These Contenders HAVE To Go ALL IN at the Deadline

Sports Illustrated
2 followers
Nov 9, 2026
Before we get to Sunday's games, Albert,
let's catch everybody up on what has happened
with the trade deadline to this point.
The latest news, the Jacksonville Jaguars send a two
and a five to the Atlanta Falcons
for Jesse Bates.
Atlanta covers a lot of the salary,
so it's kind of a draft pick purchase for the Atlanta
Falcons.
A little bit surprising, though.
Bates was playing well this year.
He had a couple of really good games.
The Jaguars, though, make it an offer that's too good to refuse.
They had their safety go down two weeks ago.
It was, yeah, I think it was a good trade all around.
Yeah, I love this for Atlanta.
To get a guy in a contract year, a non-premium position,
to get a two for him, I think is massive.
I mean, it's obviously an older player.
Jesse Bates has had a really good career.
The Jaguars were looking for defensive help.
Safety was, I don't think safety was even at the top of their list.
I could still see them.
Adding a defensive tackle or an edge player.
That was really primarily where they were looking
and where they have been looking.
But this is a very big swing.
And Jesse Bates is like one of the most cerebral,
like smart, like cerebral and smart is redundant.
And that's because I was up till 2 a.m. writing last night.
But you know what I mean.
The most cerebral, in control.
All
I'm going to turn my phone off now.
How about that?
There you go.
One of the more cerebral and control safeties in all football.
He's capable of running the defense from the back end.
right.
There's just, there's a lot to like about
acquiring him if you're Jacksonville.
I think the question would be the price.
Um, you know, again, uh, to get a two and a five for him,
I think the Falcons did great.
Once Eric Murray went down,
you figured that it was two tier that they were going to go
for a defensive tackle to replace Devon Hamilton
and then a safety to replace Murray.
I don't think that they're anywhere close to being done.
And as much as I think they wanted to rebuild their pick,
uh, stockpile after the Travis
Hunter trade this year, you gotta go for it.
Like this is, this is the year, the rest of the divisions crap.
Trevor Lawrence is playing great.
Liam Cohen's on a heater.
Anthony Campanale and Grant Yudinsky
might be head coaches next year somewhere else, Albert, right?
So I think this is the year that you got to punch the pedal
and it's good to see Gladstone doing that.
The Giants...
And they have a good base of picks to begin with.
They're doing what the Rams would do,
which makes sense because that's where James is from.
But they're starting to build up.
And that's what the Rams did.
The Rams were willing to move higher-end picks
because they would have so much capital backfilled
in the fourth and fifth rounds.
And that's sort of part of the logic here, too.
And I think, too, right?
I mean, let's not sugarcoat it, right?
The NIL era makes draft capital incredibly difficult to predict.
Incredibly difficult.
Uh, three years ago, four years ago, it was like,
okay, this guy's got to graduate and
come to the, to the professional ranks at some point.
Not so anymore.
You can play in college football for 11 and a half years.
You can collect your pension.
You can retire comfortably as the quarterback at Utah State
and never have to work again.
And so I think that there is just a different level,
and it does kind of sandwich the value.
Now, right, you're going to get Arvel Reese at the top of the draft.
You're going to get guys like David Bailey at the top of the draft.
If you look at even like defensive rookie
of the year right now, it's recent, it's Bailey,
but it's also guys like Jacob Rodriguez, right?
Second round pick.
And so I think that, you know,
and you could say that about most years, I would say offensively
and defensively.
And so I think Jacksonville is like, hey, we know what we need.
We know who we are.
So why not just, you know,
use some of these picks to get established veteran talent?
And that's why I wanted to bring the Giants into this, Albert.
Because that's exactly what John Harbaugh is trying to do.
They had a two and a five on the table for Jonathan Taylor
and then yanked the offer.
I dug that.
I dug the fact that John Harbaugh did not deny it either
when he was asked about it post-game.
It sounds like the Colts are going to basically,
you know, this is going to be an eBay-style auction
for Jonathan Taylor.
Yeah, I don't know about that.
I mean, I would just, I think there's some background here
that I can help with.
I do think, so I would say this.
A couple of weeks ago, they trade Quentin Nelson and DeForest Buckner.
They get a three and a five for Nelson.
They get a four for Buckner and they got,
I think, killed like in the media for it,
right?
Like, like that they didn't get enough.
And I don't think that's the case because both
those guys are aging and both those guys
are in contract years.
And so I, I don't think they did poorly in those trades.
Um, but because those guys are big brand name players,
multi-time, all pro, all that,
they did take a little bit of a beating.
And so.
The sense I've gotten talking to other teams
is that the Colts have pushed everybody back
to this week and basically saying that our owner,
our management, whoever, thinks that
we're going to do better just on our return
if we wait until the 36 hours leading up to
the deadline when teams have already played their week nine games
and have a more full
view of where they are.
And we'll see if that works or not.
But the asking price for Taylor was high.
The asking price for Taylor was a one
or the Christian McCaffrey deal.
Are they willing to come off of that?
I don't know.
You know, I wrote on Friday,
the Giants were the closest offer.
The closest team to getting to the threshold
that the Colts were looking for on Taylor.
The Vikings, the Broncos, they inquired
and they weren't willing to go there.
The Giants got closer.
So is there another team that emerges now?
Do the Giants add a sweetener?
Like, I think all of these things
are sort of what you're looking at when,
and Taylor's a great player.
Thank
But I think like John Harbaugh's approach with this,
which was really interesting.
I texted him last night.
And so I had this in the column.
you
Yes.
I had this in the column overnight and I asked him like,
is this a reflection on where, how you see your team?
for
And.
having
He responded, and I thought, again, like this was kind
of going the other way on it, which I was hoping he would.
But he said, no, that's not how we look at winning.
me.
You're never one thing away.
This is not addition and subtraction.
The math is running on multiple levels of formulas
and algorithms and humanity.
You have to assess your options and opportunities,
seek value, what makes you better short-term
and long-term, and avoid what hinders your team, even impossibility.
It's a case-by-case decision regarding options.
The work is on finding and creating the options.
That's where the stones have to get turned over.
We are building day by day
for what's coming tomorrow and in the future both.
And so.
In a nutshell, what he's saying is
we owe it to ourselves to look into everything.
We owe it to ourselves to take swings.
We owe it to ourselves to pull every lever.
And this goes back to the Simmons thing too.
They've called on players that are not available.
You know what I mean?
Like they've called teams on put
because they don't want to miss those opportunities, you know?
And that's why they were aggressive on Simmons,
whether that was a faux pas or not.
You can, you can debate that, you know,
but like defensive tackle help, like.
If you're another team, why not call the Buccaneers on Vita Vea?
Why not call the Panthers on Derek Brown?
Like now, I think the problem for those teams,
for like Carolina and Tampa,
because they have gotten calls, when you get calls like that
and you engage at all, it turns into, oh, well, he's available.
No, he's not.
Right.
And those teams have to manage that.
But if you're the team seeking the player, why wouldn't you do that?
You know what I mean?
Like, it's just.
I don't know.
I mean, we make such a big deal of the trade deadline
and it's because it creates traffic
and conversation and all that different stuff.
But I do think it's like sort of created
a real problem for these teams, you know, where
they can't have these open conversations anymore
because of the hysteria around every other
player who's mentioned, you know,
you're putting Vita Vea in a, you know, in a Jaguars edit
Like Jersey edit.
And it's like.
I mean, it can cause a problem, you know?
So I would say, like, the Giants deserve credit
for taking these sorts of swings.
And it'll be interesting to see where it goes
with the Colts over the next 24 hours
because Taylor's out there.
You know, my understanding is on Jones,
like they had told teams the call over the last week or so.
Um, not now.
That didn't mean not ever.
Um, but his, but his, his contract, you know,
like, and you look at his contract, his contract
is very tradable.
If they're willing to eat the $44 million signing bonus.
And I don't think he's going to request
a trade out of respect for Shane Steichen, who
he loves as his head coach.
Um, but you know, if you're Minnesota, would you swing on that?
So I think there's just some interesting things,
like some interesting pieces of conversation that can happen
that sometimes get torpedoed
because we make such a big deal out of it outside these teams.
I think that a couple things are going to happen
or need to happen before the trade deadline.
And I think that, again, the Jacksonville Jaguars...
Getting a defensive tackle is not a, it's not a question.
It's a need.
They can't move forward without another defensive tackle,
even though Jesse Bates.
He'll help in a lot of different ways.
I mean, he's a problem solver in the run game.
And so you can, and Campanelli will do a great job
kind of moving the pieces around to make that work.
But you need defensive tackle help.
If you're going to have any serious ambitions
of stopping the run and being a legitimate team
in December and January, you need defensive tackle help.
The Jaguars will get a defensive tackle.
The Giants will take a big swing.
I don't know who it is at this point.
But Harbaugh seems to be in the mindset
that this team is already good enough.
This division sucks, which I agree.
You know, I don't think that anybody's kind of.
fighting to take the mantle here
even next year, right? I mean, the Cowboys
are probably going to be worse next year.
You know, they're going to lose Pickens.
They're going to, you know,
Quinnen Williams is going to turn 30 next season.
Kenny Clark's going to turn, what, 33
next year? I mean, you know, that team's going to be worse.
The Eagles are
not going to have figured themselves out
over the course of one offseason. At least
I don't think so. And the Commanders will probably be starting over
the new coach. So a lot of this makes
sense. I think that Harbaugh will take a swing.
The Vikings
And tell me if I'm wrong here,
but like something's got to happen at the QB position.
Please tell me that something is happening.
I mean, the Raiders have now lost what?
Well, no, not five straight,
but because they had that Jets win in there.
Like, are we really are we really holding
on to Kirk Cousins just to like?
I think it would take something significant to get him out of there.
So this is the analogy here.
And I and I know I do have like a.
An idea of what the Colts have already turned down for Daniel Jones.
What if the Colts turned down for Daniel Jones?
Well, I, I, I, multiple picks, like I
I it's, it's not like insignificant.
I mean, it's not a huge price.
It's not the Jesse Bates price, but it's not insignificant.
Yeah.
You know?
And so like, I think what that message is, is that.
They're not just going to give them away, if that makes sense.
You know what I mean?
Like, they're not just going to give them away.
And I think it's the same thing with Cousins, where, you know,
I think there's like a, in both cases, you know,
like there is a message that goes to the locker room.
In one case, you've got a first-year coach, you know,
with Cousins and the Raiders.
In the other case, you've got a coach
who's now in a really tough situation
where the players might be looking
for signs that he could be a lame duck.
So I think in both scenarios,
there'd be challenges to walking away from your starting
quarterback. I mean, what people have to remember is this isn't Madden.
And these are human beings
that are in these locker rooms.
And when you're talking about having 22, 23, 24-year-old players
that you're looking to develop,
you're trying to create the best environment from which they can develop
And when you're early in your career,
those last two months of the season can be really important
because you're not going to see them for three months after that,
you know? So how they leave
the building could wind up painting how they handle January
and February and March and how
they come back in April. And so those things are all,
I think those things are all really important.
And I mean, if you're the Colts, you know,
the part of the risk is, and I'm not saying they
And they won't trade them.
But part of the risk is, well, you know, if.
Well, if we wind up offloading him now,
what does this look like with Anthony Richardson as our quarterback?
It's a little better in Vegas, of course,
because they've got Mendoza there.
So the messaging would be a lot easier with your team.
But there is an element here of dealing with human beings.
And like, you just.
If you go too far with a fire sale,
you can create a bad environment for your players.
Let me ask you this now,
because I'm wishcasting at this point,
and I know this,
and anyone who's listened to this podcast
is probably sick of me saying it,
but I'm willing to up the ante now, okay?
If you're the Minnesota Vikings,
your first round pick is 30 next year,
at this point, right?
Why not trade your first round pick
for Cousins at this point?
Honestly, I mean, but like.
Oh, I think the Raiders would do that.
Right.
But that's what I'm saying.
Like, you know, I mean, I'm not, that's not reporting.
That's just common sense.
I think the Raiders would do that.
Right.
But like, and I'm not saying, you know,
obviously you're going to miss out on a player, but
like, because what I think, I think because I think,
what is the point of doing this?
If you're going to slam yourself into the playoffs
with Carson Wentz and Kyler Murray,
a quarterback who has a proven track record
in your system that would unlock Justin Jefferson,
Because I think you've got one of the oldest rosters in the league
and you need resources to get younger.
That's the way I think.
That's the way I look at it would be like,
there's got to be a line somewhere, Connor.
You
And they are going to have to get younger.
And do you think you can win the Super Bowl with Kirk Cousins?
know,
Yes.
You do?
Okay.
I mean, do you not?
If that's what you think,
you,
then I'd say I would really think about a first-round pick.
Connor.
Yeah.
Look at Seattle last year.
I mean, Sam, look at like Sam Darnold is, is Sam Darnold, right?
I mean, and it has always been Sam Darnold.
The Seahawks had a, a good run game.
They had an elite wide receiver
that could take off yards after catch and make things
happen.
And they had one of the best defenses in the NFL.
Same formula.
You know, Kirk Cousins is like, you know,
second in the league in touchdown passes
right now.
Yeah.
And he knows the system like you could.
There would be no, you know.
And again, I know I'm pushing this one,
but like and everyone's like a first
round pick for Kirk Cousins.
What's the point of doing this then?
It's like, oh, there's a calculation.
We need to get younger here.
Okay, then you're giving up on the season
because Kyler Murray's not good
enough and we're going to see Carson Wentz tonight.
It's just not, you know, I don't know, man.
It's not good enough.
It's not good enough.
I know.
I know I just play Madden a little bit, folks,
you know, like, let's, you know, I don't mind the idea.
I don't get, I don't mind the idea of it.
A first round pick be a little rich for me, you know,
when the guy's probably not going to be on your team next year.
And now I, but you have him under,
but then you can make him the bridge quarterback.
You know what I mean? Right. Right.
And then you play around in the offseason, whatever you go get.
You spend the $20 million or whatever you need to spend on Mac Jones,
and then Mac Jones, Kirk Cousins, I don't know, man.
Make it work.
I haven't worked out the details fully in my head yet,
and I know that this is not like,
but I would trade a first-round pick for Kirk Cousins right now.
I know that's insane, but it's going to be the 30th pick.
It's going to be the 26th, 27th, 28th pick.
So you trade a first-round pick for Mac Jones?
Because he doesn't know your system.
Kirk Cousins can come in tomorrow
and Kevin O'Connell can unlock the little file cabinet
behind his desk and say, okay, here's the call sheet.
And here's what's interesting about Kevin.
This is, uh, uh, he told me this a couple of weeks ago.
Um, he has, so I'm sure he still has one with Kirk.
He goes into every game with different versions of his call sheet.
And depending on who comes in at quarterback,
highlighted in different sections
are the quarterback's favorite comfort zone plays.
And so whatever, if Kyler Murray gets hurt
and Carson Wentz goes in,
you flip the call sheet to the other one.
It's the same call sheet, right?
But another section of it's highlighted
where it's like, okay, these are the wheelhouse plays
for Carson Wentz.
These are the wheelhouse plays for Kyler Murray.
You don't think he's got a stack of those,
you know, somewhere sitting around there.
Here's all the Kirk Cousins play cards.
Justin Jefferson remembers the plays.
What does it matter?
I don't know, man.
Like, I just think we get so caught up in,
like the Browns have been running a version
of this Ponzi scheme for a decade plus,
where it's like, well, here's the calculation
and we got to get older here, younger here,
older here, younger here.
It doesn't matter.
Go win a goddamn Super Bowl.
I know, I know.
I would just say this.
Like, I think you have to, I think like the Rams,
like we talked about the Jaguars, right?
And the Rams are the same.
And what facilitated the Rams,
Being able to do what they did over all those years
that they didn't have first-round picks
is they had more draft picks than anyone in the league.
They just didn't have their first-rounders, right?
Right.
So they would have three fours or two threes or four fives,
and they would be able to just take swing after swing after swing,
and they wound up hitting on a bunch of guys later in the draft,
Kyron Williams, Blake Corum.
Puka Nacua, I mean, if you go way back, Cooper Kupp,
Alaric Jackson was an undrafted free agent.
I mean, Byron Young, Kobe Turner, Braden Fiske
were all outside the first round, right?
So you go down the list and you see they were hitting
on all these picks outside of the first round,
and that's what facilitates that strategy.
And I don't know, like the Vikings...
I have to look at like their draft capital over
the next couple of years,
you know,
because if you do have a multitude of picks,
it facilitates you doing that.
I just don't think you can be reckless with it.
So let me tell you this.
The Vikings have the first round pick,
their second round pick.
They have a third round pick,
an additional third round pick from the Eagles.
They have an additional fifth round pick
from the Carolina Panthers.
Okay, so.
Another additional fifth round pick from the Giants.
An additional sixth round pick from the Jets.
So I feel a little better about it then, yeah.
I feel a little better about it then, yes.
Yeah.
Come on.
Like, I'm sick of this.
You just want ---- to happen.
No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no,
no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no,
no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no,
no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no,
no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no,
no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no,
no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no
You know what this is like?
You know what this is like?
Here's what it is.
Okay, here's the comp.
You've spent $10,000 taking your family to Disney World, right?
Yeah.
And you want your family to have the time of your life.
You want them to have the trip
that they're going to remember forever, okay?
And then you get to the park, and your little girl looks up at you,
and she says, I want to have breakfast with the princess.
It's an extra $200.
So you're going to sit there, you're already at Disney,
you've already paid the entry price,
you've already paid the 10 grand,
and you're going to look at your little kid in the eyes and say,
no, the 200 bucks is,
that's in the algorithm for another cost down the road. No, like make
memories, make it happen. Push the chips to the center of the table.
Gosh, darn it. Like I'm sick
And it's different for different teams.
Like the Browns, I think it's a legit Ponzi scheme.
Dallas, their owner's just full of hot air
and it's just like a hot air balloon.
And that's different.
Minnesota, it's like, this is it.
The defense is never going to be this good again.
Not never, but like for another 50 years,
this defense is not going to be this good.
Do it now.
Like, otherwise, what are we doing here?
