LBC callers get into heated debate over housing asylum seekers
Nov 15, 2026
Very easy to look at the people of Piddington and go, well, you live
in a leafy Oxfordshire village in a Lib Dem voting constituency,
and now you have to deal with what many other communities across
the country have had to deal with over the recent few years.
But actually, I think they're right to be angry.
I think other communities
who have had large groups of undocumented migrants
foisted on their doorstep have a legitimate concern
and have legitimate reasons to be angry.
Of course we need to house them somewhere.
But 1,200 people on the edge of a village of about 300?
Is that really fair?
I've got a very simple message to Andy Burnham.
Where's your devolution now, mate?
You're the Prime Minister who came
to power saying you wanted to empower local communities.
You wanted to listen to local voices.
Well, the people in Piddington are being pretty clear.
They are saying, up with this, we will not put in it.
You and your government are overriding them.
It's devolution for me, not for thee.
What do you mean by devolving power to local communities?
Do you just mean giving tax-raising powers
to regional mayors like you used to be
so that they can increase the already sky-high tax burden?
Is that what you mean by devolution?
Or do you actually believe in empowering local communities
like the people of Piddington who actually want to...
...protect the women and girls in their area.
Because, yes, of course, I'm not saying for one moment
that every undocumented migrant is some potential sexual predator.
That is not it.
If you listen to the concerns of the people in Pittington,
that is not what they are saying.
What they are saying is 1,200 undocumented men,
we do not know their identity,
is inevitably...
Going to be a massive, massive risk.
This is the week in which we have been rightly discussing
the safety of women and girls in relation
to high-profile individuals in the media.
Why are we in the same week ignoring local concerns in Oxfordshire
about undocumented men, 1,200 of them,
being housed right on the edge of a very small village?
I was hearing on LBC a couple of days ago one
of the female residents of Piddington
expressing her concerns about the fact that if these plans go ahead
there will be eight times as many men
in and around Piddington as there are women.
If that was happening where you lived, how would you feel?
What would you be doing?
It's not about whether you are pro or anti-immigration.
So often when we have this debate,
we conflate legal and illegal immigration.
You can believe, as I do,
that we need to have a sustainable number of legal migrants.
Yes, there should be controls,
but a sustainable number of legal migrants,
not just for the economic benefits that they bring,
but also the cultural benefits they bring.
But we know that for far too long.
We have been struggling to address the situation in the channel
with the small boats crisis.
That does need to be addressed.
And we need to find a better way of getting a bit of control here.
It comes down to control.
Where the British people lose faith in the entire system
is when there is a sense that rules don't apply.
There should be safe and legal routes for people fleeing persecution
and famine to come to this country.
And we should, as a rich country, take our fair share.
But we also need to do everything we can to stop.
The crisis in the English Channel once and for all,
not least because of the humanitarian implications
for the people who are losing their lives every year
at the hands of despicable people smugglers,
but also because it is frankly sticking two fingers up
to any notion of border security.
This plays to people's fears about Britain
somehow being broken as a country.
If you can't even enforce and police your borders,
then how can we run a health service?
How can we defend ourselves? How can we run schools?
How can we get the economy moving?
It comes back to an issue of competence.
And so I think people, yes, in a liberal Democrat constituency,
which Piddington finds itself in, are angry.
And I don't think they're being hypocrites just
because some of them will have voted Lib Dem at the last election
for also being angry now at these plans
to house 1,200 undocumented men on their doorstep.
And the point is not that they are asylum seekers.
The point is they are undocumented and they are free to come
and go as they please from this site.
And we know, sadly, there have been too many cases
to be comfortable with of people
Who have come here on small boats, whose identities
are still being established, committing heinous crimes.
I mean, there's a whole list, but I'll give you one
of the most egregious examples.
So there was the awful incident earlier this year
when three men, all asylum seekers,
were found guilty of repeatedly raping a woman on Brighton Beach.
After the attack, the men took a bus back
to their asylum hotel, had a barbecue.
One of them.
20-year-old Karin Al-Danasert is a convicted murderer
who fled Egypt because he was facing
the death penalty, and his chosen means
of escape was travelling through Europe and then
arriving in Britain on a small boat.
Now, I raise that example not because he will
be typical of every person who may be housed
on the edge of Piddington,
but because we did not know at the time he raped that woman
on Brighton Beach that he was a convicted murderer fleeing Egypt.
The nature of being an undocumented migrant
is we do not know who you are,
from where you have come, and what you
might have done in your home country.
And this is where I think it is entirely legitimate
for the people of Piddington
to be raising concerns.
This is not about the fact that some
asylum seekers will be on their doorstep.
It is about the fact that four times as many undocumented men
will be on their doorstep than the size of the entire village.
So if this was where you are living,
What would your response be?
I agree with that girl 150%.
My granny said to me when I was a kid,
care for what you wish for, boy, you might just get it.
Now, that's what they've ended up with.
And don't tell everybody listening
that they didn't know what they were voting for.
They voted for a party that made it blatantly clear
they were in full, complete support of unfettered immigration.
That's what they told them.
Well, no, in fairness, Frank,
it was not in the Lib Dem manifesto in 2024
to say, let's do nothing to address the small boats crisis.
Why not? Why not?
Well, it wasn't in their manifesto.
They are not pro-undocumented migrants
getting on dinghies and going over the channel.
What you're telling me then is we,
a bit like this Labour Party we've currently got in power,
is, oh, we've got no manifesto,
we don't know anything about them,
we don't know what they're going to do,
when they're going to do it,
but I can't wait to vote for them.
Even though we haven't got a clue what they're going to do.
But I think you are conflating two different types
of immigration, though, Frank.
You are conflating the Liberal Democrats' historic support
for legal migration.
End of story. Illegal immigration.
Well, these are asylum seekers,
and whilst their claims are being processed,
that will then establish whether they,
and they have entered the country illegally via small boat.
True. Absolutely.
So they come to seven or eight different countries,
then, that are absolutely 100% safe.
But because they get their backside wiped over air,
which is another part of the conversation,
they make their way here.
No, Frank, look, I have a lot of sympathy with your argument.
I just think you should find it within yourself
to have a bit more sympathy for the good people of Piddington,
not all of whom would have voted Liberal Democrat.
Well, the ones that did.
I sympathise with the ones that didn't,
but I don't sympathise with the ones that did.
Now, I live in a small village.
There's three or four hamlets all around,
a hotel that's got 400
of these illegal immigrants in there.
The young kids are going to school to walk through
the lanes to go to school, there and back.
Young girls are out on their ponies on weekends.
Women are out on their horses on weekends.
There's groups, large groups
of immigrant men hanging around in the lanes.
Hey, little girly, little girly, come talk to me, little girly.
I like you, little girly.
And they wonder why people are rearing up around there.
Now, it makes no difference
who's actually saying that and approaching those girls.
Anybody from anywhere.
But the point being, these are undocumented men,
so we do not know who they are.
We don't know. That's everybody. That's your only excuse.
Oh, we don't know this. We don't know that.
No, I'm saying that is the issue.
If we do not know their rights, I mean, what I find staggering
is that whilst we are processing these people's claims, and yes,
of course, we need to find a way of stopping the boats,
and as far as I'm concerned, that would involve leaving
the European Convention on Human Rights so that we can do more,
we can actually detain and deport and all of that kind of stuff,
but whilst we have them here, we do have to process their claims.
What I do not understand, Frank, is why,
while we are processing their claims...
We cannot keep them under supervision
so that they are not at risk of committing potentially
heinous crimes. And that is not me saying
that all of them will go on to do so,
but unfortunately too many have. We can't keep them under supervision,
but they're putting 1,250 in a ex-army camp
and they can go wander wherever they like.
They're here illegally. That is the fact.
They've been processed. All right, I'll go with that.
They're being processed,
they're being looked at, they're being examined.
They're being judged, even
though our own people are sleeping in doorways.
Frank, stay there. I want to bring in David in Bayswater.
David, afternoon to you. You have a different take.
Yeah, well, it's nice to speak to you and Frank as well.
So basically, I used to teach a lot of refugees.
I used to teach young men refugees in the sixth form.
And the vast majority of them were amazing people,
very hardworking, attended college.
I understand.
Can people understand the mentality of most of these young men?
They're coming here from poor countries.
I admit a lot of them throw away
their documents and they're probably not.
100% refugees, but it's just,
they are coming for an understandable reason. They want to make
a better life. They're not like coming here to commit crimes.
They're just ordinary humans
trying to make a better life.
And also, can I plead with you, James, please do not.
I keep repeating this kind of very emotive rhetoric.
Which emotive rhetoric?
You said massive risk and too many crimes.
First of all, they're not a massive risk.
The number of crimes that these young men have committed
as a proportion of them that come is very tiny.
Yeah, but David, David, look.
You as a person on the radio,
you have to be extremely responsible
with the kind of things you say.
Well, let me quote you.
Let me quote you, the University of Oxford.
Yeah, what you've said today is very, very bad.
It encourages people in racist thoughts about these young men.
No, David, David, let me push back on that.
I need to quote you research done by the University
of Oxford's Migration Observatory.
Now, this is not some far-right institution.
This is the University of Oxford and
their academic, Madeleine Sumption,
has calculated, for example, that Afghan nationals
are 14 and a half times more likely to commit sexual offences
...than British nationals.
And obviously Afghanistan,
along with other war-torn countries like Sudan and Iran and Syria,
accounts for thousands of small boat arrivals each year.
Now, that is not to say that everyone coming here
from Afghanistan is a potential sex offender.
It's still a tiny minority, though, of them, James. That's the point.
And I find the whole tone of your conversation,
you're trying to sound liberal about it,
but your whole tone is very negative.
You're trying to portray them as a massive risk, and they're not.
But anyway, can I just move on?
But the point is, if we don't know who they are...
Yes, I agree. I just agree with you.
But the risk is not massive. It is not massive.
I'm sorry, if any logical person looks at the figures,
it is not massive, James.
But can I move on to something positive now?
Go on.
As a teacher of young men like this,
if I were the community in Piddington,
OK, try and make a positive out
of something that you feel is a negative.
Engage with the young men.
Start English classes, engage with young men,
try to learn about their humanity.
You can run all kinds of classes with them in the camps.
You could actually grow as a person through your experience.
So, David, I don't know how many people live in Bayswater,
but let's say, I don't know, 10,000 people live in Bayswater.
If they had plans to house 40,000 undocumented men...
You just ignored my point. You completely ignored my point.
No, no, no, I get your point.
Your point would be you'd go and give them English classes, would you?
No, I didn't just say English classes, all kinds of classes.
The people in Piddington are very clever, I'm sure.
They could teach them all kinds of skills, math.
They could try to get the young men to be involved in the community.
Why do you have to have such negative rhetoric about these young men?
Most of them are just ordinary people
trying to make a life for themselves.
David, stay there. I want to bring in Frank again,
because, Frank, you're not too far from an asylum hotel,
or you have been not too far.
What's your response to David, Frank?
Well, listen to David's wonderful, marvellous virtue signalling.
You know, look at me, I care.
Yeah, let's stick a few in his house then.
Yeah, he won't be, you know, if he got daughters,
10, 12, 15-year-old daughters walking
down through a country lane to school
and they're being approached by people all the time.
There's a couple of bus shelters at the end of the village.
It's full of them.
They're sat in the bus shelters to get out
of the rain just hanging around.
They should not be here.
See, people confuse the word immigration
with the word immigration from the 50s and 60s
when they came over from what we now call
the Windrush generation.
Take a look at the films and the photographs
of those people that came over from the West Indies.
When they were coming off the boat,
the men had their suit and ties on.
The women had their best frock on.
But they were also a different type of immigrant
because we actually invited them over
and they came here to work
and they've made a huge contribution.
You've made a good point there, James.
James, you've just made a good point,
being invited over.
Can I have a say, please?
David, yeah.
Can I get a word in?
Frank, I understand.
Frank, I do understand where you're coming from,
but you've taken specific examples.
That's not the vast majority of them.
The vast majority...
Can I give an example of one of them?
One of them that I taught, he was brilliant.
He came and he went to college, my college.
Within three years, he got three A-levels, all A-stars.
He went and became a doctor.
He was top of a medical school in Bristol.
So many of them...
provide amazing potential for this country.
Let's be positive.
Yes, I understand the fears, and we can try to...
So what we'll do, what we'll do,
because we may get one good one or ten good ones...
Most of them are good, Frank.
How many of them do you know?
Have you ever engaged with one of these young men?
I've engaged with loads of them.
So why are you going to try and meet them and talk to them?
Yes, I have.
With your negative attitude,
I'm sure you probably didn't have anything good to say to them.
I ran a company employing nearly 300 people.
I had a vast amount of Somalian kids working for me,
and nine out of ten were as good as gold.
But they came here legally.
They came here properly.
They had proper working papers.
What we've got now, let's say 10 out of the 1,250,
they're going to take the world by storm.
They're going to grab the stars.
But we don't know anything about the rest of them.
Frank, you cannot judge all of them the way you're doing it.
I've just said I understood.
You keep your virtue signaling up.
I'm not virtue signaling.
Everybody know what a wonderful man you are.
Yeah, well, I...
That's all you're doing.
James, James.
David, go on.
Yeah, I am actually teaching quite a few refugees online at the moment.
So I'm telling you, I'm not virtue signaling.
I'm living it.
So, Frank, maybe if you started living positively
and doing something to help these young men,
instead of just carping on and moaning on about them all the time,
you might change your view.
I don't know where it comes from, your negativity.
I come from a very multicultural background.
Maybe you're too monocultural.
You need to learn that different cultures also have value.
The problem with you is you're just too narrow-minded and parochial.
David, Frank, appreciate your calls.
Khalid is in Leicester.
Afternoon, Khalid. Go ahead.
Hi, James. I think, first of all, the policy needs to be reviewed.
The thing is, look, we're giving £662 million to France.
What are they doing, apart
from having 50 police officers on the beach there?
I think it's pathetic.
France should be going through each applicant,
giving them safe legal rules, first of all.
First of all, they should be assessed there.
We have up to a million jobs up for grabs at any one time in the UK.
People should be assessed.
They should be either put into work.
Yeah, but the problem
there, Callum,
and I understand
the argument, trust me,
that if you allowed asylum seekers
to work whilst their claims are being processed,
It would be good for the economy, I get that.
But would that also not just create a massive poll factor
and essentially be encouraging more people
to risk their lives at the hands of despicable people smugglers
by boarding a small boat off the coast of Calais?
No, the thing is, they are...
Look, if a small, you know, they're safe...
In other words, everyone should be assessed in France.
Well, not necessarily in France.
I mean, there are refugee camps in Turkey, for example.
And, you know, we should be doing more to take people
fleeing persecution and famine and poverty
from the places they are fleeing.
But we can't take everyone either.
No, I appreciate that, but the problem
is we've caused many problems in the world,
in Afghanistan, in Iraq, in Syria.
You know, we've had hand in all of these countries.
We can't say now, don't come here.
We've caused chaos in your countries, but we don't want you here.
It's ridiculous.
First of all, let me give you another scenario, James.
The thing is, look, say for argument, let's put it this way.
Say the UK government says, you know what?
Everybody in the UK,
you either move to Leicester or you move to Newcastle, for example.
They're your two towns.
You can't move out of there now.
Everybody else that comes from abroad,
they're going to take the rest of the UK.
Would you allow that?
Would you be happy with that?
No.
I mean, would you?
Would you just?
Would I be happy putting every undocumented migrants
in Leicester or Newcastle? No.
No, no, no, no, no, no, in everywhere.
But everybody in all the population of the UK right now would
be housed in Leicester and Newcastle.
All the other land, the rest of the land is for the illegal migrants
and the asylum seekers.
Would you be happy with that?
Well, no, but I think you're missing the point with respect, Khaled.
I think the point you're making is why should Piddington
be exempt from taking its fair share of asylum seekers?
No, no, no, you're missing the point what I'm saying.
My point is, look, on the one side, you've got to be consistent, James.
The problem you have is that, look,
you have this mindset that everybody coming over,
or not everybody, but at least some people, some of them coming over,
we don't know where they're from, et cetera, et cetera.
On the other side, you support Israel to the max,
which is exactly what they're doing over there.
Oh, for goodness sake,
how on earth have we managed to wedge Gaza into this?
Khaled, we'll leave it there. Colin's in Manchester.
Good afternoon, Colin, what would you like to say?
Well, I feel for the people of this village with only 300
and something occupants,
but at the end of the day, they've got to go somewhere.
You can't keep people that are undocumented with no ID.
Look, any other country in the world, if I was to try and go
into any other country in the world without ID, I would be detained.
It's as simple as that.
Now you detain them.
You don't let them wander out within
the perimeter of the military base.
You put guards on patrol around it to make sure they don't come out.
And so they've been processed.
If you want to throw your ID away, you've thrown it away for a reason.
I suppose the problem there, Colin,
when you start talking about kind of armed guards policing camps full
of foreigners, it sounds a bit sinister.
Well, it might sound funny. I don't care what it sounds like.
You've got to look, you either protect the citizens of the country
or you don't. Simple as that.
Now, I have no doubt that a lot of these migrants...
They do have a legitimate reason for fleeing
the country that they've fled from.
But you've got to identify them.
You've got to do background checks on them.
Just like any other person in this country,
if they have a criminal record, then that record's kept.
But we don't know who these people are, simple as that.
So until you find out who they are, until that point,
and then once you find out who they are,
Through DNA, through fingerprinting, photographic evidence,
and if they don't want to divulge where they've come from,
then they stay in the barracks until they turn around and do.
So your view is that it's not a bad idea to keep them
in this disused military site on the edge of Piddington.
The problem is, while their claims are being processed,
while we're establishing who they are,
they shouldn't be allowed to leave.
They should be under 24-7 supervision.
Exactly.
Colin, appreciate the call. Let's go to
Rodney, first-time caller in Birmingham.
Afternoon to you, Rodney. What is your take on this?
Well, I agree with the other call.
I pretty much said what I was going to say.
So, yes, you can't allow undocumented anyone to come into the country.
We can't do it, go in other countries. It's unheard of.
And obviously, with Britain, with all the benefits that you do get,
so it could be a case of migrants coming to work,
maybe not, maybe coming to get benefits.
But either way, until our system is changed, I wouldn't like it.
And I feel sorry for the people in that village. It's not great.
So if you were in Pittington, you would be doing exactly the same.
You'd be holding a symbolic referendum to leave
or you'd be threatening legal challenges against the government.
Guaranteed, yes, 100%.
I mean, no one would like it.
You wouldn't put them in Kensington,
you wouldn't put them in Westminster,
you wouldn't put them in Birmingham,
you wouldn't put them anywhere.
And someone's not going to complain about it.
The numbers, the volumes, it's not great.
And it only takes one of them, as you might know.
So someone's going to come along.
If they're not 100% legal,
and they know that there could be a possibility
they're not going to get asylum,
then they're going to go missing.
They're going to go in the system.
They're going to go...
Somewhere in the country and you're not going to be able to find them.
Eventually you might pick them up, but maybe not.
It's not, it's not, it's not with this.
It's to me national security.
And it starts at home, doesn't it?
Rodney, appreciate the call. Rodney, first-time caller in Birmingham.
Let's stay in Birmingham and squeeze in Shirley.
Afternoon, Shirley. What would you like to say?
Hi. Obviously, it's a bad idea for the residents,
but a solution would be go back to the hotels, not any hotel,
but only on a motorway, only in remote areas.
We'll give these areas a ton of money.
Like here in Birmingham, we've got a hotel on the A1 or something.
It's quite remote.
Give the area a ton of money and say,
you don't dump you, but find the remote hotels,
not inappropriate ones, in the middle of the countryside.
This is the difficulty, Shirley, isn't it?
That wherever you house undocumented migrants
while their claims are being processed,
you're going to get some people who are opposed to it, aren't you?
I mean, people didn't like the hotels.
The government is right to be moving away the hotels.
Now you're saying maybe some hotels are the right place.
Well, a barracks
is more secure than a hotel.
But there's nowhere to go, do you see what I mean?
If you want to do that, you do it, but it's not really workable.

