A Nasa Scientist Says We May Not Be The First Civilization

Think Science
73 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video examines the \"Silurian hypothesis\" and various theories regarding prehistoric advanced civilizations. It contrasts scientific inquiries into geological technosignatures with fringe theories about reptilians and ancient nuclear wars, while also exploring mythological cycles of destruction and creation found in Greek, Aztec, and Hindu traditions.
We may not be the first civilization on Earth,
and a NASA scientist says the evidence could be
almost impossible to find. Give it a few million years,
and the planet grinds every city into dust.
Somewhere in the rock under your feet,
there could be the last trace of someone who came before us.
But how would we ever know? And he isn't the only one wondering.
Some people see an ancient nuclear
war in glass found across the Sahara,
while others think a comet erased an Ice Age civilization.
But it starts with an idea named after lizard people from Doctor Who.
Did civilization exist millions of years ago?
What if an advanced civilization lived on Earth millions
of years before the dinosaurs evolved?
That's the question behind the Silurian hypothesis.
It asks whether an advanced society, not necessarily a human one,
could have existed at some point
in the roughly 3.5 billion years our planet has hosted life.
Modern humans have only been around
for something like 200,000 to 300,000 years.
That leaves billions of years before us in which
a civilization could have risen and fallen.
That civilization might have reached
the same technological heights as ours,
or it may never have advanced beyond the Stone Age.
Either way, it could still have existed.
The unsettling part is that there wouldn't be much evidence left.
Over millions of years plate tectonics pushes
the earth's surface down to the bottom of the sea
and eventually back up into mountain peaks.
All that geological upheaval would grind cities to
dust leaving not so much as a brick for archaeologists to find.
In theory a civilization
could have lasted for hundreds of thousands of years
and no one today would ever know.
The oldest large stretch of exposed ground on Earth,
in Israel's Negev desert, is only a little
over a million years old.
So if a civilization had risen 100, 300, or 800 million years ago,
any surface traces of it would be long gone.
So why even bother asking? Why ask whether a
civilization existed that long ago if there's
no way of finding out? Here's the thing.
There might be a way of finding out.
The Silurian hypothesis is surprisingly new.
It was put forward in 2018 by Gavin Schmidt,
a climate modeler at NASA's Goddard Institute
for Space Studies, and Adam Frank,
an astrophysicist at the University of Rochester.
The idea grew out of studying distant planets.
If scientists could spot a sudden temperature rise on an alien world,
they might be able to pinpoint the moment
an alien civilization industrialized.
The logic was that any intelligent beings,
going from primitive to technological,
would warm their planet, just like we have.
That got them thinking about our own planet
and our own species.
Millions of years from now, none of our skyscrapers or plastics will
still be recognizable.
If we did go extinct, some of the clearest evidence we were ever here
might be a sudden jump in temperature
and a strange shift in the chemistry of the rocks.
So instead of only looking for a civilization on another planet,
they asked how you would spot one on our own.
What if intelligent life had evolved millions
of years ago, developed complex technology,
and then, for one reason or another, disappeared?
To answer that, you would study the geological record
and look for sudden temperature spikes
similar to the one Earth is experiencing now after
the rise of human industry.
And one of those spikes did happen around 56 million years ago.
Over a few thousand years,
which is a blink of an eye in geological terms,
global temperatures rose by about
9 to 14 degrees Fahrenheit.
Scientists call it the Paleocene-Eocene Thermal Maximum.
It left geological evidence surprisingly similar
to what our carbon emissions will leave behind.
And there could have been other spikes throughout Earth's history
that the patchy geological record simply hasn't preserved.
Now, scientists don't know for sure what caused
that spike 56 million years ago.
A leading idea is a huge burst of volcanic activity
in the North Atlantic, which heated
carbon-rich sediments
and released enormous amounts of greenhouse gases.
Others have suggested an impact from space.
But here's where imaginations run wild.
What if, 56 million years ago,
an intelligent creature rose the same way we did?
It developed language, built cities,
Slowly advanced its technology and then was wiped out,
maybe by its own hand.
To be clear, Gavin Schmidt
and Adam Frank don't claim that's what happened.
They say themselves that they don't believe it.
It's just a thought experiment.
But they wrote the paper to show how you could test the idea.
It's a fascinating question.
If intelligent life isn't a one-off,
and advanced civilizations tend to destroy themselves,
how many times could it have happened here?
It doesn't bode well for humanity if that's the case.
And believe it or not, some conspiracy
theorists think lizard people were real.
They claim an advanced reptilian civilization once shared
the planet with early humans.
As humans spread out of the forest and into their territory,
the lizard people slowly faded away. By the time only a few were left,
they had become so mysterious
that our ancestors worshipped them as gods.
Believers point to reptilian-looking
imagery around the world as evidence,
from the strange, almost alien bronze masks
of Sanxingdui in China to the
lizard-headed figurines of the Ubaid culture found
at sites like Ur in ancient Mesopotamia.
Some even claim the Nephilim of the Bible were lizard people,
and that ancient carvings show humans bowing down to reptilian beings.
But archaeologists see these figures as art and symbolism,
not portraits of lost species.
Some even believe there
are lizard people walking the Earth to this day,
and that they share their advanced technology
with a hidden cabal of elites,
like the Freemasons or the Illuminati.
Could lizard people really have walked the Earth?
Let me know your thoughts in the comments.
And believe it or not, there's even evidence
of a nuclear war that occurred thousands of years ago,
which may explain how the lizard people were destroyed,
leaving the Earth to be inherited by humans.
Did nuclear war destroy the lizard people?
In 1996, an Italian mineralogist named Vincenzo
de Michele was visiting the Egyptian Museum in Cairo
when he noticed something odd about one
of Tutankhamun's pieces of jewelry.
At the center of a pectoral, a decorated chest piece,
was a yellow-green scarab carved from a strange stone.
Tests later showed it wasn't a gemstone at all.
It was natural glass,
and it was millions of years older than Egyptian civilization.
According to some theorists,
that glass might be evidence of an ancient atomic war.
The glass was traced to a remote corner of the Sahara
and the Great Sand Sea of western Egypt,
near the border with Libya. And that raised a big question.
What could have melted the desert into glass?
Christian Koberl, an Austrian geochemist
who specializes in impact craters,
studied it and found the glass had formed at temperatures so extreme
that there was really only one natural explanation.
That explanation is a cosmic impact,
but no impact crater has ever been found in the area.
So what if the glass wasn't made by something natural at all?
What if it was made by something like an atomic blast?
When the United States set off the first atomic bomb
in the New Mexico desert in 1945,
the blast left a shallow crater a few hundred feet wide,
and the ground around it was covered in a glassy green crust.
That glass is called trinitite.
According to the story often told in ancient mystery circles,
an engineer named Albion Hart noticed
that the trinitite looked just like glass
he'd seen in the African desert years earlier.
That desert glass had first been reported
by Patrick Clayton of the Desert Survey of Egypt.
In 1932, he was driving near the Saad Plateau
when he heard glass crunching under his wheels.
He stopped, got out, and found chunks of it just lying in the sand.
Pieces of this Libyan
desert glass, as it's now called,
are scattered across a large stretch of the Great Sand Sea.
And here's the catch for the nuclear war theory.
The glass has been dated to around 29 million
years old. That's a very long time before any lizard people
or humans could have been
building bombs. Stone Age people
in North Africa used this same glass to make tools,
and it ended up in Egyptian royal jewelry.
Clearly, it was a prized material.
But where did it all come from?
Most scientists think it was made by a meteorite,
either an impact or an explosion in the air
just above the ground.
Recent studies even found microscopic mineral changes that,
so far, have only ever been
found at impact sites.
Still, the missing crater keeps the debate alive.
Lightning has been ruled out.
It can fuse sand into glass, but lightning glass forms
thin, branching tubes that look a bit like coral.
Nothing like these chunky pieces.
Supporters of the nuclear theory claim
that Albion Hart calculated the glass field
pointed to a blast 10,000 times more powerful than
the one in New Mexico.
Keep in mind, there is no published study behind that figure.
But if there really had been a nuclear
war in the distant past,
it would help explain why so little would be left of the civilization
behind it. Believers
also point to supposedly radioactive sites in India and Pakistan.
One popular story claims there
is a three-square-mile radioactive zone about ten miles from the
city of Jodhpur in Rajasthan.
It was supposedly discovered while building a housing development,
with a layer of radioactive
dust and ash just below the surface,
spread in a circle as if from a blast in the air.
Take that one with a grain of salt,
because I couldn't find any scientific report to
back it up.
Over the border in Pakistan are the ruins of Mohenjo-daro and Harappa,
two of the great cities of the Indus Valley civilization,
which flourished around 2500 BC.
These cities feature heavily in ancient nuclear war theories.
The Indus Valley is one of the most
enigmatic cultures of the ancient world.
Unlike Egyptian hieroglyphs or Sumerian cuneiform,
its script has never been deciphered.
We know remarkably little about their religion,
their beliefs, or how their society was run.
For all anyone knows, they could have been lizard people.
Okay, I'm kidding. Mostly.
But it shows how much room the mystery leaves for wild ideas.
During excavations at Mohenjo-daro,
archaeologists found a few dozen human skeletons,
some of them in streets and houses rather than in proper burials.
Early on, some researchers suggested they
were victims of a final attack.
Ancient mystery writers took it further
and claimed the people had died instantly,
all at once, as if caught in a nuclear explosion.
In the 1970s, writer David Davenport claimed he had found
a blast epicenter where objects
had been fused into glass.
Other writers have claimed the skeletons were 50 times
more radioactive than normal.
But this is where the story falls apart.
Later archaeologists found the skeletons came from
different layers and different periods,
so they didn't all die in a single event.
And that radiation figure appears to trace back
to a 1960s Soviet book that misread a British
report about an Egyptian bone, not a skeleton from Mohenjo-daro.
As far as I can tell,
there are no published radiation tests on these skeletons at all.
As for the fused bricks,
Some people point to a meteor airburst instead.
Just like a nuclear bomb,
a space rock can explode in the air without leaving a crater.
But archaeologists say there is no clear evidence
of a giant blast at Mohenjo-daro to begin with.
So the radioactive skeleton is, for now,
a story that keeps getting repeated without any data to back it up.
But there's one more piece of the puzzle
that keeps the nuclear idea alive.
In Hindu tradition,
the god Brahma created a devastating weapon known as the Brahmastra.
It was said to be a single projectile carrying unimaginable power,
able to destroy entire armies.
Some modern writers argue that passages in ancient Indian texts
sound eerily like descriptions of a nuclear explosion.
In popular translations,
the weapon creates a blinding column of smoke and flame,
brighter than 10,000 suns.
Pottery breaks, birds turn white, and survivors lose their hair and
nails. That sounds an awful lot like radiation sickness to us.
The epic Mahabharata even says
a land struck by one of these weapons would be left barren,
without rain, for years.
These weapons appear in the story of the Battle of Kurukshetra,
the great war at the heart of the Mahabharata,
in which the Pandavas defeated their cousins, the Kauravas.
Near the end of the war, the warrior Ashwatthama unleashed
an even more terrible version of the weapon.
The Pandavas won in the end, but the victory came at a staggering cost,
with both sides almost completely destroyed.
Could stories like these be distant memories
of a civilization that destroyed itself?
Most historians would say no,
that this is powerful mythic storytelling.
But it's easy to see why people make the connection.
So what if civilizations have been rising
and falling again and again for thousands of years?
And what if one of them was Atlantis?
Did Atlantis really exist?
So where is Atlantis?
Mainstream scientists say it will never be found because it's a myth.
But over the centuries, people have claimed
to have found it off the coast of Spain,
near Australia, at the bottom of the Caribbean,
and in plenty of other places.
Many believers think Atlantis was the capital
of a global civilization that was destroyed
around 12,000 years ago.
Whether it was rising seas, an impact from space,
or some other disaster, Atlantis sank
and human society collapsed.
In the aftermath, the few survivors regrouped
in other parts of the world, from Egypt to
Mexico.
They used what knowledge they still had to slowly rebuild civilization.
For believers, this explains why things like pyramids appear
in cultures that lived far
apart and supposedly had no contact with one another.
But the whole story began around 360 BC
with the Greek philosopher Plato.
He described the island nation of Atlantis in two of his dialogues,
the Timaeus and Critias.
The name Atlantis means island of Atlas,
and most historians agree that Plato never meant it as a real place.
In Plato's telling, Atlantis
was a mighty naval empire that tried to conquer the
Mediterranean world.
And an idealized, ancient version of Athens stood up to it and won.
He placed the whole story about 9,000 years before
the time of the Athenian statesman Solon,
which is where that idea of roughly 12,000 years ago comes from.
Atlantis was destroyed because
its people became arrogant and hungry for power.
The gods punished them.
And in a single terrible day and night,
earthquakes and floods dragged the island into the sea.
Plato's story was a warning.
It's a moral tale about how a civilization that grows too proud
can be destroyed by its own arrogance.
So why, nearly 2,400 years later, are people still
searching for it? For a long time, Atlantis was mostly a curiosity.
Then, as Europeans began
exploring the wider world,
writers dusted off Plato's story and gave it new life.
For example, Sir Francis Bacon wrote a novel called The New Atlantis,
published in 1627, a year after his death.
In it, Atlantis-style legend meets a utopian society
on a remote Pacific island whose people are devoutly Christian.
I bet you didn't know that the Atlanteans were fans of the good book.
At the time, Europeans were grappling
with a rapidly changing picture of the world.
They had just learned about an entirely new continent,
filled with people they'd never encountered.
They wanted to know how these new worlds fit into the Bible.
Instead of accepting that indigenous peoples
had built advanced civilizations of their own,
some Europeans turned to Atlantis for answers.
They explained far-flung societies as leftovers of Atlantis.
For a long time, a popular belief held
that when Atlantis was destroyed,
some of its people made it to the Americas
and built new societies there.
One supporter of this idea was a French priest,
Charles-Étienne Brasseur de Bourbourg,
which I know I butchered that pronunciation,
but anyway, he collected Mesoamerican texts
and came to believe the Maya were connected to Atlantis.
His ideas inspired Augustus Le Plongeon,
a British-American photographer
and amateur archaeologist who went looking for evidence
in Mexico's Yucatan Peninsula in the late 1800s.
He never found Atlantis, but that didn't stop
Ignatius Donnelly.
In 1882, he published Atlantis, the Antediluvian World, which
presented Atlantis as a lost continent destroyed
by the same great flood described in the Bible.
It's largely thanks to Donnelly
that Atlantis became known as a technologically advanced
civilization of near superhumans.
Donnelly used Atlantis to try to explain the whole of human
history and all of its strange coincidences.
But even if Atlantis was never real, could there
have been a lost civilization a bit like the one he imagined?
To find out, we need to talk about the Younger Dryas Impact Hypothesis,
and the global civilization that some people believe
was erased nearly 13,000 years ago.
Did a comet reset an ancient human civilization?
A large crater-like depression recently identified
in Louisiana is being presented as possible proof
of a cosmic airburst
that exploded above North America almost 13,000 years ago.
Supporters say the airburst was equivalent
to thousands of nuclear bombs and that it plunged
the northern hemisphere back into near ice age cold.
Some even claim it wiped out advanced human
civilizations around the globe.
The site is near the town of Perkins in southwest Louisiana.
Researchers say they found high concentrations of shocked quartz,
tiny metallic spheres, and melted glass.
These are all things that can form in an impact.
Based on dating, they placed the event at about 12,800 years ago.
That lines up with what some scientists call
the Younger Dryas Boundary.
The Younger Dryas was a period of sudden, severe cooling.
After the last ice age, the world had been warming up. But then…
Nearly 13,000 years ago, the trend reversed, and temperatures in much
of the northern hemisphere plunged back toward ice age levels.
It happened so quickly
that scientists have spent decades arguing over the cause.
Some blame volcanoes, others believe it was an impact from space.
Most climate scientists, however, favor a different explanation.
As the Great Ice Sheets melted,
huge amounts of fresh meltwater, including water from an
enormous glacial lake called Lake Agassiz,
poured into the North Atlantic.
That likely disrupted the ocean currents that carry warm water north,
triggering the big chill.
Keep in mind that the impact idea is still very much on the fringe.
Many experts reject it,
and several key findings have not been reproduced.
The Louisiana site is the latest piece
of evidence its supporters point to,
but it hasn't been independently confirmed as an impact crater.
Still, it's dated to right around the start of the Younger Dryas.
If something did explode in the atmosphere,
what might that have meant for the planet?
Supporters picture a large comet breaking apart
into fragments that rain down across
different parts of the world.
One piece may have exploded over North America,
others over South America, Europe, or the Middle East.
It would have been like every nuclear weapon
on Earth launching at once.
It would have triggered an apocalyptic chain reaction.
Billions of tons of soot
and pulverized rock blasted into the upper atmosphere,
choking out the sun for months,
plunging the globe into a sudden deep freeze that mirrors
the exact onset of the Younger Dryas.
The big question is whether people had
already built civilizations by then.
Because if they had, they could have been wiped out.
That is the second half of the theory, made popular by Graham Hancock.
The idea is that an advanced global civilization
had already formed during the Ice Age,
with different cultures in different places,
all connected through trade and shared ideas.
Then, disaster struck. Crops failed, floods drowned the coastlines,
and humanity's progress was erased.
The few survivors were forced back to
a simpler way of life for more than a thousand years,
until the climate warmed up again.
Archaeologists push back hard on this.
They point out that we have lots
of evidence of Ice Age hunter-gatherers
and no evidence of cities or advanced technology from that time.
So let me ask you, how advanced
do you think people were during the Ice Age?
Had they already founded civilization
or is this whole theory a fantasy?
Let me know what you think.
If civilizations really can collapse,
some believe it isn't a one-off at all, but a cycle.
Is human civilization doomed to fail again and again?
Cyclical theories of civilization say that human societies don't move
in a straight line of constant progress.
Instead, they go through the same patterns over and over.
Birth, growth, peak, decline, and eventually collapse.
According to the more pessimistic supporters of this idea,
our modern civilization is already past its peak
and heading for a fall.
Some even believe there have
been many different versions of human civilization,
each brought down by its own collapse.
That collapse could come from nature, a meteor,
a plague, or from humans sabotaging themselves through war and greed.
One of the most influential thinkers on this was Pyotr Sorokin,
a Russian-American sociologist at Harvard.
In his work from the late 1930s,
he laid out the forces he believed drive the rise
and fall of civilizations.
At the core of his theory is something he called cultural mentality.
He argued that every civilization is dominated by a particular outlook,
defined by how it sees reality, truth, and values.
He sorted these mentalities into three types.
The first is ideational,
meaning its core values are rooted in faith and spirituality.
People find truth in the divine,
and their values are based on religious principles.
The second is sensate.
Focus on the material world and the senses.
People find truth through observation and reason,
and their values center on things like pleasure and usefulness.
The third is idealistic.
It tries to blend spiritual values with the reality of the
material world in search of balance.
But no civilization keeps its identity forever.
Sorokin traced Western culture over about 2,500 years
and found it swinging back and forth between
these types. Take the ancient Greeks and Romans, for example.
According to Sorokin,
Greco-Roman culture started out ideational,
with the gods at the center of everything.
Then it moved into an idealistic phase,
which he saw in the golden age of classical Greece,
blending the best of both worlds.
Later, it became sensate.
Faith in the gods gave way to a hunger for experiences,
possessions, and physical pleasure.
Eventually, that sensate culture crumbled.
By the time the Western Roman Empire fell,
a new ideational culture, Christianity, had
taken its place.
Sorokin argued that the modern Western world is a sensate civilization,
and an overripe one at that, after about 500 years.
He believed our culture had become obsessed with materialism
and personal gratification.
He admitted this has driven incredible technological progress,
but he thought it was also leading us toward a crisis.
In his view, a sensate culture eventually undermines itself.
The relentless pursuit of pleasure,
he argued, leads to a loss of meaning,
a fraying of the social fabric, and a moral crisis.
Does that sound a little familiar?
Many people today say they feel more anxious and isolated than ever.
Even though social media is supposed to bring us closer together.
Is that a symptom of the kind of crisis Sorkin described?
And could things like falling birth rates
and growing apathy be part of the same pattern?
Maybe, but maybe not.
Sorkin's theory says civilizations swing back and forth.
An extreme sensate culture could push the
pendulum the other way,
toward a culture that puts more value on meaning and morals than on
material pleasure. Then again,
maybe sensate culture is simply the last phase every civilization
reaches before it gets knocked back to the start.
And if the Aztecs were right,
this has all happened before. The Legend of the Fifth Sun
The Aztecs believed the world had been created
and destroyed four times before their own.
Each earlier world ended in disaster,
and to keep their own world going,
they believed they had to honor the gods
with constant rituals and sacrifice.
According to the Aztec creation story,
they were living in the fifth of these worlds.
They called each world a sun,
and each one was ruled by a different god.
The first sun was ruled by the god Tezcatlipoca.
It was inhabited by giants, who for some reason only ate acorns.
It came to an end when jaguars were sent to devour them.
To some, it is similar to
how the biblical flood was sent after the Nephilim,
who were also described as giants.
Could there be some connection between the Bible and Aztec legend?
Probably not, but it's a fun parallel.
The second sun was ruled by Quetzalcoatl
and populated by humans instead of giants.
It ended when a great hurricane swept everything away.
The few survivors clung to the treetops
and were transformed into monkeys.
The third sun was ruled by the rain god Tlaloc,
and it was populated by humans too.
That world ended in a rain of fire.
And in some versions, the survivors were turned into birds.
In others, turkeys, specifically, of all things.
These worlds are far too fantastical to be real.
There is no way it rained
fire over the entire planet and turned everyone into turkeys, right?
But what if the Aztecs were onto something?
What if, somewhere deep in their traditions,
they remembered that other people had come and gone before them?
The fourth sun, according to the Aztecs,
was ruled by the water goddess,
and it ended in a great flood, with the survivors turned into fish.
And isn't it a remarkable coincidence that the Aztecs,
Christians, and countless
other cultures all described the world before ours ending in a flood?
The Aztecs even had a place where they believed
this cycle of worlds played out,
the huge ruined city of Teotihuacan.
Abandoned centuries before they arrived,
they named it the place where the gods were made,
and they believed it was where
the gods gathered to create the current sun.
In their story, a humble god named Nanahuatzin leapt into a great fire
and rose into the sky as the fifth sun.
And how does our world, the fifth sun, end?
According to the Aztecs, in a great earthquake.
Let's hope they got that part wrong.
Thanks for watching.
When do you think the first intelligent civilization appeared on Earth?
Was it thousands, hundreds of thousands, or even millions of years ago?
I'd love to know your thoughts in the comments.
Be sure to subscribe if you haven't already,
and I'll see you soon for more mysteries of the ancient world.
Bye!
