaqing, together with the families of founding generals
Qin Jiyue and John Wanyan.
Liu Huaqing was once the most powerful CMC Vice Chairman after Deng Xiaoping and one
of the rare military figures to sit on the Politburo Standing Committee.
Rumors claim these four forces have reached a consensus and are backing Army Commander
Li Qiaoming to stabilize the situation and restrain the top leadership and their families.
One particularly explosive allegation suggests that Li Qiaoming has taken control of the
security situation in Beijing, including placing Xi Jinping's family and mother-in-law under
strict surveillance, effectively controlling Zhongnanhai.
According to this version, Xi was compelled to remain in Beijing during the Lunar New
Year and was unable to travel to Shenzhen because he had been confined by the military.
Indeed, aside from a congratulatory message published in People's Daily on Feb. 24 addressed
to Kim Jong-un, Xi has made no public appearances.
Since such congratulatory cables do not require his personal presence, some argue this absence
leaves room for speculation.
Rumors further claim that in meetings with military leaders and party elders, Xi appeared
deeply shaken and pledged not to seek a fourth term.
There are also reports that during negotiations, Xi requested that after retirement, his faction
be guaranteed at least one seat in the future power structure, and that he specifically
asked for Li Qiaoming to retain a seat on the Politburo Standing Committee.
I cannot independently verify the accuracy of these claims.
However, the circulation of sharply conflicting narratives suggests one thing clearly.
Xi Jinping does not yet hold an unchallenged upper hand, and the struggle remains intense
and highly fluid.
What do you think is more likely?
That Jiang is still alive, or already dead?
That Xi has lost his freedom, or that he remains firmly in control?
Leave your thoughts below.
Thank you, and see you next time.
