At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
These vidoes are intended to represent the law at the time of recording to the best of my ability. If there are any updates and/or mistakes, I endeavour to make sure these mistakes are corrected. Where you find a mistake, comment under the video and I will check and make the appropriate amendments.
The reality of law is that it is an ever changing and deeply complex subject. As such, mistakes and updates are inevitable. I feel that this it the best approach for this kind of educational content, given its static nature.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This video traces the historical evolution of the law of the sea, from the early philosophical conflict between \"open\" and \"closed\" seas to the establishment of the UNCLOS framework. It examines how technological advancements and resource competition shifted maritime law from simple navigation rules to a complex \"Ocean Constitution\" balancing national sovereignty with global interests.
In this video we're going to spend some time thinking about
the historical development
of the law of the sea.
We're going to begin by looking at some of the early ideas
and develop forward through to the modern framework
for the law of the sea that we have,
the United Nations
Convention on the Law of the Sea framework
During this we'll also look at some
of the basic principles that had been developed over time
of the sea framework.
throughout this period as well as some of the key cases
that illustrate how these principles are
developed. Some of the principles of course still have
and bear quite a lot of relevance to this day.
And so we can really begin by looking
at the earliest ideas that existed with regards to
this delineation, this kind of struggle,
if you will, between the idea of the open sea
versus the idea of the closed sea.
You could make this delineation between
the concept of the freedom of the seas,
this idea that the ocean should remain
open for navigation and trade and all those different kinds of things.
And then on the other side of that debate,
the struggle on the other side of that debate
concerns this idea of coastal state control,
that states should control nearby seas for
security purposes,
to protect their own resources and also their economic development.
Now, what we will see at the end of this lesson
is that the 1982 Convention on the Law of the Sea,
usually we describe as the Enclosed Treaty,
tries to create a semblance of balance between these two ideas.
This idea of having certain parts of the seas
and the oceans be delimited for the purposes of navigation and freedom,
whereas other parts are exclusively
the territorial sovereignty of the coastal states.
Now for much of history,
control of the sea was not really an issue of much legal merit,
it was more of a practical reality.
Where there was international law, there wasn't really much
international law as it pertained to the sea.
Empires and city-states, mainly around the
Mediterranean, would use naval power to enforce their sovereignty
and authority over the sea.
They did not resort to legal traditions.
So, for example, Rome treated the Mediterranean as a mare nostrum,
this idea of our sea.
Similarly, the use of maritime power was a thing that was used quite
a lot controlling the Adriatic with regards to the Venetian Empire.
And so there was no real law of the sea in order to essentially...
To get to a point at which we are thinking about
the law of the sea we have to go all the way to
the major turning point which is of course the work of Hugo Grotius.
In 1609 then the Dutch jurist
Hugo Grotius published Mare Liberum
which is this idea of the free sea. It is in this work
that Grotius argues that the sea could
not be owned in the same way as that of the land.
One of the reasons was it was because it was fluid,
it was open, it was incapable of permanent possession.
You can't build a house on a part of the sea in the same kind
of way that you can over a part, a plot of land.
His arguments supported Dutch trading interests in Portugal and Spain.
Specifically, sorry, Dutch trading
interests against Portugal and Spain.
Specifically, Portuguese
and Spanish claims to control oceanic trade routes.
Now, we can see here, ultimately,
that Grotius linked maritime law to a broader principle in this regard.
The high seas should be open to all states for navigation and trade.
That is the sort of fundamental principle that was utilised.
Grotius' view would be...
...contested by the English jurist John Selden.
This is not John Selden, this is an image of Hugo Grotius,
who published a rebuttal,
a response to Grotius' work in 1635.
He published Mare Clausum, or Clausum, should I say,
or the idea of the closed sea, okay?
And it is in this work that Selden argued that the seas
could be subject to dominion and ownership.
Especially where a state could exercise control over
that particular territory.
Now, this idea of the Mare Clausum was partly
a response to the work that was written by Grotius,
but it also sought to have practical reasons and rationales as well.
It was partly also due to the fact that John Selden sought to try
and justify British fishing rights in the North Sea,
And eventually.
As the British Empire would start to expand,
try and exert dominance and dominion over
larger parts of the seas as part
of the broader work of the British Empire.
The British Empire was beginning to sort of start up
in terms of its growth and its influence
in the 1630s, but it wouldn't reach its sort of high watermark,
its high point of expansion
until a good couple of hundred years into the future.
But ultimately, this debate between the free seas
and the closed seas reflects the Grotius-Selden debate,
shaping this later compromise
that we would later get with regards to this idea
that some states should be able to control narrow belts
of the sea next to their coasts,
but up to and past a certain point,
the high seas should begin to remain open for all.
Now one of the most interesting early developments
of the law of the sea was something known as the
cannon shot principle.
And this is one of the first illustrations of how we can see states
measuring what parts of the sea outside
of their coastal sovereignty was actually part of their
territory that they could have control over.
Because a lot of the debates that we seem to see
It's debates about.
The amount of the sea that the state has the right to access
and have control over,
how far beyond the coast can you actually claim sovereignty?
Now according to the cannon shot
principle, by the 18th and 19th centuries states
were increasingly accepting the view that coastal
states did have at least some sovereignty over
a narrow belt of adjacent sea along the coasts.
Now, the common historical explanation
was something known as the cannon shot rule.
Now, the cannon shot rule basically said
that a state could claim control over the waters
it could defend from a shore-based artillery.
So however far a cannon could shoot outside of your territory,
off from the coast into the sea,
was how much territory you basically had.
Of course, depending on the cannon,
you would be able to determine how far you could actually
shoot out, but even
though it was a bit of a subjective interpretation, because even
according to how fast
and in what direction the wind is blowing could probably get you
a good few meters further with a cannon shot,
or how big the cannon actually was, ultimately
This idea would become boiled down to a.
idea of a three mile territorial sea.
Now historians do debate how direct the connection
was between the eventual settlement of a three mile territorial sea
and the cannon shot principle
but ultimately we can see that the traditional view links
this three mile limit to the cannon
shot rule.
Even if this origination has been challenged,
there's actually a very interesting paper by the
American Journal of International Law that I'll link
in the description below that discusses this,
if anybody's actually interested
in the origination of the three mile rule and the
connection between the three mile rule and the cannon shot principle.
Now, ultimately, this rule is important,
and the main reason why it's important is because it preserves
this basic idea of the open seas, the Grotian idea of the open seas,
because if there is a three-mile rule or a cannon shot length
that is allowed for the territorial sea for a person to have,
for a state to have sovereignty, then in that regard, the majority
of the oceans and the sea become open and free for anybody to use.
Coastal sovereignty existed, but it only existed close to the land.
Beyond this closeness of sovereignty,
then navigation and commerce was free for everybody.
Now, internal waters then were subject to full sovereignty,
similar to that of land
territory, and then the territorial sea,
being subject to coastal state sovereignty, would
be treated differently to this idea of the high seas,
which would be open to freedom
of navigation, of fishing, and of commerce,
and of communication, and all those different
kinds of things.
Now, eventually, when things become a bit more complicated is when...
Technology makes offshore resources more valuable
and more ascertainable.
So at least in this early 18th century, 19th century time period,
Okay.
The idea of a territorial sea and the desire to have a territorial sea
was based mainly on this idea of a certain degree of security
and sovereignty, that you should be able to have some control over
a little bit of the sea that existed outside of your coastal territory
for security reasons and for other reasons of that kind.
But as technology begins to develop,
it becomes a bit more valuable to have more and more
access to the territory outside of your coastal region.
Because of the fact that there are seabed minerals,
because of the fact that you have
distant water fisheries,
it becomes a more economically valuable resource.
And so there is the desire to eventually start
to push this idea of the territorial sea outwards
and further and further and further.
And we'll get to that in a second.
And so when we get to the early 20th century,
there is increasingly this belief that there
is a need for codification of the law of the sea.
By the early 20th century, this customary law, these basic,
quite spurious, quite sporadic principles of international law
that were saying some things about this part of the sea,
some things about this principle,
were beginning to show how difficult it was becoming.
States were beginning to disagree over
the breadth of the territorial sea,
jurisdiction when it comes to fishing rights,
rights over the continental shelf,
navigation through different straits,
legal status of bays and baselines, okay,
and then don't even get me started on the problems of delimitation.
If you have two countries, two states
that have territorial seas that are next to each other,
such that there can be a bit of overlap, what do you do?
How do you resolve that dispute?
All of this then culminates in the 1930s,
when we get the 1930 Hague Codification Conference
under the League of Nations.
This was trying to codify not just parts
of international law of the sea but other parts
of international law more broadly,
including issues about things like the territorial sea.
It failed to produce a comprehensive settlement however.
The basic problem
was that states could not agree
on how far coastal sovereignty should be able to extend.
Coastal states that recognize
the inherent economic value of the resources outside of
their land territory in the sea will be pushing
for as far as they can possibly get, whereas
other states, states that maybe rely on straits
and passages for freedom of navigation and
for economic exploitation themselves,
will be pushing for a smaller territorial sea.
So as to be.
be able to fish and to extract resources
in parts of the sea that is considered by
international law as free for everybody to be able to utilize.
Now a major case that we see in this early 20th century
is the Lotus case, the case of the SS
Lotus. This is obviously a very famous case
that you will be familiar with if you have already
studied international law, general international law,
on this playlist, on the playlist that we
have on the Law Academy already.
It was a case in front of the Permanent Court of International
Justice, the sort of League of Nations version of the ICJ,
and it reflected more of an older
The high seas principle.
It concerns specifically a collision
on the high seas between a French ship and a Turkish ship.
Now, on the one hand,
France had argued that the only flag state could prosecute.
OK, only the flag state could prosecute.
That was, of course, France.
However, the Turkish government
and the Turkish state claimed that they, in fact, had jurisdiction
because as the result of the collision,
it was Turkish nationals who had died.
This represents a classic jurisdiction, active,
passive personality jurisdiction kind of case
about who has jurisdiction over whose nationals
and the effects of whose nationals and all these
different kinds of things.
Ultimately, the case became famous for the principle that unless
international law prohibits state action,
states may have a freedom to act. And so when we think
about the law of the sea, the treaty law would
eventually move away from this quite broad
And we'll start to create.
A lot more detailed jurisdictional rules.
They will make a lot more detailed jurisdictional rules
for jurisdiction in general,
the sort of law of jurisdiction
of which we have a lecture on that already,
but also rules specifically concerning international law of the sea,
but also private law of the sea, i.e. maritime law,
law concerning shipping and collisions
and maritime zones and things like that.
That all, of course, is concerned in maritime law,
which is a different area that we're studying here.
Probably the most important shift in the mid-20th century
comes after the end of the Second World War in 1945
when we get the Truman Proclamation, okay?
The Truman Proclamation, President Harry Truman is pictured here,
looking quite dapper, if you were to ask me.
And the proclamation comes on the 28th of September 1945
when President Harry S. Truman issued
the proclamation on the continental shelf.
Essentially, the United States in this proclamation claimed
jurisdiction and control over the natural resources of the seabed
and subsoil of the continental shelf adjacent to its coasts.
This is a typical example of the United States just coming
in with quite a lot of force and political power
and exerting rights over things that they want to have control over.
And the proclamation argued that the...
Declaration of these natural resources would be reasonable
and just because the continental
shelf was a natural extension of the coastal state's landmass
and because offshore resources
often extended from deposits within land territory.
That's the basic principle that was
that was elucidated by the Truman Proclamation.
So basically the continental shelf is the part
of the land that is underneath the sea
that is connected to the territory, the land territory itself.
We'll get into the sort of more scientific definitions
when we actually look at it in a bit more detail.
I'll elucidate it in a bit more detail for you there.
But essentially the Truman Declaration
is at least factually basically correct
in the sense that it is a natural extension
of the coastal state's landmass.
Whether or not that matters for international law
is of course a debate that we'll get to in a second,
but fundamentally from a sort of scientific perspective,
Truman was speaking with a certain
degree of sense or some amount of sense.
But what this impact did, what the Truman Proclamation
actually did, was represent a major break from the older rule,
the older three-mile rule,
the cannon shot principle,
or the traditional view of the territorial sea.
Instead of suggesting, however,
that there was full sovereignty over the waters,
the Truman Proclamation made it quite clear
that they asserted coastal state rights
over seabed resources beyond the territorial sea.
And this is something that we will start
to see increasingly become a delineation made
into the future, in future videos and in future stages.
One of the things that is very, very interesting is that often
the case states and the law tries to make a delineation between
the actual sea itself and the resources either in the sea,
like fishing resources or resources underneath the seabed,
the seabed resources or even underneath the seabed,
things like oil resources as well.
And we'll get to that, like I said, in a second.
Of course, the seabed...
It made the seabed a central objective of international law,
and we will get to, again as well, the sort of the transience rules
that exist with relation to the deep seabed, sometimes known
as the area, and really why it is in a state of sort of stasis
at the moment, given that there hasn't been much legal agreement
as to what to do with that part of the international,
of the space, as they say, with regard to international law.
What's really important, though?
Apart from things like the legal claimability of offshore oil and gas,
allowing other states to make similar claims, okay?
Because, of course, if the United States is going to make a declaration
to being able to have access to the continental shelf,
then under what circumstance can the United States argue
that other states cannot do that?
Of course, they couldn't.
But it also created this modern concept of the continental shelf,
that coastal states maybe have.
certain rights over these deep seabed resources beyond
their territorial sea.
The first codification then,
the first major codification that we start to see develop
is in 1958 with the 1958 Geneva Conventions,
sometimes known as UNCLOS I.
We will think about the structure of each
of these again in future lessons.
But UNCLOS I was the first United Nations conference
on the law of the sea.
It was held, okay,
from the 24th of February to the 27th of April, 1958.
Now, ultimately, the conference produced
the 1958 Geneva Conventions on the Law of the Sea,
and it followed earlier codification work,
including the work that came from the 1930 Hague Conference.
Ultimately, as well, there were four major conventions
that were developed and that were adopted in 1958 that deal
with each different part of the sea and the law relating to the sea.
So, for example, the Convention on the Territorial Sea
and Contiguous Zone, the main subject of which, of course,
concerns things like coastal sovereignty, innocent passage through
that coastal sovereignty, and the laws related to the contiguous zone,
a new part of the sea that begins to develop as a legal concept.
You also get the Convention on the High Seas, which,
of course, deals with issues such as freedom of navigation,
fishing, the laying of cables, and also overflights.
Of course, the airplanes become a major issue after the Second
World War as commercial flights become more and more popular.
So, too, does sort of undersea cables that, of course,
existed prior to the Second World War, but, of course,
now is existing and growing in terms of its influence
with the impact of technology and globalization.
You also have the convention on fishing and conservation
of living resources of the high seas, basically fisheries conservation,
and then finally a convention on the continental shelf that sought
to try and address issues concerning rights over seabed resources.
Ultimately, then, this system was the first attempt
at a major convention on the law of the sea,
a fundamental convention on the law of the sea
that would ultimately try to regulate
and systematize the structure of the law of the sea in a way
that can allow for a bit more predictability in the law,
a bit more predictability with regards
to the principles of the law as well.
And so for that, it obviously had a lot of achievements, okay?
It transformed some of the customary law principles
into formal treaties,
which is obviously important.
And, um...
Confirming principles like the freedom of the high seas,
the principle of innocent passage,
coastal state rights over the continental shelf,
the Truman Proclamation being codified into a
treaty system, and also things concerning
the duties to conserve living resources,
something that of course has a lot of relevance
with regards to the relationship between
international law of the sea
and international environmental law and the law concerning
um uh wildlife and wildlife law more broadly.
Now the reason why it's important that you have
a treaty of course is not necessarily
because it's going to become more binding, customary
law is binding on every state,
but because it becomes more formal it becomes more accessible
you actually have the ability to actually confirm
these principles and to and to apply
and to add these some other principles additional principles
into your broader system.
Ultimately, the settlement was incomplete,
all right, so it failed to resolve probably the most
politically sensitive issue at the time,
this being the breadth of the territorial sea. You
have the support of the original principle,
the sort of cannon shot rule of the three miles,
some states wanted six miles, some states wanted 12 miles,
other states even wanted more.
Really?
Yeah.
This is a big deal, okay?
I don't know if you can hear the sound of that.
Yeah, that was great.
I can hear it now.
Essentially, you are trying to make a determination
It's coming.
So let's just keep going.
on how much sovereignty coastal states have
Oh, my God.
So yeah, it's not too bad.
We've got all of our sets.
outside of their territory.
Well, that sounds like it's going to be a lot better.
It really is.
Yeah, I mean,
I'm not sure we're going to have to work together on this one, but that
And the difference between three miles and 12 miles
is what we have here.
So I think it's gone.
I think we've got all of our sets.
is quite a lot.
Yeah.
It's a good few miles.
Yeah.
And so the result here is that there needs to be
Also, the way I see it, when we say,
like, we've got the sets, we've got the
men and the women.
So, does that mean that this isn't like someone who's helping you out?
some kind of codification on this particular rule.
And so ultimately then, what we start to see
is the slowing down of some of these principles, okay?
There was planned a 1960 conference,
the second United Nations conference on the law of the sea.
It took place from the 17th of March to the 26th of April 1960.
The main purpose of this conference was to try
and settle any kind of unresolved issues around specifically
the territorial sea and also the limits concerning fisheries.
Now, there was a lot of substantive discussions
on all of these issues, okay?
UN records show how much was discussed at this conference, okay?
One of the problems, however, was that a lot of these discussions
were deferred to be dealt with in a later stage.
This is one of the sort of main things that we see in this sort
of international legal development, the creation of international law.
When there are issues that are just a bit too politically sensitive
or are completely deadlocked,
you don't want to essentially throw the baby out of the bathwater
and have the entire conference with all the other principles fail.
At the behest of the single principles of which there is deadlock.
So you tend to often defer some of these to later stages.
But ultimately, this conference would fail
to create a substantial treaty,
a substantial development, because it showed, essentially,
that old maritime powers and new coastal states
had fundamentally different priorities.
You have naval and trading powers
that wanted to see navigation remain open
and to avoid things about excessive coastal control.
You had...
Coastal fishing states that wanted to protect their fisheries.
You have to remember as well
the broader historical context of the 1950s, early 1960s.
This is a period of decolonization.
This is a period where there are lots and lots and lots of new states
that are becoming added to the community of states.
The United Nations that existed at the end of the Second World War
compared to the United Nations that existed
in 1960 was a very different system.
There's a lot more states in there, a lot more global south states,
Newly economic states that wanted to secure strong economic resources.
You have archipelagic states and landlocked states that wanted to,
in turn, respectively control territorial waters between islands,
as well as those landlocked states that wanted
to preserve access to maritime trade and resources.
So basically the whole issue is deferred for an entire decade,
the context of the new negotiations
would have to take place in the 1970s through the 1980s
and we'll get to them in a second.
But as a quick interlude, a brief interlude,
I want to just spend a little bit of time
thinking about what the International Court
of Justice is doing during this time period.
Now, these are cases that we will, of course,
explore in more detail in the future,
but there are a number of judicial developments that are taking place
before UNCLOS III is codified before 1982.
These are a number of cases,
the first of which being the Corfu Channel case in 1949.
The Corfu Channel case was a case where
the International Court of Justice
considered passage by British warships through waters near Albania.
The reason why this case was so important
is because it raised issues and questions
about the principle of innocent passage,
especially innocent passage through what
are known as international straits.
So we can see that this is a pretty important dispute.
It elucidates a lot of different principles
of international law of the sea.
It doesn't just come up with one particular conclusion.
So we will get to those as we go throughout this series of lessons.
Another case concerning the United Kingdom takes place in 1951,
the UK versus Norway fisheries case.
It was in this case that the ICJ upheld Norway's use
of straight baselines along its deeply indented coastline
for the use of fishing and fisheries resources.
The importance of this case was the fact that it allowed baselines
to determine where maritime zones were measured from.
And ultimately, the court found against the UK's challenge
and accepted Norway's method in the circumstances.
This case also influences some
of the later UNCLOS rules concerning baselines that we will get to.
And then probably the most important cases,
not just for the international law of the sea,
but for international law more broadly,
concerning lots of different issues about sources of international law,
the idea of customary international law,
basic principles of equity in international law.
These are, of course, the North Sea continental shelf cases.
There's, I believe, two North Sea continental shelf cases.
There's, um...
And they are central to this development of the law concerning
the continental shelf as well as maritime delimitation, okay?
The court rejected the automatic use of something known as equidistance
as a binding customary rule for Germany, Denmark, and the Netherlands.
And instead developed what were known as equitable principles to try
and make determinations as to where maritime boundaries actually lied.
Now, this will be a principle that changes in the future in future ICJ
and Law of the Sea Tribunal cases when it comes to delimitation
and favoring instead a multi stage approach with regards to
delimitation that includes not only equidistant rules,
but also equitable principles as well.
And then finally, the fisheries jurisdiction cases
in 1974 concerned the UK and Germany
challenging Iceland's extension of an exclusive fisheries jurisdiction.
The UK case as a dispute over Iceland's
proposed extension of fisheries,
fisheries limits from 12 nautical miles to 50 nautical miles.
So again, it showed the extensive need
for new rules concerning legal zones and maritime zones.
The eventual answer, by the way, to this question in 1974...
It was the creation of an additional layer
of territorial sovereignty in the sea,
which was the creation of what became known
as the Exclusive Economic Zone,
which I say we'll get to in a second.
And so then this main development
that we have to think about is, of course,
that of UNCLOS III, sometimes known as the Modern Ocean Constitution.
Thank you, Sean.
We know why there was the need for a new convention.
Not only were there issues that did not become resolved
at the previous conference in 1960, nor in 1958, but...
There's also a lot of different new developments
that are beginning to take place.
Decolonization creates many new coastal states.
They all demand economic control.
You see the development of offshore oil
and gas extraction becoming more and more
economically viable. You also have the growth of industrial fishing,
which creates a conservation complex. You start to see
A number of issues concerning environmental awareness.
Maritime pollution becomes a legal issue.
Climate change has started to become a legal issue in the 1970s, 1980s.
And then you also have the problem of the deep seabed.
This raised questions about
who owned resources beyond national jurisdiction.
Questions that still haven't yet been answered, really,
when we think about how these principles are actually applied.
Not only apply to the deep seabed, but apply to other sort of terra
nullius regions that have extensive and quite valuable resources.
You could probably make the same point about outer space resources,
things like water on the moon, for instance,
that is deeply valuable and in fact doesn't necessarily have
an answer to it about who actually gets to own it.
Probably the most symbolic moment came in 1967
when Malta's ambassador Arvid Pardo addressed the UN General Assembly
and called for an international regime
for the seabed beyond national jurisdiction.
The international law of the sea ideas basically provide us
with this jurisdiction here that Pardo notes that in his speech in 1967
we get the convening of the third UN conference on the law of the sea.
This begins in 1973, and so when we get to UNCLOS III,
the actual development, the actual
conference, okay, lasts a very, very long time.
It runs from 1973 to 1982, so basically 10 years, okay.
The final convention was open for signature
at Montego Bay in Jamaica on the 10th of December
1982.
So it took a lot of time to develop a lot of these principles.
The UN states that this essentially marks
the culmination of more than 14 years of work
across 150 different countries
and was the major codification of the law of the sea.
It was additionally also a political bargain.
It allowed for a number of balances that we see between
a lot of different competing interests.
So the political bargain includes, for example,
the fact that coastal states receive wider economic rights
to resources beyond their national jurisdiction.
Maritime powers are able to preserve navigation
and overflight freedoms.
Archipelagic states are able to receive recognition for their existence
and for their law of sea rights.
Developing states, okay,
one of the best and most important principles that they got access to
was the basic principle of the common heritage
of mankind with respect to the deep seabed.
Now, we will get to looking at the structure of UNCLOS
in either the next video or the video after that
because it's divided into a good 14 or 15 different parts
which are all very, very important
and concern different issues and principles.
And I want to just spend the last part of this lesson
looking at the parts
of the 1994 agreement.
The 1994 agreement is important, of course.
And essentially what this does is deal with the deep seabed,
which is politically very, very controversial,
a very, very difficult thing to resolve.
Ultimately, the developed states objected to features such
as mandatory technology transfer and production controls
when thinking about the mining regulation of the deep seabed.
And so, when we think about this area, sort of known as the area,
we get these disagreements leading to the 1994 agreement relating
to the implementation of this part of the UNCLOS treaty.
Now, this is, of course, part 11 of the UNCLOS treaty.
The 1994 agreement was adopted on the 28th of July 1994
and it entered into force in 1996 and essentially it's controversial
because of the fact that developed states
were concerned about these different kinds of issues.
We will see this being interpreted together
as part of our part 11 as a single instrument
and we'll see what the developments have been on that.
They've not really been many developments on this issue at the moment
and we'll see what the sort of future of the area as it is known,
the deep seabed and its resources into the future and what the future
of the common heritage of mankind principles actually entails.
And so we've sort of basically got to the point
at which we are at the present day.
There's quite a lot of things that we've left out
that, of course, we will talk about in
their own separate videos, but this has gone on long enough.
It's a lecture on the history of the law of the sea.
I just wanted to spend a bit of time looking
at some of the contemporary controversies
surrounding law of the sea,
because if you don't know if this is a particularly interesting
course for you, or if you think that it's not that important,
then hopefully this will
change your mind thinking about the different controversies.
The first concern is the BBNJ agreement.
This agreement is just the abbreviation
of the Biodiversity Beyond the National Jurisdiction Agreement.
This is a major recent change.
...that was developed,
sometimes called the High Seas Treaty, by the way.
The treaty collection states that the BBNJ agreement
was adopted on the 19th of June 2023.
It enters into force on the 17th of January of this year, of 2026,
after the 60th ratification, approval,
acceptance or accession of that particular treaty.
Ultimately, what this treaty does is address
a number of different gaps that existed in UNCLOS.
So it created rules about marine genetic resources.
Benefit sharing with regards to issues
and to resources beyond national jurisdiction on the
high sea for area-based management tools,
including things like marine protected areas,
environmental impact assessments,
capacity building, and marine technology transfer.
So this is a major agreement that we're going
to spend a whole lecture looking at
at the end of this series
because it develops on and builds upon the UNCLOS framework.
And it adds a few more detailed rules about the idea
of biodiversity concerning issues beyond national jurisdiction.
Probably one of the most important issues that is sort
of plaguing international law of the sea at the moment
is the disputes concerning how the South China Sea is to be regulated.
The South China Sea disputes show how UNCLOS interacts
with sovereignty issues.
Okay, historic claims.
As well as the development of islands,
rocks and reefs to stake claims towards sovereignty.
Thank
It doesn't decide sovereignty of a land territory.
It determines how maritime zones, land features can generate
when sovereignty or legal status is addressed.
But ultimately, some of the biggest disputes that are existing
with regards to the sea at the moment
are disputes concerning the South China Sea,
you.
disputes between China, Taiwan,
the Philippines, Malaysia, and also Japan.
Are all really, really important in this particular area,
with China exerting increasing amounts of control
and with China and Taiwan having quite a lot of tension,
to say the least, with regards to their individual sovereignties.
You could also make the point about
environmental problems and climate change
concerning issues around the Arctic and also around the world.
Climate change has made Arctic navigation
and seabed claims more important.
You might also make the point that states have used on-class procedures
to claim extended continental shelves where they can show
that there is a geographical entitlement.
So this will obviously be a problem in the future.
The Arctic is increasingly becoming an area
for national security purposes.
I developed the notes for this lesson
before the claims that were attempted to be made
by the president at the moment, Donald Trump,
over the island of Greenland against Denmark.
A US president threatening a NATO member
for territorial sovereignty over an island,
which of course is unprecedented.
Thank
So that is not included in this particular final slide
because the notes were created before that happened
a few months ago, but it's very, very important
you
and it's a very, very important part of the world
that is showing its growing importance
very
with the state of Russia, the Russia Federation,
with NATO members up in the Arctic,
with Latvia, Lithuania, Estonia,
much.
with the growing influence of the United States
with an increasingly imperialistic and territorial claim
And so all of this is very, very important to keep an eye on.
Deep seabed mining, of course,
remains probably the most contested contemporary issue
outside of these isolated issues such
as the South China Sea and the Arctic.
Thank
There are obviously environmental impacts of the deep seabed mining
in addition to equitable interests who actually gets these resources.
Is this just another type of imperialism
for developing states versus developed states?
Again, the area covers around 54%
percent
of the total area of the world's oceans.
And according to the UNCLOS treaty, and according to international law,
those resources are the common heritage of mankind.
Precisely because of this...
vagaries with regards to what that actually means
and how that is going to be regulated,
the Deep Seabed Mining Authority
and its various different rules have not really come up with
a structured codification of what is actually going
to be the resource distribution of those
particular resources, if and when they get access to them.
And then finally, of course, climate change and the issue
of climate change, the existential threat of climate change,
creates a lot of difficult questions about baselines,
about the territorial sea, about the protection of maritime boundaries.
And of course, this is something that we'll have to look
at in more detail in both this series of lessons and in the series
of lessons when we look at international environmental law.