A good few years ago, I was desperate for sales after my word of mouth work dried up.
I got hellishly drunk one night and wrote a completely absurd cold email. I was still tipsy the next morning and decided it was still a good idea to send it to pretty senior Marketing Directors at big brands.
To my astonishment, it worked. I got the most amazing complimentary responses and requests for calls/meetings.
My favourite one succinctly said "My colleague forwarded me your spam email and we would like to meet you to discuss opportunities."
I’ve met with senior decision makers at RedBull, Pepsi, Symantec, Hewlett-Packard, HSBC, Barclays and countless other global brands, exciting start-ups and regular ol’ SMEs. Symantec and Hewlett Packard became clients.
All because of a crazy cold pitch.
Every time I sent one of my irreverent emails out, I’d wake up to compliments and people suggesting we should talk.
I’ve used this same style to get senior editors at large publications such as Entrepreneur, Inc, Venturebeat, The Guardian, The Independent, Time Magazine and many more to respond to me and publish my clients content.
I’ve used it to help my friends get as many job interviews as they want - and to meet people I really look up to.
I then started sending the same copy as a letter and followed up with an email. This increased this techniques effectiveness further..
For years, I hated it when people posted my letters/emails on Twitter. I’d found a technique that worked like magic and I wanted to keep it to myself. I won’t bore you with the details but I was in a bit of a depressed rut last year.
I managed to climb out of a bad situation and when I did, I for some reason decided it was time to tell the world about my weird approach to getting attention and responses.
In March last year, I decided to start a Facebook group called Charm Offensive, detailing my unorthodox approach to cold pitching.
I’d just come out of another long period of hopelessness and depression, and just on a whim I thought, let’s see what happens.
I was curious.
Boy, am I glad I did.
People listened to me.
They implemented my advice.
People listened to my unorthodox advice and when it worked, they posted about it.
Hey John, how are you? I'm very good. How about yourself? I'm doing well, thanks man. Well,
I'm so pumped to have you here. I mentioned this before we hit record, but I've been on
your newsletter now for one, two, three years. I don't know how long. I've been a big fan, so
really excited to have you here. Oh, thank you. Well, I really appreciate the invitation, man.
Of course. Would you mind kind of starting with your background and kind of the story of how
this all started? I think people are going to get a kick out of it. Yeah, yeah, sure. So I used to
work for digital marketing agencies in London. That was my profession. I moved down to London
in 2006. Worked for digital marketing agencies, sort of quit my way to the top, you know,
stayed at one place for a year or so and then moved to another. And then after about five years,
I decided, you know, I think I can do this better myself. And I started an agency with my brother,
put my notes in, started an agency, and it all went really well. But then about a year in,
all of my word of mouth leads dried up and I realized, oh, it's pretty important to be able
to generate leads. It's all, you know, I know how to close deals, but I didn't know how to open.
And I had just lost a few clients at the time and I was a bit desperate. I had staff to pay.
And that's when I, one night, I dealt with that the only way I knew how. I got blind and drunk
and for some reason decided to write the most absurd cold email I could possibly come up with.
And then in the morning was still tipsy enough to think sending this to some of the most senior
decision makers at some of the world's largest brands and corporations was a good idea. And to
my amazement, it worked. I got loads of positive responses and saying things like, I never replied
to a cold email in my life, but I had to reply to this one. This is the best cold email I've ever
seen. And my personal favorite was just kind of succinct, which just said, my colleague forwarded
me on spam email and we would like to meet you to discuss opportunities, which I thought was really
funny. And to my amazement, every time I sent this email, it worked really well. I then started
sending a direct mail letter with the same copy and then following up on email. I didn't know
that sending an email sequence was what you meant to do. That was my way of getting response rates
up. And that worked really well. And then I realized that I could use the same style of
writing, this sort of charming way of writing to get more people to say yes to my reasonable
requests more often than what they might be. So that was if I wanted to get my clients covered
in a publication, I could use the same style. If I wanted to get people to events pre-COVID,
you could, or they could do the same with virtual events now. Getting my friends as many job
interviews as they want. I realized that I'd got something here and I started Charm Offensive in
March 2017. I've just got some momentum. I've got myself out of some unfortunate personal
circumstances. And with the momentum of that, decided to start the Charm Offensive Facebook
group, started my email list a month later and it took off. Now I used to collect screenshots
of sharing all my responses to cold emails. Now I collect customer testimonials where
all of that, I get to enjoy the warm buzz of seeing those responses, but I don't have to do
any of the work. So I'm kind of in the best position possible. And now it's my entire business,
Charm Offensive. I've got loads of products that I sell on email and I've got my professional
subscription. And yeah, I can't believe I get to do this for a living. And yeah, it's amazing.
That's so cool, man. No, I love that. I think I must've found you probably from the press that
you got around that crazy cold email that you said. I think it probably was doing research on
cold email back in time and came across you. So kind of you briefly talk about what does today
look like? Is it an agency? Do you mainly sell info products and coaching? You have the Facebook
group. Like what does today look like for you? I've been able to put myself in a really great
position. Like it's pure info products and subscriptions. I don't do any client work
anymore. I haven't since 2018. I've had to make the decision to get rid of my clients because I
wanted to work on this and I don't really do any like high ticket coaching or anything. My diary
is empty other than the things that I want to do, like this podcast and like this interview,
sorry, for your newsletter. So it's all, yeah, all information products and the subscription.
And now my goal is really, I'm always making new products, is scaling using Facebook ads,
just growing my audience and telling more and more people about this way of writing that can
open up opportunities for them. Okay. So can we talk real quickly about like the transition from,
you know, going from, you had a job, then you went out on your own with your brother,
you built this agency and now you're kind of doing this. And what was the evolution of like,
you had the agency, like how did you wind it down? How did you decide that you wanted to
sell info products? What did that look like? Well, there was a number of different things.
One of them was that we just had the three calls of death. We had like three of our biggest clients
leave. And also I was losing enthusiasm at the time for the kind of work. And I actually wanted
to try and become a writer. And then it was because of some unfortunate personal circumstances,
I decided to leave the business and then decided when I got myself out of these circumstances,
I decided, you know what, I should tell more people about that email that I sent,
because I sent that and it works so well for me and for getting clients, for getting my friends,
job interviews, for getting PR coverage, for anything, getting beta access to software that
I liked or ad platforms. And that's when I started the group. And I had some freelance
clients because, you know, I had to pay the bills, but a very, either within three months of starting
the Facebook group and the email list, I'd started selling products. I was like, I want to do this
for a living. Like I'd love not to do, have to do anything to do with clients ever again,
which is funny because I'm selling a product that helps people get clients.
But I just decided, when I saw that Colin of the Cult of Coffee, he's got a Facebook group
called the Cult of Coffee. His name's Colin Theriot. I hope I'm pronouncing his surname right.
I saw what he'd got. And I was like, I'd love to have a business like that. And I love the
atmosphere of his Facebook group. He created something interesting. And I did a paid call
with him. And I've never paid for someone's time before like that for $250 for a call.
But it was a great call. And he told me, you've got something interesting here. Clearly it works.
And you're enthusiastic enough about it that you can make it work. And then I just, I tried it.
And as soon as I started making money, I was like, I want to do this for a living. I want to do this
full time. And I had to get rid of some decent retainer freelancer clients to put the time in.
But I'm really glad I did. I love this business model. It's awesome. It's just so much less
stress. I don't have to deal with anyone. It's great. Yeah, man, you're living the dream, right?
This is the ultimate version success, being able to do what you want and something you're so
passionate about. And it's really clear. So that's awesome. I'd love to talk about your newsletter.
It feels like it's a, is it a daily newsletter seven days a week? Or is it five days a week?
How far ahead do you, you plan it? Like, you know, how much work is involved with each email
you write? Can you walk me through some of that? Yeah, yeah, sure. So I've been doing this
a while now. So I've got, because when I first started, I wanted, I had to,
I had to keep making new stuff so I could sell it so I could afford to do it as a job. So I created,
I've created loads and loads of different products. And sorry, I need to refer to your
question again. I've gone blank. No worries. No worries. I'm excited to hear the answer. But
so like your newsletter, is it five days a week? So it's, it's pretty much every day. But sometimes
like after I've done a launch of a product or a sale of a product, I've sent a few emails in one
day. I'll usually have a day off, but pretty much it's every day. For the writing of campaigns,
like if I come up with a new pack, it's all in a real quick time period. I've gotten very good
at coming up with an idea, getting a sales, draft sales page together, getting it all,
writing the emails and getting them scheduled. Obviously I've got lots of stuff. As I've done
previous campaigns, we can reuse emails that say we've done a launch. We can reuse some of those
emails, edit them a bit and decide to schedule them whenever we want. So there's a lot of
different offers that are rotating. We know that they work and they're good. But if there
is a new product, yeah, it's a pretty, pretty quick turnaround. And I try and write as in the
moment as I can when I'm coming up with new stuff and I'm excited about it. But yeah, it's usually
every day, but sometimes there's a day off to give people a break. Yeah, that makes sense. What about
terms of tools that you use? What email platform do you use? Do you use anything else for editing
copy, anything for design? I know all your emails are plain text, but do you use any other tools
outside of your ESP for helping? ConvertKit is the email platform we use. It does pretty much
everything that I want. There's some automation features there that I'm tempted to go to someone
else for. I use Deadline Funnel for evergreen and fixed deadlines. So it automatically redirects
when the deadline's expired. What other software? For the Facebook group, Relytics for looking at
which posts have been successful and which haven't. For Facebook ads, AdEspresso. I don't know if this
is the... That's some of the tools that I use. Yeah, that's fantastic. People love tools,
so that's awesome. One more question about the email list, and then I want to talk about the
Facebook group. When you send an email, can you predict to some degree of like, hey, this email
is going to get this open rate and this clicker, this conversion? Has it gotten down to more of
a science where it's kind of mathematical? Yeah, you do build up a heuristics of like,
you know what certain things work. Anytime you launch something new and you put new in the
subject line, your open rates and clicks are just going to be way more. So there are certain things
that definitely work, but then there are times where I'll do split tests and I'll split test
something really boring with something that I think is really interesting and fun, and the
really boring one will work. So it's not an exact... I'm not perfect at it, but you can kind
of tell when you come up with something good, this is going to do well. Not always, but you do
gain an ability for it over time, especially when you're always testing mad different stuff all the
time, because I've got the full creative control as well. That's the really cool thing. I don't
have to put anything past anyone or anything. I get to market things exactly how I want,
write whatever I want, design whatever I want. So it is really cool and you get to test a lot
of stuff. But yeah, I've gotten pretty good at it, but nobody's perfect. You can always get better.
Awesome. Yeah, that's really cool. I do want to talk about Facebook from someone's side.
One last question I have. I'm not asking for specific numbers. I'm more asking
with the revenue that you drive, is there seasonality? Is there trends? Is it pretty
consistent month over month? Does it depend on what you're launching? I think a lot of people
that are doing info products, whether they're starting their own thing probably are wondering,
hey, if I'm doing something that doesn't have recurring revenue, how do I make it certain
months? What does that look like? Again, I'm not asking for numbers. No, no, no. Well, actually,
I decided to launch the subscription, the recurring subscription, because I built so many
products, made so many products, because I had to keep making new stuff, because new stuff always
sells the best. Obviously, when you've made something, you can't sell it again, but you've
For me, that's what made me create the subscription, is I was worried that if you
have a few bad sales, it's really, really worrying. That's why I created the subscription.
I would say, because I've got the subscription, it's pretty level. You'll see increases when I put
more effort in. If I go and find some joint ventures and try and do some deals, and they
get booked in, that month's going to be bigger. If I put more effort into creating more new
products, like if I have a month where I decide to create two or three new products, that month
is always going to be bigger. This really is down to my effort, my level of effort. Because I've had
so many different products, different offers that I can schedule in, sometimes I can coast a little
bit if I want, if I want a bit of time off. That's another little cool thing you can do. You can just
schedule stuff in. Really, the difference between each, between month to month is not massive
seasonality, I wouldn't say. I'd have to look at the data, but there's not any gigantic peaks.
It's really around how much effort I've put in. The more effort, then the better that month will
be. I wish I could be super gung-ho all the time, because I'm trying my best not to burn out while
still scaling. Yeah, and again, it seems like you've created the ultimate lifestyle business,
right? It's level, it's even keel, it's cool. That's awesome. Can we talk about your Facebook
groups? Is it a single group? Is there multiple groups? Is the group open to anyone that's
listening? Could they join? Is it a paid group? How does that work? The Charm Offensive group,
there's a free one, that's the main one. I think there's 13,000 or 14,000 people in there.
There's loads of fun ad, funny ad copy, PR campaigns, anything that can help inspire people,
because it's an example of something that's funny and you can see what's good and what's not by how
much engagement it gets. Also, there's a whole archive of all the stuff I used to post about
cold email and LinkedIn. There's so much content. If you go into the tags, you go through that,
there's loads and loads of different stuff that people can go through, loads and loads of useful
stuff. Anyone can join that group. There is a paid group, but if you join Charm Offensive
Professional, there is a paid Facebook group, but the main one is the free one that anyone can join,
and I recommend that they do. That's awesome. I'll definitely include the link to it in the
notes. With the Facebook group, how much of the Facebook group is you pushing people to join
versus Facebook organically showing people your group to others? When I first started, I put loads
of effort into going on podcasts, and I did get some PR coverage. I was directing loads of people
to the Facebook group to get it going, but once I've got a few thousand members, you do become a
recommended group, and you do get a certain level of new people that just join because if they're in
a cold email group or an advertising group or a marketing group or a copywriting group, they'll
often see Charm Offensive come up. The screenshot that comes up, the cover art that comes up in the
little icon even shows one of my responses, so that naturally intrigues them, and I get new
members that way. I do get new members just by the virtue of growing my email list, like through
Facebook ads or through posting stuff on LinkedIn or through PR or whatever, but for the most part,
I do have a lot of success just because Facebook recommends me. I do link to the Facebook group on
my main website, so I do get some growth that way. These days, I am focusing more on my email
list than the Facebook group. It just converts better, and I don't like spending loads of time
on Facebook other than the ads, which is just incredibly powerful. I'm trying to spend less time
on social media because it can drive me a bit mad, so I'm much more focused on the email list now.
Yeah, it makes sense, especially being an email guy, right? That makes a lot of sense. It's a lot
of congruency. One more question I have for you before I would love to talk about getting your
advice and tips on cold emails, emails for clients, etc., but the last kind of question I have for you
before we get to that is how much does a personal brand play into what you do? How much of it is
people buying your content because you're John, the email guy, versus just people like your content
and it's good and peer-respected? How much of a personal brand plays into what you do in the
info product space? I think... Oh, it seems like... Oh, no. I thought it froze in there, but it
hasn't. For me, it helped me because I was able to get on podcasts, and I was able to get coverage
that I wouldn't have if I didn't have an interesting story. I am lucky that I've got that
story. I'm really glad that I was desperate at that time and that all that whole thing happened.
A, because it really helped, you know, I generated all those meetings. It was really exciting, and
A, but down the line, it's obviously been really, really useful to me. So, I think it helped me that
way because the drunk cold email that changed my life, I've used to use that as a subject line to
get on many podcasts. I mean, it's just inherently interesting, so I would say it's definitely
helped, but I think if you're knowledgeable and also you're enthusiastic, those are some of the
main things. If you can make it interesting, like that cold email is not a particularly sexy topic,
but adding humor to it has made it fun and interesting. So, if you can take something
and make it fun and interesting, that's a huge part of it. I've probably done well because when
I go on podcasts and I've got a lot of experience in dealing with people, like in the agency days
and doing pitches and all that kind of stuff, so all that kind of stuff probably helped.
So, I think it's a combination of things. You've got to know your stuff, but being interesting,
it definitely helps. I've got an interesting story. It's definitely helped me. Yeah, no, I know I was
excited to talk to you about that. All right, well, I'd like to end with like one or two things that
are like really kind of actionable or tactical, and I'll let you decide whatever those might be,
like, you know, a subject line or two that's working, you know, how you think about writing
a cool email, like whatever you want to throw out there, like just one or two things that are
actionable. I'll try and give some things that are transferable if I can. I think the first one
is to, when you are more, like the big thing about my email, it was more honest than anyone
would expect it. Well, it didn't have that veneer of, I'm a serious business person and I'm really
good at this. It was just so honest. The first line admitted I got their details from a list,
you know, and bought their data. You know, it was just so refreshingly honest that that really
takes people back. And I think you can do that in any kind of marketing. Like you'll see it with,
you know, when you see really honest ads, it really takes you back and it gets your attention.
So even if you can't be funny, if in your copy, if you can just be more honest than is expected,
something catches people off guard. And also being super honest can be funny sometimes,
especially depending on the situation. So that's the first thing I would suggest is trying to
remove as much as possible. It's not possible for everyone, any kind of stuffiness or
pompousness and level with people and speak like a human. That is, that's number one.
Number two is to, I would say, I can give a little bit of a trick from the email,
from the original DroneCon email. So the reason that I wrote that email, I realized that I used
to stay up watching stand-up comedy when I was a youngster, from the age of like eight or so,
till like 16, till the early hours watching it in sitcoms. And then for a brief period,
I tried some open mic comedy. So I was learning about joke writing for like a year or a year and
a half. So as well as watching it for all those hours, my 10,000 hours experience.
So I knew all of these joke formulas. And one of them is called, the simple one is called the
comic triple. So the pair of three, for some reason, anything in threes is really powerful.
A comic triple is where the third variable is unusual or weird or out of place compared to the
other two. So in my email, there's a line where I go, if you agree to meet with me to talk about
your digital marketing campaigns, I will take you for coffee or lunch or tequila shots. I promise to
be somewhat entertaining. If you're lucky, I may even wear a top hat. So the structure of that first
bit, I may take you for, I'll take you for coffee or lunch or tequila shots. It's that third
variable that's unusual. So it's not like standup comedian funny, but it's in the context of a
business email, who says that? Like if you get that in a business, cold business email, that's
like so unusual and obviously silly. Although two people did take me up on the offer, I had tequila
with them. The key there is that sometimes I'd get invited to pitches just to, even though I was the
wildcard option. So they've got seven serious agencies or something. And then the wildcard
option, the silly ferret guy. But then I would go and blow them away with how good I was, how good
we were and how much we knew and my enthusiasm. So even if you're invited in as the wildcard,
you can take advantage of that. So I'd say it went on a bit of a ramble there. The comic triple
was the piece that I was meant to tell you about. So another example of that is you can get a hold
of me by phone, email, or by deploying carrier pigeons. There's a real simple joke formula
there. Serious, serious. And then the third one is the silly element. So there's a little trick
you can add to add a little bit of humor to your emails and add coffee and whatever else it might
be. It's called the comic triple. You can Google it if you wish to look in more detail. John,
man, that was a fire way to end this. I really appreciate your time. For people that are still
listening, and I'll include all these links that you mentioned in the notes and in the email,
how can people find you? Is it the Facebook group? Is it your email list? Is it Twitter?
Yeah, go to charm-offensive.co.uk. You can put a link in the description, I'm sure,
in the email. And also, if you search for John Buchan, you can find me on LinkedIn.
My profile picture is me rescuing a baby in a basket of burning kittens from a burning building.
You can also join the Facebook group, Charm Offensive. There's about 14,000 people in there.
But I do advise you to go to charm-offensive.co.uk and sign up to my email list. Get the free mini
course or the free drunk hold email template, and then you can hear more from me.
Sweet, John. Thank you so much.
Thank you so much. I really appreciate your inviting me on.
Of course. Cheers.