Paquete Habana (using learned writings to identify customary international law)

Global Affairs Academy
6 followers
Sep 4, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedDuring the Spanish-American War, the US seized two Spanish fishing vessels, the Paquete Habana and the Lola. The resulting legal battle reached the US Supreme Court, which had to determine if a customary international law existed that exempted fishing vessels from capture during wartime. The court ruled in favor of the fishermen, ordering the US to provide compensation.
In 1898, the Spanish colony of Cuba was pressing for independence, which the colonists violently
resisted. The USA sent a warship to protect Americans present, but the Spanish sank it.
This led to the Spanish-American War. Two Cuban fishing vessels, the Paquete Habana and the Lola,
both sailing under the Spanish flag, left Cuba just before the war broke out.
They were returning home with thousands of fish on board when each of them was intercepted by
American warships. The fishermen had no idea there was even a war underway. The ships were seized
and sold. Thing is, the lawyers for the fishermen alleged that there was a centuries-old custom
whereby nations at war did not capture fishing vessels. The argument went,
by an ancient usage among civilized nations beginning centuries ago and gradually ripening
into a rule of international law, coast fishing vessels, pursuing their vocation of catching and
bringing in fresh fish, have been recognized as exempt with their cargoes and crews from
capture as prize of war. The US Supreme Court therefore had to decide whether this was,
in fact, an international law. Remember, this is long before institutions like the United Nations
and the formalized system of treaties we have today. Instead, the members of the court examined
the history of this alleged practice, looking at historical documents from the 1400s onwards,
and including the observations of learned scholars about what the principles of international law
were. The court described its process this way. International law is part of our law and must be
ascertained and administered by the courts of justice. For this purpose, where there is no
treaty, resort must be had to the customs and usages of civilized nations, and as evidence
to the works of jurists and commentators, who by years of labor, research and experience
have made themselves peculiarly well acquainted with the subjects of which they treat.
To this day, one of the sources of customary international law is the writings of learned
academic commentators, but this is the least often used of the sources. This case provides
one of the best examples of a court reviewing the historical writings of centuries to determine the
content of customary international law. The court found that the practice of nations was that
fishing vessels were immune from capture, and so the United States had to compensate the fishermen.
