Freeman Patterson: The DNA of Art Photography | An Interview with Martin Osner (Part 1)

Art Photography
10 followers
#VisualStorytelling #FineArtPhotography #ArtPhotography
What makes a photograph 'God Awful' or a masterpiece? Join me for a rare, deep-dive interview with legendary photographer Freeman Patterson as we explore his artistic philosophy and life's work. What is the DNA of photography? Join Martin Osner and legendary photographer Freeman Patterson as they explore why true art is about design, soul, and emotion rather than rigid rules.
AI Generated·May contain errors
What I'm saying about this is, when something grabs you, like that, and that was, I've had
many experiences like this, but none as powerful as that. You stay with it. You stay with it.
Don't say, why, why, why? Shoot. It's like this ridiculous rule of thirds.
It's like saying, this, we've thought this all out ahead of time. This has been, people thought
it out over the decades and centuries. You just be a good boy, Martin, and you follow the rules.
That's an insult to you. If you're a photographer who feels that something is still missing in your
work, your photographs are good, but lack emotion and lack a personal style, this conversation is
for you. You see, I recently sat down with one of the most remarkable photographers alive today.
I thought we would probably talk for half an hour or so. Well, our discussion went on for almost
two hours, so much so that we had to break this recording into two parts, both of which are
worth your while, I promise you. But before you continue, I need to warn you, this is not a
discussion you can put on double speed and sort of half listen to while you're doing something else.
This is like sitting down with the finest whiskey that deserves your time. So if you are distracted
at the moment or have too much going on, I recommend that you come back to this interview
when you can give it the attention it deserves. Because if you don't, you're going to miss the DNA
of what this is all about. Who is this photographer I hear you ask? Well, his name is Freeman Patterson.
He is 88 years old and has spent most of those years either behind the camera or teaching
workshops or writing one of his 12 books on photography and visual design. Freeman Patterson
holds the Order of Canada, the highest honour a Canadian citizen can receive, and his work
is in the permanent collection of the National Gallery of Canada. And listen to this. He has
also received the Progress Medal from the Photographic Society of America, an award
previously bestowed upon Ansel Adams and Edward Weston, among others, two of the greatest
photographers who ever lived. But this is not what makes him interesting to me. I must tell you what
makes him interesting to me is that he turned up one evening in 1980 at a tiny hotel in a place
called Cummies Cruan in South Africa. It's in the Northern Cape, right on the border of Southern
Namibia. There was one room left and after dinner the hotel owner decided to show her guests some
of her slides. They were, in Freeman's own words, absolutely god-awful. Terrible, in fact, he said.
He sat through every one of them and said nothing. He went to his room afterwards and came back with
the last copy of his book that he had with him and left it with her. He said, I think this will
help you, without telling her that he had written it. Now listen to this. That one evening led to
twenty-five years of workshops at that very same hotel in the Namakwaland. Forty-six trips back to
South Africa. Why? Well, you'll find out in the discussion. To give you some context, I first
came across Freeman Patterson's work through a student of mine, Herbert Breuer. He returned from
one of his workshops completely fired up. He handed me a couple of Freeman's books to look through
and I must say I connected with his teaching immediately. His thinking was so close to what
I had been saying in my own lecture room to my own students for years. So much so that I made
his books recommended reading on my full-time photography program thereafter. Then last year
he visited Cape Town again. This time as the keynote speaker at a National Photography Congress
where I was also asked to speak. Before the Congress he paid a visit to our art gallery
in Hout Bay. At the time we were showcasing some of my students' work from my Fine Art Photography
Masterclass. And here we met for the first time and I offered to explain how the work was made,
what techniques were used and he said, rather not. In those two words he confirmed forty years of my
thinking. In this conversation we went to places I didn't expect. He speaks about two liver
transplants he survived in the year 2000, six weeks in a coma and two weeks from certain death
and how that experience found its way into his photography in ways he didn't even realize.
And funny, he had something to say about the rules of composition that I think is going to make
a few photographers feel quite uncomfortable. Throughout this discussion you'll see some of
Freeman's iconic work. Let his pictures sit with you. Let them make you feel uncomfortable.
Uncomfortable enough that you do something about it. Part one is what you are about to watch. Part
two is where this conversation goes somewhere neither of us had planned. Don't miss it.
One more thing before we dive in. If this is the kind of conversation you want more of,
subscribe to my channel and also sign up for the Osna Studio Atelier. You will find the link below
and there's a lot more interesting discussions like this coming up.
Let us begin the first half of this conversation.
Well Freeman, it's wonderful to have you on this discussion. It's a great privilege and
an honor on my side to have you come and chat with me. I must tell you though,
I got to know about you back in I think it was sort of the late 1990s where a fellow student
who came to on one of your workshops was also doing a full-time photography program with me.
His name is Herbert Breuer, a German gentleman but an absolute fanatic about photography.
I remember him walking in my office and saying he would like to go to a workshop
almost as if he needed my permission. He never mentioned where it was going to be
or what it was going to be but I remember him coming back and he was so fired up.
He gave me a copy of a couple of your books which he had managed to get.
At that point, once I'd read some of your material, I was really blown away. It was
fantastic to the point that I also suggested that our college at that stage used it as
recommended reading material for the students. So it's such a privilege and then of course
I got to meet you face to face recently when you were out in South Africa
having come through to the conference and I got to meet you at our gallery when you came to visit.
So yeah, this is really a privilege to me. I think I want to start off this discussion,
if you don't mind, specifically with the South African connection,
the connection you've got to South Africa and specifically to
the Namakwa Lunt itself, Southern Namibia, the Northern Cape, that sort of area.
And I would like to quote you if I could. There's a quote of yours here and I actually
loved it when I read it. It said, here and elsewhere in the Southern Naba,
you say that change occurs so slowly that I often feel like afternoon could be two million years ago
and it could be two million years in the future as nowhere else I've ever been on this planet.
And then you say, I feel eternity. Wonderful quote. And I think for anybody who's been to
the Namib or who's been to Northern Cape or that area around Kamiskeren will know
exactly what you mean. But I want to ask what particularly or particularly drew you to that
area of the Namakwa. What is the reason why you almost settled there? Because I
know you taught there for many years in Kamiskeren. Yeah. Well, my very first visit
to South Africa was in 67. I was back again in 69. And when I was in Joburg at that time,
there were some photographers who were having an exhibition and I went to it.
And as a result of that, I was invited by the Photographic Society of South Africa
to make a few presentations at the 1972 Congress in Joburg. And then I was invited back again in 1976
and they asked me if I would gear my presentations this time to nature photography,
which I did. I was quite happy to do that. And people at that Congress said to me,
you should go to Namakwa land. You should go to Namakwa land. Well,
not one of them who said this had ever been there herself or himself. It was very remote
in those days because there was... So anyway, the third time I was invited to a Congress was in 1980.
So after the Congress, a friend of mine in Joburg and I flew from Joburg to Upington and
there was no road across from Upington at that point. So with this vehicle, we managed to drive
on dongas and sheep trails and one thing and another until we got over to Achenese and then
we hit some tar and then a few flowers and then we got to Springbok and we spent a couple of days
around Springbok. Well, flowers were okay, but we were late. So we headed down on the third day,
which was the 18th of September, 1980, a date in my personal history, down the N7.
And we went by Commie Spruan. We went out on a road toward Honda clip by and about four o'clock
in the afternoon, we found some good flowers out there. I said to my friend, Dirk, I said,
we don't have any place to stay tonight. What do you think? He said, well, that last village that
we went by, there's a little hotel some. So I said, well, maybe we should go back and see if
we can get a room. Well, as it turned out, they had one room left. There were nine rooms in the
hotel in those days. So he went back at dinner that night. Mrs. Swatt, Paula Swatt, who owned
the hotel with her husband, she'd inherited from her dad. She announced she was going to show some
of her slides on the walls of the e-commerce, and this is something she'd never done before.
But the other people in the hotel that night were on a little minibus from Cape Town,
and they had come up to see the flowers, and they were disappointed in them. And one of their
members was sick, so they decided to go back to Cape Town the next day. So she was showing these
slides. So now, Afrikaans is the main language in that area, but everyone understood.
So she was speaking English. So I asked her if Dirk and I could stay and watch her slides.
Well, she said, oh, absolutely. Now, the slides were absolutely god-awful. I mean, they really
were terrible. But the subject matter, I'm saying, oh my heavens, if I could see flowers like that,
I'd just give anything to see that. But she knew that her pictures weren't very good,
but she was taking no responsibility. She was blaming the camera for this,
blaming the camera for that. Anyway-
Did she know, sorry to interrupt, but did she know who you were?
No, not at all. And that's part of her story. So after dinner, I went back to my room. I had
one copy of my second book, Photography and the Artist, and I took it back into her,
into the e-commerce. And I said, Mrs. Swatt, I said, you're having problems with your
cameras, with your photography. And I said, maybe this book will help you. And I gave it to her.
And I did not tell her I had authored the book. I did not tell her. So anyway,
the next morning I'm eating breakfast and I remember what I was eating. I remember the
table I was sitting at and everything. And the door of the dining room bursts open and she comes,
Carla comes in and she said, her name's Paula, short for Cornelia. She said,
you're a professional photographer and you sat through my slideshow last night and I am mortified.
And she said, I've canceled everything I have to do, which was one hell of a lot for the next two
days. She said, if you can stay for two days, I'll show you the best flowers we have left in
the Markle land this year. So I said, it's a deal. And by the time we went right up the
Commiesburg Pass right behind the hotel the next morning, and I had four films by the time we got
to the top of the pass, she thought it was out of my mind. She made a film due for her one full
year, one film she put in December at Christmas and then she'd replace it the following Christmas.
Anyway, and I handed her a cup of films. Anyway, so after two days, I left. I taught her everything
I could teach her in two days. And then that was the end of it. And the following year, end of
August, early September, I was sitting in my kitchen in Canada and the phone rings and it was
a Canadian Pacific Telegraph office that still telegraphs in those days. And the gentleman,
when I answered, said, I have a telegram. And he said, would you like me to mail it to you? Or
would you like me to read it? So I said, well, please read it. Where's it from? He said, South
Africa. I said, read it. And it was this, flower superb, come at once, call a swap. And I had no
choice. I mean, it means, you know, you've got to get here in a hurry. And so remember this is 1980
and I called Air Canada. And one thing, I could only get a business class ticket. And I,
anyway, I got a business class ticket. And when I flew by way of New York and
Joburg and then down to Cape Town, anyway, and I shared the business class cabin with the Osmond
family, the Demps. I remember them. Yeah, Marie Osmond. Yeah. So I stayed for three weeks. And
when I went to settle up, Cooney called his husband, said, there's no charge. I said,
what? I said, I've been eating your food for three weeks. He said, you've taught
Carla too much. There's no charge. So I said, well, look, I said, this little hotel is the
perfect place for workshops. You've got a nice hall and you've got the dining facilities,
you've got the rooms. I said, I want you to pay your way to Canada next year. That would have
been 1982. And I said, and then I will look after you, but I want you to audit one of my
Canadian workshops. So the following year they came, they audited a workshop. I flew them out
to Western Canada, to the Rockies and so on. And then the following year, 83, we had two workshops
in Commie Scruen. Carla was a brilliant student. She was a very brilliant woman. In fact, she was
the first woman in the mock land ever to have a university degree. So anyway, I think we had
two students on our first workshop, four on our second. The next year they were full and they were
plugged right through until she had to step aside in 2006. So I taught there for a quarter
of a century, workshops. And then after that, overhead, I went back in March, February, March,
and we had wilderness camping tours at the coast and in the Richtersveld. And I've spent, I've had
50 trips now to South Africa, 46 of them to the mock land. And I think I've spent about eight and
a half years of my life. Fantastic. And the area itself, I mean, I know it well. I must also tell
you that about that time when Carla was retiring from the teaching, around the 2006 mark, I went
on a trip up through Namibia to photograph specifically for my old abandoned collection
of photographs that I was busy shooting. So old broken down things, whether it was motorbikes or
cars, but things that have just been left abandoned and they're organically still beautiful.
And we actually stayed there, myself and my family, we stayed there for a night or two
on the way up to Namibia. And Carla wasn't there, I don't think I actually know,
I never met her then. She retired to pick up her daughter. Her husband took over.
The room, I think, or the hotel at that point had been expanded to 23 or 26 rooms.
But in the back, and you may remember this, there's a petrol pump that stands in the back
of the property. And it looks like a cowboy from the western Europe. It looks like guns in the
holster with the petrol. And I photographed that. There's other places in Commonwealth
that look the same way. It's like a mid-western North American town back in the days.
And that photograph's in my portfolio. It's actually a very popular print.
So I'll put it into this presentation for the viewers to see what I'm talking about.
But besides the flowers, I mean, the makaron flowers are incredible. For anybody who's
never seen them, I mean, it is just a carpet of just festivity of color and beauty.
And it's so vast. It just runs for miles and miles and miles.
And people make a huge mistake to go just for a weekend.
The shortest time I've ever spent there in flower season is two weeks. That's the shortest.
Yeah, at least.
You go investigating and just, oh, the discoveries you make on the back roads.
Yeah, it's incredible. But the question I want to ask is besides the flowers,
because there's so much more there, what else did you experience in that area?
I mean, it was a very special and is still a very special area to you.
Well, where I live in Canada, it's a very forested area. And I mean, it's also agricultural, but
big forests and forestry is a big career opportunity. And what's the word I'm looking for?
Product, forest products. But anyway, what I was going to say is that I can't understand it exactly,
but I love deserts. I just totally love deserts. And when you get up in Namibia,
say in the area of Sossusvlei and so on, I mean, I can, and I went walking alone in the dunes
on numerous occasions. I never worry about getting lost. I always could find my way.
But I really, and also in the Richterstel where, I mean, this is really the south end of the Namib,
and it's not that there are dunes there, but there are these incredible rock formations.
And there's an area in the Richterstel called Cucurbum Bluf.
I know it as well.
Yeah. And that to me, when I go there, I just feel I'm going home. I'm going home.
And every time, I've been camping there many times. And when I leave,
I haven't gone three kilometers until I just feel overcome with homesickness.
I can't explain it, but it's as if maybe, I don't know, a thousand years ago, I lived there.
I feel like I know the place. And the first time that I went into that area,
I went just Kala and me. And we went up over Hell's Loose Pass, and the road was incredibly
awful. I mean, it was awful. It's always awful. That road is always awful. It gets washed away
with a lot of the rain. Yeah. Anyway, and when we got in there, she said, we pull up the vehicle
under a rock for the night. And she said, well, I'm going to make us a bite to eat, and why don't
you go for a walk? So I set out around the huge triangular rock called Dituan. And anyway,
there were these big rocks sitting out in the felt. And I came up to one, and I kind of imagined
what was on the other side. And I walked around this huge boulder. And what I had imagined was
exactly what was there. And it really brought me up sharp. And so I kept going. There was another
gigantic boulder, I mean, huge, massive boulder sitting in the felt. And again, I pre-visualized
and which one does what's on the other side, walked around, and there it was. At that point,
I turned around, and I went back to Kala. And I said to her, I said, you know, I've never been
here before, don't you? She said, of course, that's why I brought you. And I said to her,
I know this place. And I said, I know it really well. You know, that to me was, it was a kind of
a, one of the things I, I'm not going to go into it now, but I love reading and studying about
consciousness. And why I knew, why I could pre-visualize has not happened to me in any
other situation I can ever recall. It did that. That is deep. And did you do much photography
there? Or was it just a place of solitude for you? Oh, no, a great deal over the years. I can't
remember how many times I've been into that area. Well, we went, we went in there, and I was
expecting to be quite productive in the Ruchtersveld. I really, you know, I had,
I'd studied the area. As I said, a good friend of mine, Chris van der Linde,
photographed that area for many years, and I'd seen some of his work. And I actually struggled,
I really struggled to photograph there. The landscape was almost like from another planet.
It is.
And to the eye, it looked incredible. But the moment you brought the lens to it,
I couldn't capture what I was feeling. And I really struggled. I got, I got a couple of
photographs I was happy with, but it was, it was, I saw, I understand your, the connection you had
and the feeling you had there, because it's got that spiritual feeling about it. It is,
it's just superb. And again, you have to go there to actually experience it for yourself.
So Freeman, moving on from the Southern Hemisphere, and the dry areas and the dry
areas of the Northern Cape and the Narbib Desert, and the prolific colors and flowers, we go
back to your, back to your hometown. And in preparing for this discussion with you, I
read through one of your articles that you had written, and very well written, by the way, you
really have a gifting for writing, which is very obvious. But again, I would like to quote this,
if I could, let me just get it here in front of me. You say over here, and this is specifically
about subjects or familiar subjects itself, and symbolic weight, as you put it. But you,
you said over here that nearly every year, when the first flakes of snow begin,
the visual transformation of what you call your rural landscape, you say, yeah, I find myself
standing on my doorstep, camera lens pointed almost straight down. Anybody watching asks,
what on earth are you photographing? So my question is in two parts. The one is that
you return to the same place you return to year after year, if I understand what you've written
correctly. Something that I almost battle with, because I don't, I don't like revisiting places
more than once. It's just a completely different mindset, I guess. And you say the same patch of
gravel, and then you're able to actually photograph something new every time. Can you help me to,
to understand that? What draws you back? What is the reason why you would go back to the same spot,
basically connected to what you describe as, and you mentioned it as symbolic weight,
and I'd like to also understand what you mean by symbolic weight, something that has
deeper personal meaning, or a subject that holds something special for you. Can you explain both
of those? Sure, I just wanted to say that I went, I brought with me here today, a quote
that I wanted to read to you. And it's by Anthony Stevens, who was from Oxford, he's one of the
world's great psychotherapists. And he said, art, like the dream, is an emotionally loaded
form of communication conducted through the use of symbols. Now, I'm going to, I would really like
to speak to that question, because the photography that matters to me is the photography that I do
for me. In other words, if I'm drawn to a subject, I'd like to stay with it
until it's lost its pull. In other words, that may be for 10 minutes, it may be for,
you know, five hours, or I may go back repeatedly to that area. And when I'm standing on my doorstep,
my front doorstep, my driveway ends right there, and it's a gravel drive.
But there's little patches of grass in there as well. And there's nothing else, there's no,
you know, center of interest, point of dominance, or anything else. It's all quite integrated. And
then the flakes of snow come down. So I have the white tone of the snow, I have all the dark gray
of the gravel, and then the mid tone brown of the grasses. So I have the almost complete tonal range,
nothing stands out. It's just a completely intricate weave.
Almost like camouflage, I guess.
Almost. But the point is, the first time, I love doing photographing situations like that.
And the first time I became aware of how much I liked it was on the other side of my house a few
years ago. I was looking out from my kitchen window, and I saw the whole field look like that.
I went on the back deck and made photographs. And after five or 10 minutes, photographing here and
there, now the back deck down at this field, which was the same grasses, little black shadows in that
case, and mid tone grasses. I was higher than a kite. I was just flying. So I came in the house,
I made myself a cup of tea. I went back, sat down on the chair, and I said, what's going on? And,
you know how sometimes when you ask yourself a question like that, you know the answer,
and you'll say it right away. And then you think it's too foolish, you keep on going.
Well, that happened to me that morning. Very quickly, I said to myself,
this field looks just like you'd like your life to look, integrated. And I said, oh,
for God's sake. And I kept on going. And then a few minutes later, I said, the field does look
I'd like my life to be. The white tones are all the wonderful things that have happened to me.
They're everywhere, but they're different everywhere. The little black shadows was a
cloudy morning from the grasses. They're everywhere. And the mid tone browns were
showing through, and they're everywhere. It was just like a totally integrated spread.
So that field, and when I stand at my doorway and point the lens down on the
as you described, that's what I'm photographing. I'm photographing integration.
Look, am I an integrated person? Probably not, but more so than I was, and it's a lifelong
challenge. I can give you another example, and it's a very powerful one. In 2000, I had not one,
but two liver transplants, five days apart. And yeah, the first one failed. So I was put into a
coma. And anyway, I was in a coma for six weeks. And after six weeks, when I woke up, my transplant
surgeon told me that I'd won the national lotto five weeks in a row. He said, you shouldn't be
here. But there I was. So anyway, a good many years later, I've taught workshops several times
in Israel, and four times in southern Israel in a little Moshav agricultural community called
Foran. And on the desert floor there, just outside of Foran, there's about a thousand
fabric greenhouse that's too hot for glass ones. So they have fabric, and they can have more fabric
or less. When I was there in 2011, I would take the students in the workshop over there. We worked
as a good place to study lines and shapes and so on. And I made photographs, and I liked it.
When I went back in 2016, I could not stay away from those. And between workshops,
I was doing between workshops, I was there at dawn for a couple of hours,
go back, have some breakfast, go back at noon, over the noon hour, I'd be there for two or three
hours, go back, have a rest in the afternoon, and go back at sunset. I couldn't stay away.
Now, I was shooting digital by this point, and I was deleting a lot of images as I went.
But I returned to Canada with 3,300 digital files. What can you do with 3,300 digital files
of fabric greenhouses? Nothing. So I did a very hard edit, and I got it down to 750.
And then I have a print agent, and I knew I wanted to print some of these. And so I did
a totally brutal edit and got it down to 75 images. In the process, I began to discover
the symbol. In the end, I ended up with eight photographs. They tell the story of my first
picture, represents me and my body about 1998-99. It's ripped and torn fabric, that's me.
And then there's a photograph of this mist, the skeleton of a greenhouse with gray mist,
and a black shroud fabric hanging down. And that represents me. I was about two weeks from dying
when I got the transplant. And it was a skeleton, that's me, the skeleton of the greenhouse.
And that black fabric was the shroud waiting to wrap my emaciated body. And then,
in the eight pictures, it goes from near-death to intensive care, all pictures of fabric,
to my return to full health, and then finally just the energy pulsing through my body. And I've been
a very healthy person in the 26 years since. So what I'm saying about this is when something
grabs like that, and I've had many experiences like this, but none as powerful as that,
you stay with it, you stay with it. Don't say, why, why, why? Shoot, shoot, shoot. And
in the editing process, usually, that's where you'll discover why that mattered to me.
When you're in that space, and I'm asking this because something happens to me when I'm shooting,
and I pretty much know that I'm on to something, even if I don't understand what it is,
do you also get that feeling in your tummy? It's not butterflies, but it is…
Is it a certain excitement?
Yeah, it's almost like, it's not nerves, it's an excitement, but it's almost like a
beautiful tingly feeling in the tummy that I can't explain, but it's like a creative bubbling.
And when that starts to happen, the whole world around me closes down and time itself stops.
And that's probably very similar to what you're saying when you're in that moment,
you're not sure why, but it feels right. And when you get back from a shoot like that,
sorry, I interrupted there, but when you get back from having taken that many photographs
under those conditions, do you leave your photographs one side for the emotion,
just to sort of die down before you start to look at your editing or before you start taking it
through a process of sort of calling out the ones you like versus the ones you don't,
or do you get straight into it?
I think both of those things, but this stuff, I had to take a long time, I had so many files
to go through. And so I spent over a period of, well, maybe even weeks before I ended up
with the 75 that I sent off to my print age, but the eight for myself. When I got those,
I said, that's why I could not stay away from those greenhouses, because the greenhouses were
a symbol for my illness, my near death, and my full recovery.
And when you are photographing in that space, just the depth of the emotion, I think, just
brings out something so much more special in one's photography. So no, it's funny,
in my world, I've got to put my files away for six months, maybe a year. I cannot look,
no, I can't look at them early, because the emotions for me are too high. So the fact that
I was out there, the fact that I experienced that, the fact that the wind was blowing,
the fact that there were smells around, the senses were working, the good feelings and all of that,
that all seems to play a role in, you know, and then I just find that I'd rather come back,
I put them away, I forget about them, six months, a year later, I'll open them up.
And of course, when I do, it's very similar to what you, what you went through with these,
I end up throwing so much away, I donated those files back to cyberspace for somebody else.
Right.
It's so good to, you know, when you hear other photographic artists'
view, and also how you actually work through it, it's very refreshing, very refreshing indeed.
Freeman, the last image of the eight, I know that that's a special image to you, and you also
have some symbolic, you know, something symbolic that you can bring to it when it came to the
circus, and would you tell everybody about that as well?
Well, in the last, actually, three photos, in the last three images, you see this red fabric,
it's in the middle of the picture, it's tiny, and it gets wider and wider and wider and wider,
and it's like, yes, I'm back, I'm back, I'm back, I'm back, it's just like, and then the
second last picture, it's like I'm performing in the circus, and there's wires there, and then the
red fabric are like safety nets underneath, so out of hospital, and I'm immediately performing
in the circle, and then the last one are very red, yellow, and blue hues, and very strong
tonal contrast as well, strong lines throughout, and it's just like energy flowing, and that's
been pretty well ever since. If you photograph for yourself, then don't worry at all, but if
anyone else likes your images, that's not important. If you're photographing, and the making
of the pictures matters to you, and some of the photographs you make matter to you deeply,
you will develop your, you don't, how do I put it, you don't go searching for a style,
the style finds you, because you're being honest to yourself. Photograph, what matters,
nobody else likes it, tough. I mean, we all like, that's ego, when someone else loves your picture,
that makes you feel good, of course, and you hope that images you make have relevance for other
people, but fundamentally, you must do what matters to you, and then that represents you in a very,
I think, accurate way. Correct, and it brings the more deeper, emotive type of work out of you as
well. That's right. Absolutely. I remember the day you came through to visit us here at the
gallery, and we had an exhibition up of our Masterclass students' work, and I remember you
taking a lot of time to go through the exhibition. In fact, I was very impressed with the fact that
you did, you know, not just sort of gaze over it quickly, and before, or as you started looking at
the work, I said to you, Freeman, if there's anything you want to know about any of these
pieces that are up, I know these students so well, I've spent a number of years with each one of them,
I know what they're thinking, I know what they tried, and I know how they produced the work,
and you said to me, rather not. You didn't want to know anything about the piece. You didn't
want to know the craft behind how it was created, but you wanted to spend some time with it,
and that for me was very special. Do you want to maybe just enlarge on that? I have
also a quote of yours. Your quote is this here, you say, the question why is central to art,
the question how is central to craft, and then you say art is conceived in our unconscious,
in our imagination, our passions, our dreams. We use craft to give it birth. So that's the quote,
and I think that quote is pertinent to the way I saw you enjoying the work that people had spent
so much time putting together. Because, and I think photographers, I mean, it's true of every
visual medium. How do you do this? How do you do that? That's craft.
Why you do it? Why am I pointing the camera down? The real issue is not how I made the photographs.
The real issue is why I made them. Once I identified that this kind of image, which is
just a weave, a tapestry, with no dominant point or anything like that, matters to me.
I don't care if anyone else liked it. It just speaks to something that it is a visible
expression of something that is a deeply emotional need or whatever, this need for
integration. And so when I remember so well that morning just looking at the various photographs
of yours in the gallery, and it was very special. And I mean, you know, obviously as I'm looking at
it, I'm thinking, well, yeah, I think, I don't even think I asked how very much of myself.
No, you didn't. You actually didn't ask one single piece. You didn't want to know how it
was created. But I did ask our students to put up a small brief on the piece and what it meant to
them and why they created it. And you spent a lot of time reading that, but you didn't want to know
how it was created. That didn't matter to you. You know, in a lot of photography magazines that
they'll have underneath it, Nikon camera, model, whatever, the most useless information in the
world. Exactly. I agree. Totally useless. I absolutely agree. But I think one of the things,
you know, to a large degree, craft, in a sense, it precedes art. Not the genesis of art, but
obviously, if you don't know your tools and don't know the building blocks of visual design,
like line, shape, texture, and if you don't know how to, you know, principles of composition,
how you arrange lines and so on, you've got to know that in order to pull off the art,
so to speak, to make the why visible. Yeah, quite correct. I mean, I remember reading your,
and I can't tell you exactly which book it was in, but where you
did discuss the concept of visual design, and I remember you breaking it up into primary shapes,
I think, if I recall correctly, and secondary shapes. That's right. Yeah, and then broke
that up into rhythm and pattern and so on. I mean, in language, we have, I mean,
the two basic building blocks or parts of speech are the noun and the verb. You give me a noun
and give me a verb, and I can make a statement, or I can ask a question. That's all I need.
Everything else is a bit extra. Adjectives, adverbs, all of these things are modifiers
or join things together, and it's exactly the same with visual design. The noun and the verb
of visual design are line and shape. You know, give me a piece of paper or give me a white screen
or anything, and I draw a line across it. It can be a straight line or it can be an undulating line
or a curving line. Immediately, I have two shapes. Okay, if I move the line this way,
let's say it's a straight line, and I'm just driving from top to bottom. If I move the line
this way, I've got a narrow rectangle over here and a much larger rectangle over there.
It feels differently than if I have the line in the middle and have two equal,
right, equal sides. So, line and shape are expressive. And, you know, a straight line
makes us feel differently from a curving or an undulating line. And I remember in Namaquapin,
I illustrate this point in my workshops because of one of the pictures or comparison shots.
I was standing at the base of a big rock, and the breakers, the waves were coming in,
smashing against the rock and coming up. And I did two shots, both of them that I think
ordered about like a quarter of a second. So, here's this black rock, and up come these straight
lines. In the first picture. In the second photograph, same composition, but this wave,
they don't come straight up, the lines go. So, immediately, just by looking at the lines,
you know, the first wave was the stronger of the two waves. In other words, the curving line
is expressing, oh, well, I've got more time, or I'm not so strong, I'm not feeling so well. You
get that feeling from it. In some cases, more peaceful, depending on your subject matter,
whereas your straight line is a lot more purposed.
And then a line like this, or a line like this, or a line like this, you know, you have an oblique
line like here, here, or even a diagonal from corner to corner, and that's always got thrust
and dynamic to it. Almost feels like it's in motion, I guess. That's right.
Very interesting that visual design, I think, as a photographer, so not myself necessarily,
but I'm talking about photographers in general, photographers, photographic artists,
whatever you want to call them, that are listening to this talk now. For many of them,
they've never experienced the design layer to their work, or working with design.
But what they do experience, usually, is what is firstly taught, which is then the rules of
composition. And for many of the photographers, they never really get out of the rules. So
the rules will tend to dominate their work and almost make what I have seen their work a lot
more predictable. Whereas, I think, in my opinion, those rules should never be called rules. I think
they should be called guidelines. And I think the layers that something like visual design can
bring onto your work over and above that is just incredible. It can take your work from predictable
to something that is exciting and worthy of looking at. Do you want to maybe comment on
just your feeling on the rules of composition versus your...
Well, first of all, how can you compose if you haven't talked about what you're composing?
You have to talk about lines, you have to know about shapes, you have to know about depth,
you have to know about textures. Those are the four that I talk about in particular.
Line and shape, of all else. Then you can compose them. But if you've never talked,
it's the same thing when you're in elementary school. You learn the parts of speech or the
building blocks of speech. What's composition? Then you learn how to arrange them in sentences
and in paragraphs. That's composition. You don't start off talking about composition until you
know what a noun is and a verb is. And what they do. And it's exactly the same thing.
Your example of people wanting to talk about composition without ever talking about the
building blocks that they're composing or arranging, they've left the first half out.
Exactly.
So then, and what you call guidelines, I call principles, same thing here. Rules are an insult.
If I say, this is like this ridiculous rule of thirds, it's like saying,
we've thought this all out ahead of time. People have thought it out over the decades and centuries.
You just be a good boy, Martin, and you follow the rules. That's an insult to you.
And that's where we leave part one. Next week in part two, we go deeper into the rules of
composition, Monier's influence on Freeman's creative vision, and his transition from film
to digital. Three conversations you do not want to miss. Subscribe to the Osno Studio Atelier below.
You'll receive early access to new videos just like this, and you will always know
what is coming up next. Until next week, part two of my discussion with Freeman Patterson,
stay creative. Why? Because it's just good for you. Cheers, everybody.
