Capitol Report Full Broadcast (Nov. 13)

NTD
11.9K followers
568 Video Views·Nov 13, 2026
The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) orders an emergency ground stop for all U.S. flights. We bring you reports of air traffic control communication issues and discuss what we know about the disruption.
The alleged spy at the center of the Nvidia scandal has ties to China’s Huawei, according to a private intelligence firm. What does this mean, and how is China using espionage to target American markets?
President Donald Trump speaks on the Nvidia scandal. What is he saying, and why is a top cabinet official moving onto a military base?
AI Generated·May contain errors
Good evening.
And tonight on the Capitol Report,
the FAA ordering an emergency ground stop for all
U.S. flights, reports of air traffic control communication issues,
and what we know about
the disruption.
This is Capitol Report,
live from our global headquarters
in our nation's capital.
Here's Steve Lance.
Good evening. The Federal Aviation Administration ordering
an emergency ground stop for all flights
inside of the United States.
The reason for the stop, unclear as of now, but the agency says
there were communication issues affecting air traffic control.
This isn't another 9-11. I just can't repeat that enough.
People are making that assumption
because that's the last time we had a nationwide ground stoppage.
This is a telecommunication outage. This is much different.
Secretary of Transportation Sean Duffy says FAA technicians
are investigating the issue.
This is the second nationwide ground stop since
the September 11th attacks.
The other happening in January of 2023 during a computer outage
and for the latest on the
official response we bring
in NTD's Washington correspondent Jack Bradley on this. Jack good
evening talk to us what are federal officials saying right now?
Well right now they're saying
that there's no clear indications whether
or not this was a threat but they want to make sure that
they get the message out so we're hearing multiple reports
that they will be holding a press
We'll have a press conference very soon
on this, possibly at the White House.
Now, as for Secretary of Homeland Security,
he held a press conference on this earlier,
saying that President Trump has been briefed on this.
Mullen says there aren't any clear indications
as of now what caused this,
whether it was AI or SI that played any part.
But he did say that there is no indication
the outage was the cause of a nefarious act.
All flights are currently accounted for.
He says that it is not connected to yesterday's Microsoft outage.
Here's Mullen earlier.
There is no indication
and we had no reason to believe that as of right now
that this was a threat to the United States.
This was a telecommunication outage throughout FAA.
But as I will repeat myself, there was no prior indication.
There was no indication as of yet
that this was a nefarious attack against us.
Now, Mullen also told reporters there earlier
that the outages knocked out some radio and radar at air traffic
control centers starting in Chicago, New York and Boston.
But as for how long this outage will last, that remains undetermined.
Here he is. We have not discussed.
Any time frame. I'll just think about this as a whole.
If I have a loved one at the airport,
just to get everybody started back up and the flights going again,
it's going to take some time. And so this isn't going
to just be resolved and turned around within the hour.
And Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy says
that the ground stop was the result of a
telecommunications outage.
There's currently thousands of delays and hundreds of flights
canceled. We know that over 3,100 aircraft bound
for U.S. airports were in the air when the
nationwide ground stop was ordered.
That's according to Live Air Traffic Radar Service
Flight Radar 24. Now, in a separate incident,
The president has commented
on a tanker striking a river cruise paddle boat
with around 130 passengers in New Orleans.
President Trump just released a statement on that crash,
thanking the Coast Guard Governor Jeff Landry,
saying that it was incredible that no one was killed in this incident.
32 people, however, are in the hospital.
As for President Trump's comments on the FAA,
he has not responded as of yet.
And Steve, right now, we are still waiting on that press conference.
To take place, to give us more updates on what's going on.
We'll be monitoring that.
Great reporting, Jack.
We'll bring the audience
and our viewers that press conference when it does happen.
In the meantime, we go now live to NTD's Fiona Ji,
who's at Reagan National right here in
Washington.
Fiona, what is happening there on the ground?
What are you hearing?
Well, Steve, first of all, the latest news that we're hearing
in terms of any flights getting off the ground
is from the official San Francisco International Airport X account,
where they're saying that the SFO confirms
that Pacific bound flights are now cleared to depart from SFO,
including destinations in Hawaii and Asia.
But when we're talking about right here in Reagan National Airport.
Nothing is going on.
Nothing is getting off the ground.
Steve, if you take a look right behind me,
you can see the departures board and you'll
see all of those orange or red stripes.
Those are canceled flights.
The majority you'll see, they're all yellow.
They're delayed.
They're delayed by two hours, six hours, some even more.
There are a couple that seem to stay on time.
They're from American Airlines.
But I asked an American Airlines employee and he says,
no, that is not accurate.
They might just not have changed that.
As far as he is concerned, American Airlines has
no outgoing flights right now from Reagan International Airport.
Rather, I also asked the American
Airlines worker what he's been hearing.
He says he has no idea.
All he was told was that no flights are taking off,
and that's what he's been telling passengers.
He says, you know, the airline itself doesn't really know
the reason why as well, or at least they're not telling.
employees at all because this is an FAA issue.
I also had a chance to speak with some passengers.
There's an overall sense of just uncertainty
and just a sense of not knowing what to do next.
One lady I spoke with, she was supposed to be out
on a flight to a business conference in Cincinnati.
She said her flight got delayed and then it got canceled.
She's debating what to do next. I spoke
with another couple. They were supposed
to be out on a flight to Florida for a wedding.
They said it just kept getting pushed back and pushed back.
They didn't say their flight was canceled just yet,
but they didn't know if it was going to get canceled.
So these people, you see them sort of standing around,
milling around in the departure area.
They're holding off on going to security check just yet,
just in case their flights do get canceled.
At least if they haven't gone through security,
they have the flexibility of leaving and maybe coming back later.
But just overall, Steve, a sense of not really knowing what's going on
and what's going to happen next.
Over here in Reagan National Airport. Back to you.
NTD's Fiona Gee reporting live from Reagan National. Thank you, Fiona.
And with that said, we just don't know when the flights will resume.
We heard from Homeland Security Secretary
Mark Wayne Mullen saying even once they do,
it's going to be hard
to tell how quickly things will get off the ground.
So most people are right now expecting delays into the weekend.
This is affecting passenger planes and cargo planes.
So packages and various other reverberations will be felt from this.
From Secretary of Transportation, Sean Duffy,
he says the FAA issued a nationwide ground
stop for all U.S. airports following communication
issues impacting all air route traffic control
centers, and FAA technicians are investigating the issue,
will be tracking these updates
throughout the evening.
From the FAA directly,
they have posted on X saying there has been a temporary communications
outage.
Out of an abundance of caution, all flights have been halted.
Every flight has been accounted for,
and international flights will be handled on a case-by-case basis.
For the latest on the nationwide ground stop for all U.S. flights,
joining us now to discuss Darren Mott,
retired FBI supervisory special agent
and co-founder of the security firm Five Eyes.
Darren, it's great to have you with us.
Talk to us.
When you heard every en route center losing communications all
at the same time, what
was your first thought as an investigator?
Well, it's similar to what I thought with the Microsoft
Outlook outage yesterday, is it's one of three things.
It's human error. Someone did something incorrectly and it caused
a cascading effect across all of these communication centers.
It's a software or hardware error that did the same thing, or it's some
kind of nefarious action by a criminal or a state-sponsored actor.
Those are the three things. It could be a combination of one and two,
could be a combination of two and three.
And right now, the FAA and all the entities
that are doing the incident response are in
the middle of that.
And as we've heard from everybody so far, no one really knows.
Ultimately, hopefully they will know.
And the key thing I would want to see from this is.
What exactly happened?
Because we need to share that intelligence with the rest of the globe,
because how many other air traffic control facilities
in global airports or global nations
mirror what we do here?
Could they have that same potential vulnerability that no one's asking
about? And from an investigative perspective,
you've got all the three-letter agencies, FBI,
CIA, NSA, all the U.S. intelligence entities.
Viewing their feeds and their analysis stuff
and looking for any signs of someone claiming
credit or any chatter that indicates that this was a nefarious attack.
Is it going to want to really rule that out?
I know they've mostly ruled it out, but I don't think they really know.
And we may have a different story in the morning.
You know, there have been very few nationwide ground stops in history,
three since 9-11, if you include that day,
9-11, one in 2023, now this one.
What kinds of technical
or security concerns could warrant a shutdown of this scale?
Well, the key thing is not being able
to communicate with the planes so that they
don't know where the other planes are.
So if you can't tell the planes, hey, you're too low or
you're too high, you've got another plane on this side,
you've got another plane here, you're
landing, but there's a plane on the runway.
So being able to communicate with thousands of planes
in the air at one time is a necessity, obviously.
And if they can't do that, if Chicago can't
communicate with New York or New York
can't communicate with Cincinnati.
That no one knows where anybody's going to.
So I can understand them wanting to take all the planes down
because they don't want to have them crashing into each other
or having problems on landing because no one heard anything.
So those would be the key thing.
Communication, obviously, is probably the number one priority
when it comes to air traffic.
Now, officials have called
this a telecommunications outage with no sign
of anything nefarious as of yet.
What does no indication yet mean this early in an investigation?
And when we're talking about bad actors,
we are at war with Iran, who, from what I understand,
has formidable cyber capabilities.
There's also China, which is a proxy or vice versa,
in aiding Iran to a certain degree.
What type of capacity do our adversaries have
to carry out something like this?
Well, I think they certainly have all those capabilities
because all this technology is
built on interconnected communication platforms
that have internet connections, that have
vulnerabilities that people don't patch
in the right amount of time. And you have some of these
systems or legacy systems, which may not be able to be patched.
I know that they're updating their
systems to this new smart technology.
And that company has said, this is not us. But certainly
when they say there's no indication of nefarious
activity, that just means they don't know.
Because again, we're only four hours into this.
They're still in the middle of doing incident response.
They have probably still don't know exactly what's happening.
No one's come out and said, this is exactly what has happened.
This is what we're doing to fix it.
And this is the time it will be fixed.
So no one knows.
So like I said earlier, you could come back and say,
well, we found some actor in this
particular system doing stuff.
I'm speculating that I'm not saying that has happened,
but it's not outside the realm
of possibility to be something to think about.
You're going to have a lot of people online on Twitter
and wherever saying, oh, it's got
to be this,
it's got to be this, and that's going to confuse everything.
But ultimately, there'll be a final report that says,
here's exactly what happened.
And hopefully, ideally, they share all this.
This one instance is where transparency is key
when it comes to a postmortem of this
type of incident.
How long does it usually take to rule
a cyber attack in or out with confidence?
A day or two, you've got to go through a lot of log files.
You've got to make sure that those files are accurate.
No one has altered them.
You have to look at who has access
to the systems that are having the problems.
You've got these control systems.
Okay, who has access to them?
Let's go through the access log files
and say who connected when and where,
and what did they do when they connected?
Who is this IP address in Mongolia connecting?
You know, you got to find all those inconsistencies
and rule them out or rule them in to determine
what that looks like.
And this could take quite, it's not, we're not going to know tonight.
I don't think we would know tomorrow.
We'd be lucky if by Monday we had a pretty good idea.
I would think that by Sunday they can rule out nefarious activities.
That's got to be the first thing they're looking at bringing.
And they're bringing in, I would guarantee they're bringing
in third party cybersecurity
experts like CrowdStrike or Mandiant.
Or whoever, to look at this and really dive into this with a lot
of resources to very quickly identify whether
this was a nefarious action or just some kind of technical glitch.
Darren Mark, you're a former FBI supervisory agent.
Walk us through the first hours. Who's in the room right now?
FBI, CISA, FAA, the telecom carriers?
Yeah, all those people.
FBI is going to be in the room in the event that they find the
nefarious activity. The FBI is not going to be doing the forensics
and looking through all of those
things. CISA is not going to be doing that either.
Like I said, this is going to be a third party
professional incident response team that comes in to do that.
And the government entities are there
to provide support where needed.
If you've got information that leads to some IP address outside
the country, that's where the government entities have capabilities
to quickly resolve what that
CrowdStrike can't say that this IP address in China,
they may not know what it is, but
maybe there's intelligence that the
government has that can provide that.
So there's a sharing between the private
and the public sector entities to very quickly
determine what the cause of this is,
because when they determine the cause, that determines
the next steps to take.
If it's a nefarious actor, then FBI investigation will start up,
NSA monitoring of information
they have will go deeper.
If it's just.
You know, this particular server went bad
and it caused a cascading effect, then, you
know, then it's going to be, how do we fix that?
And then the government entities that would assist
with updating those would assist the
FAA, but it'd probably move more to a public sector kind of thing.
So this first 24 hours is very key
because you've got to determine what's the cause,
and that would determine the response for the federal authorities.
And if indeed there is no nefarious activity,
which there's no indication right now,
according to officials, that there is,
what is the recourse to make sure that this does not happen
again? That is a great question.
And that's where the postmortem that says, here's exactly what
happened and everybody can know it.
Because if they hide any part of it, all we're going to see
is congressional testimonies. Why didn't you know this?
What do we know? It's going to be all that
stuff that gets in the way.
So there's got to be full transparency as to here's what the problem
Here's what we identified it to be,
and here's how we're going to fix it, and here's the
redundant things we'll put in place
so that it doesn't happen again, because clearly there
was no redundancy here,
or the redundancy was overcome by the cascading effects, so
they've got to figure what that is and resolve it going forward.
I don't know if you remember.
I remember years...
20 years ago, there was a big outage on the East Coast,
turned out to be a fire at a substation.
But again, they learned from that.
You haven't had anything since then.
So you can learn from this and do better from it going forward.
But it's unfortunate it has to come to this type of... you know
huge event that grounds every aircraft to learn from.
They should have learned from it before.
But again, you know, technology is constantly changing.
AI is making it easier to find the problem. So
bring in some AI and look for other vulnerabilities.
Have AI do some testing
within a secure environment and capability.
It doesn't break it additionally,
but you've got to find these vulnerabilities
and patch them so you don't have these problems.
Just how extraordinary of an event is this?
We mentioned at the top of the program,
this is the third time, if you include 9-11,
there was a computer glitch in 2023. But for the country
to shut down all air traffic and a complete ground stop,
how extraordinary of an event is this?
It's huge. Think of the long-term ramifications come Monday.
What's going to happen to airline
stocks on Monday? Airlines had nothing to do with this,
but people aren't going to look at it that
way. They're going to look, they were inconvenienced,
stuck in an airport, I'm selling my United Air
stock or whatever. They're going to have
those downstream impacts. That's why the transparency
needs to be key because everybody's going to know about this.
Probably everybody watching this knows
someone stuck in an airport
or will have heard a story of someone stuck in an airport or trying
Trying to find a car.
to get where they're going to or their favorite
college football team can't play tomorrow
because they couldn't get to where they were going.
So it's going to have impacts over the weekend.
And this, you know, this is in order.
Because the FAA grounded every airline,
that means the communication problem was huge
and problematic, that they had to take
a look at what is the risk of doing this,
and they determined the risk to ground every plane was worth it
because of whatever the
risk was they were looking at.
So that kind of gives you an indication of how bad they thought
this could be in that event. Former FBI supervisory agent,
Darren Mott, we greatly appreciate your insights. Thank you.
And just before four o'clock Eastern,
the FAA ordered every airport in the country to hold
departing flights. The agency blaming
a telecommunications outage at the moment that
hit the regional centers that guide planes between cities,
planes already in the air.
Our landing safely, Homeland Security Secretary
Mark Wayne Mullen says there is no indication
this was an attack.
Tonight, we're looking at what failed and when flights will move again
and why this is happening.
Nationwide ground stops are rare, extraordinarily rare. This is
only the third in U.S. history,
the first coming after the September 11th attacks. The second was
It was in January of 2023 when an FAA pilot.
Alert system failed because of a contractor error,
so we're keeping our eyes out for all
possibilities this evening as information continues to come in.
Officials say there's
no sign of an attack tonight, but it is raising a bigger question.
What do America's adversaries
learn when they watch a moment like this?
Here to discuss, former CIA officer Rick De La Torre.
Rick, great to have you back with us.
From an intelligence perspective, what was your first
That's a great question.
At first, I thought, okay, well,
this seems like it could be an adversarial attack.
On our transportation system,
all indications are that that's not the case.
I'm very, very happy to hear that.
But my concerns extend far further than what's occurring today.
If you look at the technologies that we use within the FAA,
they're rather antiquated.
Um, there.
They still operate on floppy disks.
Thank
In fact, the folks that operate
these systems now are younger, were born after.
You know, many of these systems have been up and running and operating.
you
So our air traffic control systems and radars and our entire.
very
Web of how air travel happens in the United States needs
a significant upgrade into the 21st century.
much.
Now, you know, our adversaries are advancing technologies and AI,
quantum and a number of other things
that that could really wreck havoc on not just our air travel,
but a number of other critical industries within our country.
So this provides them an opportunity to see how we react,
what it means economically.
What it means to our ability to move around
and how we alert things and how we respond.
Once they have that information,
then they can adjust and adapt and come up with,
sadly, more nefarious plans
that could actually cripple us in more than one way.
Rick, to that point, officials do say that there is
no sign of nefarious attack on this incident as of yet.
How is the intelligence community processing this?
Are they quietly checking whether any foreign actor was involved?
Sure. So right now, obviously,
the entire intelligence community is focusing on existing sources,
whether those are human sources or signals intelligence
or satellite intelligence or a whole host of different sources,
monitoring social media and seeing if there's anyone out there
with credibility taking credit for this type of attack.
And then investigating those issues,
they'll be working with our friendly liaison services around the world
and see if they're monitoring anything or if they're aware
of any potential forces behind these kinds of efforts.
And if that's the case, I'm sure they'll work very effectively to
report that information to policymakers and law enforcement and others.
And Rick, when something like this happens,
something this major, do countries like China
and other adversaries, perhaps Iran,
view our aviation infrastructure as a strategic
target?
What would they stand to gain, not only from disrupting it,
but perhaps just sort of watching
how we handle it in the aftermath?
Well, sure. I mean, look,
if you interrupt our ability to travel within the United States,
the effects of that is paralyzing, obviously.
Not just for holiday travelers or business
folks heading out to conventions or meetings,
but obviously the cargo that's involved in that,
the-
Travel from international airports coming
and going into the United States.
It would have a chilling effect on air travel,
obviously, and it would take years to recover.
It would be very akin to what occurred after 9-11.
Furthermore, then, what happens is it funnels everyone
into different modes of travel then, right?
Like train and rail, car on interstate highways.
Which now provide additional target opportunities for our adversaries.
And Rick, we did see that tragic aircraft crash
into the military helicopter about a week
or two into President Trump's second presidency,
the one that we're in right now, which sparked a major discussion
with the Department of Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy about.
sort of rehabbing and rehauling,
a complete overhaul of all those systems that you mentioned.
How critical is it that we do that,
but do it at a pace that doesn't result in an incident like this?
Well, I think it may be too early to tell whether any kind
of overhaul may have caused this system.
Again, we're talking about systems that are decades old,
and it isn't something that can
be resolved in a year or two.
It takes years of planning, years of design work, because it also
has to be safe and secure
and prevent our adversaries from being able to sabotage or
Or mess with these systems.
So what that means is it is a slow process of rolling this out
because you don't want to interrupt day-to-day travel
at the same time as you do this.
I have every confidence in the fine men
and women at FAA and the Department of Transportation
who are looking out for this.
What we ought to do is make sure that our policymakers
Thank
provide the resources, funding,
and guidance to make sure that we remain the safest place to
travel in the world. A lot of folks are very happy
to accept 99% success rates in just about any
you.
But you can never accept a 99% success rate in aviation.
If that was the case, there'd be thousands of air incidents every day.
So we run a nearly perfect air system every day,
every hour of the year.
And we do that because we know what we're doing
and we take safety first, like we did in this case.
To be able to maintain that and protect it against
our adversaries now in the 21st century,
we need to think ahead.
AI, quantum, a number of new technologies can really undermine
these systems very quickly.
And Rick, lastly, which countries would you say have
the capability to target
our aviation infrastructure?
And I guess a more important question perhaps would be,
which ones would you say we should
be watching closely that may have intent?
Without a doubt, China. China is the largest threat out there.
It would be something that
China would want to focus on.
China would recognize that it would obviously cripple
I'm not going to cripple.
not just our air travel, but our ability to ship.
It would be a horror story within our economy and
stock market. It would lead to a cascading effect
that would impact a number of different industries.
And that is the sort of thing that if China wanted to do,
they certainly have the capability to do so.
The People's Republic of China has a number of PLA soldiers that are
specifically targeting every network system within the United States.
And I'm not being hyperbolic.
I mean every network system within the United States.
That includes everything in law enforcement,
everything in government, everything in...
In food handling, pharmaceuticals, oil and gas,
air systems, and that's their goal.
Their goal is to get into those systems,
wreak havoc, and steal any intellectual property,
do all of those things whenever they wish they can do.
So we always have to be a step ahead and defend ourselves.
And this is very difficult.
In conventional warfare, you can count tanks and airplanes,
and you can use satellite imagery
to see what the enemy has up their sleeves.
In this case, you really can't, you know, these are servers
and computers and buildings and, and it takes very, very, you know,
special techniques and skill sets from intelligence organizations
to get into these systems and understand what the capabilities are.
And if we give that up, if we start focusing on other things,
that's ceding significant opportunities to the Chinese.
Who can cripple us if they wanted to, if we don't defend against it.
Rick, I just have to follow up.
You brought up a lot of interesting points.
When we're talking about looking at patterns over
the past couple of days, a lot of significant
occurrences have taken place.
When you look at Microsoft having a major outage,
when you look at what happened with NVIDIA's CEO linked to China,
talk to us about the asymmetric sort
of reverberations that are felt from
Maybe these series of incidents, if we're looking at patterns,
it's not just about the NVIDIA CEO.
It's about our largest tech company who is under a microscope now
with the stock market tethered to their success to a certain degree.
And then you just mentioned,
as you pointed out here, our airline industry,
the effects that it could have on that from an economic standpoint.
And the fact that all of these things are sort
of lined up, is that something that we
should be looking at?
We need to be focused on that every day.
Allow me to remind you what happened during
the COVID incidents back in 2020, when I think
I think it was like 10 folks,
10 longshoremen at a port in Shanghai came down with COVID.
And you fast forward just a few days,
there's hundreds of container ships parked outside
of Los Angeles port that can't come into the United States.
And the effect that that had on a number of goods
and supplies that we needed within the United States.
All those things were connected,
and that's the interconnectedness of the world we live in.
Sadly, I think for the last two or three decades,
the United States has allowed our adversaries to play an integral part.
And our supply chains and a lot of those critical industries,
and what that means is that they can, you know,
can cripple us if they choose to in certain ways.
And it has a rippling effect, right?
Investors would immediately pull out.
People would have safety concerns.
Trade would come to a near halt.
And there's really no way to solve those things without
the assurances that people feel safe
and that they can continue to live about their life.
So, you know, those are the kinds of things that our adversaries study
and they want to try to do when,
you know, whenever they choose to do so.
Our job is to defend against those things.
Now, your comment about, you know,
the recent string of issues that have come up, like the Microsoft...
And, um, uh, um,
Downage and the recent tanker that has gotten into a crash.
Oh,
Look, I see when there's individual data points
and they do have significant effects on.
my
The United States at the national level
and within specific industries, it begs the question,
gosh.
I should, you know,
are these things related? Are they connected somehow?
Is someone behind it? Now, we must say
that at this stage, that doesn't seem to be the case.
And I really do hope so that that really
isn't the case. But that doesn't mean that we shouldn't prepare
or defend against that
possibility. We certainly want to be ahead
of any kind of effort like that from our enemies.
And make sure that it's not just China too,
but it could be Russia, it could be Iran,
it could be a criminal syndicate somewhere
in Eastern Europe. One doesn't know.
But one of the greatest things that has happened
is that there's now this balancing or equal effect
or capability from smaller adversaries and much larger adversaries.
In other words, if a teenager in Bosnia can steal millions
of dollars in crypto money sitting in their basement,
that's something that we need to be prepared for.
Now, imagine what a nation state with billions
of dollars of resources like China and tens
of millions of individuals working within the PLA
or the government, if they're focused
on doing something.
Those are resources that sadly here in the West, we don't consider.
Really excellent points.
Scary stuff.
Former CIA officer Rick DeLaTorre, greatly appreciate you joining us.
Thank you.
In our top story, we continue to follow the nationwide ground stop,
which remains in effect as we speak.
The FAA says a telecommunications outage is to blame.
Officials say there's no sign of foul play
and every flight is accounted for.
Tonight's failure comes a day after a global Microsoft outage
knocked email and Microsoft Teams offline in dozens of countries.
Microsoft blames a network upgrade.
It has ruled out a cyber attack
and Homeland Security says the two events are not connected.
Still, it raises a fair question.
How resilient are the systems we all depend on?
And joining us now to discuss the latest on the nationwide ground stop
is Stephen Green, retired Boeing 737 captain.
Stephen, great to have you with us.
You have a very unique perspective as a pilot.
How disruptive is a nationwide ground stop of this magnitude,
and how are the pilots
across the country handling this and processing it?
It's going to be very disruptive,
very disruptive for the next few days.
You know, the cockpit approach to it is a normal operation.
Obviously, the airborne aircraft are landing either
at their destination or in some cases, I think, probably being diverted
because we're running out of ramp space, places to put the airplanes.
But once you're on the ground, now we get into the situation
of duty time, when you're going to be able to fly again.
There are other issues like where crews are going to be
housed in these situations.
I think the biggest problem right now that is operationally
impacting flight crews that are involved is once you're on the ground,
you have to take care of
your passengers and they're not going to be able
to get off the airplane. You're going to run out
of water. You're going to run out of lavatories.
There are going to have to be procedures to
deplane. And I know the airports have that ability,
but it's going to take some time.
Talk to us about those logistics.
You mentioned duty time.
There's only a certain amount of hours that a pilot can fly legally.
And just how, when you put the scope of this event,
this extraordinary event, into perspective,
it's only happened three times in history.
Thank
And typically, when you see something like this occur,
it might be at a select few regions.
But how significant will the impact be given the fact that...
Flights have been grounded nationwide instead
of just a few areas or regions.
I think it's going to be very significant because,
you.
for no other reason, you do have
those duty time limits,
and there's then required rest periods after the duty is completed,
and that's all going to be shifted based on what's happening right now.
So there's going to be an awful significant burden
on the operators to...
reschedule and to make sure that all
of those legal requirements are met once everybody's
off the airplanes.
So I think what we're really going to see
in the next few days is a considerable difficulty
with basically getting the system back up
and running even after the FAA determines
what the problem is and resolves it, hopefully.
And how dependent are pilots on FAA air traffic control systems
and what happens in an event if those systems were to fail?
Well, obviously the air traffic controllers
and their system are really the unsung heroes of the whole industry.
They are essential to it and they do an outstanding job.
They always have throughout my career.
They work very hard. They are somewhat understaffed.
As some of your previous interviews talked about,
the technology is a bit outdated.
We do have abilities to operate without air traffic control.
That's all been considered, and we have procedures
for dealing with that if that were to take place.
Nobody's ever really had to do that on like a really massive basis.
It has happened from time to time on individual aircraft bases.
not on this basis. And I don't really think
that's happening at this point. It sounds to me like
the communication in terms of inbound flights
and so forth is working just fine.
But we do have that ability if we
were to lose contact with air traffic control.
And it's worth pointing out
also that aircraft are able to talk in between themselves as well
on the same radio frequencies.
So there are ways to manage that. But I think it's essential to
Keep in mind that the air traffic controllers are really,
like I said, the unsung heroes of this thing.
We talk a lot about flight crews.
We don't talk very much about controllers,
but they are definitely the other half of the equation.
Stephen, what about the aircraft that are already in the air?
Are pilots told to continue to their destination
when an event like this occurs, divert, or take any other precautions?
They're going to get guidance from their own operators.
I know that I'm sure the major airlines all have
their emergency operations centers
are in full swing by now
and making decisions about what they want to do.
The basic idea was that everybody would continue to their destination,
and there didn't seem to be a technical problem with that
in terms of whatever the communication issue is.
However,
So one of the first things you run
into is you run out of places to put the airplanes.
When the gates are all occupied,
you're going to have to have ramp space and conceivably even close
a runway or something to put airplanes on that space.
And that may lead to decisions to divert airplanes
to other destinations because they just need
to put them someplace where they can actually be on the ground
and have room for them and have the facilities to support them.
But that will all be communicated to the...
Flight crews by their individual operators
through discrete company communication systems.
Now, how does this compare with the nationwide grounding
of flights following 9/11, if you
could sort of bring us back to that period of time?
And since then, is this something
that pilots prepare for and train for?
I don't know that it compares.
I think, obviously, there are a number of similarities.
No worries, that's all I have to say.
I think in that case,
there was a number of flights that did not even come into the United
States. It was maybe a little bit different in that sense,
but operationally or logistically,
it's probably somewhat similar to what happened there.
In terms of actually training for it,
I wouldn't say that it's a specific training item,
but it is something that we're all aware of.
And, you know, as I say,
we have procedures for dealing with these things.
And, you know, individual flight crews, obviously,
in conjunction with their dispatchers, are
making individual decisions for that aircraft,
depending on what the situation is.
They may be instructed to divert.
The flight crew may elect to divert based on their own situation,
depending on remaining
fuel and delays and all of those sorts of things.
There are obviously hundreds of actual individuals
in the position of making operational decisions
who are making those decisions for specific aircraft
in the best interests of safety all
the time, and where's the best place to go,
and how we should best get the airplane on
the ground is in the best place we can put it.
Hopefully the destination, possibly somewhere else,
but obviously safety is the top criteria
all the time. Retired airline pilot,
Stephen Green, greatly appreciate you joining us.
And the ground stop still in place as we speak.
We continue to monitor it. The White House
supposed to be giving an update within the hour,
and we will be sure to bring that
to you once it comes. The FAA says that as its facilities recover,
flights will be cleared one by one through
its National Command Center in Virginia.
In other words, even once this lifts,
the return to normal will be gradual. Bloomberg reporting.
The FBI looking at whether
a faulty software update could be behind tonight's
outage. Officials have not confirmed a cause,
stressing there is no indication of an attack.
And for the latest on the nationwide ground stop for all U.S. flights,
joining us to discuss,
John Hansman, director of the International Center
for Transportation. John, it's great
to have you with us. The DHS says there's currently
no indication of a nefarious attack.
What circumstances or perhaps threats would prompt
the FAA to issue a nationwide ground stop?
Well, I don't think it's so much a threat.
It's clearly there was a problem with the communication system.
And we don't know exactly which system was and what the cause is.
But when that happens, there's difficulty to manage the traffic
and coordinate between air traffic control facilities.
The way the system works in general
is that you make sure you don't overload the system
so you impose a ground stop.
It's incredibly unusual to have this occur at the national level.
This does occur occasionally if there's
a particular facility that's having a problem
or there was a few years ago,
there was a case where Chicago shut down for...
A few hours.
The only parallel case that we should talk about
was the September 11th attack, which
was very different, but shut down the entire system.
So we have a situation where basically air traffic control
is not functioning in its
normal way across the country.
And they imposed this national ground stop.
So very unusual.
I'm going to turn it over to Joel.
But it's, as your other guests have said,
it's not so much a safety issue.
It's really now more what's it going to take
to get the system back up and running.
Now, what does a nationwide ground stop actually look like
from the perspective of air traffic controllers?
And sort of what happens operationally once that order is issued?
Well, when there's a problem like this, and again,
we don't know the details of the problem,
the first priority is for the controllers
to deal with the airplanes that are in the air.
You have to get every airplane that's in the air either
to its destination or at the minimum to a
safe place on the ground before it runs out of fuel.
So that's the urgent situation. And if
If you're having trouble coordinating between facilities,
then you.
Suddenly, you can't hand an airplane
from one air traffic control facility to the next,
so the airplanes get stuck.
The controllers apparently still have radio communications.
There may be some radar outages, et cetera, that they're doing.
So they're having to kind of deal with that situation.
In order to prevent it from getting worse,
you just don't want to add any more airplanes
into the system.
So that's why they've essentially imposed a stop that says,
we're not going to allow
anybody to take off.
Unless it can take off into a place where there's not a problem.
So that's basically just to manage the system for safety reasons.
So I think from a safety standpoint, we're okay.
But they're not going to turn it back on until they know it will work.
So it's not clear yet how.
comprehensive this problem
is and how easy it's going to be to fix and get
the system up to where it's either working as normal
or it may have to work in a degraded
mode or with partial procedures.
So that may be why it may not turn on fully right away.
I think it's very important to note at this moment,
very little information coming in as to how or why
this single telecom fault has been able to impact all 22 centers.
And so it sounds like what you're saying,
and it makes sense that this could be something
that might not be as catastrophic as it seems right now,
based on every, you know, airport in the country.
Grounded, could this just be out of an abundance of caution
and something that might be easily
rectified? And I guess,
why did the backup systems fail to maintain service?
So you have to understand the air traffic control system
is very complicated. There's a lot of
subsystems that are going on.
There's the communication systems that send flight plans
different facilities.
There's the communication system that takes the data from the radar
and gives it to the controllers.
There's a communication system that the controllers
use to talk to the airplanes.
There's a communication system between facilities.
So there's hundreds or thousands of these systems out there.
And all of these systems
do have backups, but the backups don't
necessarily perform at full level.
So, again, the system is sufficiently complicated.
I don't know exactly what components failed and whatever,
but it's something that wasn't local.
It was existing across multiple facilities
or air traffic control centers around the country.
And so, therefore, until you understand what's going on,
it's a reasonable...
A position to, like, say, in an abundance of caution
to just stop all aircraft until you know what's going on.
If it had been local, if it had been a certain center, then you could
have isolated the stop to only airplanes going to that location.
But because they did it nationally, it appears,
at least at the beginning, they didn't know exactly the extent of it.
And since it's continued,
it seems to be clear that it is some sort of comprehensive problem.
Now, we did hear our previous guest,
former airline pilot Stephen Green,
saying that the air traffic controllers
are the unsung heroes in the aviation industry.
Talk to us about the role they play.
Are they trained, the air traffic controllers,
for a nationwide disruption like this,
or is this an extremely unusual scenario?
No, this is not a normal training event.
However, the controllers and the pilots, we do have procedures for
when air traffic control goes down,
so the airplanes have onboard equipment that will tell them
airplanes around them.
In addition, there are loss of communication procedures
and things like that.
However, if an air traffic controller is handling aircraft
and they can't communicate with their
adjacent sector,
they can't send the airplane from their location to the next.
location downstream.
So then then the airplane sort of gets stuck with them. And then in
emergency, you could divert to somewhere within
your air traffic control facility, or you can go to
backup communication.
So instead of using the computer to send the flight plan, you can call
up your adjacent controller on the phone or,
you know, ultimate backup is on your cell phone,
right? So I think that you're probably at a
If you go in, and we'll know more later,
but assume what's going on is to get the airplanes
that are in the air safely to the ground,
the controllers are kind of freelancing or making
it up as they go along if they need to.
Now, we don't have much precedent to draw from on this,
as we've mentioned, and you pointed out at the top of the interview.
Perhaps 9-11 would be the closest,
but obviously entirely different circumstances.
But just from a logistical perspective, a nationwide ground stop.
Once a nationwide ground stop like this is lifted, how long
do you expect it to take for the aviation system to return to normal?
So it depends a lot on how long this goes on for.
So we don't know. The system isn't turned on.
If it gets fixed tonight.
It will be like there was a snowstorm that occurred at every airport
and shut down every airport in the country, right?
So it's going to take five
or six days for the system to just accommodate
because airplanes are in the wrong location,
flight crews are in the wrong location,
people need to be reaccommodated.
So it will be a fairly significant disruption,
even if it gets turned on quickly.
If it continues for a few days, it will be even more severe.
And it will be like the September 11th
where people started renting cars to get home, right?
You know, driving across the country.
So we have to wait and see how big a problem this is to fix.
Even if it's a comprehensive system,
there are kind of backup techniques that you could use
that won't operate the system at full performance,
but may get it started.
So we'll have to see.
And again, it's hard from the outside.
We don't really know.
what's going on in terms of what systems are down
and how comprehensive it is.
You mentioned that some of the aircraft have sort of backup systems,
sensors that can tell even when
some of these other systems fail.
What should travelers know about aviation safety in light
of an event like this? So the system is designed for safety.
It's incredibly safe. So the system
So the system I'm talking about,
the backup system, there's actually two of them.
One is called TCAS.
So this is, it's a way that's presented
in the cockpit of every airplane that's around you.
So even if you totally lose aircraft control,
you're not going to crash into other airplanes
because you can see those other airplanes.
The challenge is then coordinating landing at
an emergency. So you would declare an emergency
and go to that emergency facility.
As
As the pilot you talked to mentioned a few minutes ago,
a
there's also ability for the
airplanes to communicate on the radio channel between them.
so I
So it's kind of like, if you think about air traffic control
for
as sort of a traffic cop
directing traffic, if the traffic cop's not there,
that
the cars can still maneuver around
each other, but they're not doing it in a coordinated way.
time.
So there is some elevated risk of two airplanes trying
to land at the same runway at the same
time.
may have an issue, but that's, that's the,
you know, ultimate risk, but we do have
backup sensors. We have backup procedures.
So it's designed to be safe, but part of the way we
maintain that safety is if there's any question,
we operate with an abundance of caution and we
just say, okay, we're going to hold everybody
until we know what's going on. And that's kind
of where we are. John Hansman,
really appreciate you joining us to share your insights and perspective
Thank you.
And we're going to take a quick commercial break
and we'll be right back with more updates after the break.
The holidays are meant to be filled with joy and wonder.
What I love the most about the holidays,
it's the time to bring everybody together.
But for too many families facing hunger,
holiday wonder turns into wondering.
Can I make this stretch? Will there be enough?
Things are a lot more expensive during the holidays.
Even with two full-time jobs,
Right now, with food costs remaining high,
it gets hard to make ends meet.
it's getting harder for families to keep up.
There's been years where I have looked for any
and every pantry that possibly had Christmas assistance.
That's why neighbors show up for one another.
You can show up too, with a meal, a helping hand,
and urgently needed food this season and all year.
Call or go online to HelpFeedingAmerica.org and give $19 a month,
just 63 cents a day,
and your first gift can be doubled in impact.
You can give people hope and recognize they don't have to give up.
That, to me, is the most important thing that we do.
Your monthly gift to Feeding America supports
a nationwide network of over 250 local food banks.
Moving food quickly, safely,
and reliably into communities all across the country.
The food banks do help us tremendously
with what they provide for the holidays.
And it's been a true blessing
because this stuff can be pretty expensive.
Every dollar you give comes with a promise.
Food on the table for families facing hunger.
Please call or go online to helpfeedingamerica.org.
We'll send you this free canvas bag as a reminder
that you showed up for your neighbors.
There are people out there that are willing to help people.
They don't have to, but they want to.
And I think that's incredible.
It's the holidays.
Nobody should have to wonder if there's enough.
Call or go online to helpfeedingamerica.org.
Your first gift can be doubled in impact.
Your treat?
I think it's your turn.
I'm just looking for the senior discount.
Just one of the perks of growing older.
There's more than one.
We have our own life insurance from Colonial Penn,
and you can't get it unless you're over 50.
Over 50 and healthy, I bet.
No, just over 50.
That's right.
Colonial Penn whole life insurance is just for men and women over 50.
If you're between the ages of 50 and 85, your acceptance is guaranteed.
There are no health questions, no medical exam.
To enroll, all you do is fill out a simple form.
You spent years looking out for your family.
The way we see it, you've earned the right to continue protecting them,
no matter what your health or income.
Call now to learn more about the coverage designed just for you.
Call 1-800-624-6556 for free information
and a free beneficiary planner.
That's 1-800-624-6556.
Call now.
And soon, in just moments, White House officials will
be holding a briefing on the nationwide travel disruption.
NTD will be sure to bring you that as soon as it begins.
In the meantime, that's all we have
for you tonight on The Capitol Report.
Stay connected to the stories that matter
and be sure to visit us at NTD.com
and download the NTD mobile app from the nation's capital.
I'm Steve Lance. Have a nice evening.
We'll see you back here on Monday.
