Joe SLAMS GOP for NOT impeaching Hegseth | Morning Joe Weekly Highlights

US News: Connecting World
2 followers
1 Video View·Nov 15, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedDemocrats have secured a historic mandate to lower costs and improve lives. Analysts advise the party to focus on tangible economic results rather than reacting to social media provocations. Meanwhile, the Republican Party faces a crisis of \"epistemic closure,\" where an echo chamber on X and loyalty to Donald Trump have blinded them to voter priorities, leading to significant electoral losses.
Voters just handed Democrats a clear mandate,
lowering costs, making lives better, and yes,
reining in ICE and other forms of accountability.
While ICE is still doubling down on its cruel efforts,
Democrats now have the power to confront
it.
So the cruelty, Stephen Miller's cruelty, can come to an end.
Miller's promotion doesn't change Democrats' goals, it defines them.
I highly encourage Democrats and many others.
Not to take the bait.
And remember, they have the power
to deliver real results to the American people.
And Joe, I am in no way saying ignore the gravity of any situation,
including Stephen Miller getting promoted,
but just not letting reactions get in the way of the job.
Well, and it reminds me, Jim Vande Hei,
of that famous Vince Lombardi quote.
He was new to the Green Bay Packers.
Thank you.
Kickoff returner, ran at 99 yards,
scored a touchdown, did a dance at the end zone,
was dancing along the sidelines, went past Lombardi.
Lombardi just kept staring straight ahead.
About five minutes later,
he put down his clipboard and slowly walked over to the other side.
He said, next time you're in the end zone.
Looked like you've been there before.
Turned back around, picked up his clipboard and kept coaching.
Like, Democrats have won, right? They won big.
They won one of the biggest landslides since 1974,
so they don't have to post.
He screeds like they're in the minority.
I mean, I understand that's what they're used to doing.
Donald Trump does something shocking and outrageous.
They go on social media immediately to answer.
They don't have to do that anymore.
I saw Hakeem Jeffries and, you know,
he had this thing about getting Miller out of government.
I'm sitting there going, does he know?
He's the incoming Speaker of the House with the largest majority.
And like, you can stay off of Twitter.
You don't need to do that on Twitter anymore.
And then, of course, Robert Garcia,
right in the middle of this huge landslide,
instead of talking about working for the people, he's like, lawyer up.
No, you're in the majority.
You don't have to say that anymore.
You're holding four aces.
Sit back, smile, say justice will be done for all.
Accountability will come into play here finally.
But we're going to work on costs.
We're going to work on taking care of people.
And we're not going to have to post social media videos
on wherever we are on the weekend
because we got the gavel now.
I don't know, Jim.
I don't know what your thought is.
But I think Democrats in this age now where they have such
a massive majority need to
start acting like it.
Yeah. I mean, the problem is attention is seductive.
Payback is seductive. And I think
the way that Donald Trump is organizing
for the final two years is going to make it really hard
for Democrats to hold their tongues.
If you just look at what the president has done,
elevating Stephen Miller,
this is a guy who is a maximalist in terms of asserting the power of
the presidency. This is a guy
who considers Democrats to be essentially a terrorist
organization. He's called them a domestic threat.
This is a guy who believes that we need a harder line on immigration,
that we need to get more people out of this country
and that the tactics need to be even tougher.
He might not prevail on that.
But if you look at the team now between him and Blanchard, J.D.
Vance, you essentially have this group
of very sort of full throated, MAGA aggressive.
Men, middle-aged white men, essentially, is what's left,
and they feel like they have to go to war.
You even had the president on social media this weekend talking about
the possibility that you go after and you imprison anyone who tries
to investigate you because it is harassment, like forgetting the irony.
That was you that sort of started a lot of these fights.
And so it will take an absurd amount of self-discipline
to do what Mika was talking about, which I do think is the wise road.
If you just look at what voters said,
they just want you to figure out how to make things cheaper.
They want to end this war. Right.
They want to make sure they can get a job
and that their kids have decent paying jobs.
That's it. That's what they want. They were loud and clear.
Right. Washington's a different universe.
Yeah, but you know, the thing is, though,
come on, he's been in he's been in power,
Lemire, for 10 years now, off and on.
Get used to it.
If something bad happens, he immediately goes,
I'm going to hire a Martian and they're going
to run the Defense Department
and we're going to colonize Mars or something that will shock
people.
Oh, my God.
So that didn't quite happen on Friday,
but he made sure he posted something that would
make Democrats heads blow off.
Why?
Because the only thing people were talking about
is the fact that Republicans lost in Texas
and that Ted Cruz is the only remaining senator,
the only remaining statewide officeholder in Texas.
They're going to win Mississippi.
They won Kansas for the first time since 1932.
They won South Carolina.
They destroyed their opponents in Georgia.
They destroyed their opponents in North Carolina.
This was history.
And so Donald Trump didn't want people talking about
that his party suffered historic losses.
So what's he do? He appoints Stephen Miller. Mission accomplished.
Democrats took the bait instead of focusing on the win.
I mean, and as far as Stephen Miller goes and Todd Blanche
and the president's insults and the threats of retribution.
Thank you, Shannon.
How did that work for them? How did that?
This is this is seriously like playing the first half.
And your quarterback is Stephen Miller, Todd Blanche, Donald Trump.
They go 0 for 18, throw five interceptions,
three pick sixes, no touchdowns, and you're
sitting there going, wow, that was really bad.
Second half starts up.
What do they do?
They trot the same quarterback out.
And the Democrats are mad about that.
No need.
No need.
No need.
He is the reason.
Stephen Miller's policies are the reason Texas is deep, deep blue.
Now, maybe the president's thinking I'll do an immigration deal,
like he said on 60 Minutes last night,
and I can get away with it if Stephen Miller's by my side.
Maybe they're thinking that.
We don't know.
He doesn't usually think that rationally.
But he talked about it last night, so we don't know.
My main issue is, you're really freaking out about a guy being elevated
that made Democrats have the biggest landslide
in the state of Texas ever?
I'm kind of okay with it.
So there's no doubt that Trump's first goal was to win a new cycle,
his first one in a while.
He did.
He captured what we were all talking about on Friday.
I think this is a clear case of two things can be true at once.
I do think there are some real-world, short-term implications
that are scary for people.
Miller is a signal, it would appear, to be doubling down on these
hardline immigration policies that was so difficult for so many people.
I'm not saying ignore it.
No. So that's that. And secondly,
so I co-authored a piece in The Atlantic on Friday
and published over the weekend about what happened here.
One of the reasons why Susie Wiles, who had received so much praise
for so long for running a tight ship, that was she was ousted.
Of course, it's the losses last Tuesday, but also because.
Trump, in this sort of mania about trying
to crack down on leakers, which is his sort
of real obsession at the moment,
threatened he would say he wanted to push the idea that
journalists could be jailed,
that that would they would then give up their sources.
Wiles said no, she wouldn't sign off on that.
Miller has said he will.
So that is another scary real life implication.
Yeah, but again, scary, scary, scary.
OK, scary.
But guess what?
It hasn't worked.
Donald Trump has done something that no president's ever done before,
and his Justice Department's done something
that no Justice Department's ever done before.
They've ensured that their indictments will
not be returned by grand juries.
So again, I understand this is all scary,
but this scary stuff is what led to the biggest
Democratic landslide over the past 50, 60 years.
That's all.
And that's part two of this.
I'm not saying don't, I'm not saying don't worry about it.
I'm saying go, well, you know, that's very concerning.
You know what, though?
Looks like most voters didn't like that the first two years.
They're not going to like it the next two years.
Go ahead, Donald, make my day, is what Democrats should say.
And say, now we're going to get back
to lowering the cost of gas in the war.
We're going to get back to lowering the cost of groceries.
Let's end the tariffs.
We're going to get back to lowering the cost of health care.
Let's go ahead and put some of that funding back
in that Trump stripped, etc., etc., etc.
That's what they need to do instead of panicking
and setting their hair on fire.
And I think that it's two things, right?
The short term, there is scary for people.
The long term is this is a this is a disastrous
political decision for Republicans like that.
It's two things are true.
Once this could be hard for people in the short term,
but long term, David Drucker, this is the gift for Democrats,
because if Stephen Miller is is indeed a signal
that they're going to double down on the policies that got them.
Wiped out in historic fashion on Tuesday, well,
then 2028 is going to be even bluer in even more places.
Look, Stephen Miller should have been the first chief of staff.
And then Susie Wiles is who you bring in after what happened Tuesday.
That didn't happen.
And I think to Joe's point,
and I think this is key for Democrats, don't be reactive.
You use the sports analogy,
you play your game and then you see how the other side reacts.
And the most important thing to understand
is that voters want a government that worked.
I think that's why in these deep red states they elected Democrats.
And if Democrats understand that,
they will function a lot better than if they believed
this was an endorsement of their agenda.
He took a few questions there, very friendly questions,
I will note, after his opening
remarks about the impeachment effort underway on Capitol Hill.
Mika, a few highlights here.
He, of course, gave a rosy assessment
of the Iran war, as he always does.
He used a lot of overheated warfighting rhetoric,
as well as a lot of religious imagery.
He compared the casualty counts to Iran war there to what's happened
when America suffered
in Vietnam and Korea, I guess making the point that this was a...
A lesser effort.
And he, of course, was very defensive
in terms of the impeachment inquiry,
suggesting it was a win for our adversaries to make him
and his president weaker.
And he can, as he did repeatedly, every opportunity
to praise the leadership of President Donald J. Trump.
Right. So very defensive and defiant former Fox News host.
We'll
And got to pull back a little bit looking at that.
Performance. You think about those who have held that position.
be
Jim Mattis, Bob Gates, other cabinet secretaries,
right
Henry Kissinger, Brent Scowcroft, my dad, Zbigniew Brzezinski.
And then you listen to Hegseth. It is it is a little embarrassing,
back.
I have to say, to hear him talk and to hear him talk about members.
Serving in uniform. I got a text from a Republican
who served in the DOD and worked on Capitol Hill.
Hegseth's speech summarized this way.
Mr. President, please don't let me go. Pathetic
to see him cowering behind those in uniform.
And that is the big point here. This was not for
the media. I don't even think it was for the American people.
I think it was for one person.
And that would be Donald J. Trump.
What's going to matter here is,
is the president going to think this performance was anything
but embarrassing and desperate and groveling almost?
It was childish at times, the language he used,
the way he described some of the actions
that the department took.
And you mentioned the Houthis.
I mean, this is a secretary of defense who went on a group chat.
And described war plans and used little,
you know, comments to show his excitement
for the action and forgot that there
was a reporter on the group chat. Thank God it was
just a reporter, I guess, you know, and and a really good one. But.
Yeah, I that that is that was a desperate attempt to save his job.
I think I think that the president is from the reporting I've heard is.
Thinking about this.
Yeah, it's certainly an audience of one event there. David Rued,
Secretary Hegseth, went on about saying
that he'd be the first, you know,
cabinet official to be impeached like this.
We should also note that he was the first defense
secretary who got in on the virtue
of the vice president casting a tie-breaking vote. It was
50-50. And then J.D. Vance stepped in and got him through,
which shows at the beginning,
there were real questions, even among some Republicans, about Hegseth's
ability to lead this department.
He then just spent the last half hour trying to defend his
record. But it seems that, led by a Republican,
these impeachment proceedings are going to continue.
Yeah, he didn't really address the main facts
that are raised in the eight articles of impeachment.
And more broadly, it was very political.
He complained that the impeachment was, you know, a political stunt.
And he just I just want to fact check him.
I know, Jonathan, we did this again through all the spring.
But first of all, Iran has not been defeated.
He talked about Iran can no longer, my apologies, have a nuclear bomb.
That is false. That has not been achieved by the Trump administration.
He said that the U.S. was humiliated
when American troops pulled out of Kabul.
That's true. That was a failure.
But some argue that the way this war has gone
in Iran has humiliated the United States also.
And this war will have more of an impact than that had.
He talked about the success of the drug boat strikes.
That is just false, that there is no evidence
that it's reduced the flow of drugs in the
United States.
A DEA study that was reported about this summer
by The Washington Post found that drug prices
have actually dropped in the United States.
Traffickers are simply using different routes
to bring the drugs into this country.
And lastly, have his policy succeeded?
This gets beyond the impeachment questions as Secretary of State.
And that's the issue.
He's accused of carrying out a purge,
of getting rid of generals that don't support
the president enough or don't fit Secretary
Hegseth's sort of political views.
He's requested $1.5 trillion in funding.
And at the same time, U.S. forces are short
on the interceptor missiles they need to defend
themselves.
And he's hidden also the amount of damage
to U.S. bases in the region and been slow
in terms of releasing U.S. casualties.
I'm just I just want to fact check him
on these claims of success over and over.
And, you know, he's that war in Iran is won.
The Houthis have been defeated.
They're actually stronger than they were.
And again, the Venezuela situation, the boat strikes have
not reduced the flow of drugs into the United States.
Well, we appreciate this fact checking.
Of course, not clear what are the next steps in the Iran war.
We should also note he repeatedly tried to link his impeachment
proceedings with the impeachment of the president and sort
of conflated attacks on him with with attacks on American troops,
which, of course, is not at all what is happening here.
This is about the performance of Secretary Hegseth. No one else.
MSNBC senior national security reporter David Rood. Thank you so much.
Joe, I guess Democrats get another chance at this, perhaps in January.
Yeah. I mean, that's the thing.
I mean, Willie, there's going to be a lot of opportunities
for Republicans to do things over the next month and a half that would
actually help them with the standing with the American people.
But they just don't seem the least bit interested from Donald Trump.
Doing what he did, picking Stephen Miller,
somebody that even inside the White House,
every report I'm hearing inside the White House
is people are saying they don't want to work with
him. They're people that are passing up jobs.
They've been wanting their entire lives in the
White House because Stephen Miller is going
to be inside of there. And then the other side of
Pennsylvania Avenue, you look at it, they had a chance.
To get rid of Pete Hegseth or at least have a vote on it
and impeach him in the House,
have the trial in the Senate.
That's something that would have told
the Republican voters, hey, we hear you.
We're not going after Donald Trump.
But somebody has to take the blame
for this war that's made our lives terrible.
And they just can't do it.
It is amazing, isn't it?
The two things that voters taught us and told us a week ago.
Was that the immigration policy,
we can go through the numbers in the border counties
and go through the numbers across the country.
The immigration they hated.
Well, that's a policy the architect of which is Stephen Miller.
He gets a promotion. The other thing they hated was the war in Iran,
not just the war, but the fallout from the war,
which included higher gas prices and oil prices across the country,
making life unlivable for a lot of people in this country.
Republicans, one week after getting wiped out across the country,
had a chance to move on from Pete Hegseth and maybe,
maybe turn the page on the war and Mika instead.
They chose to keep him in place.
It is amazing that even at this point now. They can't do it.
Two years of a lame duck president.
These Republicans cannot move on.
You know, I think there are many
who are very concerned in the foreign policy community
about Pete Hegseth moving forward and just how long,
you know, we can go before there
is another another calamity.
You look at what happened with the girls school in Iran.
You look at a number of things that has happened under his leadership.
I mean, this was a legitimate effort to look at whether or not he...
Is the right person to lead that department?
And is is he dangerous?
And I think the question many ask is how dangerous?
Yep, no doubt about it.
So House Republican leadership.
Said they were going to block the impeachment resolution,
Mika, and that's exactly what they did, isn't it?
Yep, they followed through in a 211 to 204 vote.
The House approved a procedural motion sending the resolution to the
Judiciary Committee, effectively sidelining the impeachment push.
Congressman Thomas Massie, who spearheaded the effort,
was the only Republican to vote with Democrats,
leaving GOP leaders with enough support to deny a vote
on whether Hegseth should be removed from office.
While Republicans worried attendance could allow Democrats to succeed,
it turns out more Democrats actually missed the vote than Republicans.
In total, 11 Democrats were not in attendance.
Some said they were absent due to traffic incidents
and police escorts while they were en route to Capitol Hill.
Massey's eight articles accused Hegseth of waging war against
Iran without congressional approval, ordering extrajudicial killings
in Caribbean boat strikes and participating in the kidnapping
of former Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro, among other things.
In an interview with MSNBC following the vote,
Massey said he was not surprised by the outcome.
I'm not surprised because I didn't have anybody commit
to this and I didn't see anybody in the media committing to it,
but I am disappointed and I think it's interesting that
My colleagues are still in a suicide pact
with this administration and the Iran war.
They know it's why they lost the election,
but they can't bring themselves to do anything about it.
I thought people would want to put some daylight between themselves
and this administration and this war,
but it looks like they don't want to.
I think Trump still has control over this conference.
That's the big lesson I learned here.
The vote marks a show of support for President Trump,
who mounted an aggressive campaign
to defend Hegseth from the charges
in a social media post after the vote.
Trump wrote in part, the Democrats attempt
to impeach Secretary of War Pete Hegseth has
miserably failed and that Hegseth's spirit,
quote, led to the exoneration of a great American
patriot.
Joe.
No.
Not even close, not even close.
The whole failure is coming from the White House.
The whole failure is coming from the Pentagon.
The whole failure is coming, Willie, of course.
From a failed colossal war,
one of the worst that many historians like Bob Kagan have said,
winding up to be one of the worst losses
in American history for a variety of reasons.
And that's on Pete Hegseth.
He was the one pushing Donald Trump throughout
the entire process to move further, to move faster.
Pete Hegseth was the one who was questioning people's patriotism,
media members' patriotism, for even questioning the war.
And then we have...
This seems like a sidebar right now, but it really shouldn't.
If I were putting together articles of impeachment, I would talk about
the fact that funding was cut to the division that actually that cut
led to the killing of all those young girls in the girls school.
That would be in there. But front
and center would be the war crimes that Pete Hegseth committed.
The disadministration committed in their extrajudicial killings
in the Caribbean, firing missiles at boats,
killing people that were floating on top of boat wreckage.
I mean, that is a war crime. We all know that's a war crime.
Pete Hegseth knows it's a war crime.
Pete Hegseth, the same man who years ago was saying
to students that you can't follow unlawful orders.
Well, he followed unlawful orders.
He gave unlawful orders.
This is black and white, black and white.
Extrajudicial killings in the Caribbean are war crimes.
And if Republicans still, after getting absolutely wiped out
in historic fashion this morning, by the way, Dave Wasserman saying.
That the 13.5% that Democrats winning by is the biggest since 1974,
if they still don't
get that message after all this time,
they should probably stop covering up for things
like war crimes by Pete Hegseth.
Well, it sure didn't look that way yesterday.
What did they do yesterday?
They covered up for war crimes committed by Pete Hegseth.
And those crimes, those alleged crimes,
were in those articles of impeachment introduced by Thomas Massie.
That was on the table, and they still voted against that.
I mean, Pete Hegseth, Stephen Miller are two of the guys
who drove the Republican car off the cliff last Tuesday.
And they're being allowed not only to stay in those seats,
but to get a better seat in the car,
if you'll forgive the tortured metaphor there.
I mean, this is, you had Pete Hegseth yesterday,
Jonathan Lemire, saying.
Almost explicitly, I was just following orders,
which was an interesting twist maybe to protect
himself in there.
He said, I was following the orders
of the commander in chief when I did everything I
did and I would do it exactly the way I did it before.
I guess the question, there are two questions.
One, why Republicans feel compelled to protect
this man that we're looking at on the screen,
given what he's done to the party and to the country.
And number two,
why Donald Trump continues to hang in so closely and give Pete Hegseth
the reign to operate with impunity
and to protect the guy who has hurt him so much.
Yeah, Congressman Massie is right.
This was a test of Trump's hold on the Republican Party,
at least so far, despite the election
results last week.
That hold is still pretty, pretty firm.
And, you know, and I think this this vote
was decided hours before anyone assembled on the Hill yesterday.
It was decided when Hegseth stood up in front of the cameras
at the Pentagon, held his first press briefing since May and delivered,
you know, that performance job.
Yeah. And immediately Trump posted about it like he
was an audience of one moment.
This was in some way so predictable.
Hegseth holds news event to get Trump to watch.
Trump signs off. Republicans take their cue from that.
Trump wants him to stick around.
And as far as Trump goes, as I reported, pre-midterms,
Trump has definitely been taking the temperature
of people on the Hill,
but also his sort of outside kitchen cabinet advisors about Hegseth.
Is he doing a good job?
Should I keep him?
You know, he's had doubts.
But I think, in fact, this moment here,
in fact, the impeachment was led by Massie, who
Trump loathes because Massie has defied him
on a number of things, including, importantly,
Jeffrey Epstein.
That made Trump dig in.
So, John Hammond, that's
That lead, we had a couple markers yesterday that sort
of preview as to what January will look like.
First of all, Democrats will get
their chance once they take control to impeach Hegseth.
I think we'll have a different outcome then
and they'll be able to be the first step of their sort of balancing,
hey, the affordability agenda.
Let's do things for American people,
but also hold some of the Trump administration officials accountable.
And then to Willie's point, a preview here of what
the Trump administration, what their game plan is going
to be as they really hurdle into this lame duck session.
They're at least to, for now, double down on their worst instincts.
And then Stephen Miller, you know, his thinking was previewed,
I believe, a story in Axios this morning that he's going to focus on.
Young men and Latinos.
Stephen Miller, Latinos?
I'm not quite sure I see how that works.
Yeah, good luck with that.
I'd say, Jonathan, I'd say it's a triple down in a lot of ways. You
got a trifecta here in terms of the actions that Republicans have taken
or the White House have
taken in the aftermath of the midterm elections.
So you've got on the other side, you've got what
Donald Trump, you know, went on 60 Minutes,
said various things sounding a little conciliatory on
the on the immigration front.
But what are the three things the Stephen Miller appointment
Rallying around Pete Hegseth and then yesterday
the House Republicans deciding that Jim Jordan should
be their their leader, the minority leader going forward.
Those are.
Three pretty vivid signs of stay the course on the part of Donald Trump
and Donald Trump's
Republican Party, the MAGA-fied Republican Party,
particularly in the House.
Those are three things that any one of those three things,
the choice of chief of staff,
the Hegseth thing, and the leadership thing,
all could have been very vivid, not just symbols,
but actions taken to kind of signal to the American people,
signal to their own party
Had taken some lessons from the blue bloodbath on November 3rd.
And all of them not only not signaling that they've taken any lesson
from that, but that they're going they're
not they're going kind of going even further in the direction
that they ran over the course of the last two years.
You know, Ron DeSantis said that he thought that last Tuesday
was an extinction level event for Republicans.
Turns out that it seems like Republicans may not just
be involved in an extinction level event here,
but in a suicide pact with that extinction.
That they seem to be racing towards.
I make a solemn commitment to each and every Mississippian today.
In every decision I make,
I will never forget the most important thing is Mississippi matters.
God bless y'all.
God bless y'all.
Thank y'all.
That is U.S. Senator-elect Scott Colome speaking
to supporters last night
after defeating incumbent Republican Senator Cindy Hyde-Smith
in a monumental upset.
Good morning and welcome to Morning Joe.
It is so monumental, Mika.
It is monumental not only for the people of Mississippi.
It is monumental for the South. It is monumental for the country.
And, you know, I grew up believing that we were living in the New South
when I was born and we were raised in Atlanta, Georgia.
Born the same year Martin Luther King,
living in Atlanta, had his march on Washington.
And we did believe, Willie, that that that.
History was moving in the right direction.
We were moving toward a more perfect union.
And the South was shedding its, as Faulkner said,
stubborn, backward-looking ghosts.
That we were not looking back to the Civil War.
We were not looking back to the world as it once was.
We were looking forward.
And as we said yesterday with Doris Kearns Goodwin, this election...
It's not like 1994, 2006, not even like 1974.
It's more like 1966 when the South shifted
and began voting for Republicans
because LBJ passed the Civil Rights Act and the Voting Rights Act.
And there was a rebellion
and a lot of people started voting for Republicans
throughout the Deep South for the first time since Reconstruction.
Here we are 60 years later,
and this is a race along with Georgia, Georgia's governor,
South Carolina, North Carolina, Texas,
that shows, yes, the South finally, finally may.
Be casting aside those stubborn, backward-looking ghosts.
When you think about the long arc of history,
Joe, the last senator, black senator from the
state of Mississippi, left office in 1881 and was born into slavery.
Now that arc comes all
the way to this day and connects to Scott Colome,
the first black senator in Mississippi since then.
It is extraordinary as you think about the South,
as you just move down the map from North Carolina to South Carolina,
where Andy Andrews won, obviously to Georgia.
Louisiana was a lot closer than a lot of people thought it would be.
Add Mississippi and Texas to the list now.
Mika, it is a moment for history without without question.
And Scott Colome was making the case from the very beginning
that we cannot concede these states to Republicans.
We have to fight and play in the South.
And let's be clear, it took Democrats a while to believe him.
He ran such a good race.
And frankly, Cindy Hyde-Smith didn't run a very good race.
But he was a very strong candidate that he made the case.
And then all of a sudden, you started
to see Kamala Harris come down there.
Then Bill Clinton came in.
Cory Booker spent a lot of time down there.
Raphael Warnock was there.
Major Democrats opened their eyes.
And the party finally, in the last week or so,
put some money in that put him over the top.
And we should point out Cindy Hyde-Smith.
Conceded quickly, she called.
Scott Colome right away, even though the race was close.
No election denialism.
It's a clean win.
And now 55 Senate seats with perhaps one more to go for Democrats.
So along with Joe, Willie and me, we have the co-host of our 8 a.m.
our staff writer at The Atlantic, Jonathan Lemire,
host of Politics Nation on MSNBC,
Reverend Al Sharpton.
He's the president of the National Action Network.
MSNBC contributor Elise Jordan is here
and politics bureau chief and senior political
columnist at Politico.
Jonathan Martin joins us as well.
So Scott Colome is now the first black man ever
to be elected as a U.S. senator in Mississippi.
The last time the state had a black senator, as Willie mentioned,
was just after it was readmitted into the union after the Civil War.
But that man, Hiram Revels, was chosen by the state legislature.
Back in 1870, the Associated Press declared Colome
the winner yesterday evening after
a tally of 2,000 votes from Jackson County, a Republican stronghold.
It did not include enough votes
for incumbent Republican Senator Cindy Hyde-Smith.
The race between Colome, a 43-year-old local prosecutor,
and Hyde-Smith, a Trump loyalist.
...is the surprise of the midterm elections.
Colome energized the state's large black population,
capitalized on voters' discontent with the economy,
and honed in on some of the missteps
his opponents made during the campaign.
Here is more from his victory speech last night in Jackson.
And I'll tell you, throughout this campaign,
there were many times where I had to have faith.
There were times that I couldn't get donors to answer the phone.
They did not believe a moment like
this was possible, but I kept the faith.
There were times when I did my first town hall in Jackson, Mississippi.
Frank Figures helped me organize it.
Less than 10 people showed up, but I kept the faith.
I kept the faith.
So many people that had faith in Mississippi
at times where it seemed impossible.
People like Medgar Evers.
I can't help but think about Medgar Evers
on Veterans Day, a moment like this,
Where he served his country.
And came home to Mississippi when they wouldn't let him vote.
But he had faith that Mississippi could make progress.
He had faith that one day everybody would have the right to vote.
He had faith that a day like this was possible.
God bless you, Medgar.
God bless you, Medgar.
God bless you.
You know, politics aside and political parties aside,
Rev, this seems almost biblical.
You think of Martin Luther King in Memphis the night before he died,
saying, I may not be able to be within the promised land,
but I've gotten to the top and I've seen over that mountain.
You think of Medgar Evers courageously going back to Mississippi
and dying because of it.
You think of those three young students.
Brutally killed by the Klan and buried in Philadelphia,
Mississippi, going down fighting for civil rights.
Here we are. The wills of justice.
Yes, they they they grind slowly, but but they they grind fine.
Here we are. Sixty two years after these three young men
were slaughtered for trying to help black Americans.
Cash in on the promise,
the promissory note that Thomas Jefferson wrote them
in the Declaration of Independence,
claiming that claiming those rights that Jefferson and
our founders promised all Americans,
those three young men killed Medgar Evers, so many others
who sacrificed during that time.
And here we are, 62 years after their death, a black man
It's
a moment you
really can't
really find
the words
to express.
But it has happened.
And I think that Scott saying what he said about faith, and I talked
to him several times during the week, he is sincere about faith.
He's a very sincere faith.
A base person. And the whole civil rights movement
that you recounted was based on faith.
The people have to understand Dr. King and Medgar Evers
and others had no reason to believe they'll be successful.
But they believed the passage in the Bible.
Faith is the substance of things hoped for.
Evidence of things unseen.
Going out there like Scott did where you couldn't see a path.
Ten people at your opening rally.
You can't see it, but faith makes you go on,
and faith paid off last night.
And the historic nature of it, at a time,
let us not only talk about since 65.
Voting Rights Act happened because Goodman,
Cheney and Swern and others paid a price, two Jews and a black.
But it is also at a time that voting rights has been gutted
by this Supreme Court and Section 2 has been neutralized.
So if there ever was a time we needed to show we would not go backwards
and Scott Colums' victory says that,
it's the vote last night saying to the Supreme Court and others.
You can gerrymander all you want,
but we still are going to break through.
And that breakthrough last night meant
so much for all of us around the country,
not only people in Mississippi,
though they should be given the credit for it.
You know, the Rev brings up such an important, such an important point,
Jonathan Lemire, one that Meek and I were talking about earlier.
This man was elected.
Keisha was elected.
Other black leaders were elected.
In part because of the assault on civil rights
and voting rights of black Americans.
Were it not for the Supreme Court aggressively assaulting the Civil
Rights Act and a lot of Republicans actually saying openly what bigots,
what segregationists said in the 1960s,
it should have never been passed.
The fact that that became mainstream thought for a lot of Republicans,
that caused what we saw.
Not only in Mississippi and Georgia,
but South Carolina and North Carolina and Texas and
across America, that it was actually
the aggression against civil rights and voting rights for
black Americans that actually led
to the reaction that got Scott elected.
Question is, even a week after this election,
are they still going to be too frightened
to stand up to the worst excesses of President Trump?
It sure seems like it. I mean,
just look at that impeachment vote for Pete Hegseth,
where at the end of the day, there was a lot of public
and a lot of private criticism from
Republicans of Pete Hegseth.
They couldn't get over the line to push Hegseth out or even to get
the next vote out of it. But it is, as you say,
extraordinary to watch all these Republicans
who've been along for the ride from day one.
Have this sort of come to Jesus moment, waking up
the morning after Election Day going, whoops, we really screwed up.
And now and now they're sort of the armchair quarterbacks.
You know, they're the analysts sitting
on a TV show talking about what happened and why.
And they sort of knew this all along, beginning,
Joe, with the vice president, the United States,
who made that long post about the Iran war and Ted Cruz and Marco Rubio
and everyone who may have presidential ambitions trying
to separate themselves in some way.
In the case of Chip Roy in Texas,
He just ran and lost a pretty ugly primary campaign
for attorney general in the state
of Texas, where he was painted by his opponent
as not sufficiently MAGA, despite the fact
he was talking about keeping Sharia law from coming to Texas
and all this stuff that had
nothing to do with the cost of gas and groceries.
And he lost that race.
So whether they knew it in real time or not, I think most of them did.
They were too afraid to say that.
Republicans were headed for this disaster,
and now only after the result comes in are they able,
some of them, not all of them, to say it out loud.
Some of them can say it out loud.
There are a couple things that were happening.
I mean, one, they were afraid to cross President Trump.
The second thing was they lived in a bubble.
It was a lot like Mitt Romney's 2012 campaign,
where you actually had Mitt and Ann Romney, two people I've known.
really have liked for a very long time.
But going into that evening, they were sure they
were going to win. They lived in the Fox News bubble.
Mitt was somebody who would come on
our show all the time. Then he started running for president.
He stopped coming on. He just
started going on Fox. He started living in a bubble.
And so they didn't know what the
rest of America knew. Fox News anchors were shocked.
You even had Karl Rove just saying
Saying they can't be right.
You know, Coral is always plugged in.
But they built this information bubble that actually captured them
and it made them blind to the tsunami that was coming.
And let's bring in Jonathan O'Meara, of course, co-host of our 8 a.m.
hour and also staff writer at The Atlantic.
And Jonathan, of course, you know,
everything you write in The Atlantic is must read.
And I think makes Western civilization a little wiser.
Just just just actually even reading your byline.
But there's somebody else who wrote something almost
as good as what you write in The Atlantic, Adam Serwer.
And I would ask everybody after they finish reading every piece you've
ever written for The Atlantic for them to read Adam Serwer's piece,
because it's as brilliant as all of your pieces.
But what Adam said is there was a lot of concern when Elon Musk took
over X that he was going to do all the things actually that he did
and that that somehow would influence independent voters,
that would influence swing voters.
But what he said was.
A fascinating thing happened.
Elon Musk and X created an information bubble
that actually captured Republicans,
that actually kept them, again,
blind to all of the things that were coming last Tuesday.
They thought the polls were wrong, and the polls were wrong.
We're going to be talking about it later today,
that the polls actually, actually...
Trended in a new direction.
They actually undersold just how big
the Democratic landslide was going to be.
But he said that.
X and a lot of social media on the right completely made
these Republican candidates blind to what was about to hit them.
The tsunami that was coming.
And he went back to a Jonathan Shade article from 2019
when Jonathan Shade predicted Joe Biden would win the nomination
of the Democratic Party because of the 16 candidates.
He was the least online.
So his views of what Americans wanted would be the least twisted.
And the least distorted of all those candidates that were online.
And I said time and again, people like Kamala Harris
and others in that 2020 campaign,
you could tell that their campaign was overly influenced by Twitter
and it caused them to lose the race.
And we have the same thing happening here in 2026.
Making Western civilization a little bit better.
Jeffrey Goldberg is going to grab that.
A couple of things here about about about this.
And I think you're exactly right.
Twitter is not real life. We keep having to say that.
And campaigns who understand that tend to do better.
Now, where Twitter does impact the politics sometimes is, you know,
who doesn't always understand that Twitter is not real life?
Unfortunately, the media. And I
do think journalists sometimes chase stuff on Twitter and amplify it.
And then it becomes almost becomes sort of real.
Because they think they're seeing it.
And that's often overstated.
But this is a great example right here.
As to...
The Biden case, certainly in 2020, he was the least online candidate.
And now the Republican Party in particular,
since 2024, obviously they won that year.
But since then, with Musk taking over Twitter,
Twitter has become a pretty right wing place.
It's become an echosphere for that particular ideology.
And if you're a Republican operative, if you're a MAGA person,
if you're working in the White House,
and I know plenty of them who are on Twitter all the time,
go to their office and Twitter is constantly up on the screen.
You know, or X, the everything app that therefore and they get
a sense here as to a distorted sense as to what's actually going on.
And I think we saw this time around deeply,
deeply out of touch for what people actually cared about on the ground.
I've actually, Caddy K, let's bring in Caddy K,
who's the co-host of the actual, the official podcast.
Of Western civilization survival, the rest is politics podcast, Katty.
I've actually warned warned people inside the White House
on issues that I thought were damaging to America,
that the president was far too focused on X.
I may have even said that to him once or twice over the past.
decade or so, that that was not reality.
And if he was more concerned about keeping people on X and keeping bots
on X on his side, he was going to run afoul of the American electorate.
And that's exactly what happened.
But of course, it worked for Donald Trump in 2016.
And this is one more example, Caddy, and not just.
Axel, why don't we expand this conversation a little bit
and just talk about campaigning in general.
Republicans have made the mistake time and again that what works
for Donald Trump is going to work in their campaign.
And let me just say it never, ever does.
What works for Donald Trump works for Donald Trump.
And that doesn't even work for Donald Trump right now
with an approval rating in the low 30s.
So I think J.D. Vance, as he goes to bed every night
and says his prayers, needs to repeat a little mantra to himself,
which is what works for Donald Trump does not work for J.D. Vance,
because he's clearly trying to emulate the president
and he just can't pull it off.
I mean, it's it's so interesting to see how many Republicans now after
the election, people like Josh Hawley, Chip Roy,
are coming out and saying we missed the whole mood of the electorate.
But we were...
Josh Hawley saying we have been the Congress for AI
and data centers and big tech.
We haven't been the Congress for ordinary American voters.
And if you get into an echo chamber, which your echo chamber is either
on the right or on the left, but on the right as well, if it is.
Infected as well by voices from big tech
who have had a huge amount of sway over this
administration, you can see how you start thinking,
as the president said in that 60
Minutes interview, well, everyone's made money.
Everyone's made $3 billion.
If you have stocks, you've made money, but only about a third.
What is it, a third to a half of Americans
actually have money in the stock market?
The disconnect has been extraordinary.
And it's just, it's interesting to hear these Republicans now come out.
After the election, post facto, and say, oh yeah, we were out of touch.
Yeah, but how out of touch they were, John Heilemann, is historic.
It was shocking.
They were wrong on every major issue.
They were completely wrong on the war.
They were completely wrong on tariffs.
They were completely wrong on data centers.
They were completely wrong on AI.
And I'm talking about the Republican Party taken as a whole.
They were completely wrong on affordability.
They were completely wrong on slashing health care for rural Americans.
They were completely wrong
on issue after issue after issue after issue.
And we kept saying it here.
On Morning Joe every morning and kept showing polls
from Fox News to the Economist to you name the polls.
We were showing it that Americans were saying overwhelmingly,
we disagree with you on the war.
We disagree with you on affordability.
We disagree with you on tariffs.
We disagree with you on data centers.
We disagree with you on AI.
And yes, we disagree with you, especially.
On immigration enforcement.
So my question today is,
how could any Republican be surprised?
And the only answer is, they were locked in this bubble,
this echo chamber between X and
whatever TV stations they wanted to watch
that would regurgitate what they wanted back
to them.
And I will say, I'll just say it, you watch Fox News right now.
And and while the other networks are talking about a historic win
in Mississippi at that same time, you know, they'll be talking
about illegal immigrants or trans athletes or some other issue
that kept Republicans locked away from the reality of these candidates
and made them lose the most historic landslide, I'd say, since 1966.
So this analysis is completely correct,
but I'd like to take it one step further, Joe,
which is that you pointed out the Jonathan Chait article, right?
So first of all, this notion of what
the linguists call epistemic closure,
where you're locked in this bubble and all you get is hearing.
Hey,
it's
Rachel.
I am so glad to see you at the end of that clip
because this is where I get to tell you
about a new way to watch.
All our clips and all of our shows
and everything on MSNOW on your phone or your tablet or your laptop.
You can watch things live or recorded.
Plus, you can ask me and all the other hosts
and reporters questions in our weekly live chats.
You can go to ms.now slash membership or just click below.
Thanks.
