What do Flock cameras actually know about you?

Fox - Fox 9
44 followers
58 Video Views·Aug 24, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
We wanted to ask a few more questions
about how does this technology work?
What happens to your data?
And should you really be concerned about it all?
Joining us now to talk more about it
is Harry Moggins from Privacy Bee.
So Harry, thank you for joining us
to help shed a little bit of light on this,
because I know this can be confusing for a lot of people.
How about if we take it from the perspective
of just Joe Citizen?
I don't have any speeding tickets.
I have no criminal record.
I'm not wanted for anything.
My car is not stolen.
Why should I be concerned about these flawed cameras?
It's a good question, and we get that a lot.
The challenge is the cameras are only
trying to go after less than 1% of the population.
To your point, it's the amber alerts.
It's the hit and run drivers.
And they actually do a good job of solving crimes.
There's no denying cases are closed because of flock.
The question is the other 99% of the population,
as you said, Joe Citizen, who doesn't have Warren
Outstanding.
It's a very nuanced thing, because when
you violate somebody's privacy like that,
it's not just a matter of taking a picture of their license
plate.
The bigger picture is it's stitching together
a journey, a diary, a journal of everywhere they go online.
I mean, it's seeing the driveways
they park at overnight.
It's the churches they visit.
It's them leaving political rallies, whatever medical
clinic they go to, or doctor.
It's not just a single picture.
It's actually an entire life that's
being portrayed, a dossier on a person based on everywhere
they go, which is a lot more terrifying
than a random picture.
Yeah, but who's looking at this data?
So what?
They're collecting data.
Just to play devil's advocate here, Harry,
they're collecting all of this data on me, on you,
and where we travel.
But unless they're specifically looking for you or me,
what happens to that data?
That is the exact question to ask.
What happens to it?
Flock is a private company.
The data that leaves these cameras
goes into a private cloud.
Nobody knows who's looking at it.
They have an audit line where an officer
can record the exact reason why he's making the search.
But it's up to the officer to be correct and honest.
The majority of the times, the ones I've seen,
are vague, like where the officer just enters
investigation or whatnot.
And it's not tied to an active investigation or a case
or in pursuit of an actual criminal.
And that's where you see situations
where officers, unfortunately, some of them
have crossed the line, and they're
looking up romantic partners, or they're
using it for personal reasons.
And the ones that do get caught do get in trouble or arrested.
But I guarantee there's a lot more that are not being caught.
And that's just the officers who have a license and a seat who
are able to actually look at it.
How do we know that Flock's not selling the data
to your insurance company or to other organizations
outside of our control?
We don't know.
Yeah, and that's what I was trying to hit on.
How do we know what data they have
of our travels in our cars based upon license plate readers?
Well, in today's day and age, I mean,
mass surveillance is something we cannot just
roll over and get numb to.
One day, we're going to wake up in an Orwellian society
in 1984 where there's cameras at every street corner,
because there candidly are cameras at most street corners
nowadays.
You talk about surveillance pricing at the grocery store
changing how much your cereal costs based on your credit
score.
You talk about cabin cameras in your car
using AI to determine if you're safe to drive.
These are not theoretical things.
These are ways that surveillance and technology
is being used in masses in the private and the public sector.
And I think the reason Flock is getting so much public backlash
is because it's almost become the poster
child in mass surveillance at this point.
There's so many cameras with so much data,
it's candidly crossing a line that I believe
violates civil liberties.
Well, and it's not just Flock.
I mean, if we go back to the Super Bowl this year,
when Ring had this fairly innocent campaign commercial
talking about and basically selling Ring cameras
on the fact that, hey, if your dog ever gets lost,
our network of Ring cameras in your neighborhood
or beyond your neighborhood help us track down your dog.
And when I remember seeing that commercial
air during the Super Bowl, I'm thinking, OK,
that's a pretty unique tool.
Then I thought about it for about five seconds more,
and it was like, hey, wait a minute.
That means they can track me or my neighbor or any place else.
And it wasn't more than 12 hours later
that the rest of the country figured that out, too.
And there was this big unintended backlash
to Ring that Ring did not anticipate and was not
ready for from a PR standpoint.
And now Flock is basically being exposed to the same tension
out there from the public, correct?
Correct.
Yeah, well, I remember I saw that same commercial,
and I thought the same thing.
I'm like, oh, that's a great feature.
That's nice.
It's a good idea.
And then you start thinking about it.
You're like, wait a second.
Yeah, yeah.
Yeah, there's definitely another side to it.
And it's the same thing as the cameras.
In the very beginning, a license plate reader
just scans the letters in the back of your car
and finds stolen cars.
I don't have a car.
No repo agents are after me.
Fantastic.
But then you start connecting the dots,
and you see the bigger picture.
It's almost like legislation, where in the beginning,
they have a cute acronym of it's always
trying to protect the children, which sounds great,
and nobody's going to argue against it.
Finding stolen cars, nobody's going to argue against it.
Finding stolen puppies or lost puppies,
nobody's going to argue against it.
But when you start looking at it beyond the marketing lens,
the PR angle they're pushing, you start saying,
well, hang on.
This technology is pretty powerful.
What else can they do with it?
And who has access to it?
And how long is this stored?
And what could tomorrow look like if we don't
ask these questions today?
Now, from a law enforcement perspective,
at least one law enforcement officer,
our Ramsey County Sheriff, Bob Fletcher,
we all know Bob pretty well.
And Bob, at his core, is a law and order guy.
And he believes wholeheartedly in the efficacy
of these cameras.
And he's been telling us for the past week
that he has no intention of getting rid of them
because they work to help them track down stolen cars
and people on arrest warrants and other crimes
that he thinks they are extremely valuable.
Other law enforcement officers are listening
their communities and having second thoughts about it.
We had another sheriff, I believe in Sherbourne County,
maybe Itasca County, correct me if I'm wrong,
who said, look, I've got four deputies out in patrol.
I don't have the bandwidth labor force wise
to be monitoring all of this data that comes in from flock.
It just makes no sense for us.
From a manpower point of view
in his particular jurisdiction.
So you're starting to see a little pushback
from some law enforcement officers,
but you also have the sheriffs like Bob Fletcher,
who says, look, this works.
And I'm trying to make the case to my community
that these are important for what we do to keep you safe.
A hundred percent.
And I think we're gonna see,
I don't think we're gonna see them staying.
I really do because they genuinely do solve crimes.
It's like any new tool that the police office
or departments get.
In the very beginning when tasers came around
or even guns, right?
In the beginning, you have training,
you have education about it.
You have guardrails and auditability and transparency.
Flock is brand new.
This technology taking ALPRs,
the license plate reading cameras
and evolving them to do more dragnet surveillance.
It's brand new.
There are no guardrails.
There is no accountability.
Flock's a private company.
So they're not subject to the Freedom of Information Act.
You can't send a FOIA request to Flock.
So because there's so much opacity there,
nobody knows for sure what's happening.
All we have is the CEO's word saying,
well, we changed the default retention to seven days.
That was last week.
But what they're not saying is that's the default.
A department can go in there and crank it up
to keep the data for months if they want to.
There's no hard line and there's no way to prove
that what they say is happening is actually happening
because they're a private company.
Well, Harry, you just hit on something I hear
that I think is a central question to a lot of people.
If they have data on you, me, our neighbor,
anyone watching, how do you go get access to that data?
How can you find out if they have data and how much on you?
See, you can't, unless there's a subpoena
or an active lawsuit.
There's no way to get data out of Flock.
And only private businesses and HOAs have some ability
to remove license plates,
but only in very, very limited situations.
The vast majority are covered by the fact
that license plates are considered public in 50 states.
So there is no way to mask it.
I think where you have some ability to fight back
is a new Flock initiative called, it was Flock Nova,
they've just renamed it to Flock OS Investigate,
where Flock is buying data from data brokers
to augment the data they see from cameras.
And suddenly they don't just have your license name
and address and your picture of your car,
but they actually have your hobbies and your interests
and your families and friends and associates
and how much money you make
and all kinds of information on you
because they're buying it on the private market
from data brokers.
And that's somewhere people can fight back
by deleting themselves from the data brokers,
which in turn limits the visibility Flock has to your car
as you drive down the road.
You know, another concern I think, Harry,
that people are raising too is,
okay, so if they have data on us,
where are they storing it?
Is it being stored here in the United States
or is it being stored offshore someplace
in a country that may or may not be friendly
to the United States and may have access to this data
for not so good purposes?
Sure.
Nobody knows for sure because they're a private company,
but I do believe it's stored in the U.S. personally
because the U.S. doesn't have a national privacy law.
They don't have any of the red tape
that some other countries have.
We desperately need it.
But until we pass some legislation
on a federal level like that,
the U.S. is probably the safest place
Flock could keep the data.
Let's be clear on this too,
because we're talking about one vendor in one company, Flock,
but there are other vendors in other companies
who provide similar services and technology
to law enforcement all across the country
that's not named Flock.
I mean, most police agencies have license plate readers
in the squad cars that go around
and that's data that's being collected too.
Oh yeah, now ALPR, Automated License Plate Readers,
or a recognition I believe it is, I think it's readers,
has been around for a while.
A long time.
Yeah, truck stops have had it for a while.
You've had weigh stations,
you've had repo companies using it.
And to your point, officers' cars have had it for a while.
The difference with Flock is they're connecting the readers
to create this journey and this life
of what a person's doing.
And this connectivity, this AI-driven data powerhouse
is what's new.
It's the evolution of a tool they've had for a long time.
If it's a basic plate reader, I have no problem with it.
It's when it violates privacy
and becomes more of a phishing expedition
and an interconnected invasion of privacy,
that's when I think the line is crossed.
But to your point, there's Axon,
I know Motorola makes a different license plate reader.
There's a lot of companies in the space.
I just happen to have less personal problems
with them than Flock.
So you study this issue.
Where do you see it going from here?
Is this just a thing right now that we're going through
where it's having this particular issue
is having its 15 minutes of notoriety
and will become less hot here in another couple of months
or do you see it continuing?
They probably hope so.
I think their goal is to see which lasts longer,
the press cycle or the company itself.
We'll see.
I think the technology is not going anywhere.
It's one of those things
where once the genie's out of the bottle,
they're not gonna just give it up and turn it in.
I mean, some jurisdictions are canceling their contracts.
Like LAPD had a big contract they pulled recently.
But other ones like the one you mentioned earlier
are doubling down on it.
I don't think the technology is going anywhere.
It's more about building the guardrails
and making sure that the future gives us the auditability
and transparency that we need.
It's kind of like AI.
When it first came out, there's a lot of skepticism
and unknown and some fear
and there's a lot of back and forth.
It's not going away.
So instead we need to figure out how to regulate
and live with it in a healthy way
and not just get numb to the exploitation of privacy
that is becoming more of a common conversation.
Well, and you just hit on something there too.
How much of it is those of us as consumers
having to get used to the fact
that everything we do is getting tracked by somebody?
I mean, seriously, our grocery stores know more about us
and what we spend than maybe the IRS does.
But for sure, I mean, Kroger,
one of the biggest grocery stores in the country,
posted half a billion dollars last year in data sales,
selling data from their Kroger Plus program,
their loyalty program.
That rivals previous years of grocery profits.
That's an insane amount of money.
So I think to your point,
it's one of those things where it's the world we live in
and some days it's tempting just to move into a cabin
in the middle of the woods or go off the grid,
but it's not realistic.
So if it is, we have to make sure our social media is safe,
our surveillance tracking plate, all this technology.
We have to show up at city council meetings.
We have to write our senators and we have to stay vigilant.
We cannot just roll over and get numb to it
or we're gonna wake up one day and it's gonna be too late.
Yeah, we were just talking this hour
about how the Superior National Forest
has rolled back its campfire restrictions up north
and how a lot of us just wanna get away
and get off the grid for a while.
And this leads right into that conversation too
about getting off the grid.
I'll join you.
Harry Meagans, thanks so much coming to us
from Privacy Bee and his company there.
This is a fascinating conversation
and one that I know we're gonna continue to talk about
probably in the days ahead as more communities
and law enforcement agencies are starting to have
this serious conversation with their citizens
about their privacy and their data
and how this information is being used.
Harry, thanks so much.
Hey, thank you for having me.
I appreciate it.
