Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin - Why Lucy Hale Won't Return & Everything We Know!
Nov 9, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Your favorite mystery teen drama is coming back,
but not in the way you expected.
Pretty Little Liars making a comeback
with its spinoff series Pretty Little Liars Original Sin,
and Lucy Hale just revealed that she will
not be involved with the series. So,
keep watching to find out everything you need
to know about Pretty Little Liars,
spinoff series Original Sin,
as well as why Lucy Hale will not be involved.
Lucy's not going to be involved with the Original Sin series,
the upcoming HBO reboot of Pretty Little Liars.
Pretty Little Liars Original Sin will not be starring original
cast member Lucy Hale, according to the actress herself.
The original was an ABC Family series
that started in 2010 as an adaptation of the YA
novel series of the same name by Sarah Shepard.
Since the ABC drama came to an end in 2017,
the show's produced multiple spin-offs,
including The Perfectionist,
which was sadly canceled after just one season.
Hale revealed in November 2021 that she will
not be joining the upcoming reboot,
Pretty Little Liars Original Sin, as fans had hoped.
Hale went on to state that no one
from the original cast is involved in the upcoming
series, as far as she knows.
However, Hale noted that it will be dark, like its predecessor.
Saying, as far as I know, no one from the original
is involved in any way, she continued
to say, from what I hear, it's going to be really dark.
While some fans are saddened by the lack of Hale
and other cast members, this gives the
storyline a fresh start for a new generation,
whipping the A-slate clean and starting anew.
Oh my God, it's so depressing that I already have
to give advice to a new generation,
said Lucy in an interview. But I think it's great.
It's an honor that they want to continue
the legacy of Pretty Little Liars.
I mean, how cool is that? I also know that Bailey Madison,
who's in the show, and I adore her,
will always support other artists and actors,
no matter what the venture is.
I think it's important that we do that because
there's not enough of that.
And I'm as curious as anyone to see what they're going to do with it.
Everything we know about Pretty Little Liars Original Sin,
HBO Max is ready to bring their
A-game with the new Pretty Little Liars reboot series,
Pretty Little Liars Original Sin.
The new drama will take place two decades after
the ending of the original series.
The new show, coming from Roberto Aguirre-Sacasa
and Lindsay Calhoun, bring
Both of whom worked on The Chilling Adventures
of Sabrina will have a similar premise.
The show, which hasn't been officially identified as a reboot,
revival, or a spinoff, will take
place in present day,
20 years after a series of tragic events almost ripped the blue-collar
town of Millwood apart.
In September 2020, the first teaser was released for Original Sin,
which features one strong
message, it's not what you think.
Now, we're such huge fans of what the Marlene King
and iconic cast created, we knew that
we had to treat the original series as canon
and do something different.
Aguirre-Sacasa and Calhoun said jointly
in a statement about the new show.
So we're leaning into the suspense and horror in this reboot,
which hopefully will honor
what the fans loved about the hit series,
while weaving in some new, unexpected elements.
The search for...
A will no longer occur in Rosewood,
Pennsylvania where the original series was set. This time A is
going to be causing trouble
in a neighboring town called Millwood. According to the show's
description 20 years ago a series
of tragic events almost ripped Millwood apart. In the present day
a brand new set of Little Liars finds themselves tormented
by an unknown assailant and we find
ourselves miles away from Rosewood
but within the existing Pretty Little Liars universe.
In a brand new town with a new generation of little liars.
So the cast and where you've seen them before.
The stars of Original Sin include Chandler Kenny as Tabby,
an aspiring director and horror movie
buff with a secret. Maya Ryfko as Noah,
a track star adjusting to life after juvenile detention.
Bailey Madison as Imaging,
a final girl who kicks off the mission to find A.
Zaria as Farron, a ballerina facing both pay
and the microaggressions in the dance world.
Emily of Piles as Minnie,
the youngest of the group and a survivor of childhood trauma
who spends most of her time in the virtual world.
Now, the supporting and returning cast
is already starting to shape up, too. Among those,
Alex Ayanna as Noah's supportive jock boyfriend, Sean.
Mallory Bechtel as mean girl, Karen. Eric
Johnson as Sheriff Beasley.
Lisa Longa as Minnie's mother, who's supporting her through her trauma.
Sharon Leal as Sydney, Tabby's mom, a single mom and real estate agent.
And Alina Good as Marjorie, a nurse, and Noah's mother.
Carly Pope as Davy.
Imogen's mother and Zakiya Young as Cory,
Barron's mother, also a divorcee.
So it's also been reported that Krystala Carter plays Nurse Simmons,
the school nurse, Derek
Klinna playing Wes, Tabby's boss at the local movie theater
who may have his eyes set on her
And Kate Jennings, Grant playing Madame Ejiri,
the strict dance teacher, Robert Stanton playing
Marshall Clanton, the principal at Millwood High,
Jennifer Farron playing Martha Beasley,
the matriarch of her family, Willa Crawford playing Sandy,
Karen's right hand, Ryan Altimus
playing Tyler, a jock
who's the poster child for young toxic masculinity, and Anthony Ordonez
playing computer science teacher Mr. Gardner, Minnie's mentor.
And Jeffrey Bean plays Mr. Smith, Tabby's film teacher.
So release date and production.
Since the series has just been confirmed,
there's no additional casting or release info.
Both Aguirre-Sacasa
and Calhoun Bring have packed schedules as he resumes
production on Riverdale in Canada
and she finishes work on the final Sabrina season.
Pretty Little Liars Original
Sin will likely premiere after HBO Max's other high-profile
reboot of a beloved teen drama, Gossip Girl,
which will begin filming this fall.
Showrunner Aguirre-Sacasa confirming on August 10th that the cast
and crew arrived in upstate
New York to begin filming the series and shared a picture of the set.
The first three of our fabulous PLLs have arrived in upstate New York,
aka Millwood, Pennsylvania.
To start filming in a couple of weeks," he wrote on Instagram.
More pics to come as soon as we announce the rest of our stunning cast.
Their gorgeous smiles make me smile.
Enjoy the fun times for now.
Ladies, The Screaming starts on August 23rd.
Are there pretty Little Liar spinoffs?
So three years between the original series
and a reboot seems like a slim window, but this isn't
even the first Pretty Little Liars spinoff series
to emerge since the show's 2010 debut.
The hit drama spawned two spinoffs,
Liars Ravenswood in 2014 and Pretty Little Liars
the Perfectionist in 2019.
Ravenswood took place in a fictional town near Rosewood
and followed the character of Caleb, played by Tyler Blackburn.
Meanwhile, the perfectionist depicted Allison
and Mona's lives at Beacon Heights University.
The project really clicked with an audience
and lasted only one season each.
Other Shows by Roberto Aguirre-Sacasa
The key creative force behind Warner Bros.
TV's growing Archie Comics-based TV universe
has lined up two high-profile new drama series projects both
in the gothic horror genre.
HBO Max has ordered a pilot
and an additional script for The Shelley Society,
a mashup of gothic horror
and teen romance featuring young Mary Shelley.
Aguirre-Sacasa co-created
with Riverdale writers Tessa Lee Williams and James DeWilly.
Additionally, I hear that Aguirre-Sacasa has a specced script,
The Brides, a reimagining
of The Brides of Dracula about to hit
the premium streaming marketplace, and marks another
collaboration with Greg Berlanti's Berlanti Prods,
which produces Riverdale, The Chilling
Adventures of Sabrina, Katie Keene,
The Shelley Society, and The Brides are the first two
projects to come out of the new mega-overall deal
that he signed at Warner Bros. TV in
April.
Written, executive produced by Aguirre-Sacasa,
DeWilly, and Williams, The Shelley Society
is described as a Victorian X-Files.
Young author Mary Shelley leads a band of romantic outlaws,
among them her lovers Percy and Lord
Viren, against all manners of supernatural threats and monsters,
including Frankenstein,
author Shelley's own iconic creature.
Yep, Aguirre-Sacasa is also set as the showrunner for that one.
Created by Aguirre-Sacasa and produced with Berlanti Productions,
The Brides is a contemporary
reimagining of the Dracula saga.
It's a family drama with a trio of powerful, diverse female
leads. With strong horror elements,
The Brides is a vampire soap about empowered immortal women
and the things they do to maintain wealth,
prestige, legacy, and their non-traditional family.
So there you got it, everything you need
to know about Pretty Little Liars spin-off series
Original Sin, as well as why Lucy Hale won't be involved.
So are you excited for the spin-off?
Make sure to let us know your thoughts down below. Thanks for watching!

